Council archive · source document
Response to 2nd Council Information Request · MCU22/0118
Court Appeals & Dispute Resolution
Applications & Assessment
Due Diligence & Compliance
Project Management
General Development Advice
Friday, 21st July 2023
Our Ref: 18006
Council Ref: MCU22/0118
Chief Executive Officer
Noosa Council
PO Box 141
Tewantin QLD 4565
By Email: [email protected]
Attention: Tara Norley, Development Planner
Dear Tara,
Development Application for a Material Change of Use for Short-term accommodation
and new lagoon pool at the “RACV Noosa Resort”, 94 and 142 Noosa Drive, Noosa
Heads, described as Lot 3 on SP126203, Lot 0 on SP203417 and Lot 203 on SP267424
Reference is made to the request for further information dated 6 April 2023. Further, to the
onsite inspection with Noosa Council officers and the consultants engaged by the applicant
to discuss the changes being made to the proposal and to understand the environmental
values and the nature of the site more generally.
Pursuant to section 25 of the Development Assessment Rules, the applicant is making a minor
change to the proposal in response to the issues raised in the request for further information.
The notice of change includes the following:
• Letter from Adamson Town Planning, including:
o Attachment 1A & 1B – Amended Proposal Plans;
o Attachment 2 – Concept Rehabilitation Plan;
o Attachment 3 – Further advice from Consult Arborist;
o Attachment 4A & 4B – Amended Stormwater Management Plan and further
advice from ADG;
o Attachment 5 – Further advice from Gondwana Ecology;
o Attachment 6 – Further advice from Ecoteam;
o Attachment 7A & 7B – Updated Bushfire Hazard Assessment and Mitigation
Plan and further advice from Rob Friend and Associates; and
o Attachment 8 – Construction Methodology by Aspect Architects.
Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
(ACN: 163 798 374 | ABN: 73 163 798 374)
M| 0437 754 420 Mail: PO Box 894, Cooroy QLD 4563
‘Noosa Boardroom’, 28 Eenie Creek Road, Noosaville QLD 4566
Email| [email protected] Web| www.adamsontownplanning.com.au
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 16 pages
Page 2
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
A summary of the key changes made is provided below:
Cabin 1:
• The number of cabins has been reduced by one (1) to provide 15 cabins in eight (8)
buildings;
• Cabin 1 has been relocated to above the carpark which reduces the overall
development footprint and the impact on the site;
• The location of Cabin 1 means that no development is now proposed within the
riparian area towards the northwest with no bushfire mitigation measures necessary
within this area, which also provides for the full rehabilitation of this area;
• A minimal amount of development now encroaches within the Environmental and
Management Conservation Zone towards the northwest where the small area of
riparian vegetation is located; and
• The bio-detention basin has been resized and shaped to better service the
development following the onsite conductivity tests undertaken and is located within
the existing cleared area beside Cabin 1 and at the end of the carpark.
Cabins 02 – 07:
• These cabins have been realigned where possible to allow for more tree retention with
confirmation also provided about the retention of some trees close to the cabins,
following an analysis by the arborist and project architect, with the cabin locations
having been surveyed and pegged.
Cabins 8 & 9:
• Cabins 8 & 9 have been separated from Cabins 10 & 11 to allow for better integration
onsite and reduce the appearance of building bulk near the Noosa Drive frontage;
• The separation of these cabins also allows for an overall reduction in the amount of
elevated timber boardwalk and allows for the retention of two (2) additional trees; and
• The removal of the boardwalk from within the 6m building setback area provides for a
greater area near the frontage that can be rehabilitated with dense vegetation to
screen/buffer the development and maintain a vegetated corridor along Noosa Drive.
2|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 3
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
Figure 1 – Site Plan Tree Retention/Removal
A copy of the amended proposal plans is provided as Attachments 1A & 1B. A new Concept
Rehabilitation Plan is provided as Attachment 2. The former Landscape Concept Package no
longer forms part of the application material. Further, advice has also been provided by
Consult Arborist which is provided as Attachment 3.
