2017-08-17 Ordinary Meeting Agenda

ORDINARY MEETING AGENDA                                                          17 AUGUST 2017



          Plan No.        Rev.    Plan/Document Name                                Date
          1620/DA/1.02    D       Existing/Demolition Ground Floor Plan             15/05/17
          1620/DA/2.01    P       Proposed Basement Plan – Stage 4                  28/07/17
          1620/DA/2.02    L       Proposed Ground Floor Plan – Stage 4              28/07/17
          1620/DA/2.05    K       Proposed Roof Plan – Stage 4                      28/07/17
          1620/DA/3.01    G       Sections – Stage 4                                28/07/17
          1620/DA/4.01    K       Elevations – Stage 4                              28/07/17
          1620/DA/5.01    G       Landscape Concept Strategy – Plan                 28/07/17
          1620/DA/5.02    E       Landscape Concept Strategy                        28/07/17
Assessment
The proposed amendment to condition 2 will reflect the new set of plans and is therefore
supported subject to an additional condition being included to maintain a lift.
Condition 9
     9.      The landscape planter boxes shown on the proposed ground floor plan Drawing No.
             1620/DA/2.02 Amendment F at the rear podium car park must provide for a minimum
             soil depth and width of 600mm and incorporate appropriate drainage and plumbed
             irrigation. The landscape planter boxes must be located immediately adjacent the
             approved building as shown on the Landscape Concept Strategy – Plan
             1620/DA/5.01 Rev E dated 30/01/17.
Applicants requested change
To reflect the more recent plans of development the applicant requests to amend the condition
to:
     9.      The landscape planter boxes shown on the proposed ground floor plan Drawing No.
             1620/DA/2.02 revision L dated 28/07/17 at the rear podium car park must provide for
             a minimum soil depth and width of 600mm and incorporate appropriate drainage and
             plumbed irrigation. The landscape planter boxes must be located immediately
             adjacent the approved building as shown on the Landscape Concept Strategy – Plan
             1620/DA/5.01 Rev G dated 28/07/17.
Assessment
The proposed amendment for Condition 9 to be updated to reflect the more recent plan of
development from Revision F to Revision L and the landscape plan from Revision to Revision G
is supported as it is a natural consequence of the amended plan set. The amended plans seek
the removal of the planter boxes to the front of the new service yard. The removal of these
planter boxes is supported as they are not considered to be critical to the overall desired
outcome and they would primarily be situated out of view behind parked vehicles.
Condition 12
     12.     Replace the ‘timber look aluminium louvre screens’, ‘timber look aluminium rafters’
             and ‘timber look aluminium batten screens’ shown on the elevation plans with timber
             screens, rafters and battens consistent with Tewantin’s heritage character.
Applicants requested change
The applicant seeks that condition 12 be deleted and submits that:
This condition results with requirements to provide timber screens, rafters and battens, rather
than the Aluminium timber styled materials. There was no indication within the Architectural peer
review that prompted the material change from aluminium to timber, nor any indication that the
use of aluminium would be detrimental to the character of the area. We consider this condition to
be unreasonable as the design elements and materials are in keeping with the character of the
area, consistent with the findings of the Architectural peer review. Furthermore, the club is a not-

                                                                                     Page 61 of 89