Council archive · source document
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report · 132008.299.02
1
Dolphin Beach House MCU
Response to Council Information Request - Item 1
Intensity and need for visitor use in a residential zone
Application matter Other Change / Visitor Accommodation Type 4 -
Visitor Hostel
Council information request item Demonstrate overriding need for the proposed
additional 42 persons and 1 manager unit, having regard
to permanent residential housing and key worker
accommodation.
Subject site context Existing lawful visitor hostel operation across two
related premises, including 14 Duke Street and Lot 3 on
SP228958.
Purpose of this document To provide a detailed economic, tourism, workforce and
destination-management response to Council's stated
concern about intensity and need.
Date 10 June 2026
Central proposition
The overriding need is demonstrated because the proposal is a modest, managed and evidence-based intensification of
an existing lawful hostel use, responding to a constrained hostel accommodation market and supporting Noosa's visitor
economy and workforce ecosystem, while aligning with Council's Destination Management Plan approach of managed,
values-aligned tourism and without removing existing permanent housing stock or displacing key worker
accommodation.
Prepared for Council information response
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 35 pages
Page 2
2
Contents
1. Council request and direct response
2. Executive summary – overriding need is demonstrated
3. Correct planning frame: not a binary choice between tourism and housing
4. Quantified accommodation need: limited hostel supply and Dolphin-specific functional capacity
5. Site-specific operational and market evidence
6. Affordable hostel accommodation as a distinct land-use and economic product
7. Tourism economy evidence: Noosa, Sunshine Coast and Queensland context
8. Independent traveller, working holiday maker and workforce nexus
9. Indicative economic contribution of the proposal
10. Alignment with Noosa’s Destination Management Plan
11. Housing and key worker accommodation response
12. Response to the overdevelopment assertion
13. Management and conditioning commitments
14. Conclusion
Appendix A – References
Evidence basis and assumptions
This response relies on a combination of applicant/operator evidence, publicly available tourism and economic data,
and Council policy material. Operator-specific information, including seasonal occupancy, waitlist, guest profile,
transport behaviour, accommodation rates, management practices and complaint history, is based on advice provided
by the operator of Dolphin Beach House and its operating experience.
External tourism, economic, workforce, housing and destination-management sources are identified in Appendix A –
References. Where figures are described as approximate, indicative or “in the order of”, they are provided as planning
and economic context rather than as a formal economic impact assessment, valuation report or feasibility report
Prepared for Council information response
Page 3
3
1. Council request and direct response
Council's information request relevantly states:
"Noting the existing approval for Visitor Accommodation Type 4 - Visitor Hostel, Council is concerned that the
proposed additional 42 persons and 1 Manager unit over Lot 3 on SP228958 results in a high development intensity
across two smaller and divided lots located within the Medium Density Residential zone. Combined with the existing
development at 14 Duke Street, the total accommodation of 102 persons is considered an overdevelopment.
Information Required: Demonstrate an overriding need for a high intensity Visitor Hostel accommodation in a
Residential zone over the high need for permanent residential housing and key worker accommodation."
The applicant submits that the requested overriding need is clearly demonstrated. The need is not advanced on the
basis that visitor accommodation is generally more important than permanent housing. That is not the correct planning
test for this application. The need is demonstrated by the particular planning, economic and operational circumstances
of this proposal.
The subject use is already lawfully established as Visitor Accommodation Type 4 - Visitor Hostel. The application does
not convert permanent dwellings to short-term accommodation. It does not remove existing permanent rental stock. It
does not displace an approved residential or key-worker housing project.
Refusal of the change would not deliver permanent housing or key worker accommodation; it would simply retain the
existing hostel approval without the additional accommodation, workforce and economic benefits now proposed.
The more accurate planning characterisation is that the proposal is a modest and managed intensification of an existing
hostel use, supported by strong evidence of need, including constrained hostel supply, peak-season occupancy at
functional capacity, peak waiting lists, affordability, international and working-holiday demand, low car dependency,
strict management controls and a long complaint-free operational history.
Council's Destination Management Plan reinforces this framing. Council's own destination-management material does
not treat tourism as an activity to be eliminated; it seeks to manage tourism so that it respects community, protects the
environment, nurtures a thriving local economy and is delivered in balance with nature and local values.
The proposal responds to that policy direction by accommodating a demonstrated visitor and working-holiday cohort
within an existing, supervised and low-car hostel operation, rather than pushing demand into unmanaged dwellings or
unregulated visitor accommodation alternatives.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 4
4
2. Executive summary - overriding need is demonstrated
The overriding need is demonstrated cumulatively. The following factors should be read together rather than in isolation:
Existing lawful use: the land already benefits from approval for Visitor Accommodation Type 4 - Visitor Hostel. This is
not a new visitor use being introduced into an otherwise residential site.
No direct loss of housing: no existing permanent residential dwelling, permanent rental accommodation or key worker
accommodation is being removed or converted.
No realistic affordable housing displacement: while the site is in the Medium Density Residential Zone and may
theoretically have capacity for a small multiple dwelling redevelopment, that should not be equated with delivery of
affordable or key worker housing. Given the coastal location, land value, construction costs and likely market
positioning, any future residential redevelopment would likely produce a small number of high-value dwellings rather
than affordable or key worker accommodation. Refusal of the proposed change should therefore not be assumed to
advance Council's housing-affordability objectives.
Limited hostel supply: Noosa presently has approximately 510 hostel beds across only five hostel premises.
Modest market increase: the proposed additional 42 beds represent approximately 8.2% of the existing Noosa hostel
bed supply.
Functional capacity in the existing market: at 95% market occupancy, the 510-bed Noosa hostel sector has only
approximately 25.5 spare beds per night across the whole shire on average.
Peak-season demand: operator SiteMinder data shows occupancy of approximately 97% to 100% between October
and March, with peak-period waiting lists of up to approximately 60 persons.
Affordable accommodation product: rates from approximately $45 for a shared dorm bed, $125 for a double room and
$145 for a double room with ensuite provide one of the few low-cost visitor accommodation options in Noosa.
Specific traveller cohort: the operator advises that guests are approximately 85% international, mainly aged 24 to 32,
with a substantial working-holiday component.
Workforce-support function: the operator advises that approximately 65% of guests are on the working holiday
pathway and many seek or undertake work in Noosa and surrounding areas in hospitality, building, landscaping,
horticulture, nurseries and other service sectors, subject to visa rules.
Low car dependency: approximately 75% of guests use local transport, with only around 25% having cars. The
accommodation model is not equivalent to conventional residential traffic generation.
Managed and low-impact operation: the operator has a management plan, identification/passport verification
procedures, strict management controls, a beach/nature/yoga/surfing market position, and no complaint history over
an established 25 to 30 year business history.
Council DMP support: Council's own Destination Management Plan does not seek to eliminate tourism. It seeks to
manage tourism so that it benefits locals, protects community values, supports the economy, encourages responsible
Prepared for Council information response
Page 5
5
visitor behaviour and reduces pressure on infrastructure. The proposal aligns with that policy direction because it
provides managed, low-car, affordable hostel accommodation within an existing lawful operation, rather than
dispersing visitor demand into unmanaged residential short-stay accommodation.
3. Correct planning frame: not a binary choice between tourism and housing
Council's request asks the applicant to demonstrate overriding need for visitor hostel accommodation "over" the need
for permanent residential housing and key worker accommodation. The applicant acknowledges the importance of
permanent housing and key worker accommodation in Noosa. However, the request should not be framed as a simple
contest between all visitor accommodation and all housing.
The Noosa Housing Strategy 2022 acknowledges the housing crisis, limited housing supply and the particular challenge
created by a local economy with significant tourism, retail and hospitality employment. It also recognises that many
existing developments in Medium and High Density Residential zones came through historical approvals allowing use as
either visitor accommodation or permanent occupation, and that those approvals cannot be removed. The Strategy
states that making further short-term accommodation inconsistent in those zones applies to new development or sites
that do not already have approval for the use.[8]
That distinction is important. This application relates to an existing approved hostel use. The proposal is not seeking to
commit a previously residential site to a new visitor use. It is seeking to adjust an already established, managed and
historically operating hostel. The relevant question is therefore whether the proposed intensification of that existing
hostel use is justified and manageable having regard to need, amenity, transport, management and local economic
function.
The applicant submits that it is. Refusal of the proposed 42 additional beds would not produce any new permanent
housing supply. No self-contained apartments, affordable housing units or key worker dwellings are proposed or
approved on the site. The existing hostel use would remain. Accordingly, the proposal should be assessed on its actual
planning merits, rather than on an abstract assumption that every visitor bed is directly substitutable for permanent
housing.
The DMP is relevant to that planning frame because it draws a distinction between unmanaged visitor pressure and
consciously managed, values-aligned tourism. The applicant's case is not that all tourism growth should be prioritised
over housing. The case is that this particular proposal represents managed accommodation infrastructure for a
demonstrated international, independent and working-holiday traveller cohort, without converting housing stock or
undermining an actual affordable-housing outcome.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 6
6
4. Quantified accommodation need: limited hostel supply and Dolphin – specific functional capacity
The strongest evidence of overriding need is the combination of limited Noosa-wide hostel supply and direct Dolphin
Beach House operating data.
