Skip to the record
NoosaWatch™: The source of truth.

Council archive · source document

Approved Document Aborist Tree Rention Review OPW25-0206 · OPW25/0206

of 49

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

Check the original when the exact wording matters.

   NOOSA COUNCIL
 APPROVED DOCUMENT
OPW25/0206 11 JUN 2026

      24 November 2025

      Royal Automobile Club of Victoria (RACV)
      c/o: Adamson Town Planning

      By email:      [email protected]




                     ARBORIST TREE RETENTION REVIEW

     Project:               RACV Noosa Eco Resort Development
     Site Address:          RACV Noosa
                            94 & 142 Noosa Drive, Noosa Heads, Qld, 4567

     Local Authority:       Noosa Council (NC)
     Scope:                 Health and Condition Review & OPW Retention Status Update
     Site Inspection:       16 October 2025


    I am pleased to provide this Version 11 of the Arborist Tree Retention Review, providing an
    update of the health and condition of the trees within the site boundary of the approved RACV
    development.

    This version (V11) responds to Condition 44 and reflects the updated tree retention status
    following the Council's conditioned updated review of the trees in October 2025 and
    subsequent Retention Status amendments. 44(a) is addressed in section 8.2, and the
    response from Dr Justin Watson, Gondwana Ecology Group, is included in Appendix 8:
    Condition Response 44 (a).

    In summary, four additional trees have been lost on the site. Of these, three trees (IDs 147,
    151, and 174) were previously retained but have now deteriorated beyond the point of
    recovery or effective management, rendering them unsuitable for retention. Tree 135 is being
    removed due to irreversible decline and increasing vine infestation. Notably, none of these
    four trees is classified as a Koala tree. Following a reassessment of retention suitability, the
    statuses of Trees 248 and 250 have been switched. Importantly, through targeted
    management, one additional Koala tree (ID 254) is now able to be retained. Overall, the net
    loss of trees is three, while efforts have resulted in the retention of an extra Koala tree.

    A revised and updated Excel spreadsheet has been produced by Consult Arborist, illustrating
    changes to individual tree retention status: ‘25_10_30_DATA_VTA_RACV_OpWorks’.




                  ABN: 68 153 548 531 | [email protected] | 0450 355 770
Full text of the other 48 pages

Page 2

A revised and updated Site plan reflecting the relevant changes has been produced by Aspect:
‘AP250907_10-07 - SITE PLAN - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN - REV_JJ’



** Please note the Addendum to this Review inserted after the appendices reflecting
updates due to storm damage that occurred the week of 24/11/2025. **



Should you have any queries or wish to discuss the information contained in this review,
please do not hesitate to contact me.


Yours sincerely,



_______________________
Matthew Duncan
Director / Principal Arborist
Level 5 AQF Arborist

Matthew has worked in the arboricultural industry since 1994 and established Consult Arborist in 2011 on the
Sunshine Coast. He is a Qualified Consult member of the Queensland Arboricultural Association, holds an AQF
Level 5 Diploma in Arboriculture (AHC50510) and is International Society of Arboriculture Tree Risk Assessment
Qualified from 2015 to 2030.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                          Page 2 of 40

Page 3

T ABLE OF C ONTENTS
Table of Tables ..................................................................................................................... 4
Table of Figures .................................................................................................................... 4
1     Background.................................................................................................................... 5
2     Documents Reviewed .................................................................................................... 6
3     Scope and Limitations .................................................................................................... 7
4     Visual Review Scope March 2025 .................................................................................. 8
5     Observations March 2025 .............................................................................................. 9
6     Analysis of 2022 & March 2025 Tree Data ................................................................... 10
    6.1       Vine Encroachment Change ................................................................................ 10
    6.2       ‘Redundant’ / ‘Unsuitable’ Trees .......................................................................... 11
    6.3       Health & Structural Change ................................................................................. 12
    6.4       Tree Retention Value Change ............................................................................. 13
    6.5       Tree Retention Status Change for Koala Trees ................................................... 14
    6.6       Bushfire Tree Removals ...................................................................................... 18
    6.7       Bio Basin Tree Removals .................................................................................... 19
    6.8       Design Conflict .................................................................................................... 20
7     Site Photographs ......................................................................................................... 21
8     Site Reinspection October 2025................................................................................... 25
    8.1       NC Condition 44 .................................................................................................. 25
    8.2       NC Condition 44 (a) ............................................................................................. 25
    8.3       Condition 44 (b) Findings ..................................................................................... 26
    8.4       Tree Condition Review 16/10/2025 ...................................................................... 26
      8.4.1       Additional Removal .......................................................................................... 26
      8.4.2       Bushfire Tree adjustment ................................................................................. 27
      8.4.3       Additional Retention ......................................................................................... 27
    8.5       Updated Tree Status Table .................................................................................. 28
9     Disclaimer and Limitations of Liability ........................................................................... 29
Appendix 1: Definition of Terms .......................................................................................... 30
Appendix 2: Native Foresters Weed Management Plan ...................................................... 31
Appendix 3: AP250907_10-07 - SITE PLAN - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN -
REV_JJ ............................................................................................................................... 32
Appendix 4: AP210910_10-09 - SITE PLAN - TREE RETENTION VALUE - REV_N .......... 33
Appendix 5: AP250907_10-20(-22) - CONSTRUCTION METHODOLOGY PLAN - STAGE 1(-
3) - REV_C ......................................................................................................................... 34
Appendix 6: Analysis of Change – Spreadsheet Extract Oct 2025 ...................................... 37
Appendix 7: Spreadsheet Images Oct 2025 ........................................................................ 38
Appendix 8: Condition Response 44 (a) .............................................................................. 40




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                                                  Page 3 of 40

Page 4

T ABLE OF T ABLES
Table 1: Health and Structural Change from 2022 to 2025 .................................................. 12
Table 2: Retention Value Change to 2025........................................................................... 13
Table 3: Breakdown of the number of trees with Retention Value change 2022 to 10/2025 13
Table 4: Plan numbers change 2022 DA to 2024 to 2025 ................................................... 15
Table 5: Koala Tree Retention Value by Status October 2025 ............................................ 15
Table 6: 2024 Tree Review - Koala tree advances to ‘Redundant’ status ............................ 15
Table 7: 2025 Tree Review - Koala Tree advances to Redundant / Dead ........................... 17
Table 8: 2025 Bushfire tree removals.................................................................................. 18
Table 9: Biobasin tree removals .......................................................................................... 19
Table 10: Design conflict per tree ........................................................................................ 20




T ABLE OF F IGURES
Figure 1: Site Plan Legend .................................................................................................. 11
Figure 2: Image from the Mediation Agreement 18/03/2025 ................................................ 14
Figure 3: Updated Site Plan – A4 version available at Appendix 3 ..................................... 14
Figure 4: 2022 - Tree 30, vine engulfing the canopy ........................................................... 21
Figure 5: 2024 -Tree 30 failure event from the main canopy. .............................................. 21
Figure 6: 2022 - Tree 38, vine engulfing .............................................................................. 21
Figure 7: 2024 -Tree 38 increased likelihood of branch failure events ................................. 21
Figure 8: 2022 - Tree 39, vine engulfing the canopy ........................................................... 22
Figure 9: 2024 -Tree 39 vine increasing branch failure likelihood ........................................ 22
Figure 10: 2022 - Tree 51 ................................................................................................... 22
Figure 11: 2024 – Tree 51 totally engulfed and at an increased likelihood of major branch or
stem failure due to increased weight from the vine. ............................................................. 22
Figure 12: 2022 - Tree 134 ................................................................................................. 23
Figure 13: 2024 - Tree 134, an increase in vine density to height into the canopy............... 23
Figure 14: 2022 - Tree 165 ................................................................................................. 23
Figure 15: 2024 – Tree 165. Vine-engulfed trunks, increasing in density and height. .......... 23
Figure 16: 2022 - Tree 205 ................................................................................................. 24
Figure 17: 2024 – Tree 205 vine increasing in height into and throughout the canopy. ....... 24
Figure 18: 2024 - Young natural regrowth being constricted by the vine, rendering it untenable
as a future tree .................................................................................................................... 24
Figure 19: 2024 - Tree 160 - failure as a result of vine engulfing and weighting the canopy 24




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                                                 Page 4 of 40

Page 5

1 B ACKGROUND
The original RACV Noosa development site surveys were undertaken between 2019 and 2022
to record the trees in consideration of the proposed tourist accommodation project. This
Arborist Review should take into consideration the previous Arborist Reports, Spreadsheets
and all other relevant project plans and documents.

To gain an accurate understanding of the treescape on the site, the detailed tree surveys
involved an assessment of each tree recorded from a ground level. The following data was
recorded:

   •   Botanical Name & Common Name,
   •   Age Class,
   •   Health,
   •   Structure,
   •   Approximate size in meters - Height, Crown Spread, DBH at 1.4m
   •   Retention Value - awarded based on health, condition, age, and importance to the
       local environmental community, with a focus on consideration of Koalas.
   •   Comments were recorded relating to observations noted at the time of the inspection,
       including notes regarding the invasive Frangipani Vine, Chonemorpha fragrans,
       spreading across the site and growing into many of the trees.

Initially, the tree survey included the road reserve on the eastern side of the site and the koala
tree species within the Noosa Council River reserve on the western side. Due to the high
number of undesirable Umbrella trees across the site, these were not recorded to avoid
distorting the data of the overall site assessment. It is intended to remove all the Umbrella
trees as part of the site's weed management.

The trees are tagged and clearly numbered. CadCon surveyors accurately plotted the
locations of each tree so that detailed plans with each tree's position could be considered as
part of the design. This process of identification throughout the site streamlined the task of
reassessing each tree in August 2024 and March 2025. In many cases, photos of the trees
have been taken at different times.

The forest is a living entity that changes from day to day, and the status and condition of trees
will naturally alter. With the presence of the fast-growing invasive Frangipani Vine throughout
the site and within many of the trees, these elements needed to be reviewed to determine the
impact the vine is having on the trees' condition and ultimately their ability to function as a
viable tree. Photographs collected since 2019 can be used to demonstrate changes to the
trees and/or the status of the Frangipani Vine growth.

