Skip to the record
The gold standard in government transparency.

Council archive · source document

2ND RFI - Attachment 3 - Further advice from Consult Arborist · MCU22/0118

of 6

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

                                                                            Consult Arborist
                                                                                                                   Pty Ltd


         5/07/2023

         Shane Adamson
         Adamson Town Planning

         By email: [email protected]



         A RBORICULTURAL R ESPONSE

         Project:                   RACV Noosa Short Term Accommodation Eco Resort
         Applicant:                 Royal Automobile Club of Victoria (RACV) LTD
                                    C/- Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
         Street Address:            94 & 142 Noosa Dr, Noosa Heads
         Application No.            MCU22/0118
         Subject:                   Noosa Council – Further Advice

                                    001 ECM_22350069_v6_Further Advice Assessment Manager
                                    MCU22 0118

                                    Dated 6th April 2023

         Dear Shane,

         Further to the request for further advice and information from Noosa Council please find to
         follow the Arborist Response.

         This information should be read with the previous Arboricultural Impact Assessment report
         ‘22_06_13_AIA_Aspect_RACV Noosa Eco_V1’ and associated spreadsheets and project
         documents.

         Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any queries or wish to discuss the information
         in this document.

         Yours sincerely,




         _______________________
         Matthew Duncan
         Director / Principal Arborist
         Level 5 AQF Arborist



         Matthew has worked in the arboricultural industry since 1994 and established Consult Arborist Pty Ltd
         on the Sunshine Coast in 2011. He is a Queensland Arboricultural Association (QAA) Qualified Member
         and Approved Consultant, an AQF Level 5 since 2010, currently holds a Diploma in Arboriculture
         (AHC50510) and is International Society of Arboriculture Tree Risk Assessment Qualified 2015 to 2025.



ABN: 68 153 548 531 | [email protected] | 0450 355 770                      T O D A Y ’ S T R E ES F O R T O M O R R O W
Full text of the other 5 pages

Page 2

                                                                              Consult Arborist

B RIEF / S COPE
Respond to the request for Further Advice – Development Application by Noosa Council

   •   Provide information and clarification relating to the future management and care of the
       retained trees on the site on completion of the project.
   •   Proposed management of the invasive weed species, specifically the Frangipani Vine
       that is found throughout the site.

T REE M ANAGEMENT AND F UTURE M AINTENANCE
Since January 2019, Consult Arborist has collaborated with the management team at RACV
Noosa to conduct annual Visual Tree Assessments focused on mitigating risks and adhering
to sound arboriculture practices. The company has consistently delivered comprehensive
reports that outline their findings and provide recommendations for necessary tree work, along
with guidance for ongoing maintenance. Throughout this period, the primary objective has
been to preserve and sustain trees in a condition that optimizes their habitat value and
enhances visual appeal when viewed both within the site and from public viewpoints. Given
the advanced age of many trees, certain specimens have experienced compromised structural
integrity. To address this issue, the emphasis has been on minimizing the likelihood of
potential failures and mitigating their impact rather than resorting to complete removal. This
approach involves carefully pruning the trees in a phased manner, reducing their weight and
mass while allowing them to recover and regrow. Varying degrees of canopy management
have been successfully implemented, particularly in proximity to the accommodation dwellings
adjacent to the environmental corridor parallel to Noosa Drive.




  Figure 1: Ongoing example of canopy management     Figure 2: Active response growth following
       adjacent to RACV accommodation in the       management increasing canopy density and tree
               environmental corridor.                                  health.




23_07_05_ArbRes_ATP_RACV Noosa Eco_NC                                                    Page 2 of 6

Page 3

                                                                             Consult Arborist

Previous efforts around the resort have focused on implementing upper canopy management
strategies for certain mature Eucalypt species, prioritizing their long-term viability and safety.
Rather than opting for complete removal, the emphasis has been on prolonging the trees'
useful lifespan. To control encroachment onto the adjacent accommodation buildings,
proactive measures have been taken, primarily through selective pruning to address direct
conflicts. Total removal is only considered as a last resort. Whenever feasible, standing trunks
have been retained to serve as habitat or refuge poles, contributing to the ecological balance.
Numerous large trees located just a few meters from the resort accommodation are
deliberately preserved and closely monitored to ensure the preservation of ecological
functionality.