The new Concept Rehabilitation Plan has been prepared by Dr Watson (in consultation with
the project arborist, koala expert, bushfire consultant and stormwater engineer) and provides
for five (5) planting zones as shown. The planting pallet has also been carefully considered
for the following zones:
• Zone 1 – Wetland Rehabilitation (northwest), with no fire mitigation now required
within this area of the site;
• Zone 2 – Rehabilitated Screen across the frontage adjoining Noosa Drive;
• Zone 3 – Detention Basin with suitable species provided;
• Zone 4 – Bushfire (APZ) Management, which provides for weed control, ground covers
and low shrubs with the existing mature vegetation able to be maintained;
• Zone 5 – Balance Rehabilitation Area providing for intense weed control, dense ground
covers amongst the elevated cabins and boardwalk with interplanting allowed with
smooth bark koala and other tree species.
3|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 4
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
In summary, the changes made to the proposal are in direct response to the issues raised in
the request for further information. Following further deliberations with the ecology, koala,
bushfire experts and the arborist, the applicant has reduced the number of units being
proposed and relocated Unit 1 to above the carpark.
This change reduces the overall impact on the site, in particular, near the riparian area to the
northwest with no bushfire mitigation now required in this area. The onsite inspection with the
cabin locations surveyed has also resulted in more confidence about the trees that can be
retained. Overall, there is a net increase in the number of koala habitat trees being retained on
the site and less site disturbance with ongoing tree and weed management (refer Attachment
3).
It should be noted that under the Tourist Accommodation Zone Code, performance outcome
PO7 specifically identifies the site (Lot 203 on SP267424) to be used for a resort complex and
short-term accommodation, which is currently the case. The proposed development
adjoins/extends across land included within the same zone and is to be integrated and
amalgamated with the existing RACV Resort.
Request for Further Information
Issue – Stormwater Quality Targets and Treatment Device Details
Information Required:
1. Provide an updated SWMP, MUSIC model and preliminary engineering plans which address
the following:
1.1. Provide geotechnical borehole and test results demonstrating that the proposed ‘pipeless’
bioretention will function at the proposed location by providing the following for the
bioretention location: In-situ Soil classification, Groundwater level (BGL and mAHD), and
In-situ saturated hydraulic conductivity test results at proposed level of bioretention base
1.2. Demonstrate that the In-situ saturated hydraulic conductivity results have been correctly
applied to the MUSIC model. These rates should be applied as the bioretention design
saturated hyd cond
1.3. Provide updated plans showing the spatial requirements for the updated (enlarged) pipeless
bioretention system
1.4. Provide details of the rainfall-runoff and pollutant export parameters adopted for the source
nodes in the MUSIC modelling (pre-development and post-development scenarios)
1.5. Show how the rainwater tank overflows and the runoff from the raised walkways will
physically be able to drain to the proposed bioretention device, as assumed in the MUSIC
model
4|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 5
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
With respect to the stormwater quality and treatment issues raised, the applicant has provided
an amended Stormwater Management Plan (refer Attachment 4A). Further, the hydraulic
engineer has provided a response to the items listed above (refer Attachment 4B).
The hydraulic engineer has concluded that the proposed development achieves all
requirements for Site Based Stormwater Management Plans as described in the State Planning
Policy (2017), Noosa Shire Council Planning Scheme Policies, Queensland Urban Drainage
Manual (QUDM) 2016, Plumbing and Drainage Code AS3500.3 and the Australian Rainfall and
Runoff Guideline (ARR).
Issue – Vegetation Removal
Information Required
2. Demonstrate compliance with PO1 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay
Code.
With respect to the issue of vegetation removal, Dr Watson has addressed this issue in the
further advice that has been provided (refer Attachment 5). The tree survey and the location
of the cabins with respect to the trees have been checked on site.
It is noted that part of the development, including part of Cabin 1, part of the carpark and the
existing access are located within the existing RACV Resort (Lot 203), which is already
developed and assists in reducing the overall impact of the development within Lot 3.
In summary, Dr Watson has confirmed that 242 native trees have been surveyed on site with
the following being retained and removed:
• 160 will be retained (previously this was 142);
• 71 will be removed (previously this was 89); and
• 11 are proposed to be retained and will require arborist review and advice during
construction, which are labelled TBC (previously this was 20).
With respect to the trees that have been surveyed, 150 are, by “State” definition koala trees,
with:
• 117 to be retained (previously this was 110);
• 27 will be removed (previously this was 44); and
• six (6) are proposed to be retained and will require arborist review and advice during
construction (previously this was 10).
