Council archive · source document
Information Request - MCU23/0070 (as published)
Officer: Tara Norley
Direct Telephone: 5329 6414
Our Reference: MCU23/0070
Your Reference: M3024P
14 June 2023
Cambooya Pty Ltd
C/- JFP Urban Consultants Pty Ltd
T1.209 Kon-Tiki Business Centre
Tower 1/55 Plaza Parade
MAROOCHYDORE QLD 4558
[email protected]
Dear Applicant
Information Request
Planning Act 2016
I refer to your application and advise that Council requires further information to satisfactorily
assess the proposal.
1. APPLICATION DETAILS
Application No. MCU23/0070
Street Address: 36 & 38 Duke St, Sunshine Beach
Real Property Description: Lot 370 RP 48111 and Lot 371 RP 48111
Planning Scheme: Noosa Plan 2020 (25 September 2020)
2. INFORMATION REQUIRED
The proposal in its current form is substantially non-compliant with the relevant requirements
of Noosa Plan 2020 and requires extensive built form changes to reduce the scale of the
development. The information requested is set out below:
Issue – Proposal Plans
The proposal plans provided with the application material require further information and/or
clarification, including:
• The gross floor area of the Food and Drink Outlet tenancies is unclear.
• Evidence that the proposal will not result in overlooking of adjoining properties.
• The application material has only provided north/south section plans. Additional
section plans showing the east/west sections are required.
Information Required
1. Provide amended proposal plans clearly indicating the ‘use area’ and kitchen areas of
each of the Food and Drink Outlet tenancies. It is noted that toilets provided within the
development for the use of patrons only are not considered ‘public toilets’.
ABN 97.969.214.121 PO Box 141
noosa.qld.gov.au Tewantin QLD 4565
[email protected] 07 5329 6500
Page 1 of 6
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 5 pages
Page 2
2. Provide View Line plans that clearly identify any potential overlooking into the private
open space areas of the adjoining property to the west. Mitigation measure must also
be proposed / provided for any potential overlooking.
3. Provide east/west section plans for the below areas of the development:
Issue – Building Height (Storeys)
Performance Outcome PO9 of the Tourist Accommodation Zone Code requires development
in Sunshine Beach to be a maximum of three (3) storeys.
Performance Outcome PO9 of the Tourist Accommodation Zone Code requires development
to be of a scale compatible with surrounding development and does not present an
appearance of bulk to adjacent properties, roads or other areas in the vicinity of the site.
The proposal appears as four (4) storeys when viewed from the Duke St frontage and includes
portions of the building that are four (4) storeys in height. The proposal in its current format is
not considered consistent with the predominate scale of development in the area. Any
proposal over three (3) storeys in height is not supported.
Information Required
4. Provide amended proposal plans with a maximum building height of three (3) storeys
and consistent with the scale of development surrounding the site.
Page 2 of 6
Page 3
Issue – Site Cover
The site cover calculations provided with the application material do not accurately calculate
site cover in accordance with the Noosa Plan 2020 definition. Performance Outcome PO11 of
the Tourist Accommodation Zone Code requires development, where a mixed-use precinct
fronting Duke St, Sunshine Beach, to have a maximum site cover of 45%. Council calculates
that the proposed development includes a site cover of approximately 75%, which is
substantially over the 45% site cover requirement under Performance Outcome PO11 of the
Tourist Accommodation Zone Code and is not supported.
Information Required
5. Provide amended plans reducing site cover to 40% (as calculated in accordance with
the Noosa Plan 2020 definition).
Issue – Plot Ratio
Performance Outcome PO11 of the Tourist Accommodation Zone Code requires a plot ratio
of 0.8:1 for this site, being a total gross floor area (GFA) of 388.25m2.
The plot ratio calculations provided with the application material do not accurately calculate
plot ratio in accordance with the Noosa Plan 2020 definition
Council does not agree with the statement in the application material that the ground floor
bathroom is not included in the GFA calculation as the ‘space within a building between 2 floor
levels’ is considered to include the whole of the Ground Floor as a ‘storey’ and as such the
bathroom is not exempt under ‘a space containing only a bathroom, shower room, laundry,
toilet or other sanitary compartment’ as the storey is considered as the whole of the Ground
Floor. In addition, Council does not agree that the ‘ground floor public lobby’ is excluded from
GFA calculations. This area is not considered ‘public’ as it is only accessible to guests utilising
the accommodation on site. In addition, the lobby’s on the upper levels have also incorrectly
been excluded from the GFA calculations.
Any plot ratio in excess of the requirement under Performance Outcome PO11 of the Medium
Density Residential Zone Code is not supported.
Information Required
6. Provide amended plans reducing plot ratio to 0.8:1 (as calculated in accordance with the
gross floor area and plot ratio Noosa Plan 2020 definitions).
Issue – Setbacks
Acceptable Outcome PO13.1 of the Tourist Accommodation Zone Code requires setbacks in
Duke Street the third storey to be setback a minimum of 6m from the front boundary, 1m from
the side boundaries and 10m from the rear boundary. The proposal does not comply with
these setback requirements for Level 2 & Level 3 (noting the above item regarding the four
storey component not being supported). It is noted that the pools and planters built to the side
boundary on Level 3 is not supported. The proposed setbacks on the upper levels is not
consistent with the predominant character in the area and does not maintain the visual
continuity and pattern of buildings within Duke and Douglas Streets and is not supported.
Information Required
7. Provide amended plans complying with setback requirements for the third storey.
Page 3 of 6
Page 4
Issue – Carparking
The Short-term Accommodation component of the development requires a minimum of six (6)
covered carparks.
Noting the above item requesting amended proposal plans clearly indicating the ‘use area’ of
each of the Food and Drink Outlet tenancies in accordance with relevant planning scheme
definitions, the proposed GFA for the Food and drink outlet component is currently unclear,
however the proposal does not provide any parking for the commercial component of the
development.
