2022-06-07 Services & Organisation Committee Agenda

SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA   7 JUNE 2022




                                                   Page 12 of 48

SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA                                                                                        7 JUNE 2022

                                                                                                                      Evaluation

              NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL                          Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Evaluation
                         Contract Title:                   Register of Pre-qualified Suppliers for Provision of Trade Services
                          Contract No:                     TO00067

      if the Evaluation Panel’s final assessment is that the response to any of the evaluation criteria assessment questions is ‘NO’ then the Evaluation Panel will consider if the Supplier’s inability to meet the criteria
      is limited. Where this is agreed to be the case, the Evaluation Panel may still assess the Supplier as suitable for appointment.

                                                             Technical, Financial and Managerial             Health & Safety - Management
          Criteria                                                                                                                                         Environment & Sustainability                              Price
                                                                            Capability                                    Systems

                                                                                                                                                      Must provide details of Zero Emission Initiatives
                                                                                                             Must provide details of Health & Safety
                                                                                                                                                       and complete the questionnaire provided within
                                                                                                             Management System and complete the
                                                               Respondent MUST provide evidence in the    questionnaire provided within the tender suite.           the tender suite.                     MUST provide schedule of rates.
                                                             response to suggest that the respondent does                                                Respondent MUST provide evidence in the      Respondent MUST provide evidence in the
          NAME OF TENDERER                                                                                  Respondent MUST provide evidence in the
      N                                                      have the necessary Technical and Managerial                                                 response to suggest that the respondent, if  response to suggest that the respondent, if
          (Conforming Tenders Only)                         Capability necessary to perform contracts on time response to suggest that the respondent, if engaged to perform the contract, would provide engaged to perform the contract, would provide
                                                                                                          engaged to perform the contract, would provide
                                                              and in accordance with agreed requirements.                                            the services to Council that identifies strategies to       value for money?
                                                                                                          the services to Council in compliance with the
                                                                                                                                                         assist Council meeting the Zero Emissions
                                                                                                             Workplace Health and Safety legislation.
                                                                                                                                                        Organisational Strategy 2016 — 2026 targets.

          All Coast Drainage, A.G ZAHN & L.J ZAHN t/as                         YES                                          YES                                          YES                                         YES

          Alpha Screens & Glass, Buckhill Pty Ltd t/as                         YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
          Anchored Plumbing Co., J&J Cerneaz Investments Pty                   YES                                          YES                                          YES                                         YES
          Ltd t/as
          Appliance Tagging Services Pty Ltd                                   NO                                           YES                                         YES                                           NO
          ARC Electrical Maintenance, ATF Dein Family Trust                    YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
          t/as
          Arch Electrical & Security Pty Ltd, ATF Arch Family                  YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
          Trust fas
          Bakers & Co Painting and Decorating Pty Ltd                          YES                                          YES                                          YES                                         YES

          Bones Plumbing & Roofing, Seigus Pty Ltd t/as                        YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

          Brasser Industries Pty Ltd t/as Brasser Electrical                   YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

       10 Brooks Hire Service Pty Ltd                                          NO                                           NO                                           NO                                           NO

       11 CJ Carpentry & Construction, Connor Lee Jones t/as                   YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

       12 Carfax Commercial Constructions Pty Ltd                              YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

       13 CMBM Facility Services (Building) Pty Ltd                            YES                                          YES                                         *ES                                          YES.
       14 Coast to Country Plumbing & Roofing, BLJA Family                     YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
          Trust tas
       15 Coastal Living Painting, Fearghail Berc Pty Ltd t/as                 YES                                          YES                                         XES                                          YES

       16 Hi-Tech Drain Cleaning, DPSL Investments Pty Ltd t/as                YES                                          YES                                          YES                                         YES

       17 DYFA Electrical, KNR Services Pty Ltd tfas                           YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

       18 DYFA Plumbing, DYFA Pty Ltd tas                                      YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

       19 Dynamic Hydro Excavations Pty Ltd                                    NO                                           NO                                           NO                                           NO

      20  Evans Painting & Rendering Contractors Pty Ltd                       YES                                          YES                                          YES                                         YES

      21  Expert Plumbing & Gas Solutions Pty Ltd                              YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
      22  Gealy's Electrical, Gealy Pty Ltd ATF Gealy's                        YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
          Investment Trust t/as
      23  Hintercoast Plumbing & Gas, Hintercoast Pty Ltd ATF                  YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
          Morris Family Trust
      24  J &P Richardson Industries Pty Ltd                                   YES                                          YES                                          YES                                         YES

      25  Jim's Handyman (Noosa), Benjamin Walter Harris tas                   YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
      26  JM Plumbing & Civil, John Morgan Plumbing Pty Ltd                    YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
          tlas
      27  KW Building Pty Ltd                                                  YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
      28  Laguna Electrical Services, Laguna Electrical Services               YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
          Pty Ltd tas
      29  Lennocs Developments Pty Ltd                                         YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

      30  M2 Electrical Pty Ltd                                                YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

      31  NGL Constructions, Neil Gordon Lumsden t/as                          YES                                          YES                                          YES                                         YES

      32  Noosa Electric Co, Maclaren Holdings Pty Ltd ATF                     YES                                          YES                                          YES                                         YES
          Malcaren Family Trust t/as
      33  Pensar Building Pty Ltd                                              YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

      34  Pensar Utilities Pty Ltd                                             YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

      35  Programmed Property Services Pty Ltd                                 YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

      36  R & L Jones Constructions Pty Ltd                                    YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES

      37  Royal Roofing Qld, ATF Royal Roofing Trust t/as                      YES                                          YES                                          YES                                         YES
      38  Soft Wash Sunshine Coast, ATF Kylan Business Trust                   YES                                          YES                                         YES                                          YES
          t/as
      39  Spot On Plumbing, Stephen Gerard McDonald t/as                       NO                                           NO                                           NO                                           NO

                T000067 - Evaluation Workbook_(Master)                                                                  Page 1                                                                                              24/05/2022

                                                                                                                                       Page 12 of 48