Council archive · source document
Delegated Report - Code - Planning OPW17 0554 · OPW17/0554
Author Monkeith Kadhum Development Assessment APPLICATION DETAILS Application No. OPW17/0554 Applicant Altum Properties No 4 Pty Ltd TTE Proposal Operational Works - Carparking, Drainage Works, Frontage Work, Landscaping, Roadworks Properly Made Date 21 September 2017 Information Request Date 20 October 2017 Information Response Date 10 January 2018 Decision Due Date 15 February 2018 Report Completed Date 16 February 2018 Number of Submissions Not Applicable PROPERTY DETAILS Property Address 75 Resort Dr Noosa Heads Qld 4567 RP Description Lot 7 SP 178340 No related Land Land Area 42620 m² Existing Use of Land Vacant Site STATUTORY DETAILS SEQRP Designation Urban Footprint Locality Noosa Heads Zone Semi-Attached Housing Overlays Environmental Enhancement Area Low Potential Acid Sulphate Soils Landslide Hazard Areas Medium Bushfire Hazard Area Assessment Type Code PROPOSAL The application seeks approval for a Operational Works - Carparking, Drainage Works, Frontage Work, Landscaping, Roadworks. site details Background This OPW is to carry out development works and address compliance with the conditions of the Higher Order (MCU) Approval for 155 Multiple Dwelling Units and associated facilities initially approved by Council on 30 August 2007 and changed on 21 September 2017, Application No: 132005.1133.06. Site Description Sandy dune formation and steep land. Surrounding Land Uses Parkland and Nature Reserve and Refuge (Girraween Nature Reserve) assessment Instruments for Statutory Assessment Under the Planning Act 2016 the application must be assessed against each of the following statutory planning instruments to the extent they are relevant to the development: State Planning Policy; The Noosa Plan. The following codes from the Noosa Plan are applicable to this development: Engineering works codes Landscaping Code Water Sensitive Design Code Waste Management Code cONSULTATION Referrals The application was forwarded to the following internal Council officers: Environmental Officer - Landscaping Environmental Officer - Stormwater Quality Planning Officer – Compliance with MCU Environmental Health - Waste Management - WMP Assessment and comment The following issues have not been addressed by the applicant to allow Council issues a Development Permit for Operational Works: Stormwater Sensitive Design: The applicant has not demonstrated compliance with The Noosa Plan - Water sensitive Design Code and the conditions of the Higher Order Approval MCU (File No 132005.1133.5), particularly in relation to the following required Specific Outcomes and related MCU’s conditions: O1 Downstream ecosystems, properties and infrastructure are not adversely impacted by either changes to flow, water quality or ecosystem health caused by development Condition 49 of the MCU was provided to ensure this Specific Outcome was met. This was conditioned on the basis there was ample space to include measures that would achieve the required water quality targets or that proprietary devices could be included where space was constrained. The applicant has not explained in the application or the response to the information request (items 10-13 and 18-20) how the proposal achieves Condition 49. The MUSIC model which was provided in response to the issues raised gives water quality reduction targets for waters leaving the pipework of the basin and does not account for the nutrient losses entering the groundwater table. As the applicant highlighted, when using a combination of infiltration as well as maintaining flows to the lake system, this is not able to be modelled. As the best roughest estimate of pollutants leaving the system and therefore likely to be entering the groundwater, the MUSIC model was run by Council Officers. The results are shown in the table below. Sources A)With infiltration Considered B) Measurement of all waters leaving the basin Difference between A) and B) (i.e. waters to groundwater) Residual Load % Reductions Residual Load % Reductions Residual Load to groundwater % Reductions to groudwater compared to development input (assuming water to the lakes leaves the system completely) Total Flow (ML/yr) 59 31.3 47 47.8 19.1 16.5 32.68850525 Total Suspended Solids (kg/yr) 8620 4330 49.8 4840 43.9 510 94.08352668 Total Phosphorous (kg/yr) 19 9.75 48.8 12.3 35.5 2.55 86.57894737 Total Nitrogen (kg/yr) 1210 64.9 47.5 94.5 23.5 29.6 97.55371901 Whilst the applicant has not demonstrated pollutant reduction targets required under the state planning policy are met for all waters leaving the development, the applicant has satisfied condition 49 by the fact that, assuming waters entering the lake system have left the equation, State Planning Policy pollutant reduction targets of 80% reduction in total suspended solids, 60% reduction in total phosphorous, and 45% reduction in Total Nitrogen are met for the portion of waters entering the groundwater compared to the flow generated from the site. In relation to the waters entering the lake system, the applicant also did not provide all information required to confirm the runoff from the proposed development entering the lakes would not be worse than the existing lake water quality. Council officer interrogation of the MUSIC model showed that maximum Total Nitrogen, Total Phosphorous and Total Suspended Solids exceeded the 90th percentile for the existing water quality within the lake. This means that stress could be placed on the lake system from nutrient impulses from the new development in the extreme events. Additional information is therefore required by the developer to confirm why the Maximum values predicted by the MUSIC model, which exceed the 90th%ile values in the lake system should be accepted