As previously advised, Council may consider contributions in lieu of car parking for this site on
the basis:
•That, except for car parking, the proposal complies with the planning scheme -
including but not limited to height, storeys, site cover and plot ratio
• The extent of contributions required is less than what was identified in the pre-
lodgement meeting – in this regard a car park must be provided for each unit with
associated visitor parking and some parking for the commercial component of the
development.
The application as lodged does not comply with the relevant planning scheme provisions, nor
provide sufficient carparking for each unit, visitor parking and a portion of the commercial
carparking required. As such, an Infrastructure Agreement for contributions in lieu of
carparking may not be supported.
Information Required
8. Provide amended plans either reducing the carparking requirements or providing
additional carparking (including one carpark per unit, 2 visitor parks and additional
parking for the commercial component).
Issue – Design
The proposal is not considered to sufficiently constitute ‘lightweight’ design. It is recommended
the front façade be lightened up (eg narrowing the depth of the floors/veranda roof, cladding
the dividing stone walls in lighter materials).
The western portion of the northern elevation requires greater articulation.
Information Required
9. Provide amended plans with lightening up the Duke St frontage and providing greater
articulation to the Douglas St frontage.
Issue – Bicycle Parking
It is unclear how the proposed bicycle parking will be accessed when the carparks are
occupied.
Information Required
10. Provide amended plans with accessible bicycle parking.
Page 4 of 6
Page 5
Issue – Waste Storage Area
It is unclear if the proposed ‘Refuse’ area is of a sufficient size to service the proposed
development.
Information Required
11. Provide additional information regarding the proposed waste management requirement
for the whole of the development.
12. If required, amend the proposal plans to include a waste storage area of a sufficient size
to service the whole of the development.
Issue – Stormwater Drainage
The submitted documentation does not include sufficient information for Council to assess
how stormwater generated by the development will be controlled, collected, and discharged.
• It is unclear what the proposed structure downstream from the proposed detention tank
is and how it will integrate into the proposed drainage system (indicated by a blue
circle).
• It is unclear how the proposed detention tank overflows during events up to, and
including, a 1% AEP event (volume, discharge rate).
• It is unclear how the infiltration outlet of the detention tank will operate. Given the large
catchment area of the detention tank, Council is concerned the soil may become
oversaturated and the filtration rate of the soil will reduce which may adversely affect
the overall drainage system and the structural elements of the development.
• It is unclear how the proposed field inlet in catchment D3 will function during a 1% AEP
event. Council recognise that this field inlet serves both the overflow from the detention
tank and a small catchment area. Council is concerned that during events up to, and
including, a 1% AEP event this pit may surcharge and direct additional runoff on to the
footpath in the road reserve.
• The discharge rate of the RHS kerb adapter is unclear. Council is unlikely to support a
discharge rate higher than 25 l/s during a 1% AEP event.
Information Required
13. Provide additional detail to address Council’s concerns. The additional detail must be
prepared by a suitably qualified person (RPEQ).
Note that the detail can be preliminary in nature but must be sufficiently detailed to
demonstrate that the stormwater system is conceptually functional.
Issue – Driveway Access
The submitted documentation does not contain sufficient information for Council to assess the
proposed driveway.
Information Required
14. Provide additional detail on the proposed driveway and crossover. The detail must be
prepared by a suitably qualified person (RPEQ – Registered Professional Engineer of
Queensland) and include, but not be limited to:
a. dimensions, levels and grade of the access driveway; and
b. demonstrate that a B99 vehicle will not scrape or bottom out while entering or exiting
the driveway.
Page 5 of 6
Page 6
Issue – Earth works
An earthworks plan has not been provided and therefore it is unclear the extent of earthworks
required to be carried out for the proposed development.
Information Required
15. Provide an Earthworks Plan demonstrating the extent of the proposed earthworks
required to carry out the proposed works. The additional plan must be prepared by a
suitably qualified person (RPEQ – Registered Professional Engineer of Queensland)
and include, but not be limited to:
a. the extent and volume of cut and fill; and
b. demonstrate the proposed earthworks will not adversely affect any structures within
the adjoining properties; and
c. demonstrate that all retaining structures, both temporary and permanent, both above
and below ground, will be contained entirely within the subject site.
Issue – Carpark Turnaround Bay
TTM’s Traffic Engineering Report states that the Parking Aisle Extension, although not
compliant with the standard 1 metre extension, meets the performance outcome of its intended
use. Insufficient information has been provided demonstrating a B99 vehicle can manoeuvre
the turnaround bay and exit the site in a forward gear.
Information Required
16. Provide additional detail demonstrating that the turnaround bay at the end of the aisle is
sufficient to allow B99 vehicles to manoeuvre the site and exit in a forward gear. The
additional detail must be prepared by a suitably qualified person (RPEQ) and include,
but not be limited to:
a. assume proposed carparks R2, R3 and R5 are occupied.
3. DUE DATE FOR RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST
The due date for providing the requested information is 14 September 2023. Email your
response to [email protected]. Please advise Council of your response to this
information request in accordance with section 13 of the Development Assessment Rules.
If you do not provide a response before the due date, it will be taken as if you have decided
not to respond to the information request and Council will continue with the assessment of
your application.
4. OTHER DETAILS
You can follow the progress of this application online at www.noosa.qld.gov.au. The “Online
Services” page can be accessed via "Quick Links" on the left hand side of the screen.
Should you have any further queries in relation to the above, please do not hesitate to contact
me on the number above.
Yours faithfully
Tara Norley
Development Planner
Page 6 of 6
Used in these records
Information Request - MCU23/0070 (as published)Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 252 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.