Council archive · source document
Town Planning Assessment Report · MCU22/0139
Mur
Town Planning
Assessment Report
36 Elanda Street, Sunshine Beach
Development Permit for Material Change of Use of Premises to
establish a Dual Occupancy
August 2022
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 16 pages
Page 2
Table of Contents
1. SITE AND APPLICATION SUMMARY................................................................................................................. 3
2. PROPOSAL ..............................................................................................................................................................................4
3. BACKGROUND .................................................................................................................................................................. 5
4. SITE DETAILS ........................................................................................................................................................................ 5
4.1. SITE DESCRIPTION ....................................................................................................................................................... 5
4.2. SURROUNDING USES ..................................................................................................................................................6
5. ASSESSMENT REQUIREMENTS ............................................................................................................................... 7
5.1. FRAMEWORK FOR ASSESSMENT............................................................................................................................... 7
CATEGORISING INSTRUMENTS FOR STATUTORY ASSESSMENT ................................................................................ 7
5.2. ASSESSMENT BENCHMARKS RELATED TO THE PLANNING REGULATION 2017................................... 7
5.3. THE NOOSA PLAN 2020 ......................................................................................................................................... 8
5.3.1. DEFINITION ............................................................................................................................................................... 8
5.3.2. LEVEL OF ASSESSMENT AND ASSESSMENT REQUIREMENTS ................................................................... 8
5.3.3. ASSESSMENT...............................................................................................................................................................9
5.3.3.1. ALTERNATIVE OUTCOMES................................................................................................................................. 12
6. CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................................................................. 17
Appendices
Appendix A Proposal Plans
Appendix B Site Photographs
Disclaimer: While every care has been taken in preparing this report, Brennan Planning Pty Ltd accepts no responsibility for
decisions or actions taken as a result of any data, information, statement or advice, expressed or implied, contained within.
To the best of our knowledge, the content was correct at the time of publishing.
Page 2 of 17
Page 3
1. Site and Application Summary
Applicant
Applicant: Marjan Robert Vuletic
C/- Brennan Planning Pty Ltd
Contact Details: Marcus Brennan
Mob: 0423 952 928
Email: [email protected]
Registered Landowner(s): Marjan Robert Vuletic
Application
Development Permit for Material Change of Use of
Development Application:
Premises to establish a Dual Occupancy
Level of Assessment: Code Assessable
Referral Agencies: Nil
Assessment Manager Noosa Council
Subject Site
Address: 36 Elanda Street, Sunshine Beach
Lot Description: Lot 159 on RP48112
Area: 568.94m2
Nil
Easement(s):
SEQ Regional Plan Urban Footprint
Planning Scheme Noosa Plan 2020 (25 September 2020)
Local Plan Coastal Communities Local Plan Code
Zone: Medium Density Residential
Overlays: Nil
Page 3 of 17
Page 4
2. Proposal
This application seeks an approval for a development permit for material change of use of premises
to establish a 2 x 2 bedroom dual occupancy.
The proposed dual occupy would comprise of a basement level, ground level, second level and a
rooftop terrace. The basement level would provide parking and manoeuvring for 4 vehicles and
include stairs and a lift. The ground level of each unit would comprise an open planned kitchen/living
area, bedroom, ensuite, powder room, front terrace, internal court and alfresco dining area at the
rear. The second level would comprise a master bedroom, ensuite, lounge, bathroom and a front and
rear balcony. The rooftop terrace incorporates a wet bar, area for day beds and a spa. The terrace will
be open and unroofed except for the space containing the lift and stairway.
The building will incorporate a mixture of external materials including timber, concrete, rendered
blockwork and feature battening and screening throughout the design. It will also incorporate large
balconies and courtyard areas which are sympathetic to Noosa’s subtropical climate.
The design will be provided with a generous landscaped setting that will offer a 6m wide landscaped
area adjacent to the front setback, landscaped internal courtyard, and a large landscaped open space
area at the rear of the premises.
The dual occupancy achieves access via a crossover to Elanda Street in the northern corner of the site.
