2018-03-06 Services & Organisation Committee Agenda

SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA   6 MARCH 2018


                                                                    Attachment 1




                                                    Page 45 of 79

SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA    6 MARCH 2018

                                            Final Evaluation                          Attachment 1
      NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
[Gonmaie: —_Yromonomcntowdvas         |
     pce
      (Conforming Tenders Only) (excl of GST)
     1
     2
     3
     4 [RiCon Contractors Ptyttd $884,227)
    [ee                  ee)
     ;
     7 [Te Ss          a ee cage
     8 [Cia Ree Siok Sees 1 ne
     ya          a   ee | fa   |
     10 [eee es Sa Se ee ee)
      NON-CONFORMING TENDERS

      somoarraneowcne | tse | | om | os | sx | wm | om | m | rom | 0 | om | 0 | om | o | om | o | om] o | om | o | om |
      fontacrtpeeneencancry | asx | so | so | | soso | wo | om | es | sas | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om] o | om | o | om |
      fweodoos    |  tm | ws | as [ts | vo [ss | so | wes | os | io | om | io | om [ o | om] o | om | o | om | 0 | om |
     funy        | mw | sm | | amo | | smo | oo | am | oo | om | o [om] o | om | o | om] o | om | o | om |
     femmasaey    |     |  | am [ms | sae | mo | ao | oo [om | io | om | o | om] o | om | o | om] o | om | o | om |
      emronmencasunananiry |e | | sm | | zo | wm | so | so [2m | o | om | > [ om] o | om | o | om] o | om | o | om |
     fowmanvicaonm |   |» | oo | as [oo || sm | os[em| o [om | o [om | o [om] o | ow |e | om |e | om |
     Ce
                                           ae           i    1      |     |     7

      Total Fees (Pc)      $671,800 $747,227 $580,110 $444,227
      Average Fees (Pav) $.....csesseessseeneenne
      Price Score           90     78     105    127
      Normalised Price Score (Pn) 71 61   83     100
      Weighted Price Score (Pw) | :     a cape inst
                                    a =             Ct: 7              1.  | «4
      | __Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member2 | Jaro Bauleka and weightings of this evaluation ee
 [Assesment PanelMember2 |     Callas Bickley
                                               [Contract Administrator's signature: | aro Bauleka
      LS Seve es
      EEE aS
                                                        Page 45 of 79