Council archive · source document
Minor Change Report 51994.1292.04
APPLICATION FOR A MINOR CHANGE TO A DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL Author Development Planner, Tara Norley Development Assessment APPLICATION DETAILS Application No. 51994.1292.04 Development Approval Town Planning Consent Permit for Multiple dwelling of 9 units (TPC2655) Applicant Kris Chapman and Bridgitte Piscioneri Request Received On 25 January 2023 Report Reviewed By Lisa Pienaar – 23 March 2023 Decision Due Date 23 February 2023 PROPERTY DETAILS Property Address Pacific Outlook 8/47 Elanda St, Sunshine Beach 47 Elanda St, Sunshine Beach RP Description BUP102822 & Lot 8 BUP102822 Land Area 1540m2 (whole lot) Existing Use of Land Multiple dwelling (9 units) STATUTORY DETAILS SEQRP Designation Urban Footprint Zone High density residential Precinct Not applicable Local Area Plan Coastal Communities Overlays Landslide Hazard Moderate Hazard Area Assessment Type Minor Change to Town Planning Consent Permit PROPOSAL The applicant seeks approval to change to an existing Town Planning Consent Permit. The applicant proposes to remove the existing pergola structures located on the roof terrace of Unit 8 and construct a new pergola structure central to the roof terrace. The pergola structure is unroofed, with the applicant proposing a lightweight trellis with steel wiring and climbing plants ‘roofing’ the structure. It is noted that the applicant has provided a full suite of plans which includes internal renovations to the existing dwelling. The alterations will result in a 0.1m2 decrease in gross floor area (GFA) and a reduction in bedrooms (ie density) from three to two, and as such no further assessment of these alterations are required. It is noted that the alteration will result in a minor change to the facades of the dwelling. The locality and proposal plan are included below. Figure 1 – Locality Figure 2 – Subject Site Figure 3 – Floor Plan (Apartment Plan and Roof Terrace Plan) Figure 4 – Elevations (east and west) background Town Planning Consent Permit (TPC2655) - Multiple dwelling of 9 units was approved on 13 May 1994. A change to the original Development Approval (TPC 2655) for a Rooftop Pergola (Unit 7) was approved by Council on 23 February 2005. A Generally in Accordance letter was issued on 20 April 2017 for the 24m2 pergola structure located towards the road frontage on Unit 8. assessment Instruments for Statutory Assessment Under the Planning Act 2016 the application must be assessed against each of the following statutory planning instruments to the extent they are relevant to the development: State Planning Policy; South East Queensland Regional Plan; Planning Regulation 2017; and The Noosa Plan 2020. Statutory Process The applicant has requested to make a minor change to a development approval under s78 of the Planning Act 2016. An application for a minor change to a development approval can only be made in circumstances where a change would constitute a ‘minor change’. The proposed change to the development approval requested by the applicant is determined to constitute a minor change on the grounds that: the development would not result in substantially different development as the proposal does not include a new use or dramatically change the built form in terms of scale, bulk and appearance; the change does not include prohibited development; the change would not require the application to be referred to an additional referral agency or cause a referral agency to have regard to new matters prescribed by regulation; where the original application was code assessable, the change would not cause the application to become impact assessable. Statutory Instruments – Planning Scheme The following codes from the Noosa Plan 2020 are applicable to this development: High Density Residential Zone Code; Coastal Communities Local Plan Code; Dual Occupancy and Multiple Dwelling Code; Works Codes. Condition 2 2. The plans submitted for Building Approval are to comply with the following requirements:- The maximum building height is to be 12 metres from assumed natural ground level. The plans are to be supported by the submission of levels of floor and roof lines to confirm building height. The carparking and landscaping arrangements are to be amended at the frontage of the site to improve the landscaped appearance and shield the basement carpark wall. Specifically the car park designated as visitor parking No. 1 