Council archive · source document
2ND RFI - Attachment 5 - Gondwana Ecology Group - Fuirther information request RACV JULY 2023 · MCU22/0118
Very large file (18.2 MB): the original may take a few minutes to open or download. The page text below is quick to read.
Original PDF page 1, section 1. The text section number identifies this passage in the reader.
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd
ABN 20 143 747 326
PO Box 535
Kenmore
QLD 4069
Attention: RACV 4 July 2023
c/o Shane Adamson
Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
PO Box 894
COOROY QLD 4563
Mr Adamson
RE: 2023 INFORMATION REQUEST – PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT, 142 NOOSA DRIVE, NOOSA
HEADS - ECOLOGY
1.0 Background
The subject land is located at 142 Noosa Drive, Noosa Heads (Lot 3 on SP 126203), is part of the existing
RACV resort landholding and encompasses some 0.55ha. Council-owned land occurs to the immediate west
and northwest, with Weyba Road - Leslie Drive and the roundabout to the immediate south and east. An
aerial photograph of the subject land and surrounds is provided in Attachment A.
RACV intend to develop the land in accordance with the mapped land use (i.e. for tourist accommodation)
as an “eco-style” cabin layout amongst the retained trees and replanted/rehabilitated vegetation. Cabins
and pathways are to be raised above ground level to minimise impact and facilitate the ecological outcome.
2.0 Information Request and State Approval
The State issued an information request dated 29 August 2022, while Council issued two information
requests in 2022, dated 29th August and 2nd September, the latter dealing primarily with flood/stormwater
concerns.
The Council Information Request (29 August 2022) identified two ecological-related issues to be addressed,
i.e. Bushfire Management (which included a review of tree retention and use of certain species in
landscaping); and Koala (including quantification of koala habitat trees and addressing the residual impact
to koalas).
The Information Response dealing with Council’s 1st Information response was dated 14 December 2022 1.
The State required koala matters to be addressed and the revised layout with covenant and koala
management plan accommodated this, after which the development was approved (7 February 2023).
Councils’ 3rd information request (6th April 2023 – Further Advice) lists several issues previously not
identified in the 2022 requests. The general theme of the issues relates to the extent of disturbance area,
consistency between plans/reports compliance with the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay
Code.
The ecology issues are addressed in Section 8 below. A description of the site history, design changes in
amended plans following the site meeting are explained in Sections 4 and 5 as background and justification
to addressing the issues in Section 8 (i.e. and not necessarily repeated under each response).
Where relevant, separate responses are provided by other experts, including koala management (Dr Ellis),
arborist advice (Mr Duncan), bushfire (Mr Friend) and stormwater (Mr Mallard).
1 Gondwana Ecology Group.
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 1
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of sections 2 to 21 (of 30)
Section 2
3.0 Site Inspection and Consultation A site inspection was completed with the RACV project team and Council’s assessment officers Will Lowe (Senior Environment Officer), Tara Norley (Development Planner) and Jada Lyons (Graduate Development Planner) on 6th June 2023. Prior to this meeting, further consideration was given to respond to Council’s request by way of amendments to the layout, which included the location (relocation) of cabins and stormwater infrastructure. In order to better understand the layout on site and potential impacts, the cabin and carpark footprint was surveyed. The project team collectively inspected the site and subsequent changes were made to the design to retain better quality trees and increase overall tree retention. Matt Duncan (arborist) and Justin Watson (ecologist) subsequently identified (labelled with coloured tape) “trees for removal” and “to be confirmed by arborist” (TBC) to facilitate the site inspection with Council. The inspection with Council investigated the areas of impact, areas of retention, noted the extensive weed invasion and past fill of the site. Council’s concern with the material previously provided was discussed and further recommendations were made by Council for improving the design. It is acknowledged that the previous material had conflict between bushfire management and rehabilitation amongst the cabins. This has been addressed in the amended layout and it is important to note that the overall design/objective, is to create a green space amongst the cabins and pathways. The intent is to create a green/planted environment with interspersed cabins. Tree retention and rehabilitation/landscaping are integral to the design. 4.0 Site History and Disturbance There was an approval in 2008 for a residential development over the entirety of the subject land. As noted in previous reporting and viewed with Council during the recent site inspection, the site has been subject to earthworks/filling up to the western boundary. A rock wall is located along the western boundary and a “slab” (solid structure) is noticeable in the southwest, confirming past use of the land. A brief review of historical photography confirms clearing of the land and establishment of structures. The construction of the road and round-about would also have contributed to site disturbance and earthworks. As series of historical aerial photos are included in Attachment B. The weed species on the subject land has been documented previous. Notably the frangipani vine (Chonemorpha fragrans) has become established and essentially extracted the ecological value from the land. Vines engulf almost all native trees on the land, making the trees inaccessible for some fauna (e.g. koala). Native groundcovers and evidence of regrowth/saplings is practically non-existent, a function of past use, clearing and imported fill. It is interesting to note the original survey (completed in 2006 for the 2008 development approval) recorded a high proportion of weed species and the 2018 survey (Gondwana Ecology Group) reported an increased number of weed species (refer Attachment C of the ecology reporting). While percentage weed cover was not quantified in the original reporting, the preponderance of the frangipani vine would now result in a near 100% coverage. There are also many unusual (not naturally occurring) species along Weyba Drive frontage, likely planting as part of the previous site use and or landscaping following disturbance for road works. The site condition, and history, is an important factor when considering the site values and interpretation of the mapped ecological values, and when addressing Council’s issues. The site inspection provided an opportunity to better appreciate the site values or “lack of values”. Site location, context and size is also important when addressing ecological values, particularly noting the small site size, proximity to Weyba Drive-Noosa Drive and confluence with the Leslie Road round-about. Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 2
Section 3
5.0 Amended Plan and Improved Tree Retention
An amended design, incorporating Council’s comments and recommendations (including information
request, site meeting) is included as a set of plans 2 in Attachment C. The amended layout reduces the
overall disturbance area and retains a greater number of trees than the plan approved by the State.
