Original source · versioned page text
2019-12-16 Special Meeting Agenda
Text sections have not been matched to the original PDF pages. Use the original document to check page numbers.
SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA 16 DECEMBER 2019
ATTACHMENT 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Lambert Locations Pty Ltd Drain Tech Australia Pty Pipe Management Aussie Hydro-Vac Services Aussie Hydro-Vac Services FlowPro Pty Ltd - Environmental Services Pipe Vision Australia Pty Pipeline Technology Dynamic Hydro
PART A - Non price elements Interflow Pty Limited Dain Medics FlowPro Pty Ltd Relining Solutions Pty Ltd ProTerra Group Pty Ltd
t/as 1300B4UDIG Ltd Australia Pty Ltd - ALTERNATIVE Pty Ltd ALTERNATIVE Group Pty Ltd Ltd Services Excavations Pty Ltd
Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant Resultant
Evaluation Criteria Weighting (%) Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x Score score x
weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting weighting
Capability & Resourcing 15% 55 8.25 75.5 11.33 79.5 11.93 77 11.55 78.5 11.78 77 11.55 76.5 11.48 74 11.10 76.5 11.48 77.5 11.63 75 11.25 85 12.75 72 10.80 56 8.40 76 11.40
Contract Experience & Capacity 15% 40.2 6.03 77 11.55 80.8 12.12 80.8 12.12 82.6 12.39 80.8 12.12 75.2 11.28 68.2 10.23 75.2 11.28 81 12.15 75 11.25 85 12.75 74.2 11.13 55 8.25 75 11.25
Methodology 15% 41 6.15 78.5 11.78 80 12.00 81.5 12.23 79 11.85 80.5 12.08 71.5 10.73 70 10.50 71.5 10.73 80 12.00 69.5 10.43 88 13.20 61 9.15 54 8.10 64 9.60
Quality 10% 57 5.70 85 8.50 80.5 8.05 82 8.20 86 8.60 82 8.20 56 5.60 50.5 5.05 56 5.60 83.5 8.35 57 5.70 86.5 8.65 48 4.80 60.5 6.05 56.5 5.65
Health & Safety 5% 67 3.35 82.5 4.13 81 4.05 85 4.25 85.5 4.28 82.5 4.13 55 2.75 60 3.00 55 2.75 82 4.10 59 2.95 81 4.05 60 3.00 59.5 2.98 56.5 2.83
Environment & Sustainability 5% 84 4.20 89 4.45 87 4.35 87 4.35 87 4.35 87 4.35 50 2.50 50 2.50 50 2.50 87 4.35 50 2.50 90 4.50 50 2.50 85 4.25 53 2.65
Contribution to Local Economy 5% 49.05 2.45 56 2.80 58.6 2.93 56.25 2.81 53.1 2.66 56.25 2.81 69.9 3.50 67.45 3.37 69.9 3.50 45.9 2.30 53.3 2.67 53.9 2.70 53.4 2.67 40.85 2.04 68.75 3.44
Total Technical Score 70% 36.13 54.53 55.43 55.51 55.90 55.23 47.83 45.75 47.83 54.87 46.74 58.60 44.05 40.07 46.81
Normalised Technical Score (Tn) 43.17 65.14 66.21 66.31 66.77 65.98 57.13 54.66 57.13 65.55 55.84 70.00 52.62 47.87 55.92
Lambert Locations Pty Ltd Drain Tech Australia Pty Pipe Management Aussie Hydro-Vac Services Aussie Hydro-Vac Services FlowPro Pty Ltd - Environmental Services Pipe Vision Australia Pty Pipeline Technology Dynamic Hydro
PART B - Price element Interflow Pty Limited Dain Medics FlowPro Pty Ltd Relining Solutions Pty Ltd ProTerra Group Pty Ltd
t/as 1300B4UDIG Ltd Australia Pty Ltd - ALTERNATIVE Pty Ltd ALTERNATIVE Group Pty Ltd Ltd Services Excavations Pty Ltd
Total Fees (Pc) 30% $405,000 $434,060 $453,600 $518,738 $533,500 $567,818 $762,500 $960,960 $1,000,000 $1,046,332 $1,140,000 $1,228,950 $1,241,565 $1,251,000 $2,885,200
Average Fees (Pav) $......................... $961,948
Price Score 158 155 153 146 145 141 121 100 96 91 81 72 71 70 -100
Normalised Price Score (Pn) 100 98 97 93 92 89 76 63 61 58 52 46 45 44 1
Weighted Price Score (Pw) 30.00 29.43 29.04 27.75 27.46 26.78 22.94 19.02 18.25 17.33 15.48 13.73 13.48 13.29 0.30
Total Score of price and non price elements 73.17 94.56 95.25 94.07 94.24 92.77 80.07 73.68 75.38 82.88 71.32 83.73 66.10 61.16 56.22
Assessment Panel Position Title
Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member 1 Asset Planning Manager, Infrastructure Services
Assesment Panel Member 2 Technical Officer - Capital Planning, Infrastructure Services
Assesment Panel Member 3 Designer - Capital Works, Infrastructure Services
Assesment Panel Member 4 Workplace Health and Safety Advisor, Executive Services
Page 6 of 25
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalLog in to download the original file
Large file: the download may take up to a minute.
Searchable page text hides email addresses. Original files are unchanged and may show email addresses.