The above format of monitoring and assessment is scheduled to continue and upon its
completion, will be expanded to include the project area and completed eco-cabins.

In addition to the existing trees being managed in an environmentally sensitive way, the resort
has planted hundreds of local native trees and understory plant species to embellish the
existing canopy and ensure a viable treescape for the future. Many of these trees and plants
are beginning to infill gaps and provide lower fauna habitat. The concept of the replacement
planting throughout the eco-resort will follow this format with the same beneficial objective.

Within the eco-resort site, the prominent and larger tree species observed is the Swamp
Mahogany, Eucalyptus robusta. This particular Eucalyptus species exhibit a natural tendency
for retrenchment and renewal in its upper canopy. Essentially, during unfavourable growing
conditions, the tree naturally undergoes dieback in its outer canopy. Conversely, when
growing conditions improve, the tree stimulates new growth on its branches. This inherent
growth cycle provides numerous opportunities for pruning. The tree responds by generating
fresh growth from older branches, resulting in a tree with a reduced height and spread
compared to other Eucalyptus species known for their expansive canopies that can exceed
30 meters in height.

It is this natural growth habit that has been imitated to facilitate the successful arboricultural
management of trees adjacent to the infrastructure in the resort. The primary objective of any
ongoing tree management activities is to selectively perform pruning tasks that minimize risks
without resorting to removal. The focus is on promoting growth and maintaining the health of
these trees, allowing them to be retained while preserving their natural functionality within the
broader ecology of the site while managing the natural hazards large forest trees can present.

With trees proposed to be retained in proximity to the Eco Cabins, canopy management will
become an ongoing cycle of staggered maintenance.




23_07_05_ArbRes_ATP_RACV Noosa Eco_NC                                                   Page 3 of 6

Page 4

                                                                                Consult Arborist




    Figure 3: Large branch failed from a Swamp      Figure 4: Natural response growth of the Swamp
    mahogany, heavily pruned and retained for its    mahogany with compact canopy establishing.
                  ecological value



It is predicted that some trees will require pruning to facilitate the construction phase of the
projects, particularly to accommodate the necessary infrastructure such as safety scaffolding.
A comprehensive review of the site layout and alterations to the cabin layout has been
conducted. As a result, additional trees have been retained, and careful assessment has been
undertaken to ensure that the form and structure of the trees are compatible with the cabins.
In some cases, it has been observed that certain trees naturally grow away from the cabins,
reducing conflicts and encroachment concerns. This proactive approach allows for a balance
between the preservation of trees and the successful completion of construction activities.

Where approved larger trees are to be removed to allow construction of the project, the
methodology of removal will involve the sectional dismantling of the trees with climbing
arborists and cherry-pickers to avoid damaging the surrounding preserved trees and fauna.

N EW P LANTI NG S EL ECTION
Two particular species of Eucalypt have been proposed as part of the broader replanting
palate for the site due to their attractiveness to fauna and future arboricultural manageability.
These are the Forest Red Gum, Eucalyptus tereticornis, and Moreton Bay Ash, Corymbia
tessellaris. An understory planting of Blue Lilly pilly/Scented Satinash, Syzygium oleosum, is
proposed, as a larger shrub that can be easily managed, this will provide suitable screen
planting and augment the greening of the site.

The species choice for plantings are endorsed for their suitability for location on arboricultural
grounds.




23_07_05_ArbRes_ATP_RACV Noosa Eco_NC                                                      Page 4 of 6

Page 5

                                                                              Consult Arborist

W EED M ANAGEMENT
Weed management at the site will primarily focus on continuing the ongoing eradication
activity that is to be commenced at the earliest opportunity. This process is expected to
continue indefinitely as it becomes a natural element of the resort’s maintenance activities.

A specialist environmental company have been approached to provide RACV with specialised
weed management information. The Frangipani vine, Chonemorpha fragrans, known for its
invasive nature, has extensively spread across the central area of the site, overpowering many
trees and stifling the growth of lower-level vegetation and ground-cover plants. A priority is
now placed on initially controlling and removing the bulk of the vine. This step is crucial to
prevent further detrimental effects on the existing trees that are deemed to be retained for
longevity throughout the site.

