Council archive · source document
planning report Tristania - Change · MCU14/0076.01
Development Application
Planning Report
Minor Change to Existing Approval (MCU14/0076)
(Redevelop Detached House)
situated at 33 Tristania Dr, Marcus Beach
(Lot 14 / M1111)
Page 1 of 12
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 11 pages
Page 2
Contents
1.0 Summary ...........................................................................................................................3
1.1 Development application details.............................................................................................. 3
1.2 Planning instrument details ..................................................................................................... 3
1.3 Referral agencies ..................................................................................................................... 3
2.0 Site details ........................................................................................................................4
2.1 Site description ....................................................................................................................... 4
2.2 Surrounding land uses ............................................................................................................. 5
3.0 Proposed development details .......................................................................................... 6
4.0 Planning assessment ......................................................................................................... 7
4.1 Minor Change Assessment ....................................................................................................... 7
4.2 Key issues ............................................................................................................................... 9
4.2.1 Building Works Code Compliance .................................................................................................... 9
4.2.2 Coastal Protection Overlay ............................................................................................................ 10
4.2.3 Condition Changes ......................................................................................................................... 11
5.0 State assessment and other matters ............................................................................... 11
5.1 State interests ....................................................................................................................... 11
5.1.1 Matters established in the Planning Regulation ............................................................................ 11
5.1.2 State Planning Policy ..................................................................................................................... 11
6.0 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 12
Client Name: Sandra Baldwin
Prepared by: Jack Lewis B.Sc Hons UNSW, M.Plan OTAGO
Version: 1
Date: 12 November 2019
This report is based on the QLD Government’s planning report template (Department of Infrastructure, Local Government
and Planning), which adopts a ‘report-by-exception’ approach. The planning report only discusses the key issues and
matters where a proposed development does not exactly meet the requirements of, or conflicts with, a planning scheme
or other planning instrument.
Disclaimer: While every care has been taken in preparing this report, Pivotal Perspective Pty Ltd accepts no responsibility
for decisions or actions taken as a result of any data, information, statement or advice, expressed or implied, contained
within. To the best of our knowledge, the content was correct at the time of publishing.
Page 2 of 12
Page 3
1.0 Summary
1.1 Development application details
Type of approval sought: Minor Change to Existing Approval MCU14/0076
(Detached House in Coastal Protection Area)
Site address: 33 Tristania Dr, Marcus Beach
Real property description: 14 / M1111
Site area: 684m2
Assessment manager: Noosa Council
Owner details: Sandra Baldwin
Applicant details: Sandra Baldwin c/- Pivotal Perspective Pty Ltd
1.2 Planning instrument details
State planning policy: Nil
Regional plan: SEQ Regional Plan 2009–2031 (version commenced 2 May
Designation: 2014), urban footprint designation.
Planning scheme: The Noosa Plan
Zone: Detached Housing zone
Applicable overlays: Natural Resources (Coastal Protection Area)
Applicable codes: Building Works Code
Natural Resources (Coastal Protection Area)
1.3 Referral agencies
Nil – No development seaward of Coastal Building Line.
Page 3 of 12
Page 4
2.0 Site details
2.1 Site description
Table 1: Site description
Site Description
characteristic
Existing land use Detached House
and approvals
- MCU14/0076 – Detached House in Coastal Protection Area
- PC14/0997 Dwelling
- PC14/0998 Pool
Frontage and The site includes 20m of road frontage to Tristania Dr and is a rectangular
access shaped block with 20m of frontage to the Marcus Beach coastal reserve to the
east.
The existing pool is setback 3m from the eastern reserve.
Topography and The site slopes away from Tristania Dr to the rear of the property.
views
Existing vegetation There is no significant mature vegetation within the area of the proposed
additions.
