Skip to the record
The definitive source for everything Noosa Council.

Council archive · source document

Council Lake Weyba Information Response 28-10-13_FINAL · MCU12/0208

of 64

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

28 October 2013

The Chief Executive Officer
Sunshine Coast Regional Council
Locked Bag 72
Sunshine Coast Mail Centre
Qld 4560

Attention: Dennis Wallace

                                   INFORMATION REQUEST RESPONSE
                        DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION – MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE
 PRELIMINARY APPROVAL FOR MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE UNDER SECTION 242 OF THE SUSTAINABLE PLANNING
  ACT 2009 TO VARY THE EFFECT OF THE NOOSA PLAN AND MAROOCHY PLAN 2000 PLANNING SCHEMES FOR A
                              MIXED USE COMMUNITY TITLE DEVELOPMENT

                         EENIE CREEK RD, 99 & 191 HOLLETT RD NOOSAVILLE QLD 4566
                                                     AND
                             106, 108-142 TIDSWELL RD WEYBA DOWNS QLD 4562
Described as Lot 2 RP160983, Lot 2 SP179590, Lot 7 RP46782, Lot 53 SP163571, Lot 11 SP250714, Lot 12 RP893393
                                             and Lot 1667 M37772

                         Sunshine Coast Regional Council Reference Number: MCU12/0208

Dear Dennis,

We refer to Council’s Information Request dated 28 February 2013 made under section 276 of the Sustainable
Planning Act 2009 (SPA). We also refer to your letter dated 11 June 2013 extending the date for responding.

The purpose of this letter is two-fold, namely:

        Part 1 – to give the Council notice of three changes to the application pursuant to section 351 of SPA;
        Part 2 – to provide the applicant’s response to Council’s Information Request pursuant to section 278 of
         SPA.


Part 1 – Notification of Changes under s.351 & s.354 of SPA
Notice is given to the Council pursuant to section 351 and 354 of SPA of the following four changes:

          Proposed Change                        Type of Change                             Outcome
                                        (minor change under Section 351
                                         of SPA or change as a result of
                                           Information Request under
                                                   section 354)
 Change 1 - Strategic Cropping Land     Change under either section 351     The proposed Noosa on Weyba
                                        or 354 of SPA.                      Development no longer requires
                                                                            referral to DNRM for SCL under
                                                                            Schedule 7, Table 3, Colum 1, Item 27
                                                                            of the Sustainable Planning Regulation
                                                                            2009 as the proposed use of Lot 2 on
                                                                            SP17950 is identified in Schedule 13A of
                                                                            the SPR, Item number 5- as ‘an area
                                                                            zoned under a planning scheme for




                                                       1
Full text of the other 63 pages

Page 2

         Proposed Change                       Type of Change                            Outcome
                                       (minor change under Section 351
                                        of SPA or change as a result of
                                         Information Request under
                                                 section 354)
                                                                          rural residential or future residential
                                                                          purposes’. The remaining six lots have
                                                                          been decided non-SCL through the
                                                                          validation application process, and
                                                                          therefore the provisions of the SCL Act
                                                                          do not apply to any of the lots
                                                                          comprising the subject land.



Change 2 - Urban Design Report         Change under either section 351    A number of design layout changes
                                       or 354 of SPA.                     have been made to the Urban Design
                                                                          Report. These changes are in direct
                                                                          response     to    satisfying    SCRC’s
                                                                          Information Request.
Change 3 - Noosa on Weyba              Change under either section 351    The Specific Solutions and Probable
Locality Plan                          or 354 of SPA.                     Solutions within the Noosa on Weyba
                                                                          Locality Code have been amended in
                                                                          response to items specifically included
                                                                          within the SCRC and Referral Agencies
                                                                          Information Requests.

                                                                          Maps, Figures and Diagrams have also
                                                                          been amended in response to items
                                                                          specifically included within the SCRC
                                                                          and Referral Agencies Information
                                                                          Requests.
Change 4 - Specialist Reporting        Change under either section 351    Specialist Reporting has been revised in
   - Civil Engineer Report             or 354 of SPA.                     response to items raised in SCRC and
        (bulk           earthworks,                                       Referral       Agencies     Information
        roadworks, stormwater                                             Requests. All reports have been
        drainage and servicing)                                           included as an attachment to the
   - Water            &       Sewer                                       information response.
        Infrastructure Report
   - Flood Study
   - Stormwater Management
        Plan
   - Ecological Report
   - Koala Assessment
   - Property            Vegetation
        Management              Plan
        (PVMP)
   - Bushfire Assessment
   - Traffic Assessment
   - Assessment of the Noosa
        Population Cap impact.
        Assessment of the BDOA
        Send Site socio economic
        values. Assessment of the
        economic viability of the
        GQAL        land.      Socio
        Economic             Impact

                                                       2

Page 3

             Proposed Change                        Type of Change                                Outcome
                                            (minor change under Section 351
                                             of SPA or change as a result of
                                              Information Request under
                                                      section 354)
             Statement.         Product
             demand          statement.
             Assessment of the project
             against    the       Noosa
             Biosphere Initiatives.
        -    Community Title Report

Further details of each of these changes is now provided.

Change 1 - Strategic Cropping Land Validation Confirmation:

Further to the Information Request issued by the Department of Natural Resources and Mines DNRM, a Strategic
Cropping Land (SCL) validation application has been undertaken over the proposed Noosa on Weyba site area in
accordance with chapter 2, part 2 of the Strategic Cropping Land Act 2011 (SCL Act). The validation application was
submitted, has undergone public notice and was subsequently approved by DNRM. The approval confirmed that Lot
7 RP46782, Lot 52 SP163571, Lot 2 RP160983, Lot 11 SP250714, Lot 1667 M37772 and Lot 12 RP893393 fail to meet
the requirements necessary to satisfy the SCL Cropping History Test and therefore are not considered SCL.
Notwithstanding this the SCL Validation Decision stipulates that Lot 2 on SP179590 does meet the required cropping
history necessary to satisfy the requirement of s49 of the SCL Act and therefore this site is still mapped as potential
SCL.

Despite Lot 2 on SP179590 being identified as SCL, it is concluded that the proposed Noosa on Weyba Development
Application no longer requires referral for SCL under Schedule 7, Table 3, Colum 1, Item 27 of the Sustainable
Planning Regulation 2009 for the following reasons:

           Upon review of the Sustainable Planning Regulation 2009 (Qld) (SPR), it is apparent that (as at 20
            December 2012, when the application was lodged):

            o   Schedule 7, Table 3 prescribed the concurrence agencies for ‘Development made assessable under a
                planning       scheme, temporary local planning instrument, preliminary approval to which section 242
                of the Act applies or State       planning regulatory provisions’.
            o   Item 27 of Table 3 provided that ‘the SCL chief executive-as a concurrence agency’ was the
                concurrence agency for a          ‘Material change of use, other than a use or in an area mentioned in
                schedule 13A, of a lot of 5 ha or larger if the     footprint for the change of use is – (a) wholly or partly
                on SCL or potential SCL; and (b) more than 750 m2’.
            o   Schedule 13A of the SPR, ‘Excluded matters for SCL or potential SCL concurrence agency jurisdiction’
                includes ‘5. An          area zoned under a planning scheme for rural residential or future rural
                residential purposes’.
            o   Rural residential is defined in the State Planning Policy 1/12: Protection of Queensland’s strategic
                cropping land (SPP) as: “Rural residential areas are identified in a local planning instrument as
                specifically intended for residential      development on large lots, generally on the urban fringe
                where the primary land use is for residential living rather than       agricultural    production.     Rural
                residential areas must be identified in local planning instruments on a map (e.g. a zoning map) that:
                     (a) identifies the areas using cadastral boundaries and
                     (b) is used exclusively or primarily to assess development applications.

           Lot 2 SP179590 is zoned as ‘Rural settlement’ within the Tewantin & Doonan Locality Plan (Zone Map ZM9)
            of the Noosa Plan. The overall outcomes for the Rural Settlement Zone are:—detached housing on large
            lots—
            o is the dominant building form, to the general exclusion of other uses;
            o incorporate designs that respond to, and are integrated with site characteristics including slope and
                 native vegetation;
                                                              3

Page 4

        o    contribute to the rural or semi-rural character and amenity of the area;
        o    may be located in close proximity to working farms or other rural industries; and
        o    offers a relaxed rural lifestyle for residents.

       Therefore, the Noosa Plan categorisation of ‘rural settlement’ clearly falls within the definition of ‘rural
        residential’      as required by the SPR as-
        o There is not a zoning classification in the Noosa Plan that is actually called ‘rural residential’ and no
             other zoning aside from ‘rural settlement’ that could be considered comparable.
        o Others include: Rural, Open space recreation, Open space conservation, etc.
        o Furthermore, the Draft Sunshine Coast Regional Council Planning Scheme proposes to zone Lot 2
             SP179590 as Rural Residential, further indicating that the current zoning of rural settlement is
             consistent with rural residential for the purposes of interpreting the SPR.

As determined in the above analysis of Lot 2 on SP179590 against the Sustainable Planning Regulations and the
State Planning Policy 1/12 it is concluded that the site in question is excluded from SCL concurrence agency
jurisdiction.

The remaining six lots within the Subject Land (Lot 7 RP46782, Lot 52 SP163571, Lot 2 RP160983, Lot 11 SP250714,
Lot 1667 M37772 and Lot 12 RP893393) are Decided Non-SCL and therefore are not subject to DNRM SCL
jurisdiction either.

Although the original application was lodged with ‘potential SCL’ noted, the validation application decision notice
with respect to six lots, and the rural settlement zoning of Lot 2 SP179590 means that there are now no SCL
considerations with respect to the Subject Land.

Notwithstanding this it is noted that DNRM will continue to remain a concurrence agency for the application due to
other issues that fall within their jurisdiction (such as vegetation matters), but not for SCL.

Change 2 – Urban Design Report

Further to all information requests received, a number of changes were required to satisfy the specific requirements
of the information request items. A summary of the changes are noted below;

DESIGN APPROACH
    Road Network Plan updated to reflect revised access to development precincts
    Pedestrian Network Plan updated
    Cycleway Plan
    Open Space/Landscape Design Principles Plan updated
    Total Open Space and Active Open Space plans updated
    Placemaking and Built Form Plan updated
    Indicative Land Use Plan updated

PRECINCT PLAN
Precinct One
     Updated design concept to reflect revised access to development precincts
     Density, Typology and Movements plan updated
     Supporting diagrams and text updated where necessary

Precinct Two
     Updated design concept to reflect revised access to development precincts
     Specific Outcome ‘B: Sub-Precinct Linkage’ – removed
     Density, Typology and Movements plan updated
     Supporting diagrams and text updated where necessary

Precinct Three
     Updated design concept to reflect revised access to development precincts

                                                         4

Page 5

        Density, Typology and Movements plan updated
        Supporting diagrams and text updated where necessary

Precinct Four
     Updated design concept to reflect revised access to development precincts
     Density, Typology and Movements plan updated
     Supporting diagrams and text updated where necessary

Change 3 - Level of Assessment Table

Further to all information requests received, a number of changes to the Specific Solutions and Probable Solutions
within the Noosa on Weyba Locality Code have been amended in response to items specifically included within the
SCRC and Referral Agencies Information Requests.

Maps, Figures and Diagrams have also been amended in response to items specifically included within the SCRC and
Referral Agencies Information Requests.

The following points note the changes made within the locality code document;

        Amendments to the Level of Assessment within the Detached Housing Code and Attached Housing Code to
         alter the level of assessment on a lot burdened by an easement in favour of Energex.
        Amendments to O8 and O12 of the Noosa on Weyba Locality Code to satisfy information request item 6
         from SCRC.

A copy of the Amended Noosa on Weyba Locality Plan has been included as Attachment 1 for your reference.

Change 4 – Specialist Reporting

In response to all issues raised by SCRC and the relevant referral agencies, specialist reports have been amended
and attached. Each amended report has been re-issued as a complete document to ensure all relevant material can
easily be reviewed and assessed. The noted changes and responses to relevant information request items are
clearly noted within each amended document.

Comments on Process

We note that these changes do not stop IDAS as the changes are either a minor change under section 353 or a
change which is in response to an Information Request under s.354.

We also note that Council must give a copy of the Notice under section 352 to the entities identified in that section.


PART 2 – APPLICANT’S RESPONSE TO COUNCIL INFORMATION
REQUEST DATED 28 FEBRUARY 2013:

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Further to all information requests received the Noosa on Weyba Consulting team have spent some 8 months and
over $1,000,000.00 to ensure that the best outcome for this project, the site and the environment can be achieved.
Following a range of meetings to discuss specific items requested, a full range of amended specialist reports have
been prepared which have considered and concluded favourably the changes to the Noosa on Weyba proposal. A
number of major benefits to Council have resulted from the information response review and are summarised as
follows;

        The applicant has recognised the councils concerns over the impact of the proposed project on old growth
         trees, especially in the road reserves, and conducted a detailed on site survey of the trees in question and
                                                          5

Page 6

     plotted their numerous locations.
    This survey has led to the applicant reconsidering the proposed external road system which has been
     reviewed in extensive detail in an Access Options report which is included in this response and which has
     produced an outcome that best balances the requirements for traffic design, environmental protection and
     infrastructure costs.
    The compilation of the Access Option report has led the project team to deleting the majority of the
     previously proposed road construction in Hollett Road which has in turn caused a relocation of parts of the
     main road access system now to be bought into the subject site boundaries. This is noted on the A1 Draft
     Concept Master Plan.
    The removal of major sections of Hollett Road construction and the realignment of the internal road system
     has allowed the applicant to delete two major previously proposed floodway crossings of Kyser Creek at the
     rear of Lot 11 and this has produced a superior flood and environmental outcome.
    The Access Options report is also supported by a revised flood study which has now accommodated
     councils regional flood concerns plus the deletion of roadwork’s to Hollett Road east and the changes to Lot
     11, whilst also assessing the deletion of the proposed roadwork’s and flood path culverts in Hollett Road
     west.
    The deletion of the majority of the proposed Hollett Road construction, coupled with our plans to maintain
     the previously proposed amount of compensatory planting on site, has led to this proposal delivering
     compensatory plating to a ratio of 180% of the normally required scope.
    This Information Request response also details the additional detailed fauna threatened species
     investigations that have now been undertaken on site at the request of council, which have produced a
     result which remains environmentally supportive of the project.
    The applicant has also accepted the Council’s requests and conducted Aboriginal Heritage and Mosquito &
     Midge assessments, and this Request for Further Information response contains the appropriate specialist
     reports which support the proposed project.
    Council raised concerns about the affordability of the proposed environmental levy, which is an integral
     component of the proposed project, therefore the applicant has undertaken an extensive assessment
     through our environmental and body corporate specialists which has produced a detailed report on the
     likely levies that future residents would have to pay. This report forms part of our RFI response and shows
     that the proposed Community Title Scheme structure, including the environmental levy, is sensible and
     affordable.
    Concerns were also raised by council over whether there is a real market demand for the proposed scheme
     and whether demand exists for Age Care and Retirement Living dwellings. The applicant further engaged
     our socioeconomic specialist RPS Group who has produced an expanded in depth analysis of the demand
     that exists for this project, and a copy of their expanded report forms part of this Information Request
     response.
    Further that same specialist expanded their analysis of the impact on social infrastructure in the locality
     and have proven that this project will not exceed the currently available social infrastructure.

PLANNING ASSESSMENT

Issue
Lake Weyba and its surrounds are known areas of Aboriginal cultural significance and contain important
sites and artifacts.

Information Required

1        Provide a detailed Cultural Heritage Assessment of the site.

Response:
Please refer to Attachment 2 for the Cultural Heritage Due Diligence Assessment of the site prepared by Everick
Heritage Consultants Pty Ltd.




                                                      6

Page 7

   The Cultural Heritage Due Diligence Assessment found that no historic cultural heritage constraints were
   identified during this assessment. It is unlikely that any significant historic cultural heritage constraints will
   impact on the development potential of the Project Area.

   Future heritage assessment works as part of a future development application may be conditioned by Council.
   However, it is anticipated that in the event that Council did require such works, they would be minimal.

   Further, the desktop research undertaken prior to the site inspection did not reveal any known Aboriginal
   heritage within the project Area. Preliminary archaeological modelling and the archaeological site inspection
   identified a range of landscape features within the Project Area that have a low or moderate potential to contain
   Aboriginal Heritage. No areas were identified that are considered of high risk, such that levels of cut and fill or
   Lot layouts would require altering.

   There have also been no intangible (non-physical) heritage places identified within the Project Area. The
   potential for these places to exist within the Project Area cannot be ruled out, and can only be established
   through consultation with the Aboriginal party (Gubbi Gubbi People #2). Lake Weyba in particular may have
   places of intangible heritage significance. Given the Projects setback from the Lake, it seems that the potential
   for impacting on any intangible significance associated with the Lake is low.

    Information Required

    2       Demonstrate evidence of active engagement with the Aboriginal Traditional Owners of the land and
            effective identification and management of any Aboriginal cultural heritage deemed significant by
            the Traditional Owners has been undertaken.


    Response:

    Everick Heritage Consultants Pty Ltd have confirmed that discussions with traditional owners will be undertaken
    as part of further approvals required for the site. The current application relates to a Preliminary Approval and
    as such no works are proposed onsite.

    It is logical to engage in meaningful discussions once further applications are submitted to Council and an
    understanding of works is known through detailed design.

    Formal discussions are considered premature as part of any Preliminary Approval Assessment.

    Issue
    The Planning Report lists 34 grounds to support the proposal, including many extraneous matters.

    Information Required

    3       Provide summary grounds of no more than 10 items that clearly articulate the overarching
            planning grounds that justify the proposal for out-of-centre development and the expansion of
            Noosa‘s urban footprint.

Response:

It is considered that all 34 items listed within the Town Planning Report to support the proposal, are in accordance
with Section 329(1)(b) of the SPA 2009. Notwithstanding this, a consolidated list of 10 items which justify the
proposed out-of-centre development and expansion of Noosa’s Urban Footprint has been provided as follows:

Biodiversity Development Offset Area – expanded Noosa National Park benefits.

    (1) In September 2007, the former Noosa Shire boundary (the Noosa District) was designated as a biosphere
        region by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation’s (UNESCO) Man and the
                                                          7

Page 8

        Biosphere (MAB) Program. The Noosa Biosphere Reserve consists of 150,000 Ha of land and sea and since
        2007 the primary focus has been to ensure the area is valued, looked after and conserved. The proposed
        Noosa on Weyba development will comply with the initiatives associated with the Noosa Biosphere
        through transferring 139.5 Ha of the site to the State for the purposes of inclusion into the Noosa National
        Park, with an estimated value of $18,600,000, at no cost to the public.

    (2) The transfer of 139.5 Ha of the Noosa on Weyba site to the State for the purposes of inclusion into the
        Noosa National Park will link together two isolated sections of Noosa National Park causing a large
        contiguous section of National Park. The dedication of the BDOA ‘Send’ land will provide the opportunity to
        unlock the major component of Lake Weyba and provide public access to a greater range of National Park
        and the 1.6kms of Lake Weyba shoreline, with these areas currently not generally accessible to the general
        public due to restrictions caused by private ownership of the surrounding land

    (3) The additional 139.5 Ha of BDOA ‘Send’ Land to be included as part of Noosa National Park will increase the
        area of the total National Park by approximately 5% of which is expected to increase the number of visitor
        nights to Noosa National Park by 5%, or 88,116 visitor nights annually. The increase in visitor nights is also
        expected to generate an increase in expenditure of approximately $11.8 million. The increase in demand
        for facilities and services as a result of the expected rise in visitor nights is envisioned to have a flow on
        effect with the employment industry, with an estimated 19 full time equivalent jobs to be generated in the
        tourism industry as a result.

Environmental benefits

    (4) A proposed wide wildlife corridor (approximately 370m) will be maintained between the expanded
        National Park and the Council Wildlife Refuge to the south west of the subject site (at the intersection of
        Hollett and Tidswell Roads) and enhancements will be created under and over the roadways to support
        wildlife movement in this area.

        The Noosa on Weyba Development will further protect and enhance the flora and fauna in the surrounding
        locality through the extension of the partially completed Koala proof / wildlife exclusion fencing (with the
        existing exclusion fencing extending from the Hollett Road underpass in a southerly direction for a distance
        of only approximately 1 km) for the full length, both sides, along Walter Hay Drive from the Eenie Creek
        Road to the Eumarella Road roundabout, at no cost to the public.

    (5) As part of the Noosa on Weyba project a community education and stewardship strategy will be developed
        and implemented to ensure that all residents and visitors are aware of the Koala habitat (and other
        broader biodiversity) values of the Noosa on Weyba locality. This community education and stewardship
        strategy will include provision for measures such as the following.
                 1. Information packages for prospective residents concerning:
                          the environmental values of the Noosa on Weyba site locality;
                          specific design features of the Noosa on Weyba project that respond to those
                             important environmental values;
                          specific BC regulations and controls that residents and their guests would need to
                             comply with to ensure that important environmental values are protected.

