Council archive · source document
Attachment 2- Cultural Heritage Due Diligence Assessment MCU12/0208
EVERICK
Heritage Consultants Pty Ltd
ABN 78102206682
APRIL 2013
CULTURAL HERITAGE
DUE DILIGENCE ASSESSMENT
NOOSA ON WEYBA
NOOSAVILLE, QLD
PREPARED FOR STEVE MACRAE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
47 Arthur Tce, PO Box 146,
Red Hill Q 4059 Innovative Heritage Solutions
Phone 07 3368 2660 | Fax 07 3368 2440
Email [email protected]
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 41 pages
Page 2
Report Reference:
T. Robins, R. Robins, and A. Bishop, 2013 Noosa on Weyba, QLD: Cultural Heritage Due Diligence
Assessment (April 2013). Everick Heritage Consultants Pty Ltd unpublished report prepared for Steve MacRae
Development Services.
EVERICK HERITAGE CONSULTANTS PTY LTD
ABN: 78 102 206 682
47 Arthur Terrace
PO Box 146
RED HILL, QLD 4059
T: (07) 3368 2660 F: (07)3368 2440 E: [email protected]
Document Status:
Rev No. Version Author(s) Amended Sections Date Authorised
T. Robins, R. Robins &
1 Draft All 18.04.13 T. Robins
A. Bishop
2 Final T. Robins 1, 7 20.04.13 T. Robins
© Everick Heritage Consultants Pty Ltd 2013
This document is and shall remain the property of Everick Heritage Consultants Pty Ltd. The document may only be used
for the purposes for which it was commissioned. Everick grants authority to reproduce this document for academic
purposes. Unauthorised reproduction of this document is prohibited.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 3
DEFINITIONS Aboriginal Cultural Heritage means the same as described in the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (ACHA). Namely, that it is a significant Aboriginal area, or a significant aboriginal object, or evidence, of archaeological or historic significance, of Aboriginal occupation of an area of Queensland. Aboriginal Object means any deposit, object or material evidence (not being a handicraft made for sale) relating to the Aboriginal habitation of the area that comprises Queensland, being habitation before or concurrent with (or both) the occupation of that area by persons of non-Aboriginal extraction, and includes Aboriginal remains. Aboriginal Place means any place declared to be an Aboriginal Place (under the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003) or as gazetted by The Minister or a representative of The Minister. It may or may not contain Aboriginal Objects. ACHA means the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (Qld). Background Scatter is an archaeological term used to describe the general distribution of artefacts throughout all of Australia which supports the theory that evidence of Aboriginal occupation is ubiquitous throughout the entire continent of Australia. The ‘background scatter’ is different to discrete, higher density artefact scatters which are evidence of localised, concentrated human activity – for example a camp site, a ceremonial place or a grave site. The Consultant means qualified archaeological staff of Everick Heritage Consultants Pty Ltd. DATSIMA means the Queensland Department of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander & Multicultural Affairs. Duty of Care (DoC) means the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Duty of Care, as defined in s.23 of the ACHA. DoC Guidelines means the guidelines established under s.1.1, 1.2 and s.28 of the ACHA. The Project means the Proposed Works, including ground surface disturbance, required for the creation and development of a residential development within the boundaries of the Project Area. EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 1 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 4
Project Area means Lot 2 on Survey Plan 151113; Lot 2 on Registered Plan 20576; Lot 1322 on Crown Plan 531576; Lot 847 on Crown Plan S311193; Lot 1323 on Crown Plan 5,312742; Lot 1 on Registered Plan 178201; and Lot 859 on Crown Plan 531 1196 as shown in Figure 2. Proposed Works means all activities carried out by the Proponent within the Project Area, and any of their subsidiary companies, employees, staff, contractors or sub-contractors. Significant Aboriginal Area means an area of particular significance to the Aboriginal parties as defined under the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (Qld). EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 2 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 5
Table of Contents
1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................ 5
1.1 Brief ............................................................................................................................................ 5
1.2 Methods ...................................................................................................................................... 5
1.3 Assessment Context: Location and Description of Project Area....................................................... 6
1.4 Proposed Works .......................................................................................................................... 6
1.5 Constraints to this Assessment .................................................................................................... 11
2. LEGISLATIVE AND PLANNING CONTEXT......................................................................................... 12
2.1 The Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (Qld) ......................................................................... 12
2.1.1 The Duty of Care Guidelines ................................................................................................ 12
2.1.2 Cultural Heritage Management Plans or Agreements ............................................................. 14
2.2 The Queensland Heritage Act 1992 (Qld) ................................................................................... 15
2.3 The Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ................................................................................................. 15
3. ENVIRONMENT ................................................................................................................................16
4. DESKTOP REVIEW .......................................................................................................................... 17
4.1 DATSIMA Cultural Heritage Database Search Results .................................................................. 17
4.2 Other Heritage Registers: Aboriginal and Historic Cultural Heritage ................................................ 19
4.3 Review of Historic Aerial Photography.......................................................................................... 19
5. THE ARCHAEOLOGY OF THE PROJECT AREA ............................................................................... 21
5.1 Aboriginal Cultural Heritage ......................................................................................................... 21
5.1.1 Potential Site types .............................................................................................................. 21
5.1.2 Potential sites – Potential distribution .................................................................................... 21
5.2 Predictive Models: The Project Area’s Archaeological Potential .................................................... 22
6. SITE INSPECTION........................................................................................................................... 23
6.1 Survey Methods......................................................................................................................... 23
6.2 Survey Results .......................................................................................................................... 24
7. DISCUSSION OF CULTURAL HERITAGE RISK ................................................................................ 28
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 3
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 6
7.1 Summary of Results: Aboriginal Heritage .................................................................................... 28
7.1.1 Management Option A: Duty of Care Assessment ................................................................ 30
