Council archive · source document
Minor Change Report MCU14 0076.01 · MCU14/0076.01
APPLICATION FOR AN OTHER CHANGE TO A DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL Author Development Planners, Nadine Kirley & Billy Glover Development Assessment APPLICATION DETAILS Application No. MCU14/0076.01 Development Approval Development Permit for Material Change of Use of Premises - Detached House Applicant Sandra Lee Baldwin Request Received On 16 December 2019 PROPERTY DETAILS Property Address 33 Tristania Dr Marcus Beach RP Description Lot 14 M 11111 Land Area 685m2 Existing Use of Land Detached House STATUTORY DETAILS SEQRP Designation Urban Footprint Locality Eastern Beaches Zone Detached Housing Overlays Natural Resource Overlay (Coastal Protection) Assessment Type Other Change to Development Approval PROPOSAL The applicant seeks approval to change an existing development approval for the detached house constructed on Lot 14 on Plan M.1111.1 at 33 Tristania Drive, Marcus Beach. The proposed change includes a new building layout that comprises 4 bedrooms over 3 levels. The existing pool located 2 metres from the boundary is to be removed and a new pool incorporated into the deck and cantilevered over the lower level. Reduced setbacks are proposed to the rear coastal boundary where cantilevered building elements extend up to 1 metre into the setback area. The proposed pool and upper ground floor balcony extend into the setback area with the building foundations set back at 6 metres. The roof overhang of the upper ground floor also further extends approximately 0.9m into the setback. Figure 1: Aerial Photo background A Development Permit for Material Change of Use of Premises - Detached House was approved subject to conditions (MCU14/0076) on 10 October 2014. The 3 bedroom, 2 storey house was subsequently built generally in accordance with the approval. The applicant sought a minor change application to the original approval for the new building layout comprising 4 bedrooms over 3 levels with reduced setback to the rear. In considering the proposal against the minor change test and what may be considered substantially different development as outlined in the DA rules, the application has been determined to result in a dramatic change in the built form in terms of scale, bulk and appearance. On the advice of Council officers, the applicant subsequently changed the application to a ‘Other Changes’ application. assessment Instruments for Statutory Assessment Under the Planning Act 2016 the application must be assessed against each of the following statutory planning instruments to the extent they are relevant to the development: State Planning Policy; South East Queensland Regional Plan; Planning Regulation 2017; The Noosa Plan. The following codes from the Noosa Plan are applicable to this development: Detached House Code Natural Resources Code Statutory Process The applicant has requested to make an ‘other change’ to a development approval under s78 of the Planning Act 2016. Statutory Instruments – Planning Scheme The application has been found to generally comply with the applicable statutory instruments with the following exceptions: Criteria Planning Scheme Proposal Complies Site Area Not applicable 685m² - Site cover 50/30 or 40/40% Lower ground 12.5% Upper ground 49% Upper level 22% X Building height storeys metres 2 storeys max 8 metres 2 storeys 8 metres Boundary setbacks Frontage Side (south) Side (north) Rear 6 metres min < metres min < metres min 6 metres min 6m to wall/ 5.1m to OMP 2/2 metres 2.1/2 metres 5 metres to balcony X Roof form Pitch Eaves Avoids parapets >5 degrees 75% Square parapets X The proposed change comprises a new building design which substantially replaces the existing dwelling house on the site. A reduced setback to the rear, seaward boundary is proposed. The dwelling design is stepped down the slope of the land and includes an additional, lower ground level. The pertinent issues of the assessment together with assessment of the requested changes to the conditions on the decision notice are discussed below: Condition 2 2. Development undertaken in accordance with this approval must generally comply with the approved plans of development. The approved plans are listed in the following table unless otherwise amended by these conditions. Plan No. Rev. Plan/Document Name Date Sheet 1 Site Plan, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Sheet 2 Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Sheet 3 Upper Floor Plan, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Sheet 4 Elevations, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Sheet 5 Elevation, prepared by Dwyer Quality Homes 30.7.14 Applicant’s Request The applicant has requested that Condition 2 be changed to replace the approved plans with the new house plans as follows: 2. Development undertaken in accordance with this approval must generally comply with the approved plans of development. The approved plans are listed in the following table unless otherwise amended by these conditions. Plan No. Rev. Plan/Document Name Date SD2.01 P Lower Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD2.02 P Upper Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD2.03 P First Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD3.01 P Elevations – south, west, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD3.02 P Elevations – north, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD3.02 P Elevations – east, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD4.02 P Section CV, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 Assessment of Request The proposed detached house is substantially different in size, bulk and form from that of the existing building. The following considerations are made in respect of the proposed building: Height The applicant maintains in the submitted material that the proposal remains within the height limit of 8 metres and 2 storeys. The plans provided by the applicant showed the subfloor area on the lower level with a fully enclosed space with floor, walls and ceiling. The space is not consistent with the definition of a basement and therefore would be counted a part of the storey containing the lower ground level. In response to Council’s concerns for development over height, the applicant has revised the drawings to leave this space as natural ground level and open such that it can be considered subfloor and not count as a storey. The revised plans identified as Revision J & K, result in a 2 storey building and the over height aspect is removed as the natural ground level is not being altered in this location. Due to subsequent amendments to the plans associated with separate matters the current version of plans is Revision P – these plans reflect the changes provided in Revisions J and K and are appropriate for approval in relation to building height. Condition 3 is to be amended to ensure that the subfloor area is retained and the development is limited to two storeys. Site Cover Probable Solution S11.1 in the Detached Housing Code requires a detached house with 2 or more storeys to achieve 50% site cover for the ground floor and 30% site cover for the upper storey(s) or 40% for all storeys. Specific Outcome O11 seeks to maintain an appropriate scale that is compatible with its surroundings, minimise excessive bulk and maintain sufficient landscaping on the site. The applicant has sought to calculate site cover differently from how the officer assessment has been undertaken, this has resulted in numerous discussions. Primary to the discussions has been officer’s requirement for the pool to be included in the site cover calculation for the upper ground floor. The applicant has maintained that site cover of the pool should be allocated to the ground floor. This is not accepted as the pool level is approximately 4.2 metres above the ground surface and is directly accessed from the upper ground floor deck. Access to the pool from the ground level can only be made via 17 steps which provide access from the ground level and the upper level deck. Furthermore, there is no floor level below the pool. The Probable Outcome permits a site cover of 50% on the ground floor and 30% for the upper storey(s). In this instance the proposal does not comply with the Probable Solution as 50% site is proposed to the middle storey. However, it is reasonable to allocate the 50% allowance to the middle storey as this level appears as the ground floor when viewed from the street and the building generally maintains the form and bulk or a 2 storey building. Furthermore the lower ground is a consequence of the topography of the site, which falls away from the street, and is located to the rear of the site. Restricting the 50% allowance to the lower ground floor would be impractical as it would result in an unreasonable amount of earthworks and prevent suitable vehicle access to a garage at this level. Based on acceptance of 50% site cover for the middle storey it is noted that both the lower ground and upper floors do not exceed 30% site cover, with the upper floor being well below this requirement with 22% site cover. The proposal can be justified against Specific Outcome O11 of the Detached House Code. In the context of nearby buildings and structures in the area, the bulk and scale of the proposed detached house is consistent with neighbouring properties. Photographs taken on site from the existing upper level of the detached house illustrate the substantially sized dwellings which exist either side of the subject site (Refer Figures 2 & 3 below). Figure 2: House on southern boundary at 35 Tristania Drive Figure 3: House north of site at 31 Tristania Drive The proposal is consistent with the scale of nearby, predominantly residential detached housing, within a secluded vegetated setting. The proposed 4 bedroom house is considered to be of a domestic scale despite the inconsistency with the requirement that 50% site cover be limited to the ground floor. The proposed detached house is unlikely to result in any significant change to amenity of adjoining and surrounding properties. Setback The proposed setback to the seaward coastal boundary is reduced from the 6 metres required by Specific Outcome O21 of the Natural Resources Overlay. The foundations of the building design remain at the 6 metre setback with cantilevered elements within the setback area. The lower ground floor balcony, upper ground floor balcony and pool are all cantilevered into the setback with a further encroachment by the roof overhang. The Overall Outcomes for the code require that, f) for Coastal Protection Areas, development — i does not adversely impact upon natural coastal processes; and ii is designed and sited to protect the natural beach experience and visual amenity