The applicant understands that there are approximately 510 hostel beds across five hostel premises in Noosa. That is a
limited specialist accommodation supply base for a mature destination economy with significant overnight visitor
demand.
The proposed additional 42 beds represent approximately 8.2% of the existing Noosa hostel bed supply. In market-
supply terms, this is a modest increase. It does not represent a material or speculative expansion of the Noosa hostel
sector.
The applicant’s strongest demand evidence is the operator’s own SiteMinder and booking data for Dolphin Beach
House. That data shows that Dolphin Beach House operates at approximately 97% to 100% occupancy between
October and March, approximately 65% occupancy between April and July, and approximately 75% occupancy across
August and September. The operation therefore reaches functional capacity during the primary visitor season, while still
experiencing ordinary seasonal variation across the year.
This distinction is important. References in
this response to “functional capacity” are
directed to the primary visitor season and
peak-demand periods for Dolphin Beach
House. By contrast, the economic
modelling later in this response adopts a
conservative weighted annual occupancy
estimate of approximately 83.4%, based
on the operator’s full seasonal profile. This
avoids overstating annual economic yield
while still recognising that the hostel
reaches functional capacity during the
main visitor season.
The operator also records peak-period
waiting lists of up to approximately 60
persons. That waitlist evidence relates to
Dolphin Beach House only.
Figure 1: Comparison of Noosa-wide market capacity against Dolphin-specific unmet demand.
It does not purport to quantify unmet demand across the other four hostel premises in Noosa. It is nevertheless
significant that the proposed additional 42 beds would not fully absorb the peak-period unmet demand recorded by this
one operator, before any allowance is made for unmet demand that may also exist at other hostel premises.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 7
7
Accordingly, the accommodation need is demonstrated both at the market level and at the site-specific level. At the
market level, Noosa has a limited hostel supply base of approximately 510 beds. At the site-specific level, Dolphin
Beach House’s own operating data demonstrates functional capacity during the primary visitor season and a peak-
period waitlist exceeding the proposed additional bed capacity.
Metric Calculation / evidence Result / implication
Existing Noosa hostel supply Approx. 510 beds across five hostel Limited specialist accommodation
premises supply in a mature destination
economy.
Noosa visitor economy context Approx. 2 million visitors, more than Demonstrates that hostel supply
$1.4 billion visitor spend and must be assessed in the context of a
approx. 4.7 million visitor nights in significant overnight visitor
2024.[3] economy.
Proposed additional beds 42 beds Targeted increase to an existing
lawful hostel use.
Proposed increase to Noosa hostel 42 ÷ 510 Approx. 8.2% increase in total
supply Noosa hostel bed supply.
Dolphin Beach House peak-season Approx. 97% to 100% between Demonstrates functional capacity
occupancy October and March during the primary visitor season.
Dolphin Beach House shoulder/off- Approx. 65% April to July; approx. Confirms normal tourism
season occupancy 75% August to September seasonality and supports
conservative annual modelling.
Indicative weighted annual Oct–Mar at midpoint 98.5%; Apr–Jul Approx. 83.4% annualized
occupancy for Dolphin Beach House at 65%; Aug–Sep at 75% occupancy for conservative
economic modelling.
Range of weighted annual Using 97% to 100% for Oct–Mar Approx. 82.6% to 84.1%.
occupancy
Dolphin Beach House peak-period Up to approx. 60 persons The proposed 42 beds would not
waitlist fully absorb Dolphin Beach House’s
own peak-period waitlist.
Other hostel demand Not quantified in this response Noosa-wide unmet demand is not
relied upon unless separately
evidenced; the need case is
supported by Dolphin-specific data
alone.
Source: Existing Noosa hostel-supply estimate and Dolphin Beach House operating data are applicant/operator
evidence, Noosa visitor economy figures are sourced from Tourism Noosa.[3] Calculations are prepared from those
figures.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 8
8
At 95% occupancy, the Noosa hostel market is not merely busy. It is operating at functional capacity. In
accommodation-market terms, occupancy at or near this level leaves minimal ability to absorb peak seasonal demand,
group bookings, extended-stay working holiday makers, late-booking travellers or independent travellers seeking
affordable accommodation.
For clarity, the reference to functional capacity in this section is directed to the primary visitor season and peak-demand
periods, when the operator's data shows occupancy of approximately 97% to 100% between October and March. This is
different from the conservative annualised occupancy assumption used later in this response for economic modelling
purposes, which applies a weighted seasonal average across the full year.
The proposed 42 beds are therefore not speculative oversupply. They are a modest and targeted response to a
demonstrable capacity constraint. The proposal would increase the total Noosa hostel bed supply by only
approximately 8.2%, and even that additional capacity would not fully meet the operator's peak-period waiting list of up
to approximately 60 persons.
5. Site-specific operational and market evidence
The proposal is supported by direct
operator evidence rather than generic
tourism assumptions. The operator’s
booking and operational evidence
demonstrates that Dolphin Beach House
serves a highly specific accommodation
market and that the proposed additional
beds respond to an identified need within
that operation.
The evidence is important because it
demonstrates that the proposal is not
simply an increase in visitor numbers. It is
a response to an existing, established and
managed hostel operation that reaches
functional capacity during the primary
visitor season, accommodates a specific
international independent-traveller
cohort, has low private-car reliance,
contributes to the local workforce
Figure 2: Dolphin Beach House Seasonal Occupancy Profile demonstrating functional capacity during peak periods.
ecosystem, and has operated without complaint over a long period.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 9
9
The operator advises that the business remains seasonal, consistent with broader tourism patterns. Operator data
indicates occupancy of approximately 97% to 100% between October and March, approximately 65% between April and
July, and approximately 75% across August and September. This supports the need case in two ways. First, it confirms
that the operation reaches functional capacity during the main visitor season. Secondly, it supports the use of a
conservative weighted annual occupancy estimate for economic modelling rather than relying on peak-season
occupancy alone.
The operator also records peak-period waiting lists of up to approximately 60 persons. This waitlist evidence relates to
Dolphin Beach House only and does not purport to quantify unmet demand across the other hostel premises in Noosa.
However, it is highly relevant because the proposed additional 42 beds would not fully absorb the peak-period unmet
demand recorded by Dolphin Beach House itself.
The operator’s guest profile also supports the need case. The operator advises that approximately 85% of guests are
international travellers, with domestic guests comprising approximately 10% of the market. The main guest age group is
approximately 24 to 32 years. This confirms that the hostel is serving a specialist international, youth and independent-
traveller market rather than the conventional domestic holiday-house or apartment market.
The operator further advises that approximately 65% of guests are on the working holiday pathway, subject to individual
visa conditions. Many guests seek or undertake work in Noosa and surrounding areas, including hospitality, building,
landscaping, horticulture, nurseries, farms and other local service sectors. This evidence is relevant to Council’s
concern regarding key worker accommodation because the hostel provides temporary, affordable accommodation to a
cohort that contributes to the local labour-force ecosystem.
The operator also advises that approximately 20% of guests are short-term travellers, with short-term visa guests
commonly staying between approximately 4 and 14 days. Earlier operator evidence indicated an average stay of
approximately 13 days. This stay profile is materially different from a high-churn weekend party-house model. It
indicates a managed independent-traveller accommodation model with a longer stay pattern than typical short-stay
holiday accommodation.
The transport profile is also relevant. The operator advises that approximately 75% of guests use local transport, while
approximately 25% have cars. Guests also use e-bikes and active transport. This supports the conclusion that the
proposed hostel intensity is not equivalent to conventional residential or apartment-style car ownership and traffic
generation.
The operator’s management model is a further important consideration. The operator advises that it has strict
management controls, guest identification and passport verification procedures for international travellers, a
management plan, and a clear low-impact market position focused on beach, nature, yoga and surfing. The operator
also advises that the business has operated for approximately 25 to 30 years with no complaint history.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 10
10
Evidence point Operator evidence Relevance to overriding need
Seasonal occupancy Operator data indicates Demonstrates functional capacity
approximately 97% to 100% during the primary visitor season
occupancy between October and and supports conservative annual
March, approximately 65% between modelling using the full seasonal
April and July, and approximately profile.
75% across August and September.
Peak waitlists Waiting lists of up to approximately Demonstrates real unmet demand
60 persons during peak periods. at Dolphin Beach House. The
proposed 42 beds would not fully
absorb this operator-specific peak
waitlist.
Guest origin Approximately 85% international Confirms a specialist international
guests; domestic guests independent-traveller market rather
approximately 10%. than a conventional domestic
holiday-house or apartment market.
Identification process International travellers check in with Supports guest verification,
international passports. management control and
accountability.
Age profile Main age group approximately 24 to Consistent with youth, independent-
32 years. traveller and working-holiday travel
segments.
Working holiday profile Approximately 65% of guests are on Supports the workforce nexus for
the working holiday pathway, hospitality, building, landscaping,
subject to individual visa conditions. horticulture, nurseries, farms and
other local service sectors.
Local work connection Guests seek or undertake work Demonstrates that the hostel
around Noosa and surrounding supports the broader workforce
areas, including hospitality, ecosystem, not merely visitor
building, nurseries, landscaping, accommodation demand.
ginger farms and other sectors.
