Skip to the record
The gold standard in government transparency.

Council archive · source document

Norton Rose providing applicant's legal opinion on SCC Assessment Manager decision process - Noosa on Weyba - MCU12/0208

of 12

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

                                                                                                    A
                                                                                                    NO O OS                                                      B         G
22 November 2013
                                                                                                    Norton Rose Fulbright Australia
                                                                                                    ABN 32 720 868 049

By Email                                                                                            Level21, ONE ONE ONE
                                                                                                    1/1 Eagle Street
                                                                                                    BRISBANE QLD 4000
Cr Mark Jamieson                                                                                    AUSTRALIA

Mayor                                                                                               Tel +61 7 3414 2888
Sunshine Coast Regional Council                                                                     Fax +61 7 3414 2999
mail@sunshinecoast. Id. ovau
                                                                                                    GPO Box 407, Brisbane QLD 4001
                                                                                                    DX 114 Brisbane
MrJohn Knaggs
Chief Executive Officer                                                                             norionrosefulbright. coin
Sunshine Coast Regional Council                                                                     Direct line
mail@sunshinecoast. Id. ovau                                                                        +61 7 3414 2708

MrWarren Bunker                                                                                     Email

Director, Regional Strategy & Planning                                                              ben. harvey@ norionrosefulbright. coin
Sunshine Coast Regional Council                                                                     Your reference:                                 Our reference:
warren. bunker@sunshinecoast. d. ovau
                                                                                                                                                    2780680




Dear Cr Jamieson, Mr Knaggs and Mr Bunker

Noosa on Weyba Development Application


             We actfor Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd, the applicantforthe Noosa on Weyba development
             application MCU 12/0208 (Development Application).

2            As you know, the Queensland Government recently passed the Local Government and Other
             Legislation Amendment Act2013 (the Amending Act). The Amending Actintroduces transitional
             provisions to the Sustainable Planning Act2009 (SPA), which have serious consequences to the
             assessment of our client's Development Application.

             We have been instructed to write to you regarding the assessment process and alert you to a difficult
             practical issue as to the timing forthe decision required to be made under the Amending Act.


Amendments to the SPA


4            A new section 952 of the SPA will require the Sunshine Coast Regional Council(SCRC) to shortly
             make a decision on whether or not it is to continue to be the decision maker forthe Development
             Application (The Decision). A copy of the relevant provisions from the Amending Actis enclosed.

             Our client is concerned to ensure that the SCRC follows the correct process as required by the
             Amending Act, when making The Decision. Failure to do so may unnecessarily delay the
             assessment of the Development Application, or expose The Decision to third party challenge.

6            Our client understands SCRC is intending to make The Decision as early as next week.

7            We do not believe that SCRC can make The Decision before I January 2014. Further, it must make
             the decision no later than 2 January 2014!

8            We have been asked by our client to set out our understanding of how the new section 952 should
             be implemented.
APAC-#20984420-v3


Norton Rose Fulbright Australia is a law firm as defined in the Legal Profession Ads of the Australian states and territory in which It pradises
Norton Rose Fulbright Australia. Norton Rose Fulbrighl LLP. Norton Rose Fulbrighl Canada LLP. Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa (incorporated as Daneys Reitz Inc) and
Fulbright & Jaworski LLP. each of which is a separate legal entity. are members of Norton Rose Fulbright Verein. a Swiss Verein. Details of each entity. with certain regulatory
Information. are at norionrosefulbright. corn. Norton Rose Fulbright VBrein helps coordinate the activities @1the members but does riot itself provide legal services to clients
Full text of the other 11 pages

Page 2

                                                                                   A
                                                                                   NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT

The Law


9 Section 31 of the Amending Actinsertsthe de-amalgamation transitional provisions into the SPA.
       The new section 952 of the SPA provides that the SCRC, as the continuing local government, must
         make The Decision by 2 January 2014.

         If SCRC decides to continue as the decision maker, then it must within 2 business days of making
         The Decision, give written notice to our client and Noosa Shire Council(Noosa). SCRC will remain
         as the assessment manager forthe Development Application and Noosa will become a new
         concurrence agency.

