Council archive · source document
Part 10 of 37 Appendix 8 - Queensland Coastal Plan Assessment MCU12/0208
Plans and drawings: the text below has words only, no drawings.
Very large file (26.4 MB): may take a few minutes to open.
Place barcode here
I!i~~iI n"j fl~iE
80602697
THIS IS THE NEXT PART OF A
MULTIPLE PART RECORD
Part \ 0Of .3J
Application number: Mc’0 \’2 (020~
-
C:\Documents and Settings\eje\Desktop\Multi Part Record Cover Sheet NEXT PART
(3).doc
I
-
De’
/,..
’-
, -
r ,
.
I’ .
,
I
, r I I ~ .- M i ’" ",I .,._., \... .t. ~r
20 D C 2012
r ’: ,..~ -
"\
r I
I
~x ~.6.1-... ...~........I R:
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 47 pages
Page 2
.~
Prepared for
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann
15 October 2012
<.f)CElrdn
Shaping the Future
~
Page 3
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
Cardno (Qld)Pty Ltd
ABN 57051 074992
Level 11 Green Square North Tower
515 St Paul’s Terrace
Fortitude Valley Qld 4006
Locked Bag 4006 Fortitude Valley
Queensland 4006 Australia
Telephone: 07 3369 9822
Facsimile: 07 3369 9722
International: +61 733699822
[email protected]
www.cardno.com.au
Document Information
Prepared for Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann
Project Name Noosa on Weyba
File Reference \\Bnesan01 p\wrc$\51 01-19-03\wp\R2v2 QCP report\QCP Assessment v2.docx
Job Reference 5101-19-03
Date 15 October 2012
Document Control
Version Date Author Author Reviewer Reviewer
Initials Initials
1 5 October 2012 Nadia Guterres Trevor Johnson
2 15 October 2012 Nadia Guterres Trevor Johnson
"@2012 Cardno All Rights Reserved. Copyright in the whole and every part of this document belongs to Cardno
and may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or form or in or on
any media to any person without the prior written consent of Card no."
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page ii
Page 4
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
Table of Contents
1 Introduction 1
2 Site Description 2
3 QCP Mapping 3
4 Lake Weyba Shoreline Erosion 4
4.1 Summary 4
5 Flood Modelling 5
5.1 Summary 5
5.2 Flood Modelling 5
5.2.1 Available Models 5
5.2.2 TUFLOW Model 5
5.2.3 TUFLOW Runs 6
5.2.4 TUFLOW Results 7
6 Tidal Inundation 8
6.1 Tailwater Condition 8
6.2 Results 8
6.3 Scour Velocities 9
7 QCP Storm-tide Hazard 10
7.1 Summary 10
7.2 Proposed Development 10
7.3 Coastal Hazard Risk Assessment 11
8 Draft Coastal Protection State Planning Regulatory Provision 12
8.1 Summary 12
8.2 Erosion Prone Areas 12
8.3 Storm-tide Hazard 12
9 CONCLUSION 13
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page iii
Page 5
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
Images
Image 1 Climate Change HAT at Munna Point 8
Image 2 Resultant 2100 HAT Level in Lake Weyba 9
Tables
Table 5-1 TUFLOW Model Runs 6
Figures
Figure 1 100 Year ARI Existing Case Peak Flood Levels
Figure 2 Revised Erosion Prone Area
Figure 3 Medium and High Coastal Hazard Areas
Appendi s
Appendix A Masterplan of Development
Appendix B QCP Hazard Mapping
Appendix C Lake Weyba Tidal Gauge Record
Appendix D Shoreline Erosion AssessmenT
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page iv
Page 6
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
1 Introduction
The subject site encompasses the following lots:
The J & K Hofmann land:
. Lot 7 on RP46782 1.99 ha
. Lot 2 on RP160983 93.1 ha
. Lot 2 on SP179590 12.5 ha
. Lot 53 on SP163571 110.0 ha
The Northbrook Pty Ltd land:
. Lot 1667 on M3772 44.4 ha
. Lot 11 on RP893393 40.7 ha
. Lot 12 on RP893393 0.61 ha
It is proposed to develop around 19 percent of this site for residential purposes, with 4 percent of the site
used as parks and lake buffer zone and the remaining 77 percent of site dedicated as greenspace and
conservation areas. The proposed master plan for the development is shown in Appendix A. The combined
development is known as Noosa on Weyba.
According to information provided by the Department of Environment and Heritage Protection (DEHP),the
site is in the coastal zone as defined within the Queensland Coastal Plan 2012 (QCP),and is also located
entirely within the local Coastal Management District. The Department’s website designates parts of the site
as being affected by both storm-tide inundation and regular tidal inundation by year 2100. The site is
mapped as being affected by two types of coastal hazard; erosion prone areas and storm-tide inundation
areas. The QCP mapping is provided in Appendix B.
On the 8th of October 2012 the Draft Coastal Protection State Planning Regulatory Provision (DSPRP)was
released. The implications of this document are also discussed in this report.
The purpose of this report is to review this mapping and summarise the development potential of the site in
regards to the QCP. To this purpose the following analysis has been conducted:
. SBEACH shoreline erosion analysis of Lake Weyba, based on the requirements outlined in the QCP;
.
Hydrodynamic analysis of the area utilising TUFLOW to determine the extent of future tidal influence;
and
.
Hydrodynamic analysis of the area utilising TUFLOW to determine the flood levels produced by local
stormwater runoff.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 1
Page 7
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
2 Site Description
The J & K Hofmann land is bounded by Hollett Road to the south, Eenie Creek to the north and it includes
lots on both sides of Walter Hay Drive. Minor tributaries of Eenie Creek run through or adjacent to these lots.
The site is currently used for rural purposes and the western parts of the site are densely vegetated, while
sections to the east have been cleared for grazing purposes. The site is relatively steeply sloped, and the
tributaries are well defined, except for the area just to the north of Hollett Road where the ground is fairly flat
and flows disperse over a wide area.
The Northbrook Pty Ltd land is located to the south-east of the J & K Hofmann land and is bounded by
Tidswell Road to the west and Lake Weyba to the east. The site is currently used for rural purposes. The
majority of Lot 11 has been cleared with sections of remnant vegetation. A tributary of Lake Weyba,
historically known as Keyser Creek, is located within Lot 11, and drains from south to north. The catchment
of Keyser Creek within Lot 11 is relatively flat and low lying with levels ranging from 0.7 to 1.1 mAHD. A
track located along the northern boundary of the site currently acts as a bund controlling outflows. It has a
minimum level of 1.14 mAHD. At the southern boundary of the site the levels of Keyser Creek rise sharply.
The western section of Lot 11 is relatively flat with a grade of around 1 percent and levels from 0.7 to 6.5
mAHD. The central section of Lot 11 drains towards Keyser Creek and is generally more steeply sloped with
levels up to 14.5 mAHD. The eastern section of Lot 11 drains towards Lake Weyba and is generally steeply
sloped with a grade of around 5 percent, with natural surface levels varying from 0.5 to 14.5 mAHD.
Lake Weyba is connected to Noosa River via Weyba Creek.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 2
Page 8
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
3 QCP Mapping
Only the frontage of the site to Lake Weyba is currently subject to tidal influence. In the QCP Coastal
Hazards Guideline, paragraph 5.50 states that Highest Astronomic Tide (HAT)is defined according to the
Queensland Tide Tables in the relevant year. The current Tide Tables define a HAT level of 0.68 m AHD for
Munna Point, which is the closest permanent tidal gauge to Lake Weyba. Based on these levels, the
western drainage line is not currently prone to tidal influence.
The QCP hazard mapping (refer Appendix B) is based on the following assumptions:
. Erosion Prone Area:
o The site is not currently subject to a development right. Consequently, there is a
requirement to make allowance for climate-induced sea level rise of 0.8 m by 2100.
o The extent of tidal inundation by 2100 will therefore be determined by current Highest
Astronomical Tide (HAT)plus 0.8 m
. Storm-tide Hazard Area;
o In South East Queensland a default value of HAT plus 1.5m is used to define the extent of
storm-tide hazard areas in the absence of a more detailed assessment.
