Services & Organisation Committee Meeting, 11 July 2023
Date: Tuesday, 11 July 2023 at 1:30PM
Location: Noosa Shire Council Chambers , 9 Pelican Street , Tewantin , QLD 4565 , Australia
Organiser: Noosa Shire Council
Duration: 00:09:00
Synopsis: Contract awarded for Arkana Dr retaining wall to Sunshine Civil Solutions, Grant-funded, Durable rock design, Value-engineered, Probity/confidentiality upheld, Traffic managed w/ comms, Dry-season start, Unanimous approval.
Meeting Attendees
Committee Members
Joe Jurisevic Amelia Lorentson Frank Wilkie Non-Committee Members
Executive Officers
Acting Chief Executive Officer, Larry Sengstock Acting Director Infrastructure Services, Shaun Walsh Apologies (Did Not Attend)
Meeting Insight
Key Decisions & Discussions Committee: Resolved to award CN00375 Retaining Wall Reconstruction – Arkana Drive to Sunshine Civil Solutions Pty Ltd for $409,904.22 ex GST and authorised the CEO to finalise the contract (Item 5.1). Amelia Lorentson: Confirmed attendance, noted observer in gallery, and advanced to Item 5.1 as the sole report for consideration (00:02; Item 5.1). Shaun Walsh: Stated the project addresses a long-standing stability issue first flagged in 2015; design commenced in 2019 and the wall will be a durable rock solution (01:50; Item 5.1). Shaun Walsh: Noted escalation in construction prices but said additional government funding will cover increases with no cost to ratepayers (01:50; 06:10; Item 5.1). Shaun Walsh: Explained value engineering reduced wall height to manage costs while keeping maintenance feasible via steeper batters (01:50; Item 5.1). Joe Jurisevic: Queried tender comparability; officers confirmed like-for-like scope among three tenders (02:56; 03:02; Item 5.1). Shaun Walsh: Observed current market behavior where some bidders price to avoid award, consistent with broader industry conditions (03:31; Item 5.1). Amelia Lorentson: Probed contractor solvency/contingency; officers cited financial due diligence, past performance checks, progress claims, and retention of sufficient funds to re-let if default occurs (04:06; 04:33; Item 5.1). Frank Wilkie: Sought assurance on full external funding and traffic impacts; officers affirmed grant coverage and partial road closures with property access maintained (06:10; 06:40; Item 5.1). Shaun Walsh: Outlined communications: targeted letterbox drops, designated council contact, and possible social media updates (07:23; Item 5.1). Amelia Lorentson: Noted key residents most impacted; officers targeting dry season start, as early as September–October, to avoid wet season delays (07:51; Item 5.1). Committee: Carried the recommendation unanimously; meeting closed at 1:40 pm (Item 5.1; Closure). Contentious / Transparency Matters Frank Wilkie: Flagged whether discussion had entered confidential territory while tenders were being referenced; chair acknowledged a confidential attachment and corrected course (03:08; 03:27; Item 5.1). Amelia Lorentson: Explicitly asked if council wished to go into confidential session before close; none sought, indicating only generalities of tenders were aired in open session (07:51; Closure). Shaun Walsh: Avoided disclosing specific tender details, speaking in general terms about market conditions and evaluation (03:31; Item 5.1). Community Expectations: Officers referenced resident expectations on wall “look and feel,” indicating prior engagement that influenced rock wall selection (01:50; 05:36; Item 5.1). Legal / Risk Confidentiality compliance: Tender pricing and evaluation material constitute confidential information; brief open-session mention was corrected, limiting exposure and aligning with Queensland Local Government Regulation 2012 confidential tender provisions (03:08; 03:27; Item 5.1). Procurement probity: Officers confirmed evaluation against financial capacity and past performance, consistent with council procurement policy and probity standards (04:33; Item 5.1). Contractor default risk: Progress claim structure and retained funds provide step-in capability to re-let the works if necessary, mitigating project completion risk (04:33; Item 5.1). Budget/funding risk: External grant coverage for cost escalation reduces ratepayer exposure; ensure grant conditions, milestones, and acquittals are tightly managed (06:10; Item 5.1). Construction risk: Traffic management with partial closures and resident access; communications plan reduces safety and reputational risks during works (06:40; 07:23; Item 5.1). Conflicts of Interest Amelia Lorentson: Called for conflicts on Item 5.1; none declared, consistent with obligations under the Local Government Act 2009 for managing prescribed/declarable conflicts (01:50; Item 5.1). Community Impact & Communications Traffic/access: Partial closures on Arkana Drive with resident driveway access maintained; residents must follow traffic control (06:40; Item 5.1). Notifications: Letterbox drops to directly affected area and potential social media posts; designated council contact for updates (07:23; Item 5.1). Timing: Targeting dry season start (Sep–Oct) to reduce weather delays and community disruption (07:51; Item 5.1). Amenity/durability: Rock wall chosen for longevity and reduced maintenance disruptions in a reserve setting (05:36; Item 5.1). Procurement Market Conditions Shaun Walsh: Reported price escalation since initial estimates; some bids indicate lack of desire to win, a known market signal in constrained capacity periods (03:31; Item 5.1). Council response: Applied value engineering, rigorous evaluation, and leveraged external funding to maintain project viability without rate impact (01:50; 06:10; Item 5.1).