The data recorded was compiled in spreadsheets for analysis. This included calculation of the
Tree Protection Zone (TPZ) and Structural Root Zone (SRZ) as per AS4970-2009 Protection
of trees on development sites. Koala trees were identified under the guidance of Dr William
Ellis and were recorded based on species only. The data gathered was used to provide the
necessary information to guide the Arborist Reports and advise and assist with the
development of the plans.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                Page 5 of 40

Page 6

2 D OCUMENTS R EVIEWED
The following documents have been reviewed, analysed, and referenced during the
production of this report. This list is not exhaustive, as numerous options were explored, and
several plans were inspected that either did not progress further than initial drawing or were
altered to better suit the requirements. Many of these reports were updated and altered
following review and discussion with other experts in their fields. Additional reports, or parts
thereof, not included in this list, remain part of the general knowledge base used to understand
the context and gain insights.

 Drawing Titles                                                                           Date
 AP210910 - 10-04 A - TREE SPECIES PLAN A – REV_N                                   15/05/2025
 AP210910 - 10-04 A - TREE SPECIES PLAN B – REV_K                                   15/05/2025
 AP250907_10-07 - SITE PLAN - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN - REV_JJ               02/12/2025
 AP210910 - 10-07A - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN A - REV Q                       15/05/2025
 AP210910 - 10-07B - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN B - REV Q                       15/05/2025
 AP210910 - 10-07C - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN C - REV O                       15/05/2025
 AP210910 - 10-08 - SITE PLAN - (TPZ) TREE RETENTION_ REMOVAL - REV S               15/05/2025
 AP210910 - 10-08A - (TPZ) TREE RETENTION_ REMOVAL PLAN A - REV P                   15/05/2025
 AP210910 - 10-08B - (TPZ) TREE RETENTION_ REMOVAL PLAN B - REV P                   15/05/2025
 AP210910 - 10-08C - (TPZ) TREE RETENTION_ REMOVAL PLAN C - REV N                   15/05/2025
 AP210910 - 10-09 - SITE PLAN - TREE RETENTION VALUE - REV N                        15/05/2025
 AP210910 - 10-09A - TREE RETENTION VALUE PLAN A - REV N                            15/05/2025
 AP210910_10-09B - TREE RETENTION VALUE PLAN B – REV O                              15/05/2025
 AP210910_10-09C - TREE RETENTION VALUE PLAN C – REV M                              15/05/2025
 AP210910_10-11 - TREE REMOVAL VS RETENTION PLAN – REV L                            15/05/2025
 AP210910_10-11A - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN A – REV L                         15/05/2025
 AP210910_10-11B - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN B – REV I                         15/05/2025
 250521 AGLA RACV Noosa Resort LCP issue J                                          21/05/2025
 240902 AGLA RACV Noosa Resort RP – Issue G                                         09/09/2024
 AP250907_10-20 - CONSTRUCTION METHODOLOGY PLAN - STAGE 1 - REV_C                   17/11/2025
 AP250907_10-21 - CONSTRUCTION METHODOLOGY PLAN - STAGE 2 - REV_C                   17/11/2025
 AP250907_10-22 - CONSTRUCTION METHODOLOGY PLAN - STAGE 3 - REV_C                   17/11/2025

 Reports – Completed by Consult Arborist
 19_09_16_AIA_KDA_RACV Noosa_V3                                                     16/09/2019
 19_12_11_DATA_RACV_VMP_1.xls                                                       11/12/2019
 19_12_13_Arborist Responce_RACV_1                                                  13/12/2019
 19_12_18_VMP_RACV_ORIGINAL DESIGN_V5                                               18/12/2019
 22_06_13_AIA_Aspect_RACV Noosa Eco_V1                                              13/06/2022
 22_11_04_AA_Aspect_RACV Noosa Eco                                                  04/11/2022
 22_11_28_ARS_Aspect_RACV Noosa Eco_V3                                              28/11/2022
 22_12_12_AR_Aspect_RACV Noosa Eco                                                  12/12/2022
 23_07_05_ArbRes_ATP_RACV Noosa Eco_NC                                              05/07/2023
 24_06_11_AR_RACV_Tree Condition                                                    11/06/2024
 24_08_22_TREE DATA_RACV_RevU_Plus_BioBF.xls                                        22/08/2024
 25_05_26_DATA_VTA_RACV_RACV v NC_PostMed                                           26/05/2025
 24_09_09_AR_RACV v Noosa_Tree Retention Review_V8                                  09/09/2024
 25_05_28_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V10                              25/05/2025
 Reports
 Weed Management Plan_RACV Noosa_July2024 v2 – Native Foresters                      July 2024
 RACV Condition 44a Memo November 2025                                               Nov 2025




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                              Page 6 of 40

Page 7

3 S COPE AND L IMITATIONS
This report does not take into consideration changes to the site design or activities on which
Consult Arborist has not been requested to comment on or been advised of.

This report does not take into consideration extreme weather events or future pest and disease
outbreaks, which may affect the tree’s health, condition, and retainability.

Assessments of the retained trees have been made visually from the ground and include the
use of basic tools and techniques, i.e., cavity probing, minor root collar excavation, measuring
tapes and devices and photography to gather information. No additional specialist equipment
was used, and no conclusive comments on what may have or may be happening within the
internal structure of the tree will be made. No tissue or soil samples have been collected or
submitted for testing.

The information contained in this report is based on a visual inspection of the palms/trees and
their locations, species, health, and condition at the time of the inspection from a ground level.
The additional information provided is the author's opinion and is a 'snapshot in time' of the
specific tree's health and condition at the time of the quoted inspection, and no guarantee can
be given that faults or issues may not arise in the future.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                               Page 7 of 40

Page 8

4 V ISUAL R EVIEW S COPE M ARCH 2025
As part of the JER process, reviews of the Health and Structure of trees were untaken by
Consult Arborist, with Dr Watson present to assess the site from an ecological perspective in
August 2024. During the 2024 assessment, 204 trees were reviewed; the Melaleuca wetland
trees in the north west corner were deemed to be beyond the scope of influence of bushfire
protection, the bioretention basin, the project design, and the spread of the Frangipani Vine at
that time. A key aspect of the review was to determine the effects that the invasive Frangipani
Vine is having on the main site area and the trees within the proposed cabin footprint.

A further health and condition review was undertaken by Matthew Duncan on 24 March 2025,
following the meeting on 18 March 2025, to evaluate the impact of the matters agreed at the
Mediation. A basic visual assessment was undertaken from ground level, with reasonable
access available to most areas of the site and trees.

Of the 242 native trees recorded within the RACV site boundary, 181 trees were reviewed in
March 2025 based on their location within the Urban Footprint and the Bushfire 10m Buffer
Zone or directly adjacent to the project design and/or the spread of the Frangipani Vine. The
trees within the northwest are in the Environmental Zone and are not affected by the project
design, and were not overly impacted by the Frangipani Vine at the time of the assessments.

A key aspect of this review was to determine the effects that the invasive Frangipani Vine is
having on the main site area and the trees within the new Mediation proposed cabin footprint.

The review recorded provides an overview of any changes to the status of each tree and
confirms whether the tree remains ‘Suitable’ for retention based on its condition and the effect
of Frangipani Vine on the tree. In some trees, this was difficult to determine due to the dense
growth of the vine obstructing a clear visual of the tree structure. In these situations, the tree
was awarded a ‘Questionable’ retention status. These ‘Questionable’ trees are likely to be
overpowered by the vine, resulting in further decline in their health and structural integrity
without intervention in the near future. It is predicted that if a reassessment is undertaken in
12 months, there will be an increase in the number of trees declared ‘Redundant’ or dead.

To date, due to the aggressive nature of the vine, some trees have already been declared
‘Redundant’ as they no longer provide function as a viable tree; these trees were found to be
dead and/or dysfunctional with multiple failing branches and compromised structural integrity.

In the 2022 design, eleven trees were allocated a TBC status (To Be Confirmed), as it was
not possible to positively determine whether or not the trees could be retained due to potential
conflicts with the design. As a consequence of the amended design and further refinements,
we have been able to more precisely determine the trees that are able to be retained and
those which are not able to be retained. We are now confident that those labelled Retain can
be kept.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                               Page 8 of 40

Page 9

5 O BSERVATIONS M ARCH 2025
The dense mass of Frangipani Vine has spread across the site and has increased the number
of trees that are now affected, and the negative impact the mass of vine is having on the
vegetation of the area.

A number of trees, both large and small, have either been badly damaged or killed by the vine.
The increasing weight of the vine has caused branches to snap and fail, trunks to bend and
snap, and tree health has been reduced as the mass of vine has engulfed the canopies,
reducing the tree's ability to photosynthesise.

The Health and Structure of each tree were reassessed with either Good, Fair, Poor, Dead,
or Hazardous awarded and in many cases, the condition of the tree was reduced.

Comments were made predominantly based on the Frangipani Vine's impact on each tree,
with additional notable observations recorded.

The presence of the Frangipani Vine on the trees was compared to the original survey to
illustrate how the Vine has progressed across the site and increased in density within the trees’
canopies.

While not emphasised within the original Tree Survey, the density and spread of the
Frangipani Vine are now very noticeable. The spread is now entering the western boundary
of the site, where it can progress into the Noosa Council river reserve from Weyba Road up
to the north-west corner of the project footprint and North into the resort. On the eastern side
of the site, it is visible on the Noosa Council verge and has even found its way across the
RACV driveway into the northern end of the wildlife corridor that runs parallel to Noosa Drive.

The Frangipani Vine is on the move and will continue to spread beyond the site if it is not
controlled. As such, a Weed Management Plan was commissioned from an independent
Natural Resource Management Consultants company, Native Foresters. The report ‘Weed
Management Plan_RACV Noosa_July2024 v2’, and its findings on the Frangipani vine and
other weeds are available, and an extract of the Weed Management Plan is in Appendix 2.

