Council archive · source document
Appendix A - SARA request response by Eco-Team · MCU22/0118
RACV Noosa Resort 142 Noosa Drive Noosa Heads Response to SARA information request 2208-30467 SRA State code 25: Development in South East Queensland koala habitat areas Background: Because this proposal sits within mapped koala habitat in southeast Queensland, any development that interferes with koala habitat must comply with State Code 25: Development in South East Queensland koala habitat areas. The information request of 29 August 2022 from SARA under section 12 of the Development Assessment Rules identified that information necessary to assess the application against the relevant provisions of the SDAP were not provided. This document: a) Addresses the advice and issues raised in the information request (2208-30467 SRA) and b) Provides reference to the arborist report regarding tree retention and removal (Attachment 1), c) Provides reference to the Koala Management Plan for the site (Attachment 2), d) Provides a response to State Code 25: Development in South East Queensland koala habitat areas (Attachment 3) and e) Provides a Landscape Concept Plan for the site (Attachment 4). Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas Page 1 of 11
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 10 pages
Page 2
a) Issues raised in information request 2208-30467 SRA and responses:
General advice
1. The site provides an important connection between Noosa National Park to the north through to Leslie Park and larger, interconnected areas of
bushland that are mapped as Koala habitat area (KHA) in a Koala Priority Area (KPA) to the southeast. Furthermore, there are 107 records of
koalas within 1 km of the site, and four records of koalas on the site. SARA considers that the impacts of the proposed development may result
in an unacceptable impact on KHA, particularly as it relates to connectivity, fragmentation and safe koala movement.
Based on the information submitted with the application material, it is recommended the applicant consider whether development of the site is
appropriate, considering the current threats facing koalas in South-East Queensland.
Response:
We agree that this site is an important node within connected koala habitat for Noosa, and that it would be unacceptable for development that
reduces habitat connectivity or further fragments the local koala habitat to be approved. Hence, the proposal contains several measures that not
only mitigate potential impacts but seek to improve the quality of habitat at the site, provide for increased safety for travelling and resident
koalas and raise awareness of koala in the area to spread the message of koala safety in the local community.
Under the Noosa Plan 2020, the 6.4 Ha (approx.) site is mapped as connecting habitat area, tourist accommodation, area of biodiversity
significance and is subject to the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code. The land is mapped by the State as Category B remnant
vegetation and, significantly, has recently been mapped as core koala habitat. It lies outside of a Koala Priority Area.
The site is mapped as Melaleuca dominated palustrine wetlands (seasonally inundated open forests and woodlands) joining Eucalyptus open
forest to the north along Noosa Drive and heathlands and associated scrubs behind the current RACV resort site. The potential connections
(with respect to koala habitat) are narrow beyond the site boundaries to the north and south, consistent with the regulated vegetation mapping,
indicating a narrow band of appropriate vegetation extending north, with some southern connection to Leslie Park and Weyba Bridge Park,
fringing the mangrove and heathlands. As a result, the site forms part of a bisected patch of habitat that could provide refuge for in-transit
koalas moving between the larger patches associated with Noosa National Park to the north and bushland to the south of Eenie Creek Rd.
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 2 of 11
Page 3
With Eucalyptus robusta, a known koala food tree, common across the subject site, its value to koalas lies in both food and shelter resources.
However, encroachment of weeds, particularly frangipani vine (Chonemorpha fragrans) threatens the habitat quality for koalas, strangling the
canopy and hindering on -ground movement of koalas.
The current trajectory of vegetation quality at the site (as detailed by expert arboricultural advice – Attachment 1) is decline, with temporal loss
of habitat (mostly because of weed infestation). If development at the site is sensitive to connectivity, improves the quality of remaining habitat
and provides an on-going plan to maintain vegetation in an improved state, then it may be appropriate. The accompanying Koala Plan of
Management (Attachment 2) details arrangements to ensure on-going maintenance of the koala habitat value of the site, including for
connectivity to support safe movement of koalas.
Previous proposals that were considered for this site envisaged a significant proportion of the extant trees be removed; as part of the actions to
mitigate and avoid impacts, the present proposal foreshadows the removal of few E. robusta, i.e. the retention of most of the available fodder
species on site. This is an appropriate effort retain as much habitat, and to do so as part of a strategic approach - retaining spatially strategic
trees to retain connectivity rather than simply retaining trees where convenient.
Importantly, the status of the trees on site was carefully examined during the tree survey, and significant health concerns were identified for
many of them. A key problem facing this site is the infestation of weeds, particularly climbing vines which are degrading the health of the
existing trees and depriving the site of opportunities for improved ecological conditions – particularly as they relate to the availability and
accessibility of koala food resources. Combined with impediments to ground movement by koalas, the current prognosis for koala habitat at the
site is poor; the long-term prognosis for the retention of many of the koala resources at the site is poor without intervention to remove weeds
and replace decaying trees.
