Skip to the record
Mmm.. taste the original NoosaWatch™

Council archive · source document

Further Advice Assessment Manager - MCU22/0118 (As published)

of 9

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

                                                                   Officer:            Tara Norley
                                                                   Direct Telephone:   07 53296486
                                                                   Our Reference:      MCU22/0118
                                                                   Your Reference:     18006

                 6 April 2023


                 Royal Automobile Club of Victoria (RACV) LTD
                 C/- Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
                 PO Box 894
                 COOROY QLD 4563
                 [email protected]



                 Dear Sir/Madam
                                       Further Advice – Development Application
                 I refer to your application and advise that Council wishes to provide you with further advice
                 about the application in accordance with the provisions of the Development Assessment Rules
                 2017.
                 1.     APPLICATION DETAILS

                  Application No.               MCU22/0118

                  Street Address:               94 & 142 Noosa Dr, Noosa Heads

                  Real Property Description:    Lot 0 SP 203417, Lot 3 SP 126203 and Lot 203 SP 267424

                  Planning Scheme:              Noosa Plan 2020 (25 September 2020)

                 2.     FURTHER ADVICE

                 You are advised that:
                 The response to the information request has not addressed the items adequately as outlined
                 in the Information Request dated 29 August 2022 and 2 September 2022.
                 Additional outstanding items have also been identified by Council through the assessment
                 process requiring further information from the applicant to be provided.
                 Issue – Stormwater Quality Targets and Treatment Device Details
                 The proposed bioretention device requires further detail to show that it can fit and function at
                 the location nominated and that the required pollutant reduction targets can therefore be
                 achieved. The following issues are noted:
                 •     The MUSIC model assumes the raised walkway and overflow from all rainwater tanks
                       will drain to the bioretention basin. It is unclear how this will be achieved with the
                       bioretention basin proposed to be in fill
                 •     Geotechnical testing at the location and depth proposed for the bioretention base is
                       considered critical and has not been provided
                 •     Even if the assumed hydraulic conductivity rates stated in the SWMP are adopted, if
                       these are correctly applied as the hydraulic conductivity of the bioretention device, the
                       size of the device will significantly increase
                 •     No details have been provided for the rainfall-runoff and pollutant export parameters
                       adopted for the source nodes in the MUSIC modelling

                                               PO Box 141                   P. (07) 5329 6500        [email protected]
                                               TEWANTIN QLD 4565            F. (07) 5329 6501        www.noosa.qld.gov.au
                                                                                                                Page 1 of 9
Document Set ID: 22350069
Version: 6, Version Date: 06/04/2023
Full text of the other 8 pages

Page 2

                 Information Required
                 1.     Provide an updated SWMP, MUSIC model and preliminary engineering plans which
                        address the following:
                        1.1. Provide geotechnical borehole and test results demonstrating that the proposed
                             ‘pipeless’ bioretention will function at the proposed location by providing the
                             following for the bioretention location: In-situ Soil classification, Groundwater level
                             (BGL and mAHD), and In-situ saturated hydraulic conductivity test results at
                             proposed level of bioretention base
                        1.2. Demonstrate that the In-situ saturated hydraulic conductivity results have been
                             correctly applied to the MUSIC model. These rates should be applied as the
                             bioretention design saturated hyd cond
                        1.3. Provide updated plans showing the spatial requirements for the updated
                             (enlarged) pipeless bioretention system
                        1.4. Provide details of the rainfall-runoff and pollutant export parameters adopted for
                             the source nodes in the MUSIC modelling (pre-development and post-
                             development scenarios)
                        1.5. Show how the rainwater tank overflows and the runoff from the raised walkways
                             will physically be able to drain to the proposed bioretention device, as assumed in
                             the MUSIC model

