Skip to the record
The gold standard in government transparency.

Council archive · source document

Minor Change Report 132001 210319 1 · 132001.210319.1

of 10

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

               APPLICATION FOR A MINOR CHANGE TO A DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL
               Author                  Development Planner, Matt Pinese
                                       Development Assessment



                    APPLICATION DETAILS

                    Application No.                  132001.210319.1

                    Development Approval             Development Approval

                    Applicant                        Sarah Marie Cassidy and Andrew Cassidy

                    Request Received On              28 June 2024

                    Report Reviewed By               Andrew Gaffney – 27 November 2024

                    Decision Due Date


                    PROPERTY DETAILS

                    Property Address                 39 Douglas Street, Sunshine Beach Qld 4567

                    RP Description                   Lot 321 RP 48111

                    Land Area                        242.5m2

                    Existing Use of Land             Dwelling House


                    STATUTORY DETAILS

                    SEQRP Designation                Urban Footprint

                    Zone                             Medium Density Residential

                    Precinct                         Not applicable

                    Local Area Plan                  Not applicable

                    Overlays                         Landslide Hazard Overlay Map (OM-LS)
                                                        - High Hazard Area
                                                        - Moderate Hazard Area

                    Assessment Type                  Minor Change to Development Approval



               1.      PROPOSAL
               The applicant seeks approval to change to an existing development approval for Material Change
               of Use to establish Three Non-complying Dwelling Houses (132001. 210319 (22437 DA)).
               The locality and proposal plan are included below.
                                                                                                  Page 1 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024
Full text of the other 9 pages

Page 2

                                               Figure 1 - Locality




                                              Figure 2 - Site Plan




                                       Figure 3 - Lower Ground Floor Plan

                                                                            Page 2 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024

Page 3

                                               Figure 4 - Ground Floor Plan




                                               Figure 5 - Level 1 Floor Plan




                                       Figure 6 – Southeast and Northeast Elevations




                                                                                       Page 3 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024

Page 4

                                          Figure 7 – Northwest and South West Elevations

               2.     BACKGROUND
               A development approval for Material Change of Use to establish ‘three Non-complying Dwelling
               Houses’ was approved on 29 November 2001 (22437 DA).
               On 17 July 2002, Council approved a change to the development approval which involved
               changing conditions 18 and 25 and deleting condition 20.
               The adjoining site to the southwest (37 Douglas Street) has a similar non-conforming dwelling
               approval in place over the site since 17 August 2009. The development has not been carried out
               and there has been several requests to extend the currency period for this approval. The currency
               period for this development approval is valid until 30 June 2025.
               An extract of the Northeast Elevation and Upper Floor Plan are included below to demonstrate how
               this approval if it proceeds will interface with the proposed development resulting from this minor
               change.




                                                                                                    Page 4 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024

Page 5

                        Figure 8 - Northeast Elevation of Approved Development at 37 Douglas Street, Sunshine Beach




                          Figure 9 - First Floor Plan of Approved Development at 37 Douglas Street, Sunshine Beach


               Of note is that the building separation between the first floor of the approved adjoining development
               at 37 Douglas Street (not constructed) and the addition of the proposed Level 1 floor above the
               existing rear pod are approximately 2.0 metres.
               Furthermore, these proposed and approved sections of each building interface with passageways
               and bathrooms with covered windows.
               Similarly, the adjoining property to the northeast, on Lot 320 is an existing 2-storey development
               that was approved and constructed at the same time as the subject development. There are no
               windows that interface between these buildings which would reduce the privacy of occupants.
               The setbacks between the upper levels result in a building separation of approximately 2.0 metres.




                          Figure 10 - First Floor Plan of Approved Development at 37 Douglas Street, Sunshine Beach



               2.1. Site Description
               The site has an area of 242m² (32.0 metres x 7.5 metres in dimension) with two frontages.
               Douglas Street is located at the site’s southern frontage with Douglas Lane to its northern frontage.