During the August 2024 investigations of the site in conjunction with Dr Watson, it was noted
that the three (3) Mature, High Value, Swamp Mahogany, Eucalyptus robusta, on the eastern
side of the gateway entrance to RACV should now be considered as part of the site’s overall
treescape. The impact the frangipani vine is having throughout the rest of the site increases
the value of these trees as they are currently unaffected and continue to thrive. While they are
outside the development footprint, they are within the site boundary, and their value as
important urban vegetation and Koala habitat in particular should be distinguished.

The    findings were  included  in   an     updated      Excel     Spreadsheet,
‘25_05_26_DATA_VTA_RACV_RACV v NC_PostMed’, with notable observations explained.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                               Page 9 of 40

Page 10

6 A NALYSIS OF 2022 & M ARCH 2025 T REE D ATA
6.1 V INE E NCROACHMENT C HANGE
Across the whole site, the Frangipani vine is having a negative effect. It is negatively impacting
the health and structural condition of the mature trees while preventing and smothering young
and emerging natives. This vine uses the smaller diameter understory trees as a climbing
frame to enter the mature trees before cascading through them, reducing their ability to
function. This has resulted in an overall increase in the number of ‘Questionable’ and
‘Redundant’ trees throughout the site. These numbers were recorded in the August 2024
assessment and updated again during the status review in March 2025; the presence of the
vine was again visually increased, and emphasis was placed on the trees that were defunct
or decreasing in health and retainability.

Initially, the Vine was recorded as impacting 149 of the 242 trees within the site. This included
monkey rope vine in some of the 38 trees outside the scope of the 204 trees in the 2024
reassessment. When corrected for this, the figures showed an increase from 145 Frangipani
Vine-affected trees to 184, or an increase from 71% to 90% of the trees influenced by the
Frangipani Vine.

The trees that received a ‘Questionable’ status in the review are those that have become
engulfed in vine to the point that a reliable assessment could not be made. It is anticipated
that, without intervention, many of these trees that could be retained would succumb to the
vine and become dead or dysfunctional over the next few years. These trees can be
reevaluated following vine management and remediation work.

This is further addressed in the section on Health and Structural Change from the 2025
assessment.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                              Page 10 of 40

Page 11

6.2 ‘R EDUNDANT ’ / ‘U NSUITABLE ’ T REES
In the information provided with the DA assessment 2022, the Retention Value of ‘Dead’ or
redundant trees was classified as Low. This was amended in 2024 when the tree health review
noted a marked increase in the number of trees that had succumbed to the morbidity spiral.

The 2024 review reduced the health and condition status of 22 trees to the level that they are
termed ‘Redundant’. This has increased to 40 redundant/dead trees following the March 2025
assessment. They are now classed and named ‘Dead’ as they no longer provide function as
a viable tree with little to no ability to photosynthesise and a structural condition that is
compromised and/or failing. These trees were found to be vine-infested to the point that they
were in the midst of the morbidity spiral. These trees are illustrated in the Tree Retention v
Removal Plan – Rev GG with a black slash ‘ / ’ and the term ‘UNSUITABLE’ has been used
to identify them – see Appendix 3. The management of these trees is dictated by their position
within the design and their removal/retention status rather than their health and condition, as
some dead and dysfunctional trees, depending on their location, may be retained as part of
the natural ecosystem and are worthy of retention from an ecological perspective.




                                    Figure 1: Site Plan Legend




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                            Page 11 of 40

Page 12

6.3 H EALTH & S TRUCTURAL C HANGE
Following the reviews in 2024 and the more recent March 2025 review, a considerable number
of trees were determined to have experienced a negative health change since 2022. 181 trees
were reviewed in 2025 as being within the influence of the development. Of these, 85 trees
were noted to have experienced a negative health change, with 157 exhibiting no significant
difference in health, or were not specifically reassessed as part of the March 2025 review (61
trees), and so information from the 2022 review has been utilised instead.

65 trees have experienced a negative structural change, with 177 exhibiting no significant
difference in structural condition or were not specifically reassessed as part of the March 2025
review (61 trees), and so information from the 2022 review has been utilised instead.

These figures show a negative change in the health of 85, or 35% of the trees and a negative
structural change of 65, or 27% of the trees. When correcting for the change in total number
of trees reviewed, this shows that of the 181 trees that were reviewed, 47% displayed a
negative health change, and 36% displayed a negative structural change.

Table 1: Health and Structural Change from 2022 to 2025

               Health Change                                        Structural Change
  2022                   2025                             2022                 2025
  Good          to       Fair            18               Good      to         Fair             18
  Good          to       Poor             4               Good      to         Poor             3
  Good          to       Dead             3               Good      to      Hazardous           1
  Fair          to       Poor            26               Fair      to         Poor             30
  Fair          to     Very poor          9               Fair      to       Very Poor          1
  Fair          to       Dead            16               Fair      to      Hazardous           5
  Poor          to       Dead             9               Poor      to       Very Poor          1
                                                          Poor      to      Hazardous           6
     No significant change              157                  No significant change             177
             Total                      242                          Total                     242


A direct comparison with the recent assessment in March 2025 was not possible, as the total
number of trees that were assessed as being within the influence of the development is slightly
less, at 181. What can be noted is that in the space of 7 months from the 2024 review, the
forest experienced a further negative impact from the invasive vine.

These figures show an ongoing decline in the viable treescape at the site.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                  Page 12 of 40

Page 13

6.4 T REE R ETENTION V ALUE C HANGE
The reinspection carried out during June and July 2024, and March 2025, included a
reconsideration of the Retention Value for some trees due to the negative impact of the vine
and natural decline. 18 trees lost their High retention value designation and 32 trees their
Medium. There was an increase of 10 trees classed as Low, and 40 additional trees were
classified as Dead since 2022. Please note that the trees that were Dead in 2022 received a
Low retention value. This is illustrated in the tables below and Appendix 4.

In the October 2025 review, one additional tree status was changed from Low to Dead (T135).

Table 2: Retention Value Change to 2025

                                                                                        Change since
 Retention Value          2022            2024      05/2025          10/2025
                                                                                            2022
        High               105            89            87              87              Reduction of 18
      Medium               109            77            77              77              Reduction of 32
         Low                28            47            38              37               Increase of 9
        Dead                 0            29            40              41              Increase of 41


Table 3: Breakdown of the number of trees with Retention Value change 2022 to 10/2025

                                          Retention Value in
   Retention Value in 2022                                                    Number of trees
                                               10/2025
              High                               High                                    86
              High                             Medium                                    9
              High                               Low                                     4
              High                              Dead                                     6
             Medium                            Medium                                    69
             Medium                              Low                                     23
             Medium                             Dead                                     17
              Low                                Low                                     10
              Dead                              Dead                                    NA
              Low                               Dead                                     18
                                                                                        242




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                       Page 13 of 40

Page 14

6.5 T REE R ETENTION S TATUS C HANGE FOR K OALA T REES
In 2022, the retention status of the tree was awarded as per design conflict and/or suitability
for retention of the individual tree.

The 2024 retention status reflected the health and/or structure of each of the 204 trees
reassessed and their status for retention, regardless of the design, based on their current
condition. Some of these trees were declared ‘Redundant’ as they no longer provided function
as a viable tree, particularly in terms of Koala habitats. These trees were found to be vine-
infested, and in poor health and condition to the point that they were in the midst of the
morbidity spiral with failing branches. Seventeen such trees were declared ‘Dead’ and
removed from the Koala tree listing for these reasons. This conclusion was reached in
consultation with Dr Justin Watson (Ecologist), Gondwana Ecology, and Dr William Ellis (Koala
specialist), Ecoteam Scientific Services.

The above explains the reduction in the number of Koala Trees that were listed on site in the
DA plans from 150 to the 2024 figures of 133, as shown in Table 4: Plan numbers change
2022 DA to 2024 to 2025. Details outlining the alterations in these trees, including their health,
condition, and observations from 2022 to 2024, are shown in Table 6: 2024 Tree Review -
Koala tree advances to ‘Redundant’ status.

The March 2025 assessment revealed that 11 more trees had advanced to a state of
redundancy or death, 10 of which were previously classed as Koala trees. These are listed in
the Table 7: 2025 Tree Review - Koala Tree advances to Redundant / Dead.

Note: these figures do not include the three (3) mature Swamp Mahogany on the eastern side
of the driveway as detailed in Section 5 Observations.

However, an amended design has been agreed as part of the mediation negotiations.

In the October 2025 review, an additional Koala tree has been deemed suitable for retention
– Tree 254.

The Mediation Agreement Plan is now overtaken by the Court Approval and the subsequent
plan that has been developed following the mandated reinspection: AP250907_10-07 - SITE
PLAN - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN - REV_JJ.




    Figure 2: Image from the Mediation Agreement   Figure 3: Updated Site Plan – A4 version available at
                      18/03/2025                                       Appendix 3




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                    Page 14 of 40

Page 15

        Table 4: Plan numbers change 2022 DA to 2024 to 2025

                                      2022 DA Plans            2024 Review         05/2025 Review      10/2025 Review
         Trees on Site                         242                   242                 242                 242
         Trees Retained                        160                   173                 142                 139
         Trees Removed                          71                   64                  100                 103
         Trees TBC                              11                    5                   0                   0


         Koala Trees on site                   150                   133                 123                 123
         Koala Trees Retained                  117                   109                 84                  85
         Koala Trees Removed                    27                   19                  39                  38
         Koala Trees TBC                         6                    5                   0                   0


        Table 5: Koala Tree Retention Value by Status October 2025

                                 Retention Value
                         High       Medium              Low              Total
           Retain         74              10              1               85
          Remove           9              15             14               38
            TBC            0               0              0                0


        Table 6: 2024 Tree Review - Koala tree advances to ‘Redundant’ status

                                           2024 Review                                                               2022 Status
Tag
 ID     2024                                                                               2024        2022       2022 Comments          2022
                         2024      2024                                     2024 Value
  #   Common    Age                                  2024 Comments                       Retention   Common       (Valid @ survey      Retention
                        Health   Structure                                    Review
       Name                                                                               Status      Name              date)           Status
                                                                                                                 Hollow lower trunk.
                                                                                                                 Tree engulfed from
                                                   Mid-trunk failure
                                                                                                                   bottom to top in
                                                 occurred with all the
                Over                                                          Dead /                  Swamp              vine.
30     Dead             Dead       Poor             canopy failure                       Remove                                        Remove
               mature                                                       Redundant                Mahogany       Other branch
                                                  engulfed with thick
                                                                                                                 structure has been
                                                     heavy vine.
                                                                                                                    lost in recent
                                                                                                                        years.
                                                   Tree has become
                                                 totally engulfed with
                                                          vine.                                       Broad-
                Early                                                         Dead /
151    Dead             Dead       Poor         Upper canopy appears                      Retain      Leafed        Vine engulfed.      Retain
               Mature                                                       Redundant
                                                to have snapped; tree                                Paperbark
                                                    classed now as
                                                    dysfunctional.
                                                    Vine has totally
                Early                              engulfed the tree          Dead /                  Swamp         Vine engulfed.
157    Dead             Dead       Poor                                                   Retain                                        Retain
               Mature                             which has become          Redundant                Mahogany      Suppressed form.
                                                    dysfunctional.
                                                Trunk has snapped at
                Early                                     3m.                 Dead /                  Swamp         Vine engulfed.
160    Dead             Dead       Poor                                                   Retain                                        Retain
               Mature                               Canopy totally          Redundant                Mahogany      Suppressed form.
                                                  engulfed with vine.
                                                   Tree has become                                                  Vine engulfed
                Early                                                         Dead /                  Swamp
168    Dead             Dead       Poor          totally engulfed with                    Retain                     canopy. Tree       Retain
               Mature                                                       Redundant                Mahogany
                                                vine and is now dead.                                               decline health.




