Council archive · source document
DEPUTATION - Proposed Housing Development at 62 Lake MacDonald Drive Cooroy Applicant: Patricia Spicer Speakers: Patricia Spicer, Paul Noonan, Phil Egan · 2024-09-19 Att 1 to the OM Minutes - Deputation Patricia Spicer
. } Council’s 62 Lake Macdonald Dr Housing Development Deputation to Council by Residents - 19 September 2024 - | thank the Council for the opportunity to make this deputation. My name is Paul Noonan and | am as a representative of the residents of Dianella Court, Viola Place, Kauri Street and nearby neighbourhoods in Cooroy. This deputation is a small part of our response to the housing development proposed for 62 Lake Macdonald Drive. Due to the Council meeting being held during work hours, many residents from our group can’t attend due to work and pass on their apologies. Today’s deputation is in two parts with two speakers. Our aim is to ensure the resident’s reaction to the development is brought to the attention of all Councillors and senior Council staff. In saying this, we acknowledge the meetings we have had to voice our concerns with Mayor Wilkie, Cr Stockwell, Kim Rawlings and other planners, once with CEO Larry Sengstock (who has delegated authority on some matters), and on-site recently with Councillors Lorentson and Phillips. In response to our many detailed submissions outlining our concerns over several months we also acknowledge council’s recent supply of several technical reports associated with the proposal, including the 1081 page contaminated site investigation report on September 6, after multiple formal requests. If | could summarise our situation in one paragraph it would be this: a group of hard-working, community-minded ratepayers were horrified in late May 2024 to learn that Council was planning a broadscale high-medium density housing estate on the community open greenspace between their homes and Cooroy Cemetery. Making matters worse, Council had been working on it without our knowledge for about two and a half years. It is easy to understand the need for more housing in the shire. We don’t see the sense in wedging 120 affordable and social housing units between the cemetery hill and our low density residential area on Cooroy’s urban boundary, remote from the town centre, without public transport, and without proper consideration of the multiple negative impacts the development would inflict on the locals. And no matter what community is affected, development like this must be impact assessed, as recent comparable developments have been, not code assessed. HOUSING DENSITY A consistent density with the Dianella Viola precinct would permit about 25 dwellings. Further the type of housing proposed does not include an essential livability feature - an on site recreational area. Early consideration of these negative impacts would have been possible had Council been proactive and brought the community along. Problems are best solved cooperatively. Council are still intending to undertake major and irreversible site works around the end of this year, and existing ratepayers have been denied an opportunity to review their options and where desired, sell out of their properties in an orderly fashion. Today there are three houses adjoining the first development stage for sale and one being prepared for sale. A number of residents have been told that were the development to proceed as planned, depreciation of $100K to $150Kcould be expected. Considering the modest modern housing involved, this is of the order of 15 to 20% depreciation of housing value. This is a source of extreme stress to the hard working families who love their neighbourhood, and is caused by Council’s late disclosure of the proposal. The stress and anxiety caused by the proposal is causing mental health impacts to many residents. We are not against the development of housing choice in Cooroy. 1
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 3 pages
Page 2
P j CONTAMINATION SAFETY Historically, the land was the official Cooroy dump, gazetted for sanitary waste and rubbish disposal in 1912. It appears to have operated as a dump until the 1960’s and contains all manner of waste materials generated by the growing township of Cooroy. Locals and various industries appear to have had unrestricted dumping access to the land, which contains an area dominated by composted night soil, and a larger area dominated by industrial mixed solid waste contaminated with heavy metals and asbestos. What about the dust blowing into our homes by excavating well over 20,000 tonnes of heavy metal or asbestos contaminated waste? CEMETERY EXPANSION This land was later purchased by Council in 1999 from the same Pat Spicer who will read the second part of our deputation today. We have it on authority that the 1999 purchase by Council was for two reasons, firstly for cemetery expansion (which was DA approved in 2008 after much consultation with residents and offering more generous buffer zones for a less intensive use), and secondly to avoid housing being built on the site. Both of these reasons deserve sober consideration today, since 62 Lake Macdonald Drive is the only cemetery expansion land available in Noosa Shire. In 2008 council calculated the available land was expected to serve the funerary needs of the