                 Issue – Vegetation Removal
                 The submitted application material does not provide sufficient information to demonstrate
                 compliance with Performance Outcome PO1 of the Biodiversity waterways and wetlands
                 overlay code. The development requires the removal of vegetation identified within a mapped
                 riparian buffer area, area of biodiversity significance, core koala habitat, connecting habitat
                 area, MSES high ecological significance wetland, MSES declared high ecological value
                 waters and Regional Ecosystem 12.2.7 identified as Endangered Coastal Swamp Sclerophyll
                 Forest of New South Wales and South East Queensland.
                 The site forms part of a large contiguous patch of Threatened Ecological Communities (TEC)
                 that connects to Regional Ecosystem 12.3.4, an expansion of this TEC, which extends to the
                 north of the site. The development of this site fragments this TEC and as a result of the
                 developments footprint and bushfire requirements, modifies the regional ecosystem / TEC and
                 diminishes the ecological significance.
                 It is difficult to see how the site will be rehabilitated to meet a true 12.2.7 Regional Ecosystem
                 with the required bushfire and landscape maintenance obligations to be implemented for the
                 site in perpetuity.
                 The development material requires all papery and fibrous bark trees such as Melaleuca
                 quinquenirvia and Eucalyptus robusta to be removed within the 10 metre inner protection area,
                 all shrubs removed entirely and ground covers maintained at a height of less than 100mm.
                 No trees/shrubs are to be retained within 3 m of the buildings, and beyond 3 metres, any trees
                 to be continuously defoliated below a height of 4m from ground level, and no limbs extending
                 to within 3 m of the roof line of buildings.
                 Balance areas identified as Area A on the landscape rehabilitation strategy requires shrubs
                 no closer than 2 metres to any eco cabins, and ground cover throughout to be managed to a
                 maximum height of no greater than 100mm.




                                                                                                            Page 2 of 9
Document Set ID: 22350069
Version: 6, Version Date: 06/04/2023

Page 3

                 The development application material has not demonstrated ecologically important areas are
                 conserved or improved to ensure their ongoing contribution to the natural resources and
                 biological diversity of Noosa Shire, or protect existing habitat areas, ecological linkages
                 riparian vegetation or wetland habitat.
                 Information Required
                 2.     Demonstrate compliance with PO1 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
                        Overlay Code.


                 Issue – Ecologically Important Areas
                 The submitted application material does not provide sufficient information to demonstrate
                 compliance with Performance Outcome PO3 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
                 Overlay Code. The development layout has not been designed or sited to manage adverse
                 impacts on ecologically important areas. The site habitat trees, recruitment habitat trees,
                 roosting, breeding and feeding areas are being cleared to achieve the development footprint
                 proposed.
                 The ecological values of the site are being compromised and the ecological values of the sites
                 ecosystem diminished due to the impacts of vegetation clearing and construction of the
                 development within a mapped core koala habitat area and connecting habitat.
                 The development will bring the development front closer to identified Threatened Ecological
                 Communities, riparian areas, wetlands and waterways located north and west of the site. This
                 will result in a disturbed ecotone closer to the sensitive ecological communities adjacent the
                 western boundary.
                 Information Required
                 3.     Demonstrate compliance with PO3 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
                        Overlay Code.


                 Issue – Connecting Habitat Areas
                 The submitted application material does not provide sufficient information to demonstrate
                 compliance with Performance Outcome PO5 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
                 Overlay Code and PO26 of the Noosa Heads Local Plan Code. The site is identified on SFM-4
                 – Biodiversity strategic framework map as a connecting habitat area.
                 The development does not maintain or enhance connectivity in the north south direction. The
                 development layout reduces the width of the current undeveloped ecological linkage and
                 impedes the natural habitat with anthropogenic structures.
                 The development reduces the overall patch size of the core koala habitat, Threatened
                 Ecological Community - Coastal swamp Sclerophyll Forest of New South Wales and South
                 East Queensland associated with Regional Ecosystems 12.2.7 and 12.3.4.
                 The development does not provide solutions for existing fauna movement issues such as
                 wildlife movement infrastructure, exclusion or directional fencing, underpass or overpasses,
                 and relies completely on the elevated nature of the development to demonstrate the
                 maintenance of connectivity.
                 The proposed development does not achieve the requirements of AO26 of the Noosa Heads
                 Local Plan Code due to encroachment into areas of ecological importance and fragmentation
                 of connecting habitat through vegetation removal and infrastructure placement. PO26 of the
                 Noosa Heads Local Plan Code requires that no significant adverse impacts on biodiversity,
                 natural vegetation, native fauna habitat, landscape quality, water quality, and cultural heritage
                 values occurs.




                                                                                                          Page 3 of 9
Document Set ID: 22350069
Version: 6, Version Date: 06/04/2023

Page 4

                 Information Required
                 4.     Demonstrate compliance with PO5 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
                        Overlay Code and PO26 of the Noosa Heads Local Plan Code.
                 5.     Provide a revised development layout that demonstrates no significant adverse impacts
                        by providing the development footprint outside the areas identified as a connecting
                        habitat identified on Map SFM-4 – Biodiversity (Strategic Framework).