        25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                                       Page 15 of 40

Page 16

                                          2024 Review                                                          2022 Status
Tag
 ID     2024                                                                           2024        2022      2022 Comments          2022
                         2024      2024                                 2024 Value
  #   Common    Age                             2024 Comments                        Retention   Common      (Valid @ survey      Retention
                        Health   Structure                                Review
       Name                                                                           Status      Name             date)           Status
                                                 Vine has totally                                              Vine engulfed,
                                                                                                  Broad-
                Early                         engulfed the canopy         Dead /                             being bent over by
174    Dead             Dead       Poor                                               Retain      Leafed                           Retain
               Mature                        of the tree causing the    Redundant                             the weight of the
                                                                                                 Paperbark
                                                 top to snap out.                                                   vine.

                                             Canopy and tree have
                                                 become totally
                                             engulfed with the vine.
                                                                                                               Vine engulfed.
                                              Branch failure events       Dead /                  Swamp
178    Dead    Mature   Dead       Poor                                               Retain                 Branch failure has     TBC
                                                 have occurred.         Redundant                Mahogany
                                                                                                              started to occur.
                                               The tree may have
                                             become dysfunctional
                                                beneath the vine.
                                                Tree has become
                Early                         totally engulfed with       Dead /                  Swamp       Vine engulfed.
182    Dead             Dead       Poor                                              Remove                                       Remove
               Mature                          dense, heavy vine        Redundant                Mahogany    Suppressed form.
                                              affected tree health.
                                                Trees health has
                                             declined and it is now
                                                                                                             Tree almost dead,
                Early                             dysfunctional.          Dead /                  Swamp
222    Dead             Dead       Poor                                              Remove                     with limited      Remove
               Mature                           Minor epicormic         Redundant                Mahogany
                                                                                                                  canopy.
                                              growth on the lower
                                                    trunk only.
                                              Totally engulfed with                               Broad-
                Early                                                     Dead /                             Vine engulfed with
223    Dead             Dead       Poor      vine mid trunk - failure                Remove       Leafed                          Remove
               Mature                                                   Redundant                               snapped top.
                                                  has occurred.                                  Paperbark
                                                Canopy has been
                                                 become totally
                                                                                                  Broad-
                Early                          engulfed with vine         Dead /
225    Dead             Dead       Fair                                              Remove       Leafed       Vine engulfed.     Remove
               Mature                         affecting tree health     Redundant
                                                                                                 Paperbark
                                                      become
                                                  dysfunctional.
                                                Tree and canopy
                                                                                                  Broad-
                                                impacted by the           Dead /
228    Dead    Mature   Dead       Poor                                              Remove       Leafed       Vine engulfed.      Retain
                                               failure of Tree 160.     Redundant
                                                                                                 Paperbark
                                                 Vine engulfed.
                                                 Tree health has                                  Broad-         Twin trunk.
                Early                                                     Dead /
230    Dead             Dead       Poor      declined and it is now                   Retain      Leafed     Vine engulfed with    Retain
               Mature                                                   Redundant
                                                    deceased.                                    Paperbark      snapped top.
                                                Tree totally vine
                Early                                                     Dead /                  Swamp      Vine engulfed with
238    Dead             Dead     Hazardous     engulfed and now                       Retain                                       Retain
               Mature                                                   Redundant                Mahogany     declining health.
                                                    deceased.
                                                Tree has become
                                                                                                  Broad-
                                              totally engulfed with       Dead /                               Vine engulfed.
251    Dead    Mature   Dead       Poor                                               Retain      Leafed                           Retain
                                                vine affected any       Redundant                            Tree may be dead.
                                                                                                 Paperbark
                                             remaining tree health.
                                                                          Dead /                  Swamp        Suppressed.
268    Dead    Mature   Dead       Poor      No vine, natural death.                  Retain                                       Retain
                                                                        Redundant                Mahogany        No vine.
                                                Tree has naturally
                                                                                                  Broad-
                Early                          deceased since the         Dead /
288    Dead             Dead       Poor                                               Retain      Leafed     Suppressed form.      Retain
               Mature                          original inspection.     Redundant
                                                                                                 Paperbark
                                              Vine in upper canopy.




        25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                                  Page 16 of 40

Page 17

        Table 7: 2025 Tree Review - Koala Tree advances to Redundant / Dead

                                          2025 Review                                                          2024 Status
Tag
 ID     2025                                                              2025        2025        2024                               2024
                         2025      2025
  #   Common    Age                             2024 Comments           Retention   Retention   Common       2024 Comments         Retention
                        Health   Structure
       Name                                                              Value       Status      Name                               Status
                                                                                                              Vine throughout
                                                                                                            trunk and engulfing
                                                                                                                   canopy.
11     Dead    Mature   Dead       Poor                 Dead              Dead      Remove       Wattle        Upper branch        Remove
                                                                                                             section has failed
                                                                                                            and is now hanging
                                                                                                                 in the tree.
                                                 Dysfunctional.                                   Broad      Tree has become
                Early
147    Dead             Dead     Hazardous    Leaning over with the       Dead       Retain      Leafed       totally engulfed      Retain
               Mature
                                                      vine.                                     Paperbark         with vine.
                                                 Dysfunctional.
                                              Leaning over with the                               Broad     Tree has become
                Early
148    Dead             Dead     Hazardous            vine.               Dead      Remove       Leafed      totally engulfed       Retain
               Mature
                                                Deck realignment                                Paperbark       with vine.
                                                    conflict.
                                                                                                             Tree has become
                                                                                                  Broad        totally engulfed
                Early                          Dead with snapped
150    Dead             Dead     Hazardous                                Dead       Retain      Leafed            with vine        Retain
               Mature                                 top.
                                                                                                Paperbark     cascading to the
                                                                                                                 forest floor.
                                                                                                             Tree has become
                                                   Dead and
                                                                                                  Broad        totally engulfed
                Early                            dysfunctional.
153    Dead             Dead     Hazardous                                Dead      Remove       Leafed            with vine.       Retain
               Mature                           Deck realignment
                                                                                                Paperbark    Evidence of upper
                                                    conflict.
                                                                                                                 stem failure.
                                                                                                            Increase density of
                                                                                                            vine in the canopy.
                        Very                 Structural condition is                             Swamp
163    Dead    Mature            Very Poor                                Dead      Remove                       Strong lean.        TBC
                        Poor                     deteriorating.                                 Mahogany
                                                                                                            Evidence of branch
                                                                                                                    failure.
                                                                                                             Trunk and canopy
                                                                                                                have become
                                                                                                  Broad
                Early                          Dead with snapped                                               totally engulfed
164    Dead             Dead       Poor                                   Dead      Remove       Leafed                             Retain
               Mature                                 top.                                                         with vine.
                                                                                                Paperbark
                                                                                                            Evidence of branch
                                                                                                                    failure.
                                                                                                             Trunk and canopy
                                                                                                               totally engulfed
                                                                                                  Broad
                Early                         Potential conflict with                                              with vine.
166    Dead             Dead     Very Poor                                Dead      Remove       Leafed                             Retain
               Mature                         redesign of cabin 2/3.                                               Possibly
                                                                                                Paperbark
                                                                                                                dysfunctional
                                                                                                             beneath the vine.
                                                                                                                 Canopy has
                                                                                                               become totally
                                                 Increased vine
                                                                                                 Swamp       engulfed with vine
169    Dead    Mature   Dead       Poor              density.             Dead      Remove                                          Retain
                                                                                                Mahogany        which is now
                                                   High to Low
                                                                                                            affecting the tree's
                                                                                                                    health.
                                                                                                                 Canopy has
                                                                                                               become totally
                                                                                                  Broad
                Early   Very                     Snapped top.                                                engulfed with vine
173    Dead                      Hazardous                                Dead       Retain      Leafed                             Retain
               Mature   Poor                     Dysfunctional.                                              which may lead to
                                                                                                Paperbark
                                                                                                               vine accessing
                                                                                                                  Tree 172.
                                                                                                                  Vine totally
                                                                                                             engulfing the tree
                        Very                                                                     Swamp
177    Dead    Mature              Poor          Dysfunctional.           Dead      Remove                       and canopy          TBC
                        Poor                                                                    Mahogany
                                                                                                                affecting tree
                                                                                                                    health.



        25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                                  Page 17 of 40

Page 18

        6.6 B USHFIRE T REE R EMOVALS
        Following the mediation redesign, the Bushfire removals were reconsidered by Rob Friend,
        Rob Friend & Assocs. Tree 213 is now determined as suitable for retention, however, the
        mediation redesign requires the removal of 15 trees to remediate against bushfire risk. The
        Table below lists the trees that are nominated for removal following the 2025 health review
        and Bushfire risk reassessment based on the mediation changes in Building Envelope
        positions.