shire until 2058. With an larger population now and only a quarter of the cemetery expansion land to be retained, we don’t see the maths working out as the cemetery site will be culturally significant forever. Council now propose to concede 1 hectare of the 4 originally purchased by Council for cemetery expansion. Half a hectare has already been surrendered for a cemetery workshop. The remaining 3 hectares is proposed for housing, a sediment basin and a busy road placed a matter of metres behind the bedrooms of the low density Dianella Court and Viola Place homes. Due to the topography and road placement this is another potentially life threatening situation. The problems posed by this over-the-top proposal are so obvious to us, and several urban planners of our acquaintance, it is hard to understand how the idea got this far. Council’s vegetation clearing DA (approved in February without notification or opportunity to appeal) permits the clear felling of a 12,000m? 50 year old plantation pine forest and 3,000m2 of 50 year old Gympie Messmates, both considered a cultural asset of high value in Council’s subsequent June 2024 Cooroy Cemetery Conservation Management Plan. COAST2BAY BUYING THE FIRST STAGE? In Council’s Ordinary Meeting of May 16 it was agreed to sell the proposed Lot 1 of 62 Lake Macdonald Drive to social housing provider Coast2Bay. This was about a week before adjoining residents learned that there was any change of use proposed to the cemetery expansion land at all. We were later surprised to learn that Council’s authority to sell the land to Coast2Bay for such a purpose was contingent on certain still draft amendments to the Noosa Plan 2020 and the sale was by private agreement, not tendered. OTHER LOCAL AMENITY IMPACTS One of our first actions was to create a website to inform the public firstly that there is a proposed development, and secondly to illustrate the many problems the proposal would present to the shire, the town, and our own ability to peacefully enjoy our homes and quiet 2
Page 3
a vos urban area as we listened to 5 years of construction noise and got used to having 2 to 300 new neighbours over the back fence. All of this in full recognition that the shire will grow. We are not talking about NIMBY problems here. We are talking about inter-meshed planning conflicts with the cemetery’s ability to cope with the growing shire population, the fact that floodwater already rages in the environmental reserve on the lower Dianella rear boundaries, and that at least two homes have already had extensive retaining wall repairs to repair floodwater erosion. Almost half the 62 Lake Macdonald drive hill above Dianella Court is forested, and the forest holds stormwater back for weeks after rain, unlike roofs and roads which must deliver the stormwater into our area sooner and in greater volume. It all must drain to the only entrance to Dianella Court and flood the intersection even more than it already does. Why concentrate 120 affordable or social housing dwellings ona hilly site with about a 1.5km walk to the IGA and where there is no public transport? If you live ina two bedroom apartment and drive a car, you will be one of possibly 300 cars leaving a busy intersection at Dianella Court each morning. After repeated requests for the traffic study we must assume none has been undertaken so the flow on effects at Cooroy intersection hot spots can’t have been adequately considered. WILDLIFE And here in the Noosa Biosphere, why has so little attention been paid to the needs of our wildlife? Where do the koalas go when they need to move from the core koala habitat on the southern boundary to the habitat trees up the hill, the blackbutts and the Gympie Messmates, dodging cars and looking for the trees they’ve always used for cover. That is what they do. THE FUTURE National housing crisis or not, it is not the Noosa way to land-lock hundreds of residents into small homes, far from services, with no on site recreational facilities. If the present need for housing is genuinely on par with the shire’s need for cemetery expansion land forever more, then let’s find a solution where the scale of the development suits the constraints of the site. Let’s not risk genuine harm to existing residents in our neighbourhood. Council has done a lot to maintain the village feel of Cooroy for many years. We are fighting to defend our health and safety, the character and amenity of our neighbourhoods, the value of our properties, and our beautiful country town while looking for opportunities to contribute to new housing supply ina sustainable way. We seek to formalise our interactive meetings with Council at regular intervals where we can collaborate with up-to-date information on site planning. Naturally we request updated versions of all present and future investigations, intersection upgrade plans, traffic studies, and management plans for remediation, stormwater, erosion and sediment control, subdivision and landscaping, wildlife etc as they become available. | refer you to our website (https://62lakemacdonald.net) and to Pat Spicer who will conclude our Deputation. 3
Page 4
