Skip to the record
Search everything, all in one place.

Council archive · source document

Properly Made Submission (object) J P Shlegeris - MCU12/0208

of 4

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

                                                                             J. P. Shlegeris
                                                                             175 Lake Weyba Drive
                                                                        ;>
                                                                             Noosaville OLD 4566
                                                                        -




                                                                             5474-2750
                                                                             [email protected]


26 November 2013                                                                  SCC CORRESPONDENCE



Chief Executive Officer                                                            1111111111111111111111111
Sunshine Coast Regional Council                                                           X0065145
Locked Bag 72
Sunshine Coast Mail Centre OLD 4560


Dear Sir/Madam,


File Number: MCU12/0208
Postal Address of Land (as advertised): Eenie Creek Rd, 99 & 191 Hollett Rd Noosaville +
     106, 108-142 Tidswell Road, Weyba Downs (Lot2 RP160983, Lot 7 RP46782, Lot 53
     SP163571, Lot 12 RP893393, + Lot 1667 M37772)
Nature of Proposed Development: Mixed Use Community Title Development



I make this submission to urge the council to reject this application in its entirety.


There are numerous individual grounds, each of which, individually, would require that this
application be rejected. In this submission I will focus on just three areas:

1. Traffic and the resulting congestion and pollution
2. Habitat destruction and loss of biodiversity
3. Loss of amenity and damage to Lake Weyba


1. Traffic and the resulting congestion and pollution


The proposed development is well outside the urban footprint of the Noosa area and at least three
kilometres from the nearest commercial services. This means that every time a resident of the
proposed new suburb needs to buy any good or procure any service that person will have to drive
at least three kilometres farther~ach way-than that person would need to travel from a home
within the existing urban footprint.


Any given person may choose to live farther out from the urban footprint and endure the resulting
extra driving with every errand. In this case, however, it is estimated that the development will
generate an extra 6,000 vehicle trips every day. Every one of those trips will entail at least 6
kilometres of extra driving (3km each way).


That extra driving will amount to an extra 36,000 vehicle-kilometres per day. On an optimistic
average fuel consumption of 10 litres/100 kilometres, that’s an extra 3,600 litres of petrol every
single day, producing an extra 8.3 tonnes of carbon dioxide every day, or more than 3,000 extra
tonnes of carbon dioxide every year.


Note that this extra fuel consumption and carbon dioxide production results entirely and solely from
the fact that this proposed new suburb is in the wrong place: outside the urban footprint, far
removed from all shopping and services.


This narrow analysis entirely excludes the impact of all the extra road building which would be
required. Even after all of the impacts of that construction, the day-to-day environmental damage
will continue at a hugely elevated rate simply because the development is in an entirely
inappropriate location.

For reasons of traffic and congestion alone MCU 12/0208 should be rejected in its entirety.




Page 1 of 3                           Objection to MCU1210208                                        Shlegeris
                                                                      _’:::’l.,...L.~~.P.
                                                                                  ’
                                                                   GJ IrA
                                                                             I
                                                                 ec~                    ..




                                                                Ibcx.2\4-IO i~.~ ..X.
Full text of the other 3 pages

Page 2

2. Habitat destruction and loss of biodiversity


At 6:45am on 11 November 2013 I had to stop my car’ and block the roadway in Emu Mountain
Road about half way between the roundabouts at the Noosa-Eumundi Road and at Walter Hay
Drive to allow a female koala with a baby on her back to cross the road from south to north. These
koalas are two members of a gravely attenuated but not-yet nonviable koala population in the area.


The proposed development will create an absolute barrier to koalas seeking to follow their normal
routes parallel to the shore of Lake Weyba. The development itself will act as a physical barrier.
The inevitable dogs which would accompany the residents of the new suburb (hundreds of
additional dogs, possibly a thousand)will effectively expand the width of this barrier by killing or
harassing any koala which dares to come within hundreds of meters of the proposed development
from either the north or the south.


The koalas which survive dog attacks will be forced to cross the busy new access roads required
for the proposed development, and they will inevitably be driven out as far as Walter Hay Drive,
where the last of them will be run over.