        Table 8: 2025 Bushfire tree removals

Tag                                                                        2024
      Common                                    Height   Spread    DBH                  2025            Retention     2025
 ID                Age     Health   Structure                               Ret
       Name                                      (m)      (m)     @1.4m               Comments           Value      Retention
  #                                                                       Status
                                                                                   Vine growth on the
       Broad-
                                                                                       trunk is now
215    Leafed     Mature   Good       Good       8-10     4-6      0.3    Remove                         Medium     Remove
                                                                                   extending into the
      Paperbark
                                                                                      main canopy.
                                                                                         Vine now
       Broad-
                                                                                   extending from the
217    Leafed     Mature    Fair      Good      14-16     4-6      0.3    Remove                         Medium     Remove
                                                                                      trunk into the
      Paperbark
                                                                                          canopy.
       Broad-                                                                      Vine accessing the
                   Early
218    Leafed              Good       Good       8-10     2-4     0.15    Remove         trunk via       Medium     Remove
                  Mature
      Paperbark                                                                     understory trees.
        Broad
                                                                                     Increased vine
219    Leafed     Mature   Poor       Fair      10-12     4-6      0.3    Remove                           Low      Remove
                                                                                         density.
      Paperbark
                                                                                    Increased vine
        Broad
                   Early                                                                density.
232    Leafed               Fair      Fair       8-10     2-4     0.15    Retain                         Medium     Remove
                  Mature                                                           Cabin realignment
      Paperbark
                                                                                        conflict.
        Broad                                                                       Increased vine
235    Leafed     Mature   Poor       Fair      10-12     4-6     0.25    Retain        density.           Low      Remove
      Paperbark                                                                         BF no.
                   Early
238     Dead               Dead     Hazardous   10-12     2-4     0.13    Retain        BF no.            Dead      Remove
                  Mature
       Swamp
240               Mature    Fair      Fair      14-16     8-10    0.48    Retain        BF no.             High     Remove
      Mahogany
        Broad
242    Leafed     Mature   Poor       Fair      10-12     2-4     0.24    Retain         BF no             Low      Remove
      Paperbark
       Swamp       Early
243                        Poor       Fair      10-12     4-6     0.25    Retain         BF no             Low      Remove
      Mahogany    Mature
       Swamp
245               Mature    Fair      Fair      10-12     4-6      0.2    Retain         BF no           Medium     Remove
      Mahogany
       Swamp
246               Mature    Fair      Good      14-16     4-6     0.39    Retain        BF no.             High     Remove
      Mahogany
       Swamp
248               Mature   Good       Fair      16-20     6-8      4.3    Retain        BF no.             High     Remove
      Mahogany
                                                                                     Snapped top.
251     Dead      Mature   Dead       Poor       8-10     2-4     0.45    Retain                          Dead      Remove
                                                                                        BF no.




        25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                         Page 18 of 40

Page 19

        6.7 B IO B ASIN T REE R EMOVALS
        The following trees require removal due to compliance with the construction of a viable
        biobasin. This has not altered since the Mediation.

        Table 9: Biobasin tree removals

Tag ID Common               2025      2025      Height   Spread    DBH 2022 Ret              2024                    Retention     2025
                   Age
  #     Name               Health   Structure    (m)      (m)     @1.4m Status             Comments                   Value      Retention

                                                                                  Canopy has become engulfed
                                                                                    with vine increasing branch
 203 Cheese tree Mature     Fair      Fair      12-14     6-8      0.36   TBC                                          Low       Remove
                                                                                       failure and affecting tree
                                                                                                 health.
                                                                                  Canopy has become engulfed
                                                                                       with vine, increasing the
 204    Wattle    Mature    Fair      Poor       6-8      4-6      0.18   TBC                                          Low       Remove
                                                                                   likelihood of branch failure in
                                                                                             the short term.
                                                                                    Significant twin leader tree.
                                                                                  Vine has grown from the main
        Swamp                                                                     trunk up into the upper canopy
 205              Mature    Fair      Fair      16-20    10-12     0.8    TBC                                         Medium     Remove
       Mahogany                                                                   engulfing the branch structure
                                                                                     increasing the likelihood of
                                                                                             branch failure.




        25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                                      Page 19 of 40

Page 20

6.8 D ESIGN C ONFLICT
Following the mediation process, where the design changed on the request of the opposing
Noosa Council team, there have been a number of additional removals. Of the now 103 tree
removals, the following table illustrates the number of trees where conflict occurs with the
design.

Following consultation with the design team, the positioning of the boardwalks was realigned
to avoid high value trees, where possible, while achieving the new cabins' positions.

Please note that all TBC trees were reassigned a Remove status.

Table 10: Design conflict per tree

                                                   Remove – 2025
           Design Conflict
                                     Number of trees     Redundant / Remove
                                                              3 Redundant
           Cabin 1 & Carpark              26
                                                             23 Removals
                                                             17 Redundant
           Cabin 2 & 3                    29
                                                             12 Removals
           Cabin 4 & 5                     2                  2 Removals
           Cabin 6 & 7                     1                   1 Removal
           Cabin 8 & 9                     2                   2 Removal
                                                              4 Redundant
           Cabin 10 & 11                   9
                                                              5 Removals
           Cabin 12 & 13                   3                  3 Removals
                                                              4 Redundant
           Cabin 14 & 15                  11
                                                              7 Removals
                                                              2 Redundant
           Bushfire                       14
                                                             12 Removals
           Bio Basin                       3                  3 Removals




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                         Page 20 of 40

Page 21

7 S ITE P HOTOGRAPHS




  Figure 4: 2022 - Tree 30, vine engulfing the canopy   Figure 5: 2024 -Tree 30 failure event from the main
                                                                             canopy.




       Figure 6: 2022 - Tree 38, vine engulfing           Figure 7: 2024 -Tree 38 increased likelihood of
                                                                       branch failure events




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                        Page 21 of 40

Page 22

  Figure 8: 2022 - Tree 39, vine engulfing the canopy   Figure 9: 2024 -Tree 39 vine increasing branch failure
                                                                              likelihood




              Figure 10: 2022 - Tree 51                 Figure 11: 2024 – Tree 51 totally engulfed and at an
                                                        increased likelihood of major branch or stem failure
                                                               due to increased weight from the vine.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                          Page 22 of 40

Page 23

            Figure 12: 2022 - Tree 134             Figure 13: 2024 - Tree 134, an increase in vine
                                                          density to height into the canopy




            Figure 14: 2022 - Tree 165           Figure 15: 2024 – Tree 165. Vine-engulfed trunks,
                                                         increasing in density and height.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                 Page 23 of 40

Page 24

              Figure 16: 2022 - Tree 205                 Figure 17: 2024 – Tree 205 vine increasing in height
                                                                   into and throughout the canopy.




   Figure 18: 2024 - Young natural regrowth being        Figure 19: 2024 - Tree 160 - failure as a result of vine
  constricted by the vine, rendering it untenable as a            engulfing and weighting the canopy
                       future tree




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                             Page 24 of 40

Page 25

8 S ITE R EINSPECTION O CTOBER 2025
Matthew Duncan, the Director and Principal Arborist of Consult Arborist, attended the RACV
site on 16 October 2025 to comply with the Noosa Council Operational Works condition 44
and review the subject retained trees and ascertain if any are now not deemed suitable for
retention.

In summary, there has been an additional loss of four trees. Three of these trees, IDs 147,
151, and 174, were being retained while deemed redundant and “unsuitable” in May 2025;
now their structural integrity has reached the critical threshold where recovery or management
is not feasible. Tree 135 is being removed due to irreversible decline and ever-increasing vine
infestation. None of these four trees is considered a Koala tree. Trees 248 & 250 have had
their retention statuses switched following a review of their suitability for retention and
management. The review also revealed that with considered management, an additional koala
tree can be retained, ID 254. On balance, the number of trees lost from the project is three,
but more importantly, with effort, one extra koala tree is retained.



8.1 NC C ONDITION 44
 (Arboriculture) Retention of Existing Trees
 Condition 44:
 All works must be carried out in accordance with the referenced Arborist Report Dated
 28.05.2025, version 10, listed within this Decision Notice, with the exception of the following:

 a) Survey the location of Fraser Island Creeper, Tecomanthe hillii, to the southwest of the
 development footprint and provide management techniques required to preserve and
 maintain during the construction phase and into perpetuity.

 b) Any trees identified to be retained trees that have declined since the last arboricultural
 survey and are no longer suitable to be retained must be removed, and the area subject to
 rehabilitation planting.

 The report must be resubmitted to Council, incorporating the above amendments, prior
 to the issue of any Development Permit for Operational Works.*




8.2 NC C ONDITION 44 ( A )
Justin Watson of Gondwana Ecology Group conducted site inspections and surveyed the land
for the presence of Fraser Island Creeper, Tecomanthe hillii, as per Council Condition 44 (a).
Dr Watson’s written note of the site describes and details the location and protection of the
vine and its treatment during the construction phase, to which I concur.

Document provided by Dr Watson - ‘RACV Condition 44a Memo November 2025’ is included
at Appendix 8: Condition Response 44 (a).




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                               Page 25 of 40

Page 26

8.3 C ONDITION 44 ( B ) F INDINGS
As part of the site visit, the trees within the main site area have been re-marked with the
following colour code, that are reflected on the updated tree plot plans.

   •   Green Ribbon – Retain
   •   Pink / Red paint dot - Remove
   •   Yellow ribbon – additional removal as now deemed unsuitable for retention.

In addition to confirmation of the retention/removal status of the tree, a few trees that form part
of the Bushfire Management Strategy were reviewed for their suitability for retention,
considering their structure and form. These minor amendments have been confirmed by Rob
Friend as being compliant with his advice.

Please note that since the tree plot was completed, additional trees have grown up or naturally
become larger. Obviously, naturally occurring young growth within the building footprints will
need to be removed. There is, however, the opportunity to retain some natural, native
understory in the undisturbed areas that will be fenced to create the Tree Protection /
Exclusion Zones. Weed trees will need to be carefully removed from these areas, and where
possible, damaging these young, native trees will be avoided.