Dr Watson has undertaken a closer analysis of the 71 native trees (of which 27 are defined as
koala trees) that will be removed and advises that of the 27 koala trees to be removed:
• 11 are eucalyptus and 16 are paperbarks;
• Of the 16 paperbarks, at least five have been planted (as part of the resort development
to the north); and
5|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 6
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
• 10 of the swamp mahogany (E.robusta) described as being in poor condition, nearly
dead or vine engulfed – meaning only one of the trees to be removed is in reasonable
condition.
Consequently, despite the number of trees to be removed on the site for the development,
there is only one relatively healthy swamp mahogany and 11 naturally occurring paperbarks,
that will be removed.
An enormous amount of ground truthing work has been undertaken to provide the
development proposal in its current form. There is a clear intent to retain the vegetation on
the site given the elevated nature of the development, being integrated within the existing
vegetation.
As stated by Dr Watson, the amended layout, with a smaller building footprint and realigned
structures, has increased tree retention (including koala trees), has reduced the number of
trees to be confirmed by the arborist (less uncertainty) and increased the overall greenspace
and rehabilitation opportunities1. Dr Watson has addressed the relevant provisions under the
Biodiversity Overlay Code (refer Section 8 - Attachment 5).
The applicant is also making representations to the State Assessment Referral Agency (SARA)
to have the state approved environmental covenant area amended to be consistent with the
amended proposal. The advice provided by the experts including ecology and bushfire, is
consistent with the proposed Concept Rehabilitation Plan provided as Attachment 2.
With respect to the performance outcome PO1, Dr Watson has advised that:
• The subject land is not pristine or in good condition and is not considered an
“ecologically important area”.
• The development aims to incorporate the vegetation that does have value, remove the
weeds which dominate, and reinstate with native species from the local regional
ecosystem.
• Existing habitat areas and ecological linkages are maintained and will be enhanced
because the development either avoids these areas entirely or the development has
been designed to accommodate connections and habitat values; and
• Existing riparian vegetation, waterways and wetland habitat values are protected
(avoided), suitably buffered with setbacks and will be rehabilitated2.
The proposed development complies with performance outcome PO1.
Issue – Ecological Important Areas
Information Required
1
Ecology advice by Gondwana Ecology, dated 4 July 2023, page 4
2
Ecology further advice by Gondwana Ecology, Attachment E2, page 19
6|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 7
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
3. Demonstrate compliance with PO3 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay
Code.
With respect to compliance with performance outcome PO3, Dr Watson has advised that
ground truthing has revealed the site currently could not be considered to be an important
ecological area for reasons explained (refer Attachment 5). Further, while the proposed
development will result in a loss of some habitat values; this is limited to a few trees, the impact
of which would be adequately accommodated through rehabilitation in accordance with the
Concept Rehabilitation Plan.
The proposed rehabilitation is consistent with the bushfire mitigation required and will provide
for the on-going maintenance to support a regional ecosystem characteristic of RE12.2.7,
which will improve the current and overall ecological values for the land. The amended layout
has further reduced the impact (extent) on the land and retains more trees. The tree analysis
included illustrates few trees of any ecological value will be removed. The development is also
setback from the riparian area to the northwest and the rehabilitation areas are now greater
and consistent with all site and ecological requirements.
While the SARA approval is to be amended to be consistent with amended proposal plan,
measures have been identified to enhance the site for koalas, which are discussed by Dr Ellis
(refer Attachment 6). These actions will also benefit the overall ecology/biodiversity more
generally. The rehabilitation proposed will greatly enhance the ecology values noting the
existing condition and context of the site, which is considered to result in a net
gain/enhancement3. Consequently, the proposed development complies with performance
outcome PO3.
Issue – Connecting Habitat Areas
Information Required
4. Demonstrate compliance with PO5 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay
Code and PO26 of the Noosa Heads Local Plan Code.
5. Provide a revised development layout that demonstrates no significant adverse impacts by
providing the development footprint outside the areas identified as a connecting habitat
identified on Map SFM-4 – Biodiversity (Strategic Framework).