Figure 1 – Ground Floor Plan
Page 4 of 17
Page 5
Figure 2 – Street Elevation
Figure 3 – Northeast Elevation
3. Background
Noosa Council’s online application system reveals that there is no history of approvals relating to the
site.
4. Site Details
4.1. Site Description
Site Description
Characteristic
Existing land use Dwelling house
Frontage and access The site has a 15.08m frontage to Elanda Street to the northeast.
There is an existing dwelling house located on the site. The site
gains access via a crossover situated in the northern corner of
the site.
Page 5 of 17
Page 6
A 1.2m wide footpath exists on the northern side of Elanda
Street.
Topography The site slopes downhill to the north, towards Elanda Street, at
an average gradient of approximately 8.5%.
Figure 3 – Aerial Photograph of Subject Site
4.2. Surrounding Uses
The north-eastern side of Elanda Street is located in the High Density Residential Zone and
predominantly contains 3 storey buildings that are large in size and provide substantial plot ratios.
The south-western side of Elanda contains a mixture of dual occupancies, multiple dwellings and
dwelling houses. The dual occupancies and multiple dwellings have been developed under former
planning schemes, which allowed for larger plot ratios than the current planning scheme.
Page 6 of 17
Page 7
Figure 4 – Aerial Photograph of Subject Site and surrounding area
5. Assessment Requirements
5.1. Framework for Assessment
Categorising Instruments for Statutory Assessment
In accordance with Section 43 of the Planning Act 2016, the following categorising instruments may
contain assessment benchmarks applicable to development applications:
+ the Planning Regulation 2017
+ the Planning Scheme for the local government area
+ any temporary local planning instrument
+ any variation approval
Of these, the planning instruments relevant to this application are discussed below:
5.2. Assessment Benchmarks Related to the Planning Regulation 2017
The Planning Regulation 2017 (the Regulation) prescribes assessment benchmarks that the
application must be carried out against, which are additional or alternative to the assessment
benchmarks contained in council’s Planning Scheme. These assessment benchmarks may be contained
within:
• the Regional Plan;
• Part E of the State Planning Policy, to the extent they are not appropriately integrated into the
Planning Scheme; and
Page 7 of 17
Page 8
• Schedule 10 of the Regulation.
An assessment against the applicable benchmarks contained within the Planning Regulation is
provided below:
SEQ Regional Plan
The subject site is located within the Urban Footprint under the SEQ Regional Plan (SEQRP). The
proposed dual occupancy development is consistent with the goals, elements and strategies for the
Urban Footprint designation.
Part E of the State Planning Policy
The current State Planning Policy (SPP) commenced on 3 July 2017. The applicable State interests
relating to development assessment are set out in Part E of the document and are under five broad
themes. The assessment benchmarks of the SPP Part E that are relevant to the development
proposal are consistent with the current provisions of the planning scheme and would not warrant
further assessment.
Schedule 10 of the Regulation
The proposal does not trigger referral to any agencies or assessment against any of the benchmarks
contained with Schedule 10 of the regulation.
5.3. The Noosa Plan 2020
5.3.1. Definition
The Noosa Plan 2020 defines a Dual Occupancy as follows:
Dual occupancy-
a) means a residential use of premises for 2 households involving—
i. 2 dwellings (whether attached or detached) on a single lot or 2 dwellings (whether
attached or detached) on separate lots that share a common property; and
ii. any domestic outbuilding associated with the dwellings; but
b) does not include a residential use of premises that involves a secondary dwelling.
The proposal meets the definition of a Dual Occupancy as it involves the establishment of two
dwellings on the premises.
5.3.2. Level of Assessment and Assessment Requirements
The site is a located within the Medium Density Residential Zone and the Coastal Communities Local
Plan Area under the Noosa Plan 2020. Pursuant to Table 5.5.2 of the Planning Scheme, the proposed
Dual Occupancy use is ‘code assessable’.
Page 8 of 17
Page 9
In accordance with Section 45(3) of the Planning Act 2016 a code assessment is an assessment that
must be carried out only—
(a) against the assessment benchmarks in a categorising instrument for the development; and
(b) having regard to any matters prescribed by regulation for this paragraph.
