2018-05-08 Services & Organisation Committee Agenda

ATTACHMENT 2




  Page 8 of 107

NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL                     Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
              Contract Title:               Noosa Council Crushing - LANDFILL                                                                                                                                                                         ATTAC H M E NT 2

    NAME OF TENDERER                                                     PRICE
    (Conforming Tenders Only)                                        (excl of GST)
1   |Rosenlund Contractors                                                    $154,500)
2.  |Terragon Mobile Crushing                                                 $194,750
3 [Fai ES LS ce                                               [oe a i re]
4 |e ee) Te ee                                                     er
5: [ae ae a        NE oe                        ae
LW                                                             |
7 | BEE Taree RS ee                                                                  |
8 |G            SE                        ae Se
9 [Axe      Sah Oe       Ne |                    os
10 [55855 Rite aces se TR]
    NON-CONFORMING TENDERS                                                                                                                                   2

                                                                           1                     2                      3                    4                    5                    6                    x                    8                    9                    10
                                                                                              Crushing
                                                                             Resultant             Resultant              Resultant            Resultant            Resultant            Resultant            Resultant            Resultant             Resultant           Resultant
    Evaluation Criteria                         Weighting (%)      Score      score X    Score       score x               score x    Score     score x    Score     score x    Score     score x    Score     score x    Score     score x              score x    Score     score x
                                                                             weighting             weighting             weighting             weighting           weighting            weighting            weighting            weighting             weighting            weighting

                                                                                          Te
                                                                                              Crushing
    Total Fees (Pc)                                  35%                $154,500              $194,750                 $o                    $0                   $o                   $o                   $o                   so    .              $0                   $0
    Average Fees (Pav) $....c.cccsscsssssesesees  $174,625
    Price Score                                                            112                   88                     0                     0                   0                    0                    0                    0                    0                    0
    Normalised Price Score (Pn)                                     :      100                   79                     0                     0                   0                    0                    0                    0                    0                    0
    Weighted Price Score (Pw)                                                 0

                          Assessment Panel                                             Position Title                                                                                                                     Ki )
                                                                                                          ,                                     The Contract Administrator confirms the above scores                      Ly             \)
          Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member 1               Cameron Shields - Technical Coordinator                                        and weightings of this evaluation                                NVQ
                      Assesment Panel Member 2                          Rob Walsh - Waste Management Supervisor
                      Assesment Panel Member 3                               Keith Gravett - Quarry Supervisor                                       Contract Administrator's signature:                        Cameron Shields - Technical Coordinator
                      Assesment Panel Member 4                       Peter Robinson - Workplace Health & Safety Advisor
                      Assesment Panel Member 5                              James Santifort - Engineering Trainee
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Page 8 of 107