Dr Watson has advised the entire site is mapped as connecting habitat as are large areas in
the locality. Further, I agree with Dr Watson that an important consideration is the large portion
of the site included within the Tourism Accommodation Zone (TAZ) and intended only for
visitor accommodation, which is proposed.
3
Ecology further advice by Gondwana Ecology, Attachment E2, page 20
7|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 8
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
I agree with Dr Watson that in the circumstances avoiding areas of “connecting habitat” is not
possible on the site to establish a tourism development, in accordance with the TAZ, but it is
accepted that an appropriate balance between allowing some development for visitor
accommodation and the environmental values is to be achieved. The SFM4 mapping reflects
the actual connections in the landscape, which are not being comprised, with the development
being carefully considered and integrated within this vegetated setting.
Further responses are provided to performance outcomes PO5 and PO26 in the table at
Attachment E2 (Attachment 5). Dr Watson advises that with the changes that have been made,
there is an even greater area for the north south connection with Cabin 1 located above the
carpark. Further, the riparian area to the northwest is to be completely rehabilitated and is not
affected by bushfire mitigation.
With respect to PO5, I agree with Dr Watson that it is also important to appreciate that the
original layout had input from both koala experts (Dr Carrick and Dr Ellis), with this layout
being approved by SARA, with particular interest in koala movement. It is logical that a design
that facilitates koala movement would also provide suitable movement opportunities for other
native fauna. Consequently, the proposed development has been designed and will be
operated to maintain and enhance the connectivity, when considering the significant impact
the invasive weed species (Frangipani vine) is currently having across the site, which will be
remedied.
With respect to PO26, Dr Watson (along with the advice from other experts) has confirmed
that the development will not have a significant impact on the site and will enhance the current
biodiversity, natural vegetation, native fauna habitat, landscape quality and water quality and
is consistent with this performance outcome when all matters are considered.
Issue – Development within Waterways and Wetlands Areas
Information Required
6. Provide a revised development footprint that demonstrates compliance with PO6 by avoiding
all new development within the riparian buffer area and MSES wetland areas.
Dr Watson has confirmed, the riparian mapping under the Biodiversity, Waterways and
Wetlands Overlay does not reflect the actual ground conditions4 (refer Attachment 5). The
amended layout, nevertheless, substantially reduces the impact on the mapped area to the
northwest where it represents, a “natural” landform. Further, the revised design minimises
impact on the actual riparian values and allows for the area to be rehabilitated. There is now
no bushfire restrictions for the rehabilitation in this area, as detailed under the Zone 1 of the
Concept Rehabilitation Plan (refer Attachment 2)5.
4
Further advice by Gondwana Ecology, page 5
5
Further advice from Gondwana Ecology, page 7
8|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 9
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
Dr Watson has confirmed that mapped riparian area within the site to the west, which is
included within the Environmental Management and Conservation Zone, does not have the
riparian buffer values and does not form part of the wetland. This is because of the altered
ground levels on this part of the site, including the construction of a historic retaining wall,
which was discussed at the site meeting. The cabins have been partly located within this part
of the site deliberately in order to protect more important koala vegetation within the TAZ as
shown on the tree retention and removal plans (Attachment 1A).
Having regard to the advice provided by Dr Watson, the proposed development protects the
biodiversity and ecosystem values of waterways, wetlands and adjacent riparian areas and is
consistent with performance outcome PO6.
Issue – Koala Habitat
Information Required
7. Provide a revised tree retention plans that integrates all bushfire, ecology, tree, and landscape
recommendations and utilises this information to demonstrate how the development has
protected and enhanced koalas and koala habitat and avoids adverse impacts, both direct
and indirect.
As explained by Dr Watson in his further advice (and above), the changes made to the proposal
improves the overall level of tree protection on the land and also reduces the development
footprint. The retention of the trees on the land and the bushfire mitigation measures have
been considered by Dr Watson and by Mr Friend in the revised bushfire advice provided as
Attachments 7A & 7B. Further, Dr Watson, in collaboration with the other experts has
prepared the Concept Rehabilitation Plan, which provides the consistency between the
bushfire, ecology, tree retention/removal and rehabilitation within five (5) separate zones (refer
Attachment 2).