Short-term traveller component Approximately 20% of guests are Shows the hostel serves both
short-term travellers; short-term independent travellers and shorter
visa guests commonly stay regional touring demand.
approximately 4 to 14 days.
Average stay Earlier operator evidence indicated Indicates a longer-stay, managed
an average stay of approximately 13 accommodation profile compared
days. with high-churn weekend short-stay
accommodation.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 11
11
Regional tourism base A large proportion of guests base Shows the hostel supports regional
themselves in Noosa for K’gari / nature-based tourism and visitor
Fraser Island tours rather than dispersal beyond Noosa.
staying in Hervey Bay, including
tours/operators such as Drop Bear,
Discovery and Nomads.
Transport mode Approximately 75% use local Supports a low-car, public/active-
transport; approximately 25% have transport accommodation model.
cars; e-bikes and active transport
are also used.
Affordability Rates from approximately $45 Confirms a genuinely affordable
shared dorm, $125 double room and accommodation product in a high-
$145 double room with ensuite. cost destination.
Management controls Strict management controls, guest Distinguishes the use from
identification, management plan, unmanaged short-stay letting, party-
and low-impact house accommodation and
beach/nature/yoga/surfing market conventional holiday houses.
position.
Operational history Proven 25 to 30 year business Supports the conclusion that the
history with no complaint history. use is established, managed and
capable of operating compatibly
with its setting.
Source: Existing Noosa hostel-supply estimate and Dolphin Beach House operating data are based on
applicant/operator information. Noosa visitor economy figures are sourced from Tourism Noosa.[3] Calculations are
prepared from those figures.
On this basis, the proposed additional 42 beds should not be characterised as overdevelopment by reference to
numbers alone. The increase is modest in the context of total Noosa hostel supply, and the Dolphin-specific evidence
demonstrates that the operation reaches functional capacity during the primary visitor season. The peak-period waitlist
evidence is particularly important because it shows that the proposed additional 42 beds would not fully meet the
unmet demand already recorded by Dolphin Beach House itself.
For that reason, the need case does not depend on unsupported assumptions about the other four hostel premises. It is
sufficient that Dolphin Beach House’s own operating data demonstrates peak functional capacity, seasonal resilience,
and unmet peak-period demand exceeding the additional bed capacity now proposed.
6. Affordable hostel accommodation as a distinct land-use and economic product
The proposed accommodation should not be assessed as though it were equivalent to additional self-contained short-
term accommodation apartments, holiday houses, hotel rooms or permanent dwellings. A visitor hostel is a distinct
land-use and economic product.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 12
12
This distinction is important to Council’s overriding need question. The applicant does not contend that all visitor
accommodation should be preferred over permanent housing. Rather, the applicant submits that this specific form of
visitor accommodation performs a function that is not met by permanent dwellings, high-cost hotels, serviced
apartments or whole-dwelling short-term accommodation.
Hostel accommodation typically provides shared rooms, shared facilities, communal spaces, booking controls, guest
rules and operational supervision. It does not provide the same residential amenity, privacy, self-containment or
household function as a permanent dwelling, key worker unit or conventional apartment. It is therefore not a simple
substitute for permanent housing.
The rate structure confirms the distinct accommodation product. The operator advises that rates commence from
approximately $45 for a shared dormitory bed, with double rooms from approximately $125 and double rooms with
ensuite from approximately $145. In the Noosa context, that rate structure provides one of the few genuinely low-cost
managed visitor accommodation options available to independent travellers, working holiday makers and longer-stay
youth travellers.
That affordability is central to the need case. Noosa’s visitor economy cannot be served only by high-value hotels,
holiday houses, serviced apartments and premium short-stay accommodation. A mature destination economy requires
accommodation diversity. That includes low-cost managed accommodation for independent travellers, youth travellers,
working holiday makers, seasonal workers in transition and nature-based visitors who engage with local businesses,
local transport, surf, coastal recreation and regional tours.
The proposal also differs materially from the form of short-term accommodation that has generated broader community
and planning concern in Noosa. It is not an unmanaged whole-dwelling short-stay house. It is not a party-house model.
It is not a conversion of existing permanent rental stock. It is an existing lawful hostel operation with management
controls, guest verification, house rules, a management plan and a long complaint-free operating history.
This matters because Council’s housing concern should be directed to actual housing displacement. The proposal does
not remove permanent residential dwellings. It does not convert long-term rental accommodation into short-term
letting. It does not prevent an approved affordable housing or key worker housing project from proceeding. It provides
additional capacity within a distinct and already established hostel accommodation model.
Accommodation type Typical function Relevance to this proposal
Permanent dwelling / apartment Self-contained residential The proposed hostel rooms are not
accommodation for households. configured or operated as
independent dwellings and do not
perform the same household
function.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 13
13
Key worker housing Longer-term accommodation for The hostel is not a substitute for
workers, usually self-contained or permanent key worker housing, but
semi-self-contained. it does accommodate working
holiday makers and independent
travelers who contribute to the local
workforce ecosystem.
Hotel / serviced apartment Generally higher-cost visitor The proposed hostel provides a
accommodation with private rooms lower-cost and more communal
and guest services. accommodation product for a
different traveler cohort.
Whole-dwelling short-stay Visitor use of dwellings that may The proposal is materially different
accommodation otherwise form part of the because it does not convert a
permanent housing stock. permanent dwelling or remove
existing rental housing.
Visitor hostel Managed low-cost shared or private- This is the relevant product. It
room accommodation with provides affordable managed
communal facilities and operational accommodation for international
controls. independent travelers, youth
travelers, working holiday makers
and nature-based visitors.
Source: Accommodation-type descriptions are based on the applicant’s planning characterisation of the proposal and
the operational characteristics of the existing Visitor Accommodation Type 4 – Visitor Hostel use. Rate information is
based on operator evidence. Housing-context reference is drawn from Noosa Shire Council’s Noosa Housing Strategy
2022.[8]
The Noosa Housing Strategy 2022 acknowledges the importance of housing supply and affordability, including the
challenge created where lower-paid retail, hospitality and tourism workers are exposed to high housing costs.[8] That
context is accepted. However, it does not follow that refusing additional hostel beds would deliver permanent or
affordable housing. The subject accommodation is not permanent housing stock, and the existing hostel use would
remain even if the proposed change were refused.
Accordingly, the overriding need is supported by the distinct function of the accommodation product. The proposed
additional beds respond to a scarce low-cost accommodation segment, support a specific international and working-
holiday traveller cohort, and do so without removing existing permanent housing stock or displacing an actual key
worker housing outcome.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 14
14
7. Tourism economy evidence: Noosa, Sunshine Coast and Queensland context
The overriding need for the proposed additional hostel accommodation is also supported by the scale and structure of
Noosa’s visitor economy. The proposal should not be assessed as if visitor accommodation is an incidental or
discretionary activity in Noosa. Tourism is a core part of Noosa’s local economy, employment base and business
ecosystem.
Tourism Noosa reports that, in 2024, Noosa received approximately 2 million visitors, generated more than $1.4 billion
in visitor spend and recorded approximately 4.7 million visitor nights.[3] Tourism Noosa also identifies tourism as
Noosa’s number one industry by value-add to Gross Regional Product, with approximately $346 million in value-add,
and states that one in seven Noosa jobs is in tourism.[3]
Those figures are significant for the overriding need test. They demonstrate that overnight visitor accommodation is not
a peripheral land-use issue in Noosa. It is accommodation infrastructure that supports local businesses, local
employment, visitor expenditure and destination function.
Tourism Noosa’s material also states that approximately 75% of Noosa businesses rely on the visitor economy and that
more than 30% would fold if not for tourism.[3] That evidence is relevant because hostel guests do not only generate
revenue for the accommodation operator. They contribute to expenditure across the local economy, including cafes,
restaurants, supermarkets, bars, surf schools, tours, transport, laundry, retail, events and personal services.
The economic importance of overnight visitors is particularly relevant. Tourism Noosa’s marketing strategy is directed to
domestic, interstate and international overnight travellers because overnight visitors spend more in local businesses
than day-trippers and disperse value across the region and across business sectors.[3] Tourism Noosa identifies
average daily domestic overnight visitor spend of approximately $321, with interstate visitors at approximately $354 and
intrastate visitors at approximately $290.[3]
This supports the need for a diversity of overnight accommodation options. Noosa’s overnight visitor economy cannot
be supported only by premium accommodation, holiday houses, serviced apartments and higher-cost hotel products. A
mature destination economy also requires affordable, managed accommodation for independent travellers, youth
travellers, working holiday makers and nature-based visitors. Hostel accommodation performs that specific role.
The broader Queensland and Sunshine Coast context also supports the need case. Tourism and Events Queensland’s
International Tourism Snapshot for the year ending June 2025 records international expenditure in Queensland of
approximately $6.9 billion, international visitation of approximately 2.183 million, and average international visitor
spend per night of approximately $133.[4] For the Sunshine Coast, TEQ records international visitor expenditure of
approximately $413.4 million, approximately 325,000 international visitors and average international visitor spend per
night of approximately $116.[4]
This regional data is relevant because the operator advises that Dolphin Beach House’s market is predominantly
international, with approximately 85% of guests being international travellers. The proposal therefore responds to a real
accommodation need within the same international and independent-traveller market that contributes to Queensland,
Sunshine Coast and Noosa visitor expenditure.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 15
15
Tourism evidence Reported figure Planning/economic relevance
Tourism evidence Reported figure Planning / economic relevance
Noosa total visitation Approx. 2 million visitors in 2024.[3] Shows Noosa is a mature
destination economy requiring
managed accommodation
infrastructure.