Updated Construction Methodology Plans have been provided by Aspect that have been
reviewed and are supported by the relevant parties. A key factor that will be essential to the
successful preservation of the trees at the site will be the oversight of the Project Arborist /
Ecologist to guide the construction as it progresses through the stages.

The information below provides a summary of the amendments that are required to reflect this
most recent review of the trees within the main site footprint.

Unless otherwise stated, all other tree removal or retention statuses are to remain the same.

The    findings were  included    in    an     updated     Excel     Spreadsheet,
‘25_10_30_DATA_VTA_RACV_OpWorks’, with notable observations explained.


8.4 T REE C ONDITION R EVIEW 16/10/2025

Retained trees were flagged with green ribbons and checked for continued retention status.

8.4.1 Additional Removal
Four trees are now deemed unsuitable for retention since the last inspection.

These have been flagged with yellow ribbons:

ID 135 Bribie Island Pine - Retention value Low, 25 Review Questionable.

Vine has increased in the canopy, with very limited growth of the tree noted. It is now classed
as dysfunctional and unsuitable for retention. Its removal will allow for additional
rehabilitation/landscape planting that will benefit the site in the long term.

Remove



25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                               Page 26 of 40

Page 27

ID 147 Dead - Retention value Dead, 25 Review Redundant.

Trunk structure has declined with failure predicted within 6-12 months.

Remove

ID 151 Dead - Retention value Dead, 25 Review Redundant.

Trunk structure has declined with failure predicted within 6-12 months.

Remove

ID 174 Dead - Retention value Dead, 25 Review Redundant.

Snapped towards the base of the trunk.

Remove

8.4.2 Bushfire Tree adjustment
Location: Cabins 4-5

The following adjustments to retain/remove status are recommended; these have been
discussed with Rob.

ID 248 & ID 250

Due to the suitability of the tree form for future management, trees 248 and 250 are to have
their retention statuses switched.

248 is now Remove (red)

250 is now Retain (green)

8.4.3 Additional Retention
ID 254

On review of the condition of tree 254, although it is heavily engulfed by vine, it is displaying
growth at the top of the tree. The canopy favours away from the cabins towards the bushland
to the west. Its removal status was part of the bushfire assessment and partially took into
consideration my assessment at the time and the positioning of the cabins from an older
design layout. The canopy of 254 and the vines can both be managed so that the tree can be
retained in a suitable condition.

254 is now Retain (green)

This increases the retention of Koala trees by one (1)




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                              Page 27 of 40

Page 28

      8.5 U PDATED T REE S TATUS T ABLE
Tag                           Oct                                                               May 2025    Oct 2025
        Common                       Oct 2025                 Spread    DBH      May 2025
 ID                 Age      2025                Height (m)                                     Retention   Retention
         Name                        Structure                 (m)     @1.4m    Comments
  #                         Health                                                               Status      Status
                                                                                 Increased
                                                                                vine growth.
                                                                                   Totally
                                                                                  engulfed.
         Bribie
135      Island    Mature   Poor       Poor        10-12       4-6     0.35                      Retain     Remove
                                                                               October 2025
          pine
                                                                                 - review
                                                                                  Totally
                                                                                engulfed -
                                                                               Dysfunctional.

                                                                               Dysfunctional.
                                                                               Leaning over
                                                                               with the vine.
                    Early
147       Dead              Dead     Hazardous     8-10        2-4     0.12                      Retain     Remove
                   Mature                                                      October 2025
                                                                                 review -
                                                                                Imminent
                                                                                  failure.
                                                                               October 2025
                                                                                 Review -
                    Early
151       Dead              Dead     Hazardous     12-14       2-4     0.16     Imminent         Retain     Remove
                   Mature
                                                                                  failure.

                                                                               October 2025
                                                                                 Review -
                    Early
174       Dead              Dead       Poor        8-10        2-4      0.1     Imminent         Retain     Remove
                   Mature
                                                                                  failure.

         Swamp                                                                       BF
248                Mature   Good       Fair        16-20       6-8     0.36                      Retain     Remove
        Mahogany                                                               management.
                                                                               October 2025
                                                                                  Review -
         Swamp                                                                  Better form
250                Mature   Good       Fair        14-16       8-10    0.45                     Remove       Retain
        Mahogany                                                                     for
                                                                               management
                                                                                 than 248.
                                                                                   Totally
                                                                                 engulfed.
                                                                                Potentially
                                                                               dysfunctional
                                                                               beneath the
                                                                                    vine.
         Swamp                                                                 BF Remove.
254                Mature   Poor       Fair        16-20      10-12    0.55                     Remove       Retain
        Mahogany
                                                                               October 2025
                                                                                 Review -
                                                                                Reassessed
                                                                               as outside BF
                                                                                   zone.




      25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                      Page 28 of 40

Page 29

9     D ISCLAIMER AND L IMITATIONS OF L IABILITY
The information contained in this report has been prepared independently, free of any bias and represents the
honest opinion of the consulting arborist.

All data is based on visual inspection of the tree(s) and their location at the time of writing unless otherwise stated.
The report includes opinions, advice, and recommendations based on information gathered during site inspections
conducted by the author and data supplied by the Client (RACV Noosa).

All information received from the Client shall be deemed to be true, accurate and up to date.

To the extent permitted by law, you agree Consult Arborist Pty Ltd is not liable to you or any person or entity for
any loss of or damage (including loss or damage resulting from negligence), either directly or indirectly, arising
from your use of the information presented in this report. In no event will the author be liable for any lost revenue
or profits, or for any special, indirect, consequential, or incidental damages (however caused and regardless of the
theory of liability) arising out of or related to your use of this information, even if the author has been advised of the
possibility of such a loss or damage.

Consult Arborist Pty Ltd cannot be held responsible for the effects of non-conformance works carried out by
inadequately qualified staff or without the supervision of Consult Arborist.

Unless otherwise stated, this report may not be used in a court of law or any legal proceeding without the prior
consent of Consult Arborist Pty Ltd. The author is not required to provide testimony or attend court based on this
report unless subsequent contractual arrangements have been made.

The information contained in this report pertains solely to the tree(s) that were inspected most recently in March
2025, and through desktop review of the plans, and reflects their condition at the time of the inspection.

No warranty or guarantee, expressed or implied, is made that the problems or deficiencies identified in the plants
or property will not arise in the future. Likewise, remedial treatments cannot be guaranteed.

Arborists cannot detect every condition that could potentially lead to the structural failure of a tree. Trees are living
organisms that fail in ways not fully understood, and conditions can often remain hidden within a tree or below
ground. Consult Arborist Pty Ltd and the author cannot guarantee that a tree will be healthy or safe under all
circumstances or for a specified period.

This report does not account for the possibility of extreme weather events or other factors beyond the control of
Consult Arborist Pty Ltd.

Treatment, pruning, and removal of trees may involve considerations beyond the scope of the arborist’s services,
such as property boundaries, ownership issues, disputes between neighbours, sightlines, landlord-tenant matters
and similar concerns. Consult Arborist Pty Ltd cannot address such issues unless complete and accurate
information is provided. Furthermore, Consult Arborist Pty Ltd cannot be held responsible for the authorisation or
non-authorisation of any recommended treatment or remedial measure.

Arborists are specialists who use their education, knowledge, training, and experience to examine trees,
recommend measures to enhance the beauty and health of trees and attempt to reduce the risk of living near trees.
While trees can be managed, they cannot be controlled. To live or work near a tree involves inherent risks, and the
only way to eliminate all risks associated with a tree is to remove it entirely.

Clients may choose to accept or disregard the recommendations of Consult Arborist Pty Ltd or to seek additional
advice.

.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                                   Page 29 of 40

Page 30

A PPENDIX 1: D EFINITION OF T ERMS
The terms below are frequently used to simplify the definition of trees during assessments.

 Age Class (AC):
 Young                Early stage of growth, immature size
 Early mature:        Fast-growing well-established tree which has not yet reached mature size
 Mature               The tree reached its mature size and exhibits slowing growth rates with early stages of naturally forming
                      dead or dysfunctional wood.
 Over Mature          The tree has reached mature size and is unlikely to increase significantly in height or mass. Retrenchment
                      of the upper crown with increased vegetative vitality in the lower crown, increased fungal activity and wood
                      decay and increased colonisation by flora and fauna.
 Veteran              Tree with advanced retrenchment, reduced crown size and annual increment growth, extensive hollowing,
                      crown collapse, low vigour, advanced heartwood decay, and advanced colonisation by fauna and flora.
 Health (H):
 Good                 Good: Tree with no defects or disorders which are notable. Full canopy with good colour foliage. Minimal
                      pathogen damage.
 Fair                 Fair: Tree with minor defects or disorders which are notable. Some dead wood within what can be an
                      unbalanced canopy, foliage generally with good colour although some discolouration may be present typical
                      of species in location. Minor pathogen damage.
 Poor                 Poor: Tree with major defects or disorders which are notable. The tree has considerable deadwood present
                      and discoloured or distorted leaves indicating a further decline of the tree. Detrimental pathogen damage.
 Dead                 Dead or dysfunctional moribund tree.
 Structure (St):
 Good                 Tree with good unions and no branch defects. Sound trunk with no / minor defects. Good buttress and root
                      structure.
 Fair                 Tree with minor defects or disorders which are notable. Small areas of bark missing. Small cavities or minor
                      unfavourable branch unions may be present. Minor damage to roots.
 Poor                 Tree with major defects, large hollows, weak unions and/or problematic damaged roots.
 Hazardous            This implies a tree with a major defect that may fail at any time
 Abbreviations:
 DBH                  Diameter at Breast Height - The approximate diameter of the trunk measured visually in millimetres or meters
                      at a height of 1.4m.
 TPZ                  The Tree Protection Zone, as per AS 4970-2009 Protection of trees on development sites, is the principal
                      means of protecting trees on a development site. The TPZ is a combination of the root and crown area
                      requiring protection to be isolated from construction disturbance so that the tree can remain in a viable
                      condition. The TPZ incorporates the Structural Root Zone (SRZ).
                      The radius of the TPZ = DBH x 12
                      A TPZ should not be less than 2m or greater than 15m (unless crown protection is required).
 SRZ                  The Structural Root Zone, as per AS 4970-2009 Protection of trees on development sites, is a mathematical
                      calculation of the surface area of protection required to maintain a tree’s stability – a larger area is required
                      to maintain a tree in viable health. It is only necessary to calculate the SRZ when a major encroachment into
                      a TPZ is proposed.
 Tree Retention Value:
 The retention value status is based on industry-recognised methods of ascertaining the retention value of a tree. The suitability
 of the tree for preservation or retention is based on the individual qualities of each tree. By taking into consideration the health,
 structural condition, aesthetics, age, size, longevity (Safe Useful Life Expectancy) and ability to adapt to new environments the
 viability of the tree can be reasonably determined.
 For trees in non-use areas (e.g., Open spaces) where a range in tree quality is appropriate, all trees may be considered
 suitable, except for invasive species.

