Council archive · source document
Deputation: Opposition to Amendment No. 2, Factsheet 12 (BUSINESS ENTERTAINMENT ACTIVITIES TO THE NOOSA PLAN 2020) Applicant: Peter Thomas Stuehrenberg Speakers: Peter Thomas Stuehrenberg & Siriluk Moonthiya · Attachment 1 to the General Committee Minutes -PowerPoint
Plans and drawings: the text below has words only, no drawings.
Deputation
14/10/24
Points to be raised today:
1. Proposal to exclude Fact sheet #12 from Amendment No. 2 of
the Noosa Plan 2020.
2. The Residents requesting Point 1 are NOT against live
entertainment / music, however they are concerned of its
current and future management impacting their lives every day.
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 9 pages
Page 2
Peter Stuehrenberg
• Living in Noosa Shire since 2002
• Living temporally in Noosa Heads since 2015
• Living permanently in Noosa Heads since 2021
• Mo to Fr - working in Gympie
• Sa to So – Enjoying what Noosa has to offer including the
night life @ the Junction
It is important for me to say here… I do not know anyone
who is against live entertainment @ the Junction – in the
contrary most people enjoy it & acknowledge the need for it.
Page 3
Summary of events.
1. What happened since Christmas 2023/24
• We have had the usual annual experience during this period
where the noise increases until school begins – we know about
this and accept it, as part living close to the Junction.
• In February this year, the noise of loud music keeps coming and
lasting past 10 pm even on weekdays – Residents and guests
are irritated, and their sleep is impacted.
• In the following month residents are exploring where the loud
music comes from and are engaging with the venue owners
and the OLGR.
• Some improvements from venues were made but were not
sustained.
• Complaints were sent to the OLGR & OLGR has acted on these
complaints
Page 4
Why are some residences affected by noise from venues and others are not? Example of venue locations and the associated area affected: Red area shows where sound can travel in a straight line without barriers. Houses that are on elevated areas are more affected. Topography: Sunshine Beach Road essentially is a small valley, so sound from the strip, travels up the surrounding hillsides. Therefore, this location for nightlife & entertainment in general is & will always be a challenge with the surrounding residents in their old or newly build homes.
Page 5
Summary of events.
2. Mid-End of July - Discovery of Fact sheet #12 within the
“Proposed Amendments No 2 of the 2020 Plan”.
• Based on the residents long-term & recent experiences with
noise related issues – the mere proposal to extend the time from
current council provisions to 7 days until midnight came to a
shock to the affected residents. What will happen if the proposed
changes will be put in place?
• When asking people to make a submission to council the older,
longtime residents gave already up. E.g. comments like: “Council
is not listening anyway, they just do what they want”, etc. At least
they wished me good luck… .
• After the end of the submission period, I launched a petition to
inform people in general regarding Fact sheet #12 & the potential
negative consequences for the surrounding residences and to
provide an option for people who missed the submission
deadline. Another petition was launched “save our music” from
NJA which is concerned about the potential absence of live music
and its consequences. Both petition request a collaborative
approach.
Page 6
Current situation.
3. Residents’ Questions & fears regarding the proposed
changes of Fact sheet #12.
What will happen, if the residents’ rights to peace in their homes at a
reasonable hour cannot be guaranteed, if this continues that venues
with live or recorded music are exceeding the noise & time limits
provided in their licence to the point that residents wellbeing is severely
impacted, if there is no regulation and enforcement provided by the
council? - What are the potential impacts?
• Will current & future residents have to listen to the music in their
homes & bedrooms until midnight or longer every night then?
Listen to the noise associated with loud patrons and staff leaving
the Junction after midnight, e.g. screaming, yelling, motorbikes &
loud cars with modified exhaust systems….we can hear them for
miles. And then the essential workers living here must wake up
early in the morning to go and perform at their work, after just 4-5
hrs of sleep? How will school kids perform at school after lack of
sleep?
• What choices will these surrounding residents have? Sound-
proof their houses or apartments? Move somewhere else? Or
complain to the authorities, e.g. OGLR?
Page 7
Current situation.
3. Questions & fears regarding the proposed changes of Fact
sheet #12.