enjoyed by residents and others. The proposed dwelling is located outside of the landslide hazard area and is indicated as being affected by draft coastal hazards mapping. As such, the cantilevered design is considered unlikely to result in any adverse impact on the natural coastal processes as the building does not touch the ground except for the stair stringers on the lower level. This is considered to be a minor encroachment and is unlikely to affect stability or coastal processes to any great degree. It is also noted that the latest erosion prone mapping for 2040, 2070 and 2100 does not apply to the site. The overhanging roof line is well above ground level. The existing buildings either side of the site are sited approximately 3.5 and 2 metres from the seaward boundary and will not be impacted by the reduced setback proposed on the subject site. The extension to the existing building footprint will bring the building wall eastward by approximately 14.5 metres. All but 1.0 metre of this extension, which extends into the 6 metre coastal boundary setback area, could be reasonably expected to be occupied by a 2 storey dwelling. The 1.0 metre wide cantilevered part of the building is considered to have minor to negligible additional impact on the views and amenity of the neighbouring properties. Site photographs from the upper level of the existing building indicate that no substantial change in the view or point of interest appears to be within the view line visible from existing adjacent dwellings, which would be significantly impacted by extension of the subject house (see Figures 4 & 5). There are no substantial windows or open decks on the southern side of the adjacent dwelling to the north of the site which would be impacted by the proposed reduced setback. It is considered that eastward extension of the building on the subject site is not likely to have a significant adverse effect on views from the adjacent dwelling to the north. Figure 4: View north east from existing upper level. The property to the south is orientated towards the north and east. Some upper level windows may capture views to the ocean, a northern and eastern facing deck (situated behind blinds in figure 5) currently obtains views across the subject site. The difference between the views that would be impacted by a 2 storey building set back at 6 metres compared to the proposed reduced setback of 5 metres on the upper level, is considered to be negligible as demonstrated by the estimated view lines in Figure 7. It is noted that the adjoining building to the north is setback approximately 2 metres from the seaward boundary and will currently impede the view lines of the property to the south of the subject site. Figure 5: View south east from existing upper level. Figure 6: Extent of encroachment into setback area by upper level cantilever Figure 7: Difference in impact on views between 6m and 5m setback The analysis of the degree of difference in the viewshed with the building sited at 6 metres setback vs 5 metres setback reveals that the difference in impact between the two siting locations is negligible. It is considered that the revised set of plans are considered suitable for approval as follows: 2. Development undertaken in accordance with this approval must generally comply with the approved plans of development. The approved plans are listed in the following table unless otherwise amended by these conditions. Plan No. Rev. Plan/Document Name Date SD2.01 P Lower Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD2.02 P Upper Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD2.03 P First Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield 12.06.2020 SD2.04 J Roof Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects as annotated by Council 25.02.2020 SD3.01 P Elevations – south, west, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD3.02 P Elevations – north, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD3.03 P Elevations – east, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD4.01 J Sections A, B prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects as annotated by Council 25.02.2020 SD4.02 P Section C, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects as annotated by Council 12.06.2020 Condition 5 Setbacks 5. The pool must be setback a minimum of 2 metres from the eastern (seaward) boundary and a minimum of 1 metre from the side boundaries. Applicant’s Request The buildings must be setback a minimum of 5 metres from the eastern (seaward) boundary. Assessment of Request The applicant proposes to build a pool to a podium level on the upper ground floor which will be cantilevered into the setback area of the seaward boundary. No specific information has been provided indicating that the existing pool will be removed, however, if this is to be the case, the condition as currently written would be largely superfluous as the new pool structure is proposed no closer to the boundary than the proposed building itself. It is recommended that the condition be amended to reflect the situation of the reduced setback as follows: 5. Buildings, other structures and retaining walls are setback a minimum of 6m from the seaward boundary of the site except for cantilevered elements as varied by the approved plans. Condition 8 8. Dense vegetation must be planted between the pool and eastern boundary for the full length of the pool in