is to be deleted and replaced with mounded landscaping and natural ground level is to be maintained along the south-eastern boundary adjacent to the driveway. The building setbacks from the side boundaries are to provide satisfactory fire separation to the satisfaction of the Building Surveyor. In this regard, it is likely that amendment to the building is required. Applicant’s Request It is noted that the applicant has not requested to amend Condition 2 of the original approval. The applicant has requested to include a list of approved plans, as follows: Assessment of Request Roof Pergola The applicant is proposing to remove the two existing pergola structures located on the roof terrace of Unit 8, totalling 32.1m2 in area, and construct a new lightweight 26m2 trellis structure central to the roof terrace of Unit 8. The original Town Planning Consent included rooftop pergolas on the terrace areas of Unit 7, 8 and 9 with a combined total area of 10% of the roof area, being 44.5m2 maximum (refer to Figure 5). A Minor Change application approved a 12m2 pergola on Unit 7 (in lieu of the approved trellis under the original approval). It is noted that the approved plans indicated the pergola on Unit 8 was of a different size and shape than the original approved pergola and located in a different area, contrary to the original approval (refer to Figure 6). The combined total area of pergolas at this point in time was 28.8m2 (6.4%). A Generally in Accordance (GIA) letter was issued on 20 April 2017 for an additional 24m2 pergola structure located towards the road frontage on Unit 8 (refer to Figure 7). The combined total area of approved pergolas at this point in time was 52.8m2 (11.8%). The proposal would result in a total approved roofed/trellised area of 46.4m2 (10.4%). This is a reduction in the currently approved roofed structures, which totals 52.8m2 (11.8%) and is generally in accordance with the 10% coverage approved under the original approval. Figure 5: Original Approved Rooftop Pergolas Figure 6: Minor Change to Approved Rooftop Pergola located on Unit 7 Figure 7: Generally in Accordance to Approved Plan for Pergola located on Unit 8 It is noted that the assessment report for the original application listed the proposed building height as 12.3m, in lieu of the 12m limit required under the planning scheme at the time. Commentary in the report however indicated that the areas of non-compliance were architectural features only and as such not necessary, therefore, a condition was included in the report limiting the building height to 12m. A Minor Change approval issued in 2005 approved a redesign of the pergola on Unit 7. The planning report for the minor change indicated that the building was not constructed in accordance with the conditioned 12m height limit, and that the pergola would also not comply with the 12m limit. It is noted that the total height of the building indicated in the report (being 13.625m) was an estimate and is likely inaccurate, noting the actual height of the existing building and structures provided on the plans submitted with the application material. The GIA for the existing 24m2 pergola on Unit 8 did not approve the structure to be over height, however it is noted that the proposal plans provided with the minor change application material indicate the entire roof of the structure is in excess of 12m in height, contrary to Condition 2a of the approval (refer to Figure 7). Figure 7: Height Blanket indicating existing structures in excess of 12m height limit The minor change proposal includes the removal of the two existing over height structures on Unit 8 and the construction of a new over height trellis structure being located central to the Unit 8 roof terrace. Acceptable Outcome AO5.1 of the High density residential zone code requires a maximum 12m height for buildings and structures in this zone. As the trellis is in excess of 12m, being a maximum of 12.31m, the proposal requires assessment against corresponding Performance Outcome PO5 of the High density residential zone code, which states: Buildings and structures: are low rise and present a building height consistent with structures on adjoining and surrounding premises; are designed to provide an interesting streetscape and complement landform changes and landscapes; do not visually dominate the street or surrounding area; respect the scale of existing vegetation, maintaining a vegetated skyline; preserve the amenity of