7.1.2 Management Option B: CHMP ............................................................................................ 30
7.2 Summary of Results: Historic Cultural Heritage ............................................................................. 31
8. RECOMMENDATIONS ..................................................................................................................... 32
APPENDIX A : DATSIMA CHCU REGISTER SEARCH RESULTS .............................................................. 34
APPENDIX B: HISTORIC AERIALS .......................................................................................................... 37
List of Figures
Figure 1: General location of Project Area ......................................................................................................... 7
Figure 2: Project Area ..................................................................................................................................... 8
Figure 3: Project Master Plan .......................................................................................................................... 9
Figure 4: DATSIMA Search results.................................................................................................................. 10
Figure 5: DATSIMA Search results.................................................................................................................. 18
Figure 6: West Lot 53 on SP163571 facing north .......................................................................................... 25
Figure 7: Large shed on East Lot 53 on SP163571 ...................................................................................... 25
Figure 8: Original timber chopped down on East Lot 53 on SP163571 ............................................................ 26
Figure 9: House on Lot 12 on RP893393 .................................................................................................... 26
Figure 10: Dock on Lake Weyba on Lot 12 on RP893393 ............................................................................ 27
Figure 11: Potential Sites Areas...................................................................................................................... 29
Figure 12: 1958 Historic Aerial ...................................................................................................................... 37
Figure 13: 1974 Historic Aerial ...................................................................................................................... 38
Figure 14: 1993 Historic Aerial ...................................................................................................................... 39
Figure 15: 2008 Historic Aerial...................................................................................................................... 40
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 4
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 7
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Brief
This report presents the results of a Duty of Care Assessment regarding the Aboriginal and historic (Non-
Indigenous) cultural heritage attributes of the Noosa on Weyba Development at Noosaville, QLD (Figure 1).
The purpose of this assessment is to identify potential cultural heritage constraints that may impact on the
proposed development. This report provides an appraisal of both the technical minimum legal requirements for
managing cultural heritage, and an appraisal of other factors that may require moving beyond strict legislative
compliance.
1.2 Methods
The following methodology was used to undertake this assessment:
a) a background review of environmental factors (soils, geology and land use);
a) a search of applicable registers (see Section 4.1);
b) a search of the Queensland Department of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and Multicultural
Affairs (DATSIMA) Cultural Heritage Coordination Unit’s Database for existing records of sites that
occur within four kilometres of in the Project Area;
c) an examination of historic aerial photography and satellite images;
d) a review of the relevant geotechnical reports for the Project Area;
e) a site inspection of the Project Area areas to determine the nature and degree of past disturbance and
to determine if the Proposed Works are likely to impact on Aboriginal or Historic Cultural Heritage;
f) an assessment of the potential for the Project Area to contain significant Aboriginal Cultural Heritage;
g) mapping of any archaeologically/culturally sensitive areas located during the survey;
h) a preliminary assessment of the Project Area against the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (Qld)
(ACHA) Duty of Care Guidelines; and
i) management recommendations addressing the Proponent’s statutory obligations under the ACHA.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 5
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 8
The desktop analysis was undertaken by Everick Heritage Director Dr. Richard Robins and Archaeologist Anna Bishop. The field inspection was undertaken by Dr. Richard Robins and Anna Bishop. This report was prepared by Tim Robins, Richard Robins and Anna Bishop. 1.3 Assessment Context: Location and Description of Project Area The Project Area for this assessment is on the west coast of Lake Weyba, approximately 3.5km from Noosaville. The Project Area comprises of four conjoined lots combined to form two offset adjacent blocks, see Figure 2 (Project Area). Lot 2 on SP 179590 and Lot 53 on SP 163571 are bounded south by Hollett road and west by the Noosa Part 3 Golf Course and other private lots. To the north lies Eenie Creek and other residential developments. Walter Hay Drive intersects Lot 53 on SP 163571 running southwest to northeast. The eastern portion of Lot 53 on SP 163571 is bordered to the east by Lot 1667 on M37772, which is part of the Biodiversity Development Offset Area. Lots 11 and 12 on RP 893393 run adjacent to the southeast corner of Lot 53 on SP 163571. These lands are bordered to the west by Tidwell road and to the south by a dirt track that runs along the edge of the property. To the east of these properties lies Lake Weyba, and to the north is Lot 1667 on M37772. Part of the development plans for this project also include a Biodiversity Development Offset Area (BDOA), which comprises of Lot 7 on RP46782, Lot 2 on RP 160983, and 1667 on M37772, a total of 139.5 ha. Other than compulsory planting works, this land will not be impacted by the development and therefore is excluded from this report. 1.4 Proposed Works As a duty of care exercise, the precise details of the Project works are unknown at this stage. However, being a residential development and considering the topography of the Project Area, there will most likely be cut and fill earthwork prior to subdividing the site. For the purposes of this assessment, it has it been assumed that the Project will potentially result in significant ground disturbance to all parts of the Project Area identified as being developed under the current Draft Project Masterplan (Figure 3). EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 6 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 9
Figure 1: General location of Project Area EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 7 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 10
Figure 2: Project Area EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 8 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 11
Figure 3: Draft Project Master Plan EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 9 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 12
Figure 4: DATSIMA Search results EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 10 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 13
1.5 Constraints to this Assessment
Constraints to this assessment included:
Aboriginal and Community Consultation: The assessment has not involved consultation with the
Aboriginal Party of local Aboriginal knowledge holders. This is generally a key requirement of
assessing the significance of any identified heritage objects or places.