History has not given us the confidence that all venues can regulate
themselves in a way that does not unreasonably impact on the
surrounding residents, with the current rules regulations in place.
The proposed changes in fact sheet # 12 bear the risk the current
situation will be significantly worsened. In this fact sheet it is unclear
how a right balance between the needs of business owners and
residents can be achieved. There is no mentioning of the surrounding
residents.
Further, OPEN QUOTE “Noosa Council does not deal with noise
complaints about:
• music, loud stereos, parties, rowdy behavior and burglar alarms.
Report a complaint online with the Queensland Police
• premises with a liquor licence are regulated by the Office of
Liquor and Gaming Regulation . “ END QUOTE
So, in essence – Noosa Council makes the changes, and the
residence will have to deal with the any unintended
consequences.
Page 8
How can we expect better outcomes if we are continuing
making the same mistakes over again?
Noise in the Junction has always been an issue - several venues have, over the
years, been moved on from Hastings St (as nightlife there clashes with tourism) to
The Junction which has resulted in noise complaints and issues each time - The
Village Bike moved from opposite Nomads into Sunshine Beach Road. Little
Sister moved into where Village Bike had been, same thing happened -
complaints followed and Little Sister had to leave that location. There were noise
issues a couple of years ago with The Cornerstone. They spent tens of thousands
putting in acoustic measures, then sold to Four Pines, who, unknowingly during
their renovations, removed all those acoustic measures, started operating and of
course the noise complaints rolled in. They spent over $40 000 putting in new
acoustic mitigation measurements.
New York Minute arrived Dec. 2023 / Jan. 2024, with no plans to operate within
the restrictions of his live music licence, and by the end of Jan. complaints started
rolling in. It took 8 months of residential complaints for OLGR to eventually stop
them from playing live music - after warnings and fines initially.
Will the same thing will happen with every new licensee that comes to the
Junction? Council can provide the licence, it doesn’t work, residents complain and
spent months and months not sleeping, eventually the licensee is hit with costs to
renovate their premises with acoustic measures, or if outdoors, the need to pivot
and change their business model when they realise, they simply can’t play live
So, what are the learnings and how will they be used for the
music.
future?
Page 9
What could be done?
A future where businesses can operate with confidence, patrons can enjoy
entertainment safely and residence will not be negatively impacted….
1. Why is Fact sheet #12 included in the Amendment No. 2? – We suggest to
remove it from this amendment.
The matter deserves a collaborative approach which provides the time for
consultations, impact assessments, case studies to produce sustainable
solutions that provide the best outcomes for all stakeholders involved.
A collaborative approach is needed including stakeholders and expert
groups to explore entertainment options for Noosa that will not have
unintended consequences and potential long-term negative impacts on
the region's economy. The scope should not only focus on the Noosa
Junction Hospitality Precinct. What about if Noosa would have a long-term
“Inclusive Entertainment Strategy “ where all purposes and needs are
considered, where the Junction plays a vital part of it?
2. If #1 can be achieved, then the surrounding residents will be able to
continue enjoying live music @ the junction and be able to sleep
peacefully in their homes.
Can we achieve a result with a balance between supporting tourism-driven
nightlife and maintaining residential quality of life?
As you know, finding a balance between economic growth, residential
satisfaction, and community needs is essential to sustainable urban
development.
Page 10
I would like to Thank you,
• To all the people who have signed the petitions
on this matter – it shows that this is an
important issue, and we now could get this
right.
• To the people in my neighbourhood which
encouraged me to be here today.
• To all council members who have listened today
and can revise the Amendment No.2 before the
submission to State Government.
Open to questions
Used in these records
Deputation: Opposition to Amendment No. 2, Factsheet 12 (BUSINESS ENTERTAINMENT ACTIVITIES TO THE NOOSA PLAN 2020) Applicant: Peter Thomas Stuehrenberg Speakers: Peter Thomas Stuehrenberg & Siriluk Moonthiya · Attachment 1 to the General Committee Minutes -PowerPointAttachmentsMeeting 714 · read item & discussion ↗
About this file
- File size
- 2.2 MB (large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take up to a minute.