Skip to the record
Mmm.. taste the original NoosaWatch™

Council archive · source document

Negotiated Report (Representations made) MCU23 0070 · MCU23/0070

of 7

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

               REQUEST FOR NEGOTIATED DECISION REPORT
               Author                  Senior Development Planner, Tara Norley
                                       Development Assessment

                    APPLICATION DETAILS

                    Application No.                    MCU23/0070

                    Development Approval               Material Change of Use - Food and drink outlet, Short-term
                                                       accommodation

                    Applicant                          Cambooya Pty Ltd

                    Representations Received On        14 February 2024

                    Number of Submissions for          Not applicable
                    Original Application


                    PROPERTY DETAILS

                    Property Address                   36 & 38 Duke St, Sunshine Beach

                    RP Description                     Lot 370 RP 48111 and Lot 371 RP 48111

                    Land Area                          Lot 370 -243m²
                                                       Lot 371 - 243m²

                    Existing Use of Land               Mixed use – restaurant, office and 2 dwellings


                    STATUTORY DETAILS

                    SEQRP Designation                  Urban Footprint

                    Zone                               Tourist Accommodation

                    Precinct                           Not Applicable

                    Local Plan Area                    Coastal Communities

                    Assessment Type                    Representations made to original approval



               1.        BACKGROUND
               A development approval for a Material Change of Use - Food and drink outlet, Short-term
               accommodation was issued on 12 January 2024. The applicant suspended the appeal period and
               made representations on 14 February 2024 to the development approval conditions. The
               representations are detailed below but primarily relate to:
                     •   Setback requirements conditioned through plan amendments;
                     •   Amenity conditions; and
                     •   Fencing conditions.

                                                                                                        Page 1 of 7

Document Set ID: 22836491
Version: 9, Version Date: 18/04/2024
Full text of the other 6 pages

Page 2

               2.     ASSESSMENT
               An assessment in relation to each of the submitted representations is provided below:
               Condition 3 – Approved Plans and Plans Requiring Amendment
               3.     Development authorised by this approval must be undertaken generally in accordance with
                      the Approved Plans listed in the tables below. The plans must be amended to incorporate
                      the amendments listed within the table below and resubmitted to Council prior to the issue
                      of any Development Permit for Operational Works

                         Plan No.        Rev. Plan/Document Name                                       Date

                         7252-DA06       16       Duke Street & Douglas Lane Floor Plans prepared 11-12-23
                                                  by Blackburn Jackson

                         7252-DALS02              Landscaping Planting – Duke Street prepared by 11-12-23
                                                  Blackburn Jackson

                         7252-DALS03              Landscaping Planting – Douglas Lane prepared by 11-12-23
                                                  Blackburn Jackson

                         7252-DALS04              Landscaping Planting – Level 2 prepared by 11-12-23
                                                  Blackburn Jackson

                      The following plans require amendment.

                         Plan No.        Rev. Plan/Document Name                                       Date

                         7252-DA07       16       Floor Plan – Level 2 & Level 3 prepared by 11-12-23
                                                  Blackburn Jackson

                         7252-DA08       11       Roof Plan & Height Plane Projection prepared by 11-12-23
                                                  Blackburn Jackson

                         7252-DA14       11       Elevations prepared by Blackburn Jackson             11-12-23

                         7252-DA15       12       Sections prepared by Blackburn Jackson               11-12-23

                         7252-DA16       12       Sections prepared by Blackburn Jackson               11-12-23

                         7252-DA23       09       Sections-additional prepared by Blackburn Jackson 11-12-23

                         Amendments      a) The third storey must be setback a minimum of 6 metres from the
                                            front boundary to Duke Street, with no structures located in this
                                            setback including, but not limited, to balconies, balustrading,
                                            dividing wall, pool etc.
                                         b) The planter box located along the western façade of Apartment 3
                                            must be a maximum of 1m in height for the length of the western
                                            boundary.