Of the koala food species identified for removal to accommodate the current plan, some six to ten are identified as requiring significant
intervention in order that they do not die in their current state. Only a few trees are free of weed infestation, and many are showing signs of
poor health
The tenuous links notwithstanding, the management of patches of habitat such as this site are vital for the persistence of koalas around Noosa.
If this site continues to degrade because of tree death caused by engulfing vines, the north-south avenue for movement of koalas will be further
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 3 of 11
Page 4
diminished or lost. A careful approach to the development of the site, however, could ensure the quality and quantum of koala habitat is
improved.
Acting together, the subject site, council reserve and Leslie Park (across the busy Noosa Drive) constitute a significant node of koala habitat for
the local area, and the development proposal has considered and responded to this.
State code 25: Development in South East Queensland Koala habitat areas
2. Issue:
A response to State code 25: Development in South East Queensland koala habitat areas (Sate code 25) has not been provided.
Action:
Provide a response to State code 25 (SDAP version 3.0) in its entirety, identifying how the proposed development meets each performance
outcome (PO).
The latest version of State code 25 is available at: https://planning.statedevelopment.qld.gov.au/planning-framework/state-assessment-and-
referral-agency/state-development-assessment-provisions-sdap
Response: This now forms Attachment 3 to this document.
PO1, PO2 and PO4 of State code 25 – Connectivity, fragmentation and safe koala movement
3. Issue:
The application does not demonstrate how the proposed development supports connectivity between highly connected patches of mapped
KHA. Specifically, the application proposes to retain trees throughout the impact area; however, insufficient information has been provided to
demonstrate that koalas will be able to move through the site around / under the proposed cabins and walkways.
The application material includes proposed planting of native understorey vegetation to improve connectivity and fauna refuge opportunities;
however, the Bushfire Hazard Assessment and Mitigation Plan requires understorey and groundcover vegetation to be managed on an ongoing
basis, with groundcover kept to a maximum of 100mm.
The application does not demonstrate how fragmentation of patches of mapped KHA will be prevented. Specifically, from the proposed location
of the built infrastructure on site, it appears the development will fragment retained patches of KHA from one another and will fragment KHA
north of the site from KHA south of the site.
Although the application proposes to elevate buildings and walkways, insufficient information has been provided to demonstrate that safe koala
movement will be supported (e.g., is there evidence in the literature that koalas can and will safely and easily move under elevated structures
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 4 of 11
Page 5
such as those proposed?).
The application does not demonstrate that the proposed development will not compromise koala safety through impediments that restrict
movements between highly connected patches of mapped KHA.
Although the application proposes to retain individual trees throughout the site, the development footprint extends nearly the entire length and
width of the site, with built infrastructure scattered throughout the area, significantly reducing the permeability of the landscape to koalas and
interrupting connectivity between existing KHA north and south of the site.
Action:
• Provide a plan in digital format that identifies the location of all impacts on connectivity between highly connected patches of mapped
KHA; and the locations of all measures proposed to support connectivity (e.g., koala friendly fencing, fauna crossing measures, etc.).
• Provide clarification regarding how planting of native understorey species will be of benefit, considering the bushfire management report
requires the understorey and groundcover to be maintained on an ongoing basis.
• Provide further information, prepared by a suitably qualified ecologist, which demonstrates how the proposed elevation of the cabins and
boardwalks will be sufficient for maintaining connectivity and safe koala movement through the site (e.g., results of a literature review).
• Provide further information, prepared by a suitably qualified ecologist, which demonstrates how the impediments to safe movement
proposed by the development will not restrict safe koala movement between highly connected patches of mapped KHA.
Response: (Actions as indicated above)
• Digital plan indicating connecting measures is attached (Landscape Concept Plan – Attachment 4)
• Provide clarification regarding how planting of native understorey species will be of benefit, considering the bushfire management
report requires the understorey and groundcover to be maintained on an ongoing basis.
Koalas rarely use canopy connections to move between trees, more commonly descending to the ground before ascending another tree. Whether this
allows koalas to determine the status of the tree (occupied, recently used by another koala or they can (for example) detect plant defense compounds)
is unknown, but their vulnerability to predation during relocation appears to be related to the distance between trees and the amount of protective
understory. It is probable that some man-made structures above the ground could provide cover for relocating koalas, but under normal circumstances
some ground cover is preferable to bare ground.