Based on the Munna Point level information, the default QCP erosion prone level will be 1.48 mAHD and the
default QCP storm-tide hazard level is 2.18 mAHD. Based on these levels, the western drainage line will
become tidally affected at some stage in the future if predicted sea level rises occur.
However, HAT in Lake Weyba itself was determined to be 0.32 mAHD by the Department of Maritime Safety
Queensland in 1990. This report is attached as Appendix C. This level has not been referenced in the
relevant QCP investigations.
The QCP deems all areas subject to tidal inundation by 2100 as being erosion prone. While this may be an
acceptable position for general determinations, it will significantly overestimate the actual extent of erosion
prone areas in situations where there is little wave energy in the environment. This issue is explored in the
following sections.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 3
Page 9
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
4 Lake Weyba Shoreline Erosion
4.1 Summary
The QCP erosion prone area mapping showed a bulge along the shoreline of Lake Weyba that does not
relate to the surveyed ground levels. It seems likely that the 40 metre buffer from the extent of HAT used an
erroneous level based on Lidar data.
To determine the actual extent of shoreline erosion along Lake Weyba an assessment was carried out using
SBEACH based on the requirements outlined in the QCP Coastal Hazards Guideline (2012). This report is
attached as Appendix D. Due to the shallow depths of Lake Weyba and the relatively low fetch distances for
easterly winds, the calculated shoreline erosion due to wind generated waves is contained well within the
proposed Lake Buffer Zones for the present day, 2050 and 2100 scenarios. The revised erosion hazard
extents compared to the current QCP mapping are provided in Appendix D.
The proposed Lake Buffer Zone provided along Lake Weyba is 40 metres in width, with an additional 10
metres dedicated to a storm water treatment zone. The buildings will then be set back a further 10 metres.
Therefore a 60 metre total buffer will typically be provided along the shoreline of Lake Weyba.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 4
Page 10
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
5 Flood Modelling
5.1 Summary
Flood modelling has been conducted for the site to determine the local and regional peak flood levels and to
help determine the potential impact of development. For this erosion area analysis the flood model was
used to run a tidal simulation based on the 2100 HAT to determine the actual future tidal inundation extents.
A summary of the flood model set up is provided in this section, for further details please refer to the Cardno
Flood Study (October,2012).
5.2 Flood Modelling
5.2.1 Available Models
Regional flood modelling of the Noosa River has previously been conducted by Sunshine Coast Regional
Council using the Mike 11 computer program. The results of this study are outlined in the Noosa River Flood
Study (JWP,1995). This modelling was recently updated by Council to use Version 2010 of Mike 11. This
modelling does not include the local tributaries, including Eenie Creek and Keyser Creek, and therefore was
not of sufficient quality to determine flood levels throughout the site. It is noted that the regional flood
modelling does account for the impact of storm-tide. The regional flood levels in Lake Weyba are:
. 100 year ARI = 2.09 mAHD
. 20 year ARI = 1.53 mAHD
. 10 year ARI = 1.45 mAHD
The peak 100 year ARI regional flood level in Lake Weyba was determined as a combination of 100 year
ARI inflows and the 20 year ARI storm surge (per comm. Geoff Newell, SCRC). An equivalent 100 year ARI
event is considered to be the 20 year ARI inflows and the 100 year ARI storm surge. The maximum of these
two events was used to determine the 100 year ARI regional flood levels in Noosa River. The 30 hour storm
was the peak regional event for Lake Weyba.
The storm-tide levels used as tailwater conditions in the Noosa River Flood Study (JWP,1995)were:
. 100 year ARI = 1.8 mAHD
. 20 year ARI = 1.5 mAHD
A detailed storm tide study of the Noosa River has recently been conducted for Sunshine Coast Regional
Council (SCRC). However, at the time of writing the final results of this analysis were not available and the
report has yet to undergo peer review.
5.2.2 TUFLOW Model
The flow patterns and interactions between the different creeks and Lake Weyba are quite complex and it
was determined the software TUFLOW should be used for analytical purposes. TUFLOW is a two and one
dimensional hydrodynamic modelling system. The model extent included Eenie Creek and its tributaries,
Keyser Creek, Lake Weyba and Weyba Creek. Lake Weyba and Weyba Creek were modelled in 1 Dusing
the Mike 11 cross-sections from the regional flood model, and trimmed where necessary to avoid a double
up of storage. The model extended downstream to section Weyba 6.5, which is located at Weyba Road.
For the remaining areas, Aerial Laser Survey (ALS) obtained from the Department of Environment and
Heritage Protection (DEHP),formerly DERM, was used to develop the Digital Terrain Model (DTM).
The TUFLOW model was validated against the February 2012 flood event which resulted in significant
inundation of properties along Lake Entrance Boulevard.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 5
Page 11
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
5.2.3 TUFLOW Runs
A summary of flood scenarios modelled in TUFLOW as part of the flood study are provided in Table 5-1.
The peak local storm events were the 90 minute and 24 hour storms.
Table 5-1 TUFLOW Model Runs
Model Run Resultant
Local Inflows Tailwater Level
Number ARI (y)
Local Events -
MHWS
1 100 year ARI MHWS 100
2 50 year ARI MHWS 50
3 20 year ARI MHWS 20
4 10 year ARI MHWS 10
5 5 year ARI MHWS 5
6 2 year ARI MHWS 2
7 1 year ARI MHWS 1
100 Year ARI Local Event -
Storm Surge
8 20 year ARI 1.8 mAHD -
100 year storm surge 100
9 100 year ARI 1.5 mAHD -
20 year storm surge 100
Regional Events
10 100 year, 30 hour Regional 100 year, 30 hour 100
11 50 year, 30 hour Regional 50 year, 30 hour 50
12 20 year, 30 hour Regional 20 year, 30 hour 20
13 10 year, 30 hour Regional 10 year, 30 hour 10
14 5 year, 30 hour Regional 5 year, 30 hour 5
15 2 year, 30 hour Regional 2 year, 30 hour 2
Probable Maximum Flood
16 PMF 2.68 mAHD -
1000 year Storm Surge PMF
Climate Change
17 20 year ARI (+20%) 2.6 mAHD -
100 year storm surge + 0.8m 100 (CC)
18 100 year ARI (+20%) 2.3 mAHD -
20 year storm surge + 0.8m 100 (CC)
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 6
Page 12
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
For the climate change scenarios the storm surge tailwater level was increased by 0.8 metres and the rainfall
intensity was increased by 20 percent, as specified by the Inland Flooding Study (DERM,2010) for the
planning year 2090.
5.2.4 TUFLOW Results
The 100 year ARI extent of inundation is shown in Figure 1. The 100 year ARI extent of inundation covers a
significant portion of the Northbrook site, particularly the western drainage channel which encompasses
Keyser Creek. The existing case 100 year ARI local peak flood levels within Keyser Creek in Lot 11 range
from 2.13 to 2.23 mAHD. With the 20 year ARI storm surge as a tailwater condition the 100 year ARI peak
water level is between 2.19 and 2.26 mAHD. The 100 year ARI regional peak flood levels range from 2.16
and 2.18 mAHD in this area. These levels are similar to the default QCP storm-tide level of 2.18 mAHD
defined for the site. With the impact of climate change the future 100 year ARI water levels in this area are
predicted to increase to approximately 2.79 mAHD in 2100. The QCP coastal hazard areas are intended to
account for the future impacts of climate change, and therefore the default QCP storm-tide level could be
argued to be too low. However as detailed storm tide modelling of the Noosa River is not yet available from
SCRC the default QCP value of 2.18 mAHD is considered reasonable to use in the interim to define the
coastal hazard area.