Amendments to the layout include:
• Deletion of one cabin (now 15, previously 16);
• Relocation of the most north-westerly cabin (Cabin 01) to above the carpark and away from the
“most ecologically important areas” (and eliminates the need for a 10m Fire Buffer/Management
Zone within the Environmental Management & Conversation Zone);
• An enlarged and relocated stormwater basin to an existing cleared area (formerly Cabins 1 & 2);
• Realignment of Cabins 02-07 to retain more trees;
• Cabins 08 and 09 separated from Cabins 10-11 allows reduced boardwalk and better screening to
road; and
• Realignment of the boardwalk to retain more trees and better screen from road.
From a tree retention analysis, when compared to the previous plans, it should be noted that:
• the previous tree analysis included trees that were not on the subject land – these are excluded
from this analysis.
• there are many koala feed/roost trees and other native vegetation beyond and surrounding the
subject land – these are acknowledged, but not included in the analysis.
• vine engulfment has impacted many trees and tree health is questionable – the updated tree
retention plan has incorporated these considerations, including long-term survival potential for the
trees.
• Weed/non-native species are excluded from the analysis (including camphor laurels that are now
removed from the survey plans) and assumed to be removed as part of the ecological restoration
process.
From an overall green space perspective, the amended layout now provides an additional 150-200m2 of
either undisturbed land or an area where the opportunity exists to undertake a restoration exercise.
In summary, the amended plan results in the following with the 242 native trees surveyed on site:
• 160 will be retained (previously this was 142)
• 71 will be removed (previously this was 89)
• 11 are proposed to be retained 3 and will require arborist review and advice during construction
(labelled TBC on plans) (previously this was 20)
Of the trees surveyed on site, 150 are, by “State” definition (although not under Council’s PSP2 Landscaping
/Table SC6.3.6.1 Koala Food Trees), koala trees, with:
• 117 to be retained (previously this was 110) 4
• 27 will be removed (previously this was 44)
• six are proposed to be retained and will require arborist review and advice during construction
(previously this was 10)
Noting 71 native trees (of which 27 are defined as koala trees) will be removed, a closer analysis of those
trees provides better insight/appreciation for the potential loss of values, as described below.
2 The complete set of plans is provided by others.
3 Note – the intent is to retain mature vegetation rather than remove and replant. This is part of the envisaged design outcome
for the development.
4 Previously camphor laurel and trees to the north had been included in these figures.
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 3
Section 4
Of the 27 koala trees removed 5:
• 11 are eucalyptus and 16 are paperbarks
• Of the 16 paperbarks, at least five have been planted (as part of the resort development to the
north)
• 10 of the swamp mahogany (E.robusta) are described (original arborist report) as poor condition,
nearly dead or vine engulfed – meaning only one of the trees to be removed is in “reasonable
condition”
In context, this illustrates that only one relatively healthy swamp mahogany, and 11 naturally occurring
paperbarks, will be removed.
Of the balance 44 native trees removed:
• six are dead and not large habitat trees – no/limited habitat value
• 11 are cheese trees (Glochidion)
• three are wattles (Acacia) – a pioneer/short-lived species
• 14 are palms (Archontophoenix)
• one is a lilly-pilly Waterhousia near the road (most likely planted)
• one is a pine (Callitris)
• three are pink euodia (Mellicope)
• five are macaranga (Macaranga)
Of the six koala “feed” trees TBC (to be confirmed) by arborist during construction:
• one is paperbark
• four are swamp mahogany
• one is a vine-engulfed smooth-bark gum possibly E.tereticornis and planted near the road verge
While there is potential for these trees to be removed, the intent remains that they are to be retained
through careful construction methods and with arborist supervision.
The amended layout, with a smaller footprint and realigned structures, has increased tree retention
(including koala trees), has reduced the number of trees to be confirmed by arborist (less uncertainty) and
increased overall greenspace and rehabilitation opportunities.
6.0 Land Use
While planning matters would be properly addressed by a town planner, it is relevant (from an ecology
perspective) to appreciate that the subject land is zoned for tourism use. The proposed design incorporates
the environment with the integration of greenspace and tree retention amongst the development.
RACV Noosa’s environmental philosophy and credentials are well known (as noted in the December 2022
correspondence 6, with environmental sustainability, Earth Check certification (the world’s leading science-
based environmental certification and benchmarking program for the travel and tourism industry) and an
active Green Team part of the business approach. The proposed development is no different, other than it
focuses more heavily on the ecological component of the design.
With regards to the land use mapping (refer Zoning Site Plan 21-0910_ A10-02 in Attachment C), 0.38ha is
zoned Tourist Accommodation (orange shading) and 0.16ha is zoned Environment Management and
5 Council PSP2 definition = only 10 (primary) koala food trees will be removed (noting only one of these is in a healthy condition).