accordance with Council’s Planning Scheme Policy PSP3 Landscaping Plants and Guidelines. The planted vegetation must consist of native, endemic species Applicant’s Request Dense vegetation must be planted between the building and eastern boundary for the full length of the building in accordance with Council’s Planning Scheme Policy PSP3 Landscaping Plants and Guidelines. The planted vegetation must consist of native, endemic species. Assessment of Request Planting of dense vegetation in the setback area to the seaward boundary on the coastal dune is considered necessary to help protect the site from potential erosion. The condition as proposed by the applicant does not clearly articulate the width or density that this planting needs to be in order to be deemed compliant and therefore it is considered that further detail should be included in the condition as well as additional conditions that clarify the landscaping requirements for the site in this regard. It is recommended that Condition 8 be changed as follows: A minimum 5 metre wide soft landscape buffer must be provided along the eastern, seaward site boundary setback as annotated by Council on the approved plans. Additional conditions relating to landscaping and coastal protection are recommended as follows: A minimum of 20% of the site must be retained as soft landscaping. Native trees and shrubs selected from the preferred plant species list for Coastal Beachfront Areas in Planning Scheme Policy PSP03 Landscaping Plants and Guidelines are to be planted in the 5 metre landscape buffer. Vegetation must be planted to cover at least 50% of the 5 metre setback area between the proposed detached house and the eastern boundary of the site in accordance with Council’s Planning Scheme Policy PSP3 Landscaping Plants and Guidelines. The remaining 50% may be planted turf species capable of withstanding coastal environment otherwise must be planted out with native trees and shrubs. The planted vegetation must have a minimum pot size of 140 mm and consist of native, endemic species with a mature over-storey height of not less than 1.5 metres and a maximum spacing of 3.0 metre centres. All landscape works must be maintained generally in accordance with the approved design for the life of the development. Coastal Protection To protect the vegetation and the coastal dune from damage or degradation during construction temporary fencing or the like must be installed along the coastal boundary prior to commencing any building works on site and maintained until completion of the building. No vehicle parking, access, or storage of construction materials is permitted within the adjacent foreshore reserve at any time. draft planning scheme The Draft New Noosa Plan identifies the site within the Low Density Residential Zone. Under the new planning scheme, a Detached Dwelling would be identified as a Dwelling House and would be accepted development subject to requirements. Assessment against the following codes would be required if the proposal did not meet the acceptable solutions of the identified criteria: Low Density Residential Zone Code Low Density Housing Code The site would be subject to the following overlays under the draft scheme: Acid Sulfate Soils Overlay Bushfire Hazard Overlay Coastal Protection Overlay Landslide Hazard Overlay The draft scheme differs from the current scheme in that the Bushfire Hazard Overlay, Acid Sulfate Soils Overlay and Landslide Hazard Overlay are not currently applicable to the site. The overlays would trigger the application up to Code assessment as does the Coastal Hazards trigger in the current scheme. The minimum rear boundary setback in the draft planning scheme is identified as 6 metres in the Coastal Protection Overlay where a coastal building line does not exist, which is consistent with the current scheme requirements. The proposed development is otherwise generally consistent with the Draft Planning Scheme requirements. cONSULTATION State Referrals The application was referred to the following Referral Agencies: Department of Infrastructure, Local Government and Planning (SARA) The Director-General of the Department of State Development, Manufacturing, Infrastructure and Planning is a referral agency for Unexploded Ordinance and the referral is managed by SARA. The department has responded advising that written confirmation must be provided to the department by an approved contractor that confirms the site has been remediated and cleared of unexploded ordinances. The department has also advised that residual unexploded ordinance may still exist on site and caution should be taken during remediation and construction work. 5.2 Other Referrals The application was forwarded to the following internal Council specialists: Development Engineer Environment Officer Comments from Council’s Development Engineer and environment officer have been incorporated into the above assessment. conclusion & reasons for decision The application for an Other Change to a Material Change of Use of Premises – Detached House seeks to substantially increase the size and bulk of the dwelling and proposes reduced setbacks to the rear boundary in the Coastal Protection Area. The proposed building foundation will remain outside of the 6 metres setback required by the Natural Hazards Overlay, with cantilevered elements encroaching into the setback area. The only part of the building