Development of the site will use the higher climate change flood levels as calculated by the TUFLOW
modelling to define the minimum lot and floor levels required.
The 100 year ARI peak flood levels within Eenie Creek and its tributaries are also a result of the 100 year
ARI local inflows combined with the 20 year ARI storm surge level. This demonstrates that the local storm
coupled with storm surge results in the peak flood levels throughout the site.
The proposed development within the Hofmann sitegenerally does not extend into areas which are
inundated in the 100 year ARI event, even with the impact of climate change. Only three lots will require
minimal filling. These lots are located in an area that has existing levels of around 2.5 mAHD and above.
This portion of the site is not subject to the coastal hazard categories defined by the Queensland Coastal
Plan (2012).
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 7
Page 13
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
6 Tidal Inundation
6.1 Tailwater Condition
The TUFLOW model set up for the flooding analysis of the site was used to determine the future tidal
inundation extent. As noted above, the QCP deems all areas subject to future tidal inundation as being
erosion prone, which is a position which we do not agreed with in this case. The tailwater condition was set
as a sinusoidal tide, and scaled to match the 2100 HAT level of 1.48 mAHD at Munna Point. The resultant
tailwater condition is shown below in Image 1. The initial water level was set at 0.8 mAHD, which is the
future mean sea level.
1.600
1.400
/"\
1.200
/ \ _,--.....
1.000
/ \ I \
\
C
I
<{
.s0.800
V \
/ l\
/
>
Q)
_J
0.600
\ ’" / /
"--"’"
0.400
\ /
’-./
0.200
0.000
o Time (days)
Image 1 Climate Change HAT at Munna Point
6.2 Results
The resultant HAT level in Lake Weyba was 1.13 mAHD, due to attenuation provided within the lake and
creeks. This level is similar to the current HAT level of Lake Weyba of 0.32 mAHD plus 0.8 metres (i.e. 1.12
mAHD), and is therefore considered a reasonable prediction of the 2100 HAT level in Lake Weyba.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 8
Page 14
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
1.6
-
/"’" ...........
1.4
1.2
/ ~
’\..
/ ~~ r-----_ ~ -
----
\
:>:
..:
..s 0.8
I~~ ~
r------
~
~
0.6
~ /
~ .......
/
0.4
.........._ -
V
0.2
o
o 4 8 10 12
Time (hours’
-Lake Weyba -
Tailwater
Image 2 Resultant 2100 HAT Level in Lake Weyba
The extensive vegetation within Keyser Creek will provide significant further attenuation of tidal flows. The
resultant HAT peak water level at the northern boundary of the site was 1.09 mAHD. This level is not
sufficient to overflow across the existing track, which acts as a bund at 1.14 mAHD. The HAT tidal
inundation therefore does not inundate the site.
An analysis was conducted to determine the HAT tidal inundation extent if this bund was removed. The
resultant inundation extent is shown in Figure 2. The HAT peak water within the site was around 1.00
mAHD. This area is contained within the proposed waterway corridor which will be retained following
development. It is suggested that this inundation area be used to re-define the erosion prone area.
The proposed culvert crossing located in this area would classify as a "coastal dependent public access
facility" under the OCP. It would therefore be a permissible structure in an erosion prone area.
6.3 Scour Velocities
The site is characterised as a low energy tidal estuary. As such, the tidal velocities within Keyser Creek are
very low. TUFLOW modelling within the site shows the peak velocities in this creek to be less than 0.05 m/s.
The peak average cross-sectional velocities within the site are around 0.01 m/s. From Table 8.06.1 of
OUDM the typical bank scour velocities is 0.5 mls for non-vegetated highly erodible sandy loam soil and 0.6
mls for non-vegetated moderately erodible clay loam soils. For sparsely vegetated areas the typical bank
scour velocity is between 1.0 and 1.5 m/s. The soil is this area is typified by sandy clay, with a D50 less than
0.075mm. The peak velocities is this area are therefore significantly less than bank scour velocities. The
western drainage channel is therefore not considered to be erosion prone from future tidal inundation.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 9
Page 15
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
7 QCP Storm-tide Hazard
7.1 Summary
The site is not currently located within the Urban
Footprint of the South East Queensland Regional Plan
(SEQRP),and has a non-urban zoning. It therefore cannot be classified as an Urban Locality in accordance
with the requirements of the QCP
Policy 2.5 of the QCP deals with high and medium coastal hazard areas in urban areas, and would apply to
the site if it had an urban designation. For the purposes of this analysis, it has been assumed that an urban
designation will be achieved over the site at some time in the future. This is not a matter for engineering
consideration, and will be the subject of work to be completed by others. Without this designation,
development within high and medium hazard areas would not be permissible.
Medium hazard areas are classified as areas with less than 1 m depth of storm-tide inundation and high
hazard areas are classified as areas with greater than 1 m depth of storm-tide inundation. Based on the
default QCP storm-tide value of 2.18 mAHD the high hazard areas are therefore at levels below 1.18 mAHD.
The medium and high hazard areas are shown on Figure 3.
The high hazard area is contained within the proposed waterway corridor, with a road crossing required for
access purposes. The high hazard area on site is therefore not being developed. However, if development
within the high hazard proposed, according to policy 2.5.1 it could not proceed unless there is a
area was
relevant adaptation strategy in the planning scheme. Policy 2.5.2 states that, where an adaptation strategy
is not appropriately reflected in a relevant planning instrument, development may occur in a high hazard area
if a suitable risk assessment demonstrates that adverse coastal hazard impacts are satisfactorily managed.
Since Council has not yet adopted any adaptation strategy, it is obviously not reflected in the planning
scheme. If a risk assessment is conducted, which demonstrates that there is no increased risk as a
consequence of development of the site, development in the high coastal hazard areas can be approved.
A similar outcome is derived for the medium coastal hazard areas under policy 2.5.3. Urban development
can occur if a suitable risk assessment is completed. By using appropriate earthworks, the site could be
made fully safe against tidal inundation and storm surge, thereby immediately removing the coastal hazard
designation entirely. It is accepted that a formal Coastal Risk Hazard Assessment will be required at some
time in the future to facilitate any requisite approval under this section of the QCP. This matter is addressed
in Section 7.3 below.
7.2 Proposed Development
The proposed development is unique as it is the only Biodiversity Development Offset Area (BDOA)site
declared by the Queensland State Government. This BDOA declaration allows a development application to
be lodged over the subject site, with the purpose of extending the SEQRP Urban Footprint.
It is proposed to fill the lots within the western drainage channel to a level of 3.40 mAHD or greater. This will
provide over 500mm of freeboard to the 100 year ARI peak flood level, with climate change. Similarly all
other areas of the site will include climate change factors when determining the appropriate floor levels. The
proposed waterway crossings will allow for trafficable access to the site during a Probable Maximum Flood
(PMF)event. The PMF event is greater than the 100 year ARI event with climate change.
The flood modelling has shown that there is no adverse flooding impact on neighbouring properties in local
and regional flood events for all events up to and including the 100 year ARI event.
The proposed development will provide improved flood access for neighbouring sites. The existing
development around Lake Entrance Boulevard currently has access limited for 2 year ARI events and above.
An alternative 100 year ARI trafficable access route has been proposed.
For further details of the proposed development refer to the Cardno Flood Study (October,2012).
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 10
Page 16
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
7.3 Coastal Hazard Risk Assessment
From Figure 1 of Annex 6 of the OCP a site based risk assessment has been completed.
1. The site is affected by Coastal Hazards and a risk assessment is required.
2. The nature and extent of the hazards on site have been determined (refer Figure 2 and 3).
3. The development is a high level of intensification.
4. If no mitigation measures were employed the coastal hazards would have a high degree of impact
on the development as lots would be subject to frequent inundation and access to parts of the site
would be restricted.
5. Development will fill the site to a level above the 100 year ARI flood level with climate change. The
lots will be provided with at least 500mm of freeboard above this level. Flood modelling has shown
negligible impact to surrounding properties. Access to the site will be trafficable in a PMF event.