6 Including 2022 environmental, sustainability, tourism, business and Noosa biosphere awards/accolades.
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 4
Section 5
Conservation (green shading). The amended layout has a disturbance footprint of 1797m2 over the site, primarily in the Tourist Accommodation Zone. As noted in previous reporting and recognised during the Council site inspection, the green shaded areas represent a mapping anomaly, with the two Environment Management and Conservation parts on the site not reflecting the ground-truthed values and would not be “riparian” by definition. The southern of the two patches is in an area that has a retaining wall (and fill). The two cabins at this location have been repositioned to retain trees which are either healthier and/or provide better ecological value. The overlap with the green shaded area is noted but acknowledged the mapping does not represent ground-truthed values, which are better retained in the cabin realignment. This causes conflict (on paper) with some of the outcomes of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay (and issues raised by Council), which would practically be resolved noting the actual on-ground values would not be compromised by the proposed design at this location. In the north, the green shading better reflects the on ground values, although the true ecological values do not necessarily extend as far east as represented by the mapping. This area has been subject to filling and heavily infested by weeds. However, in order to better protect the values to the west/northwest, the development has been amended to remove the cabin that was in this location. The impact to the area is greatly reduced, more trees are retained (less bushfire management conflict with ecology) and opportunity to restore values is available. The amended development ensures additional mapped Environment Management and Conservation land remains undisturbed from development (along the western boundary and northwest corner). Vegetation between the cabins is retained (individual trees) and rehabilitated. These green spaces are to be in a covenant (refer State approval, which will need to be amended to reflect the changes made) and will contribute to the overall conservation and environmental management. Approximately 3043m2 will be rehabilitated and would be expected to be protected within a conservation covenant (>60% of the developable part of the site), similar to the current State approval. 7.0 Site Rehabilitation As noted above, the reduced footprint provides an opportunity to better restore areas in the northwest which are proximal to areas with some ecological value. It is also acknowledged (and discussed with Council) that the previous landscape/rehabilitation plans have caused some concern regarding consistency between vegetation retention, rehabilitation and ongoing management. The overall development intent, as stated above, is for the cabins to be integrated with the greenspace. The essence of the design is to incorporate tree retention and re-establishment of native vegetation. Unnecessary removal of vegetation and “bare” spaces in the landscape is not the objective of the proposal. A revised conceptual rehabilitation plan has been prepared following discussions with Council. This plan has accommodated bushfire management and ongoing arborist maintenance requirements while the key focus has been on the use of native species (reflective of the mapped pre-clearing regional ecosystem) to be planted within and around the development. A conceptual rehabilitation plan with five rehabilitation zones is provided in Attachment D. The total area to be rehabilitated is 3141m2 (including 98m2 in Lot 203). Within Lot 3, the 3043m2 to be rehabilitated represents >60% of the developable part of the site). The zones comprise the following, acknowledging that weed removal and control is the primary exercise in all zones prior to any re-establishment with native vegetation: Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 5
Section 6
Zone 1 – Wetland Rehabilitation (northwest) – 781m2
• No planting restrictions.
• Weed control/management.
• Planting with species appropriate to RE12.2.7 and locally occurring.
• Include koala feed trees.
Zone 2 – Rehabilitated Screen (south and east) 7 – 640m2
• Dense planting along southern and eastern boundary with suitable native species.
• Mid to high strata screening to be achieved.
• Weed control/management.
• Include scattered koala feed trees.
Zone 3 – Detention Basin – 68m2
• Planting with species recognised as suitable for detention basins.
• Grass and sedge species able to be managed (maintained at appropriate height 1m as needed).
• Provide habitat and water maintenance function.
Zone 4 – Bushfire Management – 357m2
• Weed control.
• Groundcovers and low shrubs.
• Retain individual trees as identified.
• No further tree planting.
Zone 5 – Balance Rehabilitation amongst Cabins – 1295m2
• Area of intense weed control/management (essentially all understorey is non-native and weed
vine on trees to be treated).
• Dense planting of groundcovers and low shrub/midstorey (i.e. cover ground and control weed
establishment and create a fully vegetated greenspace adjacent and amongst elevated cabins and
boardwalks).
• Inter-planting with smooth-bark koala and other tree species.
8.0 Council Ecology Issues to be Addressed – 2023
While the above description of site context, in conjunction with the amended layout, reduced footprint,
greater tree retention and better focused ecological rehabilitation concept responds to Council’s issues for
the project, for completeness a response is provided for the specific headings (issues) identified in the 2023
Further Advice. Where relevant, reference to the matters explained above is made for each issue
(numbering as per Council Advice). Also for completeness, extracts of the relevant Council overlays are
included in Attachment E1 with a response to relevant POs in Attachment E2.
(2) Issue – Vegetation Removal
Demonstrate compliance with PO1 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code.
The site inspection with Council, the amended development layout and material provided above addresses
the specific issue raised, including the consistency between rehabilitation, landscaping, bushfire and on-
going maintenance. The revised layout and concept rehabilitation plan illustrates an improved and
consistent ecological outcome.
Further responses are provided to PO1 in the table at Attachment E2.
7 98m2 is within Lot 2 to the north.
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 6
Section 7
(3) Issue – Ecologically Important Areas Demonstrate compliance with PO3 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code. As above, the current site values and ground-truthed exercise identifies the values. The loss of habitat values is limited to a few trees (refer updated analysis above) which would be adequately accommodated for through a rehabilitation exercise (also noting the current condition of the land). Further responses are provided to PO2 in the table at Attachment E2. (4 + 5) Issue – Connecting Habitat Areas Demonstrate compliance with PO5 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code and PO26 of the Noosa Heads Local Plan Code. Provide a revised development layout that demonstrates no significant adverse impacts by providing the development footprint outside the areas identified as a connecting habitat identified on Map SFM-4 – Biodiversity (Strategic Framework). The entire site is mapped as “connecting habitat” as is large areas in the surrounding landscape (including areas that are developed. Most of the site is mapped as a tourism landuse. Refer Council overlay mapping extracts in Attachment E1. Avoiding areas of “connecting habitat” is not possible to establish a tourism development, in accordance with the landuse zoning. However, with reference to the SFM4 mapping, refer the ecological linkage mapping which better reflects the actual connections in the landscape. Further responses are provided to PO5 and PO26 in the table at Attachment E2. (6) Issue – Development within Waterways and Wetlands Areas Provide a revised development footprint that demonstrates compliance with PO6 by avoiding all new development within the riparian buffer area and MSES wetland areas. As described above, the riparian mapping does not reflect on ground conditions. The amended layout has nevertheless, reduced overlap with the mapping in the north where it represents a more “natural” landform (note retaining wall and fill in the south). The revised design minimises impact on the mapped (and actual values) and allows for the area to be rehabilitated. There are no bushfire restrictions for the rehabilitation in this area (see Zone 1 planting – Attachment D). Further responses are provided to PO6 in the table at Attachment E2. (7) Issue – Koala Habitat Provide a revised tree retention plans that integrates all bushfire, ecology, tree, and landscape recommendations and utilises this information to demonstrate how the development has protected and enhanced koalas and koala habitat and avoids adverse impacts, both direct and indirect. The original (State approved) layout had been designed with input from the two koala experts and acknowledged to retain sufficient koala habitat and allow koala movement (by design) through and around the site. The proposed rehabilitation would also see the removal of the Frangipani vine (which has engulfed the site and reducing the E.robusta trees to little value to koalas) and replanting with koala feed trees (listed in Council’s PSP Landscaping). The State have also approved the development with requirements for enhancement of koala habitat and movement in the landscape. The amended layout retains more trees than the State approved development plus allows for more areas to be rehabilitated. Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 7
Section 8
The tree analysis for the amended layout is provided in Section 5 above and repeated below for the koala
-specific trees, i.e.:
Of the trees surveyed on site, 150 are, by “State” definition (although not under Council’s PSP2 Landscaping /Table SC6.3.6.1
Koala Food Trees), koala trees, with:
• 117 to be retained (previously this was 110)
• 27 will be removed (previously this was 44)
• six are proposed to be retained and will require arborist review and advice during construction (previously this was
10)
Noting 71 native trees (of which 27 are defined as koala trees) will be removed, a closer analysis of those trees provides better
insight/appreciation for the potential loss of values, as described below.
