Skip to the record
The only place to find full transcripts.

Council archive · source document

2ND RFI - Attachment 6 - Further advice from Ecoteam · MCU22/0118

of 7

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

                                                                                            July 5, 2023
               Shane Adamson
               Adamson Town Planning
               PO Box 894
               COOROY QLD 4563


               By email: [email protected]


               Project: RACV Noosa Short Term Accommodation Eco Resort
               Applicant: Royal Automobile Club of Victoria (RACV) LTD C/- Adamson Town
               Planning Pty Ltd
               Street Address: 94 & 142 Noosa Dr, Noosa Heads
               Application No. MCU22/0118
               Subject: Noosa Council – Further Advice 001 ECM_22350069_v6_Further Advice
               Assessment Manager MCU22 0118 Dated 6th April 2023


               Dear Shane,
               I refer to above information request and provide the following response with respect to
               koala issues raised in the request. The timeline of approvals, submissions, meetings,
               requests, and proposal amendments is dealt with in other correspondence, and I have
               provided a Koala Management Plan for the site (updated January 2023 in discussion
               with Qld State Govt and approved). The following directly responds to the request for
               information dated 6 April 2023.


               Best Regards,




               William Ellis
               Director
               Ecoteam Scientific




Ecoteam Scientific                27 Dudley Street        T 0428105275                    E [email protected]
PO Box 6154                       Bardon Qld 4065         ABN: 53705278586            W www.koalascience.com
St Lucia Post Office
Qld 4072
Full text of the other 6 pages

Page 2

Issue – Koala Habitat
“The submitted application material does not provide sufficient information to
demonstrate compliance with Performance Outcome PO11 of the Biodiversity,
Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code. The development requires the removal of
koala habitat and feed trees to achieve the development footprint. The development
material indicates a total of 101 Koala Trees have been confirmed on the site, with the
proposal requiring 44 (28%) of the koala trees to be removed with an additional 10
(6%) potentially required to be removed.
A review of the material indicates that there is potentially more vegetation clearing than
what is shown on the tree removal vs retention plan. Trees marked as koala trees
retained on the retention plan contradict the requirements of the bushfire hazard
assessment recommendations and the landscape requirements identified on the
rehabilitation strategy.
The number of non-koala and koala trees to be retained is questioned, and it would
appear when the bushfire, ecology, tree, and landscape documents are cross checked
against each other that there are significant differences in the outcomes of the site and
how the site is to be managed.
The application material has not demonstrated how incorporating the development
within the middle of a core koala habitat area will assist in the survival of koala
populations in the area and mitigate the potential threats including providing safe and
appropriate koala movement across the landscape.


AO11.2 requires that development incorporates revegetation and provides food, shelter
and movement opportunities for koalas. Long term it is difficult to see how this can be
achieved when the landscape requirements for bushfire protection (rehabilitation
strategy) require that no trees or shrubs are to be retained within 3 metres of buildings,
and beyond 3m any trees are to be continuously defoliated below 4m height from
ground level, and no limbs are to extend to within 3 metres of the roof line of the
buildings.”


Information Required
7. Provide a revised tree retention plans that integrates all bushfire, ecology, tree, and
landscape recommendations and utilises this information to demonstrate how the



                                                                                             2

Page 3

development has protected and enhanced koalas and koala habitat and avoids
adverse impacts, both direct and indirect.


Response
   1. Impacts of the Proposal
I have attached the final concept rehabilitation plan (Attachment 1) identifying the
relevant zones of rehabilitation. The revised final tree retention plans for the site,
incorporating bushfire, ecology, tree and landscape recommendations are contained in
drawings 10-07, 10-07A-C, 10-8, 10-08A and B, 10-09, 10-09A-C, 10-11 and 10-11A
and B of Attachment 1. Proposed Site and Tree Plans to the application. I have used
these plans in determining the outcomes for koalas at the site. The final landscape
design now contains combined arborist and ecological detail to address the potential
conflict between tree retention and removal proposals according to the bushfire and
other ecological requirements. Whilst these are critical to the assessment of the
ecological impact of the development, assessment of potential impacts or benefits to
koalas relies on assessment of the landscape function both in isolation from and in
conjunction with the surrounding landscape. Taken in isolation, this site currently
possesses insufficient food and shelter opportunities to support a viable population of
koalas on its own, but its importance to the surrounds and the larger koala population is
accepted. The site contains koala food trees, and presents movement and shelter
opportunities for koalas, contributing to the viability of the overall koala population in
Noosa. Indeed, even without the presence of koala food trees, the site would present
some resources to koalas for refuge and transport, so the value of this site to koalas is
not in question. The koala population of Noosa appears to be in decline (pers obs) and
the continued fragmentation, degradation and removal of koala habitat needs to be
reversed for this population to be viable into the future.
As a result, my assessment of this proposal has been based on two key questions as
follows: 1: what is the prognosis for this site under a “no intervention” scenario and 2.
can the site be improved for koalas? Thereafter, I have investigated the likely outcome
of the proposal, informed by the answers to these two questions. For context, all plans
included with this proposal indicate trees beyond the boundary of the site. These are
useful to identify surrounding koala resources such as food, shelter and transport
avenues and place the site in the context of this habitat. These plotted trees are not
included in any of the calculations of retention and removal in this response.



