Skip to the record
Trusted by locals. Built for Noosa.

Council archive · source document

Attachment 14- Amended Traffic Impact Assessment Report MCU12/0208

of 204

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

Check the original when the exact wording matters.

                                                                                         Access Options Assessment
                                                                                                   Noosa on Weyba




16             Summary
Cardno has been commissioned to provide an options assessment for potential access options relating to
the proposed development, Noosa on Weyba. 12 possible options were identified and following
consideration of transport, ecological and civil engineering factors, the suitability of each option was
estimated with a scoring matrix. A complete summary matrix of the options assessment is attached at
Appendix A.
Table 16-1 presents a summary table of the options assessment with the associated score for each option
shown.

Table 16-1 Access Option Assessment
 Access Option            Transport           Ecology            Civil       Overall Score            Rank
         1                    2.4               1.0              3.5              6.9                  11
        1A                    3.0               1.0              2.0              6.0                  12
         2                    2.6               2.0              4.0              8.6                   8
        2A                    4.2               1.7              2.5              8.4                   9
         3                    3.6               2.0              4.0              9.6                   4
        3A                    4.0               1.7              2.5              8.2                  10
         4                    2.0               4.0              5.0              11.0                  1
        4A                    2.4               3.7              3.0              9.1                   5
         5                    4.0               2.3              3.5              9.8                   3
        5A                    4.4               2.0              2.5              8.9                   6
         6                    4.0               2.7              4.0              10.7                  2
        6A                    4.4               2.0              2.5              8.9                   6


16.2           Best Holistic Scoring Option
The design option that was considered best from an overall (Transport + Ecological + Civil) scoring
perspective was Option 4. This was not the highest performing from a Transport perspective, but considered
the best when considering the environment. The key design elements of this strategy are as follows:
       > Roundabout access to Walter Hay Drive
       > No access to Tidswell Road
       > No underpass connecting the east and west of the development under Walter Hay Drive.
This option was rejected on traffic and transport grounds for the following reasons:
       > The inability of the option to deliver any sort of meaningful public transport accessibility
       > The lack of connectivity between Noosa on Weyba and the Weyba Downs Development to the
         south
       > The lack of active travel connectivity to the south of the development.

16.3           Design Masterplan Option
Given the issues with the options highlighted above it was considered that the option which scored best but
did not have any major design flaws was Option 6. This option had the following access elements:
      > Roundabout access to Walter Hay Drive
      > Road access to Tidswell Road
      > No underpass connecting the east and west of the development under Walter Hay Drive.
As a result of these options, it was decided that Option 6 would be adopted as the access strategy for the
development.


510119 13 September 2013                                Cardno                                  13 September 2013
Prepared for Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd                                                              Page 34

Used in these records

About this file

File size
7.7 MB (large file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Attachment 14- Amended Traffic Impact Assessment Report MCU12_0208.pdf · 7.7 MB (large file)

The download may take up to a minute.

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.