NoosaWatch™: The authentic archive.

Council decisions

See the patterns behind Council decisions: who votes together, who seconds motions and which proposals succeed. Browse individual votes in All Votes →

Jump to a chart

Showing General Committee (2025-06-16 to 2025-06-16).

Voting Records

Named For and Against votes from the official minutes in General Committee: how councillors vote, together and apart.

Named For/Against divisions became routine practice around 2025. Earlier years show recorded divisions only.

How often each pair of councillors voted the same way in recorded divisions. Shading is scaled to the range shown, deepest green for the most aligned pair through to red for the least. Click any cell for that pair's full division history.

Voting Alignment

ALAmelia LorentsonALAmelia LorentsonBSBrian StockwellBSBrian StockwellKFKaren FinzelKFKaren FinzelFWFrank WilkieFWFrank WilkieJPJessica PhillipsJPJessica PhillipsTWTom WegenerTWTom WegenerNWNicola WilsonNWNicola WilsonAmelia Lorentson and Brian Stockwell voted the same way in 14 of 20 recorded divisions (70%)70Amelia Lorentson and Karen Finzel voted the same way in 15 of 20 recorded divisions (75%)75Amelia Lorentson and Frank Wilkie voted the same way in 13 of 19 recorded divisions (68%)68Amelia Lorentson and Jessica Phillips voted the same way in 19 of 19 recorded divisions (100%)100Amelia Lorentson and Tom Wegener voted the same way in 13 of 18 recorded divisions (72%)72Amelia Lorentson and Nicola Wilson voted the same way in 10 of 18 recorded divisions (56%)56Brian Stockwell and Amelia Lorentson voted the same way in 14 of 20 recorded divisions (70%)70Brian Stockwell and Karen Finzel voted the same way in 19 of 20 recorded divisions (95%)95Brian Stockwell and Frank Wilkie voted the same way in 17 of 19 recorded divisions (89%)89Brian Stockwell and Jessica Phillips voted the same way in 13 of 19 recorded divisions (68%)68Brian Stockwell and Tom Wegener voted the same way in 17 of 18 recorded divisions (94%)94Brian Stockwell and Nicola Wilson voted the same way in 16 of 18 recorded divisions (89%)89Karen Finzel and Amelia Lorentson voted the same way in 15 of 20 recorded divisions (75%)75Karen Finzel and Brian Stockwell voted the same way in 19 of 20 recorded divisions (95%)95Karen Finzel and Frank Wilkie voted the same way in 18 of 19 recorded divisions (95%)95Karen Finzel and Jessica Phillips voted the same way in 14 of 19 recorded divisions (74%)74Karen Finzel and Tom Wegener voted the same way in 18 of 18 recorded divisions (100%)100Karen Finzel and Nicola Wilson voted the same way in 15 of 18 recorded divisions (83%)83Frank Wilkie and Amelia Lorentson voted the same way in 13 of 19 recorded divisions (68%)68Frank Wilkie and Brian Stockwell voted the same way in 17 of 19 recorded divisions (89%)89Frank Wilkie and Karen Finzel voted the same way in 18 of 19 recorded divisions (95%)95Frank Wilkie and Jessica Phillips voted the same way in 12 of 18 recorded divisions (67%)67Frank Wilkie and Tom Wegener voted the same way in 16 of 17 recorded divisions (94%)94Frank Wilkie and Nicola Wilson voted the same way in 16 of 18 recorded divisions (89%)89Jessica Phillips and Amelia Lorentson voted the same way in 19 of 19 recorded divisions (100%)100Jessica Phillips and Brian Stockwell voted the same way in 13 of 19 recorded divisions (68%)68Jessica Phillips and Karen Finzel voted the same way in 14 of 19 recorded divisions (74%)74Jessica Phillips and Frank Wilkie voted the same way in 12 of 18 recorded divisions (67%)67Jessica Phillips and Tom Wegener voted the same way in 12 of 17 recorded divisions (71%)71Jessica Phillips and Nicola Wilson voted the same way in 9 of 17 recorded divisions (53%)53Tom Wegener and Amelia Lorentson voted the same way in 13 of 18 recorded divisions (72%)72Tom Wegener and Brian Stockwell voted the same way in 17 of 18 recorded divisions (94%)94Tom Wegener and Karen Finzel voted the same way in 18 of 18 recorded divisions (100%)100Tom Wegener and Frank Wilkie voted the same way in 16 of 17 recorded divisions (94%)94Tom Wegener and Jessica Phillips voted the same way in 12 of 17 recorded divisions (71%)71Tom Wegener and Nicola Wilson voted the same way in 14 of 17 recorded divisions (82%)82Nicola Wilson and Amelia Lorentson voted the same way in 10 of 18 recorded divisions (56%)56Nicola Wilson and Brian Stockwell voted the same way in 16 of 18 recorded divisions (89%)89Nicola Wilson and Karen Finzel voted the same way in 15 of 18 recorded divisions (83%)83Nicola Wilson and Frank Wilkie voted the same way in 16 of 18 recorded divisions (89%)89Nicola Wilson and Jessica Phillips voted the same way in 9 of 17 recorded divisions (53%)53Nicola Wilson and Tom Wegener voted the same way in 14 of 17 recorded divisions (82%)82
Least aligned: 53%Most aligned: 100%

