Skip to the record
Noosa’s premier civic archive.

Council archive · source document

Minor Change Request report henderson st sunshine · MCU22/0145.01

of 7

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

24/09/2024

Development Assessment
Noosa Council
[email protected]



RE: Minor Change Request – MCU22/0145 & OPW22/0212 – 3 dwelling units and
associated operational works at 3 Henderson St, Sunshine Beach

Proposal

The applicant seeks minor changes to the combined development approvals MCU22/014 &
OPW22/0212, including:

   •   Slight amendment to the internal and external design including changes on each of the
       levels detailed below:

             o   Basement:
                     Inclusion of a car turntable
                     Relocate lift and stairs
                     Reconfigure non-habitable spaces




Figure. 1 Approved and Proposed Floor Plan

             o   Ground Floor:
                     Reconfigure rooms
                     Relocate lift, stairs and void
                     Maintain general footprint and no increase to GFA or site cover




Figure. 2 Approved and Proposed Floor Plan
Full text of the other 6 pages

Page 2

          o   First Floor:
                   Reconfigure rooms with terrace to west
                   Relocate lift, stairs and void
                   Maintain general footprint and no increase to GFA or site cover




Figure. 3 Approved and Proposed Floor Plan




          o   Second Floor:
                  Reconfigure rooms
                  Relocate lift, stairs and void
                  Maintain general footprint and no increase to GFA or site cover




Figure. 3 Approved and Proposed Floor Plan

Page 3

          o   Roof Terrace:
                  Relocate lift and stairs
                  Reconfigure Pool
                  Maintain all screening devices and setbacks




Figure. 4 Approved and Proposed Floor Plan




          o   Elevations:
                  Maintain general look of existing approval
                  All landscaping and fences in similar locations and levels
                  Maintain all screening devices and setbacks




Figure. 5 Approved and Proposed Elevations

Page 4

Background

    •     22 August 2023 - Council approved the MCU and OPW
    •     22 December 2023 – Negotiated Decision Notice issued
    •     12 February 2023 – Amended Negotiated Decision Notice issued

Change were made to the plans through the negotiated approval and plans requiring amendment
process.

Minor Change Test

An assessment against the meaning of minor change and a response about the proposed
application is provide below. The Planning Act 2016 defines a minor change as a change to the
approval that:

i. would not result in a substantially different development*;
      (*In determining whether the proposed change would result in substantially different
      development, the assessment manager or referral agency must consider the individual
      circumstances of the development, in the context of the change proposed.)

Schedule 1 of the Development Assessment Rules set outs provisions for a substantially different
development. A change may be considered to result in a substantially different development if the
proposed change results in any of the following outlined in Table 1 below.

Table 1 - Substantially different development

 Provisions of Schedule 1 of the DA Rules               Response
    (a) Involves a new use                              There is no new use proposed onsite
    (b) results in the application applying to a        No new parcel of land is introduced
         new parcel of land; or
    (c) dramatically changes the built form in          Although the design changes slightly, the
         terms of scale, bulk and appearance; or        building is sited in the same location as
                                                        approved with the same height, setbacks,
                                                        plot ratio and site cover. The modification
                                                        to the approved plans do not dramatically
                                                        change the scale, bulk or appearance of
                                                        the development.
        (d) changes the ability of the proposed         No change to the use approved.
            development to operate as intended; or
        (e) removes a component that is integral to     No essential component of the
            the operation of the development; or        development is proposed to be removed.
        (f) significantly impacts on traffic flow and   The proposal does not trigger any
            the transport network, such as increasing   additional traffic or car parking to that
            traffic to the site; or                     originally approved.
        (g) introduces new impacts or increase the      No new impacts or the severity of impacts
            severity of known impacts; or               is likely to result from the plan
                                                        modifications.
        (h) removes an incentive or offset              Does not remove an offset or incentive
            component that would have balanced a        components of the development.
            negative impact of the development; or
        (i) impacts on infrastructure provisions.       There is no       additional   impacts   on
                                                        infrastructure.

Given the above, the proposed change to the existing approval is a minor change in accordance
with Schedule 2 of the Planning Act 2016 and Schedule 1 of the Development Assessment Rules.

Page 5

Deciding the Request

In accordance with S81 of The Planning Act 2016, Council must only consider the information
provided and any other matter considered relevant, including — all matters Council would or may
assess against or have regard to, if the change application were a development application.