               2.2. Surrounding Land Uses
               Douglas Lane is located directly to the north of the site which is a 6.5 metre wide unsealed
               landscaped road reserve not accessible by vehicle traffic. This reserve area provides a dual
               function as both an informal pedestrian pathway between Byant Street to the east and Duke Street
               to the west and a visual buffer to the rear of the subject site as shown at Figure 9.
               Existing dwellings within proximity to the site and to the north of Dougals Lane are three; similar
               styled Dwelling houses located at 50, 52 and 54 Ferguson Street (ie Dwelling houses also located
               on small lots of 242m²). The Dwelling houses at 52 and 54 Ferguson Street (Fig 11, red line work)
               contain a balcony and windows that are orientated south towards Dougals Lane.



                                                                                                             Page 5 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024

Page 6

               A site inspection on 12 November 2024 confirms that the width and height (approx. 6-8 metres) of
               vegetation along the length of Douglas Lane provides a substantial landscaped screen between
               buildings located to the north and south of the lane. Further, the more elevated topography along
               Ferguson Street reduces the potential for any direct overlooking.
               The upper floor rear extension will contain a bedroom and ensuite at the rear façade only (no
               external balcony) which will restricts any reverse amenity impacts between properties.




                   Figure 11 - Existing site and development (yellow shade) and the vegetated Dougals Lane located between
                                                   buildings to the north of the site (red outline).



               3.      ASSESSMENT
               3.1. Instruments for Statutory Assessment
               Under the Planning Act 2016 the application must be assessed against each of the following
               statutory planning instruments to the extent they are relevant to the development:
               •       State Planning Policy;
               •       South East Queensland Regional Plan;
               •       Planning Regulation 2017; and
               •       The Noosa Plan 2020.
               3.2. Statutory Process
               The applicant has requested to make a minor change to a development approval under s78 of the
               Planning Act 2016. An application for a minor change to a development approval can only be made
               in circumstances where a change would constitute a ‘minor change’.
               The proposed change to the development approval requested by the applicant is determined to
               constitute a minor change on the grounds that:
               •       the development would not result in substantially different development as the proposal is
                       to make additions and alterations to the existing dwelling that include:
                            o reconfiguring the ground floor;
                            o developing a second storey; and
                            o making cosmetic improvements to the external façade of the building;
               •       the change does not include prohibited development;
               •       the change would not require the application to be referred to an additional referral agency
                       or cause a referral agency to have regard to new matters prescribed by regulation;


                                                                                                             Page 6 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024

Page 7

               •       where the original application was code assessable, the change would not cause the
                       application to become impact assessable.
               3.3. Statutory Instruments – Planning Scheme
               The following codes from the Noosa Plan 2020 are applicable to this development:
               •       Medium Density Residential Zone Code;
               •       Low Density Housing Code;
               •       Works Codes;
               •       Landslide Hazard Overlay Code.
               The below discusses the proposed changes consistency with planning scheme provisions in place
               at the time the original development application was made and the current planning scheme
               provisions.
               The 1997 Strategic Plan
               The proposal remains consistent with the key provisions of the 1997 Strategic Plan.
               Provision: Are low rise and which respect the scale of vegetation in the particular part of
               the locality.
               Comment: The proposed changes maintain a low rise (2-storey) dwelling. The built form changes
               are either internal or are located at the rear of the dwelling, which is not visible from the street. The
               proposal maintains the vegetation in the road reserve.
               Provision: Have low site impact, enhancing the opportunity to maintain natural site
               characteristics.
               Comment: The proposed change will have a low site impact as the second storey is located within
               or above the existing curtilage of the dwelling and will not require any earthworks.
               Provision: Integrate with the landform, by stepping along or with the dune systems, without
               the need for extensive cutting and filling.
               The changes will maintain the existing landform and not require any cutting or filling to occur.
               Provision: Vary in line and plane, complementing the landform changes and landscapes,
               which are characteristic of the area.
               Comment: The proposed changes integrate with the existing development by stepping horizontally
               and vertically. The design also incorporates shade elements including open timber pergolas,
               awnings, batten screens and louvres. The proposed façade improvements also incorporate timber
               weatherboard cladding and complement the surrounding development.
               Provision: Promote the concept of small separate building entities, rather than large single,
               bulky developments.
               Comment: The changes to the dwelling maintain the concept of a small separate building entity,
               located on a small 242m2 lot.


