Skip to the record
Search everything, all in one place.

Council archive · source document

Negotiated Report (Representations made) MCU22 0145 [As Published] · MCU22/0145

of 8

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

               REQUEST FOR NEGOTIATED DECISION REPORT
               Author                  Consultant Planner
                                       Development Assessment



                    APPLICATION DETAILS

                    Application No.                    MCU22/0145 OPW22/0212

                    Development Approval               Material Change of Use - Multiple dwelling

                    Applicant                          JMML Investments Pty Ltd

                    Representations Received On        21 November 2023

                    Number of Submissions for          Not Applicable
                    Original Application


                    PROPERTY DETAILS

                    Property Address                   3 Henderson St Sunshine Beach

                    RP Description                     Lot 0 BUP 4358, Lot 1 BUP 4358, Lot 2 BUP 4358

                    Land Area                          602m²

                    Existing Use of Land               Duplex


                    STATUTORY DETAILS

                    SEQRP Designation                  Urban Footprint

                    Zone                               High Density Residential Zone

                    Precinct                           Not Applicable

                    Local Plan Area                    Coastal Communities Local Plan Area

                    Assessment Type                    Representations made to original approval



               1.      BACKGROUND
               A development approval for a 3 storey multiple dwelling of 3 units and associated operational works
               was issued on 22 August 2023 subject to conditions, including a number of required plan
               amendments.
               The applicant on 15 September 2023 suspended the appeal period for 20 business days and on
               29 September 2023 requested a further 2 months (to 29 November 2023) to make representations,
               advising that they wished to prepare amended plans. The representations were received on 21
               November 2023 to the development approval conditions, with the applicant advising they also seek
               to extend the change representations period until 8 December 2023. The representations primarily

                                                                                                     Page 1 of 8

Document Set ID: 22712822
Version: 5, Version Date: 22/12/2023
Full text of the other 7 pages

Page 2

               address the conditioned changes to the plans of development, with the applicant providing
               amended plans.
               2.     ASSESSMENT
               An assessment in relation to each of the submitted representations is provided below:
               MCU Condition 3 – Plans of Development
                      Plans and Documents
               3.     Development authorised by this approval must be undertaken generally in accordance with
                      the Approved Plans listed in the table below. The plans must be amended to incorporate the
                      amendments listed within the table below and resubmitted to Council prior to the issue of any
                      Development Permit for Building Works.

                         Plan No.                  Rev.         Plan/Document Name                       Date

                         C1.0                      -            Basement Floor, prepared by Chris 04.07.23
                                                                Clout Design

                         C1.1                      -            Ground Floor, prepared by Chris Clout 04.07.23
                                                                Design

                         C1.2                      -            Level 2, prepared by Chris Clout 04.07.23
                                                                Design

                         C3.0                      -            Section 1                                04.07.23

                      The following plans require amendment.

                         Plan No.           Rev.        Plan/Document Name                            Date

                         C0.1               -           Site Plan, prepared by Chris Clout Design     04.07.23

                         Amendments         •          Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                                       concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                                       of 10m from the front boundary.
                                            •          Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                                       found..
                         Plan No.           Rev.        Plan/Document Name                            Date

                         C1.3               -           Level 3, prepared by Chris Clout Design       04.07.23

                         Amendments         •          Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                                       concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                                       of 10m from the front boundary.
                         C1.4               -           Level 4, prepared by Chris Clout Design       04.07.23

                         Amendments         •          Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                                       concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                                       of 10m from the front boundary.
                                            •          Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                                       found..
                         Plan No.           Rev.        Plan/Document Name                            Date

                         C2.0               -           Elevation (East)                              04.07.23

                                                                                                          Page 2 of 8

Document Set ID: 22712822
Version: 5, Version Date: 22/12/2023

Page 3

                         Amendments    •   Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                           concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                           of 10m from the front boundary.
                                       •   Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                           found..
                         C2.1          -    Elevation (West)                              04.07.23

                                       •   Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                           found..
                         C2.2          -    Elevation (South)                             04.07.23

                         Amendments    •   Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                           concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                           of 10m from the front boundary.
                                       •   Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                           found..
                         C2.3          -    Elevation (North)                             04.07.23

                         Amendments    •   Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                           concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                           of 10m from the front boundary.
                                       •   Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                           found..
                         C3.1          -    Section 2                                     04.07.23

                         Amendments    •   Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                           concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                           of 10m from the front boundary.
                         C3.2          -    Section 3                                     04.07.23

                         Amendments    •   Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                           concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                           of 10m from the front boundary.
                                       •   Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                           found..
                         C3.3          -    Section 4                                     04.07.23

                         Amendments    •   Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                           found..
                         C3.4          -    Section 5                                     04.07.23

                         Amendments    •   Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                           found..
                         C3.5          -    Section 6                                     04.07.23

                         Amendments    •   Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                           concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                           of 10m from the front boundary.
                                       •   Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                           found..


