Skip to the record
Beware of cheap imitations.

Council archive · source document

PETITIONS · 2024-07-18 Attachment 1 to the Minutes - Petition - Noosaville Infratructure Foreshore Masterplan - Caryn Musgrave and Bernard OSullivan

of 8

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

                                                                                Caryn Musgrave




          Electronic Petition: Oppose the Noosaville Foreshore Plan - UPDATE

17th July 2024

Noosa Council
9 Pelican St Tewantin, QLD, 1565
Via email to [email protected]

To: The Council and Councillors of Noosa Council

I Caryn Priscilla Musgrave (                                      ) on behalf of the community as
requested by members on the Facebook Noosa Community Notice Board was asked to start
this Petition and so I confirm I am the principal petitioner. My contact details are above.

The issue and action requested of Council
Based on the overwhelming comments made on the Notice Board, the petition is Opposing the
Plan in its current draft. The content of the e-petition presented is in the PDF document
attached to this letter and email submission.

The requested action
Is to stop proceeding with the current plan, leave it alone, and create a new maintenance plan
that takes in the community's reactions and suggestions.

The petition seeks to be presented to the whole of Council

How support for the e-petition was obtained

The e-petition was created on June 25th at Change.org. Change.org is leading global e-petition
web application that is used extensively by Local councils among others in Australia.

The link to the petition is below for reference and was posted to the Facebook Noosa
Community Notice Board on June 25 th. With change.org once the petition is signed the person
has the option to share via other social means.

https://chng.it/FCjHbYCLvk

In addition, QR Code based - Flyers were printed by Noosa O-Boat’s and displayed at the
adjacent Tennis Court. Additional QR Code based – Flyer was hung next to the Council
Foreshore Plan Notice board near the Pelican Boat Hire.

As of 12 pm Sunday, July 7th, 2024 in line with the “Have your Say” deadline the e-petition had
obtained 1,154 signatures. Since then it has now increased to 1,511.
Full text of the other 7 pages

Page 2

Yours sincerely,




Caryn Musgrave

Attachments
    - Full signature list of 1,511 signatories with name and location
    - PDF of all the comments made by the signatories
    - Analysis of sentiment
    - Copy of the e-Petition content listed on Change.org

Page 3

16/07/2024, 16:24                                                                Petition · Oppose the Noosaville Foreshore Master Plan - Noosaville, Australia · Change.org




                     Congratulations on starting your petition!
                     Take steps to strengthen it.




                                               Petition strength             Start an image test
                                                                             Upload a few images and we’ll find the
                                                                             one driving the most signatures.
                                                    9      Good
                                                                             Start smart image test




                                            Oppose the Noosaville Foreshore Master Plan
                                            Started                                     25 June 2024
                                            Petition to                                 Noosa community and 1 other



                                            1,511                                                                                                                              2,500
https://www.change.org/p/oppose-the-noosaville-foreshore-master-plan?recruiter=124190610&recruited_by_id=95542b50-0898-11e4-a2a3-ffc7cda2184b&utm_source=share_petition&utm_campaign=petition_dashboard&utm_medium=c…   1/6

Page 4

16/07/2024, 16:24                                                                Petition · Oppose the Noosaville Foreshore Master Plan - Noosaville, Australia · Change.org
                                            Signatures                                                                                                                         Next goal

                                                                                                      people signed this week

                                                                                                     Share this petition


                                            Why this petition matters

                                                   Started by Caryn Musgrave

                                                 Media Inquiries

                                            The Noosaville Foreshore Plan Impacts

                                            Significant concerns are raised on the Noosa Community Facebook group about the draft plan with comments growing
                                            daily. This plan has a large impact, especially on the current community.

                                            What is at stake?

                                                 1. Noosa Tennis courts have been designated to be replaced with a playground impacting retirees' weekly/daily
                                                    social gatherings.

                                                 2. Parking will be reduced impacting accessibility to the daily surf ski community, boat hires, and businesses

                                                 3. Loss of the current natural integration with the foreshore and birdlife.

                                                 4. And others such as the massive disruption that would occur for years if this were to be built in a full-scale
                                                    development.