6. The proposed mitigation measures are viable in regards to environmental, social and economic
factors.
7. The lots will be located at 3.40 mAHD or above and culvert crossings of the waterway will be
provided.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 11
Page 17
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
8 Draft Coastal Protection State Planning Regulatory
Provision
8.1 Summary
On the 8th of October 2012 the State Planning Policy 3/11: Coastal Protection was suspended so that the
State Government could undertake a review. The Draft Coastal Protection State Planning Regulatory
Provision (DSPRP)will be in effect in the interim. The DSPRP appears to enshrine the general intent of the
QCP while removing the specific restrictions on development in the coastal area. The DSPRP still requires
consideration of issues such as land use planning and coastal hazards, but does not contain the explicit
prohibitions or restrictions on urban development that were contained in the SPP 3/11. The DEHP coastal
hazard mapping remains in place.
8.2 Erosion Prone Areas
The DSPRP states that "to the extent practicable, erosion prone areas are to remain undeveloped apart from
acceptable temporary or relocatable structures for safety and recreational purposes". The proposed
development does not extend into erosion prone areas, as redefined by detailed tidal inundation mapping
(refer Figure 2), therefore this requirement is met. The proposed road crossing is a required "coastal
dependent public access facility", and is therefore acceptable.
8.3 Storm-tide Hazard
The DSPRP states that:
"Development in areas on the coastal zone identified as having a high risk of being affected by coastal
hazards needs to be carefully considered and wherever possible, be retained undeveloped. Where an area
vulnerable to storm tide inundation is developed, or has a development commitment, further development in
these areas needs to address:
(a)its vulnerability to sea level rise and storm tide inundation
(b)the proposed access to and protection of evacuation routes."
The proposed development will take into account future sea level rise and increases in rainfall intensity.
Suitable mitigation measures have been proposed in the design to ensure that people and property are not
at unacceptable risk. The proposed access routes to the site will be trafficable in a PMF event, and flood
access to neighbouring areas will be improved.
It is therefore considered that development within the defined coastal hazard areas is acceptable based on
the conditions of the DSPRP.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 12
Page 18
Noosa on Weyba
QCP Assessment
CI"Cardnoe
9 CONCLUSION
The QCP erosion prone mapping has been reviewed based on SBEACH coastal erosion modelling and
TUFLOW flood modelling. The results have shown that the proposed development is not located in erosion
prone areas, except for the waterway crossing which is classified as a "coastal dependent public access
facility" and is therefore acceptable under the QCP. The proposed revisions to the erosion prone areas on
site are shown in Figure 2.
The site is also impacted by medium and high coastal hazard areas, as defined by the QCP. Development
within the medium coastal hazard is
proposed. Mitigation strategies (i.e. filling to above the future
area
inundation level) will allow the development to proceed without increased risk to people and property.
Therefore development within this area will be acceptable based on the DSPRP, which supersedes SPP
3/11.
Northbrook Corp Pty Ltd and J&K Hofmann Version 2 15 October 2012
QCP Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 13
Page 19
Noosa on Weyba
Figure 1 100 Year ARI Existing Case Peak F
Levels
Figure 2 Revised Erosion Prone Area
Figure 3 Medium and High Coastal Hazard
~r")CardnoO)
Shaping the Future
Page 20
NOOSA ON WEYBA
QCP ASSESSMENT
<._Dc:ardn
~
~
LEGEND
CJ Site boundary
PeaK Water Level (mAHO)
- Above 800
- 750to800
- 700to750
- 650to700
- 600to650
- 5 50 to 6.00
- 5 00 to 550
- 475to500
- 450to475
c: 425to450
c:::: 400to425
C 375to400
C 350 to 3.75
C 3 25 to 350
- 300to325
- 2 75 to 3.00
- 250to275
C 225to250
- 200to225
- 1 50 to 2 00
- 1 00 to 1 50
- 050tolOO
- Below 050
’--
100 0 100 200 300 400 50 Om
... I 110,000
@ Cardno (Old)Pty Lid All Rights Reserved 2012 Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
Copyright in the whole and every part olthis drawing tlelongslo Cardno (Old)Ply LId and
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole orin partin any manneror
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreemenlwilh Cardno (Old)Ply Ltd. FIGURE 1
This document is produced by Cardno (Old) Ply LId solelyforthebenefitofand useby
the client in accordance with the terms olthe relainer.Cardno (Old)Ply LId does nol
and shall not assume any responSibility orliabilily whalsoeverloany thrd party arising auto! 100 YEAR ARI EXISTING CASE PEAK WATER LEVEL (LOCAL AND REGIONAL)WITH DEV PLAN
any use orreliance by tl’lird party on Il’Ieconlenlofll’lisdocument
Rev: 0 I Drawn: N.G.I Checked: N.G,I Date: 5/10/2012 Project No.: 5101/19/3
PRINT DATE: 08 October, 2012 10:29am
North broo k Co rp Pty Ltd and J& K Holm ann
-
CAD FILE: 0:\5101-19-03\Figures\R2v2 OCP Assessment\Figl -
100Y Existing Peak Water Level.dwg
XREF’s: 0(08; dev_plan: site; Max_E05_100y_Loc_Reg_h
Page 21
NOOSA ON WEYBA
QCP ASSESSMENT
<._Dc:ardn
~
~
LEGEND
c=J Site boundary
2100100 Year Shoreline Storm
Surge Erosion Extent
Tidal Erosion Extent
2100 HA T Level (mAHD)
- Above 125
- 100 to l25
- o 75 to lOO
- 050to075
- Below 0 50
100 200 300 400 50 Om
... I 110,000
@ Cardno (Old)Pty Lid All Rights Reserved 2012 Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
Copyright in the whole and every part olthis drawing tlelongslo Cardno (Old)Ply LId and
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole orin partin any manneror
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreemenlwilh Cardno (Old)Ply Ltd. FIGURE 2
This document is produced by Cardno (Old) Ply LId solelyforthebenefitofand useby
the client in accordance with the terms olthe relainer.Cardno (Old)Ply LId does nol
and shall not assume any responSibility orliabilily whalsoeverloany thrd party arising auto! REVISED EROSION PRONE AREAS
any use orreliance by third party on Iheconlenloflhisdocumenl
Rev: 0 I Drawn: N,G.I Checked: N.G,I Date: 5/10/2012 Project No.: 5101/19/3
PRINT DATE: 12 October, 2012 10:33am
North broo k Co rp Pty Ltd and J& K Holm ann
-
CAD FILE: 0:\5101-19-03\Figures.\R2v2 OCP Asses.s.ment\FigZ - Climate Change HAT Peak Water Levels.dwg
XREF’s: OC08; dev_plan; site; Max_E05_bund_HA TtideCC_h
Page 22
NOOSA ON WEYBA
QCP ASSESSMENT
<._Dc:ardn
~
~
LEGEND
c=J Site boundary
High Hazard Area
Medium Hazard Area
100 200 300 400 50 Om
... I 110,000
@ Cardno (Old)Pty Lid All Rights Reserved 2012 Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
Copyright in the whole and every part olthis drawing tlelongslo Cardno (Old)Ply LId and
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole orin partin any manneror
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreemenlwilh Cardno (Old)Ply Ltd. FIGURE 3
This document is produced by Cardno (Old) Ply LId solelyforthebenefitofand useby
the client in accordance with the terms olthe relainer.Cardno (Old)Ply LId does nol
and shall not assume any responSibility orliabilily whalsoeverloany thrd party arising auto! QCP STORM-TIDE HAZARD AREAS
any use orreliance by third party on Iheconlenloflhisdocumenl
Rev: 0 I Drawn: N,G.I Checked: N.G,I Date: 5/10/2012 Project No.: 5101/19/3
PRINT DATE: 12 October, 2012 10:18am
North broo k Co rp Pty Ltd and J& K Holm ann
-
CAD FILE, O,\5101-19-03\Figures\R2v2 OCP Assessment\Fig3 -
OCP Storm-tide Hazard Areas.dwg
XREF’s: OC08; dev_plan; site; OCP HaZ<lrd Areas
Page 23
Noosa on Weyba
<:..f) Carclno’"
Shaping the Future
[OCR of page images]
Noosa on Weyba
APPENDIX
MASTERPLAN OF DEVELOPMENT
c+ Cardna
Shaping the Future
Page 24
I I
LEGEND:
-
SENDSITE
-
RECEIVE SITE
-
ASSET PROTECTION ZONE
TREE PROTECTION ZONE PROTECTED
-
O KOALA BUSHLAND HABITAT
== POWERLlNE EASEMENT 25m -
= BUSH FIRE ACCESS TRAIL 6m
-
-
NOOSA ON WEYBA -_
~/ ~~ ..
