Council archive · source document
Response to submissions · MCU22/0118
Court Appeals & Dispute Resolution
Applications & Assessment
Due Diligence & Compliance
Project Management
General Development Advice
Monday, 6th March 2023
Our Ref: 18006
Council Ref: MCU22/0118
Chief Executive Officer
Noosa Council
PO Box 141
Tewantin QLD 4565
By Email: [email protected]
Attention: Tara Norley, Development Planner
Dear Tara,
Development Application for a Material Change of Use for Short-term accommodation
and new lagoon pool at the “RACV Noosa Resort”, 94 and 142 Noosa Drive, Noosa
Heads, described as Lot 3 on SP126203, Lot 0 on SP203417 and Lot 203 on SP267424
Reference is made to the submissions received during public notification of the
abovementioned development application.
While there were a number of submissions lodged in objection to the proposal, there were
also submissions lodged in support. There are also a few late submissions received after the
public notification period.
The majority of the submissions received in objection were primarily from concerned local
residents, with some submissions from residents from the Sunshine Coast and a community
group, this being the Noosa Parks Association. The submissions provided in support are also
primarily from local residents, local businesses and prominent local business groups. The
business groups that have lodged a submission in support, include the following:
• Noosa Chamber of Commerce;
• Noosaville Business Association;
• Tourism Noosa;
• Hastings Street Association; and
• Noosa Junction Association.
Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
(ACN: 163 798 374 | ABN: 73 163 798 374)
M| 0437 754 420 Mail: PO Box 894, Cooroy QLD 4563
‘Noosa Boardroom’, 28 Eenie Creek Road, Noosaville QLD 4566
Email| [email protected] Web| www.adamsontownplanning.com.au
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 5 pages
Page 2
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
It is also noted that one of the late submissions received was from the Queensland Koala
Crusaders (QKC). The QKC have recognised the benefit of the development in terms of the
planned and needed rehabilitation of the site and also have appreciated the extensive design
exercise that has been undertaken to maximise tree retention and minimise the impact on
koala habitat. The QKC have also openly stated they have no objection to the proposal.
Since public notification commenced, the State Assessment Referral Agency (SARA) has
provided its referral agency response and approved the development subject to a number of
conditions (discussed below). The conditions were discussed with and accepted by the
applicant. In this case, SARA is the lead agency for the koala issue, with the referral being
triggered under Schedule 10, Part 10, Division 3 – Development within koala habitat in the SEQ
Region under the Planning Regulation 2017.
With respect to the submissions in objection, including the late submission, the following are
the common themes, which are broadly summarised below:
• Adverse environmental impacts caused because of a loss of koala habitat on the site
and consequently adverse impacts caused to the local koala population, which is listed
as an endangered species.
• The site is designated a Core Koala Habitat Area and therefore should be protected
from development.
• The development will cause adverse impacts to the local koala population during
construction, from lighting and increased traffic movements and from drowning in the
proposed new pool.
• The payment of an environmental offset for the loss of koala habitat is not the panacea
or solution to allowing the development on the land.
• Noosa does not need more short-term accommodation (STA), which is currently
saturated within Noosa, with added impacts being caused in terms of increased traffic
congestion, lack of parking and impacts on other infrastructure.
• There is a compelling economic and social argument for this development to not be
supported given the current lack of affordable housing and a lack of need for additional
short-term accommodation.
• Noosa is a Biosphere and should be protected as such but is becoming overdeveloped
which impacts on this status.
• The development is only slightly different to the previous approval on the site and
should be refused for the same reasons.
• The invasive frangipani vine should be removed in any event with the site should be
properly managed and protected as koala habitat by RACV.
• The State Assessment Referral Agency (SARA) has raised a number of concerns about
the proposal in the information request, including removal of koala habitat, loss of
connectivity through fragmentation, mitigation of bushfire requiring essential
management clearing beyond the clearing that is currently being proposed.
• The proposed development does not meet community expectations, primarily with
respect to protecting koala habitat on the land.
2|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, March 2023
Page 3
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
• The Council should adhere to the Noosa Shire Koala Conservation Plan.
