Original source · versioned page text
2021-11-09 Services & Organisation Committee Meeting Agenda
Very large file: it may take a few minutes
The original of this document is very large (12.0 MB). Opening the original or downloading it may take a few minutes. Please be patient and don't click again. The page text is quick to read. If you are on mobile data, it is best to wait until you are on Wi-Fi.
Text sections have not been matched to the original PDF pages. Use the original document to check page numbers.
SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA 9 NOVEMBER 2021
Page 13 of 64
Attachment No.1 - Evaluation Spreadsheet
NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
~~ La [hneecrtion | aan [eaenaiedMercrmdm | aman |
Codtioning PfwhC] Syrterse Price After Correctiors as
a i ii aie
[conforming and Alterrate Tenders Onty 2 2 2 ‘ s « ? . . » a 2
|Aseritan Buniress Mernber (ABM oes 733 256 suozuam | reosus | sasensm | sess | aewosmocr | samsocmze | SS SSM! | pannus | casesaoa
ET Ceahys
ings Mecrance Macies helsing Py
Marne of Tenderer (Respondent) Atsmmntervce | Aimaarcunmts | Carine ar |OREArCordtionme! cy ge peying | SAMeMt Gil Pry d —— — sen7@t | tg ATF Madaree|Sytem Ale Pey ita
Ja: per Rerpondent Details ABW (S80) Pry ued {id} Pry uted Conditioning Pry itd Pry lie ‘tian EQUIANE on . a Farefiy Tram t/me | SADE Sendome Group
Mechanics Servicer Conitoeniey sand Moces Clectric Co
Retreertion
[ote of Suteniasion om per VerdorPane!} woz oos-23 onoe-2 an-ot-2 o6-0e-23 cb oezt onoa-2 07-08-23 oboe zt 6-23
[uses Regteres cress (State Oni) EageFam. aD | SeleCrest.cid | Sretonbtte,ciD | Thgnipe, Ce Cooreteah, CLD | kerwaner, NOW | Coombeh, CLD Geobeng CHD Mocemfie. cD | Loganholme, CLD
|Terstered Price (fect GST) $ meses.oo |S mea. 7s0.50) $ onaso.00 | $ 872,296.50 | $ .o70775.00) $ mmeaiss | $ 4,202.50 | $ yea ssoas | ¢ 1a4zopes.00 | $ 663,578.00
|Terdered Price (incil GST)
| =rectiona/carfcations fac G57) $ -|$ - Is - Is - ls - Is - Is -|$ - Is -|$ -
| entoreing or iterate Conterring Conterming. Cantorming: Conforming Cortarcing: Cantarming Conforning Contarming Contorreing Conterming
[Alternate Price Adjustments (Bac GST)
foo saa * . $ mess. ¢ 7ers050 $ wmason0 $ sr229650 $ Loma $ mmaaisas S$ 20250 $ mmeassoms $ i4mosson $ B63, 670
[price variance % from Lowest Price 2s CoN 2s as a a8 aa ae as 2s
eeereane sO OS
[Price Variance from Median + ees +S mss Ss monzs ¢ 47073 | $ aoaesas |S 1as29.40 | ises2s nswm $ sSiase2zs 42078
/Price Variance Strom Medan oO -_ oe us ~~ = ma = ad on “a
| sherthist (VM) ves Yes ‘. Yes ‘ ve Yes es ve ve
(DART A- Non price elements (AE Sent Service Alnamer Asreatle ae Oatar DAM Ale Py Lit Engie ATE Geaty's 7 ‘Syateee Air Pry!
(5EON Pow tnd AOD Pew ont Condidenine Pov ind Conditioning Pty ind Servicer (Otc) Pov ind fewestment Traut tae ind ATF Mitfow Unit Pty int ATF Mectoren t/a SAD Servicer
Jevelustion Gtterie ‘Weighting (%) wegen wee ed reams tae eed meeinee megan wise wrens meee went rere werent cee wages mere ages mise
| Capatslity and Resourcing -_ 450 720 720 6m ss eso 72 620 700 om oo oco
| Comtract taperience and Capacity ~ as aso i138 2. as 300 400 27s 300 ans c.o0 000
[tetnedctany a aso ars acs 70 as as noo m3 32048 ons ooo oo
| Cnaaitey ns oc 3.00 230 2s 200 soo so 1s 30 320 ono oo
Meath & Safety a m 00 620 6m en 350 - os so > cD 000
|treronmert § sutaratally ~ aso a2 2380 2 an 2s 3 1s 200 320 oo ooo
|cereteation to Local Ecomorry os an aus s2s an wo 640 10.00 42 2000 = oo ooo
[rota tecscal score ~~ a8 ae ma ts ws ae 480 us a2 (20.18 20 00
Normatived Technical Score (Tn) on 0 ara aor os 348 00 “is sea2 sa
PANT B - Price ol AE Senith Service “Alnamer Asrmatic: ‘Corsetdine Aly Oatar DUM Ab Pay Lat (Engle Mecharvca! ATE Geaty's ‘Mfow indus Pry Mociaren Woking: Syuteee Air Pry Lee
= (5EOI Pow tnd NOK Pre cee Condidenine Pry ind Conditionina Pry ing py Servicer (Oki) Pov ind lewextment Trunt tar ind ATF Mitiow Uinft Pty int ATF Maclaren t/a SABE Servicer
| Total Fems (Pe) -“~ $806,448.90, $7ma,7s0.50 ($900,450.00 sar2s0 $1,070, 778.00 ‘guseais.25 $a%4,102.50 $79es30.43 ‘$L420.045.00, ‘Saes.e75.00
Price Score 3 is 7 108 s 1 2 i“ - 20 ° °
| mecrealines Price Scare (Pn os 100 ™ 2 n » = » a = ° °
| Wewghtes Price Score [Pw m6 0.00 ma un zs 3620 0 as 16az 3723
Total Score of price and non price elements “us 70 95 nn mn nm v2 ow 7303 90.84
Racha
The Anamramest Pane! confirms the abow scores ang eeighting: of ts evatsstior and canfirry the evatuction hes beer cosducted in acordonas att the Procurereers Prabtty Pan
Aaseximent Panel ‘Position Tithe ‘Signature
| tvausbon Panel Char § Assesment Panel Merrber 1 Desking: & Facies Coordinator (CS) R Chute Stach
Aaseamert Panel Member 2 Actrg Buildings & Facilities Coordingtor (P) a Van Pearce
Assesment Panel Member 3 Acting Manager Ubraries & Galleries (TK) 2 iy 4
| ‘pasexrmant Panel Marner 4 The | Coordinator (58) *% Scott 2rab, ‘
Asveamert Pare! Meroer Worslace Health and Satety Acts (7) * Leta DbtonSee the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalLog in to download the original file
Very large file: the download may take a few minutes. If you are on mobile data, it is best to wait until you are on Wi-Fi.
Searchable page text hides email addresses. Original files are unchanged and may show email addresses.