As explained above, the SARA approved layout had been designed with input from the two
koala experts in order to retain sufficient koala habitat and allow koala movement (by design)
through and around the site. The proposed rehabilitation would also see the removal of the
invasive Frangipani vine, which has engulfed the site and the E.robusta trees, providing little
value to koalas currently, and provides for replanting koala feed trees (listed in Council’s PSP
Landscaping)6.
The approval by SARA provides for an environmental covenant to be placed throughout the
site, which is to be amended to reflect the latest proposal plans. As explained by Dr Watson,
the amended layout retains more trees than the State approved development plus allows for
more areas to be rehabilitated with less bushfire mitigation required. The SARA approval also
provides for koala signage to be erected in Noosa Drive and Leslie Drive, as shown on the
6
Further ecology advice from Gondwana Ecology, page 7
9|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 10
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
Indicative Koala Signage Plan, this being an initiative undertaken by the applicant to improve
safety for koala (refer Attachment 1B).
The koala issue has been carefully considered by Dr Ellis, who has provided further advice as
Attachment 6. Dr Ellis advises in his conclusion, that a “long term” view is required, which
must evaluate the long-term prognosis and scenarios for this site. Dr Ellis advises that the
current trajectory is toward decreased koala value on site through the loss of food resources
and impeded movement across the ground. It is unlikely that, without intervention, the site
will provide habitat resources to koalas in the long term. Dr Ellis advises that various
interventions could reverse this outcome, and the current proposal has been considered
accordingly. As stated by the arborist, it is proposed that trees be managed where close to
buildings and not removed (Attachment 3).
Dr Ellis states … there are several conditions around tree retention, ground cover and fencing
that could improve safety and facility on site for koalas, compared with the long-term projected
outcomes under the status quo, which lead me to judge that, on balance, adverse impacts will
not flow from the current proposal. Retention of significant food resources, tree and site
management that leads to improved tree health, an open planning of the structures with raised
boardwalks to facilitate koala travel (combined with prohibition on pet access) are objectives met
in the current proposal. The impact of removing the small number of food trees (many of which
are in poor condition) can be negated through replanting and with the nourishment of existing
trees on the site, whilst opportunities for travel by koalas should be improved with the
management of ground cover.7
Given the advice provided by Dr Watson and Dr Ellis, the proposed development has been
designed and will be constructed and operated to protect and enhance koalas and koala
habitat and will reduce the known adverse impacts (the invasive Frangipani vine). Further, will
assist in the survival of any koala in the locality without increasing the threats, and provides
for the safe movement of koala through the site, consistent with performance outcome PO11.
Issue – Bushfire Management within Biodiversity Areas
Information Required
8. Provided a revised tree retention plans that integrate all bushfire, ecology, tree, and
landscape recommendations and utilises this information to demonstrate how the
development maintain and enhance biodiversity.
The amended design has removed/relocated the cabins that originally caused bushfire
management maintenance to extend further west, which led to some conflict with retaining
the environmental values on the land, in particular the riparian area. In accordance with the
Conceptual Rehabilitation Plan, Zone 1 is now free of any bushfire requirements and Dr
Watson has confirmed the planted species within this location and Zone 5 (amongst the
7
Further koala advice from Ecoteam, pages 6 & 7
10 | P a g e
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 11
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
cabins) will comprise species typical of RE12.2.7. This includes groundcover, mid-storey and
trees.
The bushfire expert has provided an amended Bushfire Hazard Assessment and Mitigation
Plan (Attachment 7A). Both the bushfire expert and arborist have confirmed the planting list
for each zone, which provides for extensive weed management initially (and ongoing) and will
deliver a net ecological benefit on the land. Further, the species selected will ensure a low
bushfire risk without reducing the biodiversity values (refer Attachment 7B).
Mr Friend has confirmed that with respect to the bushfire fire risk, there is now no restriction
for Zone 1, Zone 4 is to be managed as the bushfire (APZ) management area and Zone 5
around the cabins can provide for interplanting with smooth-bark koala and other trees
species (refer Attachment 2).
The proposed development has adopted bushfire management measures that are based on
ecological principles consistent with performance outcome PO12 under the Biodiversity,
Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code.
Issue – Scenic Amenity
Information Required
9. Demonstrate compliance with AO13.1 by retaining all native vegetation (trees, shrubs, and
groundcovers) within 10 metres of the major road network.