Noosa visitor spend More than $1.4 billion in 2024.[3] Shows tourism is a major economic
driver and supports the need for
diverse visitor accommodation.
Noosa visitor nights Approx. 4.7 million visitor nights in Demonstrates the importance of
2024.[3] overnight accommodation capacity
to Noosa’s economy.
Tourism value-add Approx. $346 million value-add to Supports the economic significance
Gross Regional Product; tourism of visitor accommodation as local
identified as Noosa’s number one economic infrastructure.
industry by value-add.[3]
Tourism employment One in seven Noosa jobs is in Links accommodation supply with
tourism.[3] employment and workforce need.
Business reliance Approx. 75% of Noosa businesses Demonstrates that visitor
rely on the visitor economy; more accommodation supports a broad
than 30% would fold if not for local business ecosystem.
tourism.[3]
Domestic overnight visitor spend Approx. $321 average daily spend; Supports the economic value of
interstate approx. $354; intrastate overnight visitors compared with
approx. $290.[3] day-trip visitation.
Queensland international Approx. $6.9 billion, year ending Demonstrates strong international
expenditure June 2025.[4] visitor expenditure at the State level.
Queensland international visitors Approx. 2.183 million, year ending Supports the recovery and ongoing
June 2025.[4] importance of international visitor
markets.
Queensland international spend per Approx. $133 per night.[4] Provides a conservative benchmark
night for economic modelling of hostel
visitor expenditure.
Sunshine Coast international Approx. $413.4 million, year ending Demonstrates the regional
expenditure June 2025.[4] importance of international visitor
expenditure.
Sunshine Coast international Approx. 325,000, year ending June Supports the relevance of
visitors 2025.[4] international visitor accommodation
in the Sunshine Coast / Noosa
context.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 16
16
Source: Tourism Noosa, Membership Prospectus 2025–26 for Noosa visitor numbers, visitor spend, visitor nights,
tourism value-add, employment, business reliance and domestic overnight visitor spend.[3] Tourism and Events
Queensland, International Tourism Snapshot – Year Ending June 2025 for Queensland and Sunshine Coast international
visitor expenditure, visitor numbers and spend-per-night benchmarks.
The above evidence does not suggest that all tourism growth should be accepted regardless of planning impacts.
Rather, it supports a more nuanced planning conclusion: Noosa requires managed, diverse and values-aligned visitor
accommodation that supports the overnight visitor economy while minimising adverse impacts on housing, traffic,
amenity and community values.
The subject proposal satisfies that description. It is not unmanaged short-stay letting. It is not a party-house model. It is
not the conversion of existing permanent housing. It is additional capacity within an existing lawful and managed hostel
operation, serving a predominantly international, independent-traveller and working-holiday market.
The economic need is therefore not confined to the private interest of the operator. The proposal supports a form of
accommodation that contributes to Noosa’s visitor expenditure, local employment base, small business ecosystem
and regional tourism function. That broader economic context is relevant to Council’s request to demonstrate overriding
need.
8. Independent traveller, working holiday maker and workforce nexus
The operator’s guest profile demonstrates
that Dolphin Beach House serves a market
strongly aligned with international youth,
independent traveller and working holiday
segments. This is directly relevant to
Council’s request to demonstrate
overriding need because the proposal is
not simply additional visitor
accommodation. It provides affordable,
managed accommodation for a cohort that
contributes to both the visitor economy
and the local workforce ecosystem.
Tourism Australia identifies the youth
sector as a vital part of Australian tourism
and states that working holiday makers
tend to stay longer, spend more and
disperse more widely than most other
target segments.
Figure 3: Dolphin Beach House guest profile demonstrating the strong nexus between international independent
travellers and working holiday makers.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 17
17
Tourism Australia also identifies that working holiday makers have a higher than average propensity to combine work,
visiting friends and relatives, and holiday/leisure experiences.[5]
That profile aligns with the operator’s evidence. Dolphin Beach House advises that approximately 85% of guests are
international travellers, the main guest age group is approximately 24 to 32 years, and approximately 65% of guests are
on the working holiday pathway, subject to individual visa conditions. The operator also advises that many guests seek
or undertake work in Noosa and surrounding areas, including hospitality, building, landscaping, horticulture, nurseries,
farms and other service sectors.
The Department of Home Affairs’ Working Holiday Maker Visa Programme Report records that, as at 30 June 2024, there
were 170,437 Working Holiday Maker visa holders in Australia, up from 137,391 at 30 June 2023, and that 234,556
Working Holiday Maker visas were granted in 2023–24.[6] The same report records specified-work participation across
sectors including agriculture, forestry and fishing, accommodation and food services, and construction.[6]
The relevance of this evidence is not that hostel accommodation is a substitute for permanent key worker housing. It is
not. The relevance is that hostel accommodation provides temporary, affordable and managed accommodation for a
cohort that commonly participates in the casual, seasonal and service-sector labour market. In a destination economy
such as Noosa, that labour-market pathway is part of the broader workforce ecosystem.
Jobs and Skills Australia records Accommodation and Food Services as a substantial employing industry, with
approximately 967,200 workers, a 61% part-time share and a median worker age of 26.[7] That industry profile is
consistent with the age, mobility and work patterns of many working holiday makers and independent travellers. It also
aligns with the operator’s evidence that guests seek or undertake work in hospitality and other local sectors.
Tourism Research Australia has also identified post-COVID workforce shortages as a challenge for the visitor economy,
including the role played by the absence of permanent and temporary migrant workers during the pandemic period.[9]
This is relevant because Noosa’s visitor economy depends on the availability of workers across hospitality,
accommodation, food services, cleaning, retail, construction, landscaping, horticulture, tourism activities and related
service sectors.
Council’s own Housing Strategy recognises the interaction between Noosa’s housing challenge and its employment
structure. The Housing Strategy identifies the imbalance between lower-paying retail and hospitality sectors and high
local housing costs, and recognises that employers can face difficulty attracting and retaining staff.[8]
That context is important. The applicant accepts that permanent key worker accommodation is a significant planning
issue. However, refusing additional hostel beds would not create permanent key worker accommodation. It would
instead reduce the ability of an existing managed hostel to accommodate the international independent travellers and
working holiday makers who contribute to Noosa’s visitor economy and, in many cases, to its casual, seasonal and
service-sector workforce.
The proposal therefore has a complementary workforce-support function. It does not solve Noosa’s permanent housing
challenge, and it should not be presented as doing so. However, it does assist a particular part of the workforce
Prepared for Council information response
Page 18
18
ecosystem by providing affordable temporary accommodation for mobile workers and work-seeking travellers who
support sectors that are central to Noosa’s local economy.
Workforce evidence External/source evidence Relevance to the proposal
Youth and working-holiday traveller Tourism Australia identifies the Supports the relevance of hostel
profile youth sector as vital to Australian accommodation to a recognised
tourism and states that working national visitor segment with longer
holiday makers tend to stay longer, stays, local expenditure and
spend more and disperse more workforce participation.
widely than most other target
segments.[5]
Working Holiday Maker visa Home Affairs records 170,437 Demonstrates the scale and
numbers Working Holiday Maker visa holders recovery of the working-holiday
in Australia as at 30 June 2024 and market after the pandemic.
234,556 WHM visa grants in 2023–
24.[6]
Specified-work sectors Home Affairs records specified-work Aligns with operator evidence that
participation across sectors guests work or seek work in
including hospitality, building, horticulture,
agriculture/forestry/fishing, nurseries, landscaping and related
accommodation and food services, sectors, subject to visa rules.
and construction.[6]
Dolphin guest origin Operator evidence indicates Shows Dolphin Beach House serves
approximately 85% international a specialised international traveller
guests. cohort.
Dolphin guest age profile Operator evidence indicates the Aligns with youth, independent-
main age group is approximately 24 traveller and working-holiday
to 32 years. segments.
Dolphin working-holiday profile Operator evidence indicates Supports the labour-market
approximately 65% of guests are on connection between hostel
the working holiday pathway, accommodation and local
subject to individual visa conditions. workforce participation.
Local work connection Operator evidence indicates guests Demonstrates that the hostel
seek or undertake work in supports the broader workforce
hospitality, building, landscaping, ecosystem, not merely short-term
horticulture, nurseries, farms and visitor demand.
other sectors.