 Suitability for Retention/Preservation Categories are:
 High:               Tree retention is the priority.
                     The tree has high amenity, heritage and/or environmental value. It is in reasonably good condition (any minor
                     structural or health problems can be mitigated), has a long life expectancy and can recover from injury or
                     respond to environmental changes.
 Medium:             Tree retention is desirable.
                     The tree is in fair-good condition, is a locally common species, the tree contributes to the aesthetics of its
                     locality and should survive for many years. The tree may have health or structural problems that can be
                     mitigated with treatment.
 Low:                The tree is not considered worthy of special measures to ensure its retention.
                     The tree is in poor condition with significant defects that cannot be mitigated, has a short Useful Life
                     Expectancy, or the tree is expected to decline regardless of treatment. The tree has low value in the
                     landscape or is an undesirable species.
 Dead/               Tree removal is recommended, unless in a suitable area for ecological retention.
 Remove:             Trees are considered potentially hazardous, have very poor specimens, and/or may be environmental or
                     noxious weeds.




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                                                                Page 30 of 40

Page 31

A PPENDIX 2: N ATIVE F ORESTERS W EED M ANAGEMENT P LAN




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1   Page 31 of 40

Page 32

A PPENDIX 3: AP250907_10-07 - SITE PLAN - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN - REV_JJ




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                             Page 32 of 40

Page 33

A PPENDIX 4: AP210910_10-09 - SITE PLAN - TREE RETENTION VALUE - REV_N




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                  Page 33 of 40

Page 34

A PPENDIX 5: AP250907_10-20(-22) - CONSTRUCTION METHODOLOGY PLAN - STAGE 1(-3) -
   REV_C




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1                        Page 34 of 40

Page 35

25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1   Page 35 of 40


[OCR of page images]
( onsult \rborist

 

 

MeoRTNT

 

 

wake

   
    
   
  

  

© mone
Gi ce rerccome. |
—_ . i
ei
ee

 

'
REDUOED SITE SETUP & LAY
Bown aren

!

<< ewrorany riemovat oF CENTRAL

\ ROAD ISLAND FOR CONSTRUCTION
NENIGLE ACCESS

MATERIAL LAY DOWN
AREA PER CABIN AULD

 

LEGEND
@
2 i
i @ = retaneptrees @ ¥
&
5 =
3 @ TBC @2z
© bea g
* © TREES WITH EXTRA Oo
2 SIRES eae ae ces :
MEASURES noi SOGLOGST TODETERMINE.
(@REEN DASH
@ _ UNSUITABLE -
RETAINED TREES
NOTES
TBC - RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE. SUBJECT TO PERMETER TE rence

DETAILED DESIGN AND ARBORIST ADVICE. ad

[Ln RACV

 

 

  

 

COMPLETE WORKS TO RAISED
NATERIAL LAY COWNAREA WalKwavsasenvices
‘CONSTRUCTION ZONES
Toomious| ESE) BOLOGNA
‘COMPLETED AREA, —
‘TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION ANENTITES eee

INTERNAL WORHS IN PROGRESS |

 

 

 

 

 

‘encuno provecron zones Ba
NOOSA RESORT- ECO
RESORT
——— _noveanveconsraucron sre rewane ROYAL AUTONOBLE CLUB OF
\cToRA

exponen. exeLusion zone FENCE
[NOICATWELECATION PROWECT.
ARBORIT /E0O.O0K7 TODETERNNE

 

1142 NOOSA DANE, NOOSA HEADS
lain 4567

STAGE 2 CONSTRUCTION - INDICATIVE

 

 

 

 

CONSTRUCTION MANAGMENT PLAN uy [Construction netHoooLosy
@ geese
F lirvws 29 "zr
oS 5 [ptocio_avoat [e

 

25_11_24 AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1 Page 35 of 40

Page 36

25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1   Page 36 of 40


[OCR of page images]
( onsult \rborist

 

 

 

 

  
  
     

LEGEND
2
2 6
i @ = retaneptrees @ ¥
&
7 =
3 e TBC’ @2z
: g
* © TREES WITH EXTRA Oo
6 PROTECTION
MEASURES
@ _ UNSUITABLE -
RETAINED TREES

NOTES

TBC* - RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE. SUBJECT TO
DETAILED DESIGN AND ARBORIST ADVICE.

L_]

 

‘CONSTRUCTION SETUP AREA,

WATERIAL LAY DOWNAREA

‘CONSTRUCTION ZONES

‘COMPLETED AREA

‘TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION ANENTITES

‘TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION ACCESS

{GROUND PROTECTION ZONES.

[NOJCATWE CONSTRUCTION STE FENCING

ENVIRONMENTAL EXCLUSION ZONE FENCE,
INDICATE LOCATION PROJECT
ARBORIT ECOLOGIST TODETERNINE

 

|
}
/
/
1

1

!

COMPLETE CAR PARKING
ERASED WALKWAYS. |
'

(COMPLETE WORKS 10 RAISED
WALKWAYS 8 SERVICES

<> RENSTATE CENTRAL ROAD
ISLAND WITH NEW |ANDSCAPING.

REHOVE ENVIRONMENTAL EXCLUSION
ZONEFENCE & REHABILITATE ALL AREAS.

  
  

REMOVE PERIMETER SITE FENCING & ——4
REHABILITATE ALL AREAS 4

STAGE 3 CONSTRUCTION - INDICATIVE
CONSTRUCTION MANAGMENT PLAN

25_11_24 AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1

MeoRTNT

 

wake

RACV

AVASPECT

 

Toonmams swat pL

 

 

NOOSA RESORT- ECO
[RESORT

[ROYAL AUTOMOBILE CLUB OF
\wcroRA

1142 NOOSA DANE, NOOSA HEADS
lain 4567

 

\CoNSTRUCTION METHODOLOGY
PLAN-STAGE 3
2) ar

 

 

 

(210¢10_at022 c

Page 36 of 40

Page 37

A PPENDIX 6: A NALYSIS OF C HANGE – S PREADSHEET E XTRACT O CT 2025




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1               Page 37 of 40

Page 38

A PPENDIX 7: S PREADSHEET I MAGES O CT 2025




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1   Page 38 of 40

Page 39

25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1   Page 39 of 40


[OCR of page images]
( oncult \rborist

tt Arborist

      

    

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

 

 

Ee, 2
a —
2 cr anne ar ro vow % 1 7
2-2 ee ee 2 t i
ae — % ‘ ‘ oe '
mm "O" teyuae Got ced eka? tan : eee f
Sen ee = ‘ ' = ear oo :
eo a es : : em "
= = oe = : .
= ze x Sn :
ne me ew o : ‘ =
= aoa :
oe en we - : 2S
ee es = <=
ae recat taht 1
| ” 1 ' ee
a ee eae cS a zi 2 ee 1
— a tt ae '
2S ee = :
= oe = = 2
SS = “ a
cn = =
=
ao i

Consult Arborist

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

ih

 

 

 

 

 

rr

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

)eees)e lle

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

fel lee e lef] efe feel eye

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

ERalaisielslajslels|e sig alala laa afaialeis|sia

 

25_11_24 AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1 Page 39 of 40

Page 40

A PPENDIX 8: C ONDITION R ESPONSE 44 ( A )




25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_1   Page 40 of 40

Page 41

                       RACV PROJECT – Fraser Island Vine in Road Reserve
                                     Justin Watson 1, Gondwana Ecology Group
                                                      4 November 2025
Introduction and Background
The project for 15 cabins over Lot 3 on SP126203 was approved 1 September 2025 with
conditions.
Condition 44 (a) requires that “All works must be carried out in accordance with the referenced
Arborist Report Dated 28.05.2025 version 10 listed within this Decision Notice, with the
exception of the following”:
        Survey the location of Fraser Island Creeper Tecomanthe hillii to the southwest of the
        development footprint and provide management techniques required to preserve and
        maintain during the construction phase and into perpetuity.
This note provides:
       1) a description and map of the location of Tecomanthe hilli southwest of the development
          footprint; and
       2) measures to protect the species during construction and perpetuity.
Fraser Island Vine
With respect to the Fraser Island vine, several site inspections have been completed for the
subject land and surrounds. More recently site inspections and detailed surveys for the vine
were completed on 15th and 16th October 2025. Both targeted meanders in the locality and
transects were carried out to ensure the area of the vines was properly covered and specimens
identified.
A small “population” (i.e. several individuals) was recorded in the road reserve to the south of
the subject land (refer Photo Plates). This is a Council-managed area, contains various
infrastructure, e.g. electricity, stormwater and overhead powerlines.
Either due to historical land use or as a verge screen/buffer a variety of species have been
planted in this location (the date and reason for this planting is unknown). This includes rows of
matrush and lilly pilly. The potential that this vine was planted at this location cannot be
discounted, but for the purposes of this exercise the vine is considered to be “in the wild”.
The area associated with this population is also weed infested and comprises an entanglement
of vines, creepers, groundcovers and shrubs. The creeping inch plant (weed) is also prevalent in
this location.
The “edge” or outermost specimen/s were determined with a survey around the population and
extending beyond, i.e. to identify the “edge”.
While a GPS point is given {-26.4038; 153.0827}, it should be noted that canopy cover causes
error and is of little value under the circumstances. Importantly, the “larger” trees have

