Skip to the record
For the highest quality transcripts.

Council archive · source document

Sealed Notice of Appeal (RACV) - 15.12.2023 · MCU22/0118

of 8

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

In the Planning and Environment Court                                                             No.4) Ub        of 2023
Held at: Brisbane

Between:                 ROYAL AUTOMOBILE CLUB OF VICTORIA                                        Appellant
                         (RACV) LIMITED (ACN 004 060 833)

And:                     NOOSA       SHIRE COUNCIL                                                Respondent



                                                 NOTICE OF APPEAL

Filed on:                            15 December 2023
Filed by:                            MILLS OAKLEY
                                     Solicitors
Service address:                     Level 23, 66 Eagle Street, Brisbane Qld 4000
Phone:                               (07) 3228 0400
Fax:                                 (07) 3012 8777
Email:                               [email protected]
Reference:                           9380843


ROYAL AUTOMOBILE                    CLUB OF VICTORIA (RACV) LIMITED (ACN 004 060 833)
c/- Mills Oakley,         Level     23,     66    Eagle     Street,     Brisbane      in the State of Queensland,
hereby         appeals   to the     Planning          and        Environment     Court      at Brisbane       against    the
Respondent's           decision     notice       dated      23    November      2023       whereby    the     Respondent
refused        the    Appellant's         development             application   for    a    development         permit   for
material change of use for short-term accommodation (15 cabins) on land located at
94 & 142 Noosa           Drive, Noosa            Heads and properly described as Lot 0 on SP203417,
Lot 3 on        SP126203,         Lot 203        on   SP267424,         Lot 0 on SP203415,             and    Lot 200     on
SP267421 (Development Application).

The Appellant seeks the following orders or Judgment:

(a)       the appeal be allowed;

(b)       the        Development          Application        be     approved     subject     to    conditions     that   are
           relevant to, but not an unreasonable                         imposition     on the development           or are
           reasonably required in respect of the development; and

(c)       such further or other orders as the Court deems appropriate.




      NOTICE OF APPEAL                                                          MILLS OAKLEY
          |]                                                                    Solicitors
      Filed/on behalf of the Appellant                                          Level 23, 66 Eagle Street
      /4                                                                        BRISBANE QLD 4000
      Form PEC-1                                                                Phone no. (07) 3228 0400
                                                                                Fax no.(07) 3012 8777
                                                                                Email: [email protected]
                                                                                Reference: 9380843
                                                                                                                1
Full text of the other 7 pages

Page 2

The grounds of appeal are:

iP    The land is:

      (a)      situated at 94 & 142 Noosa Drive, Noosa Heads;

      (b)      described as Lot 0 on SP203417,                  Lot 3 on SP126203,          Lot 203 on SP
               267424, Lot 0 on SP203415, and Lot 200 on SP267421;

      (c)      in total 6.384 hectares in area;

      (d)      located within the Tourist Accommodation Zone and the Environmental
               Management         and     Conservation         Zone     of the     Respondent’s           planning
               scheme, Noosa Plan 2020 (Noosa Plan);

      (e)      within the Noosa Shire Local Plan Area of the Noosa Plan; and

      (f)      subject to various overlays under the Respondent’s Plan.

      On or about 28 June 2022, the Appellant lodged the Development Application.

      On    16 August    2022,      the    Respondent          issued    a confirmation          notice     to the
      Development Application. The Development Application was properly made on
      9 August 2022.

      On    10 January 2023, the Respondent              issued an amended              confirmation notice
      for the Development Application.

      The Development Application was impact assessable under the Noosa Plan.

      Public notification was undertaken from 13 January 2023 to 8 February 2023.

      The   Development        Application    was   referred to the State Assessment                      Referral
      Agency (SARA) as a concurrence agency — Schedule 10, Part 10, Division 3,
      Subdivision 3     - Development in SEQ Koala Habitat Area.

      On    8 August    2023,     SARA       provided    the     Appellant       with   a changed          referral
      agency response.

      By way of decision notice dated 23 November 2023, the Respondent notified
      the Appellant of its decision to refuse the Development Application.