                      *(Refer to Advisory Note)
               Applicant’s Representation
               The application has requested Condition 3 be amended to approve all proposal plans, providing
               the following statement:
                      All outstanding matters have been resolved with the exception of the setback encroachments
                      on the 3 storey where Council remains concerned that the proposed development impacts
                                                                                                    Page 2 of 7

Document Set ID: 22836491
Version: 9, Version Date: 18/04/2024

Page 3

                      on the view lines from the adjoining premises (Unit 7), 28-34 Duke Street and results in
                      excessive mass when viewed from Duke St. Accordingly, Council required plan amendments
                      within the decision notice to ensure that the 3 storey setback is achieved.
                      The proposed plan amendments required by Council’s decision notice (i.e. Condition 3) seek
                      to impose strict compliance with AO13.1 (i.e. acceptable outcome – one means to achieve
                      the performance outcome) which essentially prohibits any structures including the plunge
                      pools and associated fencing / screen walls from being within the 6m front setback on level
                      3.
                      The removal of these structures and available use area on this level is not acceptable to our
                      client and prejudices the ability of the development to compete with other tourist
                      accommodation offerings in the Duke St locality.
                      As stated throughout the application process our client is seeking a performance outcome
                      with respect to the front setbacks under Noosa Plan 2020.
               Assessment of Representation
               The proposal plans submitted with the original application material included a front setback
               intrusion on the third floor, with the setback to the balustrading, planter box and privacy wall
               proposed at 3m (refer Figure 1 images). It was determined that these structures within the 6m front
               setback would adversely impact on view lines of unit occupants to the west and as such were not
               supported. The original Decision Notice therefore included plan amendments requiring all
               structures on the third floor to be setback a minimum of 6m from the front. In addition, a reduction
               in the height of the planter box located along the western façade of Apartment 3 to a maximum of
               1m in height for the length of the western boundary was also conditioned.
               The applicant has provided amended proposal plans with the change representations, retaining
               the 3m setback but reducing the bulk and visual impact of the structures within the setback when
               viewed from the property to the west, including a change in materials from solid walls to transparent
               glass balustrading.




                                                      Figure 1: Original Design




                                                   Figure 2: Representions Design

               Council Officers meet with the applicant and the adjoining property owner on site to discuss the
               proposed setback variation, where the adjoining property owner provided support for the design
               as per the proposal plans lodged with the change representations.

                                                                                                       Page 3 of 7

Document Set ID: 22836491
Version: 9, Version Date: 18/04/2024

Page 4

               The proposed plan amendments will provide a high level of amenity to users of the subject
               site whilst not impacting on the amenity of, or unreasonably obstructing views or cause overlooking
               of private open space or habitable areas of adjoining premises.
               The proposed plan amendments are therefore considered to meet Performance Outcome PO13
               of the Tourist Accommodation Zone Code and as such a change to condition 3 is included in the
               recommendation approving all of the proposal plans provided with the change representations.


               Condition 4
               4.     The premises must not be used as a party house, with no events, functions or parties (e.g.
                      bucks parties, hen’s parties, raves, or wedding receptions for example) permitted on site.
               Applicant’s Representation
               The applicant has requested condition 4 be deleted, stating:
                      Our client seeks to have this condition deleted as the development application has sought
                      approval for Short term accommodation and food and drink outlet, not a Party house which
                      is a separately defined use.
                      We do not believe the condition is warranted for a development, which is seeking to provide
                      short term accommodation aimed at twin share or single persons. It is considered that the
                      small size of the units (i.e single bed) assists in mitigating the risk of units as being used as
                      a party house.
                      Any precautionary measures relating to the premises being potentially used as a party house
                      would be more appropriately nestled in the approval’s advisory notes and/ or property
                      notations. It is also understood the future owners will be required to adhere the requirements
                      of Noosa Council short term accommodation local law policy, which is required for all short
                      term letting or home hosted accommodation. It is considered that this local law has sufficient
                      safeguards to ensure the proposed 1 bedroom’s units are not used for the purposes of a
                      party house.
               Assessment of Representation
               Council includes standard conditions on all short-term accommodation approvals relating to
               amenity concerns. It is however acknowledged that the condition should not specifically reference
               a ‘party house’ given this is a separate, stand-alone use that has not been applied for as part of
               this application. It is however considered relevant to retain a condition restricting the short-term
               accommodation dwellings from hosting functions/events/parties etc. An amended condition is
               included in the recommendation removing reference to a party house.