                 Issue – Development within Waterways and Wetlands Areas
                 The submitted application material does not provide sufficient information to demonstrate
                 compliance with Performance Outcome PO6 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
                 Overlay Code. The development footprint indicates buildings and vegetation clearing within a
                 mapped riparian protection area identified along the western boundary as well as an MSES
                 high ecological significance wetland and MSES declared high ecological value waters
                 (wetland).
                 The development indicates vegetation removal within the riparian protection area, reduction
                 in the width of the terrestrial habitat within the riparian zone, and the width of wildlife corridor
                 and connecting habitat. The development increases the development footprint of the RACV
                 development and will result in clearing in areas currently vegetated.
                 Requirements of the bushfire hazard management plan will reduce canopy, remove mid strata
                 and require ground layers less than 100mm. This will create an increase in light penetration
                 and rise in the possibility of weed ingress into the riparian buffer and associated ecological
                 communities associated with Weyba Creek.
                 Information Required
                 6.     Provide a revised development footprint that demonstrates compliance with PO6 by
                        avoiding all new development within the riparian buffer area and MSES wetland areas.


                 Issue – Koala Habitat
                 The submitted application material does not provide sufficient information to demonstrate
                 compliance with Performance Outcome PO11 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
                 Overlay Code. The development requires the removal of koala habitat and feed trees to
                 achieve the development footprint. The development material indicates a total of 101 Koala
                 Trees have been confirmed on the site, with the proposal requiring 44 (28%) of the koala trees
                 to be removed with an additional 10 (6%) potentially required to be removed.
                 A review of the material indicates that there is potentially more vegetation clearing than what
                 is shown on the tree removal vs retention plan. Trees marked as koala trees retained on the
                 retention plan contradict the requirements of the bushfire hazard assessment
                 recommendations and the landscape requirements identified on the rehabilitation strategy.
                 The number of non-koala and koala trees to be retained is questioned, and it would appear
                 when the bushfire, ecology, tree, and landscape documents are cross checked against each
                 other that there are significant differences in the outcomes of the site and how the site is to be
                 managed.
                 The application material has not demonstrated how incorporating the development within the
                 middle of a core koala habitat area will assist in the survival of koala populations in the area
                 and mitigate the potential threats including providing safe and appropriate koala movement
                 across the landscape.




                                                                                                             Page 4 of 9
Document Set ID: 22350069
Version: 6, Version Date: 06/04/2023

Page 5

                 AO11.2 requires that development incorporates revegetation and provides food, shelter and
                 movement opportunities for koalas. Long term it is difficult to see how this can be achieved
                 when the landscape requirements for bushfire protection (rehabilitation strategy) require that
                 no trees or shrubs are to be retained within 3 metres of buildings, and beyond 3m any trees
                 are to be continuously defoliated below 4m height from ground level, and no limbs are to
                 extend to within 3 metres of the roof line of the buildings.
                 Information Required
                 7.     Provide a revised tree retention plans that integrates all bushfire, ecology, tree, and
                        landscape recommendations and utilises this information to demonstrate how the
                        development has protected and enhanced koalas and koala habitat and avoids adverse
                        impacts, both direct and indirect.


                 Issue – Bushfire Management within Biodiversity Areas
                 The submitted application material does not provide sufficient information to demonstrate
                 compliance with Performance Outcome PO12 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
                 Overlay Code. The proposed bushfire management measures required to be adopted do not
                 maintain or enhance the biodiversity of the ecological community on the site. The proposal
                 requires the removal of Koala habitat / feed trees, removes the mid strata layer of the regional
                 ecosystem down to under 500mm in height and requires the understorey be maintained to
                 less than 100mm in height. These changes to the Regional Ecosystem to achieve a suitable
                 bushfire separation distance is in opposition to the main principles of the Biodiversity,
                 Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code.
                 It appears that there are inconsistencies between the tree removal plan, landscape plans and
                 bushfire management plan. The bushfire management plan requires the inner protection area
                 have all papery and fibrous bark trees such as Melaleuca quinquenervia and Eucalyptus
                 robusta be removed, including the entire shrub layer. The tree removal plan indicates the
                 retention of these species within the inner protection area.
                 The landscape plans indicate that the inner protection area extends along the western
                 boundary in front of units 1,2,3, and 4. The tree management plan needs to be updated to
                 include the correct level of vegetation clearing, which will include all papery and fibrous bark
                 trees such as Melaleuca quinquenervia and Eucalyptus robusta, all shrubs to be removed and
                 ground covers no greater that 100mm in height in accordance with the bushfire hazard
                 assessment for inner protection areas.
                 The landscape plans indicate that no trees/shrubs are to be retained within 3m of buildings.
                 The tree retention plan indicates many trees being retained within the 3m limit imposed by the
                 Landscape Plans. These plans also indicate that tree canopies cannot have any limbs that
                 extend to within 3 metres of the roof line of the buildings. This will require the removal of
                 significant areas of tree crown to comply. This is deemed as an unrealistic outcome for the
                 development and the long-term health of the trees.
                 Information Required
                 8.     Provided a revised tree retention plans that integrate all bushfire, ecology, tree, and
                        landscape recommendations and utilises this information to demonstrate how the
                        development maintain and enhance biodiversity.