Of the 27 koala trees removed:
• 11 are eucalyptus and 16 are paperbarks
• Of the 16 paperbarks, at least five have been planted (as part of the resort development to the north)
• 10 of the swamp mahogany (E.robusta) are described (original arborist report) as poor condition, nearly dead or vine
engulfed – meaning only one of the trees to be removed is in reasonable condition
In context, this illustrates that only one relatively healthy swamp mahogany, and 11 naturally occurring paperbarks, will be
removed.
Only 10 (primary) koala food trees will be removed (acknowledging that only one of these is in a relatively healthy condition).
(8) Issue – Bushfire Management within Biodiversity Areas
Provided a revised tree retention plans that integrate all bushfire, ecology, tree, and landscape
recommendations and utilises this information to demonstrate how the development maintain and enhance
biodiversity.
Following site meeting and discussions with Council it is acknowledged that there was conflict between the
bushfire, landscaping, on-going maintenance and proposed ecological rehabilitation.
The amended design has removed a cabin that originally caused bushfire management maintenance to
extend further west. In accordance with the Conceptual Rehabilitation Plan (Attachment D), the area
(zone 1) is now free of any bushfire requirements and will be planted with species typical of RE12.2.7.
It is also confirmed and described in the other planting zones (especially zone 5 amongst the cabins) that a
variety of native species (typical of RE12.2.7) can be planted. This includes groundcover, midstorey and
trees.
Both the project bushfire expert and arborist have confirmed the planting list for each zone, which provides
(with extensive weed management initially) a net ecological benefit to the land.
The selection of species ensures low bushfire issue but does not reduce biodiversity values, and with the
site currently heavily infested with weed species, the proposed rehabilitation (cognisant of bushfire
requirements) will enhance biodiversity as per PO12 (1) of the Biodiversity Waterways and Wetlands
Overlay Code.
(9) Issue – Scenic Amenity
Demonstrate compliance with AO13.1 by retaining all native vegetation (trees, shrubs, and groundcovers)
within 10 metres of the major road network.
The amended layout allows a greater setback to the road with additional tree retention. There is no
requirement to remove native vegetation within the zone adjacent to the road.
Native vegetation (note AO13.1) is extremely limited on the subject land and is reduced to some trees along
the road. There has been historical planting along parts of the road interface. Some are native species.
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 8
Section 9
With reference to Attachment D zone 2, this area is to be rehabilitated with native species including
RE12.2.7, but also has a priority (as discussed with Council) to provide a “screen”. The species selected for
planting in this zone (amongst the retained trees) are noted for their screening capability.
The planting in this zone will serve both an ecological and visual screen/buffer function.
(10) Issue – MSES Wetland
Provide a revised ecological assessment that addresses the direct and indirect impacts this development will
have on the MSES wetlands and what mitigation measures have been implemented to demonstrate no
impacts will occur.
The proposed development will not directly impact any “wetland”.
The cabins in the northwest have been removed from the location and the area will be rehabilitated (refer
Attachment D – zone 1) with RE12.2.7 species. The area is heavily weed infested, and a weed
control/removal exercise will be essential to enhance biodiversity values for the ecosystem.
Stormwater is a matter for others, but as noted, the basin provides stormwater management in the
northwest and will be suitably rehabilitated (refer Attachment D – zone 3).
(11) Issue – Threatened Ecological Community (TEC)
Provide sufficient information to demonstrate that the development will not have a significant impact on
the critically endangered ecological community. This must include:
11.1. demonstration that the development will not reduce the extent of an ecological community
11.2. fragment or increase fragmentation of an ecological community, for example by clearing
vegetation for roads, transmission lines or infrastructure
11.3. adversely affect habitat critical to the survival of an ecological community
11.4. modify or destroy abiotic (non-living) factors (such as water, nutrients, or soil) necessary
for an ecological community’s survival, including reduction of groundwater levels, or substantial
alteration of surface water drainage patterns
11.5. cause a substantial change in the species composition of an occurrence of an ecological
community, including causing a decline or loss of functionally important species
11.6. cause a substantial reduction in the quality or integrity of an occurrence of an ecological
community, including, but not limited to: – assisting invasive species, that are harmful to the
listed ecological community, to become established, or – causing regular mobilisation of
fertilisers, herbicides or other chemicals or pollutants into the ecological community which kill or
inhibit the growth of species in the ecological community, or
11.7. interfere with the recovery of an ecological community.
11.8. demonstrate that a referral application is not required.
While Commonwealth matters are separate to this application, it is acknowledged that the subject land
supports an ecosystem with characteristics of RE12.2.7, which can, under certain circumstances, be a TEC.
Reference is made to the Commonwealth Conservation Advice for this community 8.