               Noosa Plan 2020
               The application has been assessed against the Acceptable Outcomes of the applicable codes and
               generally complies. Where compliance is not met with the Acceptable Outcome, the corresponding
               performance outcomes or overall outcomes of the code are addressed below.

                   Performance Outcomes                             Comment

                   Plot Ratio                                       Meets the performance criteria for PO11
                   PO11
                                                                    Performance outcome PO11 provides a
                   Plot ratio of development:
                                                                    prescriptive requirement that Plot Ratio for

                                                                                                         Page 7 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024

Page 8

                     a. does not exceed 0.4:1; or                development does not exceed 0.4:1 (where not
                     b. for small dwellings or for development   for small dwellings). The proposed additions
                        which provides a ratio of at least       and alterations would increase the plot ratio of
                        three small dwellings to one             the site from 0.69:1 (167m2) to 192.9m2
                        other dwelling, does not exceed 0.5:1.   (0.79:1) being a 0.1 or 25m2 increase.
                                                                 It is noted that each of three lots are small lot
                                                                 (signficantantly less than 450m2), with Lot 321
                                                                 being 243m2. The size of this lot coupled with
                                                                 the proposed additions, would amplify the
                                                                 increase to plot ratio resulting from this change
                                                                 to the development.
                                                                 The proposed extension would increase the
                                                                 plot ratio of the building to 0.48:1. Despite the
                                                                 non-compliance with Performance Outcome
                                                                 PO11, it is considered that the proposal
                                                                 achieves the overall outcomes and purpose of
                                                                 the of the Medium Density Residential Zone
                                                                 Code.

                Building Setback                                 Meets the performance criteria for PO12
                PO12
                                                                  a. the proposal will provide a high level of
                Buildings and structures are designed and
                                                                     amenity to users of the subject site and
                sited to:
                                                                     the adjoining premises. This includes
                a. provide a high level of amenity to users of       provision of visual and acoustic privacy
                     the subject site and adjoining premises,        and access to sunlight in that it will
                     including provision of visual and acoustic      provide improved living spaces within the
                     privacy;                                        dwelling, connection to the rear pod, and
                                                                     shaded outdoor living areas.
                b. not unreasonably obstruct views or cause
                                                                     The proposed encroachments relate to a
                     overlooking of private open space or
                                                                     small portion of the wall and eaves
                     habitable areas of adjoining premises;
                                                                     between 4.5m and 6.7m.
                c. provide adequate distance from adjoining          The encroachments are setback greater
                     land uses;                                      than or consistent with the setback of the
                d. preserve existing vegetation that will help       existing lower level and the adjoining
                     buffer development;                             dwelling at Lot 320 on RP48111;
                                                                  b. the encroaching elements would not
                e. allow for space and landscaping to be             unreasonably obstruct views or cause
                     provided between buildings including            overlooking opportunities upon the
                     adequate       area   at ground   level for     private open space or habitable areas of
                     landscaping with trees, shrubs, outdoor         adjoining premises, as it interfaces with a
                     living and utilities;                           blank wall associated with the adjoining
                f.   be consistent with the predominant              dwelling to the northeast (Lot 321) and
                     character of the surrounding area; and          will not overlook the adjoining dwelling to
                                                                     the southwest;
                g. protect the natural character and avoid        c. the additions will maintain the existing
                     adverse impacts on ecologically important       separation to the adjoining dwellings,
                     areas such as national parks, waterways         which is adequate to protect their
                     and wetlands.                                   amenity;
                                                                  d. the additions are located within and
                                                                     above the curtilage of the existing
                                                                     dwelling and will not impact on any
                                                                     vegetation within the site;
                                                                  e. the existing lots and dwellings within this
                                                                     development are on a small lot and there