Official Meeting Minutes
MINUTES Services & Organisation Committee Meeting Tuesday, 11 July 2023 1:30 PM Council Chambers, 9 Pelican Street, Tewantin Committee: Councillors Amelia Lorentson (Chair), Joe Jurisevic, Clare Stewart, Frank Wilkie “Noosa Shire – different by nature” SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING MINUTES 11 JULY 2023 1. ATTENDANCE & APOLOGIES COMMITTEE MEMBERS Cr Joe Jurisevic Cr Amelia Lorentson Cr Frank Wilkie NON COMMITTEE MEMBERS Cr Karen Finzel EXECUTIVE Acting Chief Executive Officer, Larry Sengstock Acting Director Infrastructure Services, Shaun Walsh APOLOGIES Cr Clare Stewart 2. CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES Committee Resolution Moved: Cr Frank Wilkie Seconded: Cr Joe Jurisevic The Minutes of the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting held on 6 June 2023 be received and confirmed. Carried unanimously. 3. PRESENTATIONS Nil. 4. DEPUTATIONS Nil. 5. REPORTS FOR CONSIDERATION OF THE COMMITTEE 5.1. CN00375 - RETAINING WALL RECONSTRUCTION - ARKANA DRIVE Committee Recommendation Moved: Cr Frank Wilkie Seconded: Cr Joe Jurisevic That Council note the report by the Project Officer to the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting dated 11 July 2023 and: SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING MINUTES 11 JULY 2023 A. Award contract no. CN00375 Retaining Wall Reconstruction - Arkana Drive to Sunshine Civil Solutions Pty Ltd for the lump sum price of $409,904.22 (excl. GST); and B. Authorise the CEO to negotiate the final contract with Sunshine Civil Solutions Pty Ltd. Carried Unanimously 6. REPORTS FOR NOTING BY THE COMMITTEE Nil. 7. CONFIDENTIAL SESSION Nil. 8. MEETING CLOSURE The meeting closed at 1.40pm.
Meeting Transcript
Amelia Lorentson 00:00.801
I declare the meeting open. First I'd like to begin by an Acknowledgement of Country. I would like to respectfully acknowledge the Kabi Kabi people as the Traditional Custodians of the lands and waters that form the region we call Noosa. Pays its respect to Elders past, present and emerging and welcomes the ongoing role that Indigenous people play within the Noosa community. Attendance and apologies. There are no apologies at the table. And I note that. Oh, excuse me, I note. The mayor's gesture is an apology for today. Also note in attendance Councillor Frank Wilkie and Councillor Joe Jurisevic, and note that Councillor Karen Finzel is sitting as an observer in the gallery. Can I please request before commencing the meeting that everyone have their phones on silent or turned off. Confirmation of minutes. Can I have a mover and a seconder? I'll move thank you. That Madam Chair. I'll second. Moving and Councillor Joe Jurisevic seconder. No discussion. All in favour? Thank you. Presentations and deputations. There are none. And we'll go straight to the Reports for consideration of the Committee. There is only one. 5.1 Retaining Wall Reconstruction, Arkana Drive. I'll ask if a staff member can join us at the table. And before I ask you to give us an overview of the report, can I ask firstly any conflicts of interest? No? Sure, can you please just give us a summary or overview of the report? Shaun Walsh 01:51.174
This report proposes the reconstruction of a steep embankment on Arkana Drive at Noosa Heads. Stability issues were first identified in 2015 and the design process undertaken from 2019. So this is a project that's been a long time coming. The residents have an expectation of a particular outcome. This is definitely a sort of a bit of a look and feel. There is a rock wall, you know. It has ended up being more expensive than anticipated as a result of recent escalation and in construction prices, we are able to draw on additional government funding, so it's not at any expense to ratepayers to proceed with the construction. Have we have done some value engineering in terms of reducing the height of the wall, even though it's quite long, which steepens the garden better. As the top and the bottom, but it will still be an easy to maintain solution. It should be a very long, durable solution for residents of Arkana Drive as well. The recommendation is to proceed with letting the tender for the construction to occur. Amelia Lorentson 02:52.924
Questions, Councillors? Councillor Wilkie? Jo? Councillor Wilkie? Joe Jurisevic 02:55.781
Yeah, sure. I'm looking at the three tenders. Were the three tenders quoted for the same job? Shaun Walsh 03:02.349
Yes, the three tenders were quoted for the same job. Because there's chalk and cheese, but there's one price and they like to do it. Excuse me, that's appropriate. Frank Wilkie 03:08.353
Sorry, we're in confidential, aren't we? Amelia Lorentson 03:16.474
That's alright. My apologies, I didn't realise that hadn't been made clear. There's no mention of confidential elements in there Shaun Walsh 03:29.108
It does say confidential. My apologies. I could answer the question generally which is in the current market we are seeing prices submitted which are clear indications the construction entities actually don't want to construct the job. That if they're going to get it, it's going to be at a premium because they're going to have to employ an additional workforce or casual labour hire to do it. So that's not uncommon in the current market. So they must price themselves out of the job. If they do get it, they're going to get the reward for it. Amelia Lorentson 03:55.661
