2017-12-12 Services & Organisation Committee Agenda

Page 26 of 79

NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL                     Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
                                            RSPC Arrangement  for Trade Services & General
                                            Maintenance/A     ance

    NAME OF TENDERER                                                HOURLY RATE
    (Conforming Tenders Only)                                        (excl of GST)
 1  |Laguna Electrical                                                                 10% Mark up
2.  [J&P Richardson                                                                    15% Mark up
3   ohn Buckley Electrical                                                             No Mark up
4   |M2 Electrical                                                                     7.5% Mark up
5   [Nicklin Electrical                                                                10% Mark up
6                                                                                      10% Mark up
7                                                                                      5% Mark up
8                                                                                      10% Mark up
Sp
MO
    NON-CONFORMING TENDERS
    Two Forty Volt No Mark Up - Limited information provided
    Pride Electrical No Mark Up - Pricing to high                                 $120
                                                                           1                     2                      3                    4                    5                    6                    7                    8

                                                                             Resultant             Resultant              Resultant            Resultant            Resultant            Resultant            Resultant            Resultant
    Evaluation Criteria                         Weighting (%)                 score x               score x                score x              score x   Score      score x   Score      score x              score x    Score     score x
                                                                             weighting             weighting             weighting            weighting            weighting            weighting             weighting            weighting
  pee                                     |                 fo fem fm [mp                                             po        [elle [le l@wle [=|                                                                                 a,
    Resourcing

                   Normalised Technical Score (Tn)

                        PART B - Price element                      Laguna Electrical     J&P Richardson     John Buckley Electrical   M2 Electrical       Nicklin Electrical    Paul Matters
    Total Fees (Pc)                                                       $75                   $97                   $80                   $58                  $55                  $70                  $72                  $90
    Average Fees (Pav) $......cccsssssseeeeeeee
    Price Score                                                            99                    70                    93                   122                  126                  106                  104                  79
    Normalised Price Score (Pn)                                            79                    55                    73                    97                  100                  84                    82                  63
    Weighted Price Score (Pw)

              Total Score of price and non price elements

                                                                                                                                               The Contract Administrator confirms the above scores
         Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member 1                  Building and Facilities Co-ordinator                                        and weightings of this evaluation
                     Assesment Panel Member 2                                         Facility Officer
                     Assesment Panel Member 3                                       Parks Supervisor                                                Contract Administrator's signature:                           Building and Facilities Co-ordinator
                     Assesment Panel Member 4                            Workplace Health and Safety Advisor (1)
                     Assesment Panel Member 5                            Workplace Health and Safety Advisor (2)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Page 26 of 79