NORTHBROOK CORP PTY LTDAND J & K HOFMANN
I1~00/Sa
.MASTER PLAN
on weyba -
Design
-
MlDesign Ply Ltd 0 SO.O 100 architecture I master plannirg I urban design I interior design
ACN100492304 ~
ABN 89159048228
PlotDate:8J08I2012
W~ SCALE-1:10000@A3 APPROVED FOR ISSUE:_ 07/08/2012@ ML Design Ply. Ltd. JOB NO: NORT0001 MP-004-[J] -
.
L File Path: P:INORTOOOCLake WeybalB_Dorumentatioo\BI_ProductionlB1_Olll’NingsVlrdliCADlLayoutsINORTOOO1_layout.pln
_j
Page 25
Noosa on Weyba
<..D Carclno"’
Shaping the Future
[OCR of page images]
Noosa on Weyba
APPENDIX
QCP HAZARD MAPPING
c+ Cardna
Shaping the Future
Page 26
153003.00..E 153003’30" E
V>
::, 0
"" ’"
’" ’"
N
N
0
0
’"
’"
N
N
::,
""
’"
N
o
’"
N
::,
""
’"
N
o
’"
N
153003’00" 153003’30"
Coastal Hazard Areas Map
Erosion Prone Area
Requested By: [email protected]
Date: 05 Mar 12 Time: 10.26.20
Centered on Lot on Plan:
11 RP893393
N Selected Land Parcel 1. The areas shown on this map are indicative of the extent of erosion
and permanent inundation defined by the declared erosion prone area
plans. Only the declared erosion prone area plans should be used for
Indicative Erosion Prone Area 2100 *
(including projected climate change impacts to 2100)
.. Erosion due to storm impact and long
term trends of sediment loss and channel
e development assessment. To determine the actual position of the erosion
prone area a registered surveyor or geotechnical consultant may be
required if there is any doubt. Erosion prone area plans for each local
government area and a comprehensive description of their determination
are available from the Department of Environment and Resource
Manage me nt we bsite at www.derm.qld.gov.au
migration
Queensland
Government 2. The erosion prone area includes the impact of climate change to 2100
..Erosion and permanent tidal inunation
due to level rise sea
including a sea level rise of 0.8m
LOCALITY DIAGRAM Whilst every care is taken to ensure the accuracy of this product,
*
The erosion prone areas shown on this map are indicative of the the Department of Environment and Resource Management makes
erosion and inundation extent that may occur with climate change no representations or warranties about its accuracy, reliability,
impacts up to 2100. completeness or suitability for any particular purpose and disclaims
all responsibility and all liability (including without limitation,
liability in negligence) for all expenses, losses, damages (including
indirect or consequential damage)and costs which you may incur as a
I I Coastal Management District result of the product being inaccurate or incomplete in any way and
for any reason. This map is intended to be printed on an A4 page.
~ Coastal Zone
I
100 200 :JOO 400 50Dm
This scale bar is approximate only
Horizontal Datum: Geocentric Datum of Australia 1994 (GDA94)
This product is unprojected and is not suitable for measuring distances @ The State ofOueensland, 2012
Page 27
153003.00..E 153003’30" E
o
’"
’"
N
o
’"
N
’"
"
""
’"
N
o
’"
N
’"
"
’"
’"
N
o
’"
N
153003’00" 153003’30"
Coastal Hazard Areas Map
Storm Tide Inundation Area
Requested By: [email protected]
Date: 05 Mar 12 Time: 10.26.22
Centered on Lot on Plan:
11 RP893393
N Selected Land Parcel 1. A default storm tide inundation level of 1.5 m HAT in South East
Queensland regional planning area and 2.0 m HAT for the
remainder of Queensland is used where storm tide inundation levels
Storm Tide Inundation Area
(including projected climate change impacts to 2100)
.. High hazard (greater than 1.0m water depth)
area
e including climate change have not been determined locally. The
default level uses a sea level rise factor of 0.8m to 2100.
2. The high hazard area may be subject to permanent inundation
by sea level rise refer to the Erosion Prone Area map.
-
Queensland 3. The map should be used as a guide only. Field surveys are
.. Medium hazard (less than 1.0m water depth)
area
Government recommended to verify feature boundaries.
I I Coastal Management District
Whilst every care is taken to ensure the accuracy of this product,
LOCALITY DIAGRAM the Department of Environment and Resource Management makes
II ’I Coastal Zone
no representations or warranties about its accuracy, reliability,
completeness or suitability for any particular purpose and disclaims
all responsibility and all liability (including without limitation,
liability in negligence) for all expenses, losses, damages (including
indirect or consequential damage)and costs which you may incur as a
result of the product being inaccurate or incomplete in any way and
for any reason. This map is intended to be printed on an A4 page.
I
100 200 :JOO 400 50Dm
This scale bar is approximate only
Horizontal Datum: Geocentric Datum of Australia 1994 (GDA94)
This product is unprojected and is not suitable for measuring distances @ The State ofOueensland, 2012
Page 28
Noosa on Weyba
<:..f) Carclno’"
Shaping the Future
[OCR of page images]
Noosa on Weyba
APPENDIX
LAKE WEYBA TIDAL GAUGE RECORD
c+ Cardna
Shaping the Future
Page 29
I, ’I
"
,~.
Report ID
~ =~ ~-. ~(:i :J?~~.
,.
~". .
LAT CZl BZI AHD HAT RM5 RM4 RM6 Datum Staion
Creatd: 0 1
Datum LAKE
2 B
22
TIDE BOARD
GDA /<
MAR LOWEST
CHART ZERO AUSTRLIN 1970-8) HIGEST RECOVRY RECOVRY RECOVRY - Descripton WEYBA
2012
AUSTRLIAN
ASTRONMICL DHEAITGUHMT ASTRONMICL
ZERO
I
I
MARK MARK MARK
5 4 6
HEIGHT RIVER
NO SA
TIDE TIDE
DATUM
(EPOCH Tidal
TIDES SEE SEE DE P DRIL PSM Staion
-
Tidal COMENT COMENT DRIVEN HOLE 5046 Benchmark MR
R
L
-
Data SP
ID
N
Oper
PEDRSN Related
Enquires Public Datum
System
Elevation
Y
Details
0,230 0, 0 0, 0 0, 0 0,320 0,61 0 0,701 0.8710 TGBM Latiude
-26
From PSM .
10-MAY9 1O-MAY90 1O-MAY90 10-MAY9 10-MAY.9 10-MAY9 1O-MAY90 10-MAY9 Date 1393
25,2
.
1
,7020 Longitude .