Share of each councillor's recorded votes that were on the losing side of the division. A higher share means voting against the eventual decision more often; it is not a measure of merit.

Votes on the Losing Side

Contested Votes

Divisions where at least one councillor voted Against. The full table, every division linked to the meeting and the official minutes, has its own page.

Seconder Pairings

Who seconds whose motions in the official minutes in General Committee.

Who Seconds Whom

mover ↓seconder →ALAmelia LorentsonALAmelia LorentsonJPJessica PhillipsJPJessica PhillipsFWFrank WilkieFWFrank WilkieKFKaren FinzelKFKaren FinzelTWTom WegenerTWTom WegenerBSBrian StockwellBSBrian StockwellNWNicola WilsonNWNicola WilsonJessica Phillips seconded 7 of the motions moved by Amelia Lorentson7Frank Wilkie never seconded a motion moved by Amelia Lorentson in this viewKaren Finzel seconded 2 of the motions moved by Amelia Lorentson2Tom Wegener never seconded a motion moved by Amelia Lorentson in this viewBrian Stockwell never seconded a motion moved by Amelia Lorentson in this viewNicola Wilson never seconded a motion moved by Amelia Lorentson in this viewAmelia Lorentson seconded 1 of the motions moved by Jessica Phillips1Frank Wilkie never seconded a motion moved by Jessica Phillips in this viewKaren Finzel never seconded a motion moved by Jessica Phillips in this viewTom Wegener never seconded a motion moved by Jessica Phillips in this viewBrian Stockwell never seconded a motion moved by Jessica Phillips in this viewNicola Wilson never seconded a motion moved by Jessica Phillips in this viewAmelia Lorentson seconded 2 of the motions moved by Frank Wilkie2Jessica Phillips never seconded a motion moved by Frank Wilkie in this viewKaren Finzel seconded 1 of the motions moved by Frank Wilkie1Tom Wegener seconded 2 of the motions moved by Frank Wilkie2Brian Stockwell never seconded a motion moved by Frank Wilkie in this viewNicola Wilson never seconded a motion moved by Frank Wilkie in this viewAmelia Lorentson never seconded a motion moved by Karen Finzel in this viewJessica Phillips seconded 1 of the motions moved by Karen Finzel1Frank Wilkie seconded 1 of the motions moved by Karen Finzel1Tom Wegener never seconded a motion moved by Karen Finzel in this viewBrian Stockwell never seconded a motion moved by Karen Finzel in this viewNicola Wilson seconded 1 of the motions moved by Karen Finzel1Amelia Lorentson seconded 1 of the motions moved by Tom Wegener1Jessica Phillips never seconded a motion moved by Tom Wegener in this viewFrank Wilkie seconded 1 of the motions moved by Tom Wegener1Karen Finzel never seconded a motion moved by Tom Wegener in this viewBrian Stockwell never seconded a motion moved by Tom Wegener in this viewNicola Wilson never seconded a motion moved by Tom Wegener in this viewAmelia Lorentson never seconded a motion moved by Brian Stockwell in this viewJessica Phillips never seconded a motion moved by Brian Stockwell in this viewFrank Wilkie seconded 2 of the motions moved by Brian Stockwell2Karen Finzel never seconded a motion moved by Brian Stockwell in this viewTom Wegener never seconded a motion moved by Brian Stockwell in this viewNicola Wilson never seconded a motion moved by Brian Stockwell in this viewAmelia Lorentson never seconded a motion moved by Nicola Wilson in this viewJessica Phillips seconded 1 of the motions moved by Nicola Wilson1Frank Wilkie never seconded a motion moved by Nicola Wilson in this viewKaren Finzel never seconded a motion moved by Nicola Wilson in this viewTom Wegener never seconded a motion moved by Nicola Wilson in this viewBrian Stockwell never seconded a motion moved by Nicola Wilson in this view
Least: 1Most: 7