If the council were to approve this proposal it would effectively be guaranteeing the extinction of
koalas over an area far larger than the development itself, most probably over the entire area east
to Walter Hay Drive and north to Eenie Creek Road. The remaining lightly developed land to the
south of the proposed development is not large enough to support any more than a remnant koala
population unable to cope with one more source of stress and destined for extinction.

Koalas, of course, are just the most charismatic of the many species of native animals which will
be killed in untold numbers as a direct result of the proposed development.


Koalas and other species are protected under commonwealth legislation. Other specifically
protected species occupy the development site itself. The council’s obligation to protect native
wildlife and avoid developments which will lead to the wanton destruction of such wildlife is by itself
enough to require the council to reject this proposed development in its entirety.


3. Loss of amenity and damage to Lake Weyba


Residents and ratepayers in the Noosa area will suffer great loss of amenity under this proposal
and will realise no benefit whatever. Most of us have chosen to live in and around Noosa precisely
because it is different from most other developed coastal areas in Australia. The proposed
development would act to diminish this distinction by adding greatly to traffic and congestion, by
putting greatly increased pressure on endangered native animals and by ruining the exceptional
amenity of Lake Weyba.

Presently one can go to the middle of Lake Weyba and see scarcely any evidence of human
activity in any direction. I can think of no other developed area which has such a treasure.

Lake Weyba makes a big contribution to the health of the Noosa River and the waters of the river
mouth. It is a hatchery and nursery for many species. It slows the flow of floodwaters into the
river. It supports abundant bird life. I believe it continues to support a small-scale commercial
fishing operation.

The proposed development will cause untold damage to Lake Weyba. Most of the site runs
directly downhill into the lake; the rest of it drains into creeks which feed the lake. The silt and
muck loosened by construction will all end up in the lake, as those little mesh fences only work
until the first time it rains hard, at which point they let go of all of the sediment briefly trapped
behind them. As the new suburb is developed, vast quantities of pesticide, herbicide, and fertiliser
will be washed into the lake. Each class of chemicals is by itself a serious threat to life in the lake;
all together they may overwhelm the ability of the lake ecosystem to persist.


Lake Weyba, while covering a lovely great area, contains surprisingly little water. There are only a
few places in which it’s too deep to stand. One of the most common sights around the lake is
someone out in the middle of the lake,     walking, dragging a kayak or canoe behind. The sediment

Page 2 of 3                          Objection to MCU1210208                               J.P. Shlegeris

Page 3

from the proposed development would clog and strangle the lake while the inevitable chemical tide
will accumulate in a too-small volume of water.


I ask the council to make its decision in respect of the proposed development with a view to
protecting the amenity of the Noosa area for its residents and visitors. The creation of a new
suburb on a fragile site with no services would be a giant step in the wrong direction.


The totally unsuitable location of the proposed development is by itself reason enough to reject this
proposal in its entirety.

I urge the council to reject every element of the proposed development.




J. P. Shlegeris




Page 3 of 3                         Objection to MCU1210208                            J.P. Shlegeris

Page 4

                                                AUSTRALIA

                                                   NOOSAVILLE LPO

.
    ,


                             ~~.                  $2.30
                                                  Optional Extras
                                                 27111313:084566 C
                                                                                ,




                                                Postage Paid




            c~~ e- f)<       Q ClI\   f,’ ~ Of-fc’t:.e,v-
                                        v




                  ~\t,;’^
               IA’"              COM t ~            \0\11 a (Gou w:.i I
                            ~
                                               EJ           M Cl;\ 11../02.08
                 12- ’.,   SUb’V\t\~ s 0V\           e.


            L<:6~              1L
                           ~-’Coast M              L        QLO
            SlAY\5V\"lV\~                                            POSTCODE


                                                                     @[2~[g

        ~



--
                                                                                    <:.   ~~
                                                                                          ..




                                            J ~5h     o~l \ ~ ’OsooN                           J
                                                04t~rY\ 10l 5iJ

Used in these records

About this file

File size
2.2 MB (large file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Properly Made Submission (object) J P Shlegeris - MCU12_0208.pdf · 2.2 MB (large file)

The download may take up to a minute.

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.