                                                                                                     Page 8 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024

Page 9

                                                                        is limited space for landscaping between
                                                                        buildings;
                                                                   f.   the proposal is consistent with the
                                                                        predominant character of the streetscape
                                                                        which includes a mixture of two storey
                                                                        dwelling houses on small lots and large 2
                                                                        and 3 storey multiple dwellings; and
                                                                   g.   the proposal would not result in any
                                                                        adverse impacts to ecologically important
                                                                        areas.
                                                                  Further information about the separation and
                                                                  interface of the proposed development with the
                                                                  existing and approved adjoining development
                                                                  is included in the background section of this
                                                                  report above.

               Condition 18
               Development undertaken in accordance with this approval must generally comply with the
               approved plans of development. The approved plans are numbered DSH.319.03, DSH.319.05,
               DSH.320.03, DSH.320.05, DSH.320.06, DSH.321.03, DSH.GEN.02, DSH.GEN.03 prepared by
               Will Franklin and dated 8.7.02 and as may be amended by these conditions.
               Applicant’s Request
               The applicant submitted Proposal Plans showing the minor changes to the existing dwelling at 39
               (Lot 321) Douglas Street, Noosa Heads.
               Assessment of Request
               It is recommended that this condition be amended to include the new approved plans for 39 (Lot
               321) Douglas Street, Noosa Heads.
               It is noted that this minor change only relates to Lot 321 and that the plans references relating to
               the other dwellings on Lot 320 and Lot 319 are to be maintained.


               Amended Condition
               Development undertaken in accordance with this approval must generally comply with the
               approved plans of development. The approved plans are numbered DSH.319.03, DSH.319.05,
               DSH.320.03, DSH.320.05, DSH.320.06, DSH.GEN.02, DSH.GEN.03 prepared by Will Franklin
               and dated 8.7.02 and DD.01, DD.02, DD.03, DD.04, DD.05, DD.06, DD.07, DD.08, DD.09, DD.10,
               DD.11, DD.12 and DD.13 prepared by Georgina Price Design, as may be amended by these
               conditions.


               4.     CONSULTATION
               4.1. Referral Agencies
               Not applicable
               4.2. Internal Council Referrals
               Not applicable
               5.     CONCLUSION & REASONS FOR DECISION
               The proposed development generally complies with the requirements of the planning scheme and
               does not raise any significant issues that cannot be addressed by reasonable and relevant
               conditions. The application is therefore recommended for approval.
               The report is provided in accordance with Section 63(5) of the Planning Act 2016.
                                                                                                     Page 9 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024

Page 10

               RECOMMENDATION
               With regard to Application No. 132001.210319.1, to make a minor change to an existing approval
               for Material Change of Use to establish Three Non-complying Dwelling Houses (132001. 210319
               (22437 DA)) situated at 39 Douglas St Sunshine Beach Qld 4567 described as Lot 321 on
               RP48111, Council on 27 November 2024 decided to:
               A.     Approve the change.
               B.     Amend condition 18 to read as follows:
               Development undertaken in accordance with this approval must generally comply with the
               approved plans of development. The approved plans are numbered DSH.319.03, DSH.319.05,
               DSH.320.03, DSH.320.05, DSH.320.06, DSH.GEN.02, DSH.GEN.03 prepared by Will Franklin
               and dated 8.7.02 and DD.01, DD.02, DD.03, DD.04, DD.05, DD.06, DD.07, DD.08, DD.09, DD.10,
               DD.11, DD.12 and DD.13 prepared by Georgina Price Design, as may be amended by these
               conditions.




                                                                                               Page 10 of 10

Document Set ID: 23265956
Version: 5, Version Date: 27/11/2024

Used in these records

About this file

File size
4.0 MB (large file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Minor Change Report 132001 210319 1.pdf · 4.0 MB (large file)

The download may take up to a minute.

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.