The proposed development is setback about 6m from the Noosa Drive frontage. The elevated
timber boardwalk has mostly been removed and relocated from the frontage with alternative
access provided to Cabins 8 & 9, which have also been realigned to maintain mostly a 6m
building setback, with the exception of a small deck area (refer Site Plan - Attachment 1). It is
noted that Cabins 8 & 9 and Cabins 10 & 11 have been separated to allow for the new
boardwalk location and access to the cabins, which also reduces the building bulk being
presented to Noosa Drive. The building setback area is also to be screened under the Concept
Rehabilitation Plan (Attachment 2).
The majority of the trees within the front 6m building setback area will be retained, as shown
on Figure 1, above. Importantly, Zone 2 on the Concept Rehabilitation Plan is to be comprise
dense planting along the eastern and southern boundary with suitable native species, which
is to achieve mid to high strata screening of the development and including scattered koala
feed trees. This area also has no bushfire restriction in terms of the types of trees able to be
planted. The detail of the screening that will be achieved is a matter that can be provided at
the operational works stage.
It is noted the 10m building setback requirement is an acceptable outcome under AO13.1. The
development proposal is required to meet the performance outcome PO13, which seeks to
11 | P a g e
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 12
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
ensure the scenic amenity and vegetated character of the landscape is protected by retaining
vegetation along the major road network.
The proposed development does not remove important vegetation fronting Noosa Drive and
will substantially increase the amount of planting in this location. Further, the development
will not be visible from Weyba Road because of the amount of screening vegetation provided
to the south and west, with the development being two (2) storeys in height. The proposed
development will not have an impact on the scenic amenity and the vegetated character of
the major road network and complies with performance outcome PO13.
Issue – MSES Wetland
Information Required
10. Provide a revised ecological assessment that addresses the direct and indirect impacts this
development will have on the MSES wetlands and what mitigation measures have been
implemented to demonstrate no impacts will occur.
The cabins have been decreased in number by one (1) with Cabin 1 now being located to
above the carpark, further reducing the development footprint. There is now no built form
near the riparian area to the northwest, and Dr Watson has confirmed there will no direct
impact on the “wetland” area. Further, there is no bushfire mitigation works required within
this area as confirmed by Mr Friend 8 . Further, Dr Watson has prepared the Concept
Rehabilitation Plan, which clearly identifies the planting zones and the species to be provided,
which has been prepared in collaboration with the other experts. There is no restriction to the
planting within Zone 1, which is to be rehabilitated.
Issue – Threatened Ecological Community
Information Required
11. :
1. Provide sufficient information to demonstrate that the development will not have a
significant impact on the critically endangered ecological community. This must include:
11.1. demonstration that the development will not reduce the extent of an ecological
community.
2. fragment or increase fragmentation of an ecological community, for example by clearing
vegetation for roads, transmission lines or infrastructure.
3. adversely affect habitat critical to the survival of an ecological community.
8
Advice from Rob Friend and Associates, page 2, part 4
12 | P a g e
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 13
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
4. modify or destroy abiotic (non-living) factors (such as water, nutrients, or soil) necessary for
an ecological community’s survival, including reduction of groundwater levels, or substantial
alteration of surface water drainage patterns.
5. cause a substantial change in the species composition of an occurrence of an ecological
community, including causing a decline or loss of functionally important species.
6. cause a substantial reduction in the quality or integrity of an occurrence of an ecological
community, including, but not limited to: – assisting invasive species, that are harmful to the
listed ecological community, to become established, or – causing regular mobilisation of
fertilisers, herbicides or other chemicals or pollutants into the ecological community which
kill or inhibit the growth of species in the ecological community, or
7. interfere with the recovery of an ecological community.
8. demonstrate that a referral application is not required.
Dr Watson has explained in the further advice provided that Commonwealth matters are
separate to this application. It is acknowledged that the subject land supports an ecosystem
with characteristics of RE12.2.7, which can, under certain circumstances, be a Threatened
Ecological Community (TEC). However, Dr Watson has advised that the site is highly disturbed.
The aerial photography provided shows the site has been cleared in its entirety in the past
(refer Attachment 5). Further, the site inspection and background information provided along
with limited clearing proposed would not cause a significant impact.