               Condition 12
               12.    The operation of the approved use must not detrimentally affect the residential amenity
                      (including but not limited to noise, overlooking, light spill or odour) enjoyed by surrounding
                      residents or cause a nuisance, including a noise nuisance.
               Applicant’s Representation
               The applicant has requested to condition 12 be deleted, stating:
                      Our client does not believe this condition is reasonably required for the development and is
                      potentially vague in its application. The operation of the use is adequately controlled through
                      the approved plans and other conditions of approval such as hours of operation (food and
                      drink outlet) which mitigate the potential impacts from overlooking and noise on surrounding
                      premises. In addition, noise nuisance matters are appropriately addressed EP Noise policy.
                      Accordingly, we request that the condition be deleted and any additional commentary
                      regarding potential noise impacts can be addressed by way of Advisory Notes and the short
                      term accommodation local law, as per Condition 4 above.


                                                                                                          Page 4 of 7

Document Set ID: 22836491
Version: 9, Version Date: 18/04/2024

Page 5

               Assessment of Representation
               Council includes standard conditions on all short-term accommodation approvals relating to
               amenity concerns. It is therefore considered unnecessary and inappropriate to remove the
               condition, and as such a recommendation is provided below to retain the existing condition with a
               minor administrative amendment to change ‘use’ to ‘uses’.


               Condition 20 & 21
                      20.     Any street fencing along Douglas Lane must not exceed 1.8 metres in height, be set
                              back an average of 1 metre and articulated to provide visual interest by stepping the
                              design. Any fencing on the front boundary must either:
                                       a.   not exceed a maximum height of 1.2 metres
                                       b.   be of open construction.
                      21.     The area of land between the fence and the front property boundary must be densely
                              landscaped to screen any fencing from the street.
               Applicant’s Representation
               The applicant has requested Condition 20 be amended, stating:
                      No fence is proposed across the rear of the site apart from the proposed bin enclosure area.
                      Notwithstanding this, if a fence is ever proposed, the condition should be amended to be
                      setback an average of 2m. The reason for this is because the 1m access path to the bin
                      enclosure area would effectively preclude any landscaping from being visible from Douglas
                      Lane when applying a 1m average setback. Accordingly, we suggest an average 2m depth
                      would provide a more visually appealing outcome when being viewed from Douglas Lane.
                      The condition also refers to fencing along the front boundary. The proposal involves outdoor
                      dining along the Duke St frontage and no fencing is proposed. Accordingly, we request that
                      the reference to the front fence be deleted as per below:
                      Amended Condition 20
                      Any street fencing along Douglas Lane must not exceed 1.8 metres in height, be set back an
                      average of 1 2 metre and articulated to provide visual interest by stepping the design. Any
                      fencing on the front boundary must either:
                      a. not exceed a maximum height of 1.2 metres
                      b. be of open construction.
               The applicant has requested condition 21 be deleted, stating:
                      This condition appears to be applied through error, as no front fencing is proposed due to
                      the commercial premises being located on the Duke St frontage.
               Assessment of Representation
               Given the approval includes a built to boundary design on the Duke Street frontage, the fencing
               conditions were included for controlling fencing along the Dougal Lane frontage only, which was
               not clearly articulated in Conditions 20 and 21 in the original approval.
               Condition 20 is a standard condition applied to Material Change of Use approvals within the Tourist
               Accommodation zone where fencing has not necessarily been proposed as part of the MCU,
               however is acceptable under Noosa Plan 2020 in the form outlined in the condition. Should fencing
               be proposed in a subsequent Operational Works (landscaping) application, the proposal would be
               required to comply with the built form requirements of Condition 20. The condition includes
               reference to a 1m average setback along the frontage (which is required to be landscaped as per
               Condition 21). It is noted the condition relates to a minimum setback only, however this is not
               clearly articulated in the condition. A recommendation is therefore included in the conclusion to
               amend Condition 20 to reference the 1m average as a minimum setback, and as such the condition
               would not preclude the applicant increasing this average to 2m if more appropriate.
                                                                                                       Page 5 of 7