2-AUG190 2-AUG190 2-AUG190 2-AUG190 2.AUG-190 2-AUG190 2-AUG190 2-AUG190 To
Date Metr s 153’
MI tdme
Page
I
of
I
Above
Staion
Datum
4,5’
~n,s.I_dGrm!1t
SdI y
Quenslad
Page 30
Noosa on Weyba
<:..f) Carclno’"
Shaping the Future
[OCR of page images]
Noosa on Weyba
APPENDIX
SHORELINE EROSION ASSESSMENT
c+ Cardna
Shaping the Future
Page 31
Prepared for
Cardno QLD
28 September 2012
Cardno@
Shaping the Future
[OCR of page images]
Noosa on Weyba
Erosion Hazard Assessment
510119\016
Prepared for
Cardno QLD
28 September 2012
C>
Cardno’
Shaping the Future
Page 32
Noosa on Weyba
Document Information
Prepared for Cardno QLD
Project Name Noosa on Weyba
File Reference R001 Ver 1
Job Reference 510119\016
Date 28 September 2012
Contact Information
Cardno (NSW/ACT)Pty Ltd
ABN 95 001 145 035
Level 9, The Forum, 203 Pacific Highway
St Leonards NSW 2065
PO Box 19 St Leonards NSW 1590
Telephone: 02 9496 7700
Facsimile: 02 9439 5170
International: +61 2 9496 7700
[email protected]
www.cardno.com
Document Control
Version Date Author Author Reviewer Reviewer
Initials Initials
28Sep. 12 Doug Treloar PDT Chris Beadle CJB
@ Cardno 2012. Copyright in the whole and every part of this document
belongs to Cardno and may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or
reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or form or in or on any media
to any person other than by agreement with Card no.
This document is produced by Cardno solely for the benefit and use by the
client in accordance with the terms of the engagement. Cardno does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third
party arising out of any use or reliance by any third party on the content of
this document.
28 September 2012 Cardno
\\ausydcfs01 \COE-Jobs\CM\51 0119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 33
Noosa on Weyba
Table of Contents
1 Introduction 1
2 Data 2
2.1 Elevation Data 2
2.2 Water Level Data 2
2.3 Wind Data 2
2.4 Wave Data 3
2.5 Sediment Data 3
3 Erosion Hazard Assessment 4
3.1 Design Wave Criteria 4
3.2 Shoreline Erosion Modelling 4
3.3 Assessment of Erosion Prone Area 5
4 Conclusion 7
5 References 8
Tables
Table 2-1 Double Island Point Lighthouse: Directional Design Wind Speeds (Modified) 3
Table 3-1 Study Area Design Wave Criteria 4
Table 3-2 Shoreline Erosion Modelling Scenarios 5
Table 3-3 Shoreline Erosion Results 5
Figures
Figure 1-1 Locality Plan
Figure 2-1 Wind Rose -
Double Island Point Winds -
Modified
Figure 3-1 SBEACH Profile Locations
Figure 3-2 Erosion Prone Areas
Appendi s
Appendix A Noosa on Weyba Precinct Plan
28 September 2012 Cardno iii
\\ausydcfs01\COE-Jobs\CM\510119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 34
Noosa on Weyba 1 Introduction Cardno has been engaged to conduct an erosion hazard assessment for a land parcel on the western foreshore of lake Weyba, on the Sunshine Coast of QlD. Figure 1.1 provides a locality plan. Whilst the area has already been assessed as part of DERM’s coastal hazard mapping, the broad scale of the assessment has resulted in concerns being raised about the potential accuracy of this assessment at the study site. As part of the assessment Cardno has estimated design wave criteria near the foreshore at the site, conducted storm induced erosion modelling for a range of locations and scenarios, and conducted an erosion hazard assessment of the study site based upon methodology outlined in the QlD Coastal Hazard Guidelines. 28 September 2012 Cardno \\ausydcfs01 \COE-Jobs\CM\51 0119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 35
Noosa on Weyba
2 Data
A range of data items were required for this erosion hazard analysis.
2.1 Elevation Data
Regional bathymetric (lake/seabed depth) data for the site was available from the QLD Transport Boating
Safety Chart: Noosa River and Lakes, released in October 1991.
This data was presented in respect to chart datum, which was LAT at Noosa. All data was reduced to mAHD
for the required analyses by applying a correction to LAT of 0.8m for the area, based on the datum at Noosa.
This datum relationship was confirmed by MrWayne Bagnell of Maritime Safety Queensland.
It should be noted that all bathymetric data precedes the major flooding that occurred in south-east
Queensland (including the Noosa river catchment) during 2011, and as such the lake bathymetry may be
less accurate around the creek entrance areas to the north of the study site.
Topographic data for the beach area was available in the form of 1m vertical contours, and was provided by
DERM. The topographic contours were merged with the lake bathymetric data to construct three elevation
profiles along the foreshore of the study site.
2.2 Water Level Data
The regional flood levels in Lake Weyba, obtained from flood modelling undertaken for Council are:-
. 1 OO-years ARI = 2.09 mAHD
.
20-years ARI = 1.53 mAHD
. 1 O-years ARI = 1.45 mAHD
It is unlikely that high wind speeds would be associated with severe flood level peaks.
QLD government dictates that for environmental assessments potential changes to mean sea level as a
result of projected climate change be assessed also. For planning purposes the quantified values for mean
sea level rise above present day MSL is 0.3m for the year 2050 and 0.8m for the year 2100.
2.3 Wind Data
Wind data was necessary as aninput to the wind wave modelling. Recorded hourly wind speed and
direction data (10-minutes average wind speed) was available from the Bureau of Meteorology for Double
Island Point Lighthouse for a period from 1995 to 2010. This weather station is located at the lighthouse that
sits atop a cliff at Double Island with an elevation of approximately 95m above sea level. As such, the wind
speed data was reduced assuming a power-law wind profile, and the following formula:-
1
U10m
Uzm
=
(10)7
Z
Although wind data was available from closer weather stations, such as Gympie, the Double Island Point
lighthouse station was utilised because its proximity to the coast meant that it contained more typical South-
Easterly trade winds, in both direction and magnitude. A wind rose of the reduced Double Island Point
Lighthouse wind data can be seen in Figure 2.1.
The wind data was separated into directional sectors and then the data for the ENE, E and ESE directional
sectors were analysed. These directional bands were chosen because the area of interest lies on the
western foreshore of Lake Weyba. Hence it will be affected most severely by wind generated by waves from
these directions.
28 September 2012 Cardno 2
\\ausydcfs01\COE-Jobs\CM\510119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 36
Noosa on Weyba
The probability of exceedance analysis conducted for each direction gave results for wind speeds that are
exceeded for 30 minutes in 100 years and 30 minutes in 50 years. The results are given in Table 2.1 below.
Fully developed sea states for the lake are expected to occur within 30 minutes.
Table 2-1 Double Island Point Lighthouse: Directional Design Wind Speeds (Modified)
Wind Speed exceeded 30 Wind Speed exceeded 30 mins
Directional Sector
minutes every 50 years (m/s) every 100 years (m/s)
ENE 20.6 21.5
E 21.0 21.7
ESE 22.5 23.3
2.4 Wave Data
There is no recorded wave data for this site. Hence wind wave modelling was required for this investigation
in order to develop the required design wave parameters used in foreshore erosion modelling.
This report has not addressed boat waves that may also affect the site.
2.5 Sediment Data
Sediment data was provided by the soil classification tests performed as part of the Geotechnical
investigation conducted by Cardno. The data available to Cardno was not on the shoreline itself and showed
a high proportion of fines. High resolution aerial imagery and the site visit conducted by Cardno showed that
the shoreline at the site is more sandy, and the smallest allowable D50 particle size of 0.15mm (SBEACH
limitation) was adopted.
28 September 2012 Cardno 3
\\ausydcfs01 \COE-Jobs\CM\51 0119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 37
Noosa on Weyba
3 Erosion Hazard Assessment
3.1 Design Wave Criteria
As mentioned in Section 2.4, there is no recorded wave data for this site. As a result, wave modelling was
required for this investigation in order to develop the required design wave parameters used in the foreshore
erosion modelling.
