Original source · versioned page text
2020-06-09 Services & Organisation Committee Agenda
Text sections have not been matched to the original PDF pages. Use the original document to check page numbers.
Page 8 of 26
NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL _—_— Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
PSA Tree Management & Maintenance Serves
NAME OF TENDERER
(Conforming Tenders Only)
1 | active Tree Services Pry Ltd SP CATEGORY 2 - MAJOR TREE SERVICES
2 [Arboriculture Contractors Australia Pty Ltd [CSI
3 [Branch Creek Pty Ltd
4 [Bush & Beach Tree Srevices Pty Ltd [S65] * NB. Price based on common work scenario applying Respondent's submitted schedule of rates.
5 i.e. Stump Grinding (per hour) + Maintenance/Removal (3-Person Crew) + Elevated Work Platform (18m; per hour)
6 [Farrugia Bros Vegetation management
7
8 [Professional Tree Surge $355
9 [RST Systems Pty Ltd $524
10 [Steve's Tree Cutting
11 |Top Cut Tree Solutions Pty Ltd
2
B
14
15 [Treesafe Australia Pty Ltd
NON-CONFORMING TENDERS
1 2 3 4 Ss 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
a Active Tree Services Arboriculture Bush & Beach Tree ETS Vegetation Farrugia Bros Professional Tree a z Top Cut Tree a — Tree Solutions Treesafe Australia
PART A - Non price elements __ | Branch Creek Pty Ltd . - Noosa Tree Man RST Syst Ltd | st Tree Cutting 7 Tree Fi Tree Logisti °
pty Ltd Contractors Australia meek Pty Srevices Pty Ltd Management Vegetation a“ Surge ystems Pty ue Solutions Pty Ltd “_ es Australia Pty Ltd pty Ltd
Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant
Evaluation Criteria Weighting (°%) = = = a ee a ——e = a =n = = a ee =
coasnanone fm fr [me |» | ae | [ao] [ae] @ [an] = [ae] ~ [om] [ao] © [ao | [am | © [am| [aw] ne fae] fae] [ae]
cmatooinwncm | mf = fr fe [as [ [| [lel m[=fmfs ff [ws [ele[e[ =| [ole [ = |m[ || os | an |
— se [ee Pe [ase Pas Pe Paes [ele [oe [ = [as[ = [asf = [asf = [owls [es[ = [es [» [me [e [om [= [me
omy tm | om | | om | os | om | mm | om] ow | om] | sm | | om | om | om | ow | om] ow | eo | om | ow | s | rm | m | rm] @ | om] @ | om |
ometssaomay Off = pf [| = [= pe pepe pepe p=le [=| = [=| =|=|~|@|»| =| =| [=> [we [o
Fete soe pom | wes | cts || some sess sein] | cass | cee | am | so |e |e co
Normalised Technical Score (Tn)
| amet ettd | contre autre | ROMACeCHPI Ue | OS ig | ‘Monegenent | vegtntn | NOO2Tee Mon | PUSSY [-asrsptemsmyted [sever ree cut | scttonsomrisa | TeeF | Meets | attoowuy | emits
PARTB - Price element ch Ti T 's Tr Tree Fi T
pty Ltd Contractors Austratia | B/mh reek PRY Ltd | crevices pty Ltd anagement Vegetatio Noosa Tree Surge RST Systems Pty Lid | Steve's Tree C Solutions Pty Ltd ce ree Logistics Australia Pty Ltd pty Ltd
Total Fees (Pc) 15% $579 $605 $495 $465 $444 $410 $355 $524 $420 $828 $447 $710 $440 $410
Average Fees (Pav) $.....ssssecsssssseeseeees $518
mes psf ee ee ee fe
ee poe ee ew i i
Weighted Price Score (Pw)
Total Score of price and non price elements
Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member 1 Parks and Gardens Coordinator
Assesment Panel Member 2 Arborist - Tree Assessment Officer
Assesment Panel Member 3 Technical Officer Parks & Gardens
Assesment Panel Member 4 Workplace Health and Safety AdvisorSee the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalLog in to download the original file
Large file: the download may take up to a minute.
Searchable page text hides email addresses. Original files are unchanged and may show email addresses.