Council archive · source document
LATE - Cover Letter - Response to Information Request · MCU22/0139
Date: 20 July 23
The Chief Executive Officer
Noosa Shire Council,
PO Box 141
Tewantin QLD 4565
Via Email ([email protected])
Attention: Nadine Gorton
Dear Madam,
RE: Response to Information Request and Change to Development Application relating to a
Development Permit for Material Change of Use of Premises to establish a Dual Occupancy at
36 Elanda Street, Sunshine Beach (Council Reference: MCU22/0139)
I refer to Council’s Information Request issued on 23 September 2022 in relation to the abovementioned
application.
In accordance with Part 3 Section 13 of the Development Assessment Rules and the Planning Act 2016, we
hereby provide a response to the items raised in the request as detailed below.
Please note that we also seek to change the development application to include Operational Works
(Engineering Work and Landscaping Work). An amended DA Form 1 and associated operational works
plans are provided to accompany this response.
Issue – Site Cover
The planning report submitted with the application indicates that the proposal complies with site cover
requirements of the Medium Density Zone Code. Site cover is defined as:
site cover of development, means the portion of the site, expressed as a percentage, that will be covered by a
building or structure, measured to its outermost projection, after the development is carried out, other than a
building or structure, or part of a building or structure, that is—
a) in a landscaped or open space area, including, for example a gazebo or shade structure or;
b) a basement that is completely below ground level and used for car parking; or
c) the eaves of a building; or
d) a sun shade.
Further information is required to demonstrate that the proposed basement area is completely below ground
level and does not comprise site cover.
Information Required
1. Provide additional plans that demonstrate the basement is completely below ground level.
2. Provide a plan detailing the areas used to calculate site cover.
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 4 pages
Page 2
Response
Please see attached amended proposal plans that include site calculations and diagrams and calculations
for each level. The development will provide a total site coverage of 38.4%.
Issue – Plot Ratio
The proposed covered/enclosed walkway adjacent to the stairway and lift area is considered to comprise a
storey as it is not a space containing only a lift shaft, stairway or meter room or a space containing only a
bathroom, shower room, laundry, toilet or other sanitary compartment and therefore contributes to gross floor
area.
Information Required
3. Provide a plan (including the upper level covered/enclosed walkways) detailing the areas measured to
calculate gross floor area.
Response
The design has been amended to remove the covered walkways on the rooftop level. This level now only
comprises a covered stairway, which does not constitute a storey or gross floor area.
Issue – Roof Form
AO19.2 of the Medium Density Residential Zone Code details that development is not to include roof top
terraces. The proposed roof form is not considered to meet PO19(a) and (c) of the Code as the lift area and
stairs create a box profile and will enable overlooking into adjoining properties. The proposed roof top planting
is also not considered to provide sufficient screening to adjoining properties.
Information Required
4. Provide further information demonstrating that the roof top terrace will not overlook adjoining sites noting
that screen planting is not a long term solution for privacy.
5. Reduce the box profile of the upper level accessway and structures.
Response
Please refer to the View Analysis on plan numbered CD08, which illustrates that residents will not be
capable of overlooking the adjoining properties. A 1.7m high planter and batten screening device will be
installed around the perimeter of the terrace which will ensure that any low angle visibility is blocked.
The design has also been amended to significantly reduce the form and extent of the stairway structure on
the upper level, which had a boxy from. It has been replaced with a much narrower structure that has a total
width of 2.1m presenting to the street frontage and includes 12 degree pitched roofs.
Issue – Building Scale and Bulk
PO9 of the Medium Density Residential Zone Code states:
Page 3
PO7 of the Coastal Communities Local Plan code further details that buildings are not to include rooftop
terraces.
The proposed roof top terrace area and access is not considered to be of a scale that is compatible with the
surrounding area which on the western side of the street comprises low rise development and not roof top
areas.
Information Required
6. Provide amended plans that provide a development consistent with the surrounding built form on the
western side of Elanda Street. It is recommended that the roof top structures be removed from the
building as they are not considered consistent with the character of the street.
Response
As detailed in the assessment report, the north-eastern side of Elanda Street is located in the High Density
Residential Zone and predominantly comprises large scale 3 storey multiple dwellings that provide
substantial plot ratios. The south-western side of Elanda contains a mixture of dual occupancies, multiple
dwellings and dwelling houses of a similar form and scale to the proposed dual occupancy. The dual
occupancies and multiple dwellings located on south-western side of Elanda were also developed under
former planning schemes, which allowed for larger plot ratios than the current planning scheme.
