Council archive · source document
2ND RFI - Attachment 5 - Gondwana Ecology Group - Fuirther information request RACV JULY 2023 · MCU22/0118
Very large file (18.2 MB): the original may take a few minutes to open or download. The page text below is quick to read.
Original PDF page 3, section 1. The text section number identifies this passage in the reader.
5.0 Amended Plan and Improved Tree Retention
An amended design, incorporating Council’s comments and recommendations (including information
request, site meeting) is included as a set of plans 2 in Attachment C. The amended layout reduces the
overall disturbance area and retains a greater number of trees than the plan approved by the State.
Amendments to the layout include:
• Deletion of one cabin (now 15, previously 16);
• Relocation of the most north-westerly cabin (Cabin 01) to above the carpark and away from the
“most ecologically important areas” (and eliminates the need for a 10m Fire Buffer/Management
Zone within the Environmental Management & Conversation Zone);
• An enlarged and relocated stormwater basin to an existing cleared area (formerly Cabins 1 & 2);
• Realignment of Cabins 02-07 to retain more trees;
• Cabins 08 and 09 separated from Cabins 10-11 allows reduced boardwalk and better screening to
road; and
• Realignment of the boardwalk to retain more trees and better screen from road.
From a tree retention analysis, when compared to the previous plans, it should be noted that:
• the previous tree analysis included trees that were not on the subject land – these are excluded
from this analysis.
• there are many koala feed/roost trees and other native vegetation beyond and surrounding the
subject land – these are acknowledged, but not included in the analysis.
• vine engulfment has impacted many trees and tree health is questionable – the updated tree
retention plan has incorporated these considerations, including long-term survival potential for the
trees.
• Weed/non-native species are excluded from the analysis (including camphor laurels that are now
removed from the survey plans) and assumed to be removed as part of the ecological restoration
process.
From an overall green space perspective, the amended layout now provides an additional 150-200m2 of
either undisturbed land or an area where the opportunity exists to undertake a restoration exercise.
In summary, the amended plan results in the following with the 242 native trees surveyed on site:
• 160 will be retained (previously this was 142)
• 71 will be removed (previously this was 89)
• 11 are proposed to be retained 3 and will require arborist review and advice during construction
(labelled TBC on plans) (previously this was 20)
Of the trees surveyed on site, 150 are, by “State” definition (although not under Council’s PSP2 Landscaping
/Table SC6.3.6.1 Koala Food Trees), koala trees, with:
• 117 to be retained (previously this was 110) 4
• 27 will be removed (previously this was 44)
• six are proposed to be retained and will require arborist review and advice during construction
(previously this was 10)
Noting 71 native trees (of which 27 are defined as koala trees) will be removed, a closer analysis of those
trees provides better insight/appreciation for the potential loss of values, as described below.
2 The complete set of plans is provided by others.
3 Note – the intent is to retain mature vegetation rather than remove and replant. This is part of the envisaged design outcome
for the development.
4 Previously camphor laurel and trees to the north had been included in these figures.
Gondwana Ecology Group Pty Ltd 3
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
2ND RFI - Attachment 5 - Gondwana Ecology Group - Fuirther information request RACV JULY 2023.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 18.2 MB (very large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take a few minutes. On mobile data, it is best to wait for Wi-Fi.