                 2. Issue of a regular (e.g. quarterly) Environmental Newsletter providing information:
                         concerning notable environmental observation or events within the Noosa on Weyba
                             locality (e.g. commencement of Koala breeding season);
                         reminding residents of their environmental management obligations under the BC
                             regulations; and
                         contact details for the reporting of sick/injured wildlife or free-roaming dogs.

                 3. Initiation of a Noosa on Weyba Land Care Group (or similar) that is designed to provide
                    residents with the opportunity to become actively involved in the monitoring and management
                    of the biodiversity, including Koala habitat, values of the Noosa on Weyba.
                                                          8

Page 9

             4. Establishment and maintenance of environmental interpretative signage throughout the Noosa
                 on Weyba project that provides residents and visitors with information concerning the Koala
                 ecology and conservation issues of relevance to the Noosa on Weyba locality.

    In addition to educating the community on environmental features, the proposed Community Title Scheme
    Body Corporate levies structure will also contain an environmental levy to maintain the Koala proof /
    wildlife exclusion fencing and provide funds to manage feral animals in the expanded Eenie Creek section
    of the Noosa National Park.

    The Noosa on Weyba development will also incorporate an Integrated Water Cycling Management scheme
    which, in conjunction with the latest stormwater management technique, will aid in improving the
    stormwater quality impact on surrounding waterways. The stormwater quality treatment of the Noosa on
    Weyba development employs a range of innovative measures to ensure the best results. These include:
         10 kilolitre rainwater tanks for each residential lot. (This is more than twice the requirement of
            Queensland Development Code)
            Bio-retention street trees and bio-retention gardens incorporated into the road reserve
         Bio-retention basins
         Vegetated bio-retention swales
            Litter baskets
         Natural wetland areas
         Buffers to environmentally sensitive areas

(6) Should a Development Approval be granted the land owners have applied to the Qld State Government to
    have the subject site declared a registered Wildlife Refuge to further protect the environment and the
    surrounding ecosystem . The dedication of the BDOA ‘Send’ land will result in only 19% or 58ha of the
    303ha total site area is to be developed into net urban uses footprint (this excludes the environmental
    buffers) therefore allowing for approximately 81% or 245ha to be either deemed as National Park or
    environmentally protected land.

    Community benefits

(7) The Noosa on Weyba development will generate a large amount of income for both the State and Council
    with the creation of $7,640,000 in Stamp Duty income to the state and annual rates income at project
    completion of $661,000 will also be delivered.

(8) The Noosa on Weyba Locality Plan provides for a range of housing affordability options, including Age Care
    and Retirement Living, for an estimated population of 2,000 people and the creation of housing for some
    600 to 800 people that will work in the surrounding shire. The proposed development will not only
    providing housing for employees of existing jobs in the area but is also projected to create an abundance of
    additional employment opportunities. The Noosa on Weyba project is also predicted to create an
    estimated 2,023 construction jobs during development of the estate over an anticipated 8 years with an
    estimate $250,000,000 being spent on construction during that time as well as an estimated 309 full time
    operational jobs in the immediate locality when the project is completed. The proposed development will
    also support existing local business, employees and the Noosa Civic Shopping Centre with annual
    household expenditure of $22,600,000 predicted to be created once the project is fully completed.

(9) Public amenity in the form of a tea house / café will be made available at the proposed entrance to the
    new National Park on Hollett Road, and this will include public parking for cars and bicycles in Hollett Road,
    which will all service the public visiting the expanded National Park and accessing Lake Weyba.

(10) The proposed Noosa on Weyba development will create and enhance the efficiency in the use of the
     existing community infrastructure and facilities in the region through the following provisions;
         The project will allow for flood free emergency access / egress from the dwellings along Lake
             Entrance Boulevard to the north of the subject site that currently get “cut off” in medium flood
                                                      9

Page 10

                conditions. Tidswell Road will be constructed to a “flood free” standard which will provide existing
                residents along this road with flood free access.
               The project will deliver sealed roads along the current dirt tracks in the Tidswell and part of Hollett
                Roads road reserves at no cost to the public.
               The town sewer and water connections could be made available to the adjoining Eumarella Shores
                & Weyba Point Cottages developments, and properties in Hollett Road, if those residents choose
                to connect to it.
               An extension of the Noosa cycleway system will be provided, at no cost to the public, which will
                substantially enhance cycle and walkway access to the National Park and Lake Weyba, and create
                an alternative cycleway route off Walter Hay Drive to Noosaville.
               The proposed roundabout on Walter Hay Drive will,
                          a) Slow traffic speed down to 60kmph from 100kmph for a section of the road which will
                         lower the incidents of “road kill” of wildlife.
                          b) Create an alternate access / egress for residents in Hollett Road
                          c) Lower the traffic speed on Walter Hay Drive which will lower the road noise impact on
                          Hollett Road residents.

Biodiversity Development Offset Area

   Issue
   The Noosa on Weyba Locality Plan precinct maps do not provide a clear overview of the development

   Information Required

   4       A single A1 proposed Plan of Development is required to clearly identify a master plan layout for
           the development area (―receive site‖) and should include:
   (a)     Each land use category in its own zone/precinct e.g. Precinct/Zone A neighbourhood centre. Precinct
           B – Detached Housing. Pre C Attached Housing, etc.
   (b)     The size of each zone/precinct
   (c)     any staging details
   (d)     identify open space areas for
           -    environmental conservation areas
           -    active parks
           -    visual amenity
           -    drainage
           -    bioretention /detention areas
           -    dog off leash areas
   (e)     road layout
   (f)     pedestrian/bicycle paths and connections

           A table on the plan should be included for each precinct identifying:
   (a)     consistent uses in the zone/precinct
   (b)     maximum yields:
           -    minimum and maximum lot size
           -    number of dwelling units (aged care, retirement living)
           -    building heights

   Response:
   Please refer to Attachment 3 for amended Noosa on Weyba C o n c e p t Master Plan Map. The A1 Concept
   Master Plan of the Noosa on Weyba development incorporates the above mentioned information and identifies
   additional details that original Precinct Maps did not include.

   Please note that this plan is only a concept Master Plan and the current application only relates to a Preliminary
   Approval to guide future development. The ultimate design of the Noosa on Weyba estate will be subject to
   further approvals following completion of detailed designs.

                                                        10

Page 11

Issue
The development codes within the proposed Noosa on Weyba Locality Plan contain substantial amounts of
information relating to aspects that cannot be considered or conditioned via a development application (such
as domestic pets, protective clothing and maintenance issues).

Information Required

5        Amended codes of development that remove those aspects which cannot be addressed via a
         development approval, or similarly, should not form part of an assessment for self-assessable
         development.

         Where such issues are required to address environmental or community management outcomes they
         should be compiled in a separate document detailing community title rules.

Response:

It is considered that the inclusion of such restrictions are integral to the establishment of an environmentally
sustainable development onsite. Whilst it is recognised that these issues are not generally dealt with as part of
a locality code, in this instance and due to the unique nature of the proposal at hand consistency between the
locality code and body corporate bylaws will assist in ensuring all future residents of Noosa on Weyba will fully
understand their responsibilities and restrictions.

We would be amenable to minor amendments to certain outcomes within the Locality Code should an
appropriately worded condition be imposed which required specific issues to be incorporated within the body
corporate by-laws.

Furthermore please refer to Attachment 6 for the Noosa on Weyba Community Title Guidelines Documentation
which further details how the environmental and community management guidelines will be implemented.

Issue
Division 12 of the proposed Noosa on Weyba Locality Code includes outcomes that seek to maintain existing
vegetation and environmental systems.

Information Required

6        Provide comment on how outcomes O8 and O12 of the proposed Code might be achieved, given
         the nature and intensity of development and earthworks proposed within the urban precincts.

Response:
Please find the below revised wording of Outcomes 08 and 012 of the proposed Noosa on Weyba Locality Code.
Please refer to Attachment 1 for the amended Noosa on Weyba Locality Code in full.

 BUILT FORM
 Density
 Landscaped Setting
 O8
Tall trees and native vegetation add to the character of the locality and are retained within the designated Open
Space Conservation Precinct;
 AND
Existing character trees such as eucalypts, melaleucas and figs are retained within Urban Precincts where the
retention does not compromise public health or safety.

Environment Conservation and Recreation
Environment and cultural heritage values
O12

                                                     11

Page 12

Within the designated Open Space Conservation Precinct there are no significant adverse effects on biodiversity,
native vegetation, native fauna habitat, landscape quality, water quality or cultural heritage values, including
those related to—
     a) changes to natural drainage;
     b) disturbance of the wetland system;
     c) management of landslide and fire risk;
     d) erosion and the transport of sediments off site;
     e) unmanaged public access;
     f) effluent disposal;
     g) changes to fauna habitat and behaviour; and
     h) disturbance of buildings and features, including natural features, of cultural heritage significance.

Issue
Development parameters and yields vary between the application documents

Information Required

7        Provide a table detailing the potential yields for all precincts, sub-precincts and open space areas of
         the development and clearly stating the maximum development yields. The table shall be included
         or referenced in all application documents for clarity and consistency.

         Summary details should also be provided for:
        The numbers of lots
        Urban park areas
        Conservation areas
        New National Park areas
        Buffer/esplanade areas
        Wetland/bio-retention areas
        Fill areas
        Cut areas
        Vegetation clearing areas

Response:
Please refer to Attachment 3 which provides an A1 Concept Master Plan which outlines the proposed concept
for the Noosa on Weyba development, including each precinct, the predominant use, approximate area and
potential dwellings. As previously indicated the concept Master Plan is indicative and is provided merely as a
guide to assist Council in considering the potential yields and developable areas for each precinct.

Issue
The Community Titles structure of the development provides the primary tool for implementing
sustainability measures for future development.

Information Required

8        Provide comment on the proposed timing of the Principal Community Title Scheme and how that
         might be conditioned via a development approval(s).

Response:
Further to Council’s request please refer to Attachment 4 which provides the amended Noosa on Weyba
Community Title Report. The amended document provides details on the timing of the proposed community
titles scheme along with an updated structure which includes an indicative Environmental Levy costing and
demonstration of how the Community Title model collects levies to fund management and conservation for
Noosa on Weyba.

It would be considered logical that the Principal Community Title Scheme be conditioned as a requirement of
the first Reconfiguration of a Lot application following approval of any Preliminary Approval. Furthermore it is
                                                     12

Page 13

anticipated that Council would provide specific conditions as part of the current application as to the timing of
the Principal Community Titles Scheme.

Issue
Significant works are required to connect the pathway networks external to the site.

Information Required

9        Provide confirmation whether connections to existing pathway networks external to the site are
         proposed to be made as part of the development or if this cost is to be borne by others.

Response:
Further to Council’s request please refer to Attachment 3 which includes the A1 Concept Master Plans. These
documents outline the anticipated external pathway network. Detailed design and construction costing of the
external pathways network will be undertaken as part of future applications. The Preliminary Approval currently
being assessed by Council confirms that suitable connections can be achieved to ensure the Noosa on Weyba
development can connect to and enhance the surrounding cycle and pedestrian network.

Issue
The Needs Report links the development with increased tourism visitation to the expanded National Park.


Information Required

10       Provide details of the source of the current tourism visitor nights attributed to Noosa National /
         State Parks quoted in the Needs Report. Provide further detail on the exact nature of these
         visitor nights, e.g. do they represent registered campers on Noosa North Shore or are they
         apportioned from total visitor nights within the Noosa area.

Response:
Please refer to the amended Economic Needs Report within Attachment 5 This report has undertaken further
analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the following;

The tourism numbers outlined in Sections 5.3.2 Purpose of Visit – Sunshine Coast and 5.3.3 Visitors to National
Parks – Noosa District on pages 26 and 27 of the Needs Assessment submitted with the original Development
Application were sourced from Tourism Research Australia. As such, the source of the current tourism visitor
nights attributed to Noosa National / State Parks quoted in the report was Tourism Research Australia. Data
used in the Needs Assessment was the best available information at the time of writing the report. Tourism
Research Australia does not provide data that outlines further detail on the exact nature of these visitor nights.
Tourism Research Australia provides data for the Individual Activity conducted by international tourists and All
Destination Activities conducted by domestic tourists (including visiting National / State Parks), which was
outlined in the Needs Assessment.

Of consideration in this case is that the enlarged Noosa National Park will provide enhanced access to Lake
Weyba. This provides the opportunity to enhance the recreation experience and attract visitors to a new
experience. The consideration of ‘campers’ as a metric for assessment is too narrow. Many visitors (including
those who visit the Noosa National Park) stay in commercial accommodation or with friends/relatives. The
expanded range of recreation opportunities provided by the larger national park will act to increase the number
of visitors to the region. It is recognised that these opportunities will need to be ‘unlocked’ with the provision of
new/expanded services and facilities. An example of this is the improved access to the national park and Lake
Weyba provided by the proposed development.

Issue
The Needs Report suggests a lack of residential land supply within the area.

Information Required
                                                      13

Page 14

11      Provide further detailed analysis of the residential market and land supply within the area, including:
             (a)     Analysis of new dwelling approvals over the past 10-20 years to provide a
                     comprehensive review of dwelling approval activity.
             (b)     Reduction of the 10% assumption for internal market churn to 8% to reflect census
                     data for the Sunshine Coast LGA and Noosa SA3.
             (c)     Further details of Noosa North Rise, Doonella Noosa, Beckman‘s Green, Elysium
                     Noosa, Greenwood Grove and Peregian Springs developments missing from the
                     report.
             (d)     Detailed analysis of the capacity and uptake of existing supply including waiting
                     lists, sales rates and related information.
             (e)     Additional information including a pros and cons analysis for each site needs to be
                     provided to establish a basis for why the Noosa on Weyba site should be preferred to
                     other sites in the surrounding area.

Response:

Please refer to the amended Economic Needs Report within Attachment 5 This report has undertaken further
analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the following;

R11(a) As outlined in Section 4.2 Dwelling Approvals on page 18 of Attachment 7- Addendum to Needs
Assessment, due to the effects of events such as the global financial crisis, the high Australian dollar against the
US dollar, and the high unemployment rate in the Sunshine Coast compared to the State average, dwelling
approvals have continued to increase and drop, depending on the circumstances. It is therefore not considered
that historical supply to be an indicator of future demand, particularly in a supply constrained market. As such,
providing historical dwelling approvals data from the past 10 to 20 years is considered to be moot.

R11(b) As outlined in Section 4.3 Underlying Residential Demand on pages 18 to 20 of Attachment 7- Addendum
to Needs Assessment, it is estimated that the typical household undertakes a change in living arrangements
every 8 to 12 years. A reduction of the 10% assumption for internal market churn to 8% is therefore considered
to be reasonable.

Based on a reduction of internal market churn to 8%, the revised underlying residential demand in the Noosa
District is in the order of 1,756 per year, comprising 1,001 houses, 193 lots and 562 units per year. The revised
underlying residential demand in Maroochy North is in the order of 1,915 per year, comprising 996 houses, 402
lots and 512 units per year.

As outlined in Section 5.4 Length of Supply on page 25 of Attachment 7- Addendum to Needs Assessment, the
revised market churn increases the level of land supply within the Area of Influence to 11 to 12 years. While this
is longer than originally outlined in the Needs Assessment (9 to 10 years), as outlined in Section 5.5 Implications
on pages 25 and 26 of the addendum, it is considered there should be five years supply of land approved and
ready for development any time; 10 years of land that is appropriately zoned and 15 years of future supply
dedicated in local planning schemes. The proposed Noosa on Weyba development will provide a diversity of
residential offer through the provision of residential lots, townhouses and retirement product, as well as part of
the solution for the land supply pipeline in this area, increasing the variety of locations for this supply.

R11(c) Section 5.2 Active Surrounding Residential Developments on pages 22 to 23 of Attachment 7- Addendum
to Needs Assessment, outline further details on the Noosa Northrise, Doonella Noosa, Beckmans Green, Elysium
Noosa, Greenwood Grove and Peregian Springs developments as well as others. These details include the total
number of lots for each development, the number of lots that have been developed to date, as well as the
number of lots currently available. In total, there are currently 95 lots and 14 apartments that are currently
being actively marketed within the Area of Influence.

R11(d) As outlined in Section 5.2 Active Surrounding Residential Developments on page 22 of Attachment 7-
Addendum to Needs Assessment, it is considered the request for detailed analysis of the capacity and uptake of
existing supply including waiting lists, sales rates and related information to be unreasonable as the current
slow conditions are considered to be reflective of the broader economic conditions, as well as a supply
                                                      14

Page 15

constrained market. In order for conditions to change, more supply of residential product, such as that
proposed for the subject site, needs to be released in this supply constrained market. This request is therefore
considered to be moot.

R11(e) Section 3.0 Assessment of Alternative Sites on pages 10 to 17 of Attachment 7- Addendum to Needs
Assessment, outlines a set of criteria to assess the suitability of sites within the Urban Footprint to house the
proposed uses for the Noosa on Weyba site. Only one site was deemed suitable for assessment. Once assessed,
it was found that this alternate site would not be suitable for the proposed uses for the Noosa on Weyba site as
it has already been earmarked for future residential supply as part of the Ridges Peregian Springs development.
In addition, this site would not provide the environmental benefit of the Noosa on Weyba site, as the Noosa
National Park is present whether this site is developed or not. As such, this site is not considered to be a suitable
alternative for the uses proposed for the Noosa on Weyba site.

As outlined in Section 3.4 Implications on page 17 of Attachment 7- Addendum to Needs Assessment, the
subject site is considered to be the most appropriate location for the Noosa on Weyba development as it is
located on the edge of the Urban Footprint and would therefore form a natural extension of the Urban
Footprint as it will provide an expansion of the residential uses located to the north and south of the site. The
development of Noosa on Weyba on the subject site would also provide an environmental benefit of the
transfer of 139.5 Ha of land for the purposes of inclusion into the Noosa National Park. The broader community
is expected to benefit from this development through increased population supporting the existing retail and
employment uses such as the Noosa Business Centre, Noosa Civic Shopping Centre and the nearby industrial
area.

Issue
Nature of proposed aged care and retirement housing.

Information Required

12       Provide an analysis of existing aged care and retirement housing within the Noosa area including a
         detailed review of the current and future demand and supply. Demonstrate h o w the
         d e v e l o p m e n t s e e k s t o address demand for relevant accommodation and care types.

Response:

Please refer to the amended Economic Needs Report within Attachment 5 This report has undertaken further
analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the following;

Section 6.0 Retirement Economic Needs Assessment on pages 27 to 36 of Attachment 7- Addendum to Needs
Assessment, provides an analysis of existing aged care and retirement housing within the Noosa area including a
detailed review of the current and future demand and supply. The Addendum to Needs Assessment found a
current undersupply of 440 Independent Living Units in the Area of Influence. Even with the supply of the 220
(est) retirement living / aged care dwellings proposed for the Noosa on Weyba development, an undersupply of
220 (est) Independent Living Units would remain. Including the proposed Noosa on Weyba retirement product,
this undersupply is forecast to increase to 428 Independent Living Units in 2016 and 468 Independent Living
Units in 2021. The proposed 220 (est) retirement living / aged care dwellings for the subject site would
therefore provide only part of the solution in meeting demand for this type of product as the over 65 year
population continues to increase.

13       Provide details of the breakup and nature of the retirement housing precincts proposed.

Response:

 Please refer to the amended economic needs report within Attachment 5 This report has undertaken further
 analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the following;

 As outlined in Section 6.1 Introduction on page 27 of Attachment 7- Addendum to Needs Assessment, as the
                                                      15

Page 16

     application for the Noosa on Weyba development is for a Preliminary Approval and not a full Development
     Permit, a further breakdown of the proposed retirement product is not considered necessary. However as an
     indication, the 220 (est) retirement living / aged care dwellings are expected to be made up of predominantly
     Independent Living Units, with some small one bedroom low care apartments to also be provided.

    STRATEGIC LAND USE PLANNING

    Issue
    Further details of the developments impacts on social infrastructure are required.

    Information Required

    14       Demonstrate how the proposed increase in population and demand for social infrastructure
             will be catered for. Reference should be made specifically to Council‘s Social Infrastructure Strategy
             with particular reference to LOI 31 and 12.