Dr Watson has confirmed that due to historical clearing, earthworks and the invasive vine, the
site has essentially no native understorey or mid-storey and is not consistent with
Commonwealth Conservation advice for a TEC. Further, … the vegetation on the site is “not
protected”, not a TEC and the proposed development would not have a significant impact on a
TEC, i.e. a Matter of National Ecological Significance. A referral to the Commonwealth is not
required.9
Further Information
12. Provide revised development plans that incorporates a development footprint that does not
require vegetation clearing and ongoing maintenance to facilitate the development.
As explained above, the amended cabin layout with Cabin 1 located above the carpark has
removed the need for the bushfire management asset protection zone (APS) from extending
into the primarily riparian area to the northwest shown as Zone 1 on the Concept
Rehabilitation Zone provided (Attachment 2). The APZ is provided as Zone 4 and includes
Zone 3, being the bio-detention basin.
9
Further ecology advice Gondwana Ecology, page 10
13 | P a g e
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 14
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
Both of these zones provide for specific planting to prevent further tree removal and to provide
bushfire mitigation for the development, as detailed in the further advice provided by the
bushfire expert (refer Attachments 7A & 7B). Further, Consult Arborist has explained that
RACV has a continuing tree management plan in place that has been ongoing for an extended
period of time for the existing resort, which will be extended to include the proposd
development (refer Attachment 3).
The intent for this part of the resort is to provide a different visitor accommodation experience,
when compared to the existing resort, with the development integrated within the site. This
will come at higher maintenance and management cost, which is expected and accepted by
the applicant. It is suggested that in the circumstances, RACV is the only operator capable of
achieving this outcome, with minimal site disturbance, with some of the development also
extending into the existing RAVC Resort.
Information Required
13. Demonstrate compliance with PO6 of the Bushfire Hazard Overlay Code
The proposed development does not provide for any new roads with the existing access being
utilised to access the site. The land will be amalgamated, and the existing access easement
extinguished. Consequently, the performance outcome PO6 is not relevant to the assessment.
Despite this, Mr Friend has addressed this issue in the further bushfire advice provided (refer
Attachment 7B), including:
• No vehicle accessible fire breaks being required or proposed;
• All emergency services will use the existing access roads;
• Safe access and egress will be in accordance with the Emergency Response Plan for
RACV; and
• Hydrant stand pipes to be provided as required, with all infrastructure to be suspended
under the proposed boardwalk.
The proposed development is able to comply with the required bushfire mitigation
requirements without adversely impacting on the environmental values and will be designed
in this manner, consistent with performance outcome PO2. Further, can provide an adequate
water supply for firefighting purposes, which is reliable, safely located and freely accessible
consistent with performance outcome PO3. The site provides for easy and safe evacuation of
residents and access for emergency services to Noosa Drive and internally to the existing RACV
Resort, consistent with performance outcome PO6.
Information Required
14. Provide amended plans complying with the maximum 8m height limit.
14 | P a g e
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 15
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
The proposed development provides for 15, two (2) storey cabins which is consistent with
TAZC, performance outcome PO9(f)(iii)(B), being on Lot 3 on SP126203 and Lot 203 on
SP267424. While the development marginally exceeds the 8m height requirement under
acceptable solution AO9.1, the amount of exceedance is minimal and the development is to
comply with the performance outcome.
A copy of the floorplans, elevations and sections is provided as Attachment 1B. As can be
seen in the section drawings, some of the roof lines marginally exceed the 8m height
requirement. It is noted that the cabins closest to Noosa Drive are Cabins 6 & 7, 8 & 9 and 10
&11, and have the following attributes:
• The roof line for Cabins 6 & 7 is below 8m near the road frontage and marginally
exceeds the 8m height requirement by about 450mm for a length of about 2.2m of the
roof line towards the rear of the cabins and will not be visible and discernible off the
site;
• The roof line for Cabins 8 & 9 are below the 8m height requirement; and
• The roof line for Cabins 10 & 11 are below the 8m height requirement.