Survey Conditions: During the site inspection performed on 5 April 2013 there was extremely low
Ground Surface Visibility, which inhibits the archaeologist’s ability to see Aboriginal Objects. This may
have limited the resulting number of artefacts found during the assessment.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 11
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 14
2. LEGISLATIVE AND PLANNING CONTEXT
In relation to cultural heritage, the site will be affected by four primary pieces of legislation. Indigenous heritage
falls within the auspices of the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (Qld) (the ACHA). This legislation
operates independently of any development application process. Historic heritage in Queensland is managed
through the Queensland Heritage Act 1992 (Qld). The Noosa Plan (2006), the Draft Sunshine Coast
Planning Scheme (2013) and the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld) also contain general provisions
relating to the management of both historic and Aboriginal cultural heritage.
2.1 The Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (Qld)
The methodology developed for this study was informed by the provisions of the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage
Act 2003 (QLD) (the ACHA). Within the ACHA are a set of guidelines which establish that any land user
must exercise due diligence and take reasonable precaution before undertaking any activity which may harm
Aboriginal cultural heritage. This is considered to be a land users ‘Duty of Care’ towards Aboriginal Cultural
Heritage. To assist land users in discharging their Duty of Care, the ACHA establishes processes for the timely
and efficient management of activities to avoid or minimise harm to Aboriginal cultural heritage.
Under the concept of Duty of Care, a person or organisation who carries out an activity must take all
reasonable and practicable measures to ensure the activity does not harm Aboriginal cultural heritage (the
Aboriginal cultural heritage Duty of Care). Part of the Duty of Care requires an assessment of:
(a) the nature of the activity, and the likelihood of its causing harm to Aboriginal cultural heritage;
(b) the nature of any Aboriginal cultural heritage likely to be harmed by the activity;
(c) whether the land user (i.e. Tri-Star Coal Company) carried out a study or survey, of the area affected
by the activity to find out the location and extent of Aboriginal cultural heritage, and the extent of the
study or survey; and
(d) the extent to which the person has complied with Aboriginal cultural heritage Duty of Care Guidelines.
2.1.1 The Duty of Care Guidelines
The Duty of Care Guidelines can be followed, for certain lands and projects, as the sole method of a cultural
heritage assessment and reporting. It is Everick’s opinion that this is unlikely to be the case for the current
Project. Never-the-less, understanding the Duty of Care Guidelines is important for planners, as they may be
of use as a negotiation tool where agreement cannot be reached with the Aboriginal party, for discrete sections
of the Project, and/for subsequent development applications.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 12
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 15
The Duty of Care Guidelines (The DoC Guidelines) are based on the concept of ground disturbance, both the
previous ground disturbance to a location, and the proposed ground disturbance which will be carried out by
the intended project. In summary, the type of ground disturbance is classified into five (5) categories under
The DoC Guidelines which are as follows;
CATEGORY 1 – No Ground Surface Disturbance. This means exactly that, there is no further
ground surface disturbance, and therefore no threat to physical Aboriginal Heritage. Proposed works
that are assessed as falling into this category may proceed without further investigation.
CATEGORY 2 – No Additional Surface Disturbance. This means that ground surface disturbance
has occurred in the past, and the proposed activities is the same or similar to what has occurred
previously. Examples given of a Category 2 disturbance are grazing cattle on paddocks already used
for grazing cattle, and maintaining and using pre-existing roads and vehicle track.
CATEGORY 3 - Developed Area. Similar to Category 2, in that disturbance of the proposed works
will be impacting an area already disturbed somewhat. Category 3 specifically applies to works of
infrastructure in areas of infrastructure, e.g. sewer maintenance, road upgrades, electrical
infrastructure etc.
CATEGORY 4 – Areas previously subject to Significant Ground Disturbance. This category
particularly applies to landscapes that initially may not fall into the proceeding categories but in which
Aboriginal Cultural Heritage is unlikely to be harmed. An example of a Category 4 landscape would be
regenerated forest after extensive timber logging had occurred. Care must be taken, however, with
this category as residual Aboriginal Cultural Heritage value may remain, particularly ceremonial or
mythological value which may not have been impacted by the “Significant Ground Disturbance”.
