Original source · versioned page text
2020-06-09 Services & Organisation Committee Agenda
Text sections have not been matched to the original PDF pages. Use the original document to check page numbers.
Page 11 of 26
NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL __ Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
he] NAME OF TENDERER PRICE *
(Conforming Tenders Only) (excl of GST)
1 CATEGORY 4 - TREE ASSESSMENT AND CONSULTANCY
2 [Arbor Australis Consulting Pty Ltd [245]
3 [Arboriculture Contractors Australia Pty Ltd
4 [Bush & Beach Tree Srevices Pty Ltd * NB. Price based on common work scenario applying Respondent's submitted schedule of rates.
5 i.e. Tree assessment and report preparation (per hour)
6
7 [Heritage TreeServicesPtyltd P25]
8 | Independent Arboricultural Services
9
10 $189
1a
12
13
14
15 | Tree Solutions Australia Pty Ltd
16
v7
NON-CONFORMING TENDERS
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 3 14 15 16 v7
Active Tree Services bor Australis Bort Bush & Beach Tree | Co Bo getatio Heritage ree depend acle Arborpro Sunshine Tree | Tree Dimensions Pty Tree Sokutions 7 fralla
[ener tonaeetements | yd | conutinnryitd | contactor autvalo | sevtesoyud | ind” | Managment | senier?yuid | Abercdtul | pyund |r omemsrtved | See, [Wernimiem ry] eer | teetonitis | atrtmemted [and [on Foret concent |
a pty Ltd Consulting Pty Ltd_| Contractors Australia | Srevices Pty Ltd anag Services Pty Ltd Arboricultural p te gery Pty Ltd Itd “ ‘Australia Pty Ltd
‘Resultant
fev fm || as| [ae] |e] » fas] = [os] a [ae] © [ae] © [ae] |ee| > [os] » fas] [am] = [oe] = [ae] a [as] » |e] @ | oe]
xenncam ~ = [=|] =|s|=|=>=|@|=|=l=|s[=[=|=|=|=>=>=|=|>|=lele>=)=|=|=[@|=|= >=] =| |
st P= p= [=f feef= [=| paw] = [eo] sof [as[ = [as[ | oe| @ [aw] » fos] » [os] © [os] = ||» | oe | om |» | we |
lamin Tm Tm | om | wm | om | co | coo | co | coo | oo | om | mo | soo | m | soo | s | soo | m | ro | m | sm | m | rm | m | om [is | re [ m | rm | om | om | o | eo | so | sm |
teat Set Poa ef fe fm fe [lee] few] fe | se | fe | | ef ie | oe | | oe | | oe | mw | ow | | ow | mw [ew | ow | os | ow | om | mw | oe |
covionmentsstiaity [se | | ase | so | ase | mm | sso | om | am | | com | wm | aso | os | as | so | as | os | om | ss | os [om | os | @ | am | ow | oo | m | am | o | oo | @ | om | | om |
[omwmonacmom | = [sls [s>=>e>=|«|=|s|=|@|=|s|=ls|=[s|=[s|=|=|=|=|~[«l=|=|=las|m| spel e |
stressors Tem Tes cess oats | sass esas sars | esas esas | ens | saso [caso [sas | cos cuss sas
Normalised Technical Score (Tn)
T five Tree Service bor Australi boricul Bush & Beach Tree | Co ori getatio age Tree dependent Pinnacle Arborpro Sunshine Tree | Tree Dimensions Pty Tree Solutions | Treesafe Australia Pty
PART B - Price element = Urban Forest Concepts
Pty Ltd oP Contractors Australia | _Srevices Pty Ltd — Services Pty Ltd [efentadiedl p ee) gery Pty Ltd td Tree Logistics Australia Pty Ltd Ltd u
Total Fees (Pc) $145 $108
[Average Fees (Pav) Sennen
a po ee ee ee
Romande Sere pce | se Pc Tce Pe Ps see Ts
Weighted Price Score (Pw)
Total Score of price and non price elements
a
Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member 1 Parks and Gardens Coordinator
‘assesment Panel Member 2
‘Assesment Panel Member 3 Technical Officer Parks & Gardens
Assesment Panel Member 4 Workplace Health and Safety AdvisorSee the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalLog in to download the original file
Large file: the download may take up to a minute.
Searchable page text hides email addresses. Original files are unchanged and may show email addresses.