Figure 1: Coastal Protection Overlay Mapping
Source: Noosa Council Mapping System
Page 4 of 12
Page 5
Looking east from Tristania Dr Looking east towards the coastal reserve
Looking southwest from the coastal reserve Looking northwest from the coastal reserve
Figure 2: Site Photos
2.2 Surrounding land uses
Table 2: Surrounding land uses
Surrounding land uses
North 31 Tristania Dr – Detached house (building setback 3m from coastal boundary)
South 35 Tristania Dr – Detached house (building setback 4.5m from coastal boundary with
pool 1m setback)
East Coastal Reserve
West 44 Tristania Dr – Single storey detached house
Page 5 of 12
Page 6
3.0 Proposed development details
The application seeks to change conditions 2 (Approved Plans), 5 (pool setback 2m from eastern
boundary) and 8 (Vegetation between pool and eastern boundary) of the existing approval
MCU14/0076 to develop a new split-level design detached house, including the following details:
- 4 bedrooms across the lower and upper ground floors;
- Kitchen and deck on the first floor;
- First level vertical screens to western façade with highline windows for light; and
- Landscaping along frontage and 5m between coastal boundary and the proposed building.
Figure 3: Proposed render looking west from coastal reserve.
Page 6 of 12
Page 7
4.0 Planning assessment
4.1 Minor Change Assessment
An assessment against the meaning of minor change and a response about the proposed application
provided thereafter underlined. The Planning Act 2016 defines a minor change as a change to the
approval that:
i. would not result in a substantially different development*;
(*In determining whether the proposed change would result in substantially different
development, the assessment manager or referral agency must consider the
individual circumstances of the development, in the context of the change proposed.)
A change may be considered to result in a substantially different development if the
proposed change:
- Involves a new use; or
Response: The proposed development does not change the existing detached house use.
- Results in the application applying to a new parcel of land; or
Response: No new parcels of land are applicable.
- Dramatically changes the built form in terms of scale, bulk and appearance; or
Response: The site currently includes a two storey house with a blank façade to Tristania Dr.
Although the house is being rebuilt by a different architect/designer - the scale and bulk of
the house both take advantage of the higher topography at the front of the site and share
similar design fundamentals, as shown below.
Existing House Proposed House
Existing House Proposed House
The proposed house will have a two-storey bulk orientated towards the coastal reserve, with
a slightly less bulky/colourful appearance from the street than the existing house. Although
the designs are different, the presentation to the street, orientation to the coastal reserve and
Page 7 of 12
Page 8
two storey-built form will not result in a dramatic change from the existing built form as a two
storey beach house. The proposed design also includes larger more meaningful landscaping
to assist in screening much of the bulk from the street, coastal reserve and adjoining
properties.
A search of QLD case law relevant to determining whether an application is a minor change,
subject to dramatic changes to the built form appears to mostly involve redevelopment of
historic multi-unit buildings in Brisbane – however, the courts appear to allow quite substantial
changes to built form and numbers of units, without considering them dramatically different.
- Changes the ability of the proposed development to operate as intended; or
Response: The site will still be used as a detached house.
- Removes a component that is integral to the operation of the development; or
Response: There are no components being removed from the development integral to the
operation of the development.
- Significantly impacts on traffic flow and the transport network, such as
increasing traffic to the site; or
Response: No change
- Introduces new impacts or increases the severity of known impacts; or
Response: No new impacts are introduced.
- Removes an incentive or offset component that would have balanced the
negative impact of the development; or
Response: The proposal does not remove an incentive or offset.
- Impacts on infrastructure provisions.
Response: No change.
ii. if a development application for the development, including the change, were made
when the change application is made would not cause—
A. the inclusion of prohibited development in the application; or
Response: The change does not include any prohibited development.
B. referral to a referral agency, other than to the chief executive, if there were no
referral agencies for the development application; or
Response: Although the EPA were an original concurrence agency - No agencies are now
triggered for referral.
C. referral to extra referral agencies, other than to the chief executive; or
Response: The original application was referred to the as a Concurrence Agency. No referral
agencies are applicable to the current development (no development in front of the coastal
building line).
D. a referral agency to assess the application against, or have regard to, matters
prescribed by regulation under section 55(2), other than matters the referral
Page 8 of 12
Page 9
agency must have assessed the application against, or have had regard to, when
the application was made; or
Response: The proposed change would not result in the chief executive having to consider
matters additional to those considered when the application was made.
E. public notification if public notification was not required for the development
application.
Response: The change does not require the application to be publicly notified.