         If SCRC decides to not be the decision maker, then it must within 2 business days of making The
         Decision, give written notice to our client and Noosa. On the day that Noosa receives the notice, it
         will become the new assessment manager forthe Development Application and SCRC will become
         a new concurrence agency.

         However, pursuantto section 2(2) of the Amending Act, section 952 of the SPA, which empowers
         SCRC to make the Decision, does not commence untill January 2014.

Summary

13 In summary, SCRC's power to make The Decision in respect of our client's Development Application
        arises from section 31 of the Amending Act, which introduces a new section 952 of the SPA.

14 However, section 31 of the Amending Act does riot commence, and will not be law, untill January
         2014.


15 It seems to us that the intention of the legislature is for The Decision to be made by SCRC in full
        Council or by authorised delegation on either I January (a public holiday) or 2 January 2014.
16       This would seem correct, if one considers that:

         (1) On I January 2014 and not before, Noosa will become a new local government under the
                   Local Government Act2009;

         (2) The Decision to be made by SCRC ought not to be made until Noosa exists as a local
                   government; and

         (3) To avoid concerns of conflict of interest, The Decision should be made by SCRC at a time
                   when the Councilis reconstituted with justthe Councillors for Divisions I to 10.

         We are available to discuss the contents of this letter with you if required, and our client is
         concerned, given its substantial investment in the project, that The Decision is lawfulIy made by
         SCRC in a way that it cannot be challenged and/or delayed.

Please contact MichaelWalton on (07) 3414 2633 or Ben Harvey on (07) 3414 2708 for further assistance.

Yours faithfully
                    .


                        \


Mic I alton
N nRoseFulbrightAustralia
Co act: BenHarvey

     C



Extracts from the Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013




APAC-#20984420-v3

Page 3

                                                                          A
                                                                          NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT




SCHEDU E

Extracts from the Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013




APAC-#20984420-v3

Page 4

Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013
Part I Preliminary

[s I]

The Parliament of Queensland enacts-




Pa t,                      Prelim na y


         Short title

              This Act may be cited as the Local Government and Other
              Legislation Amendment Act 2013.

2        Commencement

         (1) The following provisions commence on a day to be fixed by
              proclamation-
              . sections25t029;
              . section 31to the extent it inserts new chapter 10, part 8,
                    division I;
              . section 32(3)to(6);
              . schedule Ito the extent it amends the Sustainable
                    Planning Act2009.
         (2) The following provisions cornmence on I January 2014-
              ' section 17;
              . section 19 to the extent it inserts new chapter 9, part 7,
                    division 2;

              . section 31 to the extent it inserts new chapter 10, part 8, _;^^--
                    division 2;
              . section 32(I)and(2).




Page 6                                                        2013 Act No. 60

Page 5

                         Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013
                                  Part 5 Amendment of Sustainable Planning Act 2009

                                                                              ts 311

3       Insertion of new ch 10, pt 8
              Aftersection 947-

              insert-

                  Part 8                 Transitional provis ons
                                         for Local Government
                                         and Other Legislat on
                                         Amendment Act20,3


                  D     s on             State p ann rig nstrumen s

                  948 Existing development applications
                      (1) This section applies to adevelopmentapplication
                            made, but not decided, before this section
                            commences


                      (2) The development application must be dealt with
                            and decided under this Act as if sections 26 and
                            43, as in force before the conrrnencement, had
                            notbeen amended by the amending Act.
                      (3) However, for assessing or deciding the
                           application, an assessment manager or referral
                           agency for the application may apply the sections
                           amended by the amending Act to the extent it
                           considers appropriate.
                      (4) In this section-
                            cine"dingAct meansthe Local Government and
                            Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013.




2013 Act No. 60                                                            Page 25

Page 6

Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013
Part 5 Amendment of Sustainable Planning Act 2009

[s 31]

                 D    s on 2             De-amalgamation o
                                         particular local
                                         governments
                 Subd       s on         Preliminary
                 949 Definitions for pt 8, div 2
                      In this division-

                           @PPItc"tto" means an application made under
                            this Act.