The site is highly disturbed (as noted on site and described previously in this response and the original DA
reporting). Aerial photography (Attachment B) also shows the past clearing (in its entirety) of the site.
8 DAWE (2021) Conservation Advice for the Coastal Swamp Sclerophyll Forest of NSW and SEQ.
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 9
Section 10
The site inspection with Council, background information provided in this response (including extensive
weed species and coverage) and the limited clearing (perhaps only one healthy tree) of E.robusta suggests
any impact would not be “significant”.
Further to the above, and as described previously, the proposed development aims to integrate native
vegetation (including trees) into the design. It is an eco-style, not a broadscale high-density development,
so retention and replanting of vegetation is an essential part of the design.
The lack of any native understorey or midstorey currently, is proposed to be remedied through the
rehabilitation exercise (which would include extensive weed control and a dense planting of RE12.2.7
characteristic species) – refer Attachment D, rehabilitation zones 1-5.
The Commonwealth Conservation advice identifies that this TEC has a high diversity of native understorey
(ref. Appendix A of the Advice). The subject site, due to historical clearing, earthworks and the invasive
vine, has essentially no native understorey or midstorey.
The area of E.robusta {potential TEC} area is approximately 0.42ha (refer Attachment D – E.robusta {TEC}
area could be considered all, but the Zone 2 area.) With reference to the Commonwealth Conservation
Advice Table 2, the patch size (on site) could be considered – either:
• Small contiguous patch (The patch is at least 0.25 ha and less than 2 ha and is part of a larger area
of native vegetation of at least 5 ha) OR
• Small patch (The patch is at least 0.5 ha and less than 2 ha which is isolated or part of a small native
vegetation remnant less than 5 ha in total).
Regardless of which “patch size” the area is considered, the Biotic threshold would be at least “Low
Condition”, i.e. Non-native species comprise more than 80% of total ground layer vegetation cover.
Non-native species comprise 99% of the ground layer vegetation cover.
As such (refer Table 2 Commonwealth Conservation Advice), the community (be it a small contiguous patch
or a small patch) is NOT PROTECTED.
However, even if a conservative approach was taken, and the Biotic threshold was considered elevated to
a Moderate threshold, i.e. Non-native species comprise 50% - 80% of total ground layer vegetation cover
(which we know is not the case for the site) - the community (be it a small contiguous patch or a small
patch) is still (refer Table 2 Commonwealth Conservation Advice), NOT PROTECTED.
The vegetation on the site is “not protected”, not a TEC and the proposed development would not have a
significant impact on a TEC, i.e. a Matter of National Ecological Significance. A referral to the
Commonwealth is not required.
Regardless of the “not protected” status, the proposed planting (noting the species selected) will create an
ecosystem more closely resembling the TEC than what currently occurs (specifically by reinstating the
native understorey and midstorey) and encompassing at least 0.3ha. Other measures to protect and benefit
the surrounding environment and overall biodiversity have been discussed previously.
9.0 Conclusion and Overall Ecological Enhancement Measures
As noted in the December 2022 response (and May 2022 Gondwana Ecology Group report), several
measures would be expected to be implemented in order to ensure protection of existing important
vegetation and enhancement of habitat which ensure a “no net loss” and “net overall benefit” for the
environment. Subsequent to those recommendations, the State has approved the development with
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 10
Section 11
specific koala management measures (as incorporated into the Koala Management Plan9). In addition to
these measures, further discussions with Council (on site) and the project team to achieve an improved
ecological outcome have been considered with a summary of enhancement measures provided for
completeness below:
• implement a weed control strategy (for the Frangipani vine in particular) as soon as practical 10;
• clearly identify and demarcate (and install protection fencing) areas, trees, vegetation for retention
and removal;
• tree management and construction to be supervised by qualified arborist;
• use of fauna spotter catchers to ensure no impacts occur to koalas or other fauna during vegetation
clearing;
• salvage of habitat features (e.g. logs);
• planting species which support local fauna, including koala habitat trees (feed and shelter) and
accommodate bushfire risk where specified (see rehabilitation zones);
• enhancing the buffer along Weyba Road and Sanctuary Drive (and the roundabout) with suitable
native species (see screen planting zone);
• installation of nest boxes in the retained E.robusta (or other large trees);
• implementation of the koala management plan including road signage (refer State approval); and
• covenant (refer State approval) for protection and management in perpetuity, of the green space
(to be amended to reflect the changed layout).
These are all measures, that in my experience, would be a condition of approval and reasonably expected
to be imposed.
The amended layout provides a smaller disturbance footprint within the Tourist Accommodation Zone,
allows for a greater area (greater than the mapped Environment Management and Conservation Zone) to
be retained and rehabilitated, and protected with a covenant. The amended plan causes a greater number
of native trees (and koala trees) to be retained while, upon more detailed analysis, the fewer trees (i.e.
fewer than the original application) to be lost have low ecological value.
Finally, when considering the context, site history and condition, the proposed development (noting
proposed use compliant with the land zone anticipated use) is not considered to cause a significant
ecological impact and the proposed development, with focussed design and rehabilitation, has the
potential to enhance the ecological values within and surrounding the subject land.
Please do not hesitate to give me a call on 0407 410 099 if you need to discuss further.
Kind regards
Justin Watson (PhD; CEnvP.)
Director/Principal Ecologist
Gondwana Ecology Group
Encl.
• ATTACHMENT A – Aerial Photograph of the Subject Land
• ATTACHMENT B – Historical Photographs
• ATTACHMENT C – Amended Proposed Development (June 2023) – {set of plans}
• ATTACHMENT D – Concept Rehabilitation Plan
• ATTACHMENT E1 & E2 – Council Overlay Mapping and Code Responses
9 Dr Bill Ellis.
10 Note – earlier discussions with Council indicated the works for weed control should not start prior to the DA approval.
