2017-03-13 General Committee Agenda

ATTACHMENT 1




 Page 8 of 34

NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
                        Design & Construction of Peregian Geach Digital Rub Building &
    pCa                                                                                                        ATTACHMENT 1
[cence                 fioms
      NAME OF TENDERER              PRICE
      (Conforming Tenders Only)   (excl of GST)
     i
     2 [Bryant (Qld) Pty te 98,445}
     3
     4
     5 [Midson Construction  ees      189, 120}
     6
     7
     Be
     Sp
    tO
      NON-CONFORMING TENDERS
      IR&O Communication Pty Ltd
      a |                                |
                                     1        2         3        4        5        6         7        8        9        10
                                          vo  0 rs [Og snorted
                                                      n onstructions integra! Constructio iCQ Co truction Pt UM Civil Contrecto
                                               Resultant
      Evaluation Criteria                      score x
                                               weightin             I        Ct       ating    1
     Ervmrinatenaatewnen | as  | vas | om [ me | ase [noms | om [oom] ame | vas [om [vss | co [mum | an | 0 [om | 0 | om | 0 | om |
      MethodsloeyterProjectDetvery | zox | ses | a0 | ss | sao | 7 | smo | sors | a | as | am | ie | sa | 2 | 2 [| o | om | o | om | o | 000 |
      entry          ms               ots Ts | ots Ts | os | s [os | s | os | s | oa | 2s | ox | o | om | oo | om | 0 | om |
     Panna setety                 ss | ote | seers | ous | aus | ox | asus | ox | aseas | om | ars | ow | 2s | os | o | om | 0 | om | 0 | om |
     frekoomenesensiebimy | me ts | os | s | os | s | os | os [os | s | os | s | os | 2s | om | © | om | o | om | o | om |
     foumiowwctwom     | ox | 2 | om | + | om | na | ie |uons| on [ues] om [umm] om [wom] om | © | om | o | om | 0 | om |
      tat Techn Soe    a EE                                        ee       ee       ee       ee       ee       ee       ee
            Mermeted Tecate Sere (Td                                                                rr a
      [eam titnedemant          | Hutchinson sere | Sooner ied | OO tag nn prytad | Méton construction [NOT | mm |
                                                     K ons ton: integra! Constructic iCQ Constructio IM Civil
      ‘otal Fees (Pc)              $2,727,461 $2,933,445 $2,997,938 $3,121,684 $3,169,120 $3,326,350 $5,930,410        $0
       erage Fees (Pav) $.........ccee
      Price Score                   121       115       113      110      108      104      29                          °
      Normalised Price Score (Pn)   100       95        94       91       89       86       24                          °
        thted Price Score (Pw)
          [aa on ped np So                                                                             ee      ee
              Ce                                                  The Contract Administrator confirms the above scores
        Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member 1             and weightings of this evaluation
| Assesment PanelMember2        |   Property Advisor, Corporate Services|
                                                                    Contract Administrator's signature: Project Manager, Planning and Infrastructure
                                 Workplace Health and Safety Advisor, Executive Office
             Assesment Panel Member 5 Procurement Services Consultant
                                                                                                                 Page 8 of 34