Council archive · source document
Representations to SARA · MCU22/0118
Court Appeals & Dispute Resolution
Applications & Assessment
Due Diligence & Compliance
Project Management
General Development Advice
Friday, 21st July 2023
Our Ref: 18006
Council Ref: MCU22/0118
SARA Reference: 2208-30467 SRA
State Assessment Referral Agency
South East Queensland (North) regional office
PO Box 1129
Maroochydore QLD 4558
By Email: [email protected]
Attention: Danika Cowie, Principal Planning Officer
Dear Danika,
Development Application for a Material Change of Use for Short-term accommodation
and new lagoon pool at the “RACV Noosa Resort”, 94 and 142 Noosa Drive, Noosa
Heads, described as Lot 3 on SP126203, Lot 0 on SP203417 and Lot 203 on SP267424
The purpose of this letter is to provide advice about the changes being made to the
abovementioned proposal and make representations to the conditions of approval issued by
the State Assessment Referral Agency (SARA) on 7 February 2023.
Reference is made to a request for further information made by Noosa Council on 6 April 2023.
Further, to an onsite inspection held with Noosa Council officers and consultants engaged by
the applicant to discuss changes being made to the proposal and also to understand the
environmental values and the nature of the site more generally.
Pursuant to section 25 of the Development Assessment Rules, the applicant is making a minor
change to the proposal in response to the request for further information made by the Council.
The notice of change includes the following:
• Letter from Adamson Town Planning, including:
o Attachment 1A & 1B – Amended Proposal Plans;
o Attachment 2 – Concept Rehabilitation Plan;
o Attachment 3 – Further advice from Consult Arborist;
o Attachment 4A & 4B – Amended Stormwater Management Plan and further
advice from ADG;
Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
(ACN: 163 798 374 | ABN: 73 163 798 374)
M| 0437 754 420 Mail: PO Box 894, Cooroy QLD 4563
‘Noosa Boardroom’, 28 Eenie Creek Road, Noosaville QLD 4566
Email| [email protected] Web| www.adamsontownplanning.com.au
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 7 pages
Page 2
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning
advice”
o Attachment 5 – Further advice from Gondwana Ecology;
o Attachment 6 – Further advice from Ecoteam;
o Attachment 7A & 7B – Updated Bushfire Hazard Assessment and Mitigation
Plan and further advice from Rob Friend and Associates; and
o Attachment 8 – Construction Methodology by Aspect Architects.
For simplicity herein, the references to the attachments remain the same.
A summary of the key changes is provided below:
Cabin 1:
• The number of cabins has been reduced by one (1) to provide for 15 cabins in eight (8)
buildings;
• Cabin 1 has been relocated to above the carpark which reduces the overall
development footprint and the impact on the site;
• The location of Cabin 1 means that no development is now proposed within the
riparian area towards the northwest with no bushfire mitigation measures, which also
allows for the full rehabilitation of this area;
• A minimal amount of the development now encroaches within the Environmental and
Management Conservation Zone towards the northwest where the small area of
riparian vegetation is located; and
• The bio-detention basin has been resized and shaped to better service the
development following the onsite conductivity tests undertaken and is located within
the existing cleared area beside Cabin 1 and at the end of the carpark.
Cabins 02 – 07:
• These cabins have been realigned where possible to allow for more tree retention with
confirmation also provided about the retention of some trees close to the cabins,
following an analysis by the arborist and project architect, with the cabin locations
having been surveyed and pegged onsite.
Cabins 8 & 9:
• Cabins 8 & 9 have been separated from Cabins 10 & 11 to allow for better integration
onsite and reduce the appearance of building bulk near the Noosa Drive frontage;
• The separation of these cabins also allows for an overall reduction in the amount of
elevated timber boardwalk and allows for the retention of two (2) additional trees; and
• The removal of the boardwalk from within the 6m building setback area, which
provides for a greater area near the frontage that can be rehabilitated with dense
vegetation to screen/buffer the development and maintain a vegetated corridor along
Noosa Drive.
2|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort Short-term accommodation
Page 3
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning
advice”
Figure 1 – Site Plan Tree Retention/Removal
A new Concept Rehabilitation Plan (CRP) has been prepared by Dr Watson (in consultation
with the other experts) (refer Attachment 2). The CRP provides for five (5) planting zones as
shown. The planting pallet has also been carefully considered for the following zones:
• Zone 1 – Wetland Rehabilitation (northwest), with no fire mitigation now required
within this area;
• Zone 2 – Rehabilitated Screen across the frontage adjoining Noosa Drive;
• Zone 3 – Detention Basin with suitable species provided;
• Zone 4 – Bushfire (APZ) Management, which provides for weed control, ground covers
and low shrubs with the existing mature vegetation able to be maintained;
• Zone 5 – Balance Rehabilitation Area providing for intense weed control, dense ground
covers amongst the elevated cabins and boardwalk with interplanting allowed with
smooth bark koala and other tree species.