5.3.3. Assessment
Pursuant to Table 5.5.2 of the Planning Scheme, the application is assessable against the following
codes:
+ Coastal Communities Local Plan Code
+ Medium Density Residential Zone Code
+ Dual Occupancy and Multiple Dwelling Code
+ Works Codes
An assessment against the abovementioned applicable codes has revealed that the development is
compliant with, or can be conditioned to comply with, each. The pertinent issues arising out of an
assessment against each of the codes are discussed below.
Table 5.3.3.1
Criteria Noosa Plan 2020 Proposal Compliance
2
Site area - 568.94m NA
Building height 8m 8m P
Site Cover 40% (227m2) 35% (200.85m2) P
Plot Ratio 0.4:1 (227m2) 0.412 (234.8m2) O
Boundary
setbacks
• Frontage 6m 6m P
• Side
(northwest) 1.5m – 2.5m 1.5m – 2.5m P
(southeast) 1.5m – 2.5m 1.5m – 2.5m P
• Rear 6m 10.8m P
Wall length <15m 7m P
Basements Are limited to one access a Basement with 4.6m wide entry P
maximum of 6 metres wide;
Do not encroach Front – 6m P
into building setback areas. Side (northwest) - 1.5m P
Side (southeast) - 0.19m O
Rear – 10.8m P
Front Fences Set back an average of 1m Requirement can be conditioned P
articulated to provide visual
interest by stepping the design
Where on boundary, 1.2m in
height or 50% transparent
Roof form Does not include roof top terraces Proposal includes a roof top O
terrace
Page 9 of 17
Page 10
Width of parapet wall < 50% of
frontage No parapet P
Landscaping 6m width to frontage 6m width to frontage P
Landscaping to minimum of 40% of 53.6% (305m2) P
the site.
60% (145.6m²) to be soft 34.8% (198m2) of soft landscaping P
landscaping
Private open Minimum of 25m² Far more than 25m2 P
space
Carparking 2 covered spaces and one 4 spaces P
additional
*Please refer to Table 5.5.3 – Alternative Outcome for an assessment against the performance/overall
outcomes of the relevant codes in relation to any non-complying elements detailed in the table above.
Driveways and Parking Code
The proposed development complies with the Performance/Acceptable Outcomes of the Driveways
and Parking Code in that:
• It provides the following parking provisions in compliance with Table 9.4.1.4:
• It will provide for a driveway crossover design in compliance with RS-049 and have a maximum
width of 4m;
• It will provide for driveways, parking and manoeuvring areas compliant with Australian
Standards for off-street carparking.
Sustainable Building Design Code
The proposed development generally complies with the Performance/Acceptable Outcomes or otherwise
the Overall Outcomes of the of the Sustainable Design Code. An assessment against Performance Outcome
PO8 is included below, which is the most relevant outcome.
Performance Outcome PO8 Comment
a) orientates buildings and windows to make the The design provides exceptional opportunities to
most of prevailing winds, natural ventilation take advantage of prevailing winds, natural
and cross breezes; ventilation and cross breezes including:
• At the ground level, each unit is provided with:
o a covered front terrace that enjoys multiple
aspects;
o an internal courtyard the provides a
north/south orientation and encourages
cross ventilation through the units;
o a rear deck that provides an alfresco dining
opportunity and opens to the rear yard; and
• At the second level, each unit is provided with:
Page 10 of 17
Page 11
o two large balconies that offer multiple
aspects;
• At the roof level, each unit is provided with a
terrace area that will enjoy multiple aspects.
b) maximises shade to east and west walls; The design maximises shade to east and west walls
by incorporating large balconies on each side that
will shade the walls of the building. To the west
the building also includes a large planter area on
the second level that will provide shading to the
walls and reduce heat retention.
c) contains an open and permeable built form The design provides for an open and permeable
that connects indoor and outdoor spaces in an built form by using large terraces, internal
integrated design; courtyards and large balconies that create an
integrated indoor/outdoor design.
d) retains existing vegetation and natural shading The site does not include any native vegetation
where possible; that is of significance. The design will allow for
significant areas for landscaping areas at the
ground level that will allow for the establishment
of large trees that will shade the building and open
space areas.