• The proposed development is inconsistent with the biodiversity benchmarks under the
State Planning Policy 2017 and the Noosa Plan 2020, including the Noosa Heads
Locality Plan and the Biodiversity Overlay Code, because of the impact upon the
environmental values, in particular koala habitat.
• The development will have an adverse impact upon the water quality of Weyba Creek.
• The area is culturally significant to the Kabi Kabi people and requires a cultural heritage
assessment.
• Building design requirements including the BAL ratings will result in a need to remove
more vegetation; and
• The proposed landscape planting will not aid koala protection; and
• The development will impact upon the character and amenity of Noosa with over
development already occurring.
With respect to the submissions in support, including the late submission, the following are
the key themes broadly summarised below:
• The development is consistent with the Tourist Accommodation Zone and is
reasonably expected on the land and will be integrated with the existing RACV Noosa
Resort, which is desirable.
• The proposed development will provide for a unique eco-tourism asset and will
contribute positively to the local economy.
• Advice has been obtained from a range of consultants including a koala expert, and
expert ecologist and arborist, which has resulted in a considered design and the
maintenance of a substantial amount of koala habitat on the land in the long term.
• If left in its current state the land will continue to be overtaken by the invasive weed
and will further degrade, which is already having a significant impact upon the existing
koala habitat.
• The plan to provide koala signage will reduce road trauma on Weyba Road and Noosa
Drive.
• Based on the level of detail provided and the considered approach to the design, the
proposal ought to be supported and will have environmental, social and economic
benefits.
• The importance of having a new and enhanced accommodation product in Noosa is
recognised and the development will provide for a unique opportunity and solution
concurrently given other visitor accommodation is outdated.
• The development will provide for the long term sustainability and management of
threatened koala habitat on the site.
• RACV is a significant economic contributor to the Noosa economy, has high
environmental and sustainability credentials and the development should be
supported.
• The proposed development aligns with the Noosa Junction’s own sustainability values
in supporting tourism while protecting the environment; and
3|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, March 2023
Page 4
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
• RACV has engaged number of experienced consultants to provide expert advice and
support for the proposed design.
It is evident from the submissions received in objection, that the majority of the submitters
have simply opposed the development without properly considering the application material,
in particular the advice provided by the koala expert, and the other advice from the ecology
expert and expert arborist. It is fair to say however, that some of the submitters have taken the
time to consider at least some of the application material, in part.
Many of these submitters have not appreciated that the site is currently substantially degraded
because of the invasive weed (Frangipani vine) which has engulfed the trees and the ground
and is currently rendering the site unusable by koala. Unless some development is allowed on
the land consistent with the intent of the planning scheme, the site will continue to degrade
and will remain unsuitable for koala as a part of a corridor. In a practical sense, no owner is
going to rehabilitate the site at considerable cost, without some return.
The majority of the submitters also do not appreciate the cost associated with rehabilitating
the site in this manner, without wholesale clearing of koala habitat being proposed. Allowing
for some development on the land integrated with the existing RACV Noosa Resort will allow
for the rehabilitation and maintenance works to be funded in the long term. The expert arborist
has advised of the need for immediate intervention and ongoing maintenance to prevent the
death of some trees within the site.
The impact the development will have on existing koala habitat has been carefully considered
by SARA, who has approved the development subject to a number of conditions, including:
• Provision of an environmental covenant to prevent any chance of further vegetation
clearing because of essential management around the eco-cabins, in accordance with
the Amended Site Plan (Attachment 1A).
• Provision of solar powered and other koala signage to be erected in accordance with
the approved Indicative Koala Signage Plan, to improve driver awareness and help to
reduce vehicle speeds (Attachment 1B).
• The proposed development will also be undertaken in accordance with the approved
Koala Management Plan, which has been amended and approved by SARA
(Attachment 1C); and
• An environmental offset is also required under the Environmental Offsets Act 2014 to
counterbalance any significant residual impacts.