1
    PhD, MSc, BSC (Hons); Certified Environmental Practitioner; State-recognised botanist for protected flora survey.

                                                                                                                        1

Page 42

previously been marked by detailed survey and as such, the location (position) is well mapped
and confirmed due to the identification on the ground and by map of individual numbered trees.
A count was conducted to quantify the number of vines. By function of the growth form, it is not
possibly to determine the precise number of vines without potential destruction of the vines. The
vines have a main stem which is mostly below surface and finer stems with leaves/branchlets
are visible climbing into other vegetation or on the ground. It is apparent that one plant has
several stems potentially extending several meters.
It may be possible to get a better estimate of numbers if the stems where untwined and pulled
from the ground to determine if stems belonged to a single plant. This would undoubtably create
interference with the growth form and certainly damage (and most likely destroy) plants. Under
the circumstances, in my opinion, understanding the population “footprint” is more valuable
than destroying plants to provide an individual count.
Nevertheless, at least 17 stems where counted/tagged and likely these are from at least 6-8
(perhaps 10) individual plants 2.
The plants were located within an area some 22m by 5m aligned generally parallel to the road. A
map of the population is provided in the plans in Figure 1. Refer tree numbers (#) in the plans.
The southern/southwestern most individual was located near tree #71 and the most easterly
located just south of a timber power pole, nearest marked tree being #54.
The habitat quality at this location is be considered “moderate” but highly modified noting the
area has been planted out with “screen/landscape” plants including lomandra and lilly pilly, has
less invasion by the frangipani vine, has some native midstorey, but does have a weedy ground-
cover (including creeping inch plant) and has several pieces of infrastructure. The tangle of other
vines, creepers and native trees shrubs nevertheless provides “moderate” habitat for the Fraser
Island vine to “survive in the wild”.
Management Measures
By way of the approval conditions and stringent restricted clearing footprint, direct impacts to
the vines in the road reserve is highly unlikely. Nevertheless, specific measures to protect these
plants from the development are identified below.
General Protection of the Plants
A vegetated separation (screen/buffer) is retained (approximately 12m) between the road
reserve population and the clearing area (i.e. nearest cabin to the north) on the subject land.
The approved rehabilitation proposed also includes the planting with suitable native species in
the “buffer area” which separates the cabin in the south to the road reserve which contains the
“vine population”. Planting this area with suitable native species further “buffers” the road
reserve plants.




2
 A specimen has been lodged with the Queensland Herbarium and a Wildnet (State database) record has been
lodged.

                                                                                                           2

Page 43

Clear felling with heavy machinery is not proposed. Trees are selectively felled in a controlled
fashion to avoid inadvertent damage to trees for retention (and minimise dust plumes
associated with clearing).
The construction process is also to be sensitive in that heavy machinery, and earthworks are not
proposed. Construction is also limited to small areas of the site at any one time. The approved
Construction and Tree Management Plan outlines the process for vegetation protection and low
impact construction.
The rehabilitation plan will establish the entirety of the balance land with native vegetation. This
will further buffer/separate the road reserve population.
Physical Protection of Plants during Construction
The Construction and Tree Management Plan describes the construction measures to ensure
trees for retention are retained and inadvertent vegetation clearing is avoided. The road reserve
population occurs south of the subject land. A construction/tree protection fence would be
established along the southern boundary to prevent inadvertent clearing (or access) to this area.
The boundary is already partially cleared due to the existing infrastructure (e.g. cables) in this
area.
In addition, the vines (refer Figure 1) are also located south of large trees, meaning the trees
provide additional (physical) protection from any movement from the north (e.g. any machinery
moving southwards would not pass the large trees in any event 3).
Long-term Protection and Survival in Perpetuity
The group of vines are protected “from the development” (i.e. nature based accommodation) in
the long term by way of physical separation and associated rehabilitation as described above.
Rehabilitation and Weed Management
A site based rehabilitation plan has been approved for the subject land. The treatment of weeds
(including the invasive frangipani vine) and planting with native species on the subject land (i.e.
Lot 3 managed by RACV) will enhance the general ecological values of the local landscape.
Due to the poor condition of the subject land, specifically high level of weed infestation and
limited (to no) native understorey and midstorey, the rehabilitation exercise ensures a significant
improvement to the local environment (i.e. by establishing a native ecosystem that currently is
absent).
Establishing a Protected Population
The rehabilitation plan includes the planting of at least 67 Fraser Island vines in Zone 5. While
the vine is listed as near-threatened, it is readily available from nurseries and commonly used
as a screen/climbing plant. This species could (at the discretion of RACV) be further considered
in landscaping associated the subject land and existing resort.




3
    Noting none should be in this area for the project.

                                                                                                  3

Page 44

The rehabilitation plan and ongoing maintenance is a condition of approval. A contractor is
engaged to ensure the rehabilitation plan is appropriately implemented and maintained
(including weeding, watering, replacement planting).
The balance land beyond the development footprint (some ) rehabilitation area is also under a
covenant for conservation purposes.
RACV have onsite grounds staff to maintain (in perpetuity) the area following completion of
rehabilitation planting and maintenance.
The rehabilitation exercise establishes a population of Fraser Island vines within the
development (i.e. as part of the rehabilitation plan). This area is maintained for conservation
purposes, is under a covenant and ensures the survival of the species in this locality in
perpetuity. This is a positive conservation outcome advancing the “viability in the wild” of this
species.
Conclusion
Existing threats to the road reserve population of Fraser Island vine includes the “management”
of the area by Council. As described previously, this area is disturbed, contains
landscape/garden plantings and weed species. Recent disturbance/clearing (pers. obs.
October 2025) in the area (presumably by Council) for stormwater management has impacted
the vines. Long-term management of this area is a matter for others, i.e. not under the control
of RACV.
Physical separation between the nearest clearing area, a vegetated buffer and area to be
rehabilitated reduces any risk of impact to the group of vines.
The strict controls imposed for clearing and vegetation management (including on site
management/guidance during clearing and physical barriers/fences) further minimise any risk
of inadvertent disturbance (from the project) to the vines.
Weed management and rehabilitation with native species on the subject land improves the local
ecological landscape.
Finally, the establishment of a Fraser Island vine population within the subject land and under
the circumstances where it would be protected in perpetuity (under covenant and ongoing
management) is a positive and long-term conservation outcome for the species.


Encl.

    •   Photo Plate – Fraser Island vine
    •   Figure 1. Map of location of Fraser Island vines




                                                                                               4

Page 45

PHOTO PLATES




Photograph: Fraser Island vine - edge of Noosa Drive (road reserve) 15th October 2025 (J.Watson)




                                                                                                   5

Page 46

Figure 1A – Approved Plans with location of Tecomanthe hilli population
Note:

   •    See enlarged area in Figure 1B
   •    Nearest cabin6/7 corner is 6m from property boundary




                                                                          6

Page 47

                       A




                                      B



Figure 1B – Location of Tecomanthe hilli in Road Reserve
Note:

   •    For scale purposes = note (i) the 6m setback to boundary and (ii) distance between point A and B is 20m,
        i.e. southwest corner of subject site to edge of road
   •    Green labelled trees = trees to be retained
   •    Solid red line = six meter setback to development inside site boundary
   •    Red dashed polygons = location of Fraser Island vine (total area) = approximately 22m x 5m



                                                                                                              7

Page 48

      ADDENDUM

      The following is an Addendum to the Arborist Review, ‘25_11_24_AR_RACV_RACV v
      NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11’.

      Following the completion of Version 11, a severe weather event occurred throughout the South
      East of Queensland during the week of 24 November 2025. Whilst onsite completing the weed
      control, storm damage was reported by Biodiverse and Gwondana Ecology, who attended site
      and reported the following:

      ‘#51 (robusta) – this was a tree to be removed. The canopy has completely collapsed (looks
      like a lot of vine in the head). Tree is gone beyond return.’

      As such, this tree will no longer be included in the tree data as a functional Koala Tree and is
      now considered Redundant / Unsuitable; the plans are amended to reflect same.

Tag                         Oct                                                                May 2025    Oct 2025
      Common                       Oct 2025                 Spread    DBH       May 2025
 ID               Age      2025                Height (m)                                      Retention   Retention
       Name                        Structure                 (m)     @1.4m     Comments
  #                       Health                                                                Status      Status
                                                                             Increased vine
                                                                                 density.
                                                                                 Canopy
                                                                                engulfed.


                                                                              This tree was
                                                                                lost during
                                                                              storms across
       Swamp      Over                                                       SEQ during the
51                        Poor       Poor        14-6        14-6     1.5                      Remove      Remove
      Mahogany   mature
                                                                                  week of
                                                                              24/11/2025, is
                                                                             now redundant /
                                                                             Unsuitable, and
                                                                                 no longer
                                                                               considered a
                                                                               viable Koala
                                                                                   Tree.


The tree totals are amended as follows:


ALL SURVEYED TREES ON SITE                                  242
TREES RETAINED                                              139
TREES REMOVED                                               103

KOALA TREES ON SITE                                         122
KOALA TREES RETAINED                                        85
KOALA TREES REMOVED                                         37




      25_12_03_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_Addendum                               Page 1 of 2

Page 49

The data has been amended in the                          spreadsheet       to   reflect    the   following:
‘25_12_03_DATA_VTA_RACV_OpWorks’

Appendix 6: Analysis of Change – Spreadsheet Extract Oct 2025 is updated to the following:




Should you have any queries or wish to discuss the information contained in this review,
please do not hesitate to contact me.




Yours sincerely,



_______________________
Matthew Duncan
Director / Principal Arborist
Level 5 AQF Arborist

Matthew has worked in the arboricultural industry since 1994 and established Consult Arborist in 2011 on the
Sunshine Coast. He is a Qualified Consult member of the Queensland Arboricultural Association, holds an AQF
Level 5 Diploma in Arboriculture (AHC50510) and is International Society of Arboriculture Tree Risk Assessment
Qualified from 2015 to 2030.




25_12_03_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V11_Addendum                                    Page 2 of 2

Used in these records

About this file

File size
7.2 MB (large file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Approved Document Aborist Tree Rention Review OPW25-0206.pdf · 7.2 MB (large file)

The download may take up to a minute.

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.