                           changeoverd"y means 11anuary 2014.
                           contt""ing loc"Igover"merit means-
                            (a) Cairns Regional Council; or
                            (b) Rockhampton Regional Council; or
                            (c) Sunshine Coast Regional Council; or
                            (d) Tablelands Regional Council
                            contt""ing local government @rea, for a
                            continuing local government, means the local
                            government area for the continuing local
                            government that comes into existence on the
                            changeover day.
                            decision maker, for a continuing or new local
                            government, means an entity that has a function
                            under this Act to make a decision about a matter.

                            existing proceeding, means a proceeding that-
                            (a) started under the Act before this section
                                 commences^


                                 (i) before a building and development
                                        cornimttee; or
                                 (11) in acourt; and
                            (b) on the coriumencement-
                                 (i) has notbeen decided; or
Page 26                                                         2013 Act No. 60

Page 7

                  Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013
                            Part 5 Amendment of Sustainable Planning Act 2009

                                                                        ts 311

                           (11) has not been withdrawn, or disntissed,
                                struck out or otherwise disposed of
                                under the Act.

                     IC"d, for an application, offence comumtted,
                     proceeding or request means the land to which it
                     relates.

                     mew IOC@I government means each of the
                     following local governments that comes into
                     existence on the changeover day-
                     (a) DouglasShireCouncil;
                     (b) Livingstone Shire Council;
                     (c) NoosaShire Council;
                     (d) MareebaShire Council.
                     new IOC@I government are@, for a new local
                     government, meansthe local government area for
                     the new local government that comes into
                     existence on the changeover day.
                     related-

                      I Cairns Regional Councilis related to
                          Douglas Shire Council.
                     2 RockhamptonRegionalCouncilisrelotedto
                         Livingstone Shire Council.
                     3 Sunshine CoastRegionalCouncilis related
                           to Noosa Shire Council.

                     4 Tablelands Regional Councilis related to
                           Mareeba Shire Council.

                     request means a request made under this Act.




2013 Act No. 60                                                      Page 27

Page 8

Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013
Part 5 Amendment of Sustainable Planning Act 2009

[s 31]

                 Subd       s on 2      Applications orrequests
                                        made before changeover
                                        day

                 950 Application orrequest relating to land wholly
                     within continuing local government area
                    (1) This section applies if-
                            (a) before the changeover day, a continuing
                                 local government-
                                 (1) is the decision maker for an application
                                       or request; and
                                 (it) has not decided the application or
                                       request; and
                            (b) on the changeover day, the land is wholly
                                 within the local government's area.
                    (2) On the changeover day, the local government
                            continues as the decision maker for the
                            application or request.


                 951 Application orrequest relating to land wholly
                     within new local government area
                    (1) This section applies if-
                            (a) before the changeover day, a continuing
                                 local government-
                                 (1) 1sthe decision maker for an application
                                       or request; and
                                 (ii) has not decided the application or
                                       request; and
                            (b) on the changeover day, the land is wholly
                                 within a new local government's area.




Page 28                                                        2013 Act No. 60

Page 9

                          Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013
                                    Part 5 Amendment of Sustainable Planning Act 2009

                                                                                ts 311

                    (2)      On the changeover day, the new local
                             government becomes the decision maker for the
                             application or request.
                    (3)      Subsection (4) applies if, on the changeover
                             day-
                             (a) the new local government must under this
                                  Act, take a particular step as decision maker
                                  for the application or request within a
                                  certain period; and
                             (b) the step has not been fully taken.
                    (4)      The local government has a further 10 business
                             daysto take the step as wellas any unexpired part
                             of the period.