Notwithstanding the above, the roof top terrace has been significantly reduced in bulk and scale so that the
undercover areas have now only related to the stairway leading up to the terrace.
Issue – Vegetation
AO5 of the Coastal Communities Local Plan Code states that development is to retain and enhance mature
trees and character vegetation that contributes to the vegetated backdrop and streetscape character of
the area.
Information Required
7. Provide a plan detailing the existing vegetation to be retained or removed from the site.
Response
Please refer to the attached landscape plans provided, which illustrate that the site will be landscaped with a
variety of trees, shrubs, and ground covers that will achieve a well landscaped setting.
Issue – Driveway Access
Page 4
The submitted documentation does not contain sufficient information for Council to assess the proposed
driveway, crossover and areas of verge.
Information Required
8. Provide additional detail on the proposed driveway and crossover. The detail must be prepared by a
suitably qualified person (RPEQ – Registered Professional Engineer of Queensland) and include, but not
be limited to:
a. a design generally in accordance with RS-049, RS-050 and any associated addendum;
b. levels and grade of the access driveway;
c. a longitudinal section extending from the centre of the formation along Elanda Street to the
property boundary; and
d. demonstrate that a B99 vehicle will not scrape or bottom out while entering or exiting the driveway.
9. Provide additional detail demonstrating how trip hazards will be eliminated within the road reserve due to
the construction of the proposed driveway crossover. Please note that Council is unlikely to support
private retaining structures within the road reserve. The amended plan must be prepared by a suitably
qualified person (RPEQ – Registered Professional Engineer of Queensland) and include, but not be
limited to:
a. the full extent of the transition to the adjoining areas of verge.
Response
Please refer to the attached engineering plans which provide the crossover design and a longitudinal
section of the driveway.
Issue – Stormwater Management
The submitted documentation indicates a significant increase in hardstand and otherwise impervious areas. A
Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) has not been submitted as part of this application.
It is unclear from the submitted documentation how the basement garage will drain rain water caught from the
downward slope of the driveway and any incidental rain water brought in by vehicles during rain events.
Information Required
10. Provide a site-specific Stormwater Management Plan that demonstrates how the rain water generated
on hardstand and otherwise impervious areas will be collected and released. The plan must be prepared
by a suitably qualified person (RPEQ – Registered Professional Engineer of Queensland) and include, but
not be limited to:
a. demonstrate how the proposed basement will collect and discharge any captured rain water; and
b. a 3,000 litre rainwater tank for non-potable services per dwelling (cumulative volume accepted) to
address Performance Outcome 2 of the Sustainable Building Design Code
Response
Please refer to the attached stormwater management plans prepared by N. Koloff and Associates.
Page 5
Issue – Basement Carpark Functionality
Council are concerned regarding the functionality of the proposed basement garage. The submitted
documentation does not include a turning path plan.
Information Required
11. Provide a turning path plan to demonstrate how a B99 vehicle can safely enter and exit each carpark in
the proposed basement garage while the remaining carparks are occupied. The plan must be prepared
by a suitably qualified person.
Response
Please refer to the attached engineering plans prepared by SCG Consulting and swept path diagrams
prepared by The Drafty which illustrate the areas and dimensions of the basement and include swept path
diagrams for 4 x B99 vehicles parking in the basement.
Issue – Earthworks
The submitted documentation does not contain sufficient information for Council to assess the earthworks
required to carry out the proposed development.
Information Required
12. Provide additional detail demonstrating the full extent of earthworks required to carry out the proposed
development. The additional detail must be prepared by a suitably qualified person (RPEQ – Registered
Professional Engineer of Queensland) and include, but not be limited to:
a. the full extent of cut and fill; and
b. the volume of cut, fill and excess earth.
Response
Please refer to the Earthworks and Piling Plan prepared by SCG Consulting.
Proceeding
This office trusts that the information supplied comprehensively addresses all of the issues relating to the
information request. Should you have any further questions in relation to the proposal, please do not hesitate
to contact the undersigned on 0423 952 928 or via email at [email protected] sincerely,
Marcus Brennan
B. Urb. Reg. Plan.
Used in these records
LATE - Cover Letter - Response to Information Request.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 193 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.