10.   The Respondent's reasons for refusal are Annexure A                         to this Notice of Appeal.

11.   The    decision     to     refuse      the    Development            Application      is      erroneous,
      unreasonable and unlawful having regard to the below.

12.   In respect of the Respondent's decision to refuse the Development Application,
      the Appellant says:

Page 3

(a)    In respect of paragraph 1 of the Respondent's reasons for refusal:

       (i)    the proposal is largely located within the urban boundary and only
              partially extends beyond the urban boundary into the Environmental
              Management and Conservation Zone;
      (ii)    in the circumstances, the minor encroachment into the
              Environmental Management and Conservation Zone is necessary
              to retain the largest and most significant koala habitat trees on the
              land;
      (iii)   the density and height of the proposal is consistent with the local
              character as:
              (A)       the proposal comprises eight (8) separate buildings that are
                        two (2) storeys in height which is consistent with the
                        expected built form in the Tourist Accommodation Zone;
              (B)       the proposal has a scale and density that is compatible with
                        the intent of the Tourist Accommodation Zone and the
                        preferred character of the local area;
              (C)     — the proposal is of a scale and bulk that is compatible with
                        surrounding development, including the existing RACV
                        Noosa Resort;
              (D)     — the proposal will not visually dominate the street or
                        surrounding areas; and
              (E)       the proposal will preserve the amenity of surrounding
                        premises including privacy, views and access to sunlight.
              there is planning need for the proposal which will provide
              community benefit as:
              (A)       Noosa’s economy relies significantly on the tourism, retail,
                        health and construction sectors;
              (B)       the proposal will contribute to a diversity in tourist
                        accommodation; and
              (C)       the proposal is predominately on land in the Tourist
                        Accommodation Zone, within which the proposal is a
                        consistent use.
(b)   In respect of paragraph 2 of the Respondent’s reasons for refusal:

      (i)     the encroachment into the Environmental Management and
              Conservation zone, is minor and not significant as:
              (A)       the site has a dual zoning and can be developed in part for
                        the proposed use of tourist accommodation within the
                        Tourist Accommodation Zone; and
              (B)       the encroachment into the Environmental Management and
                        Conservation Zone is required to protect significant
                        vegetation which is located within the urban boundary;
              the encroachment into the Environmental Management and
              Conservation Zone is acceptable because:
              (A)       more significant vegetation is retained within the urban
                        boundary portion of the land, than may otherwise be the
                        case; and

Page 4

              (B)     significant ground truthing exercises have been undertaken
                      to consider and identify the vegetation within the
                      development footprint area which is to be protected and
                      retained;
      (ii),   the proposal will not have unacceptable impacts on the biodiversity
              of the locality and can be appropriately managed through a
              Rehabilitation Management Plan and Koala Rehabilitation
              Management Plan.

(c)   In respect of paragraph 3 of the Respondent's reasons for refusal:
      (i)     the Appellant repeats and relies on paragraphs (a)(i)-(ii) and (b)(i)
              herein;

      (ii)    the proposal is not an overdevelopment of the land as:
              (A)    the development footprint only represents a small portion of
                     the total site area;
              (B)    the proposal has a site cover of 20.6% over Lot 3, which is
                     the primary part of the development land to be developed,
                     being substantially less than 40% allowed for in the Tourist
                     Accommodation Zone; and
              (C)    the proposal generally has a minimum 6 meter building
                     setback to Noosa Drive and a minimum setback of 4 metres
                     to the south-western boundary;
      (iii)   the proposal does not result in unacceptable clearing of vegetation
              in an ecologically important and environmentally sensitive area, as
              ecological assessments have been undertaken to identify the most
              significant vegetation which is be protected and retained;

      (iv)    the land is presently of little value for use by koalas because an
              invasive weed species has overtaken the koala habitat trees. The
              proposal will remove and manage the invasive weed species by
              way of an Environmental management plan to improve the health of
              koala habitat trees on the land;

      (v)     it can be demonstrated that the proposed stormwater treatment
              meets or can be conditioned to achieve the water quality objectives
              and protection of biodiversity areas required under the Water
              Quality and Drainage Code;
      (vi)    the built form of the proposal is consistent with the locality and does
              not have any adverse impacts as:
              (A)    the proposal has a low-rise built form of 2 storeys in height
                     and maintains a minimal footprint being comprised of small
                     building units that are to be elevated to minimise the extent
                     of earthworks required;
              (B)    the proposal will have elevated built form to minimize the
                     impacts on vegetation. The elevated built form will also
                     improve and enhance connectivity to other koala habitat
                     areas on the Land;
              (C)    it is adjacent to similar built form in terms of height;
              (D)    it is not perceptible from surrounding areas; and
              (E)    it is screened by vegetation.