DEPUTATION TO GENERAL COUNCIL MEETING THURSDAY, 19 SEPTEMBER, 2024 My name is Pat Spicer. My husband and | sold the land to council in 1999. Following on from Paul, | intend to address some additional issues and concerns of neighbouring residents. Community engagement is happening now although “an extensive range of background studies and site investigations have been conducted” over the last two years resulting in decisions, reports or draft plans. All assessments to date have been done under code assessment which means no public consultation is required. “Good Governance is transparent, equitable, inclusive and participatory”. These good decision-making processes have not been experienced. Access to documents has only recently occurred. All the face-to-face consultation to date has been instigated by the residents’ group. The remediation of the contamination on the land is of particular concern to residents because of the health risks of dust containing asbestos and heavy metals including arsenic. Complete removal of all vegetation above and below ground will loosen the soil creating dust even if watering down is used. The soilis to be sieved to remove old rubbish which will create even more potentially hazardous dust. There is to be no retention of vegetation on the site. This seems short-sighted in these days of global warming. The large trees including the pine forest are close to 50 years old. The Ecological Assessment report dated November 2022 recommends “a native tree survey is prepared to identify the number of native trees required to be offset”. This has not been done even though there is an accepted clearing vegetation plan dated 9 February 2024. The ecological important area associated with the known waterway and spring has not been addressed either. A plan for managing fauna is recommended in the Ecological report. The Clearing Vegetation Decision notice lists fauna relocation and removal as the predominant management strategy. Fauna relocation ignores the territorial nature of native animals. Trees are important to fauna too. Council states “new native plantings throughout the subdivision will offset the removal of existing native trees.” With the proposed density of housing and a single 5 metre buffer zone along the shared fence line with Dianella Court this offset target cannot be met on the site. The native Gympie Messmates could be maintained on the cemetery expansion land, the understory restored with advice from Landcare and the area utilised as an attractive bush internment site. This fits with the recommendation from the Cemetery Management Plan commissioned by council in July 2024, which states the pine trees and Gympie Messmates should be retained because of the visual amenity and cultural significance. | was totally shocked by the proposed density of the development. The proposal is not appropriate for the site or for Cooroy. Access for the proposed development shares Dianella Court. The north-east corner near this access road has an historic problem for flooding. The Dianella Court intersection already floods. Flooding is a particular concern for all Dianella Court / Viola Place residents because of the access problem and the property flooding they already experience.-[The flood level on the 1993 preliminary plan for Dianella Court development was not true to fact. Council’s draft flooding and stormwater plan states there will be no additional water flow outside the boundaries of the development property. There will be no vegetation to slow down and disperse the flow of the water [from the site]. Once houses are added to the land there will be increased hard surfaces. Soil absorbs water, hard surfaces do not. Residents have no confidence that flooding to their blocks will not increase. The development road along the fence-line of Dianella Court is designed to act as a drain directing water to the Bio Retention Basin. A road that is designed to be a drain is a safety issue with the possible aqua-planing of vehicles and stopping traffic movement in high rainfall events. As well, this road will take a lot of extra water to the Bio Retention Basin which is already a known flood area. Soil erosion will increase with vegetation clearing and soil sieving. Residents are not confident the Erosion and Sediment controls in the report will be sufficient to overcome this additional erosion and landslide hazard from soil with no vegetation for stabilisation-Residents’ retaining walls are essential for protecting their properties from raging flood water. (See our website video) There is no confidence proposed measures to control storm water on the development will prevent flooding of these Dianella Court properties or control the erosion and landslide hazard. Residents want Council to consider the impact this development will have on the Dianella Court area as well as the whole of Cooroy. The current proposed development needs to be changed to reflect and address community concerns. Going forward we want full community consultation and clear communication on how our concerns have been addressed.
Used in these records
DEPUTATION - Proposed Housing Development at 62 Lake MacDonald Drive Cooroy Applicant: Patricia Spicer Speakers: Patricia Spicer, Paul Noonan, Phil Egan · 2024-09-19 Att 1 to the OM Minutes - Deputation Patricia SpicerAttachmentsMeeting 719 · read item & discussion ↗
About this file
- File size
- 1.5 MB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.