Council archive · source document
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report · 132008.299.02
5
visitor behaviour and reduces pressure on infrastructure. The proposal aligns with that policy direction because it
provides managed, low-car, affordable hostel accommodation within an existing lawful operation, rather than
dispersing visitor demand into unmanaged residential short-stay accommodation.
3. Correct planning frame: not a binary choice between tourism and housing
Council's request asks the applicant to demonstrate overriding need for visitor hostel accommodation "over" the need
for permanent residential housing and key worker accommodation. The applicant acknowledges the importance of
permanent housing and key worker accommodation in Noosa. However, the request should not be framed as a simple
contest between all visitor accommodation and all housing.
The Noosa Housing Strategy 2022 acknowledges the housing crisis, limited housing supply and the particular challenge
created by a local economy with significant tourism, retail and hospitality employment. It also recognises that many
existing developments in Medium and High Density Residential zones came through historical approvals allowing use as
either visitor accommodation or permanent occupation, and that those approvals cannot be removed. The Strategy
states that making further short-term accommodation inconsistent in those zones applies to new development or sites
that do not already have approval for the use.[8]
That distinction is important. This application relates to an existing approved hostel use. The proposal is not seeking to
commit a previously residential site to a new visitor use. It is seeking to adjust an already established, managed and
historically operating hostel. The relevant question is therefore whether the proposed intensification of that existing
hostel use is justified and manageable having regard to need, amenity, transport, management and local economic
function.
The applicant submits that it is. Refusal of the proposed 42 additional beds would not produce any new permanent
housing supply. No self-contained apartments, affordable housing units or key worker dwellings are proposed or
approved on the site. The existing hostel use would remain. Accordingly, the proposal should be assessed on its actual
planning merits, rather than on an abstract assumption that every visitor bed is directly substitutable for permanent
housing.
The DMP is relevant to that planning frame because it draws a distinction between unmanaged visitor pressure and
consciously managed, values-aligned tourism. The applicant's case is not that all tourism growth should be prioritised
over housing. The case is that this particular proposal represents managed accommodation infrastructure for a
demonstrated international, independent and working-holiday traveller cohort, without converting housing stock or
undermining an actual affordable-housing outcome.
Prepared for Council information response
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 1.1 MB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.