Page 5

                                                Particulars
            (vii)     The proposal complies with, or can be conditioned to comply with
                      the following provisions of the Noosa Plan, or otherwise if there is a
                      non-compliance that non-compliance is not determinative:
                      (A)    Strategic Framework — 3.2.2, 3.2.5, 3.3.1(b) and 3.3.4(b)(p);
                      (B)    Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code —
                             8.2.2.2(2)(a), (b), (c), (d), (e), (f), (g), (h) and (i) Table 8.2.23
                             PO1, PO3, PO6 and PO11;
                      (C)    Water Quality and Drainage Code — 9.4.82(2)(a) and (b) and
                             Table 9.4.8.3 PO6;
                      (D)    Noosa Heads Local Plan Code — Overall Outcomes
                             (2)(b)(d)(e) and (ad) and Table 7.2.5.3 PO4, PO5, PO6 and
                             PO26;
                     (E)     Environmental Management and Conservation Zone Code —
                             Overall Outcomes (2)(a) and (b), Table 6.7.1.3 PO1, POS,
                             PO7, PO8, POY, PO11 and PO13;
                     (F)     Tourist Accommodation Zone Code - Table 6.3.4.3 PO9 and
                             PO10.
      (d)   In respect of paragraph 4 of the Respondent’s reasons for refusal:
            (i)     | the South-East Queensland Regional Plan 2017 supports the
                      proposed use of the land for urban development, being for tourist
                     accommodation; and
            (ii)    | the proposal is consistent with the Tourist Accommodation Zone, as
                     it seeks to provide tourist accommodation       largely within the urban
                     boundary.
      (e)   In respect of paragraph 5 of the Respondent’s reasons for refusal, the
            Appellant repeats and relies on paragraphs (c)(iii) and (a)(iv) herein.
Relevant Matters

13.   The other relevant matters to support the approval of the proposal include:

      (a)   the proposal strikes an appropriate balance between planned
            development for tourism purposes and the retention of significant
            amounts of native vegetation that is to be maintained and enhanced by
            way of a Rehabilitation Management Plan and Koala Rehabilitation
            Management Plan;

      (b)   the proposal will provide a different tourist experience in the Noosa
            Heads locality;
      (c)   the proposal will provide substantial community benefit in terms of
            increased employment during construction and through the ongoing
            operation of the cabins as part of the existing RACV Noosa Resort;
      (d)   the proposal will not cause any visual amenity, traffic, infrastructure or
            other adverse impact; and

      (e)   the proposal will have a low site impact being comprised of elevated
            structures.

14.   For the reasons above,      in the exercise of the Court’s discretion:

Page 6

       (a)     the Development Application complies or can be conditioned to comply
               with all applicable assessment benchmarks;
       (b)     the appeal should be allowed; and
       (c)     the Development Application should be approved subject to reasonable
               and relevant conditions.




                                                                      Mills Oakley                .
                                                                      Solicitors for the   Appellant




If you are named as a respondent in this notice of appeal and wish to be heard
in this appeal you must:

         (a)     within 10 business days after being served with a copy of this
                 Notice of Appeal, file an Entry of Appearance in the Registry
                 where this    notice   of appeal        was    filed or where      the court file is
                 kept; and

        (b)      serve a copy of the Entry of Appearance on each other party.

The   Entry    of Appearance     should        be    in Form    PEC    — 5   for the   Planning       and
Environment Court.