as not affecting the water quality of the lake system and unlikely to be considered responsible in the future for any eutrophication related incidents within the lake system. O8 Development design including density and scale provides adequate footprint to integrate all elements of stormwater quality and quantity treatment infrastructure including, where relevant, bio retention basin batters and maintenance access, without the need for retaining walls. Condition 49 required the stormwater treatment train to be confirmed prior to issue of operational works to ensure adequate footprint was available for all elements of eth design. As the application has not yet clearly demonstrated the development will not cause stress on the Noosa Springs lake system, the compliance with Specific Outcome O8 cannot yet be adequately confirmed. Additionally, the provided engineering drawings are missing the detail design drawings draining runoff from Blocks 20-22 and as with Specific Outcome O8 it is unclear whether additional treatment footprint areas are necessary to meet the required water quality. For this reason the application has not been able to be properly assessed and cannot be approved. It is recommended to either delay approval to seek the required information from the applicant, or refuse the application. Landscaping: The final submitted landscaping plans have missing elements and require some corrections particularly in relation to planting of koala food trees and local native species and landscaping details for the road reserve fronting Resort Drive. Waste Management Plan: The submitted Waste Management Plan for the site requires a number of corrections and amendments particularly in relation to references and assessment against Sunshine Coast Council Waste Management Code and other operational details. Civil Engineering: The submitted stormwater drainage plans require amendments in relation to achieving compliance with Condition 96 of the MCU approval regarding providing 2 metres of extensively landscaped buffer to Resort Drive on Blocks 7, 8 and 9. conclusion & reasons for decision The proposed development has not adequately demonstrated compliance with all the relevant requirements of the planning scheme and the conditions of the higher order MCU approval. As such a number of issues need to be addressed and additional information is required to enable the assessing officers to include the appropriate conditions and approved plans for the development works to be complied with. The application is therefore recommended for preliminary approval only. The report is provided in accordance with Section 63(5) of the Planning Act 2016. RECOMMENDATION With regard to Application No OPW17/0554 for a Development Permit for Operational Works - Carparking, Drainage Works, Frontage Work, Landscaping, Roadworks situated at 75 Resort Dr Noosa Heads Qld 4567 and described as Lot 7 SP 178340, it is recommended the application be granted a preliminary approval only in accordance with the following details for the Decision Notice: application details Application No: OPW17/0554 Street address: 75 Resort Dr Noosa Heads Qld 4567 Real property description: Lot 7 SP 178340 No related Land Planning Scheme: The Noosa Plan (3 July 2017) Decision details Council decided to issue the following type of approval: Preliminary Approval for Operational Works - Carparking, Drainage Works, Frontage Work, Landscaping, Roadworks (Precinct F – Stage 1) CURRENCY PERIOD of approval The currency period for this development approval is 2 years starting the day that this development approval takes effect. assessment manager conditions STORMWATER SENSITIVE DESIGN AND WATER QUALITY Prior to issue of a Development Permit for Operational Works, the Detailed Stormwater Quality Management Plan must be approved as per Condition 49 of the MCU (File No 132005.1133.5). The following items of the Detailed Stormwater Quality Management Plan require amendment prior to it receiving approval: Demonstrate how concentrations for Total Nitrogen, Total Phosphorous and Total Suspended Solids in all modelled rainfall events, including events where the concentrations exceed the 90th%ile values currently recorded in the Noosa Springs Lake System, would not be considered responsible or a contributor for adverse water quality impacts, such as a cyanobacterial outbreak, within the Noosa Springs Lake System. Include staging plans which demonstrate how the water quality treatment infrastructure proposed to be completed for each stage of the development will achieve the water quality required by Condition 49 in isolation of any other stages of developed occurring. As part of this response demonstrate whether or not Bio retention Basin 2 is necessary to meet the water quality requirements. Amend the monitoring to be undertaken for a minimum period of 5 years consistent with other approvals for the site. Include reference for monitoring and analysis methods to be consistent with the 2018 version of the Department of Environment and Science Monitoring and Sampling Manual. Amend the monitoring trigger rainfall flow event to capture the first flush events – i.e. 25mm rainfall events with at least one event being captured per season (i.e. summer, autumn, winter and spring). Refer to the Water By Design Maintenance and Rectification Guidelines. Include maintenance measures to ensure the infiltration capacity of the swales and bio retention basins, as proposed by the MUSIC model used to inform the Stormwater Management Plan submitted for approval, is retained for the lifetime of the development. The following plans require amendment prior to issue of a Development Permit for Operational Works: Update detail design drawings: C12–A1, C15-A1 of by Morgan Consulting and the relevant stormwater drainage