Original source · versioned page text
2015-10-19 General Committee Agenda
Text sections have not been matched to the original PDF pages. Use the original document to check page numbers.
GENERAL COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA 19 OCTOBER 2015
Page 7 of 18
Final Evaluation
Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet
ContractNo; |_1816T017_
Rea |Dr Pages Road : \d Kinmond Creek Road Construction
ees [Upgrade
cai —_—_| ae
No. |NAME OF TENDERER lexcl of GS a
1([SGQPytte C—C“‘“CC*dSCC#S4, 758,333} ‘ * 2 = a 2 « " a ~
2 [Shadforths Civil Engineering i ($4,659,630) ae = 7 = = a
3L _ _ i= at} The ratings:
4L AE =i} +0 (zero) = Unacceptable a fail for that criteria and extreme risk
SSS SS +20 (twenty) = Very Poor — the content of the submission for that criteria is of a low standard and high risk
6] lL a * 40 (forty) = Poor - the content of the submission for that criteria is unimpressive and poses a moderate risk
a ie i +60 (sixty) = Good ~ the content of the submission for that criteria is meritable and will need to be monitored if awarded
et on a += 80 (eighty) = Very Good - the content of the submission for that criteria is of a high standard and advantageous
rere eee ny] + 100 (one-hundred) = Exceptonal - the content of the submission for that criteria is flawless / outstanding and most advantageous
77 ——===a=a=aaz- ===
11 a =f Once all the data is entered the resultant scores based on the price and non price elements are automatically calculated for you
121 of: =]
13 | |
141 tL |
a
NON-CONFORMING TENDERS Number of Tenders Evaluated
r [Do not evaluate
1 2
— Shadforths Civil
mecemeemcseaenes | ions vs" | ce | "so | as |
DESCRIPTION Resultant Resultant
Probity Plan Criteria exactly +
Total Technical Score po AS
Normalised Technical Score (Tn) Lt TS
PART - Price element | soar id | Oenaigeerinn —|
hinnerir LL |
|Average Fees (Pav) $2.00... $4,709,082
Price Score 99 101
Normalised Price Score (Pn) 98 100
ghted Price Score (P
ments
OTHER DETAILS
Assesment panel member 1 Nicholas Wellwoc
Assesment panel member 2 \da to
Assesment panel member 3 Craig Eldridge
Assesment panel member 4 Rod W ns
Assesment panel member 5 Mike Bryett (GH D)
Assesment panel member 6 Cncl WH&S Off _ The Contract Administrator confirms the above weightings
QBSA LICENCE CHECKED (if applicable) Contract Administrator's signature: = __
15167017 - Evaluation Workbook Alternative B pavement Moy Pocket PANEL (2).xIsx Page 1 14/10/2015
Page 7 of 18See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalSearchable page text hides email addresses. Original files are unchanged and may show email addresses.