                                                                                              Page 3 of 8

Document Set ID: 22712822
Version: 5, Version Date: 22/12/2023

Page 4

                         C3.6                -      Section 7                                      04.07.23

                         Amendments          •     Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                                   concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                                   of 10m from the front boundary.
                                             •     Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                                   found..
                         C3.7                -      Section 8                                      04.07.23

                         Amendments          •     Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                                   concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                                   of 10m from the front boundary.
                                             •     Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                                   found..
                         C3.8                -      Section 9                                      04.07.23

                         Amendments          •     Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered
                                                   concrete façade profiles and flat roof at Level 3 to a minimum
                                                   of 10m from the front boundary.
                                             •     Revise as per Condition Error! Reference source not
                                                   found..


               Applicant’s Representation
               The applicant submits that the plans have been amended to incorporate all suggested changes
               including:
               •    Remove/setback architectural features including the rendered concrete façade profiles and flat
                    roof at Level 3 to a minimum of 10m from the front boundary.
               •    Revise as per Condition 9 – ‘With the exception of the lift shaft and stairs, no wall or privacy
                    screen at Level 4 must be higher than 1.7 metres’.
               Assessment of Representation
               The proposed amended plans have removed the flat roof over the level 3 terraces which intruded
               into the 3rd storey setback of 10m in accordance with the conditioned plan changes. The flat roof
               has been replaced with a small eave overhang which is setback a minimum of 9.436m from the
               front boundary. This eave is considered acceptable within the setback as it will provide some
               shading to the level 3 façade and improve the building’s general presentation to Henderson Street.
               A dividing wall on the terrace has also been maintained between the units within the 10m front
               setback but has been reasonably tapered down towards the site’s front. These setbacks are shown
               in Figure 1 below.




                                                                                                       Page 4 of 8

Document Set ID: 22712822
Version: 5, Version Date: 22/12/2023

Page 5

                                                 Figure 1 – Front Setbacks to Level 3

               However, the amended plans have increased the height of the solid balustrading to the rooftop
               terrace from approximately 1.2m to 1.5m and result in the rooftop terrace being more visually
               prominent and contribute to its appearance of a fourth storey. These changes did not form part of
               the conditioned changes and are not acceptable. The condition is recommended to be changed to
               accept the revised plans but require change to the roof top structures.
               The amended plans otherwise satisfy the intent of the development approval conditions and The
               Noosa Plan 2020.


               OPW Condition 1 – Approved Plans
               1.     Development authorised by this approval must be undertaken generally in accordance with
                      the Approved Plans listed in the table below. The approved plans are listed in the following
                      table unless otherwise amended by these conditions.

                         Plan No.               Rev.    Plan/Document Name                       Date

                         C01                    G       General Notes prepared by HR Design      22 June 2023

                                                                                                     Page 5 of 8

Document Set ID: 22712822
Version: 5, Version Date: 22/12/2023

Page 6

                         C02                    G       Site Plan prepared by HR Design              22 June 2023

                         C03                    G       Finished Grading Plan prepared by HR 22 June 2023
                                                        Design

                         C04                    G       Cut Fill Plan prepared by HR Design          22 June 2023

                         C05                    G       Pavement Plan prepared by HR Design          22 June 2023

                         ED 22266 OPW - 01      D       Site Layout Plan by Element Design           30/06/2023

                         ED 22266 OPW - 02      D       Planting Plan (Ground          Level)   by 30/06/2023
                                                        Element Design

                         ED 22266 OPW - 03      D       Planting Plan (Level 04) by Element 30/06/2023
                                                        Design

                         ED 22266 OPW - 04      D       Details Plan by Element Design               30/06/2023

                         ED 22266 OPW - 05      D       Plant List & Specification Plan by 30/06/2023
                                                        Element Design

               Applicant’s Representation
               The applicant submits that the landscape plans have been updated in accordance with MCU
               condition 23 for waste management to include wheelie bins located behind the front fence. There
               are still ample landscaping areas in front of the building and fence to screen the bulk of the building,
               whilst providing for bin storage at the front of the site.
               Assessment of Representation
               The proposed locations of the waste storage areas are acceptable and consistent with condition
               23. Accordingly, these plans may be updated.