Given that the Frangipani vine is a creeping species that spreads along the ground and
infiltrates leaf litter, ongoing management will be necessary to address its regrowth over time.
While complete eradication may require years of effort, gaining control over the vine would
pave the way for the restoration of local flora and fauna, marking a significant ecological
achievement for the site. The ultimate goal is to create an environment where native plants
and wildlife can thrive.




             Figure 5: Frangipani vine                    Figure 6: Vine smothering trees




23_07_05_ArbRes_ATP_RACV Noosa Eco_NC                                                       Page 5 of 6

Page 6

                                                                                               Consult Arborist

C OPYRIGHT
This report/document is subject to copyright laws and remains the property of Consult Arborist Pty Ltd. Penalties
@280c per word per incident of unauthorised usage. No part of this report may be reproduced or used without the
written permission of Consult Arborist Pty Ltd. No responsibility will be accepted by Consult Arborist Pty Ltd for
unauthorised or partial use of this report.

General Permission of use as subject to Consult Arborist Pty Ltd copyrights:
•   Hard copy permission: Entire copies may be printed for use by the Client for internal or Project liaison.
•   Electronic permissions: Must be original PDF format for filing and/or limited to the agreed parties with a direct
    and vested interest in the case.

A SSUMPTIONS AND D ISCLAIMER
This report's information has been prepared independently, free of any bias and represents the honest opinion of
the consulting arborist.

All data is based on a visual inspection of the tree/s and its/their location at the time of writing, unless otherwise
stated, and contains opinions, advice and recommendations based on information and data gathered from site
inspections carried out by the author and information supplied by the Client (Aspect / RACV Noosa).

All information received from the Client shall be deemed to be true, accurate and up to date.

To the extent permitted by law, you agree Consult Arborist Pty Ltd is not liable to you or any person or entity for
any loss of or damage caused or alleged to have been caused (including loss or damage resulting from negligence)
either directly or indirectly, by your use of the information made available in this report. In no event will the author
be liable to you for any lost revenue or profits, or for special, indirect, consequential, or incidental damage (however
caused and regardless of the theory of liability) arising out of or related to your use of that information, even if the
author has been advised of the possibility of such a loss or damage.

Consult Arborist cannot be held responsible for the effects of non-conformance works performed, by unsuitably
qualified staff or without the supervision of Consult Arborist.

Unless otherwise stated this report cannot be used within a court of law or any legal situation without the prior
consent of Consult Arborist Pty Ltd. The author shall not be required to give testimony or to attend court by reason
of this report unless subsequent contractual arrangements have been made.

There is no warranty or guarantee, expressed or implied, that the problems or deficiencies of the plants or property
in question may not arise in the future. Likewise, remedial treatments cannot be guaranteed.

Arboriculturalists cannot detect every condition that could possibly lead to the structural failure of a tree. Trees are
living organisms that fail in ways we do not fully understand. Conditions are often hidden within trees and below
ground. Consult Arborist Pty Ltd and the author cannot guarantee that a tree will be healthy or safe under all
circumstances, or for a specified period of time.

This report does not take into consideration the possibility of extreme weather or other events over which Consult
Arborist Pty Ltd has no control.

Treatment, pruning and removal of trees may involve considerations beyond the scope of the Arboriculturalists
services, such as property boundaries and ownership, disputes between neighbours, sightlines, landlord-tenant
matters and related. Consult Arborist Pty Ltd cannot take such issues into account unless complete and accurate
information is given to them. Likewise, Consult Arborist Pty Ltd cannot accept any responsibility for the authorization
or non-authorization of any recommended treatment or remedial measure.

Arboriculturalists are tree specialists who use their education, knowledge, training, and experience to examine
trees, recommend measures to enhance the beauty and health of trees and attempt to reduce the risk of living near
trees. Trees can be managed, but they cannot be controlled. To live or work near a tree involves some degree of
risk. The only way to eliminate all risks associated with a tree is to eliminate the tree.

Clients may choose to accept or disregard the recommendations of Consult Arborist Pty Ltd or to seek additional
advice.




23_07_05_ArbRes_ATP_RACV Noosa Eco_NC                                                                      Page 6 of 6

Used in these records

About this file

File size
1.1 MB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

2ND RFI - Attachment 3 - Further advice from Consult Arborist.pdf · 1.1 MB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.