CATEGORY 5 – Any activity or area that does not fall into the preceding categories.
“Significant Ground Disturbance” as mentioned in Category 4 means:
(a) disturbance by machinery of the topsoil or surface rock layer of the ground such as by ploughing,
drilling, creating bore holes, or dredging; and
(b) the removal of native vegetation by disturbing root systems and exposing underlying soil.
The three key characteristics that need to be considered when assessing degrees of disturbance in regards to
Duty of Care by the Proponent are:
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 13
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 16
(a) the nature of past disturbance and the impact this may have had on Aboriginal Cultural Heritage;
(b) the nature of the development and potential damage it may cause the Cultural Heritage; and
(c) the nature of the Aboriginal cultural heritage likely to be found in the Project Area, particularly the
characteristics, extent and location.
The methodology used in this assessment focused on assessing these aspects, with a view to developing
strategies to reduce the Proponent’s risk of causing harm to Aboriginal cultural heritage.
2.1.2 Cultural Heritage Management Plans or Agreements
Under the ACHA, a land user can meet its Duty of Care when they can reach an agreement with the Aboriginal
Party on the management of cultural heritage. The agreements can come in two forms, either an approved
CHMP by DATSIMA or not. The benefit of agreements that are not approved by DATSIMA is that can take any
form, are generally faster to negotiate, and also more cost effective. However, on relatively large project such
as the present project, we do not recommend unapproved CHMP Agreements. The reasons are that:
a) the CHMP will be required to last a relatively long period, as different stages of the project are
released;
b) there is the potential that the Aboriginal party will change, with transition provisions more likely to be
approved by DATSIMA where included in an approved CHMP; and
c) there is a greater likelihood that in the event of future legislative change, and approved CHMP will
remain a legally valid means of managing cultural heritage.
The process for adopting an approved CHMP is detailed under Part 7 of the ACHA. Under these provisions, a
Sponsor (the Proponent) is required to provide formal notification of their intent to develop a CHMP to the
Aboriginal Party (Gubbi Gubbi People #2). The Aboriginal Party have 28 days to respond in writing that they
wish to develop the CHMP. The Sponsor and the Aboriginal Party then enter an 84 day period of negotiations.
In the event that Agreement is reached before 84 days, both parties can consent to submitting the CHMP to
DATSIMA for approval. In the event that agreement cannot be reached, the Sponsor have dispute resolution
processes available to them, which includes submissions to the Land Court of Queensland if required.
Note: If an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is required for the Project, The Proponent will be required to
prepare an approved Cultural Heritage Management Plan (CHMP) under Part 7 of the ACHA.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 14
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 17
2.2 The Queensland Heritage Act 1992 (Qld)
The Queensland Heritage Act 1992 (Qld) (‘the QHA’) is the principle piece of legislation controlling actions
on items or places of historic (non - Aboriginal) state heritage significance. The primary protection for such
items or places is provided through nomination and registration for entry onto the Queensland Heritage
Register. Once a place is entered onto the register, the Queensland Heritage Council (QHC) has a range of
decision making powers over subsequent development applications. The Cultural Heritage Unit of DATSIMA is
also given responsibilities over the management of cultural heritage in Queensland.
2.3 The Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)
Under Section 3 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), the main objectives of the legislation are to:
a) provide for the recognition and protection of Native Title
b) establish ways in which future dealings affecting Native Title may proceed and to set standards for
those dealings
c) establish a mechanism for determining claims to Native Title
d) provide for, or permit, the validation of past acts, and intermediate period acts, invalidated because of
the existence of Native Title.
Native Title is the recognition by Australian law that some Indigenous people have rights and interests in their
land that come from their traditional laws and customs. Native title rights may include the right of Indigenous
people to:
a) live on the area
b) access the area for traditional purposes including camping or ceremonial activities
c) visit and protect important places and sites
d) hunt, fish and gather food or traditional resources including water, wood and ochre
e) teach law and custom on country (National Native Title Tribunal, 2011).
The Aboriginal party for this area is the Gubbi Gubbi People #2. This group received Native Title claim over
the Project Area in 2001. The status of this Native Title claim was later discontinued, and as such there are no
Native Title claims over the proposed development area.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 15
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 18
3. ENVIRONMENT The landscape is one of mostly flat grasslands with some light slopes and multiple dams and gullies. Relief is up to 16 m in the eastern half of the Project Area, and 22 m in the western half. Streams are erosional, tributary and integrated. Vegetation is extensively cleared tall open forest with remnant vegetation along stream lines and occasionally isolated in the landscape. The land is currently used for cattle and horse grazing. Soils and Geology: The soils and geology within the Project Area are predominately a medium plasticity sandy / clay loam (podsols). The cultural horizon appears relatively shallow over the slopes and ridge crests, to a depth of approximately 600 – 1,000 mm. Greater depth of 1,500 mm is anticipated at the base of the hill slopes and along the creek lines. Original Vegetation: There is a considerable amount of remnant forest within the Project Area on which to assess the vegetation prior to European Settlement. Current Vegetation: The Project Area has been subject to extensive vegetation clearing since the 1970’s, at the latest. Some original trees dot the largely cleared areas, but most are mixed in with younger vegetation in the surrounding forest. The area is now predominately under pasture grasses suitable for cattle grazing, (buffel grass, Rhodes and Mitchell grass), with regrowth suckers / saplings of Eucalypt sp. However, remanent vegetation remains along the shallow ephemeral creek line on the eastern portion of the Project Area. EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 16 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 19
4. DESKTOP REVIEW
4.1 DATSIMA Cultural Heritage Database Search Results
A search of the Department of Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander & Multicultural Affairs Cultural Heritage was
undertaken on 20 March 2013. A four kilometre buffer was used around the combined Project Area in order
to incorporate all of the land surrounding Lake Weyba. The search results (Appendix A) were returned with no
Aboriginal Sites being recorded on:
a) Lot 2 on Survey Plan 179590;
a) Lot 53 on Survey Plan 163571; and
b) Lot 12 on Registered Plan 893393.