Response:

Please refer to the amended economic needs report within Attachment 5. This report has undertaken further
analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the following;

Section 4.3 Implications on page 22 of the Needs Assessment states that the additional 876 (est) dwellings proposed
for the Noosa on Weyba development are expected to house approximately 2,059 people. This would provide an
incremental increase to the 2011 population of approximately 4.1%. As such, this population is not likely to
generate the need for additional social infrastructure but instead it will increase the number of people utilising the
existing infrastructure. The most efficient way to make use of existing infrastructure is to maximise the number of
people that utilise it. As the subject site is located alongside existing residential uses and road networks which are in
close proximity to existing social infrastructure in the Urban Footprint to the north, the outcome of the expansion of
the Urban Footprint to include the proposed Noosa on Weyba development will provide a more efficient use of
existing infrastructure by maximising the capacity of the number of people that utilise it.




                                                           16

Page 17

15      Demonstrate how the proposed increase in population and demand for open space networks will
        be catered for. Refer specifically to Council‘s Open Space Strategy, Appendix 5, Sunshine Coast
        Network requirements, Sunshine Coast District requirements (Rural 3 & Urban D) and Sunshine Coast
        Localities (31 & 12) requirements. All requirements relating to the networks are required to be
        addressed.

Response:

Please refer to the amended Economic Needs Report within Attachment 5 This report has undertaken further
analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the following;

As outlined within information request item 14, the proposed Noosa on Weyba development population of
approximately 2,059 people would provide an incremental increase to the 2011 population of approximately
4.1%. As such, this population is not likely to generate the need for additional open space networks outside that
proposed to be provided as part of the Noosa on Weyba development (approximately 8.06 Ha).

Issue
The nature of the proposed lake front public access provisions are unclear.


                                                     17

Page 18

Information Required

16       Further clarification in relation to the proposed public access is required to demonstrate
         the following:
              (a)       meaning of ―formal, controlled access to Lake Weyba‖,
              (b)       details of the intended users,
              (c)       the level of accessibility to the wider community,
              (d)       how any further additional access to Lake Weyba benefits the broader
                        Sunshine Coast community and in particular its impacts on the planned
                        upgrades of facilities to provide this access as specified in the Open Space
                        Strategy,
              (e)       which sections are intended as ―gated‖ or with limited public access. In
                        particular, this needs to be clarified in relation to the proposed retail facility
                        and recreational access to Lake Weyba.

Response:

Please refer to the indicative A1 Concept Master Plan in Attachment 3 which details the following;
a) Controlled access ensures users of the area will not create undesirable informal access to the lake. The
     access will be designed in the form of a nature path in the location shown on the plans.
b) The controlled access will be open to the public as well as residents of Noosa on Weyba
c) The wider community will have unrestricted access
d) Controlled and sustainable access to the lake as part of the Noosa on Weyba Development will enable a
     broader section of the community to enjoy the benefits of the lake which currently is entirely within
     private ownership.
e) All areas of access to the lake, except where fronting the community facility fronts the lake, will have
     unrestricted access.

17       Demonstrate how the general public recreation usage of the Existing Lake Weyba Esplanade and
         the proposed Lake Weyba Buffer community title area are to be reconciled from a public liability
         perspective.

Response:

The existing Lake Weyba Esplanade is not land that is part of this application and is connected to the existing
council road reserve for Hollett Road. The Lake Weyba Buffer community title area will be managed and
maintained by the Principal Body Corporate and a public access easement will be created over this area.
Standard public liability insurance will be entered into as part of the establishment of the Body Corporate
Structure. We would anticipate Council would impose a condition of any approval regarding the requirement for
public liability insurance within body corporate areas.

URBAN DESIGN

Issue
Density proposed is considered high for this sensitive ecological environment. Concern is raised of the
ability for small lots to be located within most of the proposed residential areas.

Information Required

18       Clarification the extent to which small lots and multiple units are restricted within the proposed
         residential areas.

Response:



                                                        18

Page 19

Please refer to Attachment 3 which includes the A1 Concept Master Plan. This document outlines the
anticipated extent of small lots and multiple units. For a proposal of this nature it is considered that the mix of
uses will ensure a vibrant community at a low to low-medium scale. The proposed environmental levy will
better protect the significant environmental features of the site and the specialist reporting submitted with
application concludes that the density calculations can be justified without adversely affecting the surround
community or environmental features of the site.

Issue
Vegetated / Green / Rural buffers between urban areas are critical character elements of the Sunshine
Coast.

Information Required

19      Rural buffers are a major component of the Sunshine Coast Character and this proposal
        dramatically erodes the rural environment to the south of Noosa‘s Urban Area. Provide a detailed
        assessment of the proposed impacts on the visual amenity to the Walter Hay Drive corridor and
        measures to minimise or mitigate impacts.

Response:

Issue
The natural landscape character and vegetation along the foreshore areas of Lake Weyba and Weyba Creek
is protected. Furthermore the proposal incorporates significant buffers to ensure the natural features and
aesthetics of the site maintained. Following the completion of all site constraints onsite the proposal at hand is
considered a sensitive proposal which enhances the significant environment at the south end of Noosa and
northern end of Maroochydore.

Although photomontages/perspectives from Walter Hay Drive were incorporated as part of the original
lodgement documentation, please refer to the attached amended Urban Design Report included within
Attachment 6. This material further confirms that the proposal at hand is responsive to the environmental
needs of the site whilst maintaining suitable buffers to protect the existing character of the area.

Information Required

20      The proposal includes significant character changes to this area. Provide revised plans to mitigate
        the change proposed in this area. This should include the required setback, reduced cut and fill and
        additional vegetation screening.

        A photomontage of the proposed development should be submitted showing Precinct 1, from the
        lake, with the proposed cut and fill complete and densities (including site cover and gross floor areas)
        at the proposed maximums.

Response:

Although photomontages/perspectives were incorporated as part of the original lodgement documentation,
please refer to the amended Urban Design Report included within Attachment 6. This material further confirms
that the proposal at hand is responsive to the environmental needs of the site whilst maintaining suitable
buffers from the lake within precinct 1 to protect the existing character of the area.

Please also refer to the revised Ecological Report included as Attachment 7 which concludes the following;

The foreshore will not be re-vegetated to create a dense swath of vegetation as this would displace many
species which depend on the open nature of the vegetation that exists in this area. As such habitat
enhancement/landscaping works in this area will not preserve “existing views” but will maintain views through
an open woodland foreshore vegetation.


                                                      19

Page 20

Details concerning the locations and extents of land that would be subject to bulk earthworks (cut and fill) are
provided in the amended Noosa on Weyba Engineering Report (see Attachment 8).


ENVIRONMENT & ECOLOGY

Issue
Retention of Old Growth Trees

Information Required

21       Demonstrate how the significant stands of Old Growth Trees located throughout the development
         footprint are being protected.

Response:

Please refer to the amended Ecological Assessment report within Attachment 7 This report has undertaken
further detailed onsite survey analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the
following;

Based on the hollow bearing tree survey work detailed in Section 5.4 of the amended Ecological Assessment
included within Attachment 8:
      ~ 2,400 hollow bearing trees are located within the boundaries of the Noosa on Weyba site; and
      If the proposed development was to proceed, over 90% of hollow bearing trees within the Noosa on
         Weyba site shall be retained. This assessment is based on the assumption that all hollow bearing trees
         located within areas where urban development is proposed would require removal.

Section 5.4 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report also provides details concerning measures to be taken
to minimise and offset impacts to hollow dependent native fauna that may utilise hollow bearing trees that
would be lost either within the Noosa on Weyba site or adjacent sections of public roadway that require
upgrading.


22       Demonstrate how the significant stands of Old Growth Trees located along the Hollett and
         Tidswell Road verges are to be protected from the proposed road widening/upgrading works and
         the provision of services e.g. water and sewerage, power and telecommunications and
         bikeways/pedestrian pathways.

Response:

Please refer to the amended Ecological Assessment report within Attachment 7 This report has undertaken
further detailed onsite survey analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the
following;

The configuration of the road network servicing the proposed development has been specifically amended to
minimise the extent of hollow bearing tree clearance. Based on the hollow bearing tree survey work detailed in
Section 5.4 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report included within Attachment 7:
  ~ 133 hollow bearing trees are located within the boundaries of the Hollett Road reserve of which ~ 80%
     would be retained; and
  ~ 50 hollow bearing trees are located within the Tidswell Road reserve of which it has been conservatively
     assumed that 100% would require removal.

It should be noted that further analysis has resulted in the revision of the following specialist reports in light of
the additional information obtained:
i.       Ecological Report
ii.      Civil Engineering Report
                                                       20

Page 21

iii.     Traffic Impact Assessment Report
iv.      Urban Design Report

The changes to the abovementioned reports has resulted in the following changes being made:

The amended Engineering Report included in Attachment 8 also addresses the proposed road network with
regards to trunk road alignment (sections 3.1) and existing road upgrades (section 3.3) and the fundamental
design principles implemented to ensure the protection of the environment.

 The removal of the road within Hollet Road reserve to the west of Walter Hay Drive and replacement with an
internal driveway to precincts J, K & L has reduced significantly the amount of vegetation to be removed
including old growth trees in the road reserve. The location of the internal driveway is along an existing gravel
track which is largely cleared of vegetation.

The relocation of the collector road within Hollet Road reserve to the east of Walter Hay Drive and relocation to
the internal alignment to the south of precincts F & G, has also greatly reduced the amount of vegetation to be
removed. Hollet Road East will now contain only a 4m wide bushfire emergency, access track and cycleway
which has been located to reduce the impact on mature and hollow bearing trees.

Issue
Expansion to Noosa National Park

Information Required

23       Provide evidence of the Department of National Parks, Recreation, Sport and Racing, Qld Parks
         and Wildlife Service commitment to the provision of access and associated capital works and
         resulting ongoing maintenance for the active use proposed expanded Noosa National Park, as
         anticipated by the application material.

Response:

Please refer to the amended Economic Needs Report within Attachment 5 This report has undertaken further
analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the following;

Section 3.3.2 Send Site on pages 17 and 18 of the Needs Assessment states that in conjunction with the transfer
of the 139.5 Ha of Send Land to be transferred to the State for inclusion into the Noosa National Park, the
developers propose to develop sealed access roads along Hollett and Tidswell Roads and new cycle access paths
from Walter Hay Drive and Noosa-Eumundi Road. As such, this provides the potential to unlock the major
component of Lake Weyba and provide public access to a greater range of National Park.

Furthermore the Department of National Parks, Recreation, Sport and Racing, Qld Parks and Wildlife Service
have provided written confirmation, in a letter dated 2 August 2013, that they support the proposal in terms of
the provision of access to land transferred to the State for incorporation into the National Park estate for the
purposes of undertaking environmental enhancement and offset works. Please refer to Attachment 18 for the
subject letter from the Department of National Parks, Recreation, Sport and Racing, Qld Parks and Wildlife
Service detailing the above.

24       Provide evidence of how the proposed economic benefit of the expanded Noosa National Park
         can be achieved when all / any park embellishments and maintenance costs are dependent upon an
         external party (NPWS) which is not included in this application.

Response:

Please refer to the amended Economic Needs Report within Attachment 5 This report has undertaken further
analysis in response to Council’s request for further information and concludes the following;

                                                     21

Page 22

    Section 5.4 Implications on pages 27 and 28 of the Needs Assessment outlines the potential for the additional
    139.5 Ha of Send Land to be included as part of Noosa National Park to increase the number of visitor nights to
    Noosa National Park by 5%, or 88,116 visitor nights, and increase expenditure by $11.8 million.

    This increase in visitation is not entirely dependent on expenditure by NPWS with subject development
    providing increased access to the national park and Lake Weyba. These increased recreational opportunities will
    underpin increased tourist visitation (many of whom will stay in commercial accommodation or with friends and
    relatives). Further, an assessment of this type must make reasonable assumptions in order to paint a full picture
    of the benefits to the community. The assumption that (over time) the enhanced facilities will be provided in
    the Noosa National Park is considered reasonable given the announced state government policy of encouraging
    access and enabling innovate investment.

    Issue
    Buffer to Lake Weyba

    Information Required

    25      Demonstrate why a 100 metre wide buffer has not been provided to Lake Weyba in accordance with
            the Waterways Code of the Maroochy Plan 2000.

Response:

The Noosa on Weyba proposal makes provision for the maintenance of buffers between proposed areas of urban
development and areas of high conservation value located within or adjacent to the Noosa on Weyba site. Most of
the buffers have been incorporated into the proposed Open Space Conservation Zone with retention of native
vegetation within the Open Space Conservation Zone and the associated requirements for building setbacks to:

        meet bushfire hazard management requirements as set out in State Planning Policy 1/03 - Mitigating the
         Adverse Impacts of Flood, Bushfire and Landslide (SPP 1/03); and
        meet Tree Protection Zone requirements as set out in Australian Standard AS 4970—2009 - Protection of
         trees on development sites.

These internal buffer details would be resolved as part of future development applications, but the general nature
of such buffers are as shown in the Concept Master Plan presented in Figure 7 of the Amended Ecological Report
(see Attachment 7) and as detailed in the amended Bushfire Assessment Report see Attachment 9).

In respect of the dimensions proposed for the buffers to waterways and wetlands that have been proposed as part
of the Noosa on Weyba development, consideration was given to:
      the Queensland Wetland Buffer Planning Guideline (DERM 2011a) which provides a framework for
         considering wetland values, threats to those values and appropriate buffer arrangements; and
      the Fisheries Guidelines for Fish Habitat Buffer Zones (FHG 003) produced by Queensland Fisheries Service
         (2000), which provides a suite of recommended minimum setback distance required for a range of buffer
         functions.

A detailed assessment and analysis of the proposed Noosa on Weyba Development against the Queensland
Wetland Buffer Planning Guideline (2011) can be found in the amended Ecological Assessment Report in
Attachment 7. The analysis demonstrates that the proposed dimensions, form and management arrangements for
the buffers to Lake Weyba are generally consistent with the arrangements promoted in the Queensland Wetland
Buffer Planning Guideline and therefore are considered both appropriate and suitable for the locality.

Furthermore the 100m buffer noted within the Waterways and Wetlands Code of the Maroochy Plan 2000 is only
an ‘acceptable measure’ The performance Criteria states ”A buffer is maintained to protect and enhance the
environmental values and ecosystem services of waterways, wetlands and fish habitat areas having regard to:
•        fauna habitats;
•        adjacent land use impacts;

                                                         22

Page 23

•         stream integrity;
•         sustainable aquatic and wetland ecosystems; and
•         recreational amenity”.

Please refer to the revised Ecological Report which has addressed each of the above criteria. The ecological report
has concluded that the proposed buffer is both appropriate and suitable for the locality and therefore complies with
the Performance Criteria of the Code.

    26       Demonstrate how landscaping and revegetation works within the proposed Lake Weyba Buffer can
             be implemented if existing views over the lake are maintained.

    Response:

    Please refer to the revised Ecological Report included as Attachment 7. This report concludes the following;

    The foreshore will not be re-vegetated to create a dense swath of vegetation as this would displace many
    species which depend on the open nature of the vegetation that exists in this area. As such habitat
    enhancement/landscaping works in this area will not preserve “existing views” but will maintain views through
    an open woodland foreshore vegetation.

    27       Justify why the proposed Lake Weyba buffer has not been widened to incorporate an increased
             proportion of the large old growth hollow bearing trees.

    Response:

    Please refer to the revised Ecological Report included as Attachment 7. This report concludes the following;

    Available tree survey information for the Lake Weyba foreshore area of Lot 11 indicates that ~ 135 trees with
    stem diameters > 150mm (average > 550mm) are located within 100m of the foreshore. Approximately 20% of
    the surveyed trees have branch hollows or other habitat features.

    Of these only 10 trees (or ~ 7%) are located in proposed urban development areas where it would not be
    possible to retain the trees. On this basis it is considered that an increase in buffer width is not warranted to
    achieve a greater level of tree retention.

    Furthermore it is noted that over 90% of the existing hollow bearing trees within the Noosa on Weyba site
    would be retained and any loss of tree hollows can be compensated for by the establishment of nesting boxes
    etc.

    28       Provide further details on the Lake Weyba foreshore management and where and how formalised
             walking tracks and access points are envisaged. Such tracks are needed to reduce the impact of
             pedestrians on the terrestrial and aquatic environments in this location.

    Response:

    General details concerning the nature, purpose and location of formal access infrastructure to the Lake Weyba
    foreshore are provided in the amended Urban Design report and Section 5.4 of the amended Ecological
    Assessment Report (see Attachments 7). This detail specifically recognises that the access infrastructure is
    needed to reduce the impact of pedestrians on the terrestrial and aquatic environments in this location. It is also
    noted that the Lake Weyba foreshore has traditionally been used for the grazing of livestock and is periodically
    slashed using tractors to maintain pasture. The proposed arrangements would be a more sensitive treatment of
    this area.

    Further details regarding the specific design and location of public access infrastructure that would be
    established to facilitate sustainable forms of public access to the Lake Weyba foreshore would be provided in
    support of formal development applications to establish this infrastructure.
                                                          23

Page 24

Issue
Fauna movement

Information Required

29      Demonstrate how fauna movement (other than koalas) is going to be addressed throughout this
        development.

Response:

Details concerning safe fauna movement measures that have been considered in the design of the Noosa on
Weyba proposal and which would be implemented if the development proceeds are provided in Sections 5.5,
5.7 and 5.8 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 7) and plans/figures referenced
therein.

Issue
Rural Settlement zone environmental impacts

Information Required

30      Demonstrate how the proposed Rural Settlement Zone is compatible with the surrounding
        Conservation Lands, in respect to bushfire setbacks, bushfire management within the surrounding
        reserves, edge effects upon the adjoining reserves and fauna movement between the surrounding
        reserves.

Response:

These issues have been addressed within Section 5 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see
Attachment 7) and the amended Bushfire Assessment Report (see Attachment 9). In summary these documents
demonstrate the following:
  The potentially hazardous vegetation adjacent to the Rural Settlement Zone (RSZ) has a “moderate” (not
      “high”) hazard rating as determined in accordance with SPP 1/03.
  The RSZ has a defined building envelope (BLE) which provides setbacks to potentially hazardous vegetation
      within adjacent proposed Open Space Conservation areas that meet the bushfire hazard mitigation
      requirements of State Planning Policy 1/03 – Mitigating the Adverse Impacts of Flood, Bushfire and
      Landslide (SPP 1/03) and the Noosa Plan Natural Hazards Overlay Code.
  Any dwelling constructed within the defined BLE within the RSZ would need to comply with AS3959- 2009
      Construction of buildings in bushfire prone areas.
  The RPZ would be connected to a reticulated water supply which could be accessed for fire management
      purposes.
  Alternative routes of access/egress are available in the event of a bushfire.
  Being part of the Body Corporate there would be restrictions on the keeping of pets, landscaping etc which
      would minimise the potential for adverse edge effects upon adjacent Open Space Conservation areas.
  Any fencing of the RSZ (apart from any dedicated dog enclosure) would be of a fauna friendly form
      permitting the free movement of native fauna.
  Development of the RSZ would not require the clearance of any vegetation or fauna habitat of regulatory
      conservation significance (e.g remnant vegetation, koala bushland habitat, or areas of significance
      pursuant to the Noosa Plan Biodiversity Overlay mapping).

Issue
Interface between private lots and conservation areas

Information Required


                                                   24

Page 25

31      Private lots adjoin retained bushland in many areas throughout the proposed development.
        Demonstrate how this is a superior outcome to perimeter road interfaces particularly in achieving
        bushfire setbacks, managing urban runoff, private (yard) encroachment and restricting public and
        maintenance access.

Response:

Please refer to the revised Ecological Report included as Attachment 7. This report concludes the following;

The proposed Noosa on Weyba development is not a standard urban residential development and is based on a
Body Corporate model and as such many of the issues typically associated with having private lots fronting onto
open space /conservation areas will be avoided (i.e. extension of back yards, dumping of refuse, garden
escapees etc). Provision has also been made for appropriate building setbacks adjacent to all areas of potentially
hazardous vegetation and fire-trails for bushfire management purposes.

Having residential lots fronting onto open space conservation reserves in some areas also provides an
opportunity for a “soft” edge to these conservation areas as opposed to a “hard” edge that would be associated
with roadways. In areas where lots are not separated from adjacent Open Space Conservation areas, the
proposed restrictions on fencing and keeping of domestic pets within the residential lots should effectively
increase the availability of habitat for native fauna inhabiting the adjoining Open Space Conservation reserves.

Issue
Affordability of the proposed Environment Levy

Information Required

32      Provide an estimate of the proposed Environmental Levy cost to future property owners given
        this cost impost will be on top of existing Council Rates and various levies, water rates and other Body
        Corporate Charges. It is assumed from reading the Noosa on Weyba documentation that the
        Environment Levy will pay for fauna fences and associated maintenance, wildlife road crossings,
        revegetation/offset plantings and maintenance, bushfire management, feral animal control,
        weed control and the maintenance of urban park, Lake Weyba buffer, wetland/ stormwater
        treatment, roadside verges and noise buffers.