Given the above, the proposed change to the existing approval is a minor change in accordance with
Schedule 2 of the Planning Act 2016 and Schedule 1 of the Development Assessment Rules.
4.2 Key issues
4.2.1 Building Works Code Compliance
The proposed development meets all the Accepted Outcomes of the Building Works Code regarding
setbacks, height, site cover and soft landscaping requirements as demonstrated in the table below.
Parameter Requirement Proposal Compliance
Setbacks Front - 6m Front – No change Y
Side and Rear – 1.5m up to Rear – Existing 2m to pool, Y
4.5m in height, and 2m Proposed 5m to pool
between 4.5m and 7.5m in
height. AND
Side (north) – Existing 1m to pool,
*Nil for class 10a buildings Y
Proposed 1.5m
Side (south) – Existing 1m to pool,
Proposed 2m Y
Height 8m No change = 7.9m Y
2 Storeys No change = 2 storeys Y
Site Cover 40% all levels Proposed Y
Lower ground = 155m2 (23%)
Ground Floor = 276m2 (40%)*
First Floor = 152m2 (23%)
Landscaping 20% soft landscaping 217m2 (31%) Y
Materials Appropriate colours that blend Roof and colours to match in with Y
and Finishes into the natural environment the existing and adjoining
buildings.
Roof Form No rooftop terraces No rooftop terraces Y
Note: Roof includes 5-degree pitch and
eaves to 75% of building.
Page 9 of 12
Page 10
4.2.2 Coastal Protection Overlay
The Overall Outcomes of the Natural Resources Overlay seeks for development within the Coastal
Protection Area to not adversely impact upon natural coastal processes and shall be designed to
protect the visual amenity enjoyed by users and others. The following table demonstrates the
compliance against the relevant Probable Solutions and Specific Outcomes of the Overlay Code.
Specific Outcome Probable Solution Assessment
O18 The siting and design of S18.1 A mix of native landscaping, such as Complies - The building setback is
development and materials used within ground covers, shrubs and trees, is provided proposed to increase by 2m to 6m
the Coastal Protection Area, as for a width of 5m from the seaward or rear from the coastal reserve. An average
identified on the Natural Resources boundary of the site to provide adequate of 5m of landscaping is provided along
Overlay Maps, do not cause any landscape buffering to protect the coastal the 20m of frontage to the Marcus
significant adverse impacts on the dune system. Beach coastal reserve.
coastal resources of the location nor
interrupt the natural cycles of erosion This landscaped area is not visible
and accretion of foreshore areas and from any pathways external to the
beaches. site. All landscaping is to include a
O19 Buildings, structures and works S19.1 A mix of native landscaping, such as mixture of coastal species in
within the Coastal Protection Area that ground covers, shrubs and trees, is provided accordance with PSP3 as detailed in
are visible from the beach- for a width of 5m from the seaward or rear Appendix 1 and be chosen and
a. are designed to protect the boundary of the site to provide adequate planted in accordance with a suitably
character of the beachfront when landscape buffering to protect the character qualified landscape contractor at the
viewed from the water and of the beachfront. time of landscaping.
integrate with the surrounding
natural landscape and skyline
vegetation (see Figure 13.6); and
b. are finished predominately in
colours and hues of the
surrounding natural landscape.
O20 Buildings and other structures Not Applicable
including swimming pools and retaining
walls do not extend seaward of the
coastal building line except-
a. Uncovered and unenclosed
cantilevered balconies that do not
extend greater than 3m seaward of
the coastal building line; and
b. Are setback a minimum of 6m from
the seaward boundary (see figure
13.7).
O21 Where a coastal building line does S21.1 No solution provided. Generally Complies – The design
not exist on properties fronting the includes a cantilevered pool and
beachfront or a reserve adjoining the balcony setback 5m from the 20m
beachfront – buildings, other structures long boundary with the Coastal
and retaining walls are setback a Reserve.
minimum of 6m from the seaward
boundary of the site. The cantilevered buildings are not
visible from any public walkway areas
and is designed to provide a
connected interface to the vegetated
coastal setback area.
O22 Rear fences adjacent to the S22.1 Rear fences adjacent to the beachfront Complies – No fencing is proposed as
beachfront within the Coastal within the Coastal Protection Area part of the development.