                                                                                                         Page 5 of 9
Document Set ID: 22350069
Version: 6, Version Date: 06/04/2023

Page 6

                 Issue – Scenic Amenity
                 The submitted application material does not provide sufficient information to demonstrate
                 compliance with Performance Outcome PO13 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
                 Overlay Code. The subject site is located on a major road network and includes buildings and
                 structures that do not meet AO13.1 - vegetation is retained within 10 metres of the major road
                 network. The bushfire management plan requires that Area A on the landscape rehabilitation
                 strategy requires shrubs maintained no closer than 2 metres to any eco-cabins and ground
                 covers throughout this area is to be managed to a maximum height no greater than 100 mm
                 (also refer to Issue – Setbacks above).
                 Information Required
                 9.     Demonstrate compliance with AO13.1 by retaining all native vegetation (trees, shrubs,
                        and groundcovers) within 10 metres of the major road network.


                 Issue – MSES Wetland
                 The site is mapped as being an MSES high ecological significance wetland and MSES
                 declared high ecological value waters (wetland). The application material has not addressed
                 these aspects of the site and how the development will prevent any direct or indirect impacts
                 to this ecologically important area. Development should protect the physical and ecological
                 integrity and biodiversity of the ecologically important areas through protection of terrestrial
                 habitat and existing riparian, waterway and wetland habitat areas.
                 Information Required
                 10.    Provide a revised ecological assessment that addresses the direct and indirect impacts
                        this development will have on the MSES wetlands and what mitigation measures have
                        been implemented to demonstrate no impacts will occur.


                 Issue – Threatened Ecological Community
                 The application material has not addressed the Commonwealths EPBC search that identifies
                 the site containing regional ecosystem 12.2.7 which is an Endangered category of the
                 threatened ecological communities list under the Environmental Protection and Biodiversity
                 Conservation Act 1999. The site vegetation is considered to conform to the definition of
                 Coastal Swamp Sclerophyll Forest of New South Wales and South East Queensland
                 Threatened Ecological Community.
                 Information Required
                 11.    Provide sufficient information to demonstrate that the development will not have a
                        significant impact on the critically endangered ecological community. This must include:
                        11.1. demonstration that the development will not reduce the extent of an ecological
                              community
                        11.2. fragment or increase fragmentation of an ecological community, for example by
                              clearing vegetation for roads, transmission lines or infrastructure
                        11.3. adversely affect habitat critical to the survival of an ecological community
                        11.4. modify or destroy abiotic (non-living) factors (such as water, nutrients, or soil)
                              necessary for an ecological community’s survival, including reduction of
                              groundwater levels, or substantial alteration of surface water drainage patterns
                        11.5. cause a substantial change in the species composition of an occurrence of an
                              ecological community, including causing a decline or loss of functionally important
                              species




                                                                                                             Page 6 of 9
Document Set ID: 22350069
Version: 6, Version Date: 06/04/2023

Page 7

                         11.6. cause a substantial reduction in the quality or integrity of an occurrence of an
                               ecological community, including, but not limited to: – assisting invasive species,
                               that are harmful to the listed ecological community, to become established, or –
                               causing regular mobilisation of fertilisers, herbicides or other chemicals or
                               pollutants into the ecological community which kill or inhibit the growth of species
                               in the ecological community, or
                         11.7. interfere with the recovery of an ecological community.
                         11.8. demonstrate that a referral application is not required.


                 Issue – Bushfire Management
                 The application material indicates that significant areas of native vegetation, core koala
                 habitat, threatened ecological communities and MSES wetlands are required to be cleared to
                 achieve the proposed separation distances for Units 1 and 2.
                 The development has not demonstrated that the bushfire mitigation measures do not have
                 adverse impact on the biodiversity values, connectivity and ecosystem function of the site and
                 the surrounding ecologically important areas.
                 Information Required
                 12.     Provide revised development plans that incorporates a development footprint that does
                         not require vegetation clearing and ongoing maintenance to facilitate the development.