Council must only consider the statutory instrument, or other document, as in effect when the
development application for the development approval was properly made. However, may give
weight they consider appropriate, in the circumstances, to—

(a)   the statutory instrument or other document as in effect when the change application was
      made (Superseded Planning Scheme); or
(b)   if the statutory instrument or other document is amended or replaced after the change
      application is made but before it is decided—the amended or replacement instrument or
      document; or
(c)   another statutory instrument—
      (i) that comes into effect after the change application is made but before it is decided; and
      (ii) that the responsible entity would have been required to consider if the instrument had
      been in effect when the development application for the development approval was properly
      made.

Therefore in accordance with the above the proposal is assessed against the conditions of
approval and the Noosa Plan 2020. The proposal complies with all these instruments and approval
and is discussed below.

Page 6

     Assessment

     The key development parameters from the existing approval are outlined below and an
     assessment of the differences is provided thereafter.


     Table 2 – Development Parameters

    Criteria                            Approval              Proposal                 Compliance
    Plot ratio                          0.4:1                 0.43:1                    
    Building height
                                        3 storey              1 storey                   
•    storeys
                                        12 m                  7.8 metres                 
•    metres
    Boundary setbacks
    • Frontage
    - 1st and 2nd storeys               6m                    6m                         
    - 3rd+ storeys                      10m                   10m                        
    • Side (north)
    - 4.5m                              1.5m                  1.5m                       
    - 4.5-7m                            2m                    2.0m                       
    - 7.5m+                             2m+                   2.5m                       
    • Side (south)
    - 4.5m                              1.5m                  1.5m                       
    - 4.5-7.5m                          2m                    2.0m                       
    - 7.5m+                             2m+                   2.5m                       
    • Rear
    - 1st and 2nd storeys               6m
    - 3rd+ storeys                      8m
    Length of wall                      15m                   14.6m                      
    Basement width                      6m                    6m                         
    Landscaped open space               40%                   >40%                       
    Soft landscaping                    60% to be soft        >60%                       
    Landscaping Setbacks                2m to car parking     6m                         
    Rooftop terrace                     y                     y                          
    Carparking                          5 covered             6 covered                  

     As outlined in the Table, the proposal is generally in accordance with the existing approval

Page 7

Changes to Conditions
As a result of the proposed changes the following conditions require changing:

Condition 3 of the MCU and Condition 1 of the OPW requires amending to reflect the changes
and sought to read as follows.

MCU – 3. Development authorised by this approval must be undertaken generally in accordance with the
Approved Plans listed in the table below.
        Plan No.         Rev.      Plan/Document Name                                   Date
      A01            G           Site Plan, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      A02            G           Half Basement, prepared by Ellia                     20.09.24
      A03            G           Ground Floor, prepared by Ellia                      20.09.24
      A04            G           Level One, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      A05            G           Level Two, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      A06            G           Level Three, prepared by Ellia                       20.09.24
      C2.0           G           Elevation, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      C2.1           G           Elevation, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      C2.2           G           Elevation, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      C2.3           G           Elevation, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      C3.0           G           Section 1, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      C3.1           G           Section 2, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      C3.2           G           Section 3, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      C3.3           G           Section 4, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24
      C3.4           G           Section 5, prepared by Ellia                         20.09.24


OPW – 1. Development authorised by this approval must be undertaken generally in accordance with the
Approved Plans listed in the table below. The approved plans are listed in the following table unless
otherwise amended by these conditions.
        Plan No.         Rev.     Plan/Document Name                                        Date
      C01            C          General Notes prepared by HR Design                       18/09/24
      C02            C          Site Plan prepared by HR Design                           18/09/24
      C03            C          Finished Grading Plan prepared by HR Design               18/09/24
      C04            C          Cut Fill Plan prepared by HR Design                       18/09/24
      C05            C          Pavement Plan prepared by HR Design                       18/09/24
      ED     22266   G          Site Layout Plan prepared by Element Design               23/09/24
      OPW – 01
      ED     22266   G          Planting Plan (Ground Level) prepared by Element Design   18/09/24
      OPW – 02
      ED     22266   G          Planting Plan (Levels 01 & 04) prepared by Element        18/09/24
      OPW – 03                  Design
      ED     22266   G          Details Plan prepared by Element Design                   18/09/24
      OPW – 04
      ED     22266   G          Plant List & Specification Plan prepared by Element       18/09/24
      OPW – 05                  Design


If you have any further queries in relation to the above, please do not hesitate to contact myself.

Regards,




Jack Lewis B.Sc Hons UNSW M.Plan Otago MPIA
Planner/Director
Pivotal Perspective Pty Ltd
0406 334 227

Used in these records

About this file

File size
3.2 MB (large file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Minor Change Request report henderson st sunshine .pdf · 3.2 MB (large file)

The download may take up to a minute.

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.