Response:

Please refer to Attachment 4 for an estimate of the proposed Body Corporate Levy cost to future property
owners within the Community Title Report. The attached Body Corporate Levy budget within the Community
Title Report shows estimates for between 800-1000 subsidiary lots and estimates the total cost to future
property owners as indicated in the below provided table:


Initial Estimate Noosa on Weyba Principal Scheme Budget




                                                     25

Page 26

The indicative Body Corpoate Levy budget includes the following tasks when calculating the cost per annum
(excluding GST):
 Annual Koala fence maintenance along Walter Hay Drive.
 Environmental land maintenance throughout the estate.
 Environmental (flora, fauna and WQ) monitoring of Open Space Conservation Areas.
 Feral animal control in environmental areas of the project and in the Eenie Creek Noosa National Park.
 Environmental Education.
 Policing of Environmental By Laws.
 Administration.
 Insurance premiums.

Issue
Cut and Fill

Extensive areas of the development footprint are subject to bulk earthworks (cut and fill) and vegetation
loss.

Information Required

33       Demonstrate how the resulting loss of seasonal frog habitat (fill areas) old growth tree habitats
         (cut areas) and the ongoing impacts on adjoining areas will be addressed.

Response:

Details concerning the locations and extents of land that would be subject to bulk earthworks (cut and fill) are
provided in the Noosa on Weyba Engineering Report (see Attachment 8).

It is acknowledged that there will be some loss of non-core ephemeral frog habitat and loss of old growth
hollow bearing trees as a result of the development, including impacts associated with the proposed bulk
earthworks program. Much of the affected habitat is currently degraded by current lawful uses of the land and
would be further degraded or lost as a result of commitments that attach to the land.

As detailed in the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 7), areas of essential habitat for
threatened native fauna would largely be retained and their condition would be enhanced via the removal of
impacts from agricultural/grazing uses. The environmental offset works proposed will also effect a net gain in
the extent (and in all likelihood the quality) of essential habitat for threatened specifies such as the acid frogs
and Koala.

As detailed in Section 5.4 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 7), the majority of
hollow bearing trees would be retained and the loss of nesting hollows would be offset using nesting boxes etc.
The cessation of livestock grazing and facilitation of the regeneration of native vegetation will also provide a
new generation of trees which will replace the old growth trees that will eventually be lost through natural
                                                     26

Page 27

processes. This is also an advantage of the proposed pattern of land use over continuation of existing land use
patterns where there would be a gradual decline in the tree hollow resource located in those parts of the site
which are actively managed as pasture and within which there is no recruitment of new trees.

34      Further assessment should also address changes in hydrological flows and potential impact on frog
        and aquatic habitats. This report needs to address proposed cut and fill against existing hydrology
        and demonstrate clearly that no direct impact on significant frog or fish habits and nesting (old
        growth trees) habitat will result.

Response:

The Noosa on Weyba Stormwater Management Plan (Cardno, 2012) and Flood Study (Cardno, 2012) originally
submitted with the Development Application (and now amended and included in Attachment 11 and 12
respectively) demonstrate that:
  appropriate frequent low flow and water quality criteria can be met; and
  the peak flows from the developed site have been reduced to existing case levels for all ARI events up to
     and including the 100 year ARI event.

As such it is not anticipated that there would be any significant impacts to core and ephemeral areas of frog
habitat retained within Open Space Conservation Zone. Similarly fish habitat values would not be adversely
affected.

We also note that the most abundant and broadly distributed listed frog species known to occur at the site
(Crinia tinnula – the Wallum froglet) is known to be tolerant of physical disturbance as is evident by the fact that
it has colonized several small constructed dams on the site, including one located adjacent to and receiving
runoff from Walter Hay Drive.

Issue
Biodiversity Development Offset Area (BDOA)—for Koala protection

Information Required

35      Demonstrate how the surrender of 139.5ha (the send site) of marginal Koala habitat for
        incorporation into the Noosa National Park can be a net gain for Koalas (and other flora and
        fauna species) when the (receive site) allows for 1039 dwellings and associated cut and fill, urban
        infrastructure and associated impacts.

Response:

Both the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 7) and the amended Koala Impact and Net
Benefit Assessment (see Attachment 10) provide considerable detail concerning the benefits that would be
derived from the proposal compared to:
  the continuation of existing lawful uses of the subject land; and/or
  the uptake of existing development commitments that attach to the land.

It is also noted that ex-Professor, Doctor Frank Carrick AM has completed a detailed review of the Noosa on
Weyba proposal and has concluded that “In the particular circumstances of the ‘Noosa on Weyba’ proposal, it is
my opinion that the case is persuasive that a better outcome for Koalas will be achieved by this sort of holistic
approach, in contrast to the likely outcome of the piecemeal developments already approved or in prospect for
the area.” A copy of ex-Professor, Doctor Frank Carrick’s assessment report titled “Noosa on Weyba - Review of
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment and Ecological Assessment Report” by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd is
provided in Attachment 10 and 7 respectively.

36      Demonstrate how this outcome is superior to the existing protection mechanisms applying to the
        send site, namely:-

                                                      27

Page 28

             (a)      Vegetation Management Act. PMAV 2012/004900
             (b)      Regional Ecosystem 12.5.3 (Endangered) and Regional Ecosystem 12.3.4 Of Concern
             (c)      EPBC Koala Protection
             (d)      Noosa Planning Scheme Biodiversity Overlay and associated Code
             (e)      Noosa Planning Scheme Environmental Protection Zoning
             (f)      Sunshine Coast Regional Council Temporary Local Planning Instrument—No. 1
                      (Protected Vegetation Overlay) 2012

Response:

As detailed in the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 7) and the amended Koala Impact
and Net Benefit Assessment (see Attachment 10) the proposed development achieves compliance with the
relevant requirements of local, State and Commonwealth regulations that promote ecologically sustainable
development. The proposal will also be the subject of a separate EPBC Act referral process to ensure that
appropriate consideration has been given to Matters of National Environmental Significance.

Council should note that the BDOA is not a process which should be assessed as part of a Preliminary Approval
for a Material Change of Use. It was a separate application which was gazetted on 20 January 2012.
Notwithstanding this, a summary of DLGP’s reasoning for gazetting the Noosa on Weyba BDOA Infrastructure
Agreement has been provided as follows to demonstrate the benefits of the project.

The Noosa on Weyba BDOA Infrastructure Agreement, which is attached for your reference (See Attachment
19.), has been prepared over a period of approximately 18 months by the State of Queensland (acting through
the Department of Local Government and Planning) and addresses the issues raised in points 35 and 36 above.

While it is acknowledged that in preparing the Noosa on Weyba BDOA Infrastructure Agreement, EHP (formerly
DERM) and SCRC did not provide their support, DLGP were of the opinion that the BDOA Agreement would
result in a significant net benefit for koala conservation in Noosaville and South East Queensland for the
following reasons amongst others:

        The proposed BDOA ‘Send’ site is located in Noosaville location adjacent to Lake Weyba and the Noosa
         National Park. The send site constitutes a significant adjunct to the Noosa National Park to the north
         and together with an existing vegetation corridor to the south in the receive site provides a major
         potential link between heavily vegetated SCRC owned land to the south (i.e. as a nature refuge) and the
         national park.
        The BDOA ‘Send’ site is heavily vegetated with 91.3% of the 139.5 hectares being covered by Bushland
         Habitat (Low to Medium) vegetation.
        The BDOA Agreement could result in an additional 139.5 hectares being transferred to the State for
         inclusion into the Noosa National Park, with approximately 98% of the area constituting Bushland
         Habitat which is very suited for koala conservation purposes.
        There are no current development approvals or rezoning approvals affecting the BDOA ‘Send’ site that
         may result in further loss of koala habitat.
        The BDOA ‘Receive’ site which the applicant is seeking to develop and use as an offset in exchange for
         the transfer of koala habitat has areas of significant clearing used for small scale grazing activity.
        The BDOA ‘Receive’ site has a development approval for rural holiday accommodation over part of the
         site consisting of 24 villas, a restaurant, reception building, managers residence, other ancillary service
         buildings and outdoor recreation facilities (i.e. including tennis courts and swimming pool).
       It is noted that the development application and development approval affecting the BDOA ‘Receive’
        site can be progressed by the applicant regardless of whether a BDOA is declared – i.e. consent has
        already been granted for the rural holiday accommodation on Lot 11 which enables the proponent to
        develop the site without the need to provide koala or other environmental offsets, particularly to the
        extent offered by the send site. Similarly the development application for the reconfiguration of Lot 53
        is the subject of an appeal and if approved by the court would enable the proponent to also develop the
        site. (N.B: This consent has now been approved).


                                                      28

Page 29

    Issue
    Estimated land valuation of Send Site

    Information Required

    37       Provide an independent Land Valuation prepared by the Queensland Department of Natural
             Resources and Mines of the Biodiversity Development Offset Area (BDOA) (the Send Site).

    Response:

    It is not considered reasonable or relevant to request a land valuation for this purpose as the BDOA process has
    been completed and is separate to the current Preliminary Approval Application. Please refer to Attachment 11
    for Norton Rose Fulbright legal advice confirming validity of BDOA.

    Issue
    Glossy Black Cockatoos

    Information Required

    38       Glossy Black Cockatoos are known to occur in this area, provide detailed mapping of their
             feeding/food trees (Allocasuarina littoralis), watering sites and breeding hollows (habitat trees).

    Response:

    The amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 7) recognises the recorded presence of the
    Vulnerable (at a State level) Glossy Black Cockatoo in the site locality and that vegetation communities within
    the site boundaries that provide habitat resources for this species. As detailed in the figures contained within
    the amended Ecological Assessment Report, the vast majority of suitable feed trees, watering sites and nesting
    hollows for the Glossy Black Cockatoo are located within the proposed Open Space Conservation Precinct.

    Issue
    The Tidswell and Hollett Road Reserves are known to support populations of Flora and Fauna Species
    Scheduled in the Qld Nature Conservation Act and the Commonwealth Environment Protection and
    Biodiversity Conservation Act.


    Information Required

    39       Provide an additional Environment Assessment of the Tidswell and Hollett Road reserves
             targeted towards Scheduled Flora and Fauna Species and the distribution of Old Growth Habitat
             Trees.

Response:

Sections 4.2 and 4.3 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 7) recognise the potential or
confirmed presence of:
         17 threatened flora species; and
         26 threatened fauna species;

         within the Noosa on Weyba site.

No threatened flora species were identified within the boundaries of the Noosa on Weyba site nor within those
sections of the Hollett and Tidswell Road reserves. It is anticipated that it is likely that some specimens that belong
to populations that range across the broader locality may be present within these Hollett and Tidswell Road
reserves. It is understood that Council is aware of the presence of some threatened flora within the Hollett and
                                                          29

Page 30

Tidswell Road reserves, however Council has not been able to provide locations for these records to assist in the
ecological assessments of the Noosa on Weyba project.

As detailed in the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 7) the proposal will retain over 90% of
the hollow bearing trees located within the Noosa on Weyba site, with a substantial number of hollow bearing trees
also being present within the surrounding landscape (i.e. Noosa National Park, Weyba Nature Refuge, Tanish’s
Nature Refuge). The proposal also includes a range of mitigation and offset measures that will be implemented in
respect of any necessary loss of hollow bearing trees.

Overall, the upgrading of Tidswell Road and a small section of Hollett Road would have some impact in habitat
resources for threatened fauna (e.g. Koala and Glossy black cockatoo) however the magnitude of such impacts are
not likely to be significant given:
       the presence of existing and past clearance and disturbance within these road reserves;
       the ability to design (subject to Council’s agreement) nonstandard roadways that minimise the loss of
           habitat;
       the fact that upgrading of some sections of these roadways would occur as a result of other development
           commitments; and
       the ability to translocate or offset.

    Issue
    Impact upon adjoining Voluntary Conservation Agreement and Nature Refuge Properties

    Information Required

    40       Demonstrate what potential impacts the proposed development will have upon the adjoining
             protected properties and how these are to be mitigated.

Response:

The amended Ecological Assessment Report (Attachment 7) explicitly recognises and responds to the presence of
the Weyba Nature Refuge, the Tainsh’s Nature Refuge and adjoining sectors of the Noosa National Park. Section 5 of
the amended Ecological Assessment Report details the range of measures that have been incorporated into the
design of the development and which would be implemented during the construction/operational phases of
development to preserve the conservation values of proposed on-site and adjacent conservation areas.

    Issue
    Appendix 10 Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment.

    Information Required

    41       Provide an amended Koala Assessment Report which addresses the following issues:-

    (a)     Provide details of primary and secondary Koala food trees – based on known preferences and field
             results (evidence of Koala activity). This should form the basis of any comparisons of habitat
             quality, rather than tree density which does not account for the habitat preferences of Koala.

    (b)      Undertake additional field assessment on Koala and Koala habitat values and provide associated
             data and detailed methodology within the report (datasheets are not necessary to include but
             should be retained in Appendices i f s o c h o s e n ). Methodology s h o u l d b e p r o v i d e d i n
             d e t a i l sufficient to replicate and should be designed according to accepted survey guidelines, e.g.
             Policy 4 of the Nature Conservation (Koala) Conservation Plan 2006 and Management Program 2006-
             2016, and DSEWPaC Interim Koala referral advice for proponents. Koala surveys should be conducted
             by experienced o b s e r v e r s . The n a m e s o f i n d i v i d u a l s w h o c o m p l e t e d th e surveys should be
             included in the report.

    (c)     Provide justification on how the current Plan of Development provides for the loss of Koala Bushland
                                                                 30

Page 31

             habitat. The proponent should look at redesign to retain all Koala Bushland as required by the SPRP.
             The proponent should provide a clear demonstration(s) on how the proposed actions meet the
             assessment criteria (Table7) of the SPRP.

    (d)      Provide detailed calculations on the number, size, species and illustrate locations of Koala
             habitat trees which will be cleared as a result of the proposed actions. This should include all
             associated road upgrades, services and facilities, firebreaks and walkways.

    (e)     Ensure that figures are contained within subsequent reporting and not as appendices to allow readers
            ease of referencing relevant information within the report.

Response:
Please refer to Attachment 10 which includes an amended ‘Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Report’
prepared by Cardno.

41 (a) The Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Report (KAR) does not rely on tree densities to determine
Koala habitat quality, rather it relies on the Koala SPRP Maps. Assessment of koala habitat tree densities is required
to meet the requirements of the Koala SPRP. The above reference to the fact that high tree density does not
account for high koala habitat quality and the importance of primary food species is specifically recognised in the
report.

Furthermore data concerning “primary” and “secondary” koala food trees was collated during the surveys included
within the originally submitted Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Report’ and could be analysed to generate
an index of habitat quality based on the relative proportion of primary and secondary koala habitat trees in
different vegetation types.

R41 (b) Details concerning the transect based Koala survey method used in the ‘Koala Impact and Net Benefit
Assessment Report’ are presented in Appendix B of this report. Please refer to Attachment 10 for a copy of the
amened Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Report. In addition to the formal transects surveys substantial
time was dedicated to detecting the presence of koalas within the site during general ecological surveys completed
by appropriately qualified ecologists as detailed in Section 3.4.1 of the amened Koala Impact and Net Benefit
Assessment Report.

The survey method and efforts used for the surveys are considered appropriate for purpose and consistent with
guidance given in Policy 4 of the Nature Conservation (Koala) Conservation Plan 2006 and Management Program
2006-2016.

R41 (c) As detailed in Sect 6.1 of the amened Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Report the only clearance of
non-juvenile Koala Habitat Trees within Koala Bushland Habitat will be for linear infrastructure purposes (i.e. Road)
which has been acknowledged as being assessable against Division 4 of the SPRP and on that basis the proposal can
meet the requirements of SPRP.

R41 (d) It is considered that the Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Report generally provides relevant details
for the purpose of the current application.

R41 (e) Relevant figures are presented within the body of the Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Report
based on more extensive data presented in appendices as per standard practice.

    Issue
    Appendix 9 Ecological Assessment Report

    Information Required

    42      Provide an amended Ecological Assessment Report which addresses the following issues:-
    (a)   Provide detailed design and discussion on how suitable facilitation of fauna movement, specifically
            targeting all proposed and existing roadways. The option of creating suitable safe crossing
                                                         31

Page 32

             opportunities to connect habitats dissected by these roads does not appear to have been sufficiently
             considered.
    (b)    Provide detailed road crossing designs for both aquatic in-stream fauna and terrestrial fauna at all
             drainage and riparian crossings. The relevant reference within the report should also address
             this matter.
    (c)    Provide justification on fauna corridor(s) size(s) and locations. It appears that corridors have
             been designated in balance lands outside of the proposed development footprints. It appears
             the size, location and suitability (function) of the corridors has not been considered.
    (d)    Provide details on what habitat values are provided within the fauna corridors and for which species
             (present on site) and how it is envisaged these (corridors) will provide sufficient habitat and safe
             movement options.
    (e)   Provide database searches on 5km or greater (from the site) to obtain records of species known
             from the broader landscape. The search as presented in the report is based on 2km radius of
             the central coordinate (-26.4313,153.0499) does not account for the home ranges of many
             protected species, including the Koala and only just covers the full extent of the site. A search radius
             of at least 5 km would be more appropriate. This wider search will assist with the identification of
             species present in the local landscape which have potential to utilise the extant habitats.
    (f)    Provide justification why the field surveys (flora and fauna) failed to follow the Noosa Planning Scheme
             Policy 18 – Ecological Assessment Guidelines or the Terrestial Vertebrate Fauna Survey Guidelines
             for Queensland (refer- http://www.ehp.qld.gov.au/ecosystems/biodiversity/fauna-survey.html for
             further information on suitable survey methodologies.)
    (g)    Provide additional information on the presence and habitat (during wet and dry periods) of
             significant frog species. The ‗Survey Guidelines for Australia‘s Threatened Frogs‘ (Commonwealth of
             Australia 2010) recommends that surveys are scheduled to correspond to breeding seasons and
             respond to weather conditions conducive to target species‘ breeding activities. Given the known
             presence of state and federally listed species it is important that methodologies as stated in these
             guidelines are undertaken.
    (h)    Provide a figure that shows where all surveys were conducted and what level of survey effort was
             applied at each location.
    (i)    Provide a significant species management plan, which addresses all known and potential species.
             There should be provision of figures showing all significant habitat/s, known significant species
             locations, mitigations, responses, and monitoring requirements.
    (j)    Provide comment on the management of direct and indirect impacts of proposed development
             and associated activities in proximity to the retained habitats .Specific comment on how proposed
             actions meet and provide ongoing compliance with relevant VMA codes.

Response:

Please refer to Attachment 7 for the amended Ecological Assessment Report.

R42(a) A number of safe fauna passage measures are to be implemented as part of the Noosa on Weyba project,
including the completion of the fauna exclusion fencing along Walter Hay Drive. The width and length of this
roadway in combination with the high volume and velocity of traffic that it conveys, Walter Hay Drive is a major
barrier to the safe movement of fauna through the locality.

It is not proposed to establish fauna exclusion fencing along other local roadways that would service the proposed
development given the low speed design of these roadways, the relative low volume of traffic that they would
convey, and the other safe fauna passage measures that are proposed (see below). This assessment also recognises
that whilst exclusion fencing is effective in reducing road trauma it does affect the movement patterns of native
fauna and as such can fragment habitat.

However, as part of the Noosa on Weyba Biodiversity Management Strategy it is proposed that a register of
observed fauna road kills on local roadways would be maintained and bi-annual surveys of fauna movement across
internal and external roadways will be undertaken to:
      confirm which fauna species are moving across local roadways;

                                                         32

Page 33

        investigate whether the safe fauna passage infrastructure (see below) that has been established is being
         utilised; and
        identify locations where additional exclusion (guide) fencing may be required and the most appropriate
         form of that fencing.

If it is determined, in consultation with Council, that the establishment of additional exclusion (guide) fencing on the
local road network is warranted then a funding contribution for same would be made from the Noosa on Weyba
environment levy.

Currently there is no “furniture” within the Eenie Creek bridge underpass that is designed to facilitate the safe
passage of arboreal fauna. To enhance the values of this strategically important underpass it is proposed to
establish escape poles and elevated log bridges similar to those which have been established through the
southernmost Walter Hay Drive fauna culverts.

The preliminary engineering design for the Noosa on Weyba project made specific provision for the establishment
of culverts of a suitable dimension to facilitate the passage of fish and most terrestrial fauna species. All upgrades of
existing waterway crossings are proposed to be designed in accordance with the Qld Department of Agriculture,
Fisheries and Forestry’s Fish passage in streams: Fisheries guidelines for design of stream crossings (FHG 001).

Where new or upgraded roadways traverse forested sectors of the proposed Open Space Conservation Zone and
adjacent protected areas (e.g. Weyba Nature Refuge) canopy bridges will be established to facilitate the safe
passage of arboreal species such as possums and gliders.