Document Set ID: 22836491
Version: 9, Version Date: 18/04/2024

Page 6

               Condition 21 is also a standard condition applied to all development within the Tourist
               Accommodation zone and is to be utilised in conjunction with Condition 20. As such, Condition 21
               is in reference to screening landscaping being necessary across the frontage of any potential
               fencing along the Douglas Lane boundary. As such, a change to the condition to reference the
               Douglas Lane frontage is included in the recommendation.


               3.     CONCLUSION & REASONS FOR DECISION
               RECOMMENDATION
               With regard to Application No. MCU23/0070 and the representations made, Council on 18 April
               2024 decided to:
               A.     Agree to amend conditions 3 and 4 to read as follows:
                      3.      Development authorised by this approval must be undertaken generally in accordance
                              with the Approved Plans listed in the tables below.

                                 Plan No.         Rev. Plan/Document Name                                     Date

                                 7252-DA06        19     Duke Street & Douglas Lane Floor Plans prepared 12.02.2024
                                                         by Blackburn Jackson

                                 7252-DA07        19     Floor Plan – Level 2 & Level 3 prepared by 12.02.2024
                                                         Blackburn Jackson

                                 7252-DA08        12     Roof Plan & Height Plane Projection prepared by 12.02.2024
                                                         Blackburn Jackson

                                 7252-DA14        12     Elevations prepared by Blackburn Jackson             12.02.2024

                                 7252-DA15        13     Sections prepared by Blackburn Jackson               12.02.2024

                                 7252-DA16        13     Sections prepared by Blackburn Jackson               12.02.2024

                                 7252-DALS02      09     Landscaping Planting – Duke Street prepared by 12.02.2024
                                                         Blackburn Jackson

                                 7252-DALS03      09     Landscaping Planting – Douglas Lane prepared by 12.02.2024
                                                         Blackburn Jackson

                                 7252-DALS04      09     Landscaping Planting – Level 2 prepared by 12.02.2024
                                                         Blackburn Jackson

                      4.      The premises must not be used to host events, functions or parties (e.g. bucks parties,
                              hen’s parties, raves, or wedding receptions).
               B.     Refuse to delete condition 21 as this is a standard condition applied to all development within
                      the Tourist Accommodation zone. A minor change to the condition to reference the Douglas
                      Street frontage has been made to clarify the condition.
               C.     Refuse to amend conditions 12 and 20 as per the applicant’s request:
                      a.      Condition 12 is a standard condition included on approvals to ensure impacts on
                              amenity are managed, and as such it is therefore considered unnecessary and
                              inappropriate to remove the condition. A minor change to correct a typing error has
                              been made to the condition.



                                                                                                        Page 6 of 7

Document Set ID: 22836491
Version: 9, Version Date: 18/04/2024

Page 7

                      b.      Condition 20 is a standard condition in accordance with fencing requirements in the
                              Tourist Accommodation zone. A minor change to the condition to clarify code
                              requirements (ie the inclusion of the word ‘minimum’) has been made to this condition,
                              which therefore would not preclude increasing the average setback if more appropriate.
               D.     Note the report is provided in accordance with Section 83(9) of the Planning Act 2016.




                                                                                                        Page 7 of 7

Document Set ID: 22836491
Version: 9, Version Date: 18/04/2024

Used in these records

About this file

File size
502 KB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Negotiated Report (Representations made) MCU23 0070.pdf · 502 KB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.