Council archive · source document
Information Response to EHP MCU12/0208
28 October 2013
Department of Environment and Heritage Protection
PO Box 362
Maroochydore
QLD, 4558
Attention: Julie Murdoch
INFORMATION REQUEST RESPONSE
DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION – MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE
PRELIMINARY APPROVAL FOR MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE UNDER SECTION 242 OF THE
SUSTAINABLE PLANNING ACT 2009 TO VARY THE EFFECT OF THE NOOSA PLAN AND MAROOCHY
PLAN 2000 PLANNING SCHEMES FOR A MIXED USE COMMUNITY TITLE DEVELOPMENT
EENIE CREEK RD, 99 & 191 HOLLETT RD NOOSAVILLE QLD 4566
AND
106, 108-142 TIDSWELL RD WEYBA DOWNS QLD 4562
Described as Lot 2 RP160983, Lot 2 SP179590, Lot 7 RP46782, Lot 53 SP163571, Lot 11 SP250714,
Lot 12 RP893393 and Lot 1667 M37772
DEHP Reference: 398161
Dear Julie,
Following receipt of the Department of Environment and Heritage Protection Information Request
under Section 276 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009, dated 06 March 2013, we respond to the
issues raised as follows. We also refer to your letter dated 20 June 2013 extending the date for
responding;
INFORMATION REQUESTED:
Development in erosion prone areas
1. The proposal includes an extension of the dwelling within lot 12 further seaward into the
Erosion prone area.
Justify the extension of the dwelling seaward of the “Erosion Prone Area Extent – 2100 – 100yr
ARI” as calculated in Cardno’s QCP Assessment (15 October 2012) in accordance with policy 2.2
(3) and (4) of the Draft Costal Protection State Planning Regulatory Provision (Coastal SPRP).
11
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 7 pages
Page 2
Response:
Please refer to Diagram 1.2 Sheet 3: Community Facility Concept Plan for proposed extensions to
the existing dwelling within Lot 12 which is proposed to be the Noosa on Weyba community
facility (see Attachment 1). Please note that the proposed works to the existing house (including
the proposed roofline) will be within setback of the existing dwelling. Therefore no proposed
works will extend seaward of the existing pergola.
2. The Proposal includes use of the existing jetty. A search of departmental records does not
reveal any approval for the existing jetty.
If you believe that the jetty is in an approved structure with a development approval, please
provide evidence of the approval.
Response:
The jetty is an existing structure on the subject site (Lot 12). The jetty does not form part of
the current application and its use has not been considered as part of the lodgement
information. As such the historical approval of the structure is not applicable to the
application at hand.
Areas of High Ecological Significance
3. The Maroochy Plan 2000 and Noosa Plan have been reviewed and the subject area is
shown as water supply resource area and rural, respectively. These are not considered as
urban areas as per the definition in the Costal SPRP. As such, the subject site does not fit
any of the exclusion criteria for policy 2.2 (10) Areas of high ecological significance (HES).
Development and development infrastructure is to be located outside of, and not have a
significant impact on, an area of high ecological significance in any costal management
district.
The Ecological Report states the vegetation and habitat clearance will not occur within areas
that are remnant vegetation, essential habitat or koala bushland habitat. These areas are
2
Page 3
regarded as areas of HES. Other reports provided with the application purpose to clear
within these areas.
Demonstrate how the proposal complies with policy 2.2 (10).
Response:
Further to the Department of Environment and Heritage Protections Request for Information
please refer to the amended Ecological Report, included within Attachment 2, which has
concluded the following;
Section 6.4 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 2) provides an
assessment of the proposed Noosa on Weyba development against the requirements of the
Draft Coastal Protection State Planning Regulatory Provision (Draft Coastal SPRP). Therein it
is recognised that the proposed development would result in direct physical disturbance to <
1.0 hectares of land that supports mapped remnant vegetation or Koala bushland habitat
and which could be considered to be of High Ecological Significance (HES). The areas of HES
disturbance have also been subject to past disturbance events are also in a disturbed
condition (i.e. contain clearance tracks).
In so far as the Noosa on Weyba project does involve, in two instances, development
infrastructure within areas of HES, it is submitted that these aspects of the project would not
compromise the overall nature conservation outcomes sought by the Draft Coastal SPRP
given:
the considerable ecological benefits that will be secured if the Noosa on Weyba
proposal is approved, as detailed previously and summarised in Section 7 of the
Ecological Assessment Report v2 (Cardno 2013); and
the proposed development infrastructure is essential to the proposed development
and has been located and designed to minimise impacts to areas of HES and their
associated biodiversity values and functions.