               3.     CONCLUSION & REASONS FOR DECISION
               It is concluded that the amended plans have addressed the required changes to the plans of
               development but have raised a new issue with the height of the balustrade on the rooftop terrace
               increased from 1.2m to 1.5m which is not acceptable. The condition has been amended to require
               changes to the roof terrace.
               RECOMMENDATION
               With regard to Application No. MCU22/0145 OPW22/0212, and the representations made, Council
               on 5 November 2023 decided to:
               A.     Agree to amend condition 3 of MCU22/0145 to read as follows:
                      Plans and Documents
               3.     Development authorised by this approval must be undertaken generally in accordance with
                      the Approved Plans listed in the table below. The plans must be amended to incorporate the
                      amendments listed within the table below and resubmitted to Council prior to the issue of any
                      Development Permit for Building Works.

                         Plan No.                Rev.         Plan/Document Name                         Date

                         C0.1                    -            Site Plan, prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                              Design


                                                                                                          Page 6 of 8

Document Set ID: 22712822
Version: 5, Version Date: 22/12/2023

Page 7

                         C1.0                  -            Basement Floor, prepared by Chris 21.11.23
                                                            Clout Design

                         C1.1                  -            Ground Floor, prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                            Design

                         C1.2                  -            Level 2, prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                            Design

                         C1.3                  -            Level 3, prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                            Design

                         C1.4                  -            Level 4, prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                            Design

                         C3.0                  -            Section 1 prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                            Design

                         C3.2                  -            Section 3 prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                            Design

                         C3.5                  -            Section 6 prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                            Design

                      The following plans require amendment.

                         Plan No.          Rev.     Plan/Document Name                          Date

                         C2.0              -        Elevation (East) prepared by Chirs Clout 21.11.23
                                                    Design

                         C2.1              -        Elevation (West) prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                    Design

                         C2.2              -        Elevation (South) prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                    Design

                         C2.3              -        Elevation (North) prepared by Chris Clout 21.11.23
                                                    Design

                         C3.1              -        Section 2 prepared by Chris Clout Design    21.11.23

                         C3.3              -        Section 4 prepared by Chris Clout Design    21.11.23

                         C3.4              -        Section 5 prepared by Chris Clout Design    21.11.23

                         C3.6              -        Section 7 prepared by Chris Clout Design    21.11.23

                         C3.7              -        Section 8 prepared by Chirs Clout Design    21.11.23

                         Amendments        •       The balustrades, acrylic pool window, planter boxes on
                                                   rooftop terrace must not exceed a maximum height of 1.2
                                                   metres as generally depicted on Drawing Numbers C2.0,
                                                   C2.1, C2.2, C2.3 and dated 4 July 2023 and to the
                                                   reasonable satisfaction of the Manager Development
                                                   Assessment.


                                                                                                    Page 7 of 8

Document Set ID: 22712822
Version: 5, Version Date: 22/12/2023

Page 8

               B.     Agree to amend condition 1 of OPW22/0212 to read as follows:
               1.     Development authorised by this approval must be undertaken generally in accordance with
                      the Approved Plans listed in the table below. The approved plans are listed in the following
                      table unless otherwise amended by these conditions.

                         Plan No.               Rev.   Plan/Document Name                        Date

                         C01                    G      General Notes prepared by HR Design       22 June 2023

                         C02                    G      Site Plan prepared by HR Design           22 June 2023

                         C03                    G      Finished Grading Plan prepared by HR 22 June 2023
                                                       Design

                         C04                    G      Cut Fill Plan prepared by HR Design       22 June 2023

                         C05                    G      Pavement Plan prepared by HR Design       22 June 2023

                         ED 22266 OPW - 01      F      Site Layout Plan by Element Design        21 Nov 2023

                         ED 22266 OPW - 02      F      Planting Plan (Ground        Level)   by 21 Nov 2023
                                                       Element Design

                         ED 22266 OPW - 03      F      Planting Plan (Level 04) by Element 21 Nov 2023
                                                       Design

                         ED 22266 OPW - 04      F      Details Plan by Element Design            21 Nov 2023

                         ED 22266 OPW - 05      F      Plant List & Specification Plan by 21 Nov 2023
                                                       Element Design


               C.     Note the report is provided in accordance with Section 83(9) of the Planning Act 2016.




                                                                                                     Page 8 of 8

Document Set ID: 22712822
Version: 5, Version Date: 22/12/2023

Used in these records

About this file

File size
417 KB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Negotiated Report (Representations made) MCU22 0145 [As Published].pdf · 417 KB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.