Accommodation and Food Services Jobs and Skills Australia records Supports the relevance of younger,
industry approximately 967,200 workers, flexible and mobile workers to
61% part-time employment and a hospitality and food service sectors.
median worker age of 26 in
Prepared for Council information response
Page 19
19
Accommodation and Food
Services.[7]
Tourism workforce shortages Tourism Research Australia Supports the need for
identifies post-COVID workforce accommodation that assists access
shortages and the absence of to mobile and temporary workers.
permanent and temporary migrant
workers as relevant to visitor-
economy workforce deficiencies.[9]
Source: Tourism Australia youth and working-holiday market material.[5] Department of Home Affairs Working Holiday
Maker Visa Program Report.[6] Jobs and Skills Australia Accommodation and Food Services industry profile.[7] Noosa
Shire Council, Noosa Housing Strategy 2022.[8] Tourism Research Australia tourism workforce material.[9] Dolphin-
specific guest profile, work-seeking and sector information is operator evidence.
The overriding need is therefore supported by the proposal’s role in accommodating a recognised and economically
important traveller-worker cohort. The proposal provides affordable, managed accommodation for international
independent travellers and working holiday makers who stay in Noosa, spend locally, use local transport, and may
participate in the local labour market. That is a materially different planning function from unmanaged short-term letting
or high-cost visitor accommodation.
For these reasons, the proposal should be understood as supporting both Noosa’s visitor economy and its workforce
ecosystem, without removing permanent housing stock or displacing an actual key worker housing outcome.
9. Indicative economic contribution of the proposal
The following modelling is indicative and conservative. It is intended to demonstrate the order of magnitude of the
economic contribution associated with the proposed additional 42 hostel beds. It is not presented as a formal
economic impact assessment and should be read subject to the operator evidence and assumptions identified below.
The modelling deliberately adopts a conservative weighted seasonal occupancy estimate rather than a flat peak-season
occupancy figure. This reflects the operator’s data, which indicates that Dolphin Beach House operates at
approximately 97% to 100% occupancy between October and March, approximately 65% occupancy between April and
July, and approximately 75% occupancy across August and September.
Using the midpoint of the peak-season occupancy range, being 98.5% for October to March, together with 65% for April
to July and 75% for August to September, produces an indicative weighted annual occupancy of approximately 83.4%.
The range is approximately 82.6% to 84.1%, depending on whether the lower or upper end of the October to March peak-
season occupancy range is applied.
This approach is intentionally conservative. It avoids overstating annual economic yield while still recognising that the
operation reaches functional capacity during the primary visitor season.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 20
20
Model item Calculation Indicative result
Additional annual bed capacity 42 beds x 365 nights 15,330 available bed nights
Peak-season occupancy October to March, midpoint 98.5% Reflects operator data showing 97%
assumption to 100% occupancy
Shoulder/off-season occupancy April to July at 65%; August to Reflects operator seasonal data
assumption September at 75%
Weighted annual occupancy 182 days at 98.5%; 122 days at 65%; Approx. 83.4% annualised
61 days at 75% occupancy
Weighted annual occupancy range Using 97% to 100% for October to Approx. 82.6% to 84.1%
March
Occupied additional bed nights 15,330 x 83.4% Approx. 12,781 occupied bed nights
per annum
Occupied additional bed-night Applying annual occupancy range of Approx. 12,667 to 12,896 occupied
range approx. 82.6% to 84.1% bed nights per annum
Indicative guest stays 12,781 occupied bed nights ÷ 13- Approx. 983 guest stays per annum
night average stay
Indicative international guest stays 85% of guest stays Approx. 836 international guest
stays per annum
Indicative working-holiday related Conservatively applying 65% to Approx. 543 working-holiday related
stays international guest stays only guest stays per annum
Indicative work-seeking guest stays Conservatively applying 40% to Approx. 334 international guest
international guest stays stays involving guests looking for
work
Conservative direct visitor 12,781 occupied bed nights x $133 Approx. $1.70 million per annum
expenditure — Queensland per night
benchmark
Conservative direct visitor 12,781 occupied bed nights x $116 Approx. $1.48 million per annum
expenditure — Sunshine Coast per night
benchmark
Accommodation revenue floor only 12,781 occupied bed nights x $45 Approx. $575,000 per annum, noting
dorm rate this excludes higher room rates and
all off-site spend
Source: Occupancy, guest profile, average-stay and rate assumptions are based on applicant/operator evidence.
International visitor spend-per-night benchmarks are drawn from Tourism and Events Queensland’s International
Tourism Snapshot – Year Ending June 2025, which records average international visitor spend per night of approximately
$133 for Queensland and approximately $116 for the Sunshine Coast.[4]
On this conservative basis, the proposed additional 42 beds could support approximately 12,781 occupied bed nights
per annum and approximately 983 guest stays per annum. Applying TEQ’s conservative international visitor spend-per-
Prepared for Council information response
Page 21
21
night benchmarks, this equates to indicative direct visitor expenditure in the order of approximately $1.48 million to
$1.70 million per annum.[4]
That expenditure should not be understood as revenue to the hostel operator alone. Hostel guests spend locally across
cafes, restaurants, supermarkets, bars, surf schools, tours, public and private transport, laundry, retail, events and
personal services. The accommodation therefore supports local economic activity beyond the subject premises.
The modelling also indicates the potential workforce relevance of the proposal. On a conservative basis, the proposed
additional beds could accommodate approximately 836 international guest stays per annum. If 65% of those
international guests are on the working holiday pathway, this equates to approximately 543 working-holiday related
guest stays per annum. If 40% of international guests are looking for work, this equates to approximately 334 work-
seeking international guest stays per annum.
Those figures should not be read as a guarantee of employment outcomes. Rather, they demonstrate the scale of the
traveller-worker cohort that the proposed additional beds could accommodate. That is relevant to the overriding need
test because the proposal supports a form of accommodation used by international independent travellers and working
holiday makers who contribute to the local visitor economy and, in many cases, the local labour-force ecosystem.
For completeness, if the same conservative seasonal occupancy model is applied to the full 102-bed hostel operation,
it would produce approximately 31,041 occupied bed nights per annum. Applying the TEQ Queensland benchmark of
$133 per night would indicate approximately $4.13 million per annum in direct visitor expenditure, before considering
any multiplier, supplier, employment or induced effects.[4]
The applicant does not rely on multiplier effects for the purpose of demonstrating need. The above figures are sufficient
to demonstrate that the proposed additional 42 beds would make a material contribution to local visitor expenditure,
while remaining modest in supply terms and responding to a demonstrated accommodation need.
10. Alignment with Noosa's Destination Management Plan
Noosa Council’s Destination Management Plan is highly relevant to Council’s information request. The DMP does not
position tourism as something to be eliminated from Noosa. Rather, it recognises that tourism must be consciously
managed so that it remains aligned with community values, environmental care, local economic benefit, responsible
visitor behaviour, transport management and the character of Noosa.[1][2]
This distinction is important. Council’s concern in this information request is directed to the intensity of visitor
accommodation in a residential zone and the need for that accommodation having regard to permanent housing and
key worker accommodation. The DMP assists that assessment because it provides Council’s own policy distinction
between unmanaged visitor pressure and managed, values-aligned tourism.
The applicant accepts the DMP’s premise that Noosa experiences pressure from visitation, population growth, traffic,
housing affordability and changing travel behaviours. However, the DMP response to those pressures is not to suppress
all visitor accommodation or treat all visitor demand as undesirable. The DMP seeks to manage the visitor economy so
Prepared for Council information response
Page 22
22
that tourism delivers local benefit, respects community values, supports environmental protection, encourages
responsible behaviour and reduces adverse impacts.
The proposal aligns with that policy direction. It does not introduce unmanaged visitor accommodation into residential
housing stock. It does not convert permanent dwellings into short-stay letting. It does not create a dispersed party-
house or whole-dwelling short-stay accommodation model. It provides additional capacity within an existing lawful
hostel operation that is managed, supervised, low-car, evidence-based and capable of being conditioned.
The DMP’s relevance is therefore not limited to general tourism policy. It supports the planning frame advanced in this
response: the issue is not whether Noosa should accommodate visitors, but whether visitor accommodation is
managed in a way that protects community values, supports local benefit, minimises adverse impacts and avoids
further loss of permanent housing stock.
The proposed intensification satisfies that frame.
DMP theme / policy direction DMP relevance How the proposal responds
Managed tourism rather than The DMP seeks to manage tourism The proposal concentrates
unmanaged tourism pressure in balance with community, additional demand within an
environment, economy and visitor existing managed hostel operation
experience.[1][2] rather than dispersing visitor
demand into unmanaged dwellings
or informal accommodation.
Tourism that benefits locals The DMP recognises that tourism Hostel guests spend locally in cafes,
should support local prosperity, restaurants, supermarkets, bars,
local businesses and community surf schools, tours, transport,
benefit.[1][2] laundry, retail and services. The
hostel also supports a working-
holiday labour pathway for local
service sectors.
Protection of Noosa’s character and The DMP seeks to protect the The operator’s market position is
lifestyle character, lifestyle and values that low-impact beach, nature, yoga and
make Noosa distinctive.[1][2] surfing travel. This is more aligned
with Noosa’s character than
unmanaged party-house or high-
impact short-stay accommodation.