                                            Why we need to act now?

                                            The deadline for community feedback is July 7th. If this petition has the support we need to submit electronically by July
                                            6th to ensure compliance.

                                            The back story

                                            The following story was posted on Facebook obtaining over 44 comments and 90+ likes as of June 24th. The request from
                                            some of the members was to use this story as an outline to understand more.


                                            The Noosa Foreshore!
                                                                                                     people signed this week
                                            Happiness is very present now!
                                                                                                     Share this petition

                                            I wandered the entire length of the foreshore today and saw nothing but happiness and appreciation. Gatherings of all
                                            levels from retirees, to young families. In fact the entire length of the reach had numerous people enjoying every aspect of

https://www.change.org/p/oppose-the-noosaville-foreshore-master-plan?recruiter=124190610&recruited_by_id=95542b50-0898-11e4-a2a3-ffc7cda2184b&utm_source=share_petition&utm_campaign=petition_dashboard&utm_medium=c…   2/6

Page 5

16/07/2024, 16:24                                                                Petition · Oppose the Noosaville Foreshore Master Plan - Noosaville, Australia · Change.org
                                            it. Why disrupt the status quo?

                                            The Tennis Courts


                                            Every Tuesday at 9am the locals gather to play games, socialise and interact with the natural surroundings. If you are
                                            watching the “let’s live Forever” program on channel 9 one of the keys to longevity is social engagement, followed by diet
                                            and other aspects. How could anyone want to deny these lovely semi-retired and retired residents lose their tennis court
                                            to yet another kids playground.

                                            Interstate Visitor Concerns


                                            As we walked we came across a couple staring at the Council plan sign on the post near the walkway. We said hi what do
                                            you think. They responded “It seems really wrong, all the key words on the sign are meaningless”. What do you mean?
                                             “Well it’s all glossy and not specific” was the reply. “It looks like they are trying to copy other ‘on trend’ locations, why
                                            would you mess with this natural beautiful location?”.

                                            Reduced Parking


                                            This is the hot topic for business. They desperately need to retain as much regular vehicle traffic as possible. What about
                                            all the local “surf skiers”! We love to walk by to see so many happy folks with their cars backed in, ski’s on roof or under
                                            wash down after a good paddle up the river. Ties right back to “longevity” and happiness.


                                            Fishing

                                            Promoting timber outlooks to help fishing is a big concern. From practical experience in Sydney Harbour, where the
                                            foreshore provided platforms for fishing ended up creating more problems. First this cohort of fisherman are more the lazy
                                            type that leave rubbish, including unused bait and fish hooks. We had to stop letting our dog off the lead as it would go
                                            sniff the bait and end up with a fish hook in its paws! We believe true fisherman who want to fish in the Noosa river do not
                                            need timber decking to help them, they will wade into the water, use a boat or whatever it takes to catch that fish.
                                            Conclusion, fishing features should not be a part of the future plan.

                                            Wildlife & Habitat


                                            Yesterday we also had a picnic on the foreshore and 3 ducks waddled up to check out what we were eating! They seem to
                                            be the same ducks from another picnic a few days earlier at the busking day. Here’s the thing! If we start putting jutting
                                            out timber lookouts etc. are the ducks going to come and interact with our families and enable a natural integration with
                                            our beautiful surrounds?


                                            With this plan - what duck is going to climb up a timber postsigned
                                                                                                  people   and come   talk to us? What this plan will result in is a
                                                                                                                this week
                                            SEPARATION of human nature with natural birdlife and fauna. We need our kids and grandkids have the freedom to
                                            naturally interact with nature.


                                            E-Bikes & co-existence with us People


https://www.change.org/p/oppose-the-noosaville-foreshore-master-plan?recruiter=124190610&recruited_by_id=95542b50-0898-11e4-a2a3-ffc7cda2184b&utm_source=share_petition&utm_campaign=petition_dashboard&utm_medium=c…   3/6

Page 6

16/07/2024, 16:24                                                                  Petition · Oppose the Noosaville Foreshore Master Plan - Noosaville, Australia · Change.org
                                            We already have an issue of e-bikes going so fast and doing wheel stands down the streets. Why promote reduced vehicle
                                            access and increase cycling? The layout today is so safe and workable.