4. Lake Weyba is listed as a wetland of importance in A Directory of Important
Wetlands in Australia, high ecological value (HEV) waters in the Environmental Protection
(Water) Policy 2009, and is Declared Fish Habitat A. The proposed buffer width is not
supported by information that demonstrates the width is sufficient to protect the existing
qualities of Lake Weyba. Some wetlands may require a setback distance of greater than 100
metres. The Queensland Wetland Buffer Guidelines provides a Wetland buffer design
method for determining appropriate buffer distances.
Please provide information to demonstrate an appropriate buffer width for the site.
3
Page 4
Response:
Further to the Department of Environment and Heritage Protections Request for Information
please refer to the amended Ecological Report, included within Attachment 2, which has
concluded the following;
Section 5.6 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 2) provides
information concerning the proposed dimensions of the buffer to Lake Weyba and includes
reference to the Qld Wetland Buffer Planning Guideline. A specific assessment of the
proposal against the Qld Wetland Buffer Planning Guideline is also provided in Appendix J of
the amended Ecological Assessment Report.
It is incorrect to state that the buffer to Lake Weyba is 50m in width as:
over 75% of the Noosa on Weyba lake frontage would be dedicated as National Park
and maintain buffers > 1km in width; and
the balance of the buffer ranges from 50-90m in width.
The proposed dimensions and configuration of the buffers provided in combination with
other aspects of the proposed plan of development (e.g. water quality management,
effluent management, access management etc) are considered to sufficient to protect the
values of the adjacent sectors of Lake Weyba.
5. The open space conservation zone between precinct 1 and precinct 2 on Lot 11 RP893393
is described as a dedicated Koala Corridor in the Urban Design Report. However, the
objective of this zone is not clear as multi-uses; such as the proposed road, road bridge,
pedestrian pathways, primary and secondary advice parks and stormwater infrastructure;
are planned.
There are a range of mapped state significant biodiversity values co-located with this zone
including high ecological significance mapping; a watercourse; remnant endangered regional
ecosystem; essential habitat for the koala; medium value bushland koala habitat endangered
high value regrowth; of concern high value regrowth; and essential regrowth habitat (Crinia
tinnula, Litoria freycineti and Pezoporus wallicus).
The integrity of the koala corridor may be adversely compromised by the level of
infrastructure and by the residential sub-precinct development proposed to be located within
the teo “arms” of the corridor. It is noted that the assessment report did not recommend a
koala management plan.
Please address how the potential threats to the koala corridor function and integrity will be
ameliorated.
Response:
Further to the Department of Environment and Heritage Protections Request for Information
please refer to the amended Ecological Report, included within Attachment 2, which has
concluded the following;
4
Page 5
As detailed in Sections 5.5 and 5.7 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see
Attachment 2), the proposed plan of development makes provision for multiple ecological
linkages and other controls to facilitate the safe passage of fauna through the Noosa on
Weyba site and between areas of external habitat. There are three ecological corridors
provided within Lot 11 for this purpose, in addition to the major corridor linking the Weyba
Nature Refuge with the south-eastern sector of Lot 53 on SP163571 and Lot 1667 on M3772.
All infrastructure that would be established within or across these corridors, including the
single road crossing extending along the southern boundary of Lot 11, would be designed
and constructed so as to preserve the functional ecological values of these linkages.
6.The Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment report by Cardno estimates the clearance of
Approximately 6500 non-juvenile koala habitat trees. The does not accord with the
Ecological Assessment Report that states that 100 koala habitat trees will be cleared –
approximately 0.05ha of endangered RE 12.5.3.
Please clarify the disparity and confirm the exact clearing extent.
Response:
This apparent disparity is a function of the facts that:
Section 5.3 of the Ecological Assessment Report v1 (Cardno 2012) focuses on
broader categories of habitat clearance and cites the number of non-juvenile Koala
habitat trees to be cleared in mapped areas of Koala Bushland Habitat; and
the Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment v1 (Cardno 2012) provides a more
detailed analysis of the extent of clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees
located within and outside of mapped areas of Koala Bushland Habitat (~ 6500).
The extents of disturbance to mapped areas of remnant vegetation and Koala Bushland
Habitat have been revised to take into account some changes that have been made to the
proposed plan of development in response to issues raised in the various Information
Requests. Updated details concerning the extents of various categories of habitat
disturbance are provided in:
the amended Ecological Assessment Report (see Attachment 2); and
the amended Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment(see Attachment 3.).
Public Access
7. The Coastal Protection and Management Act 1995 makes provision for land surrender
when a development application for reconfiguration of a lot is undertaken within a coastal
management district. EHP may seek the surrender of all lands within the erosion prone area
on the site, to the State. No information is provided on any mechanism under the body
corporate / community title for tenure of this area.