The general locations where these additional safe fauna passage measures would be implemented are illustrated in
Appendix 7- Amended Ecological Assessment Report (Figure 11). All of these measures would be designed and
constructed in general accordance with the specifications of Chapter 6 of the Department of Main Roads Fauna
Sensitive Road Design Volume 2 (DMRT, 2010).

For additional information regarding fauna movement and habitat linkages please refer to Sections 5.5, 5.7 and 5.8
of the Amended Ecological Assessment Report.

R42(b) Please refer to the above response (R42[a]) for detailed information regarding habitat movement within the
Noosa on Weyba site. It is considered appropriate that Council impose reasonable and relevant Conditions requiring
appropriate provisions be made in accordance with the development commitments given which are based on the
Department of Main Roads Fauna Sensitive Road Design Volume 2.

R42(c) Over 56% of the Receive Site has been dedicated as Open Space for the purpose of providing habitat and
movement corridors for native wildlife. The “development footprints” are compact and located within areas that
do not have high habitat or corridor values. As noted within the amended Ecological Report, measures will also be
taken within the “development footprints” to facilitate the movement of native wildlife, however the primary
movement corridors are located outside of the “development footprints”.

R42(d) The designated Open Space Conservation Precinct areas will provide habitat resources, including movement
corridors, for the same diversity of native fauna that currently inhabit these areas. In some instances the habitat
values of the Open Space Conservation Precinct areas will be enhanced via the cessation of current land uses (e.g.
livestock grazing, pasture management etc) and the natural and assisted regeneration of remnant vegetation,
including the enrichment of ground layer habitats via the placement of hollow logs and branches sourced from
areas to be developed. The new and upgraded waterway crossings will also be established to a much higher
engineering and ecological standard than the existing rural crossings which provide for restricted flow under most
conditions.

R42(e) The 2km search radius is considered appropriate as the resultant search areas extend well beyond the site
and to areas of significance such as:
 Eumundi-Noosa Road to the West;
 Eenie Creek Road to the north,
 the centre of Lake Weyba to the east; and
 Beyond Weyba Downs to the south.
                                                           33

Page 34

The 5km search radius produces records of an additional:

    452 plant species, including 15 threatened species ; and
    274 fauna species, including 17 threatened species.

The amended Ecological Assessment Report (Attachment 7) includes the details from, and an assessment of, an
expanded 5km search radius of the Wildnet database.

R42(f)& (g) The ecological surveys and assessments were carried out in general accordance with the Noosa Planning
Scheme Policy 18. To overcome the inherent limitations of field based ecological surveys a pre-cautionary approach
was adopted. In this respect it was assumed that native wildlife species that are known, or considered likely, to
occur in the Noosa on Weyba site were assumed to be present if suitable habitat resources were present.
Assessments of the nature and magnitude of ecological impacts associated with the Noosa on Weyba project were
made on this basis, taking into account:
     the nature and extent of habitat retention and enhancement, including consideration of the proposed
         surrender of existing land use and development rights over a substantial area of high ecological
         significance;
     the nature and extent of habitat loss and degradation;
     the nature and likely effectiveness of biodiversity impact mitigation and offset strategies that form an
         integral part of the Noosa on Weyba project.

R42(h) Refer to Section 3 and Figure 4 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report (Attachment 7) which provides
general details concerning the nature and distribution of ecological surveys that have informed the Noosa on
Weyba project.

R42(i) Relevant information regarding the manner in which it is proposed to manage significant species and their
habitats is presented in the amended Ecological Assessment Report. It would be considered reasonable for Council
to impose a Condition of approval requiring that a Threatened Species Management Plan be prepared and
submitted in support of subsequent applications for development approval.

R42(j) The proposed development is to be referred to the Department of Natural Resources and Mines (NRM) for
assessment as a concurrence agency as the property:
      is greater than 2 ha; and
      contains remnant vegetation shown on a RE Map.
In this respect, NRM’s MCU Policy is used to assess MCU development applications under the Sustainable Planning
Act 2009. Furthermore, as part of compliance with the MCU Policy, the proposed development is required to
demonstrate compliance with the RVM Code.

An assessment of the proposed development against the relevant Performance Requirements of the MCU Policy
and the RVM Code is provided in the amended Property Vegetation Management Plan (see Attachment 12 for
further detail).

    43      Provide additional categories on species Identified from database searches. In particular expand
            the categories used to address the likelihood of occurrence. We recommend the use of Confirmed,
            Expected, Potential, Unlikely and Not expected, and provide further discussion on how/why
            occurrence rating has been applied. It would be helpful for species listed as possible that their
            potential occurrence on site was assigned to the broad vegetation communities and habitats (e.g.
            breeding/roosting) habitats mapped.

Response:

Please refer to Attachment 7 which includes the amended Ecological Assessment Report.

Field observations, Wildlife Online and the EPBC Protected Matters database searches, and a review of threatened
species whose geographic distribution encompasses the locality resulted in the compilation of a list of significant

                                                        34

Page 35

fauna species that have either been observed or that are considered likely to occur in the site locality.

A review of species databases was undertaken to identify fauna species of conservation significance that may occur
within the Noosa on Weyba locality. Specifically, the following databases were interrogated.
      Wildlife Online, which is an online database of confirmed species records with restricted geographic
         precision that is maintained by DEHP. The Wildlife Online search was conducted for a 5 km radius
         surrounding a central point within the study area (latitude 26.4313 and longitude 153.0499) (DEHP 2013).
         The results of this database search are provided in Appendix G of the amended Ecological Assessment
         Report (see Attachment 8).
      EPBC Act Protected Matters Search, which is an online database that is maintained by SEWPaC. The EPBC
         Act Protected Matters Search identifies MNES, including nationally Threatened species that may
         potentially occur within a defined boundary, primarily based on habitat modelling. The EPBC Act Protected
         Matters search was conducted for a 2 km radius surrounding a central point within the study area (latitude
         26.4313 and longitude 153.0499) (SEWPaC 2012a).

For each species of conservation significance that was identified by the above searches, or which had been reported
as occurring in the locality by local community groups, an assessment of the potential for the species to occur within
the study area was subsequently undertaken. This assessment was based on the documented habitat preferences of
each species, and involved assignment of each species to one of the following ‘likelihood of occurrence’ categories.
      Confirmed, if the species has been positively identified by Cardno during ecological surveys within the
         study area or has been reported as being observed on the site by a cited source.
      Possible, if suitable habitat for the species has been observed during ecological surveys within the study
         area.
      Unlikely, if suitable habitat for the species has not been observed during ecological surveys within the
         study area.

 Sections 4.2 and 4.3 of the amended Ecological Assessment (Attachment 7) provide details concerning the broad
vegetation community-habitat types that are either confirmed or potential habitat for threatened flora and fauna
species. The three level “likelihood of occurrence” classification system used in the amended Ecological Assessment
Report, and as outlined above, is considered appropriate.

    Issue
    Waterways Study

    The proposed development contains and drains into significant waterways which are likely to support
    populations of endangered fish e.g. Honey Blue-eye and Oxleyan Pygmy Perch and other freshwater species
    e.g. Wallum Freshwater Crayfish.

    Information Required

    44       Provide a comprehensive aquatic fauna survey (Aquatic Fauna and Their Habitats) of the whole site
             including Eenie Creek. This report should include discussion relating to waterway values and their
             ongoing protection, as well as how aquatic species will be accommodated by roadway construction
             and/or upgrades.

Response:

Please refer to Attachment 7 which includes the amended Ecological Assessment Report.

The Swamp Crayfish (Tenuibranchiurus glypticus) is a potential inhabitant of the waterways and wetlands of the
Noosa on Weyba site locality. This species is not listed as a threated species pursuant to the EPBC Act or the NC Act.

The retention and enhancement of areas of suitable habitat for this species would provide benefits over
continuation of existing uses. Both the Honey Blue-eye and Oxleyan Pygmy Perch are small freshwater species
typically associated with densely vegetated tannin stained drainage systems traversing wallum dominated coastal
areas. Both species are known to occur in Marcus Creek, part of which lies in the East Weyba section of Noosa

                                                          35

Page 36

National Park.

The Action Plan for Australian freshwater fishes (R. Wager and P. Jackson Environment Australia, June 1993) states
that “Other land on which species occurs: Possibly private land encompassing headwater streams of Lake Weyba, at
the mouth of the Noosa River (Qld).”

It is considered that a comprehensive aquatic fauna survey of the whole site including Keyser Creek and Eenie Creek
is not reasonably required to inform the ecological assessment. This position is based on the facts that:
        both of these waterways would be contained within the proposed Public Open Space Conservation
           Precinct;
        the proposed change in land use would result in the cessation of existing rural use activities (e.g. livestock
           grazing, pasture management) that are currently having an impact on these waterways;
        vegetated buffers of an appropriate dimension would be maintained between these waterways and
           proposed urban development areas;
        the Stormwater Management Plan (Cardno 2013) demonstrates that adverse impacts upon the water
           qualities of these waterways would be avoided via implementation of water sensitive urban design
           principles;
        apart from the upgrading of several existing crossings of 1st order sections of these waterways there
           would be no physical development activity within the waterways; and
        the upgraded waterway crossings would allow for a more natural hydrological regimes and better
           ecological connectivity (e.g. fish passage) between waterway reaches located upstream and downstream
           of the crossings.


    45       Indicate whether the road will be elevated above the waterways or whether culverts will be
             provided to allow for protection of hydrological regimes and connectivity of habitat for in-stream
             flora and fauna. Detailed drawings showing proposed waterway crossings and fauna movement
             facilities are required to allow understanding of habitat connectivity in these locations.

Response:

As detailed in the amended Ecological Assessment Report in Attachment 7 all road culverts would be designed in
accordance with the Qld Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry’s Fish passage in streams: Fisheries
guidelines for design of stream crossings (FHG 001). Preliminary design details for all crossings were provided in the
engineering plans which were also referred to in Section 5.6 and Figure 8 of the amended Ecological Assessment
Report.

Council should note that with any amended Civil Engineering Report (see Attachment 8) that 2 waterway crossing
originally proposed in Hollett Road and Lot 11 have now been removed in response to Councils concerns. This has
substantially reduced the impacts of culverts on waterways throughout the subject site.
    Issue
    Appendix 11 Property Vegetation Management Plan

    Information Required

    46      Provide a revised Vegetation Management Plan which:-

    (a) Provide further detail on all required actions, maintenance and monitoring of proposed retained
    vegetation.
    (b) Provide a tree plot indicating location, species, girth, height and number of hollows of trees within the
    clearing footprint (including roadside vegetation walkways and facilities (sewer lines, electricity, etc.) as well
    as a Tree Retention Plan. There should also be clear identification and details of where suitable hollows
    are being retained in the balance lands.
    (c) Provide a Tree Retention Plan for all vegetation to be affected by the construction of the proposed
    roadways and required road upgrades.

                                                          36

Page 37

Response:

The Property Vegetation Management Plan (PVMP) is a document that was specifically prepared to satisfy the IDAS
requirements for a development application involving the clearance of vegetation assessable against the Vegetation
Management Act.

As detailed in Section 5.8 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report (Attachment 7) a commitment has been
given (which could be Conditioned by Council) that for each stage of construction a detailed Vegetation and Fauna
Management and Monitoring Plan (VFMMP) would be developed to Council’s satisfaction. It is proposed that each
VFMMP would specify:
     the precise location and nature of any vegetation that is to be retained on all construction plans;
     the precise nature of measures that are to be implemented to protected vegetation identified for
         retention, in accord with Australian Standard AS 4970—2009 - Protection of trees on development sites
         (AS4970-2009);
     the precise locations where vegetation clearance is permitted on all construction plans and physically
         marked in the field;
     that a pre-clearance and fauna survey must be carried out prior to the clearance of any vegetation and that
         any tree hollows are to be physically examined by an appropriately qualified, licensed and equipped Fauna
         Spotted Catcher;
     that no vegetation is to be cleared until any occupying fauna have self-relocated from the vegetation or
         have been safely and appropriately relocated by an appropriately qualified, licensed and equipped
         Fauna Spotted Catcher (note: Koala are not to be relocated);
     that all vegetation clearance works be carried out in a sequential manner and under the supervision
         and control of an appropriately qualified, licensed and equipped Fauna Spotted Catcher;
     that all vegetation that is cleared is to be appropriately reused in the enhancement of the ecological
         values of the Open Space Conservation Zone;
     the nature of weed and pest species management measures that are to be implemented.

    Details concerning the locations and numbers of hollow bearing trees that would be retained and those that are
    likely to require removal are provided in Section 5.4, Appendix C and Figure 10 of the amended Ecological
    Assessment Report (Attachment 7)

    Issue
    Commonwealth Referrals – Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act

    This area supports Flora and Fauna (Koala, Wallum Sedge Frog, Honey Blue-eye, and Oxleyan Pygmy Perch)
    Species, Plant Communities (low altitude rainforest) and Habitats of National importance.

    Information Required

    47      Provide evidence that this application has been forwarded to the Commonwealth Department of
            Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities; under the Environment Protection
            and Biodiversity Conservation Act.

Response:

The Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC Act) requires that a person must receive
Commonwealth approval for any action that has, will have, or is likely to have a significant impact on MNES. MNES
that are recognised by the EPBC Act and which can act as a trigger for the Commonwealth assessment and approval
process include:
      World Heritage properties;
      National Heritage Places;
      Ramsar wetlands of international significance;
      Threatened species and ecological communities;
      Migratory species;

                                                       37

Page 38

       Nuclear actions, including uranium mining; and
       The Commonwealth marine environment.

The only MNES that has been confirmed to occur at the Noosa on Weyba site is the Koala (Phascolarctos cinereus)
which has been recently listed as a Vulnerable species. As detailed in Section 4.2.1 and Section 4.3.7 of the
amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 7) the Noosa on Weyba site is also considered likely to
provide habitat resources for a number of other EPBC Act threatened fauna and flora species.

No other MNES have been recognised within or adjacent to the Noosa on Weyba site.

A formal Referral of the Noosa on Weyba proposal will be made to the Commonwealth Minister for the
Environment under the provisions of the EPBC Act to ensure that potential impacts to MNES have been
appropriately considered and responded to.

Council will be notified once the Referral is lodged, which will be subsequent to the resolution of responses to
Council Information Request.

   Issue
   Appendix 12 Bushfire Assessment Report

   The Bushfire Assessment Report provides insufficient information with regard to the hazards, risks
   which future residents and property may experience in a bushfire event.

   The Report provides a response to State Planning Policy 1/03 – Mitigating the Adverse Impacts of Flood
   Bushfire and Land slide but as both the Noosa Plan and the Maroochy Plan are SPP1/03 compliant the
   applicant is required to respond to those planning schemes and not SPP1/013.

   The document provides a range of key aspects but provides no information with regard to those key aspects.

   The application indicates that all buildings will be designed and constructed in accordance with Australian
   Standard AS3959-2009 but this standard is not part of any mitigation measure that the applicant may seek
   to propose as it is purely about the protection of a structure that may be subjected to a Bushfire Attack
   Level (BAL) greater than 12.5.

   The indicative road network provides a number of access roads that may, during a bushfire event, place
   people in a hazardous situation. As such, the road network needs to satisfactorily respond to the landscape
   and the potential directions of threats that may endanger any residential areas should the application be
   approved.

   The application proposes to provide reticulated water to the site which is critical for the suppression of
   wildfires and the management of planned burns within the residual bushland around any development.

   The location of the retirement village and the potential single BLE on Lot 2 on SP129590 is highly problematic
   due to the constraints on suitable access for people to be able to be removed from such as facility during a
   bushfire event.

   The applicant appears to be indicating that a single BLE could be located within the western cleared area on
   Lot 53 on SP163571 (Precinct 4). Site inspections indicate this area cannot be used for the location of
   any structures that would house people on a temporary or permanent basis due to the difficulty of access and
   the flammable nature of the adjacent vegetation.

   The applicant appears to propose an access road to service the eastern residential areas (east of Walter Hay
   Drive) via access to the eastern portion of Hollett Road and Tidswell Road. Due to the distance that this road
   traverses through hazardous vegetation the use of this road during a bushfire event may place people at an
   unacceptable level of risk.

   The application appears to propose the use of the maintained area under the high voltage power lines as a
                                                         38

Page 39

possible emergency access route. Due to its length and the proximity of hazardous vegetation this proposal
is not supported.

The application suggests that Eenie Creek provides a break between the vegetation on both creekbanks.

This view is not supported. Due to the height and type of vegetation in question, Eenie Creek would not
stop a bushfire on either bank from jumping the creek and burning the vegetation on the opposite bank.

Response:
Please refer to Attachment 9 which includes the amended Bushfire Assessment Report. This report concludes
the following;

The bushfire hazard codes of both the Noosa Plan and Maroochy Plan are directly derived from and make
specific reference to SPP 1/03. As such it is considered appropriate that the proposed development is directly
assessed against the state planning policy which is the guideline for both the Noosa Plan and Maroochy Plan.

Council makes abovementioned reference to Australian Standard AS3959-2009 not being directly relevant to
the proposed developments bushfire mitigation measure. This point is not supported as it is widely considered
that assessment of proposed development in a bushfire prone area against AS3959-2009 is both a logical and
recommended measure of any bushfire hazard assessment and mitigation response.

Furthermore it should be noted that the proposed Noosa on Weyba development site is predominately within a
‘Medium Bushfire Hazard’ rated area not a ‘High Bushfire Hazard’ area. The proposed road network provides
multiple avenues for access/egress in the event of a bushfire which represents appropriate practice for bushfire
response in both the relevant planning schemes and relevant Australian Standards.

The single BLE in proposed Precinct 4 is for a non-habitable recreation facility. Appropriate setbacks from
hazardous vegetation are proposed to be provided in accordance with SPP 1/03 and the applicable provisions of
the Noosa Plan.

It is acknowledged that Lot 53 ‘Rural Residential’ BLE will be exposed to a degree of bushfire risk.
Notwithstanding this the BLE is compliant with relevant setback requirements of the Noosa Planning Scheme,
has the opportunity to be serviced by a reticulated water supply and is proposed to be provided with multiple
access/egress routes. Therefore the degree of hazard that the BLE would be exposed to from bushfire risk is
less than or comparable to other properties in the locality (for example the two (2) recently developed
properties off Tidswell Road to the south of the Noosa on Weyba site).

There are numerous roads within the locality that would pose an equivalent or greater level of risk to motorists
in the event of a severe bushfire then that of the above mentioned access road to service the eastern residential
areas. The length of the proposed road connections from the eastern most estate entry to WHD is proposed to
be 1km. This is equivalent to the length of roadway that would need to be traversed by existing residents of
Hottett Road (west) and Tidswell Road. An alternative route via Tidswell Road to the south will also be made
available as a result of this development.

The purpose of the proposed multiple route options for accessing/egressing the site is to ensure that one or
more routes would be available in the event of a bushfire approaching from a particular direction. Under most
circumstances the primary use of the routes would be for the deployment of fire management personnel and
equipment, as all future buildings will have appropriate setbacks from potentially hazardous vegetation and will
be designed and constructed in accordance with the requirements of AS3959. In the event of a severe bushfire,
it is envisioned that the QFRS, police and BC management would ensure that all traffic was diverted away from
potentially hazardous routes, as would be the case if any other residential development located in close
proximity to bushland was placed under sever threat from an approaching fire.

Information Required

                                                    39

Page 40

    With regard to those lots located within the area over which the Noosa Plan is the relevant Planning Scheme
    (Lot 2 on SP179590, Lot 53 on SP163571, Lot 2 on RP46782, Lot 2 on RP160983, and Lot 1667 on M37772).
    The documentation relating to bushfire hazard assessment has not responded to the relevant Codes in the
    Noosa Plan.

    48      Demonstrate how the application meets the overall outcomes of the Natural Hazards Overlays Code.

Response:

Natural Hazard: Landslide and Flooding Overlay
The overall outcomes are the purpose of the Natural Hazards Overlays Code.
The overall outcomes sought from the Natural Hazards Overlays Code are—
a) development in areas at risk from natural hazards is compatible with the nature of the natural hazard;
b) the risk to people, property and the natural environment from natural hazards is minimised;
c) development does not result in a material increase in the extent or severity of natural hazards; and
d) for acid sulfate areas—the generation or release of acid and associated metal contaminants into the environment
is avoided

The amended Bushfire Assessment Report included within Attachment 9 details the potential fire risks of the site
and provides an assessment of bushfire hazard mitigation measures that have been incorporated into the design of
the Noosa on Weyba Locality Plan to ensure that people and property are not placed at an unacceptable risk of
harm in the event of a bushfire.