This negative result may indicate that there is minimal Aboriginal Cultural Heritage to be found within the
Project Area. However it is more likely an indication that there have been no, or very limited, Cultural Heritage
investigations undertaken here.
One site was registered immediately south of the Project Area, on Lot 12 RP 893393, immediately outside of
the Project Area. This site (KC:H72 at -26.436:153.0622) is a Scar Tree, recorded in August 2011. If
project works remain within the indicated Project Area then the tree should remain unharmed.
It is also of note that two sites were found within the BDOA. These sites include a shell midden and scar tree
(KC:H74 26.4284:153.0601) recorded in 2011 and an earth arrangement (KC:G18 26.4219:153.0516)
recorded in 1987.
DATSIMA informed Everick that the Cultural Heritage body for the above mentioned lots is Gubbi Gubbi
Dyungungoo Group Incorporated. The Aboriginal party for the same lots is Gubbi Gubbi People #2.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 17
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 20
Figure 5: DATSIMA Search results EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 18 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 21
Limitations of the Data
Lot 11 on Registered Plan 893393 could not be searched, as it did not appear on the registers available to
the Department. However, the 4 km buffer included in searches performed for the other Project Area lots will
have incorporated this land.
It is of note that DATSIMA advise that it is not possible to conclusively guarantee the accuracy of the
recordings (in particular, the longitude and latitude location description for each site) and extra diligence is
required when operating in these locations. DATSIMA also advise that it is generally possible that the absence
of recorded Cultural Heritage places reflects a lack of previous Cultural Heritage surveys of the area. Aboriginal
Cultural Heritage which may occur within the Project Area is protected under the terms of the ACHA even if the
Department of Environment & Resource Management has no records relating to it.
4.2 Other Heritage Registers: Aboriginal and Historic Cultural
Heritage
A search of other National, State, and Local Heritage Registers was undertaken on 8 April 2013 to identify any
Indigenous and historic places within the Noosa Shire LGA.
Queensland Heritage Register: Noosa River Caravan Park. This site is not within the Project Area.
National Trust of Queensland: No listings.
Register of the National Estate (Australian Heritage Council): Eight sites were returned from a
search of Noosa Shire. None are within the Project Area. The site within closest proximity is Noosa
National Park, on the opposite side of Lake Weyba. This site will not be impacted by the Proposed
Works.
Commonwealth Heritage List (Australian Heritage Council): No returns from this search.
4.3 Review of Historic Aerial Photography
A review of historic aerial photography (Appendix B) is important for understanding the nature of past
European impacts to the site. It is of value for assessing the land-user’s legal requirements regarding cultural
heritage.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 19
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 22
Historic aerial photographs from 1958, 1974, 1993, and 2008 were reviewed in order to assist in the identification of original environmental/topographic features and the degree of site disturbance post European settlement. The earliest aerial photograph available is from 1958, which show the original forest / scrub vegetation and a largely unmodified environment (Figure 12). There is some contained clearing to the north, west, and south of the Project Area. Clearing to the north is in close proximity to the Noosaville town centre. By 1974 extensive clearing has taken place within almost all of the Project Area (Figure 13). A number of tree lines and small vegetation clusters appear to have been spared during this process; however, the majority of the study area has lost the vegetation shown in the 1958 photo. The larger clusters of remaining vegetation are generally made up of vegetation surrounding creek lines. Three dams and associated drainage lines are shown in Lot 53 on SP 163571, and one in Lot 11 on RP 893393. Some remaining trees dot the lower half of Lot 2 on SP 179590, the middle of Lot 53 on SP 163571, and the eastern half of Lot 11 on RP 893393. Lot 12 on RP 893393 appears to have minimal disturbance at this time, with no major signs of clearing. The 1993 aerial photo shows a general trend of vegetation regrowth (Figure 14). Half of Lot 2 on SP 179590 has been reclaimed by forest, as was as adjacent lands in Lot 53 on SP 163571. There is a driveway and house on the cleared part of Lot 2 on SP 179590. A younger vegetation cover is shown spreading across the west portion of Lot 53 on SP 163571 while dense forest appears to be growing in from the fringes. Approximately half of the east portion of Lot 53 on SP 163571 is covered in regrowth. Revegetation is also shown spreading through Lot 11 on RP 893393, except for the land west of the dam on this lot. Lot 12 on RP 893393 retains the majority of its vegetation, however there appears to be a structure (possibly a house) that has been built in the middle of the lot. In 2008 much of Lot 53 on SP 163571 has been reclaimed with vegetation, except where there is clear ground disturbance in one area along both sides of Walter Hays drive (Figure 15). A small structure lies within the east portion of Lot 53 on SP 163571. Lot 2 on SP 179590 remains largely the same. Both Lot 11 and 12 on RP 893393 appear to have undergone more clearing, but nothing extensive. The drainage line in Lot 11 on RP 893393 has mostly dried up by this point. The pattern of clearance and regrowth that has taken place on these lots over the last 50 years would have most likely disturbed any artefacts located within the Project Area. Additionally, the construction of dams and drainage lines would have disturbed any subsurface artefacts and removed them from their original context. EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 20 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 23
5. THE ARCHAEOLOGY OF THE PROJECT AREA
5.1 Aboriginal Cultural Heritage
5.1.1 Potential Site types
Given the location of the proposed development and the extent of ground disturbance, the types of significant
Aboriginal cultural heritage that may remain within parts of the Project Area include, but are not limited to:
Middens – the remains of shell and bone material once forming part of the Aboriginal diet. Middens
are typically (though not always) found in close proximity to the shell source.