Responsible visitor behaviour The DMP promotes responsible The applicant can incorporate DMP-
visitor behaviour, shared aligned guest induction, house
stewardship and visitor education, rules, quiet hours, behaviour
including the Noosa Promise.[1][2] expectations, environmental
messaging and Noosa Promise
material into the Hostel
Management Plan.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 23
23
Short-stay accommodation impacts The DMP and related Council policy The proposal is not unmanaged
and neighbourhood amenity material recognise the need to whole-dwelling short-stay letting. It
manage visitor accommodation is a supervised hostel with guest
impacts on residential verification, management controls,
amenity.[1][2] a management plan and no
complaint history over a long
operating period.
Sustainable transport and The DMP identifies transport, Operator evidence indicates
congestion management congestion and movement approximately 75% of guests use
management as important local transport, with approximately
destination-management 25% having cars. Guests also use e-
issues.[1][2] bikes and active transport.
Values over volume The DMP’s destination-management The proposal serves a specific
approach is directed to the quality, traveller cohort: international
behaviour and management of independent travellers, working
visitation, rather than simply holiday makers and nature/coastal
increasing visitor numbers.[1][2] visitors. It is not a generalised high-
volume party tourism model.
Affordable and diverse visitor A managed destination economy The hostel provides low-cost
accommodation requires a range of accommodation accommodation from
types to support different visitor approximately $45 for a shared
cohorts and local economic dorm bed, which is materially
functions.[1][2] different from high-cost hotels,
serviced apartments and holiday
houses.
Local workforce ecosystem The DMP and broader Council policy The hostel accommodates working
context recognise the relationship holiday makers and independent
between tourism, workforce and travellers who may seek or
local prosperity.[1][2] undertake work in hospitality,
building, landscaping, horticulture,
nurseries, farms and other service
sectors.
Data-led destination management The DMP supports informed The applicant relies on existing
management of tourism impacts booking and operator evidence, and
and decision-making.[1][2] can support conditions requiring
ongoing record keeping for
occupancy, transport behaviour,
complaints and management
response if reasonably required.
Source: Noosa Council Destination Management Plan webpage and associated DMP material.[1] Noosa Council,
Noosa’s Destination Management Plan 2026 PDF and related DMP implementation resources.[2] Dolphin-specific guest
profile, management, transport and operational evidence is applicant/operator evidence.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 24
24
The DMP is particularly useful in distinguishing this proposal from the form of visitor accommodation that most directly
contributes to housing and neighbourhood amenity concerns. The proposal is not the conversion of a permanent
dwelling to short-term letting. It is not an unmanaged holiday house. It is not a dispersed visitor accommodation model
relying on residential housing stock. It is additional capacity within an existing lawful, managed and supervised hostel.
That distinction is central to the overriding need case. If visitor demand exists, and the evidence demonstrates that it
does, the DMP supports managing that demand in forms that are accountable, supervised, lower-car and aligned with
Noosa’s values. A managed hostel is capable of doing that in a way that unmanaged short-stay dwellings cannot.
The proposal also aligns with the DMP’s emphasis on responsible visitor behaviour. The operator’s low-impact beach,
nature, yoga and surfing market position is compatible with Noosa’s destination identity. The applicant can further
reinforce this alignment through conditions requiring ongoing implementation of a Hostel Management Plan, guest
induction material, quiet-hours requirements, complaint-response procedures, transport information and Noosa
Promise / responsible visitor messaging.
The DMP also supports the proposal’s
transport argument. A key destination-
management issue is the pressure created by
traffic, parking and congestion. The operator
evidence indicates that approximately 75% of
guests use local transport, with only
approximately 25% having cars. That profile is
materially different from conventional
apartment or whole-dwelling short-stay
accommodation, where car ownership and
parking demand may be materially higher.
The DMP further supports the economic and
workforce aspects of the proposal. Noosa’s
destination economy depends on local
businesses, service workers and visitor
expenditure. The hostel accommodates a
predominantly international independent-
Figure 4: Dolphin Beach House guest transport profile demonstrating low private car reliance and strong alignment with
sustainable destination management.
traveller cohort, including working holiday makers, who spend locally and may participate in the casual, seasonal and
service-sector workforce. This supports the broader destination economy without removing permanent housing stock.
The applicant therefore submits that the DMP reinforces, rather than undermines, the need case. Council’s own
destination-management framework recognises that tourism must be managed in balance with community,
environment and economy. The proposed additional hostel beds are consistent with that approach because they
Prepared for Council information response
Page 25
25
provide managed, supervised, affordable and low-car accommodation within an existing lawful hostel operation,
supported by operational evidence and capable of being regulated by conditions.
For those reasons, the proposal is properly characterised as DMP-aligned managed tourism infrastructure, not
unmanaged tourism intensification or housing displacement.
DMP resources also identify case studies including Banff Lead Tourism for Good, Oahu Destination Management,
Wonderful Copenhagen, Bay of Plenty, CopenPay, and the Great Ocean Road Visitor Economy Master Plan.[1] The
common direction of those examples is not to suppress all visitor activity. It is to steward tourism so that it generates
local value, changes visitor behaviour, protects places under pressure and aligns the visitor economy with community
values.
The subject proposal fits that destination-management approach. A managed hostel with public/active transport use,
strict house rules, guest identification, no complaint history and a nature/coastal/yoga/surfing market is more
consistent with destination stewardship than pushing demand into informal, unregulated or unmanaged
accommodation alternatives.
11. Housing and key worker accommodation response
The applicant acknowledges that permanent residential housing and key worker accommodation are significant
planning issues in Noosa. The applicant does not seek to minimise those issues. The applicant also accepts that
Council is entitled to consider whether visitor accommodation in a residential zone may affect housing outcomes.
However, the applicant submits that the housing issue must be assessed by reference to the actual proposal before
Council, the existing lawful use of the land, and the realistic planning consequences of approval or refusal.
This proposal does not remove existing permanent housing stock. It does not convert existing permanent rental
dwellings to short-term accommodation. It does not displace an approved affordable housing or key worker housing
project. It does not involve unmanaged whole-dwelling short-stay letting. It is a proposed intensification of an existing
lawful Visitor Accommodation Type 4 – Visitor Hostel use.
That distinction is central to the information request response.
Council’s request asks the applicant to demonstrate overriding need for visitor hostel accommodation “over” the need
for permanent residential housing and key worker accommodation. With respect, that should not be treated as a simple
binary contest between tourism and housing. The proposal is not a choice between 42 hostel beds and 42 permanent
residents. Nor is it a choice between the proposal and an approved key worker housing development. There is no such
residential or key worker housing proposal before Council.
The existing hostel approval would remain even if the proposed change were refused. Refusal would therefore not
deliver new permanent housing, affordable housing or key worker accommodation. It would simply prevent a modest
increase to an existing hostel operation that has demonstrated need, affordability, low car dependency, workforce
relevance and a long complaint-free operating history.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 26
26
The Noosa Housing Strategy 2022 is relevant to this issue. The Strategy acknowledges the housing crisis, housing
affordability pressures and the difficulty experienced by employers in attracting and retaining staff in a local economy
with significant tourism, retail and hospitality employment.[8] The applicant accepts that context.
However, the Housing Strategy also recognises that many existing developments in Medium and High Density
Residential zones were historically approved for visitor accommodation or for occupation in a way that allows visitor
use, and that those approvals cannot simply be removed. The Strategy’s concern about further short-term
accommodation in Medium and High Density Residential zones is properly understood as being directed to new
development or sites that do not already have approval for the use.[8]
This application falls on the established-use side of that distinction. The land already benefits from an existing lawful
visitor hostel approval. The proposal is therefore materially different from a new application to convert permanent
housing stock to visitor accommodation.
Realistic residential redevelopment would not equate to affordable or key worker housing
The applicant also notes that the theoretical residential redevelopment potential of the land should not be equated with
the delivery of affordable housing or key worker accommodation.
The land is included in the Medium Density Residential Zone and it is acknowledged that, in a theoretical redevelopment
scenario, the site may have capacity to accommodate a small multiple dwelling development. However, that theoretical
capacity does not mean that refusal of the proposed hostel intensification would deliver affordable housing, key worker
housing or any immediate permanent residential accommodation outcome.
Having regard to the site’s coastal location, underlying land value, construction cost, development risk and likely market
positioning, any future multiple dwelling redevelopment would likely produce a limited number of high-value dwellings
rather than affordable or key worker housing. By way of indicative feasibility context, a development outcome
comprising approximately three 2-bedroom dwellings may require end sale values in the order of approximately $3.5
million to $3.8 million per dwelling, or rental levels potentially in the order of approximately $1,500 per week, to be
commercially realistic.
Such an outcome may add to permanent residential dwelling supply in a numerical sense, but it would not materially
address the affordable housing or key worker accommodation need identified by Council. It would also require a
separate landowner decision, design process, feasibility assessment and development approval pathway. There is no
residential redevelopment proposal before Council.
Accordingly, refusal of the proposed change should not be assumed to deliver affordable housing, key worker housing or
any meaningful housing-affordability outcome.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 27
27
Council Housing Issue Applicant response
The land is in the Medium Density Residential Zone. This is acknowledged. However, the land already
benefits from an existing lawful visitor hostel approval.
The proposal is an intensification of an established use,
not a new visitor use on an otherwise residential site.
Noosa has a high need for permanent housing. This is accepted. However, the proposal does not
remove existing permanent housing stock or convert
permanent rental dwellings to visitor accommodation.