The proposed Noosa on Weyba development would increase the number of people living and working within an
area that contains substantial reserves of bushland that present a hazard to human health and property in the event
of a bushfire. As such it is a requirement of SPP 1/03 that the Noosa on Weyba development make appropriate
provision for bushfire hazard mitigation and management measures.

Due to the above, the proposed Noosa on Weyba Preliminary Approval Development will incorporate the following
recommendations made in the amended Bushfire Investigative Report regarding the appropriate provisions for the
mitigation and management of bushfire hazards:
     the establishment of appropriate building setbacks from areas of hazardous vegetation within and external
         to the site;
     a reticulated water supply with the capacity to service the bushfire and general fire fighting requirements
         for the proposed development;
     upgrading of the external road network to provide enhanced access to the Noosa on Weyba site locality for
         the deployment of fire management personnel and equipment, and evacuation of residents if required, in
         response to a bushfire event;
     an appropriate designed internal network of formed roadways and fire maintenance trails that will enable
         for the safe and efficient deployment of fire management personnel and equipment;
     an appropriate system of firebreaks comprised of roadways, maintenance trails and managed vegetation
         zones to separate hazardous vegetation from potential building sites; and
     ongoing maintenance and management of on-site an assessment of the post-development bushfire hazard
         levels that would exist within the Noosa on Weyba locality, completed in accordance with the bushfire
         hazard assessment guidelines provided for in State Planning Policy 1/03 Guideline – Mitigating the Adverse
         Impacts of Flood, Bushfire and Landslide

Regarding flood impact the proposed development of Noosa on Weyba has been shown through TUFLOW
modelling (see Section 3 of the amended Flood Study included in Attachment 13) to:
     have no adverse impacts on flood levels and flows for surrounding properties for local and regional flood
        events;
     reduce the 100 year ARI event the peak flood level around Lake Entrance Boulevard due to flow attenuation
        being proposed within the site;
     provide 100 year ARI trafficability for all proposed and upgraded roads;
     provide PMF evacuation routes for all areas of the site; and
     improve flood access for neighbouring properties.
                                                        40

Page 41

       The flood levels used to set the development levels for the site include the potential impact of climate
        change. The proposed filling within the site will reduce available flood storage, although compared to the
        available storage in Lake Weyba and the surrounding floodplain, the reduction is minimal. Flood modelling
        has shown that the impact of the reduced flood storage is contained within the site. Dense revegetation of
        the western drainage channel is considered to be achievable with acceptable flood impacts for the site and
        surrounding properties should this be desirable.
       Based upon the specialist investigations it is concluded that the proposal complies with the requirements
        of the Natural Hazards Landslide and Flooding Overlay.




   49       Provide a comprehensive response to the Natural Hazards Overlays Code Probable Solutions and, if
            these cannot be met, provide a comprehensive response to the Specific Solutions.

Response:

Section 5.1 of the Noosa on Weyba amended Bushfire Assessment Report (Attachment 9) provides an assessment
of the proposed development against the requirements of the Noosa Planning Scheme Natural Hazards Overlays
Code.


   50       Provide a detailed Fire Management Plan that adequately responds to the management of
            bushfire hazards and will mitigate the bushfire hazards within the site, should the Applicant be
            able to effectively respond to the Natural Hazard Overlays Code.

Response:

    The Noosa on Weyba amended Bushfire Assessment Report (Attachment 9) provides the relevant information
    concerning Bushfire Management as required by Noosa Planning Scheme Policy 1 which states that Council
    may require:
    a) A site specific assessment of bushfire risk prepared in accordance with Appendix 3 of the State Planning
        Policy 1/03 Guideline: Mitigating the Adverse Impacts of Flood, Bushfire and Landslide; and
    b) A Bushfire Management Plan prepared in accordance with Appendix 8 of the State Planning Policy 1/03
        Guideline: Mitigating the Adverse Impacts of Flood, Bushfire and Landslide.

   It is important to recognised that the current development application does not seek approval for a particular
   development layout. The indicative development layout considered in the Noosa on Weyba amended Bushfire
   Assessment Report (Attachment 15) is used for the purpose of demonstrating one potential means by which the
   development of the site could proceed whilst meeting relevant planning requirements. As noted in the Noosa
   on Weyba amended Bushfire Assessment Report, more detailed Bushfire Management Plans will be required to
   support development applications that seek approval for a particular development layout within a particular
   precinct. This approach is consistent with SPP 1/03 Appendix 8 – Undertaking a Bushfire Management Plan
   which recognises that “If the application must be followed by another application before works can commence
   (e.g. a Material Change of Use application that must be followed by a Reconfiguration of a Lot application), then
   matters of detail could be dealt with at the later application stage.”

   Information Required

   With respect to Lot 11 on SP250714, over which the Maroochy Plan is the relevant Planning Scheme,
   the documentation relating to bushfire hazard assessment has not responded to the relevant Code in the
   Maroochy Plan.

   51     Demonstrate how the application meets the overall outcomes of 2.1.6 Code for Development in
   Bushfire Hazard Areas.


                                                        41

Page 42

Response:

Overall outcomes
(2) The purpose of the Bushfire hazard overlay code will be achieved through the following overall outcomes:-
(a) development in areas at risk from bushfire hazard is compatible with the nature of the hazard;
(b) the risk to people, property and the natural environment from bushfire hazard is minimised;
(c) development does not result in a material increase in the extent or severity of bushfire hazard;
(d) the loss of vegetation through inappropriately located development is minimised;
(e) development is sited and designed to assist emergency services in responding to any bushfire threat.

The amended Bushfire Assessment Report included within Appendix 9 details the potential fire risks of the site and
an assessment of bushfire hazard mitigation measures has been incorporated into the design of the Noosa on
Weyba Locality Plan to ensure that people and property are not placed at an unacceptable risk of harm in the event
of a bushfire.

The proposed Noosa on Weyba development would increase the number of people living and working within an
area that contains substantial reserves of bushland that present a hazard to human health and property in the event
of a bushfire. As such it is a requirement of SPP 1/03 that the Noosa on Weyba development make appropriate
provision for bushfire hazard mitigation and management measures.

Due to the above, the proposed Noosa on Weyba Preliminary Approval Development will incorporate the following
recommendations made in the Cardno Bushfire Investigative Report regarding the appropriate provisions for the
mitigation and management of bushfire hazards:
     the establishment of appropriate building setbacks from areas of hazardous vegetation within and external
         to the site;
     a reticulated water supply with the capacity to service the bushfire and general fire fighting requirements
         for the proposed development;
     upgrading of the external road network to provide enhanced access to the Noosa on Weyba site locality for
         the deployment of fire management personnel and equipment, and evacuation of residents if required, in
         response to a bushfire event;
     an appropriate designed internal network of formed roadways and fire maintenance trails that will enable
         for the safe and efficient deployment of fire management personnel and equipment;
     an appropriate system of firebreaks comprised of roadways, maintenance trails and managed vegetation
         zones to separate hazardous vegetation from potential building sites; and
     ongoing maintenance and management of on-site an assessment of the post-development bushfire hazard
         levels that would exist within the Noosa on Weyba locality, completed in accordance with the bushfire
         hazard assessment guidelines provided for in State Planning Policy 1/03 Guideline – Mitigating the Adverse
         Impacts of Flood, Bushfire and Landslide

    52      Provide a comprehensive response to the Code for Development in Bushfire Hazard Areas Acceptable
            Solutions. If these cannot be met provide a comprehensive response to the Performance Criteria.

Response:

Section 5.2 of the Noosa on Weyba Bushfire Assessment Report (Attachment 9) provides an assessment of the
proposed development against the requirements of the Maroochy Plan Code for Development in Bushfire Hazard
Areas does not have any “overall outcomes”. Rather it has a number of Performance Criteria (PC) and Acceptable
Solutions (AS).

    53      Provide a detailed Fire Management Plan (as required by Element 1 of the Code) that provides
            adequate response to the management of bushfire hazards and will mitigate the bushfire hazards
            within the site, should the Applicant be able to effectively respond to the Code for Development in
            Bushfire Hazard Areas. Please see Planning Scheme Policy No. 13 for guidance in the preparation of
            the Bushfire Management Plan.

Response:
                                                        42

Page 43

The Noosa on Weyba amended Bushfire Assessment Report (Attachment 9) provides all of the information that is
required pursuant to Planning Scheme Policy No. 13, which also makes specific reference to State Planning Policy
1/03 –Mitigating the Adverse Impacts of Flood, Bushfire and Landslide (2003).

It is recognised that some more detailed Bushfire Management Plans will be required to support development
applications for specific precincts. This approach is consistent with SPP 1/03 Appendix 8 – Undertaking a Bushfire
Management Plan which recognises that “If the application must be followed by another application before works
can commence (e.g. a Material Change of Use application that must be followed by a Reconfiguration of a Lot
application), then matters of detail could be dealt with at the later application stage.”

    CIVIL ENGINEERING

    Issue
    Additional detail is required in regard to the proposed design and functionality of the internal road network.

    Information Required

    54      Provide additional detail in regard to the proposed public transport routes to and through the
            proposed development. The detail is to include:
    (a)     The routes through the development site
    (b)     The full extent of works necessary along Hollett Road and Tidswell Road to provide for the various
            vehicle types and road users (pedestrians, cyclists etc)
    (c)     Areas to be set aside for bus stops (including shelters, bike racks etc), setdown and turning
            areas
    (d)      TRANSLink approval to utilise those sections of the routes that are located within proposed
            common property areas
    (e)     Provide comment on the delineation between private and public infrastructure in regard to public
            access and ongoing maintenance responsibilities (roads, paths, carparking areas, parks etc)

    Response:

    R54(a) Additional information regarding the routes through the development site is included within Section
    4.1.1 and Figure 4-1 of the amended Traffic Assessment Report contained within Attachment 14.

    R54(b) The full extent of works necessary along Hollett Road and Tidswell Road to provide for the various
    vehicle types and road users (pedestrians, cyclists etc) will be provided as part of further approvals required. It
    is not considered logical to provide this information as part of the current Preliminary Approval proposal.

    R54(c) Areas to be set aside for bus stops (including shelters, bike racks etc), set down and turning areas will be
    provided as part of further approvals required. It is not considered logical to provide this information as part of
    the current Preliminary Approval proposal.

    R54(d) Translink approval to utilise those sections of the routes that are located within proposed common
    property areas will be obtained and subsequently provided to Council as part of further approvals required. It is
    not considered logical to provide this information as part of the current Preliminary Approval proposal.

    Council should note that the A1 Concept Master Plan (see Attachment 3) has incorporated all traffic
    considerations when providing the indicative design, to identify that all traffic aspects can be catered for on the
    subject site.

    R54(e) Comment on the delineation between private and public infrastructure in regard to public access and
    ongoing maintenance responsibilities (roads, paths, car parking areas, parks etc) is provided in the amended
    Civil Engineering Report in Attachment 8.



                                                          43

Page 44

    Issue
    Additional detail is required in regard to the proposed improvements to the external road and pathway
    networks.

    Information Required

    55      Demonstrate that the proposed improvements to the external road network (Walter Hay Drive) are
    achievable due to the existing property boundaries, other existing infrastructure and the existing topography.

    Response:

   The amended Engineering Report included in Attachment 8 and Cardno Sketch SK102 provides both an
   indicative layout of the proposed Walter Hay Drive Roundabout and also a justification into the location chosen
   based on the ability to provide an access point which does not significantly impact on the flora and fauna of the
   locality. And provides the most suitable location where an access can be constructed without the requirement
   for excessive earthworks. For further information please refer to Section 3.1.1 of the amended Engineering
   Report and Cardno Sketch SK102. It should also be noted that where required property boundaries will be re-
   aligned to cater for all new infrastructure.

    56      Demonstrate that the proposed connections from the proposed development to the external
            pathway network are:
    (a)     Of a suitable urban standard to service the proposed development (off-road and on-road only where
            applicable).
    (b)     Achievable due to the existing property boundaries, other existing infrastructure and the
            existing topography
    (c)     Include the consent of land owners that are affected by the works.

            Please note that the pathway network to service the development must be of a similar
            standard to that existing in the Noosaville locality with a similar catchment and connect to an
            existing pathway.

Response:

As part of initial investigations a “Regional Open Space & Recreation Study” was prepared by EA Design Group. A
detailed desk top and on site ground truthing exercise was undertaken to accurately map both existing and
proposed cycle and pedestrian pathway networks throughout the region surrounding the proposed Noosa on
Weyba development site. This was undertaken to ensure that the proposed Noosa on Weyba development
facilitated an improved network of connections not only east-west but north-south through the broader Sunshine
Coast area. The findings of the study concluded that the Noosa on Weyba site when developed would provide an
important role in linking pedestrians and cyclists north and south; as well as providing a valuable controlled link to
Lake Weyba and the National Park.

A comprehensive network of pedestrian and cycle trails are envisaged as part of the Noosa on Weyba residential
community with the aim to promote walking and cycling and therefore reducing the use of motor vehicles.
Wherever possible paths have been sited and planned along existing desire lines and sited to cause minimal impact
to sensitive ecological areas.

Please refer to Attachment 3 which includes the A1 Concept Master Plan, which identifies existing pedestrian cycle
network external to Noosa on Weyba Development, existing recreational trails to be retained and proposed shared
pedestrian or cycle paths (sealed). Additionally please refer to the Pedestrian Connectivity Overlay and Cycleway
Overlay included within the amended Urban Design Report (see Attachment 6).

    57      Justify why pathways throughout the development regularly terminate at roads with no
            continuation along the road verge or connectivity to other pathways within the site.

Response:
                                                         44

Page 45

For clarification of the above identified issue please refer to Section 4.1.2 of the amended Traffic Assessment Report
included in Attachment 14.

Additionally please refer to Attachment 3 which includes the A1 Concept Master Plan and the amended Urban
Design Report for further detail regarding the proposed positioning and purpose of pedestrian and cycle pathways
(see Attachment 6). Please note that all pathways shown on the Concept Master Plan are merely indicative and trail
design is subject to future development applications.


    58      Provide additional detail on the proposed flood free connection to Lake Entrance Boulevard. The
            detail must include:
                 (a)      The intent of link (does it provide for vehicles as well as pedestrians)
                 (b)      The proposed alignment
                 (c)      The design of the formation
                 (d)      The full extent of works (drainage, banks, batters etc)
                 (e)      The consent of land owners that are affected by the works

Response:

An improved flood access for neighbouring properties is possible to Lake Entrance Boulevard/Aspera Place. This is
not required for the proposed development, rather the flood free access as shown on SK100, is a proposed added
benefit to the neighbouring community as a result of the development of the subject site. This existing residential
area is landlocked during a Q2 event as shown on Figure 14 in the Cardno Flood Study (see Attachment 13). Details
of alignment and formation will be determined by Council as part of further approval as this access is not required
by this development. For further information regarding the flood free connection please refer to Section 4.2 of the
amended Engineering Report (see Attachment 8).

    59      Provide further detail in respect of land tenure and alignment for the proposed Hollett Road
            emergency access route.

Response:
The site’s primary access is the proposed roundabout on Walter Hay Drive, with a secondary access from the south
via Tidswell Road. An emergency access connection is also proposed from the west with connection via Hollett Road
to Eumundi-Noosa Road.

The alignment of the emergency access connection to Eumundi Road is contained within the alignment of the
existing track and therefore utilising the existing use of the track.

Please refer to the A1 concept Master Plan which outlines the proposed location of the emergency access route.
This has further been addressed in detail within the following amended Cardno Reports (Bushfire Assessment
Report [Attachment 9) & Traffic Report [Attachment 14]). Please note that further land tenure detail will form part
of any future Development Application over the land.

    Issue
    The proposed lot layout within the precincts does not provide the road alignments along the perimeter to
    provide for safe/effective protection and evacuation in the case of a bushfire
    emergency.

    Information Required

    60      Provide amended precinct plans that indicate road alignments to provide for safe/effective
            protection and evacuation in the case of a bushfire emergency. The alignments must be in
            accordance with Specific Outcome O12 of the Natural Hazards and Natural Resources Overlay
            Code of the Noosa Plan.

                                                         45

Page 46

Response:

Please note the current proposal relates to a Preliminary Approval and as such the road alignments within each
precinct will be confirmed as part of further reconfiguration approvals. To assist Council’s review of the potential
road alignments within each precinct please refer to Attachment 3 which includes the A1 Concept Master Plan. It is
anticipated that any further road design could be conditioned by Council to comply with Specific Outcome 012 of
the Natural Hazards and Natural Resources Overlay Code.


    SERVICES

    Issue
    The development requires the upgrade of the Noosa Heads Sewage Treatment Plan.

    Information Required

    61     Provide details of the nature and extent of upgrade works required to the Noosa Heads Sewage
    Treatment Plant to cater for the development.

Response:

Please refer to the attached revised Civil Engineering Report from Cardno included within Attachment 8 which
addresses the future works required to the Noosa Heads Sewage Treatment Plant. Further details are also included
in Section 6.4 and Appendix C and Appendix F of the amended Water Supply and Sewerage Analysis (see
Attachment 15).

    Issue
    The alignment of proposed water mains and sewer rising mains are located within private property, Parks
    and proposed open space areas.

    Information Required

    62      Provide additional detail on the alignment of the proposed water mains and sewer rising mains.
            The detail must demonstrate that the works are achievable and include:
                 (a)     The consent of land owners that are affected by the works
                 (b)     The delineation between private and public infrastructure

    Response:

    R62(a) Please refer to the attached revised Civil Engineering Report from Cardno included within Attachment 8
    which provides additional detail on the alignment of the proposed sewer and water reticulation in section 5.1
    and 6.1 respectively. Final alignments of proposed water and sewer mains will be located in road easements
    and public land to allow access. The alignment of the proposed DN150 rising main from the site will cross Noosa
    Civic land. Although it is noted that the development can be completed without any landowners consent if
    required, negotiations with Noosa Civic representatives is ongoing in regard to a permit to construct the rising
    main within their car park.

    R62(b) Refer to section 5.3 and 6.2 and sketch SK702 of the amended Engineering Report (see Attachment
    8)- Following discussions with Unitywater and Cardno’s experience on multiple developments of a similar
    nature, all infrastructure proposed for the development will be transferred to Unitywater in the first instance.
    Ongoing consultation with Unitywater in regard to the ownership of assets will result in an Infrastructure
    agreement which could be conditioned as part of any approval documentation. .

    Issue
    The alignment of proposed water mains and sewer rising mains are located within common property, Parks

                                                         46

Page 47

   and proposed open space areas.

   Information Required

   63       Provided confirmation from Unitywater regarding the agreed design of the proposed works – in
            particular their acceptance or otherwise of the proposed ―Alternative Treatment Options‖ which
            may have an environmental impact.

Response:

   The above issue has been addressed within the response to information request items 61 and 62. Please note
   the current proposal relates to a Preliminary Approval and as such the final design will be subject to Unity Water
   endorsement as part of further approvals required.

   Issue
   Much of the proposed Road 2 – Hollett Road connection between Tidswell Road and the proposed
   intersection with Walter Hay Drive is identified as having a 7.4 metre wide carriageway. This is not
   sufficient to safely operate within the prevailing speed environment (60km/h+) and does not adequately
   accommodate on-road cyclists (which is required in addition to any off-road shared path treatment). In order
   to reduce the amount of travel time spent by residents at low vehicle speeds, any collector street extending
   east of Tidswell Road to serve the proposed urban development will also be required to operate at a 60km/h
   speed environment (with a suitable carriageway width) until the furthest lot is not more than
   700 metres travel distance from such a collector street.

   Information Required

   64       Submit revised plans that provide for at least a 9.4 metre wide carriageway (or 5 metre wide
            carriageways in each direction for divided carriageways) on the section of the Road 2 – Hollett Road
            connection currently proposed as 7.4 metres wide.


   Response:

   Please refer to Attachment 3 which incorporates the A1 Concept Master Plan. This document includes an
   indicative road layout plan. Notwithstanding this it must be noted that the current proposal relates to a
   Preliminary Approval and as such no detailed road designs have been undertaken at this stage. It is suggested
   that this requirement would be addressed as part of further approvals required over the land. Nevertheless the
   amended Traffic Assessment Report included in Attachment 14 states in Section 4.3 that 1m cycle lanes are
   proposed to be provided in addition to 7.4m wide running lanes.

   It would also be amenable for Council to impose reasonable and relevant conditions as part of any Preliminary
   Approval which would guide the design of the future road network.



   65       Submit a revised layout for the proposed development east of Tidswell Road such that any
            collector street connecting this development to Tidswell Road is at least 9.4 metres wide and does
            not have direct lot access for as far as is necessary such that the furthest lot in the catchment will
            be not more than 700 metres travel distance from the end of this street type.

   Response:

   Please refer to Section 4.4 of the Amended Traffic Impact Assessment Report for justification of the proposed
   intersections. It should be noted that more detail regarding the proposed road network will be provided as part
   of the detailed design process required for future approvals.