surrounding premises including privacy, views and access to sunlight; do not exceed three storeys, except for lots with frontage to Serenity Close, Noosa Heads which do not exceed four storeys. The proposed changes to the roof terrace result in a reduced appearance of bulk to the frontage due to the removal of the existing over height solid roofed pergola setback 2.47m from the front of the building, and proposed location of the wire trellis structure central to the roof terrace, setback 6.185m from the front of the building. The location of the trellis, central to the roof, will not visually dominate the street or surrounding area, and will not have any additional impacts on amenity of surrounding premises, due to the roof top terrace being an existing use of the space. In addition, the trellis is an open wire structure and as such will not result in an additional storey on the building. The proposal therefore complies with PO5 of the High density residential zone code. Figure 8: Height Blanket indicating proposed and existing structures in excess of 12m height limit Figure 9: Maximum Height of Trellis Structure Building Façades The proposal also includes alterations to the dwelling unit, which will result in changes to the external building facades, including ‘straightening up’ both facades. The existing approved dwelling has a curved wall on the western façade, and a staggered wall on the eastern façade (refer to Figure 10). The applicant is proposing to straighten these facades (refer to Figure 11), which will result in a 0.1m2 decrease in gross floor area (GFA) and a change to the appearance of the eastern and western elevations of the building. The change to the facades are minor and generally in accordance with the original approval and built form. Therefore, despite no changes being proposed to the other Units in the development, it is recommended the proposal plans be included as approved plans to reflect the changes to the exterior (elevations) of Unit 8. Figure 10: Existing Floor Plan Figure 11: Proposed Floor Plan It is therefore recommended that Condition 2 be changed to reflect the proposed building height and additional conditions be included regarding the maximum approved height of the trellis and changes to the approved plans. It is noted that the full suite of plans as provided by the applicant are not required to be included as approved plans. Condition Submission to and approval by Council of building plans in accordance with the Building Act, Council’s By-laws and Policies, the conditions of this approval and substantially in accordance with plans SB1 to SB5 submitted to Council on the 21st April 1994, and the Shire of Noosa Planning Scheme apart from where amendments are required or dispensations have been granted in conjunction with this approval. Applicant’s Request The applicant did not request to amend Condition 1. Assessment of Request An administrative amendment is required as it is noted that Condition 1 references ‘plans SB1 to SB5’. This notation is incorrect and should read ‘plans SP1 to SP5’ in accordance with the stamped approved plans. A change to Condition 1 is included in the recommendation to correct the error. cONSULTATION Referral Agencies Not applicable Internal Council Referrals Not applicable conclusion & reasons for decision The proposed development generally complies with the requirements of the planning scheme and does not raise any significant issues that cannot be addressed by reasonable and relevant conditions. The application is therefore recommended for approval. The report is provided in accordance with Section 63(5) of the Planning Act 2016. RECOMMENDATION With regard to Application No. 51994.1292.04, to make a minor change to an existing approval for Town Planning Consent Permit for Multiple dwelling of 9 units situated at Pacific Outlook 47 and 8/47 Elanda St, Sunshine Beach described as Lot 0 BUP 102822 and Lot 8 BUP 102822, Council on 23 March 2023 decided to: A. Approve the change. B. Amend Condition 2 to read as follows: 1. Submission to and approval by Council of building plans in accordance with the Building Act, Council’s By-laws and Policies, the conditions of this approval and substantially in accordance with plans SP1 to SP5 submitted to Council on the 21st April 1994, and the Shire of Noosa Planning Scheme apart from where amendments are required or dispensations have been granted in conjunction with this approval. 