Fencing and other measures have also been considered by the applicant and SARA, which have
been deemed not practical or appropriate for this site. This is because of the extent of the
frontages on both sides of the road, which means koala could cross in any direction to the
south or east.
4|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, March 2023
Page 5
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
The subject land is included within the Tourist Accommodation Zone and is intended for short-
term accommodation, which is being proposed. The integrated design maintains the majority
of the koala habitat on the site, by careful placement and use of elevated structures that sit
lightly on the land and do not require extensive earthworks. The parking extends into the
existing RACV Noosa Resort, which aids tree protection and could not be achieved with
another owner and or operator. The are no other environmental concerns raised with the
proposal, which is consistent with the Biodiversity Overlay Code.
With respect the use of the site for short-term accommodation, this is the only type of use
(visitor accommodation) allowed on the site under the Tourist Accommodation Zone.
Therefore, the issue of more affordable housing cannot be addressed on this site, which would
be more detrimental to existing koala habitat, with domestic animals also allowed under that
scenario, which is not the case for visitor accommodation.
The additional visitors will also be using Resort style accommodation, as opposed to
alternative short-term accommodation options such as AirBnb. The majority of these guests
will not be driving or hiring cars and will be staying at a highly eco-accredited Resort that only
uses 100% renewable energy. Furthermore, 70% of RACV Noosa resort guests reside from
Victoria, one of the highest average spends from any visitor to Noosa.
The proposed development is entirely different to the former approval over the land, which
would have resulted in the wholesale clearing of the central part of the land to provide ten
dwelling units and the associated access and parking. This development would have been
more detrimental to the koala habitat and would not be integrated within the site nor
constructed in a sustainable manner (slab on ground with earthworks), which is at complete
odds with what is currently being proposed. In contrast, the proposed development provides
for 16 eco-cabins within 8 two storey buildings integrated within the site and carefully
positioned to minimise tree removal, having a site cover of less than 20%. Further, parking is
also separate and removed from the cabins for the same reason.
The proposed development will not cause any environmental impacts with water quality also
being managed on the site. Further, the proposed development will not cause a significant
increase in vehicle movements or other impacts on the character and amenity of the area.
It is noted the applicant is proposing to erect koala signage in this location (at considerable
cost) for the benefit of the local community, despite not generating a substantial amount of
additional traffic on Noosa Drive or Weyba Road. These roads were identified under the Noosa
Shire Koala Conservation Plan 2016, as being a high risk, yet no signage is currently provided.
Any other matters raised, such as cultural heritage are to be managed as required by the
Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 and is not relevant to the assessment. Further, the risk
from bushfire has also been considered by a respect bushfire expert, with understorey
management required.
5|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, March 2023
Page 6
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
The proposed development is supported by a number of local businesses within the Noosa
area who understand the community benefit in terms of providing a new product currently
not available within the Noosa Heads locality. Further, by way of employment in the short and
long term through construction and operation in association with the RACV Noosa Resort.
The key issue to be addressed with the assessment is the impact on koala habitat. This issue
has been considered by the applicant’s experts, including a koala expert. Further, SARA has
approved the development subject to conditions, following further consideration of the merits
of the proposal.
The proposed development will maintain connectivity, with the majority of the koala habitat
being retained and koala being able to pass freely through the site because of the elevated
structures. Given the current status of the site, having been ingulfed by the invasive weed, the
connectivity through the site for koala should be enhanced by the development.
On balance, the proposed development meets community expectations when considering the
requirements of the planning scheme and the scale and form of the development being
proposed in an integrated manner. The development complies with the Noosa Plan 2020 and
should be approved subject to reasonable and relevant conditions.
The applicant requests if there are any remaining issues of concern, that these be raised with
the applicant before the application is decided. The applicant is happy to provide additional
information or attend a meeting to discuss the application as soon as possible.
Should you have any questions with respect to the above, please contact me.
Yours faithfully
Shane Adamson
Shane Adamson (BEngTech, GDURP, MPIA, MQELA)
Town Planning Specialist
Director - Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
6|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, March 2023
Used in these records
Response to submissions.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 246 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.