                  952 Application or request relating to land within
                      continuing and new local government area
                    (1) This section applies if-
                             (a) before the changeover day, a continuing
                                  local government-
                                   (1) is the decision maker for an application
                                         or request; and
                                   (11) has not decided the application or
                                         request; and
                             (b) on the changeover day the land is partly
                                   within-

                                   (a) a continuing local government area;
                                         and

                                   (b) a new local government area.
                     (2) The continuing local government for the
                             continuing local government area must decide by
                              the end of 2 January 2014 whether it is to
                             continue to be the decision maker for the
                              application or request.
2013 Act No. 60                                                              Page 29

Page 10

Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013
Part 5 Amendment of Sustainable Planning Act 2009

Is 31'

                    (3)      ithin 2 business days of making the decision,
                           the continuing local government must, give
                           written notice of its decision to-

                            (a) for an application-the applicant; and
                            (b) for a request-the person who made the
                                 request; and
                            (c) the new local government.
                    (4)     If the continuing local government gives notice
                            that it is not continuing as the decision maker for
                            the application or request, the new local
                            government becomes the decision maker on the
                            day it receives the notice (the not^/teatto" day).
                    (5)     A continuing local government that continues as
                            the decision maker, or a new local government
                            that becomes the decision maker, under this
                            section must consult the related local
                            government, in the way it considers appropriate,
                            before it decides the application or request.
                    (6)     However, subsection (5) does not apply to a local
                            government if the application is a development
                            application
                     (7)    Subsection (8) applies if, on the notification
                            day-
                            (a) the new local government is required to take
                                  a particular step as the decision maker for an
                                  application or request within a certain
                                  period; and
                            (b) the step has not been fully taken.
                     (8)    The new local government has a further 10
                            business days to take the step as well as any
                            unexpired part of the period.
                     (9)    Subsections (10) to (12) apply to an application
                            that is a development application if-



Page 30                                                          2013 Act No. 60

Page 11

                          Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013
                                   Part 5 Amendment of Sustainable Planning Act 2009

                                                                               [s 31]

                             (a) a continuing local government continues as
                                   the decision maker under subsection (2); or
                             (b) a new local government becomes the
                                  decision maker under subsection (4).
                   (10)      Regardless of which stage of IDAS applies to the
                             application, the other local government that is not
                             the decision maker is the concurrence agency for
                             the application to the extent the application is
                             aboutland within the local government's area.
                   (11)      The             agency must give the
                                    concurrence

                             concurrence agency's response within 30
                             business days after the notification day.
                   (12)      The decision maker can not make a decision
                             about the application until the earlier of the
                             following-
                             (a) the receipt of the concurrence agency's
                                   response;

                             (b) the expiration of 30 business days after the
                                   notification day.


                  953 Continuing local government to assist related
                      new local government
                    (1) This section applies if a new local government
                          becomes a decision maker for an application or
                             request under this subdivision.
                    (2) The related continuing local government must do
                             all acts and things necessary or desirable to
                             facilitate the transfer of the decision maker
                             function to the new local government.
                    (3) Without 11nxiting subsection (2), the related
                             continuing local government must give the new
                             local government the documents that are
                             necessary to enable compliance with a provision
                             of this Actincluding, for example-
2013 Act No. 60                                                             Page 31

Page 12

Local Government and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2013
Part 5 Amendment of Sustainable Planning Act 2009

ts 311


                           (a) all material relevant to the application or
                                request the continuing local government had
                                on the changeover day; and
                           (b) any material the continuing local
                               government receives about the application
                               or request after the new local government
                                  becomes the decision maker.



                 Subd       s on 3       Ex s rig p oceed rigs

                 954 Land wholly within new local government area
                    (1) This section applies to an existing proceeding
                           if-

                            (a) the proceeding was started before the
                                  changeover day; and
                            (b) a continuing local government was a party
                                 to the proceeding; and
                            (c) on the changeover day, the land is wholly
                                  within a new local government area.
                    (2) For the proceeding, the new local government
                          becomes a party to the proceeding in place of the
                          related continuing local government.


                 955 Land within both continuing and new local
                      government area
                    (1) This section applies to an existing proceeding
                            if-

                            (a) the proceeding was started before the
                                  changeover day; and
                            (b) a continuing local government was a party
                                  to the proceeding; and
                            (c) on the changeover day, the land to which the
                                 proceeding relates is partly within-
Page 32                                                         2013 Act No. 60

Used in these records

About this file

File size
3.8 MB (large file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Norton Rose providing applicant's legal opinion on SCC Assessment Manager decision process - Noosa on Weyba - MCU12_0208.pdf · 3.8 MB (large file)

The download may take up to a minute.

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.