Single artefacts - usually made from stone, which may / may not have been used as tools. Can be
found throughout any landscape at any point. May have been left where they were discarded by
Aboriginal people as they moved through the landscape, rather than having arrived at a particular
location due to a particular event or premeditated action.
Artefacts scatters (denser concentration of artefacts) occur when the density of artefacts reaches a
threshold of size or density or both. These types of sites usually have a variety of artefact types and
sizes made often from different raw materials. They also often are interpreted as indicative of a
purposeful action of Aboriginal people within the landscape, or representing a specific action event.
Hearths comprise small concentrations of heat affected stones or clay nodules that have been used
as heat retainers during food cooking. The likelihood of hearths occurring in the Project Area is low,
considering the soil type. The likelihood of hearths remaining intact, having regard to the land use
history of the project area, is even lower. However, the potential cannot be eliminated entirely.
Scarred trees formed through the process of removing bark from trees to use for a variety of
purposes including canoes, containers and huts or for steps or holes cut into the trunk of the tree.
These site types are seen where original old growth (remnant) vegetation remains to the present day,
particularly in creek lines or on ridge / spur crests. There is a potential for culturally scarred trees to
remain within very few parts of the Project Area (See Figure 11).
5.1.2 Potential sites – Potential distribution
When assessing the potential site types within the Project Area, the level and type of past ground disturbance
must be taken into account. With the degree of extensive vegetation removal within the Project Area, the lands
most likely to retain potential for in situ Cultural Heritage are those area’s least disturbed. These areas
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 21
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 24
incorporate those parts of the Project Area where remnant vegetation still stands based on the evidence of the
historic aerial photography.
5.2 Predictive Models: The Project Area’s Archaeological Potential
Archaeological theories on the presence of absence of cultural heritage can vary. The prevailing theory
amongst archaeologists is that Aboriginal artefacts are generally found:
within 50m of a creek line or water source;
on creek flats bordering creek lines;
within landscapes that have not been significantly disturbed (in remnant vegetation etc.);
where particular resources are abundant or easily accessible (e.g. where a rock type favoured for
artefact manufacture is easily accessible); and
along ridge crests and spur crests (or wherever visibility is greater within the landscape).
Where these factors overlap, the risk of cultural heritage being found there increases. For example, artefacts
are most likely to be found within 50 m of a creek line (a low level of risk), but are even more likely to found
within 50 m of a creek line which retains remnant vegetation and an easily accessible rock source (combined
factors would make this area a high risk area).
The nature of Aboriginal occupation in the region, being relatively intense and over an extremely long time
scale, makes it almost certain that Aboriginal Objects are located within the Project Area. However, there were
no areas within the Project Area that have been identified as having a particularly high likelihood of containing
scientifically significant Aboriginal Objects. The review of the historic aerial photography and soil profiles
indicates that that most cultural heritage within the Project Area is likely to be disturbed, thereby limiting any
scientific significance.
Middens and culturally scarred trees are considered unlikely to remain within the Project Area. Evidence of
Aboriginal occupation is most likely to be limited to isolated artefacts and artefact scatters, in a disturbed state.
In particular, the far eastern portion of the Project Area is considered most likely to contain Aboriginal artefacts.