                                                                                             3

Page 4

Based in the arborist reports regarding the tree condition and impact of weeds at this
site, I conclude that a “no intervention” strategy will be likely to result in adverse
impacts to koalas. The site will lose further food and shelter trees and will become less
permeable to koalas moving across the ground. The heavy vine infestation already
restricts access by koalas to some upper canopy of food trees and has led to some
tree loss to date – a clear adverse impact for koalas. In short, simply hoping that a site
will regenerate to high quality koala habitat will not work at this location, the trajectory
under the status quo is for depletion of koala resources.
What then is the potential impact of the proposed removal of koala trees on the site?
The proposal now includes the following outcome for koala trees on the site:
    -   Retention of 117 trees that fit the State of Queensland’s definition of koala trees
        (food or habitat – of approx. 150 identified on site)
    -   Removal of 27 of such trees, with the retention of a further six, subject to
        arborist assessment.
    -   These 27 koala trees proposed for removal include:
            o   11 eucalypts (fodder) and 16 paperbark (habitat):
    -   Of the 11 eucalypts proposed for removal, all, except for tree #18, are
        described by the arborist as being in poor condition, under severe weed attack,
        or dead.
Hence, the reduction in food resources attributable to the proposal is minimal and could
feasibly be mitigated through replanting of replacement trees and care of the retained
eucalypts. Most fodder trees identified for removal have little to no prospect of
providing food resources to koalas in the “long term” under a scenario of no
intervention.
Where habitat is in terminal decline, intervention has the capacity to improve outcomes
for koalas. However, where habitat is naturally regenerating toward improved koala
habitat or appears to be operating as a functional element of the landscape for koalas,
disturbance is likely to have negative outcomes.
As a potential link in well-connected habitat, the site should be directing koalas away
from sources of danger (such as roads) and provide safe access to surrounding habitat
resources. It should also have a natural understory that provides some protection for
koalas from potential dog attacks and permits easy travel by koalas crossing the
ground. The continued development of creeping vines at this site makes travel by
koalas difficult, and whether exposure to threats is increased or not currently is
unknown.


                                                                                               4

Page 5

   2. Rehabilitation at the site.
The final concept rehabilitation plan (Attachment 1) identifies rehabilitation zones of a
combined area of over 3000m2. To meet the objectives of Performance Outcome PO11
of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code regarding provision of
ongoing resources for koalas, planting of koala food and shelter trees will be included
in Zones 1 and 2. “Screen” planting adjacent to the roads (Zone 2) will incorporate
scattered koala food trees as will the wetland and heathland rehabilitation in the
northwest. In addition, koala trees (and others) currently subject to weed infestation in
Zone 5 and 4 will be managed and improved through removal of climbing vines and
ongoing maintenance to ensure no return infestations. Further, the removal of the vines
that currently choke the ground will open the understory and facilitate koala travel, also
under a system of raised walkways and beneath the cabin structures themselves.
Although raised walkways are probably not vital to facilitate this travel, their proposal
demonstrates the commitment to secure and unaffected travel by terrestrial animals
including koalas, as does the diversity of native groundcover proposed for rehabilitating
one 5 in particular.
   3. Additional activities to protect koalas.
In general, the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code envisages the
retention of vegetation providing food and shelter for koalas and that any development
facilitates safe movement opportunities for koalas. There are several features of the
current proposal that meet this expectation and improve the performance of the site
against AO11.2, when evaluated against the current trajectory of the site. By improving
the site through weed removal, care and attention to existing vegetation and
rehabilitation efforts, the long-term risk of bushfire should be removed at the site and
koala movement through the site will be less impeded than if the site remained
engulfed by weeds. Furthermore, constant vigilance regarding incursions by dogs will
make for a safer location for koalas moving on the ground and any deterrent from
access to the roads will reduce the probability of vehicle strike. The proposal also
delivers road signage (Figure 1) to alert drivers to the potential presence of koalas,
encouraging safe and vigilant driving which should benefit animals traversing roads in
the general area as well as those using the site.




                                                                                             5

Page 6

Conclusion
A response to AO11.2 that takes a “long term” view, must evaluate the long-term
prognosis and scenarios for this site. The current trajectory is toward decreased koala
facility through loss of food resources and impeded movement across the ground.
Further, none of the current threats (proximity to busy road, incursion by pest weeds
and predators) will be addressed under the status quo. It is unlikely that, without
intervention, the site will provide habitat resources to koalas in the long term. Various
interventions could reverse this outcome, and the current proposal has been
considered accordingly.
As reported by the arborist, attention to tree health has been a feature of vegetation
management at other areas of the RACV site, and indeed trees at the boundary of the
current proposal have been maintained in a manner that has increased tree health. It is
proposed that trees are managed in this manner when close to buildings, hence these
trees with branches extending into the exclusion zones will be managed, not removed.
There are several conditions around tree retention, ground cover and fencing that could
improve safety and facility on site for koalas, compared with the long-term projected
outcomes under the status quo, which lead me to judge that, on balance, adverse

                                                                                            6

Page 7

impacts will not flow from the current proposal. Retention of significant food resources,
tree and site management that leads to improved tree health, an open planning of the
structures with raised boardwalks to facilitate koala travel (combined with prohibition on
pet access) are objectives met in the current proposal. The impact of removing the
small number of food trees (many of which are in poor condition) can be negated
through replanting and with the nourishment of existing trees on the site, whilst
opportunities for travel by koalas should be improved with the management of ground
cover.




                                                                                            7

Used in these records

About this file

File size
365 KB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

2ND RFI - Attachment 6 - Further advice from Ecoteam.pdf · 365 KB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.