2. The plans submitted for Building Approval are to comply with the following requirements:- The maximum building height is to be 12 metres from assumed natural ground level, except where altered by Conditions 32 and 33 of this approval. The plans are to be supported by the submission of levels of floor and roof lines to confirm building height. The carparking and landscaping arrangements are to be amended at the frontage of the site to improve the landscaped appearance and shield the basement carpark wall. Specifically the car park designated as visitor parking No. 1 is to be deleted and replaced with mounded landscaping and natural ground level is to be maintained along the south-eastern boundary adjacent to the driveway. The building setbacks from the side boundaries are to provide satisfactory fire separation to the satisfaction of the Building Surveyor. In this regard, it is likely that amendment to the building is required. C. Add Conditions 32, 33 and 34 as follows: Development authorised by this approval must be undertaken generally in accordance with the Approved Plans listed in the table below. Plan No. Rev. Plan/Document Name Date 100.01 C Site Context - Proposed Site Plan, prepared by Minnow Studio Annotated by Council 07/03/2023 200.01 C Planning Concepts - Second Level Apartment Plan, prepared by Minnow Studio Annotated by Council 14/12/2022 200.02 D Planning Concepts - Roof Terrace Floor Plan, prepared by Minnow Studio Annotated by Council 07/03/2023 210.01 B Planning Concepts - Roof Plan, prepared by Minnow Studio Annotated by Council 07/03/2023 300.01 C Building Elevations - West Elevation (Street) - Proposed Elevations, prepared by Minnow Studio Annotated by Council 07/03/2023 300.02 C Building Elevations - North Elevation - Proposed Elevations, prepared by Minnow Studio Annotated by Council 07/03/2023 300.03 C Building Elevations - East Elevation - Proposed Elevations, prepared by Minnow Studio Annotated by Council 07/03/2023 300.04 C Building Elevations - South Elevation - Proposed Elevations, prepared by Minnow Studio Annotated by Council 07/03/2023 400.01 C Building Sections (Section A-A - Proposed Sections), prepared by Minnow Studio Annotated by Council 07/03/2023 Building Height The maximum height of the development must not exceed 12 metres above the ground level, except the ‘Open Trellis Structure with Stainless Steel Wires’ as shown on the approved plans, which may be a maximum of 12.31 metres above the ground level. Certification must be submitted to Council from a Registered Cadastral Surveyor (Qld) which certifies that Open Trellis Structure with Stainless Steel Wires structure does not exceed the maximum height requirement of this Decision Notice. [word/footer1.xml] Page 4 of 4 [word/header1.xml] 3 [Attachment: image10.png (image text)] ‘90.01 (GPA Diagramming - Second Level Pan (Exsting GFA Area 14.1222 Diagramming), prepared by Minnow Studio (090.02 (GPA Diagramming - Roof Terrace Pan (Busting GFA Area 14.1222 Diagramming), prepared by Minnow Studio (090.03 (GPA Diagramming - Second Level lan (Proposed GFA Area | 14.12.22 Diagramming), prepared by Minnow Studio 090.04 (GPA Diagramming Roof Terace Pan (Busting GFA Area 14.12.22 Diagramming), prepared by Minnow Studio 100.01 ‘Site Context - Proposed Site Plan, prepared by Minnow Studio | 14.12.22 200.01 ‘Planning Concepts - Second Level Apartment Plan, prepared | 14.12.22 bby Minnow Studio 200.02 ‘Planning Concepts - Root Terrace Foor Plan, prepared by 14.1222 Minnow Studio ‘300.01 ‘Building Elevations - West Elevation (Street) - Proposed 14.12.22 Elevations, prepared by Minnow Studio ‘300.02 ‘Building Elevations - North Elevation - Proposed Elevations, | 14.12.22 prepared by Minnow Studio ‘300.03 ‘Building Elevations - East Elevation - Proposed Elevations, 14.1222 prepared by Minnow Studio 300.04 ‘Building Elevations - South Elevation -Propased Elevations, | 14.12.22 ‘prepared by Minnow Studio ‘400.01 ‘Building Sections (Section AA - Proposed Sections), prepared | 14.12.22 bby Minnow Studio ‘500.01 ‘Ste Analysis - Height Plane Study (Existing Elements 14.1222 Exceeding 12m) prepared by Minnow Studio ‘500.02 ‘Site Analysis - Height Plane Study (Proposed Elements 14.1222 Exceeding 12m) prepared by Minnow Studio [Attachment: image11.png (image text)] 1000 Ps. PERGOLA STRUCTURE REA. SQM. OF AREA SON. ROOF. ABOVE 1500 HIGH NN NN G N S STAIRWELL ROOF HIGH) COMBINED AREA DIVIDING WALLS MAXIMUM 1500 HIGH UNT 8 UNIT 9 UNT 7 Be TAKEN TO El STORM WATER RUN St [Attachment: image12.png (image text)] gabled Bergola ZN DS 4™ pergola) fair g PLANS APPROVED srawatune call Loge DATE: wel to” unit 7 || unit 8 | unit 9 | | roof roof roof | —~—— _— Na ~ elanda street site plan 1:200 rpd lot404, rp817402 (bup 102822) [Attachment: image13.png (image text)] ‘|| ECUPSE OPENING ROOF Biot [Attachment: image14.png (image text)] a 4 “ ga oN Ue ee & ~ a os = ee N een ins. a oan ovane Fro netomat GROUND 2200060 F206 NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL RECORDS MADPING. >. EXCEEDING tim BUILDING HEIGHT MAXIMUM (NGL “2M > “ > # a Pe roe “ “ cal o- ns Tua G2 OUND TOPOGRADHY PRODUCED FROM NOOSA SHIRE, - leretaeetne aoe [Attachment: image15.png (image text)] "MAXIMUM (NGL =. BROBCED STRUCTURE REDRESENTS A Sr? "EXCEEDING tn BUILDING HEIGHT MARIMUM (NG =) [Attachment: image16.png (image text)] | 3n0 2470 OPERABLE / SOLID ROOF ! EXISTING INSET UNIT 08 [Attachment: image17.png (image text)] ENS BED WC BED 02 | (4 | FALL BED 03 peck | LIVING UNIT 08 TERRACE\ \ ) 5 | — | [Attachment: image3.png (image text)] MAIN BED [Attachment: image7.png (image text)] ‘We request that the following documentation is updated in the Approved Plans table as follows: Approved Plans 010.01 B__| Notes and Legends, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.12.22 010.02 B__ | Notes and Legends, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.12.22 020.01 B | Site Analysis, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.12.22 020.02 B__| Existing Building Fabric, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.12.22 020.03, B__| Site Analysis, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.12.22 [Attachment: image8.png (image text)] 20.04 Contemporary Response, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.1222 20.05 ‘Site Analysis, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.1222 0.01 ‘Site Context, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.1222 40.01 ‘General rangement - Basement Floor Plan, prepared by 14.1222 Minnow Studio 040.02 ‘General rangement - Ground Floor Plan, prepared by 14.1222 Minnow Studio (040.03 General rangement - First Foor Plan, prepared by Minnow | 14.12.22 ‘Studio. 40.04 ‘General rangement - Second Flor Plan, prepared by 14.1222 Minnow Studio (040.05 General rangement - Roof Terrace Plan, prepared by 14.1222 Minnow Studio 050.01 ‘Building Elevations - West Elevation (Existing Elevation), 14.1222 prepared by Minnow Studio [Attachment: image9.png (image text)] 20.04 | 8 | contemporary Response, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.1222 20.05 | 8 | site Anabysis, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.1222 ca0.01 |B | site Contex, prepared by Minnow Studio 14.1222 040.01 | 8 | General arrangement - Basement Floor Plan, prepared by 14.12.22 Minnow Studio 40.02 | 8 | Genera’ Arrangement - Ground Fioar Pan, prepared by 14.1222 Minnow Studio 040.03 | 8 | General Arangement- Fist Flor Plan, prepared by Minnow | 14.12.22 ‘Studio. 040.04 | 8 | Genera’ Arrangement - Second Floor Plan, prepared by 14.1222 Minnow Studio 040.05 | 8 | General Arangement - Roof Terrace Plan, prepared by 14.1222 Minnow Studio 050.01 | 8 | auitaing Elevations - West Elevation (Existing Elevation), 14.1222 prepared by Minnow Studio 050.02 | 8 | auitaing Elevations - North Elevation (Existing Elevation), 14.1222 prepared by Minnow Studio 050.03 | 8 | auiaing Elevations - East Elevation (Existing Elevation), 14.1222 ‘prepared by Minnow Studio 050.04 | 8 | auiaing Elevations - South Elevation (Existing Elevation), 14.12.22 prepared by Minnow Studio 060.01 | 8 | auitng Sections - Section 4A (Existing Sections), prepared | 14.12.22 bby Minnow Studio 070.01 | 8 | Demoltion Pan - Second Level Demoltion Pan, prepared by | 14.12.22 Minnow Studio 070.02 | 8 | Demoltion Pan - Roof Terace Demoltion Plan, prepared ty | 14.12.22 Minnow Studio 080.01 | 8 | Demoition Elevation - West Elevation (Street) prepared by | 14.12.22 Minnow Studio (080.02 | 8 | Demoltion Elevation - North Elevation, prepared by Minnow | 14.12.22 ‘studio (080.03 | 8 | Demoltion Elevation - East Elevation, prepared by Minnow 14.1222 ‘studio 080.04 | 8 | Demoition Elevation - South Elevation, prepared by Minnow | 14.12.22
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
Minor Change Report 51994.1292.04Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 5.5 MB (large file)
- File type
- DOCX
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take up to a minute.