e) incorporates passive building design to reduce The design optimises passive design opportunities
the need for auxiliary heating and cooling; by opening out to large covered outdoor areas and
internal courtyards which will allow for cross
ventilation and reduce the need auxiliary heating
and cooling;
f) uses low toxic internal and The design includes the use of natural and low
external building materials; toxic building materials including timber, concrete,
blockwork, glazing and metal roof sheeting.
g) uses natural light rather than artificial light, The design optimises the use of natural light
and may include skylights, atriums and light through the provision of internal courtyards, decks
wells; and balconies.
h) contains a minimum of two openings per The design provides for two aspects and openings
habitable room; per room.
i) provides a minimum floor to ceiling height of The design will including generous floor to ceiling
2.7 metres; and heights of between 2.5m – 3.6m. While the
minimum height of 2.7m will be slightly less than
2.7m, it will offer a generous height given the
small nature of the units. Further each unit is
provided with exemptional access to natural light
and air and prevailing breezes through the
establishment of large balconies, terraces, and
internal courtyards and landscaping integrated
into the building design. Overall, the building will
meet the purpose and overall outcomes of the
code in that it will create a sustainable and
resource efficient design that responds to Noosa’s
subtropical climate and will maximise human
comfort.
Page 11 of 17
Page 12
j) enables efficient operation and use of The design allows for medium density living and
the building. privacy to each of the units, while also allowing for
users to easily flow between the main living and
bedroom levels.
Other Works Codes
The development will be serviced by standard urban infrastructure provisions including reticulated water,
sewer, electricity, telecommunications, and stormwater drainage.
5.3.3.1. Alternative Outcomes
Plot Ratio -
AO11 - For a dwelling house, plot ration of development does not exceed 0.4:1
PO11 - Plot ratio of development:
a) does not exceed 0.4:1; or
b) for small dwellings or for development which provides a ratio of at least three small dwellings to
one other dwelling, does not exceed 0.5:1.
Acceptable Outcome AO11 is not relevant to the proposed development as it does not involve a
dwelling house. The correlating Performance Outcome PO11 provides a prescriptive requirement
that Plot Ratio for development does not exceed 0.4:1 (where not for small dwellings). The proposed
dual occupancy would provide a plot ratio of 0.412:1, exceeding the allowance by 0.12 or 6.82m2.
While the proposed plot ratio would be compliant if small dwellings were to be provided, the
proposed dwellings are 116m2, and slightly exceed the definition of a small dwelling unit (100m2).
Despite the non-compliance with Performance Outcome PO11, it is considered that the proposal
achieves the overall outcomes and purpose of the of the Medium Density Residential Zone Code. A
comprehensive assessment of the overall outcomes is provided in Table 5.3.3.1 below.
Table 5.3.3.1 - Assessment Against Overall Outcomes of Medium Density Residential Zone Code
Overall Outcome Comment
a) Medium density residential Complies: The dual occupancy will remain home
neighbourhoods are predominantly home to permanent residents.
to permanent residents.
b) The character of medium density Complies: The dual occupancy will remain
residential neighbourhoods varies due to complementary to the beach side character of
factors such as proximity to beaches, the the area. The building will provide a
Noosa River, recreation spaces, centres, contemporary appearance, utilising natural
topography, availability of views, the materials and colours and landscape features
Page 12 of 17
Page 13
established vegetated character, the that complement its setting. The building will be
presence of visitor accommodation and set amongst a generous landscaped setting and
the age of development. incorporate passive design principals which
respond to Noosa’s subtropical climate.
c) Development makes a positive Complies: The dual occupancy will make a
contribution to the look and feel of positive contribution to the look and feel of the
residential neighbourhoods by streetscape. The development provides a low
maintaining a low scale character with scale appearance that is compatible with the
well-designed buildings and landscaping surrounding built form character of the area and
that enhance the streetscape. provides a well-designed building with a
generous landscaped setting that will enhance
the character of the streetscape.