If you are entitled to elect to be a party to this appeal and you wish to be heard
in this appeal you must:

        (a)      within 10 business days of receipt of this Notice of Appeal, file a
                 Notice of Election in the Registry where this Notice of Appeal was
                 filed or where the court file is kept; and

        (b)      serve a copy of the Notice of Election on each other party.

The Notice of Election         should     be        in Form    PEC    - 6 for the      Planning       and
Environment Court.

Page 7

                                Annexure    A



The proposed development has failed to demonstrate a significant planning
need to develop outside of Noosa Plan 2020's urban boundary, particularly at
the density and height proposed and is inconsistent with the local landscape
character. No overriding community benefit been demonstrated, which would
justify approval despite its conflict with the planning scheme.
Valid planning grounds have been raised by submitters that the proposal will
result in an unacceptable impact on the biodiversity of the locality. Further, the
development exceeds what a community member could reasonably expect to
be developed outside of the Urban Boundary and within the Environmental
Management and Conservation Zone.
The proposed development of the subject land is inappropriate, in
circumstances where:
(a)   The proposed development seeks to expand the existing resort complex
      in circumstances where part of that land is located outside of the urban
      boundary in Noosa Plan 2020;
(b)   The proponent seeks to utilise the land for Short-term accommodation,
      which is an inconsistent use in the Environmental Management and
      Conservation zone;
(c)   The proposed development is an overdevelopment of the land at the
      expense of the natural values of the land, as the proposal would result in
      unacceptable clearing of vegetation in an ecologically important and
      environmentally sensitive area, including proposed development located
      on mapped Areas of Biodiversity Significance, Matters of State
      Environmental Significance (MSES) Environmental Values and Riparian
      Buffer Area under the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay and
      mapped Core Koala Habitat area;
(d)   The stormwater treatment proposed is not of a sufficient size to achieve
      the water quality objectives and protection of biodiversity areas required
      under the Water Quality and Drainage Code.
(e)   The built form of the proposed development is unacceptable, being
      slightly over height in metres in the Tourist Accommodation zone and
      substantially over height in metres and storeys in the Environmental
      Management and Conservation zone.
In respect of the above, the proposed development is inconsistent with the
following provisions of Noosa Plan 2020:

Page 8

(i)     Strategic Framework — 3.2.2, 3.2.5, 3.3.1(b) and 3.3.4(b)(p);

(ii)    Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code — 8.2.2.2(2)(a), (b),
        (c), (d), (e), (f), (g), (h) and (i) Table 8.2.23 PO1, PO3, PO6 and PO11;
(iii)   Water Quality and Drainage Code — 9.4.82(2)(a) and (b) and Table
        9.4.8.3 PO6;
(iv)    Noosa Heads Local Plan Code — Overall Outcomes (2)(b)(d)(e) and (ad)
        and Table 7.2.5.3 PO4, PO5, PO6 and PO26;
(v)     Environmental Management and Conservation Zone Code — Overall
        Outcomes (2)(a) and (b), Table 6.7.1.3 PO1, PO5, PO7, PO8, POQ,
        PO11 and PO13;
(vi)    Tourist Accommodation Zone Code - Table 6.3.4.3 PO9 and PO10a.
When read as a whole, the South East Queensland Regional Plan 2017
(SEQRP) does not lend support to the proposed use of the land, as:
4.1     the SEQRP sets a long term, 50-year vision, establishing aspirations for
        the region up to 2067. Given this, the timing and sequencing of urban
        development occurring within the Urban Footprint is a finer grained detail,
        the planning for which is implemented through local government planning
        schemes;
4.2     the designation of land as being within the Urban Footprint does not imply
        that all that land with that designation can be developed for urban
        purposes; and
4.3     when assessed against Noosa Plan 2020, the proposed development is
        not suitable for urban development.
The following relevant matters support refusal:
5.1     The proposed development will involve an unacceptable loss of
        vegetation in a locality which is an ecologically important and
        environmentally sensitive and serves as an important ecological linkage,
5.2     There is no planning, economic or community need for the proposed
        development on the subject land.

Used in these records

About this file

File size
2.6 MB (large file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Sealed Notice of Appeal (RACV) - 15.12.2023.pdf · 2.6 MB (large file)

The download may take up to a minute.

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.