Original source · versioned page text
2017-05-15 General Committee Agenda
Text sections have not been matched to the original PDF pages. Use the original document to check page numbers.
ATTACHMENT 1
Page 7 of 15
NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
ere nttcacncconsinctn
land Road Reconstruction
a
INAME OF TENDERER PRICE
(Conforming Tenders Only) (excl of GST)
T
2
3 [Shadforths Civil Pty Ltd (Alt-Close)
4 |G &R Brown & Sons Pty Ltd (Alt-Side&Rock)
5
6
7 [Shadforths Civil Pty Ltd (Alt-Side)
8
9
10 [Civil Mining and Construction Pty Ltd (Alt-Close}
n
12
3B
14 [Queensland Bridge & Civil
NON-CONFORMING TENDERS
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 4
PART A - Non Shadforths Civil Pty Epoca Constructions Shadforths Civil Pty Sunshine Coast Civil Mining and | PJM Civil Contractors | Shadforths Civil Pty Civil Mining and Queensland Bridge &
PART A - Non price elements. ontracting Contracti Ltd (Alt-Close, Ltd : Ltd (Alt-Side} Consulting Ltd Construction Pty Ltd itd itd Construction Pty Ltd Civil
Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resukant
Evaluation Criteria score x score x score x score x score x score x score x score x
weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting
pomemes | mm elim fest fe fom fom [elmo |» [mf fo fom[ fom [i low [ ew | fs fom [om fom ||
pense [ees Pe ae a om ns ee [os ie [oo [ee [as [ae [em [ie [To fem [os [om Poe Pie [oe [os [os Po
pow sf Ts Pom Ts fom [os fos Ts fom | s fos [Ts [os | os fom | s fos ts fos | s [os | s [os | s [os | s | om |
frwronmeneasunvnabiny | se fs [os fs fos | os [oom | os [os [Ts Jos fs fos | s fos |e fos ts [ost s fos ts fos | s [os | is | os [Ts | os |
ae pose ess twee sas tae aetna Tae
Normalised Technical Score (Tn)
a Shadjorths civil G ° poca Constructio G D Shadjorths Civil P Sunshine Coast Civil Mining and 57M Civil Contracto hadjorths civil Tvil Mining and Queensland Brid
| taterrenctoment deonsactng at coe)|__canvocing | uiatcine) | ryan | mud | mynd | tsansioe) | comutingmy us | S°27'4 Leonsrscionryus | myttd | td | camnraconrys [eu
ontracting ontracti E Consulting itd Construction Pty Ltd Construction Pty Ltd
‘otal Fees (Pc) 45% $1,481,733 $1,601,733 $1,834,193 $1,859,008 $1,864,527 $1,928,637 $1,971,764 $2,132,253 $2,152,987 $2,209,277 $2,237,036 $2,253,146 $2,377,277 $2,537,060
erage Fees (Pav) $...ccssssssssseseenee $1,850,255
Price Score 120 113 101 100 99 96 93 85 84 81 79 78 72 63
Normalised Price Score (Pn) 100 95 B44 83 83 80 78 71 70 67 66 6S 60 52
jeighted Price Score (Pw)
Total Score of price and non price elements
The Contract Administrator confirms the above scores
Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member 1 Project Officer (JB) and weightings of this evaluation
Assesment Panel Member 2 Procurement Services Consultant (AH)
Assesment Panel Member 3 Project Officer (CE) Contract Administrator's signature: Project Officer (JB)
Assesment Panel Member 5 Project Officer (RW)
Assesment Panel Member 6 aSee the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalSearchable page text hides email addresses. Original files are unchanged and may show email addresses.