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 11
Section 12
oR sion WEE PY = Cd Sua wcte emiswea0 ira Beet eed mo] fo fo] _ » oO 2 2 Ss n o <= ~ = ° <= a © +o oo °o » ° <= a. s = o <x I <x Ke 2 lu = <= Oo F <x Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd
Section 13
ATTACHMENT B – Historical Aerial Images Note – subject land boundary indicative only and for reference purposes. June 75 - mostly vegetated, evidence of disturbance from road construction (?) along eastern boundary April 79 - evidence of clearing, building/shed/container (?) on site Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 13
Section 14
October 80 – evidence of structures, shed, extensive complete clearing of site December 85 - appears removal of structures, with start of regrowth Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 14
Section 15
September 89 - evidence of regrowth with small areas of lighter green (weeds/clearing) July 99 - well vegetated, remains evidence of the road/edge disturbance/clearing Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 15
Section 16
ATTACHMENT C – Amended Proposed Development (June 2023)
{relevant extracted plans – refer complete set of plans provided by others}
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 16
Section 17
IMPORTANT:
ALL DRAWINGS MUST BE READ IN CONJUNCTION WITH
THE GENERAL NOTES SHEET
AMENDMENT SCHEDULE
ISS DATE DESCRIPTION BY
A 20/06/22 CONSULTANTS REVIEW ZT
B 24/10/22 DA RFI ZT
C 28/10/22 DA RFI ZT
D 10/11/22 DA RFI ZT
E 15/11/122 RFI ZT
F 02/12/22 RFI ZT
G 05/12/22 RFI ZT
H 18/05/23 RFI RESPONSE TB
I 30/06/23 RESPONSE TO 2ND RFI ZT
1
A65-07
65 SQM BIO RETENTION
AREA
18 CARPARKS
CABIN 1
10m WIDE BUSHFIRE ASSET EMT X
PROTECTION ZONE
EMT B
4
A65-09 RL 11.022
CABINS 14 & 15
3
1 A65-09
A65-09
RL 10.730 CABINS 2 & 3 RL 11.022
EMT A
CABINS 12 & 13
0
60 0
LOT 3
0
400
CABINS 10 & 11
2
A65-09
CABINS 4 & 5
RL 11.640
CABINS 8 & 9
TOOWOOMBA | BRISBANE | MOOLOOLABA
www.aspectapm.net
ABN 96 071 786 948 ACN 071 786 948
CABINS 6 & 7 60
00 BOAQ 4487
RL 11.810
BUILDING DESIGNERS
ASSOCIATION
GENERAL NOTES
THIS PLAN HAS BEEN PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALL
RELEVANT BUILDING CODES AND STANDARDS. NO AMENDMENTS
SHALL BE MADE WITHOUT THE APPROVAL FROM ASPECT AND/OR
RELEVANT LOCAL AUTHORITY.THESE DRAWINGS ARE SUPPLIED ON
THE CONDITION THAT, IN THE EVENT OF ERROR, ASPECTS' LIABILITY
IS LIMITED ONLY TO THE COST OF AMENDING THESE DRAWINGS.
CONTRACTORS ARE TO VERIFY ALL DIMENSIONS ON SITE BEFORE
COMMENCING ANY WORK OR PRODUCING SHOP DRAWINGS. THESE
DRAWINGS ARE PROTECTED BY THE LAWS OF COPYRIGHT AND MAY
NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE WRITTEN
PERMISSION OF ASPECT .
PROJECT
RACV NOOSA RESORT - ECO
RESORT
FOR
ROYAL AUTOMOBILE CLUB OF
VICTORIA
CONCEPT DESIGN
@
142 NOOSA DRIVE, NOOSA HEADS
QLD 4567
DRAWING TITLE
SITE PLAN
N DATE SCALE @ A1 DRAWN CHECKED
30/06/23 1 : 250 ZT TB
DRAWING No. ISSUE
1:250
0 2 4 6 8 10 20 21-0910_ A10-01 I
Section 18
IMPORTANT:
ALL DRAWINGS MUST BE READ IN CONJUNCTION WITH
THE GENERAL NOTES SHEET
AMENDMENT SCHEDULE
ISS DATE DESCRIPTION BY
A 28/01/22 SITE LAYOUT ZT
B 19/04/22 REVISION A ZT
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION C 29/04/22 SITE REVIEW TB
Project Description Visitor Accommodation Units D 28/10/22 DA RFI ZT
E 15/11/122 RFI ZT
Site Description Lot 3 on SP126 203
F 18/05/23 RFI RESPONSE TB
Local Authority Noosa Shire Council
G 30/06/23 RESPONSE TO 2ND RFI ZT
Locality Noosa Heads
Site Area 5,453m² (0.5453ha)
Developable Area 4,054m² comprising 3,818.5m² plus
236m² under Infrastructure Agreement
Site Cover 1,124m2
20.6%
Total GFA 1,557m2
Plot Percenatge 28.55%
Plot Ratio 0.29:1
LEGEND
Green Environmental management &
18 CARPARKS 1,629m2 Conservation Zone Overlay
CABIN 1 Orange Tourist Accomodation
BIO BASIN 3,824m2 Zone Overlay
10m WIDE BUSHFIRE ASSET
PROTECTION ZONE
CABINS 14 & 15
CABINS 2 & 3
CABINS 12 & 13
CABINS 10 & 11
CABINS 4 & 5
CABINS 8 & 9
TOOWOOMBA | BRISBANE | MOOLOOLABA
www.aspectapm.net
ABN 96 071 786 948 ACN 071 786 948
CABINS 6 & 7 BOAQ 4487
BUILDING DESIGNERS
ASSOCIATION
GENERAL NOTES
THIS PLAN HAS BEEN PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALL
RELEVANT BUILDING CODES AND STANDARDS. NO AMENDMENTS
SHALL BE MADE WITHOUT THE APPROVAL FROM ASPECT AND/OR
RELEVANT LOCAL AUTHORITY.THESE DRAWINGS ARE SUPPLIED ON
THE CONDITION THAT, IN THE EVENT OF ERROR, ASPECTS' LIABILITY
IS LIMITED ONLY TO THE COST OF AMENDING THESE DRAWINGS.