In summary, the changes made to the proposal are in direct response to the issues raised in
the request for further information by Noosa Council. Following further deliberations with the
ecology, koala, bushfire and arborist experts, the applicant has reduced the number of units
being proposed and relocated Unit 1 to above the carpark. This change reduces the overall
impact on the site, in particular, near the riparian area to the northwest, with no bushfire
mitigation now required in this area.
3|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort Short-term accommodation
Page 4
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning
advice”
The onsite inspection with the cabin locations surveyed has also resulted in more confidence
about the trees that can be retained. Overall, there is a net increase in the number of koala
habitat trees being retained on the site and less site disturbance with ongoing tree and weed
management required, with the site to be rehabilitated in accordance with the CRP.
With respect to the issue of vegetation removal, Dr Watson has addressed this issue in the
further advice provided (Attachment 5). The tree survey and the location of the trees with
respect to the cabins have been checked on site. It is noted that part of the development,
including part of Cabin 1, part of the carpark and the existing access, are located within the
existing RACV Resort (Lot 203), which is already developed and assists in reducing the overall
impact of the development within Lot 3.
In summary, Dr Watson has confirmed that 242 native trees have been surveyed on site with
the following being retained and removed:
• 160 will be retained (previously this was 142);
• 71 will be removed (previously this was 89); and
• 11 are proposed to be retained and will require arborist review and advice during
construction, which are labelled TBC (previously this was 20).
With respect to the trees that have been surveyed, 150 are, by “State” definition koala trees,
with:
• 117 to be retained (previously this was 110);
• 27 will be removed (previously this was 44); and
• six (6) are proposed to be retained and will require arborist review and advice during
construction (previously this was 10).
Dr Watson has undertaken a closer analysis of the 71 native trees (of which 27 are defined as
koala trees) that will be removed and advises that of the 27 koala trees to be removed:
• 11 are eucalyptus and 16 are paperbarks;
• Of the 16 paperbarks, at least five have been planted (as part of the resort development
to the north); and
• 10 of the swamp mahogany (E.robusta) described as being in poor condition, nearly
dead or vine engulfed – meaning only one of the trees to be removed is in reasonable
condition.
Consequently, despite the number of trees being removed for the development, there is only
one (1) relatively healthy swamp mahogany, and 11 naturally occurring paperbarks, that will
be removed.
An enormous amount of ground truthing work has been undertaken to provide the
development proposal in its current form. There is a clear intent to retain the vegetation on
the site, in order to provide a different visitor accommodation experience. This intent can be
achieved because of the elevated, lightweight and separated built form being integrated within
the existing vegetation.
4|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort Short-term accommodation
Page 5
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning
advice”
As stated by Dr Watson, the amended layout, with a smaller building footprint and realigned
structures, has increased tree retention (including koala trees), has reduced the number of
trees to be confirmed by the arborist (less uncertainty) and increased the overall greenspace
and rehabilitation opportunities1. The proposed rehabilitation would also see the removal of
the invasive Frangipani vine, which has engulfed the site and the E.robusta trees, providing
little value to koalas in its current state, and provides for replanting koala feed trees (listed in
Council’s PSP Landscaping)2.
The approval by SARA provides for an environmental covenant to be placed throughout the
site, which is to be amended to reflect the latest proposal plans. As explained by Dr Watson,
the amended layout retains more trees than the State approved development plus allows for
more areas to be rehabilitated with less bushfire mitigation required. The SARA approval also
provides for koala signage to be erected in Noosa Drive and Leslie Drive, as shown on the
Indicative Koala Signage Plan, this being an initiative undertaken by the applicant (refer
Attachment 1B).
The koala issue has been carefully considered by Dr Ellis, who has provided further advice as
Attachment 6. Dr Ellis advises in his conclusion, that a “long term” view is required, which
must evaluate the long-term prognosis and scenarios for this site. Dr Ellis advises that the
current trajectory is toward decreased koala value on site through the loss of food resources
and impeded movement across the ground. It is unlikely that, without intervention, the site
will provide habitat resources to koalas in the long term. Dr Ellis advises that various
interventions could reverse this outcome, and the current proposal has been considered
accordingly. As stated by the arborist, it is proposed that trees be managed where close to
buildings and not removed (Attachment 3).