                                            Lodging this Petition


                                            This petition will be lodged via email to be presented to the whole of Council.

                                            The requested action


                                            Is to stop proceeding with the current plan, leave it alone, and create a new maintenance plan that takes in the
                                            community's reactions and suggestions.




                                                                Share this petition in person or use the QR code for your own material.

                                                                Download QR code




                                               Report a policy violation




                                            Media Resources

                                                   Are you a member of the media looking to cover this petition?
                                                   Reach out for available actions.


                                            Decision makers


                                                      Noosa Council



                                                      Noosa community

                                                                                                       people signed this week




https://www.change.org/p/oppose-the-noosaville-foreshore-master-plan?recruiter=124190610&recruited_by_id=95542b50-0898-11e4-a2a3-ffc7cda2184b&utm_source=share_petition&utm_campaign=petition_dashboard&utm_medium=c…   4/6

Page 7

Analysis of comments made by the people signing the change.org petition.

The process: All comments made by the petition signers was printed to a PDF document
(see attached) and then with deleted of all names, the comments was analysed by ChatGPT
4o. If further details on the GenAI process is required please contact me.

Direct copy of the output generated (unedited) is below

The comments you provided express strong opposition to the Noosaville Foreshore Master
Plan. Here's an analysis of the main themes and concerns highlighted by the community:

1. Satisfaction with Current State:
  - Many comments indicate that the community is happy with the current state of the
foreshore, describing it as "perfect," "beautiful," and "fine as it is."
  - There is a call for minimal intervention, with suggestions to focus on maintenance rather
than extensive development (e.g., tidying up, increasing maintenance, fixing paths).

2. Opposition to Overdevelopment:
  - There is a recurring fear of overdevelopment and a transformation into something akin to
the Gold Coast, which is perceived negatively.
  - Comments suggest that more built structures are unnecessary and that the natural
environment should be preserved.

3. Concerns About Specific Changes:
  - Loss of car parking is a significant concern, with many worried about reduced
accessibility, especially for the elderly and those with disabilities.
  - The removal of the tennis courts is another frequent point of contention.
  - The proposed replacement of open grassy spaces with artificial dunes and the
introduction of more concrete structures are also opposed.

4. Nostalgia and Heritage:
  - Several comments emphasize the importance of preserving the historical and nostalgic
aspects of Noosaville.
  - There is a strong emotional attachment to the current state, with references to personal
histories and memories tied to the foreshore.

5. Community Engagement and Representation:
  - Some comments suggest that the community's voice is not being adequately considered
in the planning process.
  - There is a call for more community input and for the council to listen to the residents'
needs and desires.

6. Environmental and Practical Concerns:
   - Comments express concerns about potential environmental impacts, such as damage
and debris from floods.
   - Practical suggestions include adding more seating and toilets, removing overhead power
lines, and introducing electric buses to reduce noise.

7. Financial Concerns:
  - Several comments highlight concerns about the cost of the proposed changes, viewing
them as a waste of taxpayer money.
  - There is a preference for directing funds towards more pressing issues, such as roads or
accommodations for the homeless.

Page 8

8. General Sentiment:
   - The overall sentiment is overwhelmingly negative towards the master plan.
   - Many comments are direct and unambiguous in their opposition, with phrases like "leave
it alone," "stop destroying," and "we don't want it."

In summary, the community's feedback strongly opposes the Noosaville Foreshore Master
Plan, advocating for minimal changes, preservation of the current state, and better
maintenance instead of extensive redevelopment. There is a clear desire for the council to
listen to and engage more with the community's preferences.

Used in these records

About this file

File size
533 KB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

2024-07-18 Attachment 1 to the Minutes - Petition - Noosaville Infratructure Foreshore Masterplan - Caryn Musgrave and Bernard OSullivan.pdf · 533 KB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.