As study site sits on a lake foreshore, there is no swell wave action at the site and the wave dimate consists
almost exclusively of local wind driven waves. Thus design wave criteria were determined by conducting
wind wave modelling using the 30 minutes in 100 years, and 30 minutes in 50 years wind speeds determined
in Section 2.3. The winds utili sed in the wave modelling were those from the ESE directional sector, as they
contained higher design wind speeds, while also generating wave whose propagation was likely to be shore-
normal. The wind wave modelling was conducted using the Sverdrup-Munk and Bretschneider (SMB)one
dimensional model of wind generated waves.
As the wave heights at the study site are affected by the water level of the lake, the wave climate analyses
took account of the fact that a rainfall event is likely to accompany high winds as part of a storm (such as an
east coast low). At the same time however, it is unlikely that the highest wind speeds would be associated
with the peaks of severe floods. Hence 5MB wave modelling was conducted by coupling the 100-years ARI
wind data with 20-years ARI flood levels, and 50-years ARI wind speeds with 10-year ARls flood levels, see
Section 2.2. Design wave criteria at the site are shown in Table 3.1 below. Wave modelling also included
the projected sea level rises. This is common practice in coastal and estuarine modelling.
Table 3-1 Study Area Design Wave Criteria
Current Scenario 2050 Scenario 2100 Scenario
ARI (years) .
Hs (m) Tp (5) Hs (m) Tp (5) Hs (m) Tp (5)
50 0.73 4.3 0.75 4.3 0.78 4.4
100 0.76 4.4 0.78 4.4 0.82 4.5
The 50 and 100 years ARI wave heights do not vary significantly due to the shallow lake depth, limited wave
fetch and similar design wind speeds at the two ARI’s.
3.2 Shoreline Erosion Modelling
Storm erosion of the shoreline at the site was investigated using the SBEACH modelling system. SBEACH
was developed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE)to investigate storm induced profile response
on fine to medium grain sand beaches. It is an empirically based model that includes wave shoaling,
refraction, breaking, set-up and run-up. The model can simulate a temporally varying wave breaking-point,
which produces offshore bar migration. The model has been widely applied at sites all over the world and
has demonstrated reasonable levels of calibration.
SBEACH analyses were conducted at three profiles at the study site that were created by combining the lake
bathymetric data and foreshore topographic data described in Section 2.1. The locations of these profiles
are shown in Figure 3.1. Profile locations were chosen that were even spaced but also represented varying
different topographic aspects of the shoreline, such as the gully area at the southern end of the study site.
The SBEACH modelling was conducted for a range of lake water levels and design wave conditions. This
modelling is outlined in Table 3.2 below. Cyclone caused waves have not been addressed. In those events
wind speeds could be higher, but the wave heights will become depth and fetch limited and wind direction
would change quite rapidly for cyclones in close vicinity.
28 September 2012 Cardno 4
\\ausydcfs01 \COE.Jobs\CM\51 0119-Lake Weyba\009.ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 38
Noosa on Weyba
Table 3-2 Shoreline Erosion Modelling Scenarios
Water Level Condition Wave Conditions
Scenario Total Lake
Number Lake Water Level Design Wave Tp
Water Level Hs(m)
Scenario Scenario (s)
(mAHD)
Present Day Lake Level +
1 1.45 50yrs ARI 0.73 4.3
1 Oyrs ARI Design Flood
Present Day Lake Level +
2 1.53 1 OOyrs ARI 0.76 4.4
20yrs ARI Design Flood
2050 Lake Level +
3 1.75 50yrs ARI 0.75 4.3
1 Oyrs ARI Design Flood
2050 Lake Level +
4 1.83 100yrs ARI 0.78 4.4
20yrs ARI Design Flood
2100 Lake Level +
5 2.25 50yrs ARI 0.78 4.4
10yrs ARI Design Flood
2100 Lake Level +
6 2.33 100yrs ARI 0.82 4.5
20yrs ARI Design Flood
The results of the SBEACH erosion modelling indicated that the foreshore erosion extents presented in
Table 3.3 would occur in these events. These erosion extents were taken at 0.5m above the still water level
for each case and included post erosion slumping where the eroded profile was steeper than the dry angle of
natural repose of sand. Each storm was assumed to have a duration of 6 hours at peak wave conditions,
which is a conservative position.
Table 3-3 Shoreline Erosion Results
Scenario
Profile 1 Profile 2 Profile 3
Number
1 1.9 5.0 6.1
2 3.6 5.8 7.2
3 6.8 7.6 7.9
4 7.5 8.0 8.6
5 6.5 5.5 9.2
6 6.7 5.8 10.0
These results show that in severe storm events the present shoreline will suffer some erosion; but this is
rare, as confirmed by the grassy shoreline observed during the site visit. More shoreline erosion can be
expected when projected sea level rises occur.
3.3 Assessment of Erosion Prone Area
The QLD Coastal Hazard Guidelines (2011)outline a methodology for assessing erosion prone areas widths.
These widths are intended to accommodate both short-term and long-term erosion over specified planning
periods. This erosion prone area width is a specified horizontal distance back from the present-day HAT
water line, and is calculated by the following equation provided in the guidelines.
E = [(NxR)+C+S]x (1+F)+ D
Where:
28 September 2012 Cardno 5
\\ausydcfs01 \COE-Jobs\CM\51 0119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 39
Noosa on Weyba E = erosion prone area width (metres). N = planning period (years). R = rate of long term erosion (metres per year). C = short term erosion from the design storm (metres). S = erosion due to sea level rise (metres). F = factor of safety. D = dune scarp component to allow for slumping of the erosion scarp (metres) Values for erosion prone area width were calculated at a series of points located at 15m intervals along the foreshore of the study site land parcel. HAT at the site was based on the Queensland tide tables data for Munna Point which equates to 0.68mAHD. For this particular assessment the rate of long term erosion (N)was deemed to be zero in for this particular case, as the grassy foreshore and lack of swell waves at the site mean that this component is likely to be minimal. The values for short term erosion from design storms (C)were taken from the outcomes of the SBEACH modelling described in Section 3.2. Erosion values at the foreshore calculation intervals were then determined by interpolating the erosion values from the three SBEACH profiles. The horizontal foreshore erosion due to sea level rise (S)was determined for the 2050 (0.3m sea level rise) and 2100 (0.8m sea level rise) by assessing the topographic contours at the site. The factor of safety (F)of 0.4 has been adopted by DERM for use in this equation. This means that design storm erosion and sea level rise erosion were scaled up by 40%. As a result, erosion prone area width in some regions may even extend inland to areas of relatively high topography, particularly if steep foreshore banks are present. Dune slump (D)was accounted for in the SBEACH modelling, as described in Section 3.2. The results of this assessment can be seen in Figures 3.2 to 3.5, which depict the erosion prone areas for the current day, 2050 and 2100 scenarios. These figures indicate that even for the 2100 scenarios, the erosion prone areas remain within the Lake Buffer Zone (outlined in Appendix A) and do not encroach upon any of the proposed residential lots. It should be noted that whilst SBEACH erosion modelling indicated that some foreshore erosion is possible under severe storm conditions, another significant contributor to the erosion hazard zone lies in the sea level rise induced erosion, particularly on the northern foreshore of the site where the banks are flatter (see the topographic contours on Figure 3.2) and the southern end of the site where a small gully exists. Once the combined, these two components are scaled up by 40% under the QLD Coastal Hazard Guidelines methodology. Hence the erosion prone area can extend a distance inland that needs to be considered. In the centre of the land parcel where the foreshore bank slopes are steeper, the erosion hazard lines lie 10 to 15m from the foreshore edge. However, at the north of the site, the foreshore topography becomes significantly flatter and the resulting increase in the sea level rise erosion pushes the hazard line back to approximately 50m inland for the 2100 climate change scenario. Comparison with current erosion prone area mapping provided in the Queensland Coastal Plan shows that the erosion prone area calculated by Cardno does not extend as far inland. At this point it should be emphasised that the Queensland Coastal Plan mapping of this study site was part of a broad scale assessment, whilst the results of this report can be considered the product of a much more site specific evaluation. 28 September 2012 Cardno 6 \\ausydcfs01 \COE-Jobs\CM\51 0119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 40
Noosa on Weyba
4 Conclusion
Cardno has been engaged to conduct an erosion hazard assessment for a land parcel on the western
foreshore of Lake Weyba. As part of the assessment Cardno has estimated design wave criteria near the
foreshore at the site and conducted storm induced shoreline erosion modelling for a range of locations and
scenarios. The results of such analyses then informed an erosion hazard assessment of the study site
based upon methodology outlined in the QLD Coastal Hazard Guidelines (2011).