CONTRACTORS ARE TO VERIFY ALL DIMENSIONS ON SITE BEFORE
COMMENCING ANY WORK OR PRODUCING SHOP DRAWINGS. THESE
DRAWINGS ARE PROTECTED BY THE LAWS OF COPYRIGHT AND MAY
NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE WRITTEN
PERMISSION OF ASPECT .
PROJECT
RACV NOOSA RESORT - ECO
RESORT
FOR
ROYAL AUTOMOBILE CLUB OF
VICTORIA
CONCEPT DESIGN
@
142 NOOSA DRIVE, NOOSA HEADS
QLD 4567
DRAWING TITLE
ZONING SITE PLAN
N DATE SCALE @ A1 DRAWN CHECKED
30/06/23 1 : 250 ZT TB
DRAWING No. ISSUE
1:250
0 2 4 6 8 10 20 21-0910_ A10-02 G
Section 19
TR319 TR318 TR311
IMPORTANT:
TR312 S
TR315 TR301 ALL DRAWINGS MUST BE READ IN CONJUNCTION WITH
TR317 TR310 TR291
TR298 297 TR293 THE GENERAL NOTES SHEET
TR316 TR299 TR
TR300
TR309
TR296 AMENDMENT SCHEDULE
TR1
4
TR336
27.91
TR3054 TR290
9
TR30 TR2
28.52
TR337 TR308 ISS DATE DESCRIPTION BY
TR303
TR302 TR295 TR284 TR6 S
TR307
TR286 A 19/04/22 REVISION A ZT
TR283
TR338 TR3 B 29/04/22 SITE REVIEW TB
TR306
TR285 C 06/05/22 CONSULTANTS REVIEW ZT
9 85
TR4 17.
TR282 D 12/05/22 CONSULTANTS REVIEW ZT
TR281
TR288 E 24/10/22 DA RFI ZT
TR280 TR275
6.2
TR202 TR5
64
TR7 F 28/10/22 DA RFI ZT
TR276
TR277
TR200 S G 8/11/22 DA RFI ZT
TR340 TR287
TR342
TR346 TR198 H 15/11/122 RFI ZT
39
TR289 TR196 TR8
.8
TR195
94
I 30/11/22 RFI KOALA TREE COUNT ZT
TR278 TR197
58
32
J 18/05/23 RFI RESPONSE TB
.1
TR273
1°
95
TR279 TR188
29
TR344 TR189
'23
K 30/06/23 RESPONSE TO 2ND RFI ZT
"
TR343 TR190 108°50'
TR192 5 6.1 S
TR191 40
TR345 TR271
TR272 TR201
TR270
TR274 TR187
9.6
98
CABIN 1 TR193 TR9
11.3
BIO BASIN
76
TR347
TR186 S TR10
TR269 TR194
TR199
TR11
TR268
10m WIDE BUSHFIRE ASSET S
PROTECTION ZONE
4.2
58
TR184
TR209
TR203
TR208 TR13
TR206
2.9
40
TR178
5.237
TR183 2
TR207 TR18 1 TR15
TR18
TR204
TR14
TR179 108
°50'
TR180 2 3.2
30
TR205 TR19
TR210 TR16
TR185
4.858
TR213 TR175 TR20
TR174
TR212 TR177 TR21
TR211
TR170TR1
TR17
172
CABINS 14 & 15
TR173
TR163TR164 TR18 TR17
TR169
TR167
TR215 TR165 TR176
TR214 TR162
TR166
TR168 TR23
TR22
TR216
TR218 TR154
57
TR161
9.2
TR217 TR219
TR159
TR158 157 TR153
TR
TR220
TR160
TR151 TR152
CABINS 2 & 3 TR221 TR156
TR24
TR150
TR149
TR155
06
"
TR148
'15
TR147
23.8
°38
TR146
CABINS 12 & 13
205
TR222 TR227
TR228
93
TR226
9.4
TR229
TR223 TR230
TR225
TR145
TR26
TR233
TR224 TR144
TR231
TR234 TR232
TR235
TR238
TR237
TR236
TR241
4.320
TR143 TR27
TR239
TR240
LEGEND 0
TR242
TR28
400 ACK TR244
S ETB TR245
FER 5
BUF
.50
10 '50
"
6.456
FIRE TR243 23
6°
02
TR246
RETAIN TR247 TR140
NON KOALA TREES
TR29
TR30
TR141 TR139
TR248
KOALA TREES
TR249 TR142
CABINS 10 & 11
341
49 .7
TR137
°27'2
36
TR138
5"
TR250
8
TR33 91
REMOVE 9. 0"
6.245
'2
TR251 TR31 8°
30
TR34 22
TR252
TR136
TR253 TR35
TR32
TR254
TR36
TBC* TR135 TR38
TR37
CABINS 4 & 5
"
18
Section 20
'45
9.9
°10
207
TR39
TR134 TR40 TR41
ALL SURVEYED TREES ON SITE
TREES ON SITE (242) TR133
TR42
TREES RETAINED (160) CABINS 8 & 9
TR256
TR43
TR132
TR44
TREES REMOVED (71) TR130
183°46'10"
13.020
TR257
TR129 TR128 TR131 TOOWOOMBA | BRISBANE | MOOLOOLABA
TREES TBC (11) TR127
TR45 www.aspectapm.net
ABN 96 071 786 948 ACN 071 786 948
BOAQ 4487
TR47
KOALA TREES ON SITE (150) TR126
TR46
TR124
TR125 BUILDING DESIGNERS
ASSOCIATION
KOALA TREES RETAINED (117) CABINS 6 & 7
GENERAL NOTES
THIS PLAN HAS BEEN PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALL
RELEVANT BUILDING CODES AND STANDARDS. NO AMENDMENTS
SHALL BE MADE WITHOUT THE APPROVAL FROM ASPECT AND/OR
TR51 RELEVANT LOCAL AUTHORITY.THESE DRAWINGS ARE SUPPLIED ON
TR50
THE CONDITION THAT, IN THE EVENT OF ERROR, ASPECTS' LIABILITY
KOALA TREES REMOVED (27) IS LIMITED ONLY TO THE COST OF AMENDING THESE DRAWINGS.