Dr Ellis states … there are several conditions around tree retention, ground cover and fencing
that could improve safety and facility on site for koalas, compared with the long-term projected
outcomes under the status quo, which lead me to judge that, on balance, adverse impacts will
not flow from the current proposal. Retention of significant food resources, tree and site
management that leads to improved tree health, an open planning of the structures with raised
boardwalks to facilitate koala travel (combined with prohibition on pet access) are objectives met
in the current proposal. The impact of removing the small number of food trees (many of which
are in poor condition) can be negated through replanting and with the nourishment of existing
trees on the site, whilst opportunities for travel by koalas should be improved with the
management of ground cover.3
Given the advice provided by Dr Watson and Dr Ellis, the proposed development has been
designed and will be constructed and operated to protect and enhance koala habitat and will
reduce the known adverse impacts (the invasive Frangipani vine). Further, will assist in the
1
Ecology advice by Gondwana Ecology, dated 4 July 2023, page 4
2
Further ecology advice from Gondwana Ecology, page 7
3
Further koala advice from Ecoteam, pages 6 & 7
5|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort Short-term accommodation
Page 6
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning
advice”
survival of any koala in the locality without increasing the threats, and provides for the safe
movement of koala through the site, in the long term.
Amended Conditions
Under the approval granted by SARA, the following conditions require amendment:
Condition 1:
Clearing is limited to the removal of 54 non-juvenile koala habitat trees identified as ‘Remove’
and ‘TBC’ on plan titled Site Plan – (TPZ) Tree Retention / Removal, prepared by Aspect, dated
15/11/2022, Drawing reference 21-0910_A10-08, Revision E.
Amended condition:
Clearing is limited to the removal of 33 non-juvenile koala habitat trees identified as ‘Remove’
and ‘TBC’ on plan titled Site Plan – (TPZ) Tree Retention / Removal, prepared by Aspect, dated
30/06/23, Drawing reference 21-0910_A10-08, Revision K.
Condition 2:
To be amended as required by SARA to show the environmental covenant around the cabins
in red over the Site Plan, prepared by Aspect, dated 30/06/23, Drawing number 21-0910_A10-
01, Revision I.
Condition 3:
While the front cover of the Koala Management Plan, dated 27 January 2023, is now different
to the proposal plans, it is suggested that no changes are required to the Koala Management
Plan, being more of a generic document; however, the applicant is happy to make any minor
changes should that be required.
Condition 4:
No change is needed to this condition.
Condition 5:
Condition 5, states:
Deliver an environmental offset in accordance with the Environmental Offsets Act 2014 to
counterbalance the significant residual impacts on the matter of state environmental significance
being 54 non-juvenile koala habitat trees.
6|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort Short-term accommodation
Page 7
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning
advice”
Amended condition 5:
Deliver an environmental offset in accordance with the Environmental Offsets Act 2014 to
counterbalance the significant residual impacts on the matter of state environmental
significance being 33 non-juvenile koala habitat trees.
Condition 6:
Condition 6, states:
Provide Koala friendly measures in accordance with the Koala Sensitive Design Guideline,
prepared by the Department of Environment and Science and dated December 2022, which is to
include lit and unlit koala advisory signage in accordance with the plan titled Indicative Koala
Signage Plan, prepared by Aspect, dated 01/02/2023, Drawing No. 21-0910_A10-12,
Revision A.
Amended Condition 6:
Provide Koala friendly measures in accordance with the Koala Sensitive Design Guideline,
prepared by the Department of Environment and Science and dated December 2022, which is
to include lit and unlit koala advisory signage in accordance with the plan titled Indicative
Koala Signage Plan, prepared by Aspect, dated 30/06/2023, Drawing No. 21-0910_A10-12,
Revision C.
Conditions 6, 7, 8 & 9:
No changes required.
Summary
In summary, the changes being made to the development proposal have resulted in the
deletion of one (1) cabin, the relocation of Cabin 1 to above the carpark, which has reduced
the development footprint within the site. Other changes made to the layout result in a net
gain of koala trees within the site. This includes the bushfire mitigation within the asset
protection zone (APZ) located further to the southeast and outside of the riparian area to the
northwest. Overall, the changes made have resulted in a reduction in the number of trees to
be removed and the site is also to be rehabilitated in accordance with the Concept
Rehabilitation Plan, which has been prepared with the collective advice of the experts engaged.
The advice provided by the ecology, koala, arborist, bushfire, and stormwater experts is
consistent. Overall, there is an improved ecological outcome for the site. Consequently, it is
requested that SARA amend the referral agency approval response to be consistent with the
amended proposal.
7|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort Short-term accommodation
Page 8
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning
advice”
The Council has been requested not to decide the application until the representations to the
conditions of approval have been considered by SARA and an amended referral agency
response is provided. At this stage, the decision making period has been extended by
agreement to 21 September 2023.
Please advise if you have any concerns about the changes made or about amending the
conditions of approval as requested.
Should you require further information please contact me.
Yours faithfully
Shane Adamson
Shane Adamson (BEngTech, GDURP, MPIA, MQELA)
Town Planning Specialist
Director - Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
8|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort Short-term accommodation
Used in these records
Representations to SARA.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 488 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.