Further discussion is provided in Section 7 below.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 22
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 25
6. SITE INSPECTION 6.1 Survey Methods The physical assessment of the Project Area was undertaken by Dr Richard Robins and Anna Bishop (Everick Heritage) on 5 April 2013 following instructions from Steven MacRae. Inspection was mainly undertaken via 4WD access of the property, with spot checks performed on foot. The field team inspected all areas designated for development as indicated by the master and structural plans. Ground surface visibility (GSV) is a measurement of how much of the ground surface was visible at the time of survey in order to accurately assess the presence of Aboriginal Cultural Heritage. It is worked out by assessing a 1 m by 1 m area, and estimating the percentage of ground surface visible through the vegetation cover. A GSV of 30% means that 30 cm2 out of 1 m2 was able to be seen and assessed for Cultural Heritage. The GSV for the survey was 0-5% within all of the areas sampled. The ground surface coverage was generally dominated by shrubs and grass, ranging from a few centimetres to a metre in length (see Figure 6, Figure 8, and Figure 9). Factors which influence Cultural Heritage potential, such as environmental context, proximity to water courses, soil types, topography, previous land use, and disturbance were used to determine what areas to inspect in particular. Disturbances within the Project Area, such as the presence of residential dwellings and storage sheds, were also assessed and recorded. Careful attention was paid to the combination of original vegetation and regrowth that exists within the development footprint and surrounding of it. Original timber was assessed for cultural modifications or scars made by Aboriginal people prior to European settlement, and for European surveyors marks. The environment within and surrounding the Project Area was assessed for retention of natural resources which would have been utilised by Aboriginal People. The inspection was guided by the modelling of the proposed project details. GPS points and photographs were taken throughout the survey, as well as hand written notes detailing terrain, land forms, GSV, vegetation, and disturbance indicators. EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 23 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 26
6.2 Survey Results The Project Area has seen ‘Significant Ground Disturbance’ as described in the Duty of Care guidelines. The area which will be disturbed during the Proposed Works has already been disturbed by extensive vegetation clearing, earthworks, and drainage infrastructure. The effect of cattle grazing on the landscape, particularly in the soil types present, means that the potential for Aboriginal Heritage to remain within the Project Area in an unharmed, in situ manner is considered to be so low as to be negligible. Residences were constructed on Lot 2 SP179590 and Lot 12 RP893393, and two sheds were found on Lot 53 on SP163571 (see Figure 7 and Figure 9). This kind of construction would have included a heavy amount of ground disturbance through earthworks (cutting and filling), and excavation for the installation of sewage, electricity and water systems. Lot 53 on SP163571 and Lot 11 on RP893393 were further disturbed by the creation of the small dams and drainage lines. The earthworks required for these would have impacted the nearby ground surface fairly extensively. A house site was found in the centre of Lot 11 on RP893393. This site was a recent midden made up of trash, including a dish washer and wood beams, and resulting overgrowth. Nothing in this dump appeared to be older than 30 years, and nothing was of historic significance. There were no Aboriginal Objects, Places, or sites observed within the Project Area. EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 24 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 27
Figure 6: West Lot 53 on SP163571 facing north
Figure 7: Large shed on East Lot 53 on SP163571
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 25
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 28
Figure 8: Original timber chopped down on East Lot 53 on SP163571
Figure 9: House on Lot 12 on RP893393
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 26
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 29
Figure 10: Dock on Lake Weyba on Lot 12 on RP893393 EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 27 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 30
7. DISCUSSION OF CULTURAL HERITAGE RISK
7.1 Summary of Results: Aboriginal Heritage
Physical Aboriginal Heritage: The desktop research undertaken prior to the site inspection did not reveal
any known Aboriginal heritage within the project Area. Preliminary archaeological modelling and the
archaeological site inspection identified a range of landscape features within the Project Area that have a low
or moderate potential to contain Aboriginal Heritage. No areas were identified that are considered of high
risk, such that levels of cut and fill or Lot layouts would require altering.
Should further archaeological surveys or test excavations be undertaken, there will almost certainly be
additional Aboriginal Objects identified across the site. It is expected that any findings within the Project Area
would be of generally low density and of low or potentially moderate scientific, archaeological or historic
significance. It is unlikely that there will be archaeological findings of high scientific significance, such that
they may cause the development plans to be altered. In the event that such sites are identified, they are
likely to be in limited locations, and should be able to be easily accommodated into the open space planning
for the Project.
Three areas were identified that are considered reasonable likely to contain low or occasional medium
density concentrations of Aboriginal Objects (Figure 9):
a) The ridge crest in the east of the Project Area (Potential Sites Area A);
b) The creek line in the central east of the Project Area (Potential Sites Area B);
c) The areas within 100 – 150 m of the creekline in the north west of the Project Area (Potential Sites
Area C).
The vast majority of the Project Area (including Potential Sites Areas A – C) has undergone extensive
ground surface disturbance within the last thirty years, as can be seen from the Historic Aerial photography
(Appendix B) and from the photographs taken from within the Project Area. This would generally mitigate
against arguments for detailed archaeological test excavations.