d) New uses are located, designed and Complies: The proposed dual occupancy is
managed to be compatible with located, designed and managed to be compatible
surrounding uses. with surrounding use which consists of large scale
3 storey multiple dwellings on the north-eastern
side of Elanda Street and a mixture of dual
occupancies, multiple dwellings and dwelling
houses on the southwestern side. The buildings
on the southwestern side of Elanda Street also
generally offer forms that are much larger than
the proposed building, including
• 38 Elanda Street - which adjoins the
southeast side boundary and incorporates a
dual occupancy that was approved in 2016
and has a plot ratio of 0.454 (258.7m2);
• 40-42 Elanda Street – which contains a large
multiple dwelling; and
• 44 Elanda Street – which contains a large dual
occupancy.
e) The intrusion of incompatible uses, or Not Applicable - The proposal does not involve
uses which are more appropriately an incompatible use.
accommodated in other zones is avoided
to protect land for dual occupancies,
community residences, rooming
accommodation, multiple dwellings,
retirement and relocatable home
park facilities.
f) Development caters for both the current Complies: The proposed dual occupancy will add
and projected demographic and socio- to the housing supply in the coastal communities
economic profile of the area, including locality and provide a 2 x 2 bedroom product that
one and two-person households, will be suitable for a range of demographics and
households on low to moderate incomes persons with reduced mobility by incorporating a
and residents with reduced mobility. lift.
Page 13 of 17
Page 14
g) Small dwellings and co-housing models Not Applicable - The proposal does not involve
are integrated within the medium density small dwellings or co-housing models.
residential built form to increase housing
choice.
h) Short-term visitor accommodation is Not Applicable - The proposal does not involve
predominately provided through well- short-term accommodation units.
established resorts and holiday units.
i) Home-based businesses provide for Not Applicable - The proposal does not involve
domestic workplaces and home-hosted home-based business uses.
guest accommodation of a scale and
intensity compatible with attached and
semi-attached living and the residential
character and amenity of the surrounding
area and locality.
j) Development maintains a high level of Complies: The proposed dual occupancy will
residential amenity having regard to provide a high level of residential amenity for
traffic, noise, dust, odour, lighting and future occupants and will not result in any
other locally specific impacts. impacts relating to traffic, noise, dust, odour,
lighting and other locally specific impacts.
k) Development provides for an efficient Complies: The proposed changes will maintain an
pattern of land use and infrastructure efficient pattern of land use, involving a dual
that creates walkable and legible occupancy that is located within a highly walkable
residential neighbourhoods that and well-connected area.
integrate with active transport networks
and are well connected to activity
centres, employment nodes, open space
and recreational areas, community
facilities and educational opportunities.
l) Development is supported by appropriate Complies: The dual occupancy is serviced by all
infrastructure and essential services and essential urban infrastructure and services.
does not adversely impact on the
continued operation, viability and
maintenance of existing infrastructure or
compromise future provision of planned
infrastructure.
m) Development responds to land Not Applicable - The site is relatively
constraints including topography, unconstrained and the design appropriately
bushfire and flood. responds to its setting.
n) Natural features such as creeks, gullies, Complies: The proposed dual occupancy will have
waterways, wetlands, vegetation and no impacts on natural features including creeks,
Page 14 of 17
Page 15
bushland are retained and protected gullies, waterways, wetlands, vegetation and
from the impacts of development. Any bushland.
unavoidable impacts are minimised
through location, design, operation and
management requirements.
o) Native vegetation between buildings and Complies: There is no vegetation of significance
in the public realm enhances the amenity located on the site. The proposal will provide for
and supports local wildlife. a generous landscaped setting that is capable of
accommodating large trees.
Basements
AO16
Basements:
a) are limited to one access a maximum of 6 metres wide; and
b) do not encroach into building setback areas.
PO16
Basements:
a) visually integrate with the building;
b) do not dominate the street or building design;
c) are screened through landscaping; and
d) do not present as a storey to the street.