Noosa has a high need for key worker accommodation. This is accepted. However, refusal would not deliver key
worker housing. The proposal may assist the broader
workforce ecosystem by accommodating working
holiday makers and independent travellers who seek or
undertake work locally.
The site may have theoretical residential redevelopment Theoretical capacity should not be equated with
potential. affordable or key worker housing delivery. Any likely
redevelopment outcome would be a small number of
high-value dwellings, not affordable or key worker
accommodation.
Visitor accommodation may compete with housing In this case, the existing lawful hostel use remains
outcomes. regardless of the outcome of the change application.
Refusal would not create housing; it would only prevent
the proposed additional managed hostel capacity.
Council is concerned about short-term accommodation This proposal is materially different from unmanaged
in residential zones. whole-dwelling short-stay letting. It is a managed hostel
with guest verification, house rules, a management plan
and no complaint history.
Source: Housing context and historical-approval discussion is drawn from Noosa Shire Council’s Noosa Housing
Strategy 2022.[8] The residential feasibility discussion is applicant planning/feasibility context.
The applicant therefore submits that the housing issue does not weigh against the proposal in the manner suggested by
the information request. The proposal does not cause actual housing displacement. It does not prevent an approved
housing outcome. It does not convert permanent rental stock. It does not undermine an existing key worker housing
project.
By contrast, the proposal provides additional capacity within an existing lawful hostel operation that delivers a scarce
affordable accommodation product and supports the visitor economy and workforce ecosystem. That outcome is
materially different from the unmanaged short-stay accommodation model that has contributed to broader housing and
amenity concerns.
The correct planning balance is therefore not “visitor beds versus affordable housing”. The correct balance is whether
an existing lawful hostel can be modestly and responsibly intensified to meet a demonstrated accommodation, tourism
and workforce need, while maintaining residential amenity and without removing permanent housing stock.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 28
28
The applicant submits that it can.
12. Response to the overdevelopment assertion
Council has stated that the combined accommodation of 102 persons across the existing development at 14 Duke
Street and Lot 3 on SP228958 is considered an overdevelopment.
The applicant respectfully submits that the proposal should not be characterised as overdevelopment by reference to
the total occupancy number alone. In a hostel context, intensity must be assessed having regard to the nature of the
approved use, the operational model, the existing lawful approval, the accommodation product, the management
controls, the transport profile, amenity performance, market need and whether the proposal results in actual housing
displacement.
The proposal is not equivalent to 102 persons in conventional apartments, unmanaged short-stay houses or permanent
dwellings. It is a managed visitor hostel operation with shared facilities, guest rules, check-in procedures, management
oversight, low private-car reliance and a long operational history.
The existing use is also already lawfully established. The application does not seek to introduce a new visitor
accommodation use into an otherwise residential site. It seeks approval for a modest intensification of an existing
Visitor Accommodation Type 4 – Visitor Hostel use.
The proposed additional 42 beds represent approximately 8.2% of the existing Noosa hostel bed supply of
approximately 510 beds. In market-supply terms, that is a modest increase. The operator’s Dolphin-specific evidence
also demonstrates that the business reaches functional capacity during the primary visitor season, with operator data
indicating approximately 97% to 100% occupancy between October and March. The operator also records peak-period
waiting lists of up to approximately 60 persons for Dolphin Beach House alone. The proposed additional 42 beds would
not fully absorb that Dolphin-specific peak-period unmet demand.
The intensity is also materially moderated by the operational and transport profile. The operator advises that
approximately 75% of guests use local transport and approximately 25% have cars, with e-bikes and active transport
also used. This means the proposed hostel intensity should not be assessed as though it generates the same car
ownership, parking demand or traffic profile as conventional dwellings or apartments.
The proposal is also supported by the operator’s management framework. The operator advises that it maintains strict
management controls, guest identification and passport verification procedures for international travellers, a
management plan, house rules, and a low-impact beach, nature, yoga and surfing market position. The operator also
advises that the business has operated for approximately 25 to 30 years with no complaint history.
These matters are directly relevant to the overdevelopment question. A proposal may involve a relatively high number of
persons but still be acceptable if the use is designed and operated in a way that manages amenity, transport, behaviour,
waste, noise and operational impacts. Conversely, a lower occupancy unmanaged short-stay use may create greater
residential amenity impacts if not properly managed. The assessment should therefore focus on actual impact and
management, not only the numerical occupancy figure.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 29
29
Council concern Applicant response
The total accommodation of 102 persons is considered The use is a managed hostel, not a conventional
high intensity. apartment scheme, unmanaged holiday house or
permanent residential development. Shared facilities,
guest rules, management oversight and operational
controls materially affect the intensity assessment.
The land is in the Medium Density Residential Zone. This is acknowledged. However, the existing hostel use
is already lawfully established. The issue is whether the
proposed intensification is justified and manageable,
not whether the use exists for the first time.
The proposal adds 42 persons. The proposed 42 beds represent approximately 8.2% of
Noosa’s estimated 510 hostel beds and are less than
Dolphin Beach House’s own peak-period waitlist of up
to approximately 60 persons.
The proposal may compete with housing need. The proposal does not remove existing permanent
housing stock, does not convert permanent rental
dwellings to short-term accommodation and does not
displace an approved key worker housing project.
Refusal would not create housing.
Additional visitor accommodation may create transport Operator evidence indicates approximately 75% of
or parking impacts. guests use local transport and approximately 25% have
cars, with e-bike and active transport use also
occurring.
Additional visitor accommodation may create amenity The operator has strict management controls, a
impacts. management plan, guest verification, house rules, a
low-impact market position and no complaint history
over an established 25 to 30 year operating period.
The proposal is in a residential context. A managed hostel can be conditioned to protect
amenity through occupancy limits, management plan
requirements, quiet hours, complaint-response
procedures, waste controls, transport information and
responsible visitor behaviour requirements.
Source: Existing hostel-supply, Dolphin Beach House occupancy, waitlist, transport, management and operational-
history information is applicant/operator evidence.
When assessed in context, the proposed additional 42 beds are a modest, evidence-based and manageable
intensification of an existing lawful hostel use. The proposal responds to demonstrated Dolphin-specific peak demand,
contributes to a limited hostel supply base, supports an affordable accommodation product, has low car dependency,
and can be regulated by appropriate conditions.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 30
30
The applicant therefore submits that the proposed combined accommodation should not be characterised as
overdevelopment. It is more accurately characterised as a managed and justified intensification of an established visitor
hostel use, supported by overriding need and capable of operating compatibly with its setting.
13. Management and conditioning commitments
The applicant acknowledges that any approval should be supported by appropriate operational controls to ensure that
the demonstrated need is delivered through a managed, low-impact and accountable hostel operation.
The applicant does not ask Council to accept the proposed additional beds on an unmanaged basis. The proposal is
advanced on the basis that the existing hostel operation is, and will continue to be, subject to active management, guest
controls, responsible visitor behaviour expectations, transport information, complaint-response procedures and
ongoing operational accountability.
This is important to Council’s intensity concern. The proposal is not unmanaged visitor accommodation. It is a
supervised hostel model with operational controls that can be reinforced by conditions of approval.
The operator’s existing management framework includes strict management controls, guest identification procedures,
passport verification for international travellers, house rules, a low-impact beach/nature/yoga/surfing market position,
and an established complaint-free operating history. The applicant accepts that those controls should be formalised
and strengthened through an updated Hostel Management Plan where appropriate.
The management framework should also align with Noosa Council’s Destination Management Plan direction, including
responsible visitor behaviour, local transport use, protection of residential amenity, community values and tourism that
benefits locals.[1][2]
The following condition themes are offered for Council’s consideration.
Management / condition theme Proposed approach Relevance to Councils concern
Maximum approved occupancy Condition the maximum number of Ensures the approved intensity is
guests and the manager unit clear, enforceable and not
parameters in accordance with the exceeded.
approved plans and approval
documents.
Hostel Management Plan Require an updated Hostel Provides an enforceable operational
Management Plan to be submitted, framework for guest behaviour,
approved and implemented on an management response and amenity
ongoing basis. protection.
On-site manager / responsible Require an on-site manager or Ensures accountability and
person nominated responsible person to be immediate management response.
available to respond to operational
issues and complaints.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 31
31
Guest check-in and identification Require guest registration and Supports accountability, guest
identification procedures, including screening and operational control.
passport verification for
international travellers where
applicable.
Guest code of conduct Require guests to be provided with Directly manages residential
house rules addressing quiet hours, amenity and guest behaviour.
noise, alcohol, visitors, waste,
respect for neighbours and
responsible behaviour.
Quiet hours Require specified quiet hours for Reduces potential noise and
outdoor/common areas and guest amenity impacts in the residential
movement in sensitive periods. context.
Prohibition on unmanaged Prohibit unmanaged parties, Distinguishes the operation from
parties/events amplified music events or external party-house or event-style visitor
functions unless separately accommodation.
approved.
Complaint-response procedure Require a complaints register and Provides transparency and
response procedure, including accountability if concerns arise.
recording date, time, issue,
response and resolution.
Waste management Require waste storage, collection Reduces amenity impacts from bins,
and bin presentation to be managed litter, odour and servicing.
in accordance with an approved
waste-management arrangement.
