Council archive · source document
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report · 132008.299.02
3
1. Council request and direct response
Council's information request relevantly states:
"Noting the existing approval for Visitor Accommodation Type 4 - Visitor Hostel, Council is concerned that the
proposed additional 42 persons and 1 Manager unit over Lot 3 on SP228958 results in a high development intensity
across two smaller and divided lots located within the Medium Density Residential zone. Combined with the existing
development at 14 Duke Street, the total accommodation of 102 persons is considered an overdevelopment.
Information Required: Demonstrate an overriding need for a high intensity Visitor Hostel accommodation in a
Residential zone over the high need for permanent residential housing and key worker accommodation."
The applicant submits that the requested overriding need is clearly demonstrated. The need is not advanced on the
basis that visitor accommodation is generally more important than permanent housing. That is not the correct planning
test for this application. The need is demonstrated by the particular planning, economic and operational circumstances
of this proposal.
The subject use is already lawfully established as Visitor Accommodation Type 4 - Visitor Hostel. The application does
not convert permanent dwellings to short-term accommodation. It does not remove existing permanent rental stock. It
does not displace an approved residential or key-worker housing project.
Refusal of the change would not deliver permanent housing or key worker accommodation; it would simply retain the
existing hostel approval without the additional accommodation, workforce and economic benefits now proposed.
The more accurate planning characterisation is that the proposal is a modest and managed intensification of an existing
hostel use, supported by strong evidence of need, including constrained hostel supply, peak-season occupancy at
functional capacity, peak waiting lists, affordability, international and working-holiday demand, low car dependency,
strict management controls and a long complaint-free operational history.
Council's Destination Management Plan reinforces this framing. Council's own destination-management material does
not treat tourism as an activity to be eliminated; it seeks to manage tourism so that it respects community, protects the
environment, nurtures a thriving local economy and is delivered in balance with nature and local values.
The proposal responds to that policy direction by accommodating a demonstrated visitor and working-holiday cohort
within an existing, supervised and low-car hostel operation, rather than pushing demand into unmanaged dwellings or
unregulated visitor accommodation alternatives.
Prepared for Council information response
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 1.1 MB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.