touching the ground within the setback area are the stairs from the lower balcony. That part of the upper level which is screened with louvres and encroaches into the 6 metre setback has a negligible impact on views compared to a 6 metre setback. The site falls outside of the Erosion Prone area identified for the 2070 horizon and the encroachment on the building is unlikely to result in any significant adverse impacts on coastal resources or interrupt the natural cycles of erosion and accretion of foreshore area. The applicant’s response to Council officers’ concerns relating to height addresses the potential over-height issue by maintaining the area below Living 2 and Bedroom 2 as natural ground able to be considered subfloor. The site cover of the building at the upper ground floor level exceeds the site cover permitted for a floor above a ground floor. The allocation of the permitted 50% site cover to the upper ground floor is reasonable in this instance due to the topography of the site and that it is unlikely to result in any significant additional bulk and scale or impact on the capacity to provide meaningful landscaping and outdoor open space or facilities. It is therefore able to be justified against the Specific Outcome for the Detached House Code in this instance. RECOMMENDATION With regard to Application No. MCU14/0076.01, to make an Other Change to an existing approval for Material Change of Use of Premises – Detached House situated at 33 Tristania Dr Marcus Beach described as Lot 14 M 11111, as provided in accordance with Section 63(5) of the Planning Act 2016, Council on 15 June 2020 decided to: A. Approve the change. B. Amend conditions 2, 3, 5 & 8 to read as follows: 2. Development undertaken in accordance with this approval must generally comply with the approved plans of development. The approved plans are listed in the following table unless otherwise amended by these conditions. Plan No. Rev. Plan/Document Name Date SD2.01 P Lower Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD2.02 P Upper Ground Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD2.03 P First Floor Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD2.04 J Roof Plan, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects as annotated by Council 25.02.2020 SD3.01 P Elevations – south, west, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD3.02 P Elevations – north, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD3.03 P Elevations – east, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects 12.06.2020 SD4.01 J Sections A, B prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects as annotated by Council 25.02.2020 SD4.02 P Section C, prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects as annotated by Council 12.06.2020 3. The maximum height of the development must not exceed 8 metres above the finished ground level and the natural ground surface and 2 storeys. In this regard, the subfloor must remain as shown on the section plans prepared by Tim Ditchfield Architects and dated 25.02.2020 and 12.06.2020. The subfloor must remain and must not be modified so as to constitute a storey. 5. Buildings, other structures and retaining walls are setback a minimum of 6m from the seaward boundary of the site except for cantilevered elements as varied by the approved plans. A minimum 5 metre wide soft landscape buffer must be provided along the eastern, seaward site boundary setback as annotated by Council on the approved plans. C. Include additional conditions 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16: A minimum of 20% of the site must be retained as soft landscaping. Native trees and shrubs selected from the preferred plant species list for Coastal Beachfront Areas in Planning Scheme Policy PSP03 Landscaping Plants and Guidelines are to be planted in the 5 metre landscape buffer. Vegetation must be planted to cover at least 50% of the 5 metre setback area between the proposed detached house and the eastern boundary of the site in accordance with Council’s Planning Scheme Policy PSP3 Landscaping Plants and Guidelines. The remaining 50% may be planted turf species capable of withstanding coastal environment otherwise must be planted out with native trees and shrubs. The planted vegetation must have a minimum pot size of 140 mm and consist of native, endemic species with a mature over-storey height of not less than 1.5 metres and a maximum spacing of 3.0 metre centres. All landscape works must be maintained generally in accordance with the approved design for the life of the development. Coastal Protection To protect the vegetation and the coastal dune from damage or degradation during construction temporary fencing or the like must be installed along the coastal boundary prior to commencing any building works on site and maintained until completion of the building. No vehicle parking, access, or storage of construction materials is permitted within the adjacent foreshore reserve at any time. [word/footer1.xml] Page 14 of 14 [word/header1.xml] 3 [Attachment: image6.png (image text)] Tn ‘nani [Attachment: image7.png (image text)] = Xisting house on subject sit = 7 metre 35)
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
Minor Change Report MCU14 0076.01Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 5.6 MB (large file)
- File type
- DOCX
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take up to a minute.