The results of this assessment depict the erosion prone areas for the current day, 2050 and 2100 scenarios.
The figures indicate that even for the 2100 scenarios the erosion prone areas remain within the Lake Buffer
Zone (outlined in Appendix A) and do not encroach upon any of the proposed residential lots.
Importantly, comparisons with current erosion prone area mapping as provided in the Queensland Coastal
Plan (using non site-specific parameters), shows that the erosion prone area calculated by Cardno does not
extend as far inland as the current Queensland Coastal Plan based mapping. The differences between these
two assessments can be attributed their respective methods of analyses -
default based (DERM)and site
specific (Cardno). The QCP mapping of this study site was part of a broad scale assessment, whilst the
mapping in this report is the result of site specific analyses and modelling and hence can be considered
more appropriate.
28 September 2012 Cardno 7
\\ausydcfs01 \COE-Jobs\CM\51 0119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 41
Noosa on Weyba 5 References Department of Environment and Resource Management (2011): QLD Coastal Hazards Guideline. 28 September 2012 Cardno 8 \\ausydcfs01 \COE-Jobs\CM\51 0119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\R001 Ver 1.docx
Page 42
f~CardnD@ ’-J / Shaping the Future [OCR of page images] c+ Cardna’ aping the Future
Page 43
Noosa on Weyba
~~CardnD Locality Plan
Lake Weyba
510119 September 2012
J:\CM\510119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\AFF_016\UnframedFigures\
Figure 1.1
Page 44
+
o
N
L()
f’...
~
L()
w ~
::’>::00 ,,,,~Q,,.,,,,,,,.,,
d" ’ ,,;:;R ,
~.. (")
.’0 ..q- <0..... w
w ....’.. ~ ’0
"’"
Z o’ (Q" ""’~’" ’ex)"’" "
"’,...;;. ’#. en
o ’:’ M’. /.r-."’,
..0...... ~ CO.".
~
’C)’ L()
o
CO, ;;.’
,
0J
’’’.’.. ....’6)
N M’"
." .
N
I
’0
~:
.
.,.,~/... ~"" ;ft. ~
L() ",0,,"
en
en
./.~’/:," "’:""
.
:~’.
. :~
,
’
":".:M"
~ :L()’ r
...-....
j
"’" :
\
’ .IE.
o f
’ 0= E
z
z i..OO,L" ""~"" ,
""0:-"’’’’’’
""
"."~
en ~---
~N
<( :0: ,~
_J ,.\’,
~
.
..’ :,:" "’"
~~ : ,
.~.. \’ ",
(j) .\:’., ;’"
.
,"
,’, ",’
"’,
j~
o
""_"’~’\’::..,
.
~.t. ,.
,~
~"./
.
.,, I ,,
W _-:<"
",
_J N"
’:< ,.<’’’’:
OJ ’-.q- ,to",
""",;"",,’
~
"
L()
:J ...
<...... )..............~......... .
::.:,. :.:~ ....,: .
f’...
o
o s: M ~, ’"’’’’’~’’’’’ "",
.,:..tf? .~..;:
Z ,N (9 ’en
<<> ,~
.,.’
N"’"""""""~"",,, ,,"
;: L()
L()
N
o
Noosa on Weyba
~~CardnD Wind Rose
Double Island Point Lighthouse
510119 September 2012
-
.Modified
J:\CM\510119-Lake Weyba\009-Report"109DocsandFigures\AFF_016\UnframedFigures\
Figure 2.1
[OCR of page images]
SE
15 17.5 20+
13:8%
12.5
2.9% 12.0%1 90%
S
10
Ws (m/s)
DOUBLE ISLAND 1995-2010
N
7.5
8%
1.3%
sw
2.5
oO
Noosa on Weyba
Cc Cardno Wind Rose
Double Island Point Lighthouse - Modified
510119 September 2012
JACM\510119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\AFF_016\UnframedFigures\ Figu re 2.1
Page 45
Noosa on Weyba
~~CardnD Location of Profiles
SBEACH Shoreline Erosion Modelling
510119 September 2012
J:\CM\510119-Lake Weyba\009-Report"109DocsandFigures\AFF_016\UnframedFigures\
Figure 3.1
Page 46
Erosion Prone Area Extent -
Current Day -
50yrARI
Erosion Prone Area Extent -
Current Day -
100yrARI
Erosion Prone Area Extent -
2050 -
50yrARI
Erosion Prone Area Extent - 2050 -
100yrARI
Erosion Prone Area Extent -
2100 -
50yrARI
Erosion Prone Area Extent -
2100 -
100yrARI
Study Site - Land Parcel
Proposed Development Plan
1 m Topographic Contours
QCP Mapping Indicative Erosion
-
Prone Area 2100 due to strom impact
and long term erosion
QCP Mapping Indicative Erosion
-
Prone Area 2100 due to sea level rise
Noosa on Weyba
~~CardnD Erosion Prone Areas
50yrs ARI and 100yrs ARI for Current Day, 2050 and 2100 Scenarios
510119 September 2012
J:\CM\510119-Lake Weyba\009-ReportingDocsandFigures\AFF_016\UnframedFigures\
Figure 3.2
Page 47
f
DCardno@
~
Shaping the Future
[OCR of page images]
APPENDIX A
Sp) Cardna
Shaping the Future
Page 48
I _j
73 50 83 120 40 124 52 24 203
1 6
100 876 only design
Potenial Dwelinas yield interior
Design
I
13 36 23 37 12 15 8
30 12 1 9
19
*/ndicatve design
Dwelings/ha -
I
urban
plan irg
Area !.hID 0.59 5.65 1.37 3.60 3.22 3.38 8.29 6.17 0.80 16.38 1.77 0.66 5.20 806
236.42 1.75 303.3 18.82% 7 .95% 3.23% -
- master
.
AI1 rOx ..
I
-
Amenity Amenity
-
archi1Bture
spare)
Site Site
Use Retail Care
Envirometal Envirometal Care
weyba
r1?O/Sa
Lots Send Send Zone
Mixed Aged Aged
Lounge Residntal
1
:!60sqm 1
Lot 1
BDOA BDOA Buf er ~
Residntal Residntal Living ZoneBuf er Devlopment Lake
Use
T o w n h u s e
- -
Living Living Lots Lots Lots Lots & &
SITE (includes on
SENDITE RECIVE Predominat Residnt’s Premium Apartmen Gated Retirment Residntal Residntal Residntal Townhuse Residntal Rural Special Retirment Parks Grenspace Lake TOTAL Urban Grenspace Parks &
TBC
/1f(:,
LEG ND: - - Precint A B C 0 E F G H H K L M N 0
WEYBA HOFMAN MP-06-[C]
/ Ol ON K
&
NO SA AND NORT0 1
J
B
NO:
TO JOB
L
PTY
Ltd.
E
CORP Pty.
Design
NORTHB K
ML
@
.
N
~ F
07/8201
N
IS UE:
I
G
FOR
\
APROVED
Jf
II SCALE-1:0@3
:a.
--
PLAN
N
PRECINT
WeybalB_DocuntiIPrwgs\AhCONRTL)p
.
8MLDesignPtyd ACN9110540942328 8/0P~6N1OR2T01_Lake
Date: Path:
ABN Plot File
I L
Used in these records
About this file
- File size
- 26.4 MB (very large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
The download may take a few minutes. On mobile data, it is best to wait for Wi-Fi.