Transport information Require guests to be provided with Reinforces the low-car
information about local buses, accommodation model and DMP
walking routes, cycling, e-bikes and transport objectives.
other non-car transport options.
Parking management Require guest parking information Manages parking impacts
and controls to ensure car-owning associated with the approximately
guests use approved or lawful 25% of guests who may have cars.
parking arrangements.
E-bike / active transport Provide information and, where Supports sustainable transport and
management relevant, designated arrangements reduces private car reliance.
for e-bikes, bicycles and active
transport.
Noosa Promise / responsible visitor Include Noosa Promise or DMP- Aligns the hostel operation with
messaging aligned visitor behaviour messaging Council’s destination-management
in guest induction material. framework.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 32
32
Staff training Require management/staff to Ensures the management system is
understand the Hostel Management implemented in practice.
Plan, complaints procedure,
emergency procedures and
neighbour amenity obligations.
Ongoing record keeping Maintain records of occupancy, Supports evidence-based
complaints, serious incidents and monitoring and compliance.
management responses, available
to Council on reasonable request.
Source: Condition themes are applicant-proposed management commitments informed by the existing hostel operation,
operator evidence and Noosa Council’s DMP direction regarding responsible visitor behaviour, transport management,
community values and managed tourism.[1][2] Final conditions should be settled through the development assessment
process and aligned with the approved plans and final Hostel Management Plan.
These commitments respond directly to Council’s concern regarding intensity. A higher number of guests does not
automatically equate to unacceptable impact where the use is managed, supervised and conditioned. The relevant
question is whether the operational impacts can be controlled.
The applicant submits that they can.
The operator has an established 25 to 30 year business history and advises that there is no complaint history. The
proposed conditions would formalise the management framework and provide Council with clear mechanisms to
regulate occupancy, behaviour, transport, waste, noise and complaints.
The proposed management approach also reinforces the distinction between this proposal and unmanaged short-term
accommodation in residential areas. The proposal is not a dispersed whole-dwelling short-stay model. It is a managed
hostel operation with defined occupancy, defined management obligations and enforceable operating procedures.
For these reasons, any potential impacts associated with the proposed additional 42 beds can be appropriately
managed by conditions of approval.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 33
33
14. Conclusion
The applicant submits that the overriding need for the proposed additional 42 hostel beds and manager unit is
demonstrated.
The proposal is not a new visitor accommodation use being introduced into a residential zone. It is a modest
intensification of an existing lawful Visitor Accommodation Type 4 – Visitor Hostel use. It does not remove permanent
housing stock. It does not convert existing dwellings to short-term accommodation. It does not displace approved key
worker housing. Refusal would not deliver a permanent housing, affordable housing or key worker housing outcome.
The proposal responds to a demonstrated and quantified accommodation need. Noosa has a limited hostel supply base
of approximately 510 beds across five hostel premises, within a mature destination economy that recorded
approximately 2 million visitors, more than $1.4 billion in visitor spend and approximately 4.7 million visitor nights in
2024.[3] The proposed additional 42 beds represent a modest increase of approximately 8.2% to that limited specialist
accommodation supply.
The site-specific need is stronger again. Dolphin Beach House’s own booking evidence shows that the operation
reaches functional capacity during the primary visitor season, with occupancy of approximately 97% to 100% between
October and March. The operator also records peak-period waiting lists of up to approximately 60 persons. That waitlist
evidence relates to Dolphin Beach House only, and is significant because the proposed additional 42 beds would not
fully absorb the unmet peak-period demand recorded by this one operator.
The proposal also supports an accommodation product that is scarce in Noosa: affordable, managed, low-cost hostel
accommodation for international independent travellers, working holiday makers and nature-based visitors. The
operator’s guest profile, transport behaviour, management controls and complaint-free operating history all support the
conclusion that the proposed intensity is capable of being appropriately managed.
The economic and workforce evidence further supports the need case. The proposal would provide affordable
temporary accommodation for a traveller cohort that contributes to Noosa’s visitor economy and, in many cases, to the
local labour-force ecosystem. The evidence does not suggest that hostel accommodation is a substitute for permanent
key worker housing. Rather, it demonstrates that managed hostel accommodation performs a complementary role by
accommodating international independent travellers and working holiday makers who spend locally, use local transport
and may seek or undertake work in local service sectors.
The proposal is also consistent with Noosa Council’s Destination Management Plan direction. The DMP does not seek to
eliminate tourism. It seeks to manage tourism so that it remains aligned with community values, environmental care,
local economic benefit, responsible visitor behaviour and transport management.[1][2] A managed hostel with guest
verification, house rules, low car dependency, responsible visitor messaging and no complaint history is materially
different from unmanaged short-stay dwellings or party-house accommodation.
The residential zoning of the land does not, of itself, mean that refusal of the proposed change would advance Council’s
affordable housing or key worker accommodation objectives. While the land may theoretically have capacity for a small
multiple dwelling redevelopment, the likely market outcome would be a limited number of high-value dwellings rather
Prepared for Council information response
Page 34
34
than affordable or key worker accommodation. That outcome would not materially address the affordable housing or
key worker accommodation need identified by Council, and there is no residential redevelopment proposal before
Council.
Refusal of the proposed change should therefore not be assumed to deliver an affordable housing, key worker housing
or meaningful housing-affordability outcome. Rather, refusal would retain the existing hostel approval while preventing
a modest, managed and evidence-based increase in a demonstrably undersupplied accommodation segment.
For these reasons, the applicant submits that the proposed additional 42 beds and manager unit should not be
characterised as overdevelopment. They represent a targeted, evidence-based and economically necessary increase to
an existing lawful hostel use, supported by overriding need and capable of being managed by appropriate conditions.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 35
35
Appendix A - References
Evidence basis and assumptions
This response relies on a combination of applicant/operator evidence, publicly available tourism and economic data,
and Council policy material. Operator-specific information, including seasonal occupancy, waitlist, guest profile,
transport behaviour, accommodation rates, management practices and complaint history, is based on advice provided
by the operator of Dolphin Beach House and its operating experience.
External tourism, economic, workforce, housing and destination-management sources are identified below. Where
figures are described as approximate, indicative or “in the order of”, they are provided as planning and economic
context rather than as a formal economic impact assessment, valuation report or feasibility report.
[1] Noosa Shire Council, Noosa’s Destination Management Plan webpage.
Key references: DMP vision, destination-management framework, balanced visitor economy, responsible visitor
behaviour, community values, environmental care, local economic benefit, fact sheets and supporting DMP resources.
[2] Noosa Shire Council, Noosa’s Destination Management Plan 2026.
Key references: executive summary, guiding principles, destination stewardship, responsible visitor behaviour,
sustainable transport, visitor economy management, community values, Noosa Promise and implementation
directions.
[3] Tourism Noosa, Membership Prospectus 2025–26.
Key references: 2024 Noosa visitation, visitor spend, visitor nights, tourism value-add, tourism employment, business
reliance on the visitor economy, overnight visitor strategy and average daily visitor spend.
[4] Tourism and Events Queensland, International Tourism Snapshot – Year Ending June 2025.
Key references: Queensland international visitor expenditure, international visitor numbers, average spend per night,
Sunshine Coast international visitor expenditure, Sunshine Coast international visitor numbers and regional spend-per-
night benchmarks.
[5] Tourism Australia, Youth Sector / Working Holiday Maker market material.
Key references: youth traveller contribution to Australian tourism, working holiday maker travel behaviour, longer stays,
dispersal, expenditure and work/travel patterns.
[6] Australian Government Department of Home Affairs, Working Holiday Maker Visa Programme Report.
Key references: Working Holiday Maker visa holders, visa grants, post-pandemic recovery of the working holiday market,
and specified-work participation across sectors including agriculture, accommodation and food services, and
construction.
[7] Jobs and Skills Australia, Accommodation and Food Services Industry Profile.
Key references: industry employment, part-time employment share, median worker age, occupation profile and
relevance of younger/flexible workers to hospitality and food service sectors.
[8] Noosa Shire Council, Noosa Housing Strategy 2022.
Key references: housing supply and affordability pressures, key worker and employer challenges, retail/hospitality
workforce issues, and treatment of historical visitor-accommodation approvals in Medium and High Density Residential
zones.
[9] Tourism Research Australia, Tourism Workforce Report.
Key references: post-COVID visitor-economy workforce shortages, the role of temporary and permanent migrant worker
absence in workforce deficiencies, and ongoing workforce challenges in tourism-related sectors.
Prepared for Council information response
Page 36
36
[10] Applicant/operator evidence provided by Dolphin Beach House.
Key references: estimated Noosa hostel bed supply, Dolphin Beach House seasonal occupancy profile, peak-period
waitlist, guest origin profile, age profile, working-holiday profile, transport behaviour, accommodation rates,
management controls, market positioning, operating history and complaint history.
[11] Application material for the proposed change application.
Key references: existing lawful Visitor Accommodation Type 4 – Visitor Hostel approval, proposed additional 42 persons
and manager unit, site context, existing and proposed hostel operation, architectural/planning material and proposed
management response.
Prepared for Council information response
Used in these records
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 1.1 MB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.