Most Frequent Pairings

Read a row across: how often each other councillor seconded that councillor’s motions. Blank cells: never. Every motion block in the official minutes counts, including amendments and procedural motions, so chairing duty inflates some numbers. A motion needs a seconder before it can be debated, so frequent pairings show who reliably gets whose ideas onto the floor.

Notified Motions

How many notified motions each councillor put on the agenda in General Committee (items councillors raise themselves, not officer reports).

No notified motions were recorded in this window.

Motions

Which councillors move and second the formal motions recorded in the official minutes in General Committee, and how they fare.

Moved and Seconded

CouncillorMovedSecondedCarriedLostSuccess as mover
Amelia LorentsonAmelia Lorentson943538%
Frank WilkieFrank Wilkie5440100%
Karen FinzelKaren Finzel3330100%
Brian StockwellBrian Stockwell201150%
Tom WegenerTom Wegener2220100%
Jessica PhillipsJessica Phillips19010%
Nicola WilsonNicola Wilson1110100%

23 motions recorded: 14 carried, 7 lost, 0 withdrawn, 0 lapsed, 2 superseded by amendment. 12 were unanimous.

The chair moves many procedural motions (adoption of minutes, moving between sessions), which inflates the mayoral count. The same honesty rule as speaking time applies.

Conflicts of Interest →

Extracted automatically from the official council minutes, the statutory record under the Local Government Act 2009 (Qld) s150FA. Extraction can miss or mis-parse entries. Each entry links to the official minutes; verify against the source. Declaring a conflict is the process working, not an accusation.

Transparency

Closed sessions, petitions and deputations recorded in the official minutes in General Committee.

By Year

YearMeetings with minutesClosed sessionsPetitionsDeputations
20251001

About This Data

Every number on this page is computed from three sources, each used for what it is authoritative about, and every number is at most one click from the public record it came from.

  • Meeting transcripts feed speaking time, contributions, phrase counts and topics. Transcription and speaker attribution are machine-assisted and can be wrong. Speaking time includes chairing, which inflates the chair's share.
  • Meeting headers (the published attendance record) feed attendance, apologies and chairing. These are structured facts, not transcript inference.
  • Official minutes (the statutory record) feed motions, named division votes, conflict-of-interest declarations and transparency counters. Extraction is automated against the statutory wording and can miss or mis-parse entries; each extracted record links to the official minutes so it can be verified at the source.

A phrase count is not a formal declaration or ruling. A conflict-of-interest declaration is the transparency process working, not an accusation. Motion and voting figures count what the minutes record; named For/Against divisions became routine practice around 2025, so earlier years understate division detail.

A notified motion is an item a councillor puts on the agenda themselves. These are counted from the minutes' "Notified Motions" section, one per agenda item, credited to the councillor who moved it. Amendments and restatements of the same item are not counted again, and a conflict-of-interest determination on the item is not treated as authorship. A notice withdrawn before it was moved is recorded in the minutes but is not attributed here, because the withdrawal line is narrative rather than a structured record.

Figures for this view cover 2025-06-16 to 2025-06-16.

← All meetings & latest  ·  Search NoosaWatch

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.