CONTRACTORS ARE TO VERIFY ALL DIMENSIONS ON SITE BEFORE
COMMENCING ANY WORK OR PRODUCING SHOP DRAWINGS. THESE
DRAWINGS ARE PROTECTED BY THE LAWS OF COPYRIGHT AND MAY
NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE WRITTEN
KOALA TREES TBC (6) PERMISSION OF ASPECT .
PROJECT
RACV NOOSA RESORT - ECO
341
32
°27'2
TOTAL SURVEYED KOALA TREES IN LOCALITY RESORT
5"
BU
IL 60
DI
72
FOR
5"
.8
NG 00
'2
36
KOALA TREES RETAINED (>200)
05
4°
22
SE
TB
ROYAL AUTOMOBILE CLUB OF
AC VICTORIA
K
CONCEPT DESIGN
@
NOTE 142 NOOSA DRIVE, NOOSA HEADS
TBC = RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE. QLD 4567
DRAWING TITLE
SUBJECT TO DETAILED DESIGN TR120
SITE PLAN - TREE RETENTION VS
AND ARBORIST ADVICE. TR116
REMOVAL PLAN
TR118
TR117
N DATE SCALE @ A1 DRAWN CHECKED
30/06/23 1 : 200 ZT TB
DRAWING No. ISSUE
1:250
0 2 4 6 8 10 20 21-0910_ A10-07 K
Section 21
IMPORTANT:
ALL DRAWINGS MUST BE READ IN CONJUNCTION WITH
THE GENERAL NOTES SHEET
AMENDMENT SCHEDULE
ISS DATE DESCRIPTION BY
A 06/05/22 CONSULTANTS REVIEW ZT
B 12/05/22 CONSULTANTS REVIEW ZT
C 24/10/22 DA RFI ZT
D 28/10/22 DA RFI ZT
E 8/11/22 DA RFI ZT
F 15/11/122 RFI ZT
G 30/11/22 RFI KOALA TREE COUNT ZT
H 18/05/23 RFI RESPONSE TB
I 30/06/23 RESPONSE TO 2ND RFI ZT
108
°50'
TR313 47.1
TR314 15
TR320
TR319 TR318 TR312 TR311
TR315 TR301
TR317 TR310
TR298R297 TR293
TR316 TR299 T
TR 300
TR309
TR296
TR336
0054 TR290
RR
TT 33
TR337 TR308 TR303
TR302 TR295 TR284
TR286
TR307
TR283
TR338
TR306
TR285
TR282
TR281
TR288
TR280 TR275 TR202
TR276
TR277
TR200
TR340 TR287
LEGEND TR342
TR346 TR198
TR289 TR196
TR195
TR278 TR197
58
32
.19
RETAIN TR273
1°
TR279
NON KOALA TREES
5
29
TR344
'23
"
KOALA TREES
TR343
TR345 TR271
TR272 TR201
REMOVE TR270
TR274
TR193
BIO BASIN CABIN 1
TR347
TBC*
TR269 TR194
TR199
TR268
ALL SURVEYED TREES ON SITE 10m WIDE BUSHFIRE ASSET
PROTECTION ZONE
TREES ON SITE (242)
TR209
TREES RETAINED (160)
TR203
TREES REMOVED (71) TR208 TR206
TOOWOOMBA | BRISBANE | MOOLOOLABA
TR207
TREES TBC (11) TR204
www.aspectapm.net
ABN 96 071 786 948 ACN 071 786 948
BOAQ 4487
KOALA TREES ON SITE (150) TR205
TR210
TR185 BUILDING DESIGNERS
ASSOCIATION
TR213
KOALA TREES RETAINED (117) TR212
GENERAL NOTES
THIS PLAN HAS BEEN PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALL
RELEVANT BUILDING CODES AND STANDARDS. NO AMENDMENTS
TR211
SHALL BE MADE WITHOUT THE APPROVAL FROM ASPECT AND/OR
RELEVANT LOCAL AUTHORITY.THESE DRAWINGS ARE SUPPLIED ON
THE CONDITION THAT, IN THE EVENT OF ERROR, ASPECTS' LIABILITY
KOALA TREES REMOVED (27) IS LIMITED ONLY TO THE COST OF AMENDING THESE DRAWINGS.
TR163TR164
CONTRACTORS ARE TO VERIFY ALL DIMENSIONS ON SITE BEFORE
COMMENCING ANY WORK OR PRODUCING SHOP DRAWINGS. THESE
TR167
DRAWINGS ARE PROTECTED BY THE LAWS OF COPYRIGHT AND MAY
NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE WRITTEN
KOALA TREES TBC (6) TR214
TR215 TR162 TR165 PERMISSION OF ASPECT .
TR166 PROJECT
RACV NOOSA RESORT - ECO
TOTAL SURVEYED KOALA TREES IN LOCALITY RESORT
TR216 FOR
KOALA TREES RETAINED (>200) TR218 TR161 ROYAL AUTOMOBILE CLUB OF
TR217 TR219
TR159 VICTORIA
TR158 R157
CONCEPT DESIGN
@
T
NOTE TR220 142 NOOSA DRIVE, NOOSA HEADS
TR160 QLD 4567
TBC = RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE.
CABINS 2 & 3
DRAWING TITLE
SUBJECT TO DETAILED DESIGN
TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL
AND ARBORIST ADVICE. PLAN A
N DATE SCALE @ A1 DRAWN CHECKED
30/06/23 1 : 100 ZT TB
DRAWING No. ISSUE
1:100
0 1 2 3 4 5 10 21-0910_ A10-07A I
The text continues on section 22.
Used in these records
About this file
- File size
- 18.2 MB (very large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
The download may take a few minutes. On mobile data, it is best to wait for Wi-Fi.