5
Page 6
Please provide information on what tenure is proposed for the erosion prone area. Provide
information on how public access to this area will be maintained.
Response:
The current development application does not involve a Reconfiguration of a Lot component
and as such it is our understanding that the land surrender provisions of the Coastal
Protection and management Act 1995 cannot be imposed.
It is proposed that the “erosion prone area” of the Receive Land would be retained as
freehold land and where appropriate (i.e. the Lake Weyba foreshore area on Lot 11 on
SP250714) would be the subject of public access easements to facilitate sustainable form of
public access to this area.
It is also noted that the vast majority of the erosion prone area of the Noosa on Weyba site
is located within the boundaries of the Send Land. These areas would be transferred to the
State for incorporation into the Noosa National Park to ensure that they are managed
appropriately to achieve desirable coastal management outcomes.
Additional Advice:
Nature Conservation Act 1992 (NCA) and regulations
The proposal includes some clearing of native, protected vegetation which may also impact native
animal breeding places, so permits under the NCS may be necessary. It is suggested that the
proponent will need to clarify and provide the following to EHP:
- what flora and fauna field surveys have been carried out in the clearing footprint;
- survey methods including:
- were surveys targeted for local endemic endangered, vulnerable and near threatened
(EVNT) flora and protected fauna
- were they carried out at an appropriate time of the year to detect the target species e.g.
during breeding season for amphibians; and
- the results of those surveys
Response:
Details concerning the nature and findings of ecological surveys carried out to inform the
Noosa on Weyba project are provided in Sections 3 and 4 of the amended Ecological
Assessment Report (see Attachment 2).
Sections 5.8 and 6.6 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report recognise that there may
be a requirement to obtain permits under the provisions of the Nature Conservation Act
6
Page 7
1992 prior to the commencement of any physical development activities involving the
interference with protected wildlife. Appropriate additional surveys and management plans
would be undertaken and prepared to support requisite applications for permits under the
Nature Conservation Act.
Based on the results of field surveys, the proponent will need to consider if there is a case to
submit the following under the Nature Conservation Act 1992 (NCA) and Regulations.
1. The proponent should first check if the development area is exempt from requiring a
Clearing Permit for Least Concern flora (s89(d) NCS) and s41 Nature Conservation
(Protected Plants) Conservation Plan 2000
2. A clearing Permit application for EVNT flora detected in the proposed clearing
3. Footprint, including appropriate offsets under Biodiversity Offset Policy (an offset should
include a proposal to translocate /propagate the plants to be cleared, to retain their
genetic material in the area)
4. A species Management Program (SMP) for any fauna breeding places that will be
Impacted as a result of clearing including:
- All Least Concern fauna breeding places e.g. raptors – there may be several raptor
species nesting in the proposed development area – some species’ nests can be
relocated, but it is not possible to relocate all species of raptor – e.g. White bellied
sea eagles will not re-occupy a nest that has been disturbed and will abandon an
active nest that is disturbed (Advice, Qld Museum)
- Iconic, colonial or special Least Concern fauna (s34 Nature Conservation (Wildlife)
Regulation 2006)
- Fauna in adjacent areas that are likely to be impacted as a result of clearing e.g. a
change to hydrology in clearing area could affect Acid frogs in adjacent areas, by
causing a change in crucial water quality parameters (pH) over time.
Response:
Details concerning the nature and findings of ecological surveys carried out to inform the
Noosa on Weyba project are provided in Sections 3 and 4 of the amended Ecological
Assessment Report (see Attachment 2).
Sections 5.8 and 6.6 of the amended Ecological Assessment Report recognise that there may
be a requirement to obtain permits under the provisions of the Nature Conservation Act
1992 prior to the commencement of any physical development activities involving the
interference with protected wildlife. Appropriate additional surveys and management plans
would be undertaken and prepared to support requisite applications for permits under the
Nature Conservation Act.
7
Page 8
Conclusion
The information provided in this letter adequately addresses the matters raised in the
Department of Environment and Heritage Protection Information Request. Under the
provisions of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009, the above represents a response in full to
EHP’s information request. We request that EHP continue with its assessment of the
application. I trust that the information provided is sufficient to allow the Department of
Environment and Heritage Protection to approve the proposed development.
Should you wish to discuss this matter further please contact me on 3666 0766 at any time.
Thank you for your assistance in this matter.
Yours faithfully,
Planning Initiatives
Peter Catchlove
8
Used in these records
Information Response to EHP MCU12/0208Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 578 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.