Protection Area are designed and sited incorporate the following-
to be sympathetic with the visual a. No more than 1.2m in height; and
amenity of the beachfront and do not b. Open construction;
degrade the natural beachfront c. lightweight materials (timber);
character. d. dark colours to blend with the
natural environment.
S22.2 Gates are not installed in fences to gain
direct access to the beachfront.
Page 10 of 12
Page 11
4.2.3 Condition Changes
The proposed changes to the existing conditions are setout below within the following table
(Additions Bold Underlined and deleted text strikethrough):
Existing Condition Proposed Condition
Approved Plans Approved Plans
2. Development undertaken in accordance with this approval 2. Development undertaken in accordance with this approval must
must generally comply with the approved plans of generally comply with the approved plans of development. The
development. The approved plans are listed in the following approved plans are listed in the following table unless otherwise
table unless otherwise amended by these conditions. amended by these conditions.
Sheet 1 Site Plan, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Sheet 1 Site Plan, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14
Sheet 2 Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Sheet 2 Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14
Sheet 3 Upper Floor Plan, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Sheet 3 Upper Floor Plan, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14
Sheet 4 Elevations, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Sheet 4 Elevations, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14
Sheet 5 Elevation, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Sheet 5 Elevation, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14
SD2.01F Lower Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.11.19
SD2.02F Upper Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.11.19
SD2.03F First Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.11.19
SD3.01F Elevations – south, west, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.11.19
SD3.02F Elevations – north, east, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.11.19
Setbacks Setbacks
5. The pool must be setback a minimum of 2 metres from the 5. The pool buildings must be setback a minimum of 2 5 metres from
eastern (seaward) boundary and a minimum of 1 metre from the eastern (seaward) boundary and a minimum of 1 metre from the
the side boundaries. side boundaries.
Landscaping Landscaping
8. Dense vegetation must be planted between the pool and 8. Dense vegetation must be planted between the pool building and
eastern boundary for the full length of the pool in accordance eastern boundary for the full length of the pool building in accordance
with Council’s Planning Scheme Policy PSP3 Landscaping with Council’s Planning Scheme Policy PSP3 Landscaping Plants and
Plants and Guidelines. The planted vegetation must consist Guidelines. The planted vegetation must consist of native, endemic
of native, endemic species. species.
5.0 State assessment and other matters
5.1 State interests
5.1.1 Matters established in the Planning Regulation
Nil
5.1.2 State Planning Policy
The SPP includes assessment benchmarks that may be applicable where a local government
planning scheme does not adequately reflect the SPP. The following assessment benchmarks are
applicable and have been appropriately considered in preparing this development application:
State interest Assessment against assessment benchmark
Coastal Environment The relevant State Interest seeks for the coastal environment to be
protected and enhanced, while supporting opportunities for coastal-
dependent development, compatible urban form along the state’s coastal
land. The site is within the urban footprint and the development is not
seaward of the coastal building line.
Page 11 of 12
Page 12
6.0 Conclusion
This application seeks a minor change to conditions 2 (Approved Plans), 5 (pool setback 2m from
eastern boundary) and 8 (Vegetation between pool and eastern boundary) of the existing approval
MCU14/0076. The proposed detached house complies with the definition of a minor change under
Schedule 2 of the Planning Act 2016 and is not substantially different development in accordance
with Schedule 1 of the DA Rules 2017.
The assessment finds the development meets the relevant Specific and Overall Outcomes of the
Noosa Plan, subject to the following grounds of approval:
• The high-quality building and landscaping design enhances the coastal character of the area
which is sympathetic and does not detrimentally impact the locality;
• The proposal increases the setback by 2m to 6m from the coastal reserve, which is
substantially further setback than the adjoining developments and does not adversely impact
upon natural coastal processes; and
• The design is sympathetic to the coastal environment protects the visual amenity enjoyed by
users and others.
The Assessment Manager’s favourable consideration of the above development application is
therefore recommended. Please contact me if you require any further information and/or clarification
with respect to the above application.
Page 12 of 12
Used in these records
planning report Tristania - Change.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 2.7 MB (large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take up to a minute.