longitudinal sections to demonstrate how the water from Blocks 20, 21 and 22 (i.e. stormwater structure 6/16 will enter the swale in a manner that will not cause any scour, and will receive treatment consistent with the MUSIC model used to inform the Stormwater Management Plan submitted for approval. Detail design plans must be amended, where required to include all water quality treatment devices required for Precinct F to achieve the required water quality out outcomes, as detailed to respond to Condition 1b and to be consistent with the Stormwater Management Plan approved pursuant to Condition 49 of the MCU (File No 132005.1133.5). This includes, but is not limited to, where bioretention basin 2 is needed for Precinct F to achieve the required water quality requirements in isolation of Precinct E2 being completed, amend drawing 16003/C19 to include the required bioretention system. All vertical interfaces with the filter media within Bioretention Systems must include measures, such as a 300mm wide geofabric border with 100mm cover as detailed on IPWEQAQ drawing WSUD-001 to prevent short circuiting and runnelling of water alongside the filter media. LANDSCAPING Prior to issue of a Development Permit for Operational Works, the following items need to be addressed: Revised landscape plans must be submitted and approved which remove any formal or informal pathways from the road reserve fronting Resort Drive, specifically those shown on drawing set CTS2 Parkridge Villas. Revised landscape plans must be submitted and approved which remove any structures, including stormwater infrastructures, in the required 2m setback to Resort Drive and to include landscaping, specifically relating to drawing set CTS2 Parkridge Villas. Landscaping plans must include the planting of koala food trees and local native species within the road reserve along Resort Drive. WASTE MANAGEMENT In compliance with Condition 70 of the MCU approval (File No 132005.1133.5) the Waste Management Plan for the site is required for approval prior to the issuing of a Development for Operational Works, the following amendments/corrections to the submitted Waste Management Plan by ttm are required: References to the Sunshine Coast Council Waste Management Code need to be corrected to the relevant Codes and Planning Policies of The Noosa Plan. (Section 3) Bin Servicing Indicates collection with a front lift vehicle. This is incorrect bins will be serviced with a rear lift vehicle and bins will be removed from the enclosures and returned by the Waste Contractor. Recycling is done weekly not twice weekly. (Section 4) On-going Management – indicates bins will be towed around the site by onsite managers. Council will not supply the attachments to enable the bins to be towed. This will be at property owners’ expense. (Appendix A – Section A.1- Refuse Calculations) Reference is made to the Sunshine Council Waste Planning Scheme policy, this need to be corrected and calculations be revised accordingly. CIVIL ENGINEERING Prior to issue of a Development Permit for Operational Works, Drawings 16003/C13–A2 and 16003/C14-A2 by Morgan Consulting require amendments to comply with Condition 96 of the MCU regarding providing 2 metres for extensive landscaped area rear Blocks 7, 8 and 9, amend submitted drawings as follow : Remove all proposed retaining walls and stormwater infrastructures (to the exception of stormwater pipeline connection to the existing gully pit) from 2 metres landscape setback on Blocks 7, 8 and 9. Amend all relevant stormwater drainage layout plans, stormwater longitudinal sections and drawings accordingly. referral agencies Not applicable. Advisory notes The following notes are included for guidance and information purposes only and do not form part of the assessment manager conditions: General Advisory Notes It must be noted that a Preliminary Approval for Operational Works does NOT permit commencement of any works. Further representation to change the Preliminary Approval to a Development Permit may be made within the appeal period. After the appeal period expires, the Preliminary Approval cannot be changed to a Development Permit, and a new development application for Operational Works will be required to be made, addressing the requirements of the Preliminary Approval. A Development Permit for Operational Works has not been issued because a number of outstanding issues need to be addressed. Council may favourably consider changing the Preliminary Approval to a Development Permit via the Negotiated Decision process, if the applicant satisfactorily complies with the conditions of this Preliminary Approval. property notes Not applicable. VARIATION approval Not applicable. further development permits required Not applicable. submissions Not applicable. RIGHTS OF APPEAL You are entitled to appeal against this decision. A copy of the relevant appeal provisions from the Planning Act 2016 is attached. During the appeal period, you as the applicant may suspend your appeal period and make written representations to Council about the conditions contained within the development approval. If Council agrees or agrees in part with the representations, a negotiated decision notice will be issued. Only one negotiated decision notice may be given. OTHER DETAILS If you wish to obtain more information about the decision, electronic copies are available on line at www.noosa.qld.gov.au or at Council Offices. [word/footer1.xml] Page 7 of 7 [word/header1.xml] 3 [word/header2.xml] DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT DELEGATED REPORT
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
Delegated Report - Code - Planning OPW17 0554Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 38 KB (small file)
- File type
- DOCX
No other editions are linked here.