                 Issue
                 The application material has not demonstrated safe access and egress to the whole
                 development for emergency vehicles and personnel. Some units are approximately 70 metres
                 from the carpark area where the bushfire hazard assessment requires ‘at least one fire hydrant
                 stand pipe within the central portion of the car parking area’. It is difficult to understand how
                 QFES vehicles and personnel are to respond in an emergency situation and protect
                 infrastructure from fire.
                 Information Required
                 13.     Demonstrate compliance with PO6 of the Bushfire Hazard Overlay Code


                 In light of the above items, the following further Planning issues are also now required
                 to be addressed:
                 Issue – Building Height
                 The proposal plans indicate that Cabins 1-6 and 13-16 include portions of the roof over 8m in
                 height. Any proposal over 8m in height is not supported.

                 It is noted that the Environmental Management and Conservation zone provisions require a
                 maximum building height of 4m and one storey. Any proposed development within the EM&C
                 zone must not exceed 4m in height and one storey, however please refer to below Issue –
                 Setbacks for further requirements relating to the EM&C zone.
                 Information Required
                 14.     Provide amended plans complying with the maximum 8m height limit.




                                                                                                           Page 7 of 9
Document Set ID: 22350069
Version: 6, Version Date: 06/04/2023

Page 8

                 Issue – Setbacks
                 The proposal includes building and structures located within both the Tourist Accommodation
                 zone and the Environmental Management and Conservation zone (EM&C).

                 The Tourist Accommodation Zone Code allows a minimum 6m setback from the road frontage,
                 however Performance Outcome PO4 of the Noosa Heads Local Plan Code requires ‘the visual
                 amenity and character surrounding the major road network and entrance roads is protected
                 and enhances the entrance to Noosa Heads’, whilst Acceptable Outcome AO13.1 of the
                 Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code requires that ‘vegetation is retained
                 within 10m of the major road networks’. The proposed locations of Cabins 7-12 will require
                 vegetation removal along the Noosa Drive road frontage, significantly impacting on the visual
                 / scenic amenity and vegetated character of the area. The proposed setbacks to Noosa Drive
                 are not supported, and in particular, no buildings or structures are to be located within the 6m
                 front boundary setback at a minimum (also refer to Issue – Scenic Amenity below).

                 The Environmental Management and Conservation Zone Code requires all buildings and
                 structures to be setback ‘a distance greater than the width of the riparian buffer area shown
                 on Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetland Overlay map’. The proposed location of Cabins 1-8
                 within the EM&C zone and riparian buffer area is not supported, as the location does not:
                 •      avoid or minimise disturbance on the ecological values of the land and wetlands,
                 •      allow for vegetation retention and regrowth around the buildings and structures (due to
                        bushfire management requirements) or
                 •      protect the natural character and visual amenity of Weyba Creek (when viewed from
                        Noosa Drive).
                 Information Required
                 15.    Provide amended plans:
                        15.1. Increasing the setback to Noosa Drive to ensure no impacts on the visual amenity
                              and character of the area when viewed from Noosa Drive.
                        15.2. removing all buildings and structures from the mapped riparian buffer area.


                 Issue – SARA Response
                 It is noted that the SARA response to the application includes specific conditions regarding
                 limiting clearing of koala vegetation and a requirement for a covenant, with restrictions on
                 works in the covenant area (including firebreaks). It is unclear how the development can be
                 constructed and operate in accordance with the SARA conditions.
                 Information Required
                 16.    Provide evidence that the proposal can be constructed on site and operate whilst
                        complying with the SARA conditions and covenant requirements in perpetuity.




                                                                                                         Page 8 of 9
Document Set ID: 22350069
Version: 6, Version Date: 06/04/2023

Page 9

                 3.     DUE DATE FOR RESPONSE TO FURTHER ADVICE

                 A response to the further advice is required by <insert date response required>. Email your
                 response to [email protected].     OTHER DETAILS

                 Should you have any further queries in relation to the above, please do not hesitate to contact
                 me on the number above.

                 Yours faithfully




                 Tara Norley
                 Development Planner




                                                                                                        Page 9 of 9
Document Set ID: 22350069
Version: 6, Version Date: 06/04/2023

Used in these records

About this file

File size
160 KB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Further Advice Assessment Manager - MCU22_0118 (As published).pdf · 160 KB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.