That's right. Can I ask a question? Sort of a follow-on from Councillor Joe? If a successful tenderer has under-estimated the cost of works, how do you re-insure that A doesn't become insolvent and has need to pay these studies. And B that the works are completed? What's the contingency plan or has there been any, and I understand part of our procurement process and there process that is some disclosure there is some required by tenders as to the financial status? Shaun Walsh 04:34.490
So firstly I think the price is a fair price, so I don't think it's a case of actually undercutting, you know, so I think that's the first thing. I think what consisted with more recent estimates, they should be able to complete the job fairly for this price and to achieve a reasonable profit. So that's the first thing. You can already see there's an escalation above what we initially estimated because of that view. The procurement process, selection criteria include examination of financial performance and past performance of the company. So to actually meet specified requirements. And of course, during the construction process the is subject to progress claims so in the event you know that they default to the project, obviously we will have actually inspected the site and also made the progress claim. And ideally the structure of the pricing is set up in a way so that you've got residual funds available to complete the work by another contractor. So that's the general process of the work through. It doesn't always run quite that smoothly, but that's the general process, so. Joe Jurisevic 05:37.001
And I think the other element you mentioned there, Shaun, was a question I raised was regard to the rock wall. That was something that was decided with residents as to the nature of and the aesthetic of the room. Shaun Walsh 05:46.743
I think also the ease of maintenance for Council perspective and also, you know, it's highly disruptive, this sort of works in the middle of a reserve, so having to come along and maintain perhaps cheaper construction prematurely, you know, would be just very disruptive to residents. Joe Jurisevic 06:05.240
And the nature of a wall, a rock wall, they tend to last. Thank you. Councillor Wilkie. Frank Wilkie 06:08.563
Thank you. So just to clarify, Shaun, it's an entirely grant funded project with the cost increases. That's also going to be covered by external grant funding. So as you said, there's no cost to ratepayers. And I mentioned some traffic interference. With local traffic, any idea of what that might be? Well, I can't drive you closer in any sense of. Shaun Walsh 06:37.695
I'm across the details of the traffic management Councillor, but what I can do is once the appointment has been made, I can forward you the full details. And of course, any project like this has a good communications plan with the residents and willing to work with them. My general understanding is that it only requires partial closure of the streets and the properties should still be access the roadways because they can sort of do the construction of the rider in the top and still have a stiff lane. But it will require the residents to exercise due care and also following traffic control at all times. Frank Wilkie 07:14.104
And then in terms of, you mentioned a full communication plan, what would that involve? Does letterbox drops to that street and the main road? How far would that extend? Shaun Walsh 07:23.918
It would normally just be the area that effectively works. Sometimes it's a bit more liberal in terms of thinking whether people would use Arkana Drive as a regular access route. And then so that's the regular that's the letterbox drops and be regular updates with the specific project manager within Council contact and then it would also be subject we'll talk to our communications area about whether it's some part of a Facebook you know social media campaign, which one is the general residents awareness and colleagues. Joe Jurisevic 07:51.446
Thank you. I'll imagine it's only residents that are immediately adjacent that will be severely impacted because there are a number of ways of getting in and out of that area. Amelia Lorentson 08:01.912
On page five that Arkana Drive will remain in the journey of the week's long traffic delays. Of completion when will the work be completed Shaun Walsh 08:12.111
Well well, that's we're to actually start the works now while we have a dry period, so rather than going into the wet season, so if we're all going well, I think it's as early as September or October. Have you moved in that machine? Much, thank you very much. Amelia Lorentson 08:27.988
All in favour? No discussion. Thank you. There was a confidential attachment. Before I close the meeting, I'll ask, does anyone want to go into confidential session? No, no, no. Close the meeting. So now I'm going to close the meeting. I now declare the meeting closed at 1:40pm. 1:39. Related Noosa Council Meetings
← Browse all Noosa Shire Council meeting transcripts
