Council archive · source document
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report · 132008.299.02
25
provide managed, supervised, affordable and low-car accommodation within an existing lawful hostel operation,
supported by operational evidence and capable of being regulated by conditions.
For those reasons, the proposal is properly characterised as DMP-aligned managed tourism infrastructure, not
unmanaged tourism intensification or housing displacement.
DMP resources also identify case studies including Banff Lead Tourism for Good, Oahu Destination Management,
Wonderful Copenhagen, Bay of Plenty, CopenPay, and the Great Ocean Road Visitor Economy Master Plan.[1] The
common direction of those examples is not to suppress all visitor activity. It is to steward tourism so that it generates
local value, changes visitor behaviour, protects places under pressure and aligns the visitor economy with community
values.
The subject proposal fits that destination-management approach. A managed hostel with public/active transport use,
strict house rules, guest identification, no complaint history and a nature/coastal/yoga/surfing market is more
consistent with destination stewardship than pushing demand into informal, unregulated or unmanaged
accommodation alternatives.
11. Housing and key worker accommodation response
The applicant acknowledges that permanent residential housing and key worker accommodation are significant
planning issues in Noosa. The applicant does not seek to minimise those issues. The applicant also accepts that
Council is entitled to consider whether visitor accommodation in a residential zone may affect housing outcomes.
However, the applicant submits that the housing issue must be assessed by reference to the actual proposal before
Council, the existing lawful use of the land, and the realistic planning consequences of approval or refusal.
This proposal does not remove existing permanent housing stock. It does not convert existing permanent rental
dwellings to short-term accommodation. It does not displace an approved affordable housing or key worker housing
project. It does not involve unmanaged whole-dwelling short-stay letting. It is a proposed intensification of an existing
lawful Visitor Accommodation Type 4 – Visitor Hostel use.
That distinction is central to the information request response.
Council’s request asks the applicant to demonstrate overriding need for visitor hostel accommodation “over” the need
for permanent residential housing and key worker accommodation. With respect, that should not be treated as a simple
binary contest between tourism and housing. The proposal is not a choice between 42 hostel beds and 42 permanent
residents. Nor is it a choice between the proposal and an approved key worker housing development. There is no such
residential or key worker housing proposal before Council.
The existing hostel approval would remain even if the proposed change were refused. Refusal would therefore not
deliver new permanent housing, affordable housing or key worker accommodation. It would simply prevent a modest
increase to an existing hostel operation that has demonstrated need, affordability, low car dependency, workforce
relevance and a long complaint-free operating history.
Prepared for Council information response
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 1.1 MB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.