The proposed building includes a basement that has an outermost projection of 0.19m from the
southeast side boundary and consequently encroaches into the side setback area. Despite the non-
compliance with Acceptable Outcome AO16 of the Medium Density Residential Zone Code, the
proposed basement complies with the corresponding Performance Outcome PO16 for the following
reasons:
a) it visually integrates with the building as it is situated beneath the envelope of the building and
limited to a 4.5m wide opening facing the street;
b) it will not dominate the street or the building design as it is setback 6m from the road boundary
and the ground level will be retained around the structure;
c) the basement will be screened through tiered landscaping opportunities within a 6m setback that
will generally be uncompromised by infrastructure;
d) while the basement would have a maximum floor to ceiling height of 1.256m above the natural
ground level for a small portion at the northern corner of the building, this minor exceedance
would not be visually perceivable from the street for the following reasons:-
i. it is a minor 256mm exceedance above the natural ground level;
ii. the land surrounding the basement will be filled so that it is level with the finished ceiling
height of the basement and will become the new ground level (refer to Figure 4 below);
and
iii. the front setback area will be landscaped with a tiered plantings comprising of ground
covers, shrubs and trees and will further visually conceal the extent of the basement.
Page 15 of 17
Page 16
Figure 4 – Ground level at northeast elevation
Roof forms
AO19.2
Development does not include rooftop terraces.
PO19
Roof forms:
a) contribute positively to the local skyline;
b) complement the character of the locality and the topography of the site;
c) avoid box profiles/parapets; and
d) do not create opportunities for overlooking the private open space or internal spaces of
neighbouring properties.
The proposed building includes a rooftop terrace and consequently does not comply with Acceptable
Outcome AO19.2 of the Medium Density Residential Zone Code. While not complying with the
acceptable outcome, it is considered that the proposed building complies with PO19 of the Medium
Density Residential Zone Code for the following reasons:
a) the building will contribute positively to the local skyline in that:
i. it remains a low rise building that has a maximum height of 8m; and
ii. it provides varied and interesting roof forms which consist of a variety of pitches, balconies
and provision of landscaping opportunities on the roofs and terraces that will soften its
form;
b) it will complement the character of the locality and the topography of the site in that:
i. the form is compatible with the scale of the medium – high density residential
neighbourhood; and
ii. It is effectively design having consideration to the topography of the by maintaining a
maximum height of 8m and providing an underground basement which maximises
opportunities for landscaping in the front and rear setback areas;
c) the design avoids box profiles/parapets by including pitch roofs that are visible from the
boundaries and landscaped planters that will provide a soft visual form.
Page 16 of 17
Page 17
d) the terraces have been designed in a manner that will prevent overlooking by including
landscaped planters around the perimeter of the terrace that will obstruct low angle views as
illustrated in Figure 5 below:
Figure 5 – View analysis from
Conclusion
This report has identified that the proposed development complies with the relevant benchmarks
contained within the Noosa Plan 2020 and does not raise any significant issues that cannot be
addressed by reasonable and relevant conditions on the following basis:
+ the proposal provides a well-designed dual occupancy development that incorporates an
articulated façade comprising mixture of external materials including timber, concrete,
rendered blockwork, feature battening and screening throughout the design and landscaped
planters that soften and provide relief to the bulk and scale of the building.
+ the development provides vehicular access and basement parking that designed to be safe
and efficient and accommodate the demand of the use;
+ the design will incorporate a generous landscaped setting that will offer a 6m wide
landscaped area adjacent to the front setback, landscaped internal courtyard, and a large
landscaped open space area at the rear of the premises;
+ the development can be appropriately connected to and services by all necessary urban
infrastructure including reticulated water, sewer, electricity, telecommunications, and
stormwater; and
+ the development does not result in any offsite impacts including by way of noise, light, glare,
dust or odour emissions or stormwater runoff, traffic or environmental impacts.
This office trusts that the information supplied comprehensively addresses all of the issues that are to
be considered by the Noosa Plan 2020. Should you have any questions in relation to the proposal, or
any aspect of the development, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned on 0423 952 928
or via email [email protected]
Yours sincerely,
Marcus Brennan
B. Urb. Reg. Plan.
Page 17 of 17
Used in these records
Town Planning Assessment Report.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 4.5 MB (large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take up to a minute.