Non-Physical Aboriginal Heritage: There have been no intangible (non-physical) heritage places identified
within the Project Area. The potential for these places to exist within the Project Area cannot be ruled out,
and can only be established through consultation with the Aboriginal party (Gubbi Gubbi People #2). Lake
Weyba in particular may have places of intangible heritage significance. Given the Projects setback from the
Lake, it seems most likely that the potential for impacting on any intangible significance associated with the
Lake is low.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 28
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 31
Figure 11: Potential Sites Areas EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 29 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 32
7.1.1 Management Option A: Duty of Care Assessment
An assessment against the Duty of Care Guidelines is often the first avenue of investigation in preparation for
a development. The historic aerial photography demonstrates that the Project Area has had a history of
extensive disturbance in most parts. Where it can be demonstrated that, under the project plans, no additional
ground disturbance will occur, no further assessment will be required. Furthermore, where it can be
demonstrated that the land within the Project Area has undergone Significant Ground Disturbance (as defined
in the legislation) then no further assessment will be required.
A technical interpretation of the Duty of Care Guidelines would see all of the Project activities fall within
Category 4 of the Duty of Care Guidelines. That is, all of the are to be impacted by project works has seen
Significant Ground Disturbance. This is clearly evident in the historic aerial photography and during the site
inspection. However, this type of assessment is considered a grey area in cultural heritage management.
Section 6 of the Duty of Care Guidelines acknowledges that there may be residual cultural values associated
with disturbed artefact scatters, and one of the objects of the legislation is to involve Aboriginal people. Having
regard to this, and the proximity of the Project Area to an important environmental feature in Lake Weyba, we
do not recommend relying on a Duty of Care Assessment alone. We are however, of the opinion that this
assessment provides good context for assessing the level of any ongoing heritage mitigation works.
7.1.2 Management Option B: CHMP
Where a Duty of Care assessment is not sufficient, the land-user will be fulfilling their Aboriginal Cultural
Heritage Duty of Care where it has reached an agreement with the Aboriginal party. Agreements can come in
many forms, and may be as short as or long as required. Generally, the under the legislation there are Cultural
Heritage Management Plan (CHMP) Agreements or approved CHMP’s under Part 7 of the ACHA. What
agreement is preferable depends on the nature of the project and the potential risk to Aboriginal cultural
heritage.
A typical Approved CHMP would cover the following topics:
a) survey procedures;
b) monitoring procedures;
c) management of known cultural heritage sites;
d) management of unexpected finds;
e) excavation procedures;
f) dispute resolution procedures;
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 30
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 33
g) use in independent experts;
h) cultural heritage inductions;
i) costs and remuneration;
j) workplace health and safety;
k) ownership of information;
l) failure to implement the CHMP by the Aboriginal party; and
m) termination of agreement.
Having regard to the nature of the archaeology in the region, any agreement would likely involve survey and
clearance works. It may also involve archaeological test excavations. However, given the past disturbance to
the site, these works should not be extensive.
7.2 Summary of Results: Historic Cultural Heritage
No historic cultural heritage constraints were identified during this assessment. It is unlikely that any significant
historic cultural heritage will impact on the development potential of the Project Area.
Future heritage assessment works as part of a development application may be required by Council. However,
it is anticipated that in the event that Council did require such works, they would be minimal.
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 31
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 34
8. RECOMMENDATIONS After reviewing the resources available for the Project Area, and having conducted a one day site inspection, the following recommendations are made: Recommendation 1: CHMP If the Project proceeds, it is recommended that the Proponent does not seek to rely solely on an assessment against the ACHA Duty of Care Guidelines, owing to the risk of the Project disturbing Aboriginal cultural heritage. It is recommended Proponent looks to develop a Cultural Heritage Management Plan following consultation with the Aboriginal Party. It is recommended that any negotiations are undertaken mindful of the low to moderate risk to cultural heritage, and that the outcomes are proportional to this risk. Recommendation 2: Negotiation Timeframes If the Proponent proceeds with the purchase of the Project Area, it is recommended that negotiations with the Aboriginal Party are entered into as soon as possible. There is generally an inherent flexibility in planning for large residential communities, which can see significant cultural heritage incorporated into the Project design with little or no loss of developable lands. This can only be achieved if potential constraints are known about early in the design and engineering process. Recommendation 3: Archaeological Investigations If the Proponent proceeds with consulting with the Aboriginal Party for the Project Area, it is recommended that any archaeological investigations are limited to areas that have a demonstrated potential to contain significance Aboriginal cultural heritage and that will be impacted by development. In the event that such evidence is not available, mechanical methods should be used that are as efficient as possible to ensure maximum coverage in the minimum amount of time. EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 32 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 35
Recommendation 4: Ongoing Technical Advice It is recommended that the Proponent enter any negotiations with the Aboriginal Party assisted by a qualified archaeologist, to provide independent advice on the reasonableness of any impact mitigation strategies proposed by the Aboriginal Party. EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 33 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 36
APPENDIX A : DATSIMA CHCU REGISTER SEARCH RESULTS EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 34 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 37
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 35 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 38
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 36 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 39
APPENDIX B: HISTORIC AERIALS
Figure 12: 1958 Historic Aerial
EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 37
Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 40
Figure 13: 1974 Historic Aerial EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 38 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 41
Figure 14: 1993 Historic Aerial EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 39 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Page 42
Figure 15: 2008 Historic Aerial EV.241 Noosa on Weyba: CH Due Diligence Assessment 40 Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services
Used in these records
Attachment 2- Cultural Heritage Due Diligence Assessment MCU12/0208Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 3.4 MB (large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take up to a minute.