While the roof lines for Cabins 1, 2 & 3 and 4 & 5 also exceed the height limit in part, this is
marginal, with these cabins not being visible from the surrounding road network and other
properties. Consequently, the proposed development provides for buildings that:
a) are low rise and have a building height consistent, and in fact less than the height of
the structures within the RACV Resort;
b) will not visually dominate the street, being located behind dense screening vegetation
as shown on the Landscape Concept Plan (Zone 2);
c) will preserve the amenity of surrounding premises;
d) respects the scale of the existing vegetation and is integrated on the site;
e) responds appropriately to the topography being elevated and lightweight to minimise
site disturbance and is importantly allow for connectivity through the site; and
f) will not exceed two storeys.
The proposed built form complies with performance outcome PO9.
Information Required
15. Provide amended plans:
15.1. Increasing the setback to Noosa Drive to ensure no impacts on the visual amenity and
character of the area when viewed from Noosa Drive.
15.2. removing all buildings and structures from the mapped riparian buffer area.
With respect to part 15.1 above, the matter of the building setbacks and the vegetation
screening have been discussed. The plans have been amended to remove the boardwalk
mostly from the 6m building setback area required under acceptable outcome AO13.1(a) for
Noosa Heads. No vegetation is required to be removed from the Noosa Drive frontage with
the exception of one (1) tree shown on Site Plan -Tree Retention/Removal (refer Figure 1). As
15 | P a g e
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 16
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
discussed, the other trees are to be retained and the frontage is to be rehabilitated, including
mid to high strata planting and scattered koala feed trees.
With respect to part 15.2, as discussed above, Dr Watson has confirmed that the mapped
riparian areas to the west and contained within the EMCZ, are disturbed and do not provide
riparian values. Further, this is the reason for the inclusion of this land within the EMCZ, which
is at odds with the ground truthing undertaken on the site. Further, while still partly located
within the EMCZ, the cabins have been realigned following the onsite inspection with the cabin
locations surveyed. The cabin locations have been chosen for the primary reason to protect
the koala trees within the site, this being the primary environmental objective.
Figure 2 – Extract of Zoning Plan
In summary, having regard to the advice provided by the other experts, the proposed
development is consistent with the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetland Overlay Code for
reasons already explained. Further, is not inconsistent with the Environmental Management
and Conservation Zone, given the ecological important areas on the site are being maintained
and enhanced. Further, the development avoids and mitigates against adverse impacts on the
values and processes within ecological important areas, which must be considered in context
with the majority of the important koala habitat being retained within the TAZ10.
Information Required
10
Environmental Management and Conservation Zone, purpose & overall outcomes (a) & (b)
16 | P a g e
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Page 17
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
16. Provide evidence that the proposal can be constructed on site and operate whilst complying
with the SARA conditions and covenant requirements in perpetuity.
Representations are required to be made to SARA because of the changes made to the
proposal plans, in particular with respect to the deletion of a cabin and relocation of Cabin 1
above the carpark. Consequently, the plans approved by SARA are to be amended to be
consistent with the required covenant area shown on the Site Plan. Representations to SARA
are to be made concurrently.
The project architect for the development has provided a Construction Methodology for the
development which is provided as Attachment 8. Further, the arborist has also provided
advice about the ongoing management of the site and that some tree pruning required to
facilitate the construction phase, and to accommodate any safety scaffolding, etc.
(Attachment 3)
The location and nature of the trees with respect to the cabin locations has been determined
on site, which provides some comfort for the construction phase. The arborist has stated that
… in some cases, it has been observed that certain trees naturally grow away from the cabins,
reducing conflicts and encroachment concerns. This proactive approach allows for a balance
between the preservation of trees and the successful completion of construction activities.11 A
Construction Management Plan will be required for the development, which is a matter that
can be conditioned.
Development Assessment Rules
Under section 26.1 of the Development Assessment Rules, the changes made to the proposal
plans are in response to the request for further information, and in any event are considered
minor and the development assessment process has not stopped. The application is currently
in the decision stage, which has been extend by agreement to 21 September 2023; however,
it is noted the applicant will be making representations to SARA about the referral agency
conditions under section 28.
Should you have any questions with respect to the above, please contact me.
Yours faithfully
Shane Adamson
Shane Adamson (BEngTech, GDURP, MPIA, MQELA)
Town Planning Specialist
Director - Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
11
Consult Arborist advice, page 4
17 | P a g e
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, July 2023
Used in these records
Response to 2nd Council Information Request.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 740 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.