Under the present proposal, the distance between trees is short, hence the benefit of ground cover / shrubs is likely to be limited, however we presume
that a more natural environment containing native understory is less likely to impact koala travel. We consider that this action will be largely neutral for
koalas, albeit with better movement aided by weed removal (vines).
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 5 of 11
Page 6
• Provide further information, prepared by a suitably qualified ecologist, which demonstrates how the proposed elevation of the cabins
and boardwalks will be sufficient for maintaining connectivity and safe koala movement through the site (e.g., results of a literature
review).
There is limited literature describing koala navigation through man-made structures in Queensland, other than work by Jones and Dexter (Dexter et al.
2016; Jones et al. 2013) but our understanding of the relationship between patterns of koala movement and predation risk (or danger from cars) is well
known (Ellis et al. 2016). Koalas will use short underpasses and variously retro-fitted structures, including to navigate fences (J Hanger pers comm) and
will enter openings (such as cage traps) (Phillips 2011) which suggests that the less obstructive designs proposed for this development are unlikely to
deter movement. Whether the raised boardwalks will provide easier movement for koalas (by travelling underneath) or whether a ground – level pathway
would be a better alternative is unclear, however the raised walkways will result in less disturbance at ground level and so may contribute to a more
natural setting for koala movement, with less visibility (e.g. for predators).
• Provide further information, prepared by a suitably qualified ecologist, which demonstrates how the impediments to safe movement
proposed by the development will not restrict safe koala movement between highly connected patches of mapped KHA.
Koala habitat areas located 200m or less from each other are considered “highly connected patches” in State Code 25, regardless of the quality or
quantity of connecting habitat. Currently, the opportunities for safe travel of koalas through the current site are limited, die to the tenuous nature of
vegetated habitat adjoining this location. The site is adjacent to a road, opposite which lies housing. There is a narrow connection to the north and better
connection to the south, but no habitat connectivity for the east or west. The Landscape Concept Plan (Attachment 4) identifies the available routes for
safe travel of koalas through the site that will provide opportunities for safe travel of koalas through the site. By reducing the impact of weeds and
improving tree health at the site, it is hoped that the quality and quantum of habitat available to koalas will increase, improving the value of this
connection between patches of mapped koala habitat.
PO3 of State code 25 – Koala safety from clearing and construction activities
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 6 of 11
Page 7
4. Issue:
The application does not include a Koala Management Plan, or sufficient information to demonstrate that PO3 has been met.
Action:
Provide a Koala Management Plan which includes the following (as a minimum):
• all potential risks to koalas from clearing and construction activities proposed on site, including vegetation clearing, earthworks,
plumbing and drainage works and building works
• all potential risks to koalas from the proposed future use of the site
• all management measures that will be implemented to address the risks
• the process and measures to address accidental injury or death of koalas
• stop work procedures in the event a koala is identified as sick, injured, killed or orphaned on the site
• procedures for pre-start machinery checks
• the process for implementing the management plan including:
o identifying the person responsible for implementing the plan (e.g., site supervisor, foreman)
o the process for training all contractors working on the site to comply with the plan.
Response: See attached Koala Management Plan (Attachment 2)
PO5 of State code 25 – Avoidance, minimisation and mitigation of impacts on MSES
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 7 of 11
Page 8
5. Issue:
The application has not demonstrated avoidance of impacts to matters of State environmental significance (MSES), as the majority of the site
is intended to be developed.
The application seeks to minimise and mitigate impacts to MSES through the retention of individual trees throughout the development
impact area, constructing cabins and walkways elevated off the ground to allow minimal disturbance to tree roots during construction, and
through proposed weed control and rehabilitation of the entire site. However, the application does not include a weed management plan or
rehabilitation plan; nor has sufficient information been provided to demonstrate that the elevation of the buildings will appropriately minimise
the impacts on MSES.
Furthermore, although the application proposes to retain 276 trees throughout the impact area, information included in the Bushfire Hazard
Assessment and Mitigation Plan provides that the entire impact area would be subject to significant ongoing disturbance of ground and
understorey vegetation layers through limitations on shrub layer height, mowing and removal of leaf litter and woody debris. It is known that
structural complexity is important for supporting ecological functionality and there is evidence that koalas prefer structurally complex
vegetation. SARA considers that although the proposal seeks to retain mature trees, ongoing management of the site will reduce the habitat
value and ecological function of the site.
The application material has provided a tree retention and removal plan; however, has not quantified the number of non-juvenile koala habitat
trees (NJKHTs) proposed to be removed and retained.
The application material proposes to retain 276 trees throughout the impact area; however, SARA notes that vegetation clearing exemptions
relating to bushfire management and protection of infrastructure may apply to the site if the proposal was approved. This could potentially
result in almost the entire site being cleared of vegetation. This has not been addressed in the application material.