   As with information request item 64, It would also be amenable for Council to impose reasonable and relevant
                                                        47

Page 48

conditions as part of any Preliminary Approval in order to guide the design of the future road network.

Issue
An off-road shared path exists on the western side of the Walter Hay Drive bridge over Eenie Creek to
the north of the proposed development. However, no pathway connection to this is proposed.

Information Required

66      Demonstrate how off-road pedestrian / cycle pathway access can be provided safely and efficiently
        between the development and the existing off-road shared path on the western side of the Walter
        Hay Drive bridge over Eenie Creek.

Response:

Please refer to Attachment 3 which incorporates the A1 Concept Master Plan, this document outlines an
indicative off road pedestrian and cycle pathway network that connects to the existing off-road shared path on
the western side of the Walter Hay Drive bridge over Eenie Creek.

Issue
Planning Horizon

It is understood from the application material that construction of the various development components is
intended to be staged over a number of years.

Information Required

67      The traffic planning horizon adopted should be ten years after the completion of the construction in
        accordance with normal practice.

Response:

The traffic assessment included in the amended Traffic Assessment Report in Attachment 14 has accounted for
2018 year of opening, and 2028 ten year design horizon, as explained at Section 5.2.

Issue
Travel Times on Walter Hay Drive

The travel time estimates included in the TIA are based on current traffic volumes and operating conditions,
except for some provision for activation of the southern Noosa Business Centre access intersection. No
assessment has been made of impacts in respect of future travel times (up to the planning horizon). This
is particularly relevant because traffic volumes are expected to increase more quickly on Walter Hay Drive
than on Eumundi Road, and the proposed site access roundabout is estimated to be the most congested
roundabout in the relevant network south of Eenie Creek.

Information Required

68     Provide assessments for future year operations.

Response:

Please refer to Section 3.2 of the amended Traffic Assessment Report for a brief summary of the access options
analysis, with the comprehensive report included in Appendix G of the report. Additionally an analysis of travel
time delays is included at Section 5.3 of the amended Traffic Assessment Report.

Issue
External Road Network Connectivity
                                                     48

Page 49

Section 3.2 of the TIA is an assessment of the site access options tested. However, the explanation of the
various options tested was incomplete (clearer diagrams would assist), and the options tested were
insufficient.

Information Required

69      Provide a comprehensive analysis of access options which would not necessitate speed limit
        reductions and intersection delays on Walter Hay Drive. Council officers would be available to
        discuss other site access options to ensure all relevant options are tested, particularly those which
        would not add to through traffic travel time on Walter Hay Drive.

Response:

A brief summary of the access options analysis is included at Section 3.2 of the amended Traffic Assessment
Report, with the comprehensive report included at Appendix G of this report (see Attachment 14 for a copy of
the amended Traffic Assessment Report). Analysis of travel time delays is included at Section 5.3 of the Traffic
Report.

Issue
The application refers to emergency vehicle access options for the Lake Entrance
Boulevard precinct.

Information Required

70      Further information is required to explain how this could function, taking account of both land
        tenure considerations and physical design considerations. It is noted that there is inconsistency in
        the location of this emergency access route in some of the supporting reports. Similarly, more
        details are necessary in respect of land tenure and alignment in respect of the proposed Hollett
        Road emergency access route.

Response:

Please refer to the amended Traffic report included within Attachment 14 and the amended Civil Engineering
Report included within Attachment 8 . All reports have been revised and amended to remove any inconsistency
regarding emergency access. The reports also provide further clarification in response to Council’s concerns
regarding the emergency access route.

Issue
Bus Route Planning
Section 3.4.1 discusses possible future bus public transport route options.

Information Required

71      Further information is requested in respect of any investigations of the feasibility and like frequency
        of service of such routes, particularly taking account of proposed dead-end routes.

Response:

In response to Council’s information request justification of the feasibility and frequency of possible future bus
public transport services such as routes has been included within Section 4.1.2 of the amended Traffic
Assessment Report included within Attachment 14.

Issue
Internal Road Network Planning

                                                     49

Page 50

              Section 3.6 of the TIA provides no traffic engineering assessment of the proposed internal road
              network. It is noted that these details are not provided in either the TIA or the civil engineering
              reports.

    Information Required

    72      Provide the following details:
    (a)      Justification for proposed adoption of cross sections and alignments contrary to Council‘s normal
            standards,
    (b)      Details of intersections and speed control devices, and
    (c)      Speed control mechanisms which adequately address the issues associated with long journey paths
            purported to occur at low operating speeds for environmental reasons. As a general rule, it cannot be
            reasonably expected that motorists will adopt low speeds (40 km/hour) for more than 60 to 90 seconds.
            Much longer low speed routes are currently proposed.

Response:

R72(a) Please refer to Section 4.2 of the amended Traffic Assessment Report for justification of the proposed
adoption of cross sections and alignments which do not necessarily replicate the normal standards as those
stipulated by Council.

R72(b) Please refer to Sections 4.4 and 4.6 of the of the amended Traffic Assessment Report for details regarding
proposed intersections and speed control devices to be implemented through the proposed road network.

R72 (c) Please refer to Section 4.5 and 4.6 of the amended Traffic Assessment Report for further information
regarding speed control mechanisms including the proposed location of round-abouts and T-junctions. Please note
that although more detail regarding proposed internal road network will be provided as part of future Development
Applications, they will be based upon the road network and development proposals envisage for the proposed
intersections, shown in Figure 4-3 of the amended Traffic Assessment Report.

    Issue
    Section 7.1 of the Planning Report describes what are perceived as a number of grounds, some of which
    may be based on traffic engineering considerations.

    Information Required

    73        Clarify which of the nominated grounds are based on traffic engineering considerations,
              together with any additional information in explanation considered necessary.

    Response:

   The following Noosa on Weyba benefits have been based or partially based on traffic considerations;

    The proposed roundabout on Walter Hay Drive will achieve the following:
        (a)     slow traffic speed down to 60kmph for a section of the road which will lower the incidents of ‘road
                kill’ of wildlife.
        (b)     Create an alternate access/ egress for residents in Hollett Road
        (c)     Lower the traffic speed on Walter Hay Drive which will in turn lower the road noise impact on
                Hollett Road residents

   The project will deliver sealed roads along the current dirt tracks in the Tidswell and part of Hollett Roads road
   reserves at no cost to the public

   Tidswell Road will be constructed to a ‘flood free’ standard which will provide existing residents along this road
   with flood free access
                                                         50

Page 51

An extension of the Noosa cycleway system will be provided at no cost to the public, which will substantially
enhance cycle and walkway access to the National Park and Lake Weyba, and create an alternative cycleway
route off Walter Hay Drive to Noosaville

The project will allow for flood free emergency access / egress from the dwellings along Lake Entrance Boulevard
to the north of the subject site that currently get “cut off” in medium flood conditions.

INTEGRATED TRANSPORT NETWORK UNIT

Issue
Pedestrian Networks

Information Required

74      Based on the average person walking 80m per minute, please demonstrate the walkability of the
site between internal and external origins and attractors. In non-recreational c i r c u m s t a n c e s , a d u l t s
are typically          only comfortable walking for between 5 to 20 minutes, with children only
comfortable to walk for between 5 to 15 minutes.

Response:

Please refer to Attachment 3 and 6 which include the A1 Concept Master Plan and amended Urban Design
Report which considered the walkability of the site between internal and external origins and attractors. Whilst
the A1 Concept Master Plan is simply an indication of what could be developed it identifies a logical and useable
pedestrian network. Detailed analysis and assessment of all pedestrian networks will be undertaken as part of
further approvals required.

Issue
Cycle facilities

Information Required

75       Demonstrate that safe on-road and off-road cycling facilities will be provided between the
         development site and existing infrastructure in the surrounding urban areas. At-grade road
         crossings must be avoided (i.e. road crossings for pedestrians and cyclists must be achieved by
         underpasses that meet best practice).

Response:

Please refer to Attachment 3 and 6 which include the A1 Concept Master Plan and amended Urban Design
Report which considered cycle facilities between the development site and existing infrastructure in the
surrounding urban areas. Whilst the A1 Concept Master Plan is simply an indication of what could be developed
it identifies a logical and useable cycle network. Detailed analysis and assessment of all pedestrian networks will
be undertaken as part of further approvals required.

Issue
The proposal appears to place an over reliance on the existing on-road cycle network to provide active
transport mode-shift outcomes for the development. On-road cycle lanes generally service the needs of sport
and advanced commuter cyclists, not the needs of less confident cyclists or recreational/family cyclists that
could be expected from the proposed residential development.

Information Required

76       In accordance with Austroads there are concerns over the safety to cyclists from the development, as
         Walter Hay Drive carries very high traffic volumes (9,500-13,000 vpd according to Traffic Impact
                                                        51

Page 52

             Assessment by Cardno) at very high speeds (80- 100km/h). Austroads suggests that the
             combination of these high volumes and high speeds warrant segregated cycling facilities (not-on-
             road facilities). In this regard, please indicate the exact route that will be taken for the segregated
             facility highlighting any land resumptions that may be necessary and any infrastructure needed to
             support this, such as underpasses/overpasses and any bridges.

Response:
Proposed shared facilities for Noosa on Weyba are shown within Attachment 3 A1 Concept Master Plan. This
indicative plan provides a preliminary cycleway design addressing Council’s concerns. Please note however that the
final concept would be subject to detailed design as part of further approvals required.

    Issue
    Multi-lane roundabouts provide a high risk to pedestrians and cyclists, which combined with high traffic
    volumes and approach speeds could be extremely dangerous for residents of the proposed development.
    Such arrangements would severely limit Active Transport objectives for the development.

    Information Required

    77      Demonstrate how pedestrians and cyclists will be able to safely cross all major roads and
            intersections (including the underpass) impacted upon by the subject development, but primarily
            the multi-lane roundabout on Walter Hay Drive. Details of levels, alignments of approach and
            departure routes, etc. should be provided.

Response:
Please refer to Attachment 6 which includes the amended Urban Design Report. A specific plan within the report
addressing ‘Open Space, Road and Mobility (Pedestrian And Cycle)’ demonstrates desired pedestrian connections,
existing recreational trails, proposed cycleway extension and existing off road shared path (cycleway and pedestrian
path). Whilst detailed design of this infrastructure will be undertaken as part of further approvals, the preliminary
analysis has concluded that pedestrians and cyclists will be able to safely cross all major roads and intersections.

    Issue
    Flood immunity of pathway network

    Information Required

    78      Demonstrate that all pathways and segregated cycling facilities will achieve a minimum flood
            immunity equivalent or greater than a 1 in 20 year Average Recurrence Interval. Should this
            not be reasonably achievable in all areas please outline where and why this cannot be achieved
            and provide information on the level of immunity that can be achieved.

Response:

Please refer to the amended Cardno Flood Report report included within Attachment 13 which confirms that all
pathways and segregated cycling facilities could achieve an acceptable level of flood immunity. Please note that
detailed design of this infrastructure would be logically undertaken as part of further approvals required.

We would anticipate in this instance that appropriate conditions could be imposed as part of any approval regarding
flood immunity for pathways and segregated cycling facilities.

    Issue
    Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED)

    Information Required

    79      Demonstrate that CPTED issues will be addressed for all pathways and public spaces.

                                                          52

Page 53

Response:

This information request item is not considered to be applicable as detailed design of the pathways is yet to
occur. This is an issue which would reasonably be considered as part of further approvals required.

We would anticipate in this instance that appropriate conditions could be imposed as part of any approval
regarding CPTED for pathways and public spaces.

Issue
Vehicle accessibility

Information Required

80       Illustrate how larger vehicles, such as trucks and buses will safely manoeuvre throughout the
         site in a forward gear, with a specific focus on public transport buses.

Response:

As part of further approvals required to enable development to commence onsite roads will be designed to a
sufficient standards for the appropriate vehicles entering and exiting the development. Attachment 3 which
includes A1 Concept Master Plan provides an indicative road layout which has considered a public transport
network through the site.

In this instance it is anticipated appropriate conditions would be generated as part of any approval to ensure
future design considered specific vehicle movements through the site.

Issue
Walter Hay Drive was designed as a limited access road with the primary intention to move traffic quickly,
efficiently and safely with no intention for further intersections.

Information Required

81       Provide justification as to why Council should change its long term road network planning for
         the area as the development appears to increase the level of risks and likelihood of accidents
         either between vehicles and/or between vehicles and pedestrians/cyclists.

Response:

The amended Traffic Impact Assessment Report, included as Attachment 14, provides a number of access
options for the Noosa on Weyba development. Section 3 of the report outlines details of Access ‘Options’ for
the site. Each option is considered in detail as part of a standardised table of advantages and disadvantages.
Based on the detailed analysis option 6 within this section of the traffic report has been concluded as scoring
the best without having any major design flaws. This option had the following access elements:
     > Roundabout access to Walter Hay Drive
     > Road access to Tidswell Road
     > No underpass connecting the east and west of the development under Walter Hay Drive.

82       Provide further justification as to why access to the eastern portions of the site (i.e. east of Walter
         Hay Drive to Precincts 1, 2 and the eastern portion of Precinct 3) cannot be achieved via the existing
         roundabout at Emu Mountain Road / Walter Hay Drive / Eumarella Road via Tidwell Road.

Response:




                                                     53

Page 54

   The proposed access arrangement is explained in Section 3.3.2 of the amended Traffic Impact Assessment
   Report, with clarification on the proposed Tidswell Road extension specifically addressed paragraph 2. The
   access arrangement is also described within Section 2.1.1 of the report.


   83       Provide further justification as to why access to the western portions of the site (i.e. west of Walter
            Hay Drive to the western portion of Precinct 3) cannot be achieved via Eumundi Noosa Road and
            Old Hollett Road, as Council is not satisfied with the present proposal and believes a better Active
            Transport outcome would be achieved by not providing direct vehicle access into the site as
            proposed. To this end, walking or cycling becomes more viable if the trip length is shorter than
            motorised vehicle trips.

Response:

   The A1 Concept Master Plan included within Attachment 3, indicates that a shared pedestrian/bicycle
   connection will extend along Hollett Road to Eumundi-Noosa Road.

   In respect to Councils concerns due to the interference of Old Growth Trees a substantial proportion of Old
   Hollet road will not be constructed. Justification for not providing vehicle access is provided in Section 3.3.2, and
   Appendix G of the amended Traffic Impact Assessment Report (see Attachment 14).

   84       Old Hollett Road presently contains an underpass under Walter Hay Drive that connects to
            Tidswell Road. Provide justification why this connection should not be enhanced to provide the
            major road connection between the eastern and western portions of the development site, as
            opposed to direct access to the site off Walter Hay Drive.

   Response:

   Section 3 of the report outlines details of Access ‘Options’ for the site. Each option is considered in detail as part
   of a standardised table of advantages and disadvantages. From a traffic and transport perspective the optimum
   access strategy was found to be a tie between options 5A and 6A. These options shared the following elements
   to their access strategies:
        > Roundabout access to Walter Hay Drive
        > Road access to Tidswell Road
        > Underpass connecting the east and west of the development under Walter Hay Drive.

   However, due to engineering costs and ecological constraints the Walter Hay Drive underpass was not
   considered viable by the design team.

   Further justification is provided throughout Sections 5.2 and 5.3 of the amended Traffic Impact Assessment
   Report.

   Based on the detailed analysis option has been concluded as scoring the best without having any major design
   flaws. This option had the following access elements:
        > Roundabout access to Walter Hay Drive
        > Road access to Tidswell Road
        > No underpass connecting the east and west of the development under Walter Hay Drive.
   Issue
   Potential future duplication of Walter Hay Drive

   Information Required

   85       Walter Hay Drive has been considered for future duplication, demonstrate how the development
            will take this into consideration. Allowance must be made for road reserve dedications and
            separation of the proposed residential development from the road corridor.


                                                          54

Page 55

Response:

Further to discussions with Council it is not considered that there is a current requirement to duplicate Walter
Hay Drive. Cardno met with Council officers to obtain plans showing this duplication, but Council advised there
is no plan indicating this duplication at present. This road is not controlled by DTMR and therefore the design
team has concluded that there is no requirement for future duplication and subsequent dedications. As such it
is not considered reasonable or relevant to consider a duplication within the design as part of the current
Preliminary Approval.

HYDROLOGY & WATER QUALITY FLOODING

Issue
For PMF events trafficability has been assumed if the depth is less than 400mm with a DV product of
0.45m2/s. Insufficient justification has been provided to confirm that this depth and DV product is
acceptable for emergency vehicles to access the site.

Information Required

86      Provide confirmation from the Queensland Government Department of Community Safety that the
          proposed traffic ability criteria are acceptable for emergency vehicles.

Response:
During PMF events, access for emergency vehicles would be required. These vehicles are typically larger than
standard vehicles and so can handle greater flow depths across roads. Based on Project 10 of Australian Rainfall
and Runoff (AR&R): Appropriate Safety Criteria for Vehicles (2011), large 4WDs can cross roads with maximum
depths of 500mm, with a limiting dV product of 0.6 m2/s. Large passenger cars can cross roads with maximum
depths of 400mm, with a limiting dV product of 0.45 m2/s. For PMF events trafficability was therefore
conservatively assumed if the depth was less than 400mm with a dV product of 0.45 m2/s.

The Queensland Department of Community Safety was contacted regarding the traffic ability criteria used for
emergency vehicles. They advised that scenarios were assessed on a case by case basis and that a specific
guideline was not used. However, it should be noted that the AR&R project references the Emergency
Management Australia (EMA) manual for emergency vehicle 4WD operation that states that “if water reaches to
the bumper bar or higher, upon entering the water accelerate until a bow wave forms in front of the vehicle.
Maintain this bow wave at all costs, to keep water out of the engine.” In water depths of greater than 750mm, it
is suggested that either a snorkel extension to the engine air inlet and exhaust system is fitted or a canvas sheet
or tarp is placed across the grille to prevent water entering the engine bay.”

For similar developments in Brisbane a maximum depth of 500mm and dV product of 0.6 m2/s has been utilised
to determine PMF trafficability for emergency vehicles. This is based on the Brisbane City Council (BCC)
Subdivision and Development Guidelines (2008), Chapter 1 Part A which states that with flood depths less than
500mm and a dV product less than 0.6 m2/s, that evacuation of persons and possessions via trucks is possible
and that fit adults can wade through floodwaters.

Please refer to Section 7.2.1 of the amended Flood Study (see Attachment 13) for further detail regarding this
matter.

Issue
A sensitivity analysis has been undertaken to determine the impact of culvert blockage. In accordance with
QUDM; 20% blockage of the proposed culverts has been considered. 20% culvert blockage is considered
suitable in situations where there is a relief overland flowpath which will function prior to houses being
inundated. However, the proposed minimum road level of 4.00m AHD for the Northern Keyser Creek
Crossing means that proposed floor levels on upstream lots will be inundated prior to any relief overland
flowpath beginning to function.

Information Required
                                                      55

Page 56

87       Demonstrate that the proposal is accordance with the Performance Outcomes of the Code for
         Integrated Water Management, Specifically, demonstrate that the safety of people on the site is
         maintained and potential damage to property on the site is minimised.

Response:

     Since the original application was prepared and submitted, the location of the access road to the Lot 11 site
     has been relocated to the southern boundary. It has been offset from this boundary to minimise flood
     impacts to the neighbouring properties. This road crossing is now located upstream of Areas F and G within
     the flood study, and so blockage of culverts would have minimal impact to these proposed lots.

     The results of the analysis showed that even with complete blockage of all proposed culverts that sufficient
     flood immunity is provided for all of the proposed lots. However, the increase upstream of the Keyser
     Creek crossing is significant, as the minimum road level (3.83 mAHD) had to be set high enough to maintain
     traffic ability during a regional PMF event. This could potentially exacerbate existing flooding issues for
     some upstream properties, which has been further analysed as below:

     A range of blockage factors was trialled, to look at the potential impact at comparison points H0, H1, H2
     and H3 which are located upstream of the site in Keyser Creek. The results are shown in the table below.

     Sensitivity Analysis – Culvert Blockage




     The results show that there is minimal impact upstream, even with 50 percent blockage of the culverts. If
     the blockage factor is increased to 80 percent then there is a significant impact directly upstream of the
     culverts, however, the impact is significantly reduced before it affects areas where there are existing
     properties (H0 and H1). It is only when there is 100 percent blockage of the culverts that upstream
     properties are negatively impacted upon.

     It is considered that this situation is extremely unlikely given the large size of the proposed culverts (flow
     area totalling 32.4 m2) and the low flow velocities in the area. However, in order to reduce the likelihood
     of blockage it is proposed to install debris deflector walls on the culvert inlets for the southern crossing of
     Keyser Creek. An example of debris deflector walls is shown in Figure 10.07 of QUDM (2007). The purpose
     of the debris deflector walls is to allow built up debris to rise with the flood waters, allowing flows to pass
     underneath.