Action:
• Provide an amended tree retention and removal plan which clearly identifies the number of NJKHTs proposed to be retained and
removed.
• Provide further information regarding how retained vegetation is intended to be protected from future development, including
exempted development relating to bushfire management and asset protection (e.g., through a legal protection mechanism such as
a covenant).
• Provide a rehabilitation and weed management plan.
• Calculate the significant residual impact that would occur as a result of the proposed development.
Response:
• Provide an amended tree retention and removal plan which clearly identifies the number of NJKHTs proposed to be retained and
removed.
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 8 of 11
Page 9
Tree retention table, reproduced from the Arboricultural Response Statement (Attachment 1) which provides more detail.
On Subject Land^ Remove Retain TBC Total % Retain
Trees surveyed 89 142 20 251 65
Koala habitat / feed trees 44 101 10 155 72
Total Survey* Remove Retain TBC Total % Retain
Trees surveyed 89 266 20 375 76
Koala habitat / feed trees 44 190 10 244 82
NB. This table has calculated proportion of trees retained including the “TBC” values. If “TBC” koala habitat / feed trees are ultimately
removed, the % retention for this category (koala habitat / feed) is 65%. Hence the upper limited of predicted loss of koala trees is 35%.
• Provide further information regarding how retained vegetation is intended to be protected from future development, including
exempted development relating to bushfire management and asset protection (e.g., through a legal protection mechanism such as
a covenant).
•
The safety of people and wildlife at the site is a primary concern, but exempted clearing, such as indicated above, has the capacity to derail efforts to
maintain habitat connectivity and quality and hence has been addressed in the Koala Management Plan. A clear statement of how vegetation will be
managed (e.g. for pruning of branches) is included in that Plan. Under the conditions of the KMP, the retention of trees or their replacement if they
cannot be retained is dictated. Further, the Koala Management Plan has a review section wherein annual review of the compliance with conditions such
as habitat quality and tree retention are conducted by a qualified arborist or ecologist, with the power to initiate actions to rectify any deficit in habitat
quality. Activity that interferes with koala food or habitat trees is addressed in the Koala Management Plan and must be under the guidance of a trained
and authorized arboriculturalist, and if a tree requires significant modification, the loss of habitat value must be compensated on-site.
• Provide a rehabilitation and weed management plan.
Landscape concept plan now attached (Attachment 4)
Calculate the significant residual impact that would occur as a result of the proposed development.
Whilst it is envisioned that there will be no functional residual impact of the development (other than enhancement), there will be interference with
habitat as assessed below:
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 9 of 11
Page 10
Number of trees likely to be impacted (including TBC from Table 1 Attachment 1): 54
Multiplying factor for impact are 0.004 Ha
Result 0.216 Ha Impact
Multiplyer (3): 0.648 Ha
Financial Calculator:
Noosa Shire Council koala habitat area
Total on ground cost $12,960.00
Landholder incentive payment $8,534.16
Administrative cost $3,240.00
Total koala habitat cost for Noosa $24,734.16
Shire Council
Total offset area: 0.648 ha
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 10 of 11
Page 11
Dexter, C.E., Appleby, R.G., Edgar, J.P., Scott, J., and Jones, D.N. (2016). Using complementary remote detection methods for
retrofitted eco-passages: a case study for monitoring individual koalas in south-east Queensland. Wildlife Research 43(5), 369-
379. https://doi.org/10.1071/WR15153
Ellis, W., FitzGibbon, S., Barth, B., Niehaus, A., David, G., Taylor, B.D., Matsushige, H., Melzer, A., Bercovitch, F., Carrick, F., Jones,
D., Dexter, C., Gillett, A.K., Prevadec, M., Lunney, D., and Wilson, R. (2016). Daylight saving time can decrease the frequency
of wildlife–vehicle collisions. Biology Letters 12(20160632).
Jones, D., Appleby, R., Dexter, C., Bernede, L., and Edgar, J. Understanding the movements of koalas in a road-dominated
landscape. In 'Conserving central Queensland’s koalas', 2013, Rockhampton, Queensland. (Eds. N Flint and A Melzer), pp.
106-111
Phillips, S. (2011). Development of a lightweight, portable trap for capturing free-ranging Koalas Phascolarctos cinereus. Australian
Zoologist 35(3), 747-749.
Response to State Development Assessment Provisions v3.0: State Code 25: Development in South-East Queensland koala habitat areas
Page 11 of 11
Used in these records
Appendix A - SARA request response by Eco-Team.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 486 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.