     Project 11 of AR&R: Blockage of Hydraulic Structures (2013) details the levels of blockage that should be
     considered for culvert crossings. Table 3.16 summarises the proposed blockage values that should be used
     for various types of culverts. For culverts with effective debris control measures, such as debris deflector
     walls, the design blockage is 10 percent and the severe blockage amount is 25 percent. Given that even
     with 80 percent blockage there is minimal impact to upstream properties, the provision of debris deflector
     walls is considered to sufficiently reduce any increased flood risk to upstream properties resulting from the
     proposed development.

     For further information regarding the above item please refer to Section 8.4.3 of the amended Flood Study
     (see Attachment 13).

                                                      56

Page 57

   Issue
   With respect to loss of floodplain storage it is stated in the Flood Study that the loss of flood storage within
   the site is minor when compared to the surrounding floodplain and Lake Weyba. The cumulative
   impact of all sites within the Noosa River and Lake Weyba floodplain being developed with a loss of
   floodplain storage has however not been considered. In such a large catchment area it is the cumulative
   impact rather than site specific impact of lost floodplain storage which is of concern. In addressing this issue a
   revised Flood Study considering the cumulative impact of loss of floodplain storage on other sites is not the
   intention because continued loss of floodplain storage is not the Strategic Plan for either the former Noosa or
   Maroochy Council areas.

   Information Required

   88       Provide revised plans for the development which achieve no loss of regional floodplain
            storage.

Response:

   In response to Council’s information request, a cumulative flood assessment was conducted to look at the
   potential impact of filling in flood affected residential areas, limited development areas and rural use areas that
   have been predominantly cleared (similar to the area of filling proposed on site). The existing Noosa Airport and
   sportsgrounds on Weyba Road were also filled. The 100 year ARI flood inundation extent was taken from SCRC
   mapping. The volume of fill assessed was more than 14 times that proposed for the site.

   The results showed that there was a negligible increase (maximum of 5mm) in regional flood levels as they are
   dominated by the storm surge levels within the Noosa River. Filling of the low-lying areas around Noosa River
   and Lake Weyba would have minimal impact on storm surge levels, which are expected to further increase with
   the impact of climate change. However, filling to the extent modelled would not be achievable, as it is likely that
   there would be impacts on local flood levels for neighbouring areas. Therefore the scenario modelled is a
   conservative overestimation of the achievable fill within the catchment area.

   Due to the unique location of the site, where the upstream properties are located at higher surface levels, and
   the provision of suitably sized waterway corridors within the site, filling has resulted in negligible impact for
   surrounding properties for both the regional and local flood events. For some surrounding areas the flood levels
   have actually been improved.

   For further information regarding the above item please refer to Section 9 of the amended Flood Study
   (Attachment 13).

   Coastal Management

   Issue
   The Draft Coastal Protection State Planning Regulatory Provision Protecting the Coastal Environment (Draft
   SPRP) states that to the extent practicable, erosion prone areas are to remain undeveloped apart from
   acceptable temporary or relocatable structures for safety and recreational purposes. The QCP Access to the
   eastern portion of the Northbrook site and Lake Weyba can be achieved without passing through the revised
   erosion prone area.

   Information Required

   89       Provide revised plans for the development which to the extent practicable leave erosion prone
            areas of the site undeveloped.

   Response:

   Since the original application was properly made the access to the eastern portion of the site has been

                                                         57

Page 58

relocated so that it lies outside of the revised erosion prone area.

A pedestrian track and fire trail will still be provided along the northern boundary of Lot 11 in the Hollett Road
reserve. The existing track in this area is a gravel road with small pipe culverts that restrict tidal flows. The
upgraded pedestrian track will replace the culverts with larger ones and so reduce the restriction to tidal flows
in this area. This will result in improvement to the coastal wetland area located upstream of the track.

Section 3.2.2 (2) of the Coastal Protection SPRP states:
“Where buildings and structures exist within an erosion prone area, any future development of the land must
not be at a greater intensity than the existing development unless it can be clearly demonstrated that the
development would not compromise coastal management outcomes and principles.”

It is considered that the proposed pedestrian track and fire trail is not an intensification of the existing use.
Regardless of this, the proposed crossing of the track will improve the tidal flushing in the area and improve
coastal management outcomes.

Stormwater Quality

Issues
The Stormwater Management Plan (Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd, Stormwater Management Plan, Job Ref. 5101/19-
03) has been evaluated and the following are the concerns that need to be addressed prior to any approval.

            There are concerns regarding the location of bio-retention devices in the proposed buffer to
             Lake Weyba on lot 11 where 10 metres of the proposed 50 metre wide buffer will be used
             for these devices. This also applies to other areas associated with the proposal where bio-
             retention devices are proposed to be located in rehabilitated waterway buffer and open space
             areas.

    Response:

    The role that elements such as bio-retention basins and swales play in increasing the effectiveness of
    wetland buffers is specifically recognised in the Queensland Wetland Buffer Planning Guideline (DERM,
    2011) and other relevant planning guidelines. The location of these elements has been situated to ensure
    that they do not impact on areas of ecological significance. As stated in the amended Stormwater
    Management Plan (see Attachment 16) the proposed lake buffer width is 40 metres and the stormwater
    treatment zone is an additional 10 metres. Existing trees within this zone will not be removed. All
    stormwater treatment devices will be located outside of the 100 year ARI extent of inundation. The
    development plans have been amended to ensure that the proposed stormwater treatment devices within
    the development footprint.

    All stormwater treatment devices will be located outside of the 100 year ARI extent of inundation. The
    development plans have been amended to ensure that the proposed stormwater treatment devices within
    the development footprint.

            MUSIC modelling has been carried out on the assumption that rainwater storage tanks will
             be installed onsite. This may be the intention at this point in time however State Government is
             amending the QDC to remove the mandatory requirement for these tanks. Furthermore, the
             Government may not allow local authorities to pursue this requirement through their planning
             instruments. It is envisaged that as a minimum, the local authority requiring storage tanks for a
             proposed development will need to at least justify this requirement. MUSIC modelling therefore
             needs to be carried out based on the assumption that no rainwater storage tanks will be installed
             on each lot.


    Response:


                                                      58

Page 59

Section 8.3 of the Stormwater Management Plan amended addresses this item.

The MUSIC analysis was re-run to determine the increase in bio-retention treatment size that would be
required to compensate for the loss of the rainwater tanks and still meet the stormwater quality
objectives. As the proposed development has targeted a higher level of treatment than typically required,
the increase required was not as significant as that necessary for similar developments. It was found that if
the bio- retention filter media area in the basins and swales was increased by 25 percent then the WQOs
could be met. The exception was for areas F and G, where a 50 percent increase in the bio-retention
gardens was required. It would also be necessary to drain the roof areas to the road, rather than directly to
underground drainage. The resultant load removal for the combined site was 83% for TSS, 60% for TP and
48% for TN.

 While the water quality objectives can be met if the bio-retention areas are increased, it is still
recommended that rainwater tanks be adopted on site. The proposed development aims to promote the
use of ecologically sensitive design and the use of rainwater tanks plays an important role in this regard. As
this will be a Body Corporate development there will be more control available on the development
conditions for each lot. The use of rainwater tanks will significantly reduce the water demand of the site
(by up to 53%), reduce stormwater flows being discharged off-site and allow the remaining treatment
devices to be better target utilised treating ground and road runoff, rather than relatively clean roof runoff.



       It is proposed to combine a detention function within several bio-retention devices. Whilst it is
        claimed that more information about these devices will be provided at the detailed design phase,
        the main concerns with this approach is the viability of combining detention with bio-retention
        where vegetation could be drowned by prolonged periods of rainfall.

Response:

The use of bio-retention within detention basins is standard practice. The extended detention zone will
not be different to that of bio-retention basins, and the area will be planted with suitable plants that can
tolerate prolonged periods of ponding. Only the bio-retention zone within the basin will experience
prolonged periods of ponding. The remainder of the basin will be located at a higher level and function
similar to a traditional detention basin.

The outlets of the basins will be suitably sized using a program such as XP-SWMM to show that sufficient
attenuation of peak flows can be provided for all storm events. The bio-retention extended detention
zone will be assumed to be full, as antecedent rainfall may fill this storage volume prior to the peak storm
event occurring.

 The Healthy Waterways MUSIC Modelling Guidelines (2010) state that when bio-retention is incorporated
into the base of a retarding basin, that the volume above the top of the extended detention depth should
not be included in the model for water quality assessment. Flood storage was not included in the
stormwater quality modelling. BCC practice notes for bio-retention basins also state that they can be
incorporated into retarding basins.

Off-line detention basins have only been proposed for catchments E3, F7 and F8. These are the
catchments that drain directly to Eenie Creek and its tributaries. The other catchments that drain to
Keyser Creek or Eenie Creek will have “on-line” attenuation of peak flows for all storm events provided by
the proposed culvert crossings. The results of this assessment are summarised in Section 8.2 and
Appendix G of the amended Flood Study (see Attachment 13). Refer to comparison points Q3, Q5 and EC4
in Table G3 to compare the existing and developed case peak flows. The flood modelling that was
conducted for the developed case assumed that all of the site had developed case inflows (i.e. increased
due to the greater impervious areas), except for catchments E3, F7 and F8, as these flows will be reduced
to existing case levels by the proposed detention basins. The details of these basins will be determined at
the detailed design stage. Although Precinct H drains to a point in Keyser Creek downstream of the
proposed culvert crossings, the over-attenuation provided by these crossings is sufficient to ensure that

                                                 59

Page 60

     peak flows are not increased. It should be noted that the attenuation that will be provided by the bio-
     retention basins and rainwater tanks has not been included in the flooding analysis. These will provide
     some additional attenuation, particularly for the minor storm events. Therefore the developed case peak
     flows that have been modelled are a conservative assumption. Appropriate erosion and scour control
     measures will be required on all outlets and culvert crossings.



            Lake Weyba Water Quality Objectives (WQOs) are provided and it‘s further mentioned
             that Healthy Waterways undertakes regular monitoring under an Ecosystem Health Monitoring
             Program. It is further claimed in relation to this that MUSIC modelling (for the WSUD)
             background concentrations can be higher in some instances than the WQOs (eg background
             Total P concentration in bio-retention systems is assumed to be 130 µg/L, >WQO concentration)
             and therefore concentration based WQOs cannot be determined through MUSIC modelling.
             From this, the consultant recommends that the results from water quality monitoring carried out
             by the Healthy Waterways be used to determine whether there is an impact from the
             development.

             Whilst these results can be used, the applicant will need to be responsible by implementing an
             appropriately tailored water monitoring program as the Healthy Waterways monitoring may
             not suit the specifics of the proposal and cannot be relied on to continue for the life of the
             development especially where a State Government could either halt or reduce funding for such
             programs.

     Response:

     Section 5.3 of the amended Stormwater Management Plan addresses this item (see Attachment 16). A
     monitoring program has been proposed for the site so that the existing water quality parameters can be
     defined, and the effectiveness of the proposed stormwater treatment devices can be established.

Information Required

90       Provide information including revised MUSIC modelling results, amended plans and all relevant
         details that demonstrate the above issues have been addressed.

     Response:

     Section 8.3 of the Stormwater Management Plan amended addresses this item.

     The MUSIC analysis was re-run to determine the increase in bio-retention treatment size that would be
     required to compensate for the loss of the rainwater tanks and still meet the stormwater quality
     objectives. As the proposed development has targeted a higher level of treatment than typically required,
     the increase required was not as significant as that necessary for similar developments. It was found that if
     the bio- retention filter media area in the basins and swales was increased by 25 percent then the WQOs
     could be met. The exception was for areas F and G, where a 50 percent increase in the bio-retention
     gardens was required. It would also be necessary to drain the roof areas to the road, rather than directly to
     underground drainage. The resultant load removal for the combined site was 83% for TSS, 60% for TP and
     48% for TN.

      While the water quality objectives can be met if the bio-retention areas are increased, it is still
     recommended that rainwater tanks be adopted on site. The proposed development aims to promote the
     use of ecologically sensitive design and the use of rainwater tanks plays an important role in this regard. As
     this will be a Body Corporate development there will be more control available on the development
     conditions for each lot. The use of rainwater tanks will significantly reduce the water demand of the site
     (by up to 53%), reduce stormwater flows being discharged off-site and allow the remaining treatment
     devices to be better target utilised treating ground and road runoff, rather than relatively clean roof runoff.

                                                      60

Page 61

Acid Sulphate Soils

Issues
An ASS assessment has been provided and evaluated (Cardno Bowler Pty Ltd, Geotechnical
                                      th
Investigation: 6. ASS Assessment, 25 June 2012). Whilst the number of boreholes on site do not meet the
QASSIT Guidelines particularly on lot 53 where only 2 boreholes were dug (ie 2holes/ha if the site is >4ha (Site
area = 93.1 ha)), the results from testing 16 samples show that there is a presence of ASS material in soils to a
depth commensurate with the envisaged works at this stage (0.0 – 1.5metres).

The consultant has also acknowledged that further sampling and testing needs to be carried out when the
nature and area of disturbance is determined. From this an ASS Management Plan will be formulated.

It is considered, that due to the sensitivity of the surrounding environment (eg Lake Weyba), a full ASS
assessment carried out in accordance with the latest guidelines needs to be provided prior to any approval.

Information Required

91       A full ASS assessment needs to be provided prior to any approval demonstrating that there will
         not be any impacts to any nearby sensitive ecosystems. The assessment needs to be carried
         out in accordance with the following guidelines:

(i)     The State Planning Policy Guideline 2/02: Planning and Managing Development involving Acid
          Sulphate Soils published by the Qld Department of Natural Resources and Water;
(ii)     QASSIT: Guidelines for Sampling & Analysis of Lowland Acid Sulphate Soils (ASS) in Queensland 1998,
          published by the Department of Natural Resources and Water; and
(iii)      The Queensland Acid Sulphate Soil Technical Manual: Soil Management Guidelines Version 3.8,
          published by the Department of Natural Resources and Water.

         The ASS assessment as a minimum needs to include a plan showing location of boreholes, works
         details (eg depths of excavation and quantities of fill), bore logs, sampling regime/results of testing
         for the presence or absence of ASS including justification for any reduced sampling regime, a
         groundwater analysis and detailed interpretation if necessary. It needs to also include the necessary
         measures for managing ASS (if found) and groundwater on site. If excavated material requires
         treatment, full details of where it is to be treated is required as well as proposed haulage routes.

Response:

Following discussions with Council, it was agreed to provide a preliminary Acid Sulphate Soil (ASS) Assessment to
ensure the strategy for dealing with ASS with consideration to groundwater on the site. Please refer to section
2.6 and preliminary ASSMP in Appendix F of the amended Engineering Report (see Attachment 8).

A final ASSMP can only be completed upon knowing the lot layout and hence earthworks which can only be
completed in future applications.

In this instance it is anticipated Council would impose an appropriately worded condition regarding the
requirement for a detailed ASSMP as part of any approval package.

Issues
A preliminary Erosion and Sediment Control Plan is required demonstrating that no impacts will occur from
works during the bulk earthworks and construction phases. This is due to the proximity of Lake Weyba,
topography, soil type, and scale of works.

Information Required

92       A conceptual ESC Plan needs to be submitted prior to any approval and needs to address the
                                                     61

Page 62

         following:

         a) demonstrate that the design, intensity, configuration and establishment of development, is
         compatible with the physical constraints of the site and receiving environment
         b) includes a contoured site plan showing natural features and location of the proposed control
         structures, including sediment basins, ESC treatment train and an overview strategy for the site
         outlining the sequence of development, and temporary and permanent management mechanisms
         with an emphasis on site stabilisation to prevent erosion in the first instance, until commissioning
         of permanent water sensitive urban design features and addresses the following:

                I.       Sediment basins:
                         -         are nominated for treatment of stormwater runoff from all areas which are
                         proposed for clearing, earthworks, stockpiling or otherwise exposed soils.
                         -         are appropriately sized based on a Type D basin (preliminary
                         calculations are provided and based on SCRC Manual or IECA)
                         -         are located:
                                   o         outside of waterways and flood prone areas (at least the 1 in 2
                                             year ARI level)
                                   o         where the basin will not be inundated by groundwater
                                   o         other than in areas of retained vegetation
                                   o         on topography where they are capable of being constructed (eg
                                             not on steep slopes)
         II.    In areas of the site where a sediment basin is not feasible, compensatory erosion and
                                   sediment controls, which are capable of achieving the stormwater release
                                   limit, are nominated.
         III.    The proposed extent of vegetation clearing is limited to that necessary to undertake the
                                   works.
         IV.    Clearly identifies the proposed extent of soil disturbance and provides indicative staging of
                                   the proposed construction activities such that the area of soil exposed at any
                                   one time will be minimised.
         V.                        Proposed clean upslope stormwater diversions around or through the site
                                   are indicated. Alternatively, if it is not feasible to divert clean water around
                                   or through the site, the Plan indicates how the additional volume of
                                   stormwater runoff will be managed.
         VI.                       Proposed concentrated flow paths for conveying contaminated stormwater
                                   are indicated

Response:

Further to Council’s information request, the aim of the Erosion and Sediment Control Plan (ESCP) (Appendix E
of the amended Engineering Report [Attachment 8]) is to provide performance criteria, strategies and
procedures to assist in minimising the impact of construction activities on the physical and social environment.

An ESCP has been prepared with reference to the ‘Best Practice Erosion and Sediment Control (2008)’ guidelines
published by the International Erosion Control Association (IECA) Australasia, and current local best practice
engineering and environmental management.

The objective is to control soil erosion on the site and prevent sediment discharge to downstream local water
courses or road stormwater drainage systems during storm events for the construction phase of the project.

Please refer to section 2.6 and preliminary ESCP in Appendix E of the amended Engineering Report (see
Attachment8) for further information regarding ESCP’s.

Please note that a final ESCP can only be completed upon knowing the lot layout and hence earthworks which
can only be completed as part of future applications.
In this instance it is anticipated Council would impose an appropriately worded condition regarding the
requirement for a final ESCP as part of any approval package.
                                                        62

Page 63

    Issue
    The site will be subject to significant impact by biting insects (mosquitoes, biting midge) at times,
    particularly during Summer.

    Information Required

    93      It is requested that the applicant clearly demonstrate how the development will be sited and
            designed to minimise the risk to public health, from insect borne arbovirus, and nuisance caused by
            biting insects. In demonstrating the above the applicant is requested to provide a mosquito and
            biting midge report drafted by a suitably qualified person in the field of entomology or similar. Any
            development layout and design recommendations of the report must be reflected in the proposal
            plans.

    Response:

    Please refer to Attachment 17 for a copy of the Noosa on Weyba Biting Insect Investigation and Risk
    Management Report which recommends a number of actions that the Noosa on Weyba development will
    undertake to ensure biting insect issues are adequately management. This report concludes that there are no
    impediments to the development proceeding.

    Issue
    The development located outside of the urban footprint for the South East Queensland Regional Plan
    (SEQRP) and are consequently outside of Unitywater‘s headworks area.

    Information Required

    94      Prior to the issue of a Development Permit, the applicant is required to enter into an infrastructure
            agreement with Unitywater which provides for all the necessary work and monetary contributions.
            Accordingly, a draft infrastructure agreement can be issued for consideration should a request to
            Unitywater be made.

   Response:

   As indicated in the amended Water Supply and Sewerage Analysis, Cardno has requested Unitywater to provide
   further details in regard to an IA. As per advice in Appendix D of the amended Water Supply and Sewerage
   Analysis, Unitywater are awaiting the outcomes of the Noosa STP planning currently being undertaken before an
   IA can be formalised. Cardno has indicated to Unitywater that the IA may include external augmentations where
   relevant and also the future handover of internal trunk water and sewer infrastructure.

   Unitywater are to draft an IA in the first Instance as per our correspondence, refer Appendix F.

   In this instance it would be considered logical to impose a condition on any approval that the applicant be
   required to enter into an infrastructure agreement with Unitywater which provides for all the necessary work
   and monetary contributions.

    End of Information Request

The information provided in this letter adequately addresses the matters raised in the Sunshine Coast Regional
Council, Information Request. Under the provisions of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009, the above represents a
response in full to Council’s information request. We request that Council continue with its assessment of the
application. I trust that the information provided is sufficient to allow Sunshine Coast Regional Council to approve
the proposed development.

Should you wish to discuss this matter further please contact me on 3666 0766 at any time.


                                                         63

Page 64

Thank you for your assistance in this matter.

Yours faithfully,
Planning Initiatives




Peter Catchlove




                                                64

Used in these records

About this file

File size
1.6 MB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Council Lake Weyba Information Response 28-10-13_FINAL.pdf · 1.6 MB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.